Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 08 Tape 07 Side 1 Attachment

44 min · 4,686 words · 8 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 08 Tape 07 Side 1 Attachment
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk opens with a visualisation of the Buddha and an offering of the mandala, then moves to breath-focused meditation to calm the mind. It then teaches that lasting happiness comes from transforming the mind rather than from external things. It explains ignorance as the grasping at a self, and how attachment and desire follow from that misunderstanding.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-08

Duration: 45 min

UUID: 86283eb1-1062-4d0d-804f-30e27dbfc536

Words: 4,686

We imagine dispelling all the obstacles that are in our mind and in the environment. Also, one makes prostrations by making this mudra, This is the bringing together of wisdom and compassion together. So the only way to destroy anything is with wisdom and compassion together. You smash every obstacle that way. Actually, from this point it is worthwhile, useful for those people who have refuge, those people who are generating faith in the Buddhadharma as well.

At least such people can it’s helpful to visualise the Buddha directly in front of us at this point. Other people who have not developed any faith in the Buddhadharma, still they may like to try to do this, or visualise some other being that they see as the ultimate object, trustworthy object, having the qualities of perfect wisdom and compassion, at least to imagine that those qualities are present here before us, and we wish to receive those qualities and the blessings of those qualities in our own mind. We can visualize the Buddha seated on a very beautiful golden throne. On the throne is a lotus. On the lotus is a sun disk.

Above that is a moon disk. Seated on the moon disk is Śākyamūni Buddha. His right hand outstretched with a hand resting on his right knee, the fingers pointing down in what is called the earth touching mudra. His left hand is in his lap in the meditation position, holding a begging bowl. At the same time, we imagine ourselves surrounded by all the different kinds of sentient beings who are experiencing all kinds of suffering and confusion, who so desperately need our help.

If only we could purify and develop our minds. Especially we think of our mother on our left, our father on our right, family and friends at the back of us, and the people we dislike and or who wish harm to us directly in front of us, then surrounding those or the countless different kinds of sentient beings. And then we offer the mandala, imagining the whole universe and all the beautiful things in the universe, especially everything that we attach to, believing they’ll bring happiness, whereas in fact they have no means to do so. We offer all these things to the Buddhas in order to free our minds, to open our minds, to receive the blessings of the Buddhas so that we can hear the teachings the way they are meant to be heard, understand them correctly, and to be able to practice them correctly and gain the true insights that all the great practitioners of the past have achieved through true practice. So the prayer of refuge and Bodhicitta is on page eighteen, the Tibetan on page nineteen in English.

But before saying that, we will first spend a little time focusing on our breath as a means to generate a calm, clear and more concentrated mind and use that mind to listen to the teachings so that they can be more effective. Also, establish a neutral mind on the basis of which we can then try and generate a very strong positive motivation for listening. So, in a comfortable position, we become aware of the breath going in and going out. Try to allow the mind to become calm and clear so that we can notice the sensation at tip of the nostrils as the breath comes in and goes out. We try and take a strong interest in that and lose interest in everything else.

Seeing them simply, no matter how fascinating they may appear, how distasteful they may appear, they are simply distractions, nothing else. So we let go of them and go back to the breath. One can, as I said, can count the breaths from one to eleven, only counting undistracted breaths. If the mind wanders, we go back to the count of one. But no matter what we do, what we’ve done, what other living beings have done, it hasn’t succeeded.

We’re experiencing lasting happiness. We have experienced some happiness, but it hasn’t lasted, it hasn’t completely fulfilled us. And we are not free of suffering, discomfort, pain, worries, anxiety and so on. And if we can understand the nature of our mind, this ongoing formless process of experience, then the mind has existed before this life and we have been seeking happiness life after life and we still haven’t achieved it. So, in this very brief lifetime we can begin to understand, we can use our wisdom to understand that the reason we haven’t succeeded, despite all this time, all this effort, is because we have been using the wrong method.

We have been seeking happiness in the external world, in other things, in other people, blaming the external world for our suffering. But if we use our wisdom, we can begin to see that there is no real lasting happiness in the external world, and its source of suffering is not in the external world. Everything arises within our own mind. The only way to really achieve any kind of happiness in this life, in future lives, and and to achieve the state of perfect lasting happiness, free of suffering, is to change our mind, transform, develop our mind. And in the process of doing this, we will not only bring about our own lasting happiness, but also we begin to cause less and less harm and confusion to others.

