Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 24 Tape 47 Side 2 Afflictions

44 min · 4,920 words · 24 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 24 Tape 47 Side 2 Afflictions
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains that the self we grasp is not truly existing and that realising emptiness requires an intellectual understanding of dependent arising, single-pointed concentration, and identifying the object to be refuted. It describes how seeing that the self is merely labelled on body and mind reduces attachment, anger and other disturbing thoughts, and it notes that purifying the mind, merit and a teacher’s blessings are also needed.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-24

Duration: 44 min

UUID: 0a7af769-2092-4f22-aa1a-4f15c60434e2

Words: 4,920

We don’t actually literally see ourselves as being a totally independent phenomena, but if the way we perceived ourselves were true, it would mean that we were independent. That is the consequence of it. And so the way to destroy that is to understand dependent arising, that no phenomena whatsoever, there is no phenomena existing, no valid existing phenomena that is independent. An independent phenomena is impossible. It is a logical impossibility, a logical absurdity.

And Buddha is not independent, is not an independently existing phenomenon. Enlightenment is not independently existing. Emptiness itself, the actual nature of things, is not an independent phenomenon. It’s a dependent phenomenon because that’s the only way things can exist. This is what the Buddha perceives and this is what Lama Tsongkhapa presents in this amazing text.

So nothing can exist other than being dependent on various other things, either causes and conditions, parts, and especially the labelling mind. The mind and the way it labels or conceives things. But we have this deep seated grasping that there is something that doesn’t exist that way at all. So when we understand how these two things are totally contrary, we can destroy this ignorance. Maybe just to make this point, I won’t go into the meaning of ignorance and so on, but The aim, as I’ve been trying to say, of the path is to realise the wisdom that destroys ignorance.

So to be able to do this, need to accumulate life in one life if we were lucky enough, but otherwise during many lives, we need to accumulate a number of different things. Firstly, well I don’t know if it’s firstly anyway, we need to firstly we have to acquire an intellectual understanding of correct way things exist by studying the teachings, gaining this intellectual understanding. That is necessary, especially as presented in the Prāsaṇgika school. It may be different in other schools, but Lama Tsongkhapa gives very, very forceful reasons to believe that have to have in order to have these non conceptual experiences, we have to achieve them via a conceptual understanding. And as I tried to explain before one time, if we meditate on anything, even a simple thing, with a wrong understanding, we will just imprint that wrong understanding in our mind.

That meditation process won’t become a method to reduce or eliminate our suffering. It will become a method to increase our suffering because it will strengthen a wrong view in our mind. Can’t think of a very good example, but if we study the teachings and we come to the idea that some things are impermanent and other things are permanent. Some compounded phenomena are permanent. Some things that arise depending on conditions, most of them are impermanent, but some are permanent.

If we have that wrong view and we meditate on that, this will just cause more confusion in our mind. So we need to understand that all things, depending on causes and conditions, without exception are impermanent. So if we understand that and meditate on it, it helps counteract our wrong views. But if we don’t have a precise understanding, we just kind of reinforce some wrong views or create new wrong views that can make confusion in our mind. So if this is the case these ordinary things, surely it will be the case in order to gain highest experience of all.

What guides us there is the correct intellectual understanding. How can we get there if we don’t have any correct signposts? There have to be some correct signposts, which are not the thing. But when there’s a sign saying Kathmandu, the sign is not Kathmandu, of course. It’s nothing like Kathmandu, but you need it to find out where to get to Kathmandu.

Because if we’ve never been there before, and we’ve never been to this experience of the true nature of things before, even for one second. So we need signposts, which is this intellectual understanding. And then, you know, you see, here’s the intellectual understanding, here’s the reality. Oh, they match. I’ve got it.

I’m there. Something like that. So what was I trying to say? So we need this intellectual understanding, but that is not enough. That that won’t destroy ignorance.

What we also have to do is to meditate on that understanding with single pointed concentration. Not just some of wishy washy concentration, it has to be the real thing. The state of meditative absorption where one can focus on this effortlessly without a distracted mind for long periods of time. So we need to work at developing concentration. And what stops concentration are our disturbing thoughts, especially attachment.

So we have to try to modify these. But even those two things are not enough to realise emptiness. What we have to do the key thing, actually, key thing which is the most difficult thing to do to be able to develop wisdom is we have to find the refuting object. The object to be refuted to be negated or the negating object or the refuting object. The object to be negated, the object to be refuted.

