Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 27 Tape 53 Side 2

44 min · 5,068 words · 27 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 27 Tape 53 Side 2
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teacher explains that concentration alone does not produce wisdom, but single-pointed concentration, built on subduing disturbing thoughts especially attachment, supports insight into emptiness. He then teaches patience by viewing the enemy as kind, since the enemy exposes self-cherishing, and notes that patience must be cultivated in calm states before anger arises.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-27

Duration: 45 min

UUID: 92aea624-b678-4c13-9e98-a29c00761e75

Words: 5,068

I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, the Supreme Assembly. By the merits I create through teaching the Dharma, may I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings? So, we spend just a little time focusing on the breath. Okay. Thank you.

So this morning, we were talking about the different delusions and how to subdue them. Of course, from an ordinary point of view, even if we think there’s just the brain, then still we have thoughts. Somehow we have thoughts. So, it is our thoughts that even in this life causes suffering and confusion. So we need a way to overcome it.

But these teachings are being given in the context of following the life to liberation and complete enlightenment. Particularly, the reason we need to, of course, by subduing the mind we minimise the suffering we have, the main purpose is that by minimising the disturbing thoughts we’re able to develop single pointed concentration eventually, and on the basis of having single pointed concentration, we will be able to apply the teachings that we’ve studied about the nature of phenomena and gain the direct realisation, the direct insight of the true nature of phenomena. I just try and make it clear that concentration does not lead to wisdom at all. No matter how concentrated the mind is, one never develops just from concentration the wisdom that realizes emptiness. Concentration is simply a technique that one needs to meditate with and what one object the subject is the person.

The object of meditation is the understanding of the teachings of emptiness how to identify the refuting object, the object to be refuted and then how to realise, to experience what is actually true, free from all mental fabrications. So one studies those teachings, contemplates on them, and so by studying those teachings one gets the wisdom arising from listening to the teachings on emptiness. Then by contemplating them, doing analytical meditation, one develops the wisdom that arises from analytical meditation. But then, finally, we need to develop the highest kind of wisdom that comes from meditating on them in a state of calm abiding. And it’s only when one has that quality, that ability to meditate in a state of calm abiding that one’s understanding of the teachings on emptiness, the true nature of phenomena, can be applied totally effectively in order to destroy ignorance and gain wisdom.

I hope that makes a little bit of sense. But we need this single pointed concentration that arises from subduing the precondition is having subdued the disturbing thoughts to some extent. Because to achieve single pointed concentration, that can really only be done in very strict retreat, you can’t do that at home. Many realizations could be gained at home meditating, doing analytical meditations of the thalam rim meditations of impermanence and death, recognizing the precious human rebirth, developing the realisation of Guru devotion and so on. These possibly could, in fact, could definitely be done at home, but not single pointed concentrate.

It depends where your home is, of course. If it’s in the middle of nowhere, then you could maybe gain a realisation of concentration. But it has to be done in very special circumstances, in an extremely quiet place, a very conducive place, and the precondition is to have a mind of contentment to have a mind of contentment! Which comes from having subdued the disturbing thoughts, especially attachment, because the main hindrance to developing single pointed concentration is not anger, jealousy, pride or being afraid to be in the forest, but attachment. So, we went through some of the antidotes to attachment, general attachment and also attachment to people’s bodies.

I haven’t gone into all the details about that one because it just upsets people so there’s not much point. If you want to develop that attachment, you can read about it in considerable detail in Śāntideva’s book, The Guide to the Bodhisattva Way of Life, which is one of the most beautiful Dharma books of all time. It’s not just beautiful but it’s incredibly powerful and it contains all of the essential Mahāyāna teachings in one small volume, in verse form, for each four lines is just a little power packet of wisdom and compassion. Each stanza verse? I lived for one year at Sera Je Monastery in the south of India during nineteen eighty two, and there was a young boy in the house where I lived.

He was maybe twelve. I’m not really sure it’s very difficult to tell with Tibetans their age, they always appear much younger than they are. But he’s probably about twelve and I was talking to him one day and I discovered that he’d memorised the entire bodhisattva Charvatara by heart. He knew it by heart. So I memorized the first chapter but then I forgot it.

I once had the good fortune to have a private audience with His Holiness Dalai Lama and he advised that it’s incredibly good to just read a few verses or even one verse, I can’t remember the exact holy advice now, but it was to read one, two, three verses of this text every day and just keep going through it. So within a few months you can read this entire book, just by reading one or two verses a day, and then you’re imprinting the bodhicitta in your mind and keeping your mind in contact with the dharma all the time. I highly recommend it. I don’t know in the other traditions but in the Gelugpa tradition that there is hardly a Dharma text that has been written by a lama of the Gelugpa tradition that doesn’t quote Śāntideva’s entering the bodhisattva way of life. This text, the Lam Rim Chenmo, is full of quotations from it, full of it.

