Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 27 Tape 54 Side 1

43 min · 5,158 words · 27 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 27 Tape 54 Side 1
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk presents antidotes to delusions drawn from the lam rim. The twelve links are used against ignorance, dependent arising against pride, and rejoicing and equanimity against jealousy. It also covers precious human rebirth and reading Dharma texts against depression, then the value of taking the five lay precepts as vows. A short question session follows.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-27

Duration: 44 min

UUID: 21e3c39a-9397-4111-b467-75533988af74

Words: 5,158

When we get to the six perfections. Then as an antidote to ignorance, the mind of ignorance, there is the twelve links. Contemplate meditating on the twelve links. Through this one can understand dependent arising, how everything is a dependent arising, also by seeing how what’s the word? Inexorable?

How like once one generates a mind of ignorance then one creates karma, then one creates that is registered in the consciousness and then that at the time of death is propelled into the next life and then we have name and form and then the sixth sense bases, and then we have contact, feeling, craving, grasping, existence, birth, old age and death. From that moment of ignorance, and included in aging and death is every other suffering, right? So we start the wheel again and again and again. Once the wheel started it just keeps rolling on unless we do something powerful about it. So meditating on that, that twelve links become even a very simple way, this thing and doing the reverse process.

To be free of ignorance, aging and death, one has to be free of birth. To be free of birth, one has to be free of existence. To be free of existence, one has to be free of grasping, and so on. And to go back and then you have to, Oh, I have to be free of ignorance. Oh, I have to be free of ignorance.

How do I get free of ignorance? Meditating on the twelve links is very helpful for that. Then also for overcoming pride, the antidote to pride is contemplating also as an antidote to pride, one thinks about various kinds of dependencies because pride is a mind that is sinking into ‘I’, there’s this truly existing ‘I’ that has these truly existing qualities. I’m so intelligent from my own side, all my intelligence is totally my creation, it’s got nothing to do with anyone else. All my wonderful qualities, my knowledge, everything comes from me.

But then if we check, we find out that all our qualities have arisen in dependence on others. The fact that we may be a brilliant computer, whatever, programmer, thanks, comes from the fact that our mother taught us how to say mum, ma, pa in the beginning, taught us how to speak, and then how to read a few words, and from that now we can do computer programming, maybe, maybe not. But it’s all whatever knowledge we have has arisen in dependence on others, of people patiently explaining like the person who taught us the alphabet and so on. So it’s not qualities are not independent phenomena but dependent phenomena which our pride ignores. Our pride thinks I am just this by myself.

So special. Traditionally it also says to cut and meditate on how we ourselves are made up of many parts, we are dependent on parts. One way to cut pride is to meditate on all the parts of the body inside and out. We realize we don’t even know most of the parts of the body we’ve got, so why are we proud? And our pride, also one aspect of our pride is thinking that we are so special and unique, But one way to cut that is to realize that are so many of our thoughts and ideas that we think are so special, we generate them because that’s our culture.

The way we think is conditioned by our culture, the time that we are born in, and so on. Not so long ago someone lent me a book about Ayurvedic medicine and how you can recognise according to Ayurvedic medicine, people belong to a different kind of type, and therefore according to the type you belong to, then you should eat certain things for your health and avoid other things and so on. So to find out your type, there’s all these lists of things you should check about, like even the markings of your fingers, and the kind of hair you have, and I can’t think, there’s many many things to check. And then and even the type of faeces you produce. And then you discover, well you’re not that unique, you just fit into a type.

You think your fingernails are so your fingers are so especially unique to you but they’re just a type. I’ve just got a type of finger. Nothing very special at all, you know. And then when you discover every bit of you is just part of a type, this fits into one type, we think we’re so amazingly unique. But then we just find out we’re just boringly the same as everyone else, we just fit into different kinds of types.

And then many people are interested in astrology and then we discover we’re just an astrological type. So these things, if thought about in the right way, can help overcome our pride, act as an antidote to our pride, that is believing in this truly existing phenomena that is not depending on other things, and is completely unique, separate from other people’s characteristics. And then there is jealousy, the antidote to jealousy is contemplating seeing the equality between self and others, trying to see the equality between self and others, that we all wish happiness and don’t wish suffering. If someone since we all want that, why should I be jealous if someone has something that is making them happy? Even if I wish to have this thing, just as I wish to have this thing, also wish to have something, that same kind of thing, and they’re fortunate enough to have it.

