44 min · 4,901 words · 24 November 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains that pleasure is a form of suffering because it does not last and appears happy only in contrast with worse experiences. It uses everyday examples such as sitting, standing and eating to show that the discomfort was present from the start and that continuing a pleasant cause does not sustain the pleasure. It then covers the suffering of change and compounded pervasive suffering, followed by a question and answer exchange.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-11-24
Duration: 45 min
UUID: 1cafc7d5-14d8-4fb9-8f65-d1ce1a641c5b
Words: 4,901
It may look like we’ve experienced liberation or enlightenment, especially when one’s in the form and formless realms, but it’s just karma. It’s a karmic state. This is what the Buddha taught. I mean, maybe he was wrong, but this is what the Buddha taught. This is something to check out, think about.
Anyway, this is one way to understand how all all our pleasures and happinesses are actually a type of suffering, unsatisfying, because they don’t last. Then another way to understand it, that what we call pleasure happiness is actually in the nature of suffering. It’s not really happiness that is a type of suffering is because it’s something relative. Relative to a previous moment of obvious pain and a future moment of obvious pain, there is this gap between that we call pleasure, happiness. Between being in a lower realm in one life and then a lower realm in our next life, this looks like happiness.
Relatively compared to being in in the a dog in the previous life and and a cow in our next life, this looks like happiness. Relatively, it is. Relatively, it is. But not in reality, just relative to worse experiences. It appears to be happy happiness.
Relative to experiencing hunger now and hunger at a later moment, when we’re eating, it appears to be happiness. It appears to be pleasure. We can check this one up today. I could talk a little longer during the when it gets to eleven o’clock. Talk a little bit longer and a little bit longer.
But then I’ll have to rush off too. So But anyway, so we experience hunger, and then later on we experience hunger, but between the moments when we’re not experiencing hunger, there’s the relative pleasure of eating. The relative pleasure of stopping that hunger. This uncomfortable desire for something, for the pleasure of food, is there, then we meet the object. So there looks there’s the appearance of pleasure, and it lasts a little while, but it can only last.
It goes away, and then the hunger comes back again. So we have to start again. But in the there’s a gap. So relatively, that looks like pleasure. And the more our mind focuses on that, making it permanent, creating the illusion it’s permanent, the more it looks like happiness.
The more happy it appears to be, the more joyful, totally exciting and amazing, and our mind goes into it, gets locked into it. Thanks. Okay. So these these are two ways to try to understand recognize it. Not to why are we doing this?
Not to depress ourselves, but to awaken to the situation we’re in so we can find real happiness because it exists. It exists within us all the time. It’s always there. Yeah. It’s always there, and yet we’re always chasing out into the Samsarik supermarket for it.
And with that, we have to buy it again and again because it doesn’t last. And we have to get the stuff to buy it again and again. But there’s something in here undying, eternal, perfect. If you’ve got an ice cream cone with one ice cream blob on top, then someone come and you think that that’s the only kind of ice cream you can get, and then someone comes along with an ice cream with two blobs on, you want that one. I didn’t realize you could have an ice cream cone with two big blobs on it.
I want it. Chuck that one away, go for the one with with the two blobs, and then you see one with three blobs and sprinkles and all sorts of things on top. One wants it, roughly speaking, maybe. So when we think that what we’ve got is all what you can get and this is happiness, we will be obsessed with it. Obsessed with it.
But when we start to realize that this isn’t even real ice cream, it’s plastic stuff, you know, it’s just fake fake. It’s not cream at all. It’s just no ice cream these days. Have you ever sorry. Sorry.
I shouldn’t talk. Have you ever had real ice cream made of cream? Unbelievable. Almost impossible to buy now. Anyway, you can’t.
So when you taste that when you taste that, why you never want the old stuff, especially if you can get the real stuff. And we can get the real stuff, it’s in here. It’s there all the time, waiting. If we just look, takes a little time to get, but it’s there. Okay.
Thank you. Sorry. Short break. So when we hear this kind of teaching maybe for the first time, it again can make us perhaps sad or depressed, and we also may think, well, if I keep listening to this kind of thing, it’s going to destroy all my happiness. I was happy before I came here.
Now this guy is telling me that I’ve been miserable all the time, and if I keep listening to him, I’m really, you know, there’s no chance. But the point is, if this is true, maybe it’s not true, but if it is true, then it hasn’t changed the nature of the experiences we’ve had. They’ve always been like that, whether we knew it or not, and they’ll continue to be so whether we whether we accept it or not. But we have the chance to use our wisdom to realize that that is the nature of the there’s it isn’t denying that we that the pleasure arises. Sure.