And this is referring to the wrong view of self that we have, which we don’t think is a wrong view. We think we act assuming that how I appears to us is totally correct. But even though we all say, you know, I exist, if I try to describe who I am, you know, I can say I’ve got this body like this, I’ve done that and I’ve done this, but that’s not the I I’m grasping at. Even though we believe in it, we talk about I I I, we don’t know who we are. But there is this view, our mind is holding, grasping that there is this person, me, that has a name.

The real me. Sometimes I’m happy, sometimes I’m sad, sometimes I’m good, and sometimes I’m bad, but there’s the real me. There’s the real me deep down that doesn’t change. This essential real me that we grasp that instinctively, life after life. So it is possible when the mind becomes very calm and clear and concentrated to discover that.

And that is the key thing. Once one is able to discover that and hold that appearance in the mind and by appearance it doesn’t mean a visual thing you see. Although at first maybe you see something the wrong view of self is some actual visual thing, but that’s not the most subtle I. So we have to identify that, which actually in some way can appear clearly in the mind. And just as with the example that we’ve given before of the rope and the snake, or the tree stump and the person, If you take the example of thinking a tree stump is a person, there is the appearance of the person in the mind.

That’s definite. But ignorance believes that that appearance is real, substantial, that it’s not just an appearance, but there is something substantially there where there isn’t. There’s just this hallucinated appearance of a person where in reality, one level of reality, there’s only a tree stump. So, in the ordinary example of believing that one has seen a person, if nothing else happens, you continue to believe the rest of your life. You saw in this vast countryside, this isolated countryside, a person.

But then someone can come along to you, and if you believe this person, you trust them that they don’t lie, And they can say, it’s impossible. You could not have seen a person there. There has never been a person where you saw this person. No one has lived in this area for five hundred years or something. And this is the proof, and this is the proof, and this is the proof that it would have been utterly impossible to have seen a person.

If you check, there are no tracks, no one walked there, so a person couldn’t be there. The grass isn’t crushed, and this and that many, many reasons. And when you listen to these reasons, and you know the person isn’t lying, so you listen with faith. And so you listen to the reasons, you think, Oh, that’s true, and that’s true, and that’s You know, I thought I saw this person but that is true and that is true and that is true and true and that is true. So if all these things are true, I couldn’t have seen a person.

It’s just impossible. And when one realizes that, the mind can no longer grasp that that person existed. It disappears. Realizing emptiness, the true nature of things, is a little bit like that. We have this view which we have to discover in deep meditation, find the refuting object and hold it, and we think, well, this is how I believe I am.

It looks real, totally convincing, but this is true, things can’t exist like that because of this reason, because of that reason, because of that reason, that reason, and that reason. And so even though this thing appears like that, I appear like that, there are all these reasons to show that nothing could appear like that. So by contemplating very deeply in a state of single pointed absorption, then the mind can no longer maintain that appearance at all. And it completely goes. So that is when, at that point, one experiences the space like emptiness.

Nothing else appears. What actually is existing doesn’t appear. Is conventionally existing, the person that is conventionally existing doesn’t appear. What does appear to the mind is this mere absence of this false ‘I’. There’s this space like emptiness which is blissful.

The mind in that state is blissful. But that can only be maintained in meditation When one comes out of the meditation having had that experience, that valid experience, not some confused version of it, that when one has that valid experience, then although out of meditation things still appear to truly exist from their own side, one no longer believes it anymore because it appears all kind of very dream like. Movie like is maybe a good example for our times. When we look at movies, unquestioningly everything in there can look very real and solid, But we know it’s a movie. Sometimes we forget it’s a movie.

Fall in love with the actress or actor, get all the pictures and everything. There’s just colored dots on the wall. Yeah. People go around saying, I love actor or actress so and so, and all we’ve ever seen of them is colored dots. Nothing nothing even remotely, not one hair of their body have we seen.

We’ve just seen some colored dots on a piece of paper and we just love this person. It’s amazing. But we do have the ability to know a movie is a movie. It looks real but we know it’s a movie even when it’s one of these giant whatever you call them what do you call them? IMAX.

IMAX things. So when one has had the first experience of emptiness and comes out of that, then everything appears like that, dream like, like an illusion. So one doesn’t grasp at it anymore. So then one goes back into meditation and goes deeper into that. And after some period, then anyway, I’m not sure what happens.