So the antidote to the mind of jealousy which tortures ourselves is rejoicing, which makes the mind happy, and is one of the ways to actually increase our merit by rejoicing in the good qualities, the virtuous qualities of others, and the virtuous actions of others, we generate merit. And particularly the worst kind of jealousy is just as the worst kind of pride is spiritual pride, then we also to counteract our spiritual pride, we have to realize that whatever good qualities we have come from our teachers, come from the Dharma and come from our teachers. Without that we wouldn’t have any of these, we wouldn’t have this knowledge, we wouldn’t have the ability to meditate, whatever realizations we’ve gained have totally depended on the kindness of others. And not just that, you know, highly realized teachers but also just our Dharma friends who have helped us in some way, by supporting us to do retreat, encouraging us to do retreat and so on. So all our good qualities arise in dependence on others.

So similarly the worst kind of jealousy is to be jealous of the spiritual qualities of others. But that will arise if we also if we have encountered our ordinary jealousy to just the ordinary good qualities of others or characteristics of others that are better than our own. If we have this ordinary kind of jealousy, then for sure we will develop spiritual if we haven’t counteracted our ordinary kind of worldly jealousy, then when it comes to following the spiritual path we will generate spiritual jealousy to the spiritual qualities of others that are better than our own. So, in order to counteract our ordinary jealousy, which also creates negative karma as well, but spiritual jealousy creates even more, there’s a greater obstacle on the path, but to help counteract our ordinary jealousy we can think, you know, how what stupid kind of mind it is really, because we get jealous of people who have better qualities than ourselves, but then we could try and think of what are the consequences of that, because what we want to be, we want to be the best. So we are jealous of people who are more intelligent than us, right?

And we torture ourselves that someone is more intelligent than me. But then we can think, if if if everyone was less intelligent, that I was the most intelligent person in the world and everyone was less intelligent than me, that would be a disaster. Wow, what a mess the world would be if I was the leading genius in the world. Right? And again we’re jealous of someone who’s better looking than us but then if I was the most the best looking person in the world everyone else would have to be uglier than me.

I would have to look at all these ugly people. It would be terrible. How fortunate there are nicer looking people than me to look at. Again, we’re jealous if someone, you know, people think someone is funnier than me, but if I was the funniest person in the world it would be such a boring place if no one else was as interesting or as funny as me. Right?

If you think about it, world if I was the most special person in the world as I am, as I am, then I mean really it would be so depressing. So we can try and think like that how ridiculous it is to be jealous of the qualities, the ordinary qualities of others. And then, so on the basis of that, we can understand that if we’re following the spiritual path, especially the Mahāyāna path, where the purpose is to be able to develop for oneself the qualities that enable us to make every other living being happier and happier, have less suffering and be more and more genuinely happy, then if we see someone who has some happiness and the causes of happiness, like spiritual genuine happiness and valid causes of that, how can we be jealous of that? Because they’re achieving exactly what we’re supposed to be wanting for them. So how can we be jealous that they’ve got what we want to what we are supposedly training ourselves to give them?

It’s just totally contrary and nonsense. We should rejoice because we don’t have to give them that happiness, they’ve already got it for themselves so we can rejoice and work on making someone else happy. So we can relax in relation to that person and be happy. But jealousy makes ourselves miserable about the happiness of others. It’s such a ridiculous mind if we look at it, check on it.

So these are some ways that we can try to think, not just one time, again and again, to develop this antidote towards jealousy. Then some other antidotes that we can apply is just, for example, generally when the mind is very weak and sort of feels overwhelmed by all sorts of difficult problems, then the antidote to rely on if one has conviction in the Buddhadharma is to rely on the blessings of the Gurus and the lineage lamas to make strong requests, prayers to the lineage lamas to bless the mind, to the Buddhas and the lineage lamas. So, when the mind is depressed, a virtuous opponent to depression is meditating on the precious human rebirth, because the sign of success in meditating on the precious human rebirth is that it makes the mind happy. One recognizes that one literally has a really precious rebirth, just an unbelievably unique wonderful life and with so much potential for benefit of self and others. So when we recognize that, it makes the mind unbelievably happy.

And so when we get depressed, we need to remind ourselves that whatever is causing our depression is nothing, it’s insignificant compared to the amazing situation we have. That we just need to remember to recognize again and again how fortunate we are in time and space. Also Lama Zopa Rinpoche suggests for people who have refuge in the Dharma that what helps with depression is also reading the Jātaka tales of the Buddha, the previous life stories of the Buddha, how the Buddha practiced in previous lifetimes. The Jātaka tales, the stories that the Buddha taught of his own previous lives of how he practiced all these compassionate deeds of renunciation and so on, and created the causes to achieve enlightenment. So these can be inspiring.