There is pleasure, but it’s not what we really want. Our mind is not just seeking temporary pleasure. So that experience won’t go away. What we’re just trying to see, what the Buddhadharma is about is the Buddha Dharma. The Dharma means truth.
The truth of things. And the truth is what liberates us, what we need to experience. And the truth is or this is what the Buddha said the truth is, maybe we can discover it or not or reject it, that our our experiences aren’t what they appear to be. They appear to be to be pleasure and happiness in in the emotional moment, but the reality is that it’s they’re not like that. They just have the illusion of being fulfilling, especially when when we grasp at their at their permanence, which is not there.
Which is not there. We grasp that these these experiences are permanent, unchanging moment by moment, and therefore going to last forever. But if we check, honestly, we can see that this is not the case, and therefore they’re not going to fulfill us. So this doesn’t mean that we stop having these experiences, we should totally stop having these experiences because we will continue to have these pleasures anyway because we’ve created the karma for them in the past. But the point is to realize that they are not complete, they’re not totally satisfying, they’re not what we really want, and therefore not to invest so much meaning into them our grasping desire attachment.
To put so much time into them, making them something ultimate, which they’re not, and because we can’t do that. Things have a conventional nature that cannot be denied. So we need to recognize that conventional nature, that the happiness we’re experiencing isn’t lasting, it’s not really fulfilling. And so we can still continue to experience it, but not get attached to it, obsessed with it, and use our life trying to create more of it. Put all the energy of our life into creating more of that.
More unfulfilling experiences, temporary unfulfilling experiences, putting all our life into having fluffy cushions in the cell. We could be digging this tunnel. I mean, maybe in the analogy, digging the tunnel sounds really horrible, hard, dark work, but if we think about what Dharma practice is, it’s something wonderful. Sometimes. Not always, difficulty, ordinary life is difficult.
To get the fluffy cushions is difficult, the nice bed, the nice car is difficult. It usually doesn’t come easy for most of us. It’s hard work to get these things. So it also, it’s true, it’s hard work to practice Dharma, but the result is much more satisfying in the moment, for others, and continuously. This is something to think about.
This is the context in which we should think about this. Meditating like this is not going to change our happiness into suffering. We’re just simply going to recognize what it always has been. If we think about our death, it’s not going to make us die sooner, it’s just going to enable us to realise what is actually already existing, our impermanent nature. If we meditate on the impermanence of of a table, it doesn’t make it impermanent, we just recognize what is actually always existing.
So using Buddha wisdom to look at our experiences is not going to change them into something they’re not, It’s just going to help us, perhaps. It’s our choice, but it can help us to realize what they actually are. Firstly, to realize the conventional nature of them. So, we’re trying to understand something of the conventional truth first, in order to because if we’re blinded to that, we can’t experience the ultimate truth. But when our minds are open, our wisdom eye is open to the conventional truth of things.
That is the basis to develop the wisdom eye that sees the ultimate nature of all phenomena. So we can understand our experiences, our pleasant experiences, of being suffering because it doesn’t last and it’s something only relative to other unpleasant experiences. Then the main deeper way of understanding how our suffering is actually our happiness is actually the suffering of change, is by trying to understand using our mind, our wisdom to try to understand that these experiences that we call happiness, pleasure, and so on, are in their very nature suffering, unfulfilling. In their very nature, in the very moment they arise, and as they continue to exist, moment by moment, their very nature is suffering or unfulfilling. So there are simple analogies that have been given.
Can’t think of I suppose if I really try it, I can think of some new examples. There’s infinite examples, but just some use the same old examples, but you can use other examples yourself. But but anyway, we can take the example right now of sitting here. So as we sit here, we may experience some bodily pain in various in our knees, in our back, and so on. So by sitting here, it’s uncomfortable, a little bit painful, so then we stand up.
And when we stand up, there’s a kind of relief. The pain of sitting down stops, and then we start experiencing what we can call the pleasure or happiness of standing up. It’s not one of the major joys of life, but it’s fortunately, but one can understand it as a kind of happiness or pleasure of just standing up. But, if you experiment, and you could do this sometime, of just standing still for some time, first after like, especially you can experiment of sitting for a long time until it gets excruciatingly painful, and then you stand up, and then there’s this amazing relief and the pleasure of standing up. It’s so great, it’s so nice, and then you stand there, and you stand there, and you stand there, or we stand there, I stand there, and what happens?