And the most wonderful thing is that we can reach a point where we can be of active benefit, lasting total benefit to countless living beings. Think how wonderful that would be, that one’s very existence could be a source of happiness to others. And this actually is possible because of the very nature of my mind, my Buddha nature, the Buddha potential of my mind. So I must achieve this state, not just for my own sake, but for the benefit of all living beings. The way to achieve that state is to follow the path, the path of mental transformation to complete enlightenment.

In order to follow the path, I have to understand the path correctly, and to understand the path, first I need to listen to that and explanation on it. So for the benefit of myself and all living beings, I listen to these teachings on the Buddhadharma. I go for refuge until I am enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, and the supreme assembly by the merits I create by practising the Dharma, may I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings. So, as it says in the text about how to listen to the teachings, having generated some concentration and good motivation, then please try to listen in a respectful physical posture free of the three faults of a pot being upside down, a little bit dirty, or leaky one, so please try and avoid those faults. In this way, what is said can be of the greatest benefit.

So, as I’ve been trying to say, we have a mind, not a brain, and our mind has this amazing potential to know everything. And in knowing everything directly and precisely and unmistakenly, we become free of all suffering and we are able to develop all the positive qualities of our mind. The mere fact that the mind is that which knows means that our mind has the potential of wisdom. Doesn’t mean knowing lots of things. Wisdom, in the Buddhist context, means being able to know directly the nature of phenomena.

That is what wisdom is. It’s not having lots of information, lots of worldly experience like little old men and ladies sitting on the porch who are considered wise. But wisdom is the mind that directly sees reality, unmistakenly. So the mind, by simply being that which knows, has that potential, has that quality of wisdom. It has the potential of every good quality of compassion, patience, loving kindness, sensitivity, generosity and so on.

All good qualities exist in the mind. So all of us right now, we have these qualities active in our mind sometimes, but we don’t have them developed very much. We have some wisdom, right? Sometimes. We are not always wise, acting in a wise, intelligent way, but sometimes we do, fortunately.

I hope it was kind of a wise thing to come here. And we do have some compassion and some loving kindness and qualities of generosity and some altruism and so on. Patience, sometimes we’re patient, tolerant, persevering and so on. We have these qualities a little bit, all of us now, they arise in our mind from time to time with a certain degree of intensity. They are always replaced sooner or later by something else, something worse.

So even if there was happiness in the external world, which there isn’t, and we’ll go on to that bit, I’m just kind of stating that very dogmatically. But even if there was happiness in the external world, still, I think, it would be really impossible for us to experience. Even if there was perfect happiness in the external world, if there was something, someone, someone, something, some place that had within it the ability to produce perfect happiness, which the Buddhadharma denies. But even if there was such a place, we wouldn’t be able to experience that perfect happiness because things happen in our mind that in the mind in the mind Sorry, I wonder where I come from. Things happen in the mind that destroy our happiness.

Even if it’s out there, things in our mind cut it, get in the way, harm it. All these disturbing thoughts again and again arise. But really, just to make the point, there isn’t happiness out there. Nothing out there things out there give the illusion of happiness. They give some pleasure, and it may it last for some time, but it doesn’t last.

Right? We’ve all had joyful, happy experiences in our life. We can think back on those. Right? But the point is they are memories.

They are memories. They didn’t last no matter how wonderful they were. They are memories. And one could think say, I am perfectly happy right now. I am perfectly happy right now.

That will become a memory if we don’t change our mind. And we can only think I’m perfectly happy because we have no idea what happiness is. So the Buddhist view, the Dharma view experienced, realised by the Buddha, is that happiness is a state of mind and the perfect lasting happiness that we are seeking, that will bring fulfilment for us, is only when the mind is experiencing these positive qualities, when there is a total absence of all the disturbing thoughts in our mind, a total complete absence of them, and when the mind is pervaded by continuously pervaded by all the positive qualities of patience, perseverance, loving kindness, compassion, generosity, wisdom and so on. When these qualities arise in our mind, that is when we are experiencing happiness. Any any kind of real happiness, satisfaction that we’ve experienced arises when these positive states of mind are arising.