Realization of emptiness gets stronger and stronger, more stable in the mind, and all the delusions are then there is no basis for them to exist, completely eliminated. And also one is able to perceive the person that validly does exist, the person which is merely labelled by the mind, in dependence upon the body and mind. A person does exist, but such a person does not truly exist from their own side, independent of causes and conditions, parts and the labelling mind. But such a person does exist simply, merely as that which is just, just labelled by the mind, moment by moment, on the body and mind, which are changing moment by moment. Such a person does exist.

Such a person does not appear to our mind. Such a person is existing but really so insubstantial, changing moment by moment, because of depending on a changing body and mind, but is existing. And that person that validly does exist is the basis for ignorance to project onto that something that appears to be truly existing from its own side. There is a tree stump. On the basis of that, ignorance creates the illusion of a person.

There is a person that is what is just this insubstantial, momentarily arising phenomena that is just existing because of being labeled by the mind on the basis of the body and mind. That is there, moment by moment. And ignorance comes along and perceives that and puts on that the appearance of something which is not there at all. A person who truly exists, inherently exists, substantially really truly exists. Something separate from the body and mind.

And something that doesn’t even need a label to exist because it’s truly existing. So we need to find the refuting object and in meditation, single point of meditation, analyse how, although that appears, it simply can’t exist the way it appears. Just like some movies can look like they’re documentaries. They’re actually depictions of, like, film made of actual events. But if you use the wisdom, you can check, although it looks like that, because it’s this thing and that thing and that thing which shows that it can’t be the real event.

It’s just a creation. So this very fundamental ignorance, this instinctual ignorance is the root of all suffering, confusion, and all the experiences within saṃsāra. And what reinforce so that is said to be yeah not how do you put it? While we have that, that ignorance creates saṃsāra and while we have that ignorance, we can only have momentary pleasure in saṃsāra. While we have the ignorance of the true nature of self, we will have suffering again and again and again.

Now I’m here. One of my usual examples. To try to find the refuting object, we have to find the refuting object. It is not easy. The whole path to enlightenment is the most difficult thing.

No, one of the most difficult. Actually, I think generally it’s believed, we get the idea that realizing emptiness is the most difficult thing on the path, but actually generating Bodhicitta is more difficult than realising emptiness. That’s why it’s easier to follow the path to liberation than the path to enlightenment, because to generate Bodhicitta is much more difficult than to realise emptiness. But within realising emptiness, to gain the intellectual understanding of the teaching is much easier than to find the refuting object. This is one of the tricky things, the most subtle things to do.

So but we can start now because to to get to this most complicated thing, one has to start. And one makes many mistakes, but that’s natural. But it’s only by learning from the mistakes that we eventually get to the right view. So, for example, one can check out I don’t know how many people had a shower today or will have a shower today. But if you have one tomorrow, just check out who is having the shower.

You say, Oh, I’m going off. I am going to have a shower. See, I’m off to have a shower. So there’s this thing, this water pouring down, this is what we call a shower. So what goes under the shower?

It’s our body. What actually gets washed is our body. Our mind doesn’t get washed. It’s our body. But we always say when we put our body under the water that I’m going to have a shower.

So do we have a shower or not? When the body has a shower. So is there a person so if you take like you’re having a shower, right? So if you take if you move your body aside out of the shower or in the shower stall if it’s big enough, can move your body over and the water’s there, can you still have a shower? Can I have a shower without the body having a shower?

Actually impossible to have a shower without the body having a shower because the person we are totally depends on this body. The person we are in this life totally depends on this body. So if I want to have a shower, I’ve got to wash my body. No choice. But check, check this.

I’m sorry this sounds like I’m really wise because I haven’t had any of this experience but anyway, I hope please, maybe I’m sounding I’m sounding really arrogant here. Know it’s terrible. I’m sounding like I I know what I’m talking about. Or experience what I’m talking about, which I haven’t adore, not even at a fraction. So anyway But when we put our body under the water, under the shower, doesn’t it feel like there is a real me having a shower?

Check. That is not just the body, but there is a me having a shower. So then while you’re having the shower and thinking I am having the shower, try and find out this I. What is this I that is having a shower, which is something that is separate from the body? Well, that’s why you need single pointed concentration because you can get there very quickly.

Yeah. Because if we’re honest, we all think there is a me having a shower that is not the body. You know, oh, I feel so good after that. I feel great. So what is this I, this one?