Got off the topic, of course. In chapter on meditation Śāntideva’s chapter of meditation, the first part is about dealing with the main obstacle to meditation, single pointed meditation, which is attachment. So he goes through this meditation on the ugliness of the body. So if you read it, of course, it’s about the ugliness of the female body because it was written for monks for men. So it’s not a put down of women, it was written by a man for monks in a particular monastery and it’s just all you have to do for women is reverse it.

Same for if you’re attracted if a woman attracted to male bodies, you just think of the ugliness, the putrid nature of the male body. It works either way. Or if you’re attracted to a man attracted to male bodies or a woman attracted to female bodies, it’s the same thing. It’s just a body and it’s putrid inside. So it’s all there in detail.

Another method one can try is to think that the person you’re attracted to is your sister, your mother or your brother, your father. Depending on the age of the person you’re attracted to, you do it like that. You try that one. It says I didn’t bring it, when I want to quote it, I don’t bring it. But Kadampa Geshe says, When he lists all these things to overcome attachment, if none of these things work it means a devil has entered you so you need to see an exorcist.

But again, just one theme I try to emphasise in this course is that the way these things work is through doing it repeatedly because we have this strong habit, not just from this life, many previous lives, of following various disturbing thoughts. So it’s not like just thinking about hearing this one time even if we agree completely now, we think, Oh yes, that’s totally true. But that is not powerful enough as an antidote to our disturbing thoughts. Like Lami, as you said, our wisdom light is just so tiny, and there’s the darkness of our disturbing mind. So our wisdom light is so weak, so the darkness can easily put it out again and again.

But we can build that wisdom light up through the power of familiarity. So So then, as I mentioned, I’ll talk in some detail about developing the antidote to anger which is patience later on in the course. But for the time being, I’ll just remind, as I mentioned before, that one way to develop patience is thinking of the disadvantages of anger and the advantages of having patience for oneself now and in the future, for others now and in the future. This is one general way that we can develop patience. And Thinking of the harm to oneself, developing compassion for oneself that is harmed by anger.

If I get angry, who really is harmed? In fact, we think the enemy is harming us, but in fact it’s our anger that causes the greatest harm. No enemy can cause as much damage to ourselves as our own anger and all our other disturbing thoughts. The worldly mind believes the enemy is out there. The enemy is always out there.

But the reality is the enemy, the real enemy, is inside the mind. The two enemies, major enemies of self grasping ignorance and the enemy of self-cherishing or self obsessed thought. So, under this umbrella of the self-cherishing thought comes the spokes of that umbrella are our desire attachment, anger, jealousy, pride, doubt, fears, worries. All the disturbing thoughts cooperate together very cozily to produce the self-cherishing, self obsessed thought which is our main enemy. As Śāntideva says I think Śāntideva said something like this and also anyway, Lama Zopa Rinpoche says it, that even if all our enemies in the world join forces against us, all they can do is take our life.

They can just cut short this life. But the enemies of our disturbing thoughts can throw us into the lowest hells. Only our own mind can do that, only our own disturbing thoughts does that. In our confusion we think it is the enemy who is making me suffer, it is the enemy that is making me unhappy. But in fact, the enemy from their own side, the so called enemy, has no power from their side to do that.

We allow the enemy to disturb our mind by following anger. It’s our own anger that disturbs our mind and causes suffering, we then blame on the enemy, Look what you’ve made me do. But if enemy from their own side could make us angry and suffer, then the enemy could make the Buddha suffer, could make the Buddha angry and upset and miserable. But the Buddha isn’t in that state, and being at a much lower level of spiritual accomplishment than the Buddha are not upset by the thoughts, words and activities of an enemy because they’ve developed patience. For the worldly mind it looks like the enemy is the complete problem, it’s all their fault.

That the enemy can only be effective if we have the inner enemy, ourself, of anger and self-cherishing. So, if think about that and see how that is true, then this again is a realistic, virtuous way of thinking that undermines this unrealistic, negative way of thinking that produces anger. So there’s many, many different ways of thinking, any one of which can help generate patience. So, in Śāntideva’s text he goes through many, many ways of arguing to completely refute whatever way the mind thinks to justify anger and to cause harm to others, Śāntideva, with one little line, one teeny argument, not complicated arguments, just very simple arguments just shoots them to pieces. So, if we contemplate this again and again, we can generate this quality of patience because, again, the only way patience is generated in the mind is by contemplating it and by contemplating the various arguments that generate the thought of patience.