So this is what the path to liberation and enlightenment is about, is enabling, creating the conditions for those qualities of mind which are already there to arise and to arise fully, totally and continuously without any hindrance. When we achieve that, we’ve achieved not just liberation but when those qualities are fully developed we’ve achieved enlightenment. And those qualities then spontaneously and continuously benefit others. So, what interferes? What is the source of our suffering and confusion and limitation are our disturbing thoughts.

We have countless disturbing thoughts and when we try to meditate, we can discover those disturbing thoughts. We can experience some degree of calmness and stillness and positive qualities in our mind, and when we begin to contact those, we can begin to know that this is what we are really seeking, that this is what the mind is naturally seeking. Because of the very nature of our mind, it is impossible not to wish for perfect lasting happiness. That is driving us all the time. This is a natural aspect of our mind to seek happiness.

It’s impossible not to seek happiness, and it’s impossible not to seek to be free of suffering. Everyone, every sentient being is doing that all the time, but the trouble is, although the mind naturally does that, what has happened is again We can’t live without this example. Mind that is now seeking this happiness is totally agitated, so it cannot really recognise in that state what is happiness and what is suffering, What is the cause of happiness and what is the cause of suffering? In our confusion, we often think what is actually suffering is happiness. In our confusion, often perceive what is happiness as suffering.

We perceive the cause of suffering to be happiness, and we see the cause of happiness to be suffering. For example, practicing meditation is actually the cause of happiness. We often see it as suffering. In our confusion, we see it as suffering, the thing to be totally avoided. Much too difficult.

We try it for a few minutes, few days, few weeks, few months much too difficult. But we’ll work for years and years and years and years and years to get a new car or even to buy a second hand one. Because this is going to make me happy. Is brand new car going to make us really, really happy? And yet we work so hard to get these things.

So our mind is really confused about what is happiness and what is suffering, what is the cause of happiness and what is the cause of suffering. It worthwhile to sit down and listen to what the Buddha said. So, we have many disturbing thoughts in our mind that even to try to have a little bit of peace in our mind, stillness in meditation, we can’t have it because of these disturbing thoughts. Even we can’t have five minutes of a calm mind because this stuff gets in the way. All the time it comes and comes.

And why are these thoughts there? Why do we have these thoughts? It’s difficult to go into a complete explanation of that right now, but basically the Buddha said why we have these disturbing thoughts is because of not understanding who we are, not just not intellectually understanding who we are, but not experiencing directly, completely, vividly, unmistakenly who we are. All of us can spend hours talking about ourselves. We talk about ourselves to ourselves, and we talk about ourselves to other people.

I am this, I am that, I have done this, I have done that, I am terrific because of this and because of that, and blah blah blah blah blah blah blah. So we can do this for hours, it fills our mind for hours and hours, day after day. But none of this actually these are all thoughts, ideas, concepts about who we are. They are beliefs about who we are. They are not any direct insight into who we actually are.

We just have lots of ideas and opinions and beliefs and concepts about who we are, but we don’t actually directly, vividly, unmistakenly know who we are, how we exist. You know, sometimes we identify ourselves as our body. If people praise us and say we look very nice, handsome, beautiful or whatever, then we think, I am. Yes, I am. Yeah, that’s nice, true, I am, very beautiful.

If people praise our mental qualities, Oh, you’re so smart, so intelligent, so witty, clever, blah blah blah, we think, Yes, I am, that’s me. Yeah, absolutely true. So, we chop and change between sometimes identifying myself as the body, sometimes as the mind, sometimes we think we’re a combination of our body and mind, sometimes we think we’re something completely else, and sometimes we haven’t got a clue who we are. Yeah. But still we’re always grasping that there is there is something that is really me.

There is this real me existing that we grasp onto. And what we grasp onto as being me is a mistake. It is not who we actually are. But continuously, we are creating this appearance of a person. And we generate it through the power of a whole network of different thoughts and ideas and concepts and perceptions and so on, and we grasp onto that as being real and we hold onto it.