How does it exist? Oh, I’m really hungry. I must have something to eat. But every time I have to eat, we put the food in our body. And if I am the body and we say, well of course that’s what I am, I am my body.

But if I am my body, why do we talk about a body and an I? Body is hungry. Body is going to eat. You can’t even say my body, just say body. Body is humry.

Body is going to eat. Body is tired. Body is going to sleep. Experiment. It doesn’t feel right.

Just body is humry. It never feels like this body is humry, it always feels like I’m humry. Body is tired. Body is humry. It always feels like there’s an I there.

And there is an I there, but it somehow the I that is apparent in our mind, it somehow feels different than the body and mind, something something mysteriously separate. So we should find that one because that one is the problem. Believing in that one is the problem, the Buddha said. That is the problem, believing in that one. Of course, just thinking there’s an I that’s having a shower, that’s not so evil.

But that whole process of believing of a truly existing ‘I’, this is the problem. And it gives rise to all the disturbing thoughts. Because if we can understand that what we are, there is an ‘I’ which is just labelled, it’s just there, it’s just there, Like an illusion, it’s not an illusion, but it’s like an illusion. It’s just there, moment by moment, changing moment by moment, because all it is, is what is labelled by the mind on the basis of the body and mind. If we were able to not just intellectually know that but experience ‘I’ as that, as just that, we would not generate attachment to things or aversion to things.

We would eat food because the body has to be sustained, but we wouldn’t overeat because we know the body, I would know the body just needs a certain amount of food. There’s no need to put more in because of attachment, because of the taste, thinking I am experiencing the pleasure. Of course, there was also the creation of a truly existing pleasure. And if someone insulted us, it wouldn’t bother us at all because how can words hurt our mind? Words can’t hurt our body.

Words can’t actually hurt our mind. So if someone says we’re a complete idiot, the ugliest, revolting, most disgusting thing in the entire universe, what does it matter? What would it matter? Because I am not that. And those words can’t hurt my body, they can’t do anything to my mind at all.

But because we have wrong view of who I am, those words, those noises cause incredible pain in the mind. And they’re just noises. They’re just sounds like that. But we turn that because of the wrong view of self into pain. I mean really, sometimes when we’re insulted, it’s like being stabbed in the heart.

And it seems totally real and it seems like it was created by that disgusting, evil person who is really like that. Just like I am really like that and I’m really good, and they are really like that bad. So, if we were actually experiencing, not just thinking about how we actually do exist, if we were actually, moment by moment, experiencing who we really are, there’s no way to experience suffering and create the causes of suffering. No disturbing thoughts could possibly arise. Because also, when one is realising that, still, until one has the highest realisation of emptiness, even once one like the first realisation of emptiness doesn’t destroy the delusions.

On the path of insight, when one directly realises emptiness for the first time, it doesn’t destroy the delusions. They’re still there but they start weakening, the gross of the gross start shaking. So, they’re still there. But once one has that realisation, then even if there is the tendency when ugly words come, even when there’s the tendency to get angry, we don’t do it because we know that that disturbing thought harms the mind. And if the mind is disturbed, because I am what is merely and only what is labelled, created by the mind, in dependence on the body and mind.

The mind is agitated by anger, I am in suffering. The suffering doesn’t come from the person and the words they create, it is generated by one’s own disturbing thoughts of anger. So when one is actually experiencing in contact with who one really is, one protects the mind. By protecting the mind, I am happy. If we don’t protect our mind, if we don’t guard our mind, there’s no way I can be happy.

Similarly, even because of the still there’s these illusory like appearances, there may be some tendency to attachment, afflicted desire and attachment to arise, but then we understand that desire attachment is a disturbing mind. So we don’t follow it because if the mind is disturbed, I am unhappy. I can’t be at peace if the mind is disturbed. So when we’re actually, moment by moment, experiencing how we exist as arising depending on the nature of our body and mind and so on. None of the disturbing thoughts can arise.

It’s impossible. Even if they were there, they couldn’t arise. I don’t know if that makes sense, but I can’t present it any better, hopefully it makes a little bit of sense to think about. And of course, in terms of going back to the things that we need to realise our true nature and the true nature phenomena, it’s not just the intellectual understanding, not just concentration, not just recognising the refuting object, but we have to purify the mind. Because the impure mind, controlled by heavy, disturbing thoughts, that mind is just far too gross to be able to understand and experience these things, to remain in concentration and really deeply to be able to recognise the refuting object, which is something very, very subtle.