And this can only be done when we ourselves are not angry, when we ourselves are in a calm frame of mind. The trouble is, we make the mistake that when we’re in a calm frame of mind we think, Oh, I don’t have any anger so I don’t have to do anything about it. But actually, we all have the potential for it. So we need to cultivate patience for when we meet the object, and we need to cultivate it when we’re in a calm, virtuous state of mind. So, just like soldiers don’t learn how to fight during a battle they also do that but they train to learn how to fight before the battle starts.

It gives them a fighting chance, right? To know which way to point the rifle and how to load it. It’s better to learn while it’s quiet rather than bullets flying all around you. With anger. It’s difficult to learn patience while the mind is inflamed with anger.

It’s impossible actually to think clearly while one is angry. Patience is a way of thinking clearly and rationally and compassionately. So this can only be learnt in meditation, doing this analytical meditation and doing it again and again and again. This is the method. Just briefly, there are three kinds of patience.

In essence, all patience, the nature of patience is the same, there’s just the difference in the object. So there’s the patience towards the so called enemy. So in Buddhadharma, I don’t know what the word in Tibetan is used, but it has been translated as enemy. And of course, enemy is a very, very strong word and most of us probably don’t have enemies as such. We don’t think we have enemies as such.

But the term is just simply used to apply to anyone we may even dislike for a moment. So that in that moment, as we dislike them for any reason, that becomes the enemy. So it doesn’t necessarily mean someone we hate and want to murder, it just means someone even and of course it can mean that, but just anyone that, even for a moment, we are disliking, that becomes the enemy in that moment. So, there is the patience developed towards the enemy, there is the patience developed towards all sorts of other problems including our own disturbing thoughts and limitations and so on. And then there’s the practice of there’s the patience towards practicing the Dharma.

And ultimately, for a Dharma practitioner, especially someone trying to follow the path to enlightenment, the Mahāyāna path to enlightenment, developing patience is a key quality that we need. Patience generally is the mind that is able to bear some kind of difficulty, some kind of suffering. Anger cannot bear it patience is the mind that can bear it in a positive way, not by suppressing it and so on, is able to recognize it and support it, bear it. So this is in following the path to enlightenment, we need to be able to have this courageous mind of patience. A word His Holiness uses a lot in practising Dharma is we need courage. So what is courage?

Basically, it’s compassion. There’s not much difference really between courage and compassion. If you have compassion, you have courage. If you have courage, real courage, spiritual courage, then you can practise compassion. Patience is a type of compassion also for ourselves and the enemy.

Following the path to enlightenment is a big job. It’s a very enjoyable job, but it is a big job and there are difficulties which we have to admit. The difficulty of studying the teachings on emptiness, for example. The difficulties of practising every kind of patience sorry, generosity and pure morality and so on. Engaging all the difficulties and then getting to practising tantra and actually engaging in it correctly, intensively.

So, there are difficulties, so if we are upset by the difficulties, we won’t do them. We will avoid them. We will find them unbearable and give up. But if we have the patience to practise the Dharma, then liberation and enlightenment are in the palm of our hand. So, how we develop that most essential patience of being able to practice the Dharma begins basically with developing patience towards the enemy.

This is the one we need first, as ordinary people anyway, because we’re constantly surrounded by other sentient beings and we have negative karma and delusions. Sentient beings continuously arise in our mind as the enemy. As soon as they don’t agree with what we say so on, the opposite to what we want drive their cars in front of us, get the parking spot before we do, sit in the bus seat before we get there, or then enemies are created constantly. So, we need the patience to deal with the external enemy first. This is crucial from an ordinary point of view and especially from the dharma point of view to avoid creating negative karma.

And from the Mahāyāna point of view, why we don’t want to create negative karma is not because it causes will result in suffering towards ourselves, but because every time we create negative karma it’s harming others and we’re trying to be a bodhisattva who helps others, so it’s totally contrary. But the other main reason is every time we create negative karma, it’s an obstacle to gaining the realizations in the path. Every single kind of small, big, medium negative karma is an obstacle, it creates an obstacle in the mind to achieving any realisation on the path. So every time we create negative karma it’s just kind of putting a roadblock up. Not only a roadblock but it also forces us to detour around the roadblock.

So it takes even longer to follow the path. That’s why purification is such an important practice to get rid of all these roadblocks. So, how does one practice patience? Only way to practice unfortunately, the only way to practice patience is to have an enemy. If you don’t have an enemy, there’s no way to practice patience.