After some time, that pleasure, the joy of standing gets less and less, and not only that, it starts to get painful, And then it gets worse. And it gets so bad that you have to sit down. So when I say you, we we we it happens to all of us. We have to sit down. And then we sit down, and sitting down is suddenly so nice.
Oh, you know, so nice. This is really nice. And we sit, and we sit, and after some time we’re not thinking, oh, this is really nice. We think, Oh, ah, ah, and then we have to stand up again. Oh, this is nice.
And after some time, you know, it’s not nice anymore, and we have to sit down. So this at at at that level is we can understand how our pleasure is relative relative to relative to standing up, sitting down is pleasure, and so on. But, if we I don’t know I can explain it, I get confused by trying to explain this. What happens is that, as we’re standing we’ll take the thing of we’re standing and it’s painful, and then as soon as we sit down, the pain of standing stops, and there’s the appearance of the pleasure of sitting. And what the mind notices is this very gross difference.
There’s this very gross difference between that pain of standing and then, compared to that, there is the appearance of the pleasure of sitting. There’s the appearance of the because that gross pain has stopped, and now something else is happening, so compared to that, that appears to be pleasure, because the mind is noticing is concerned with noticing that that pain has stopped. And so now I’m sitting, so there appears to be the pleasure of sitting. But in reality, what is happening, the Buddha says, in the teachings it says, that in that very first moment of sitting there is discomfort. It’s in the very first moment that we don’t notice it because our mind is noticing the cessation of the pain of standing.
That is the dominant thing in our mind. But then as we sit, that pain of sitting becomes more and more noticeable because we no longer remember the cessation of the pain of standing. Our mind is not we can remember it, but becoming a memory. It’s not clear in the mind anymore. That’s fading away.
And then as that fades away, and if we pay attention, we may be distracted by watching television or something else, so we don’t notice, but if we just simply observe the experience of sitting, we start to be aware of the discomfort increasing moment by moment. And then, with time, it increases And we have to move, we have to keep moving, and then that’s not enough, so we stand up. So, the point is that the discomfort, the displeasure of sitting was there from the very beginning. It didn’t start after a certain period of time. It was there from the very beginning, and then gradually our mind was able to notice it, to be aware of it.
It was there from the very beginning. If something is in the nature of pleasure, it can’t change. If that’s its nature, if something has as its nature pleasure, being pleasurable, it can’t change into something else. If fire has the nature of being hot, then it can’t If that is its nature, its genuine conventional nature, it can’t change. Fire can’t change into having the nature of being cold, especially if you keep adding more wood to the fire.
If you add more wood to the fire, it won’t get colder. It maintains its nature as being hot. If something and we go back to cause and effect. If the cause has a certain nature, then it has to produce an effect of a similar nature. So, If sitting is the cause of genuine pleasure, if we continue the cause, then the pleasure should continue.
If that is the cause of the pleasure arising in the mind, if sitting is the cause of a particular real pleasure in the mind to be experienced, if we continue the cause or add to the cause, increase the cause, totally lying down or something, sitting, sitting, totally sitting, I don’t know, you can’t increase the cause of sitting, but you can continue the cause, then even if even in the sense of continuing the cause at the same intensity, the pleasure should remain. It should remain. But if we check, first, that we are sitting, there is the cause, and there appears to be some pleasure, but as that cause keeps going on, the continuity of that cause continues, the pleasure decreases. The appearance of the pleasure decreases, because it was never there in the first place. If something is producing a particular result, if you add to the cause, the result will maintain, will be of the same nature, and if you add to the cause, the result should not only be of the same nature, but should increase.
If you add wood to a fire, the fire gets hotter and hotter. But the longer we sit, the pleasure gets less. And not only does it get less, it eventually is experienced as pain. Fire can never turn into something cold because it has a particular nature. You can’t change the nature of things.
So this shows that the appearance of pleasure that we experienced was just an appearance, it wasn’t valid. There was this pain of sitting, the discomfort of sitting there all the time, and as the cause was maintained, the actual nature of the effect was perceived by the mind more clearly, because it was always there. It didn’t start halfway through sitting, it was always there. Happiness cannot turn into pain, into unhappiness. If it’s real happiness, if it’s validly existing happiness, it can’t turn into suffering or pain.