In Buddhist libraries? The Jātaka tales, they’re available. I don’t know in other languages, they definitely exist in English. There’s a number of different versions of them available. Complete sets of them and just some of them in various places.

I think generally when our mind gets slow and depressed, if we have some faith in the Dharma, what helps is just reading any Dharma book, any Dharma text. Usually when we get depressed, then our practice collapses, we forget about the Dharma, we forget about our Buddha nature and everything, we forget that there’s a method, then it’s really helpful to read a Dharma book such as Śāntideva’s Bodhisattva Way of Life. This is really inspiring. Because even when we’re depressed as dharma practitioners we think, we pretend to ourselves that the dharma is in our mind, that we know about impermanence and death and this and that and that and this, but actually it’s become very weak. And then when you read the actual words of great bodhisattvas such as Śāntideva, then it starts to become real again, it all faded from the mind and the mind gets depressed.

But then when you read the words of really great beings, then it starts to again become more real, more inspiring and it lifts up the mind. Of course, also to reflect on one’s Buddha nature that despite whatever is going on, the confusion in one’s life, the depression itself, it’s not who I really am, it’s just passing clouds in the sky of my mind which has Buddha nature. So then as I mentioned before also one antidote to all the delusions is doing breathing practice where we just we notice the disturbing thoughts arise but we don’t follow them, we don’t believe in that delusion, we try not to identify that this is me, we don’t try to identify that this is all my mind is capable of, it’s arising from the clarity of my mind. So if we can train ourselves to do this, then this helps to act as an antidote to all the delusions. And by doing this kind of practice regularly, then our mind just generally in our life, in our daily life, becomes more calm and clear.

And so in that calm, clear state, when the delusions start to arise, it’s much easier to notice them arising, and therefore to try to avoid them, not repress them, but apply some antidote. But if our mind is always fairly agitated, it’s difficult to recognize a new delusion arising or that same delusion arising more strongly. Also in general, as an antidote to our delusions, a general type of thing to do if we want to follow the spiritual life in any way, is to lead a more simple life, a less hectic, stressful, busy, busy life. This is what people are doing more and more, people are rushing around more and more, and there’s no time to practice. Because there’s no time to practice, the self-cherishing thought is strong, which causes us to rush around a lot.

And because that isn’t satisfying we have to rush around more to try and make it satisfying. And because we’re rushing around so much there’s no time to look at our mind and practice the Dharma to get a little bit of satisfaction inside, and because that isn’t arising inside, then we try to find it outside, rush around following the self-cherishing thought. And because we’re following the self-cherishing thought, there’s no time to find satisfaction inside, because there’s no satisfaction inside, we follow the self-cherishing thought which doesn’t bring any satisfaction, so we have to follow it more, which doesn’t give us time to look inside our mind and find satisfaction, therefore we have to follow self-cherishing thought more. I could go on for a long time. But that’s been going on since beginningless time.

So it’s important to look at our life and what is important, what is really worthwhile, what is really meaningful, what is really satisfying for ourselves and others now and in the future. Okay, so this is something about the delusions and the antidotes, that all the teachings, all the practices, the meditations in the lam rim are antidotes to the delusions, one way or another. Of course, again I mentioned the great antidote to all the delusions is the realization of emptiness, but also the more we develop love and compassion in our life, in our mind, and we see that as a way of life, of making our life more loving and compassionate, firstly just to ourselves, to have a life that is more loving to ourselves, taking care of ourselves correctly, not the self-cherishing thought, but taking care of our mind and being compassionate to ourselves and using our life to be more loving and compassionate to others, if we’re really engaging in that in some way, that also makes it more difficult for the disturbing thoughts to arise. There’s not a direct antidote, but when our mind is pervaded by love and compassion, then it’s more difficult for the disturbing thoughts to arise.

But why is now love and compassion really, really strong and ever present in our mind is because we follow the self-cherishing thought and keep perpetuating our delusions. So we have to attack the delusions from every angle, from every possible way. So then, if we are able to subdue the disturbing thoughts more and more, and gain satisfaction and contentment with that, then it is easier to meditate and gain more experience, more inner satisfaction, therefore we’re less obsessed with the external world, and because of that our disturbing thoughts don’t arise so much, because they don’t arise so much, then we have time to practice more, therefore more inner satisfaction, therefore it becomes easier to develop single point concentration. And we’ve got time to study, to go to teachings from great lamas on emptiness, developing the teachings about wisdom, and we’ve got time to study them, and then we can meditate on them. And then one day we will develop single pointed concentration, we will find the refuting object, and then we will have a very good understanding of the Mādhyamika, and we will destroy the refuting object.