So, we need to purify the mind and the last one oh no, there’s two more accumulate merit. And one more, have the blessings of the Guru, the inspiration, the blessings, the guidance of a qualified teacher. When we have all those together, liberation is in the palm of our hand. So, because of ignorance, this wrong view of self and others, then afflicted desire and attachment arise. So, I’ve spoken about afflicted desire quite a bit.

Object of afflicted desire itself is a contaminated phenomena, a true suffering, something created that has arisen depending on delusion and karma, such as anything in this world, virtually. The nature of afflicted desire is to exaggerate the conventional pleasant appearance of something. We exaggerate it because it makes me happy. Because this ah, anyway Because the ‘I’ that we are grasping is not really existing, it has to be we have to build up the illusion of it all the time. So, when we feel happy, the illusion of ‘I’ is very strong.

So, that’s what we want. So, anything that makes us happy must be good. Heroin makes me happy, it must be good. The stronger the wrong view of self, then our judgment of what is good and happiness and what and so on gets totally distorted. So because it makes me happy, it must be good.

And because it then the mind really exaggerates that because it makes me feel real, solid, secure, more permanent, more protected from all this threatening other. So, we exaggerate the importance, and the mind believes that the mind of afflicted desire perceives that phenomena as permanent, not changing moment by moment. It’s going to last. So, that makes it even more desirable, real happiness. Yeah.

So, we grasp it and then we get it and we become dependent on it. We can’t let it go because if we let it go, our real happiness will decline. So, we get obsessed with it, attached, stuck, stuck. We can’t separate from it. And because of that basic attachment to happiness, we generate many afflicted desires for for specific things.

And the nature of that desire is suffering. It disturbs the mind. The mind can for us as ordinary people, there are times when our mind can be quiet, at peace. Then along comes this is another topic, but why does our desire our desire isn’t in our mind all the time. The potential for it is there because of ignorance and the seeds of afflicted desire, the imprints are there because we’ve followed it in previous even in a tiny child, when a child, baby pops out of the womb, it has the imprints of afflicted desire there.

They’re there already. They were in the foetus, they were brought from the previous life. So what causes those imprints to ripen? Why do our sometimes we feel desire and sometimes not? Why does this afflicted desire arise?

The most obvious cause for these imprints to arise and to arise strongly is when we meet the object. Each of us has our own little objects that we meet that cause afflicted desire to arise. So, the object is actually present to our senses, that’s when the imprint that is the main condition for the imprint to manifest. If it’s not there, the imprint may not manifest, become manifest. The potential may not change into the actuality.

But, of course, if the object is not there and we remember it, we keep remembering it, the desire comes. Back to the point that we have periods of time when there isn’t the afflicted desire, our mind is or any of the other delusions acting, the mind is calm and clear. Then, the object is there. Suddenly, the object is there again. The afflicted desire rises.

Check what it does to the mind. It disturbs the mind. This is what the Buddha said, we should check. If that’s the case, if that cause cannot produce a pleasant effect, It may create the appearance of such a result but what we’re trying to learn is that what appears to our mind is not necessarily true. This is what ignorance does whatever appears to our mind, we grasp that it’s real.

Afflicted desire and attachment causes suffering in the moment and it creates is the basis for these negative imprints in the mind, these disturbed imprints in the mind. So, in relationships between people, between groups, in families, between communities, countries, ethnic groups and so on, what causes all of that, in many cases, is the desire attachment, clinging to our own views and so on. In a relationship when between two people, you know, we say, you know, we’re together because we love each other. But the love, if it is love, if it is has the characteristics of actual love, which is wishing happiness, genuine happiness for another, for oneself and others, the thought wishing happiness, that can never be the basis of suffering and conflict and argument and fighting and jealousy and so on. In every relationship, the suffering, the fighting, the jealousy is because of attachment, not because of love.

Because most relationships are a mixture of both. There is some love and a lot of attachment. Maybe some relationships have a lot of love and a bit of attachment. Some have fiftyfifty. Some may have all attachment and no love.

Those are really problematic relationships and don’t last long. Check up.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
compounded phenomena samskrta (Skt); du jä kyi chö (Tib)
Phenomena that arise due to causes and conditions. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top