So, this fundamental mistake, this fundamental disturbing thought that we have is technically called in the Buddhadharma ignorance, which is a mind, it is a consciousness which is clear and knowing but is knowing in the wrong way. This ignorance means that it’s not it is a consciousness that more than just not knowing who we are, it actively distorts. It creates a distorted appearance of who we are, of what we are, how we exist. It creates this distorted appearance, and on top of that, it then grasps very strongly that this appearance is one hundred percent true, unmistakenly true. So the mistake that we make about ourselves is something very subtle, but even though it is a very subtle mistake, it leads to countless other mistakes that become the source of every kind of disturbing thought and suffering and confusion.

I’m just going to state this now. We’ll try and talk about this in more detail later on to investigate what this really means. But this is just to state the Buddhist view for the time being in general way. So another term for this ignorance is self grasping because this ignorance creates the appearance of a self, a self in the sense of a person who there is this essential person, is essence within us that is me, I. If you check your mind day by day and throughout our life, are constantly changing our ideas about who we are.

As I said, sometimes we identify with the body, sometimes with the mind, sometimes with a particular aspect of the body, different aspect of the mind, and it’s changing all the time. But below for example, when we get angry, later on we may regret it and we say, Oh, that wasn’t me. Sorry, that wasn’t me. It’s not sure who it was, but it wasn’t me. So I think we’ve all possibly thought like that, oh, that wasn’t me.

I don’t know what happened to me. Something overcame me. I wasn’t myself today when I did that, when I said that. And but when we were doing it, we thought it was me. Later on, we decided it wasn’t me.

Another me decided that wasn’t me. So we are, at some extent, aware that we chop and change about who we are, but as we do that, consciously or unconsciously, at even more subtle level, a more unconscious level of our mind that is so deep and so ancient and primordial, it’s inconceivable to think about it. We are constantly grasping that there is an essential me. Like today I’m unhappy, yesterday I was miserable, and tomorrow I might be really happy. Yesterday, well, I was a bit kind of nasty to someone and not very kind, and today I’m much nicer and who knows what happens tomorrow.

But so this I change like that, but deep down there’s the real me. There’s this real me that never changes. We believe that. There’s a real me, this essential me that is always the same. Not the one who gets angry who wasn’t me, but there’s this one who is who is really, really me, who is wonderful, of course, and never changes.

There’s this essential me, which is the self. There is this self that is really me. This is I. We’re not really sure exactly what it looks like, but we know it’s there. That’s what we believe, and we grasp onto it desperately, constantly, all the time, twenty four hours a day, life after life.

Even, the Buddha said, when we’re in the womb. Even in the womb, we’re doing it, grasping very subtly, creating this illusion of me, the real me, and grasping onto it. We create this appearance ourselves, our mind creates this appearance, and we and our mind grasps onto it as being me. And because that sense of I dominates the mind, dominates our consciousness, particularly the mental consciousness which is the most important active aspect of what we call the mind. Because the eye consciousness and the other sense consciousnesses are just little slaves of the mental consciousness running around bringing back information.

Look what I saw! Sorry, I lost my point. Where am I? Was anyone listening? Yes, so because this sense of ‘I’ dominates our mind, particularly the mental consciousness, all the time, everything that the mind experiences is experienced totally, uncontrollably, without any escape through this sense of I.

This sense of I dominates our mind, everything that arises in our mind that we experience is experienced through this filter of this sense of I. I am the focus of everything. It’s very embarrassing to admit, but we all think we are the center of the universe. Even when we try to be humble, I am the humble centre of the universe. And this is an indication of the wrong view that we have because there is no one who is the centre of the universe.

All of us think we are the centre of the universe, but there can’t be thousands of centres of the universe. There can only be one, and it’s me. You’re all wrong. Right? So you are seriously in trouble.

So this just that that itself is an indication that there is some something mistaken about our sense of I, that it’s not correct, even though we like to feel that what we that our perceptions about ourself and and the world is correct, and I’m not mistaken. So, there is this sense of I that dominates the mind. Maybe before going on, you may be thinking, well, that’s just inevitable. It’s impossible for it to be any other way. How could how could I not experience things through being me?

But the Buddha said there is. There is a completely different way of experiencing the world, and it’s much better. It’s not just much better, it’s incomparably different. The way we experience the world through me actually is suffering, an unsatisfying, unfulfilling, frustrating. When one experiences the world free of this heavy sense of I, there is bliss, joy, happiness, a sense of interconnection with everything and complete fulfillment.