So this experience of sitting shows that it was painful from the very beginning, in its very nature. It was unsatisfying. We eat something, it’s delicious, it tastes nice, there’s enjoyment. If you continue eating, if it was real enjoyment, real pleasure, if you continued eating, the pleasure should increase. To some extent it does for a short time, and as you continue eating, you can’t eat anymore.
If you listen to your favorite piece of music continuously, it will drive you nuts. Every now and again, sure, one can if you play it at a certain frequency, you know, day, maybe you can still enjoy it. But if you play it continuously, if it was real happiness and you kept continuing it, the happiness of listening to it should increase and increase. You have a bucket and you put one drop of water, you add another, you get more and more water. But, when we continue the cause of what we think is pleasure, it turns, we say it turns into less pleasure and then pain, but it doesn’t actually.
It was always that, we just didn’t notice. And, unfortunately, the opposite is not the same. If we think about what we experience, what we with our ordinary mind call suffering, any kind of suffering from a headache to any kind of mental torment, check if one continues the cause, what happens? Does the suffering go away if you continue the cause? No, it doesn’t.
If you increase the cause, does the suffering get less? No, it gets worse. This is because the suffering we experience is suffering, and the happiness that we experience isn’t happiness. So the sooner we wake up from this illusion, the sooner we can stop producing the causes that produce suffering, which is suffering, and we stop wasting great time creating the causes for happiness, which isn’t happiness, and we start creating the causes for happiness, which is happiness, which is the liberated mind, the mind free of delusion and karma. So this is the suffering of change.
Everything is like that. Experiment. Increase the causes of one’s happiness and pleasure. See what happens. Well, I wouldn’t advocate it in many things, but a few small experiments would be okay.
According to the Buddha’s teachings, in this ordinary world, with the very ordinary mind, highest ecstasy one experiences is sexual orgasm. If you continue the cause for that, see what happens. But I wouldn’t experiment with that one. Plenty of people have and you see the results. Then there is the third level of suffering.
There’s one more, I’m sorry. There is the suffering of change, sorry, the suffering of suffering, the suffering of change, and then there is what is called the most subtle type of suffering of all, or dissatisfaction, which is called compounded, pervasive suffering. So, this is experienced continuously by all sentient beings in all the realms of Samsāra. So, maybe just to go back a little bit, if you look at that chart on page thirty seven, the realms of saṃsāra, if one’s interested, then the suffering of suffering is only experienced in the in the in the desire realm. That is the hells, the hungry spirits, the animals, the human realm, the demigod realm, and the god realms of the the six kinds of godlike states in the desire realm.
So, in all of those, the suffering of suffering can be experienced. So, for example, in the hell realm, that is experienced continuously, obvious pain. In the highest God realms of the desire realm, it’s only experienced occasionally, but it still is experienced. The suffering of change is experienced up until from all within the desire realm, up until up until and including the third absorption level of the form realm. Above that, the suffering of change is not experienced.
But the suffering, the compounded pervasive suffering, that is experienced in all the realms of saṃsāra. Because this is said to be what this is referring to is the mere fact of having these five aggregates, the body, the form aggregate, and the four aggregates of the mind, feeling, discrimination, compositional factors, and consciousness, the six primary consciousnesses, these are produced controlled by delusion and karma. So while we have the five aggregates produced and controlled by delusion and karma, there is always this very subtle kind of dissatisfaction, which I think is we can understand, at least in the sense that while there is delusion and karma, there is always the potential for suffering. There’s always the potential for the suffering of change, and always the potential for the suffering of suffering. So that itself is unsatisfying, even when we have when we’re in a high realm, like in a in a fortunate rebirth such as we have now, and even when in this fortunate rebirth we may be having much happiness, ordinary happiness, But even while that happiness is being experienced, there is the potential to experience the worst suffering in our mind.
That karma can ripen at some time because we have ignorance. So, that itself is not a satisfying situation. If we think about it. It is a very, very subtle kind of unsatisfying situation, but it is unsatisfying to know that or even even if we don’t know even if we don’t know that there is the fact that we have the potential for suffering to occur. We may be, in outer appearances, incredibly healthy and strong and shiny and everything, our body, that we may have a disease in us that we don’t even know is going to kill us.