We will eliminate it, and we will be liberated. So at this so yeah. But this is not the end of the path because we can’t just be liberated for ourselves, we need to help liberate all sentient beings. But what we’ve covered so far are the two first scopes of the three kinds of scopes that we can possibly generate, the three levels of ability. The first level is developing renunciation of this life, the second is renouncing all of saṃsāra and deciding to develop the wisdom realizing emptiness.

So if one just follows that to its conclusion, one will achieve nirvana, become an arhat. And at this point, if one wants to do that, then one considers engaging in the practice of the three higher trainings. In order to develop this wisdom, I have to have single pointed concentration. In order to develop single pointed concentration, I have to practice pure morality, avoiding the ten non virtues, creating the ten virtues at the very least. But in the lam rim it doesn’t go into much detail on those things now because they’re taught more in the context of Mahāyāna path.

But at least here, just briefly I can make the point that to go back to the point about how the law of cause and effect is key aspect of the buddhadharma, and the more we see the need to avoid negative karma and to at least that and perhaps accumulate positive karma, one way to be able to do that, to help do that, is to take vows, various kinds of vows. As Holiness said, on the path to enlightenment, first we have to stop creating negative karma. So by doing that, it means we have to subdue, we don’t follow our delusions so strongly. So the more we avoid creating negative karma, that means we start working with our delusions, and then having subdued them a little bit, then we can put a lot of effort into subduing them and eventually eliminating them. And what is a key part of that process is taking vows.

On the basis of taking refuge in the Buddhadharma, then one can take various levels of vows. Especially one can consider taking the five lay precepts as an essential even if one doesn’t consider taking them as vows, these are really important guidelines in one’s life as a way to integrate one’s Dharma practice in one’s daily life, of taking these five precepts as a guideline in one’s life, and ideally to actually take these vows for life. Because we can have the thought in our mind, I will not kill, I will not steal, I will not lie, I will not engage in sexual misconduct, and have a very sincere wish to not do these things, and because of that wish, because of understanding, one may not do these things. But by taking the vow not to do these in a formal ceremony according to the lineage going back to the Buddha, then this generates some extra it’s really not possible to explain how it works. I don’t think it’s really it’s one of these kind of little magical mystical things that happens, but by taking vows one generates in one’s mental continuum some extra energy that makes it easier to avoid these negative things.

Much, much easier. And so it not only because partly how it works, but it’s not the only explanation by any means, but by understanding the law of cause and effect and taking vows not to do certain things, then one understands that breaking the vow creates more negative karma. So because of that, it forces us to be more sensitive, to be more mindful of what we’re doing in our daily life. Because when we have a vow, like if we kill something, that creates negative karma for sure. But if we top of it we have the vow not to kill, then when we kill, we not only create the natural negative karma of killing, we’ve created the negative karma of breaking the vow.

So we have to be extra mindful and careful. So it’s a method for the ordinary mind to wake up, to be more clear, more sensitive of what’s going on around us, so that we don’t cause harm to ourselves and others. Not only that, so it not only has this benefit of making us more aware, sensitive, mindful and so on, and therefore helps us to avoid creating suffering, it actually creates merit, more merit. If there are two people, one in their whole life they don’t kill anything but they have no vow not to kill, but another person doesn’t kill anything but they have the vow not to kill, the person with the vow creates much more merit because of the vow, because of the power of the vow. So the vow not only protects us from creating negative karma, it creates a great deal of merit in every moment that we’re keeping it.

Okay, so it’s really worthwhile to consider this. I’m not trying to push this on to the new people but especially there’s quite a few people here who are Buddhists, maybe have refuge, but don’t have these precepts. So it is important to think about these at some point in one’s Dharma life. The five lay precepts are not killing any living being, it’s just the wish avoiding intentionally killing a living being, avoiding intentionally lying, avoiding intentionally stealing, avoiding sexual misconduct, it doesn’t mean avoiding sexual activities altogether, which some people I think thought that’s what I said, it doesn’t mean that. Avoiding sexual misconduct, and sometimes you can, as I said, you can bargain with the lama, how that one goes, sometimes you can’t.

And the last one is avoiding intoxicants. So one can take one of these vows, two of them, three of them, four of them, or five of them at different times. You can take all five at once, or you can just take one, then you can decide to take another one later on, or you could decide to take three later on, or all the others at some other time. So one can think that vows are something kind of negative, but if one understands they’re giving us freedom, it is the way to have a freer life, to be free of the delusions. If we want our freedoms to run rampant sorry, if we want our delusions to run rampant, then taking vows looks like we’re putting ourselves in jail.