This is what the Buddha taught and it’s worth investigating whether the Buddha was true or not, was correct. So because there is this heavy filter of me and this grasping of me, everything that we experience or everything in the world is not me. It is something other than me. It is and it it also appears to our consciousness to be so much not me, and we grasp it to be like that as having as being something quite separate, independent of me. There’s me, as I’ve mentioned before, we have this idea, even if we thought about it, maybe we we could agree that we tend to think of me or as me or my mind because sometimes we mix these two together, that I or my mind simply reflect what is there.

It’s got nothing to do with me. It’s just there, and I come along. Here it is. It’s out there, separate from me, and I’m just an objective, uninvolved observer. And sometimes I desire to get involved, of course, sometimes a whole lot, sometimes a little bit, but it’s my choice.

It’s just completely out there. And it’s all not me, separate, inherently not me, all this stuff. And sometimes it appears that when I contact some of this stuff, some of this not-me other, that it’s it makes me feel good, or this this pleasant feeling arises. And when this pleasant feeling arises and all these good thoughts arise as well, and what happens is that I sort of come alive a bit more, you know, I kind of grow, and I feel kind of stronger and more real, more fantastic, more solid. This is me and I feel great and this is wonderful and there’s something out there doing that.

Yeah. So that thing must be good. It must be good because it makes me feel good and strong and solid, real, secure. So that thing must be good. It must be beautiful.

Yeah. Really, really good, really beautiful. Unquestionably, unquestionably, really good. Really, really, truly, truly, truly, really good, beautiful. Such as, you know, we see some something pleasant, beautiful, nice colors, shapes, and some happiness arises in the mind.

So one wakes up, feels a bit nicer. So this object is over there. But if you closer, then the effect is stronger, nice. So if it’s closer So what happens is you notice this thing that’s making you feel so good. You you desire it.

We desire. There’s this desire that arises because of the particular view of me and it There is happiness. I am feeling happiness. Why am I feeling happiness? Because of this.

So this is the happiness. The happiness is something to do with this. Right? So if I have it, I will have happiness. I will be happy.

Right? So we desire it, and we get it and we grasp it and we hold on to it. Yeah? So now I am I am happy. Now I’m really, really happy, so I think.

But the only way to keep being really, really happy is to keep holding on to it. Right? So now I’m attached. I am now attached to this thing, and now I have to hold on to it forever. I am stuck with it.

It has now become part of me, and I can’t let go of it. Because if I let go of it, know, my happiness is my happiness, goes away. So even if it starts to move away, I have to hold on to it more. Right? So I’m stuck with it, thinking this is happiness.

So this is the way the two disturbing thoughts go together of afflicted desire afflicted desire not all desires are afflicted but there is afflicted desire and then with desire comes attachment. You know, there was a point in my life where I didn’t even know this thing existed and yet I’m still I was alive and I could survive and everything. I was okay. Then I saw this thing and I became happy. And then I desired it and then I got attached to it, and now I I simply can’t let go of it, which is really quite tiring holding this thing all the time.

It takes a lot of energy to just to keep holding it, and it gets heavier and heavier. And somehow, even though I’m completely attached to it and totally depend on it, it’s somehow, after a while, it’s not producing the same happiness as when it was over there when I first saw it, but still I can’t let go because no choice, I’m stuck with it. Yeah. So now I’m before, I was separate from this thing, but now, although I think this is the source of my happiness, I’ve become dependent on it. I’ve now become dependent on this thing.

Why I got attached to it, why I desired it and got attached to it, is because it made me happy, it made me feel stronger, more real, more secure. But in reality, what has happened is that I’ve got dependent on it. In other words, I haven’t got stronger, I’ve actually got weaker. Because before, I didn’t depend on it. Now I do.

And, you know oh, anyway. And it

Key terms in this teaching

buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
mandala khyil khor (Tib)
A circular diagram symbolic of the entire universe. The purified environment of a tantric deity; the diagram or painting representing this. LYWA
mudra chag gya (Tib)
Literally, seal or token. A symbolic hand gesture, endowed with power not unlike a mantra. A tantric consort. LYWA
prostrations chag tsel (Tib)
The act of showing respect to the objects of refuge, the Guru and the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; the first of the seven-limb practice and one of the preliminary practices. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top