It is not possible to practice patience with our friends because our friends, by definition, go along with us. They agree with us, they laugh at our jokes and everything else, so they’re our friends. So they don’t make us upset. As soon as they do, they’re our enemy, then we can practice patience with them. But while they’re being friendly, there’s no way to practice patience with them.

And when all the good conditions come together, there’s no way to practice patience. And we don’t think there’s any need to. Everything’s going along just so fine. We have the nice cozy cell with the fluffy cushions, air conditioning, three-dimensional coloured television set everything we need. So, we’re not going to get angry, but then the object comes along one day and we have no preparation for it, so the anger is even stronger.

If we have little enemies day by day and little bits of anger, that’s a way to learn to overcome them. But we may go for years and years and years and never get angry and then one day there’s no way to deal with it. So, from a dharma point of view, especially from the bodhicitta mind training point of view, to have the enemy is the best thing. Friends are our worst enemies, our worst enemies are our best friends. Our ordinary enemies are our worst enemies because they keep us in saṃsāra.

Our attachment to them, also their own delusions keep us in saṃsāra, whereas the enemy is so kind, so unbelievably kind in pointing out all our faults and forcing us to practice the Dharma and practice patience. So this is also another way of being able to generate patience, of seeing that actually the enemy is unbelievably kind. It’s unbelievably kind. In reality, this is not just being cute this is actually true. From a dharma point of view, the enemy is unbelievably kind.

Our ordinary mind doesn’t think so, but the Dharma mind can actually generate this view. This is something that is common to all the mystic traditions of all the religions. This is what Saint Francis practiced, that the mystic tradition sees suffering as the path to heaven, liberation, enlightenment, whatever you want to call it. Our worldly mind sees suffering as the worst thing possible. In the mystic tradition, suffering is the best thing possible because we are forced to develop a wise, compassionate way of dealing with it otherwise it overwhelms us.

Otherwise, we do all these negative things to escape it. So, in all the mystic traditions and in Mahāyāna Buddhism, which is a very straightforward mystic tradition, a down to earth mystic tradition, there is this view of arguing that the enemy is the best friend, is our spiritual friend. So, if we contemplate that, this itself helps us to practice patience because our perception of that person that we felt that anger labels someone who upsets us the enemy. Anything or anyone that goes against our wish for easy happy now is the enemy. Anything that does that.

And the more we have this desire for easy happy now, we create more enemies and they appear as huge enemies. Now in our modern societies we have this phenomenon that seems to be spreading all over the world of road rage. Road rage where people get because of people cutting in on their car and something, people get unbelievably angry, get out of the car, start screaming and yelling and beating people and even killing them. So this this is a reflection of the incredible self-cherishing that we are dominated by at the moment. That we we know that people cannot do that to me.

The road was built for me to get to work. Everyone knows that. You know, I paid my taxes for this road to be built for me to get to. I am going to work, you know, and I have to get to work by someone, you know. He might the person, the creep, knows that.

And everyone is totally stressed out, also that stress is because of following so many things, so many activities generated by desire and the self-cherishing thought. So there’s so much stress and tension and the need to have something easy, happy now. Yeah. And that when that easy, happy now the more we need easy, happy now, the more the mind explodes when it’s not happening easy, happy now. Difficult, miserable now.

Do not like difficult, miserable now. So, what am I trying to say? What am I trying to say? So, the self-cherishing mind creates all these enemies and so the self-cherishing mind labels that person enemy. Anyone who does that, who interferes with this easy happy mind now, is perceived, is given the label ‘bad enemy’.

Not that exact word, right? Don’t take it too concretely, just we label this person bad, a jerk, a creep plenty in French, Spanish, Italian what we label them. And then having the mind labelling that, we believe that that is the truth and then anger arises. But if we don’t label someone the enemy, they can’t appear as the enemy because nothing exists from its own side. If we don’t give it the label, it can’t appear that way.

I will try to explain this later if I work up the courage to try and give the examples of explaining that. And our habits, our habitual behaviour, forces us to label things in one way, that anything that interferes with my momentary happiness is bad. So then we label it bad, and then we see it bad. But then, if we train our mind with the Dharma teachings to see that actually the enemy is doing something very good, even if it’s not their intention, but the result can be incredibly beneficial. If we train our mind to see that in meditation, to understand that and to have a calmer, clearer mind in our daily life, when someone does something that interferes with a self-cherishing thought, rather than seeing that as something bad, since we ourselves, if we’re trying to practice Dharma, we want to destroy our self-cherishing thought.