If we want to have the freedom to develop our mind to be free of the delusions more and more, then the method that makes us free is taking vows. But we should do them, you know, when we feel that we’re ready for it and when we have confidence that we can keep them. Basically we can keep them. If one breaks some of these lay precepts it doesn’t destroy the precepts, one can purify them. It doesn’t mean if you break them one time you’ve totally lost them at all.

The precept is generating this wish to avoid these things, to intentionally avoid doing these things. So these things are worthwhile to think about. Sorry, there’s not much time, but if there’s one or two questions? Well, they also say meditating on the twelve links because it’s difficult to understand them once pride collapses. Sorry?

Rejoicing. So, for pride it’s it’s actually it can be meditating, think about anything complicated, but also meditating on how oneself is arising dependent on many things and even the qualities that we’re proud of have arisen dependent on many things, including our good old mom, teaching us very simple things. There are quite a few books of the Jātaka tales, selections of them, and there’s a three volume set of all the Jātaka tales. There’s that bookshop in Thamel, you know, what’s it called on the yeah, is Pilgrims but there’s one just nearby not right in Thamel, just as you’re coming into Thamel. You know where the Fire and Ice restaurant is, if you know where the Fire and Ice just opposite there.

There’s a bookshop there that sells the three. When you go to Fire and Ice, buy your Jātaka tales as well. Yes? Tibetan bookshop. Possibly, if Lama Yeshe said so, I can’t go against that.

Yes, possibly yes. Well, monks vows you can give back even though they’re meant to be taken for life, is possible in certain circumstances to give them back. Yes, basically it’s the same for all of us. It’s not something unique to each of us, We’re all creating the same illusory self, sense of self, yes. Yeah, there are many levels but there’s actually one final refuting object.

Yeah. There is the very subtle refuting object which is there is the appearance of a person that is not the body and mind, that is completely independent of the body and mind, and that is the refuting object, but the very refuting object sorry, the very subtle refuting object is the person that appears independent of being labelled, that is existing without the need of being labelled. This is what Lama Zopa Rinpoche says, is the very subtle refuting object. What we do is we think of all like some of the things I just said to contemplate those points that, you know, we think of an enemy we have in the past, someone who’s upset us in the past, and then we try to see especially if we’ve got a present enemy, he or she is not with us now, but we have a problem with a person and we’ve got angry with them before and this and that. So then we try and think, actually this person is really helping me.

They have no intention to, but actually rather than dwelling on the old thoughts that know, we like I mentioned before, the enemy may not be present but we fantasize about them and get totally angry about imagining something they haven’t even done. So instead of doing that kind of meditation, which we spontaneously do, we do the meditation where we think, well actually, even this person, by saying that, even if they were wrong, said I lied or stole or made a mistake, even though it was wrong, it showed my self-cherishing thought and showed me how easy I’m attached to my reputation and blah blah blah. So this was very kind. By thinking and all the other things, in a peaceful situation where the enemy isn’t there, one can start to generate this different way of looking at things so that when the enemy actually is present, then one has built up a little bit of this wisdom light, patient energy to apply to the anger, to undermine this stuff that’s saying this person is really bad, really harmful, I should shut them up, you know, should harm them. Absolutely.

I was going to talk about that later in the bodhichitta bit. Yes. But you’ve got it, that’s true, that’s it. Also, bit of an antidote to anger is having a sense of humour. Because we get angry because we take ourselves so seriously, yeah?

And it’s so real, so concrete, the thing is so terrible, there’s no sense of humor in the situation whatsoever. But if we have a little bit of we can try to be a little bit humorous about the whole thing, then that can really break that mind that is making things so concrete in the moment. Thank you very much. Lama Lhundrup will come tonight for question and answer, in the last session for question and answer. Eight o’clock?

Eight o’clock. Why quarter to eight? Seven o’clock. Oh, new time? Yes.

Oh, okay. Quarter to eight. Oh, yeah? Sorry. Sorry.

It’s the time you have given to Lama Lhundrup because the shop, of course, they all counted. Oh, no. No. It’s already fixed the quarter two, is it? Quarter to eight.

Alright. Oh, so you do quarter Vajrasattva quarter to eight. So Lama Lhundrup could come at eight? Yes. Oh, Okay, Lama Lhundrup will come at eight.

Yes? Will come at eight o’clock. Okay, is that okay? Shall we dedicate the merits? May the precious bodhi, mind, not yet arise and grow.

May that born have no decline, but increase forevermore. Okay. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
three higher trainings lhagpäi lab pa sum (Tib)
The three higher trainings of ethics, concentration and wisdom when conjoined with refuge in the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top