That’s the whole point. That’s the whole point of the game, is to overcome, first to modify, eventually eliminate the self-cherishing thought. And that’s exactly what the enemy is doing, is going against our self-cherishing thought. This is what we try to do in meditation. All the meditations of the Lam Rim are about opposing the self-cherishing thought.

Here comes someone, free of charge, to oppose our self-cherishing thought. How unbelievably kind! Someone mentioned it once before that when you try and meditate on the breath, a million thoughts come. When one tries to think about the lam rim, all the thoughts stop. The mind goes like wood at the wrong time.

So we try and meditate on all these things, the thoughts of the self-cherishing thought, and nothing comes, it’s kind of blank. Can’t think of a single fault of self-cherishing thought. Single pointed concentration on, you know, no idea what the faults of the self-cherishing thought are. But along comes someone who meditates for us free of charge, who just immediately, right up our nose as the expression goes, something like that, right in the face, right up your nose, points out all our faults to us. This is the enemy.

But when we see that, rather than seeing them as the enemy, we see them, Oh, that’s incredibly kind. That’s so beneficial. I didn’t realize that before. Oh, I thought I was kind, calm and patient and now they’ve shown me that I’m not as patient as I thought. That’s helpful.

It seems we can get to this point. As Lama Zopa Rinpoche argues, we can get to this point. He will argue for a long time that we can get to this point. And we can aspire to get to it. This is the point.

Sometimes one way of looking at the Dharma teachings seems it’s so beyond us, so beyond, I can’t do this, it’s far beyond me. But the way to get to these inconceivable states is aspiring to them. Is what the Dharma says, what the Buddhadharma talks about, is something wonderful or not? Even if it seems totally fantastic, is it a wonderful fantasy or a nightmare fantasy? I think it’s kind of wonderful And therefore we can aspire to it.

And by aspiring to it, you know, then we can there’s some energy there to move in that direction. But if there’s no aspiration, no inspiration, we’re never going to start. So rather than thinking bodhicitta is just such a huge thing, which is one way of looking at it, which brings suffering, we can look at it another way, is that it’s just such an amazing state of mind. How wonderful it would be to get to that state of mind or how wonderful to have even something remotely like that kind of thought that wants to benefit every sentient being. Wouldn’t it be wonderful to have that kind of mind?

Something even remotely like that kind of mind? Even for a little while in our mind, in my mind? I think it would be wonderful. If we don’t think it’s even slightly wonderful, we’re never going to move towards it. We don’t have to get depressed that we’re not there.

We just make our mind happy by thinking how wonderful that state is and aspire to it. So we may think, Oh, it’s impossible to think the enemy is kind. But if we aspire to what the teachings say about that, what an amazing teaching to think that one could love the enemy rather than hate the enemy. What an amazing teaching. What an amazing mind thought that out.

How incredible! Wouldn’t it be great even for one second to think like that? And then through aspiring that, maybe we can for one second think like that, and then maybe two seconds, three seconds, and then sooner before we know it we’re thinking like it all the time. So when we see the actual benefits of the enemy, then enemy no longer appears as the enemy but as the helpful friend, then the anger doesn’t arise. No way for it to arise because we see what is happening as beneficial.

What we actually want. So this is another way of practicing one of the directions one can think of to generate patience. There are many ways to think, that help to generate patience. So that’s one of them. To investigate that, that way of thinking.

Especially from the long-term point of view that this enemy is so kind in forcing me to practice patience with him or her and then by developing that patience towards ordinary people, I can develop that patience. That gives me the ability to be patient with any other kind of problem. When I have a sickness, I have some financial problems, I have problems with my family, with the job, with my own mind, whatever, then I can be patient with it and it all comes from learning patience with this person, how incredibly kind that is. And then, because of having that patience of dealing with ordinary worldly problems, I can have the patience of voluntarily taking on the difficulties of practicing the Dharma for all sentient beings. And it all comes from being patient with this person here, right in front of me, screaming and yelling at me.

How incredibly kind this person is actually acting as a cause for my complete enlightenment. So, if we think in this broad perspective, then we see how the enemy is kind, even though it’s not their intention to be. But if we follow their intention and let them hurt us, it’s ridiculous. But even though they intend us harm, by looking at it another way they can be incredible benefit. Isn’t that kind of wise and clever?

If we go along with the enemy and let them harm us, we’re doing what the enemy wants. And by that happening, by ourselves getting angry and upset and suffering, that is creating negative karma for the enemy. But if we don’t get upset

Key terms in this teaching

analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
Gelug
The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
guru devotion
After finding a fully qualified spiritual teacher and establishing a connection, the disciple trains in devotion using logical reasoning. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top