So even if we don’t know, to be that that that is the case, to be in this situation is unsatisfying. It’s not complete and perfect. A subtle kind of suffering, but it’s existing. And because that is existing, it gives rise to the more obvious suffering of change and the very gross suffering of suffering. So this is the samsaric jail that we’re in, whether we know it or not, whether we accept it or not.
And the sooner so the Buddha came to teach us, to show us that this is how we are trapped. We may not know it, we may not believe it, we may not accept it, but if this is true, it it doesn’t whether we believe it or are aware of it, it doesn’t change the reality that we are trapped, but we don’t have to be trapped in this suffering situation. We’re trapped in it because we ourselves create the jail, we create the bars, we create the guards, we create all of it, all of the prison ourselves. And but because of that, we can uncreate it. It’s created by our mind, and our mind can uncreate it, can destroy it, liberate itself, and then we can also liberate everyone else who is creating this jail moment by moment.
Sometimes we create a comfortable little cell, sometimes we create a concentration camp for ourselves. But we all have the ability to understand what we’re doing to ourselves and stop it. We have the method. We have the external method, but we have method, maybe not the method, but we have the capacity, the ability, our own mind. We have wisdom.
We have this amazing wisdom that we can develop and this basic goodness. So, it is worthwhile to apply our mind to think about these things, to motivate ourselves, to wake up to the to the the our actual situation, and to motivate ourselves to get out of it. And the more we the more we’re motivated to get out of it, and that then we let ourselves be aware that others are in the same situation. We can work not just for our own liberation, but for the liberation of all sentient beings. In one teaching I I like this example very much in the in the when in a teaching called the mind training like the rays of the sun, which was a commentary on lojong by Nam-kha Pel, it doesn’t matter.
This is text that’s available you can read in English called the mind training like the rays of the sun. And in there it says that, you know, on a hot it may be an incredibly hot day, we’re we’re we’re really suffering from heat, being tormented by this heat, and as we’re sitting there in this terrible heat, suddenly this shadow comes over us. And it’s so pleasant that we were experiencing this wonderful some shadow. We don’t know what it is, but something has come behind us and laid its shadow on us, and it’s so pleasant. But it’s the shadow of a cobra.
Of a cobra. Cobra. A cobra. A poisonous snake. You know, it comes up, it rears its hood.
So all pleasure in Samsāra is like that. It’s just a cobra rearing its head. We’re just living in the shadow of the cobra. Sorry. I like it.
I like it. No, no, no. But I think that’s slightly different, this, of course, did happen to the Buddha. The king of the Nagas came, but he protected the Buddha. And because of the Buddha he he couldn’t harm the Buddha anyway because of the Buddha’s great love.
But Yes. Sigmund Freud himself said, the essence of repression lies simply in the function of rejecting or keeping something out of consciousness. It is the refusal of a human being to recognize the realities of their human nature. Any questions? Yes.
I think the perspective is it increases. So if the pain increases Well, can vary, either it stays the same or it can increase. Maybe it’s also a little bit of karma there, I’m not sure. Because the cause is going on, the suffering is there and our mind becomes more and more aware of it. But if the pain is actually increasing, why can’t Well, I mean, it is changing.
It is changing moment by moment, sure. That’s true, but because we maintain the cause, it keeps coming back. The suffering is declining, it is impermanent, so it decays. It can’t stay there forever, but because we continue sitting, we keep creating the cause moment by moment, so even though the suffering is decaying moment by moment, because we maintain the cause moment by moment, the suffering goes on. I guess I don’t understand then how that makes the actual experience of sitting unsatisfactory or suffering.
Because the nature of what appears to be happiness doesn’t change. Yeah. If it is that, if it actually is something, then it its its nature can’t change. Its nature of being suffering. Suffering can increase or decrease, but if it’s if it’s suffering, it can’t turn into happiness.
If it’s happiness, it can’t turn into suffering. But the happiness can decrease because it’s the ordinary happiness uh-oh, anyway, guess that’s more yeah, from a from a conventional level even the happiness we call happiness, that still decreases because it’s impermanent. And the suffering also decreases because it’s impermanent. But it still is suffering. It can become less pleasurable but it can’t become suffering.
That’s the point. The pleasure can decline, perhaps, but it can’t turn into suffering, which it does. This is what we should try and check. I mean I mean, I’m saying it does, sorry. We should check.
This is what the Buddha says. I’m just saying it because the Buddha so we should check. Do do our as we as we keep continue doing something, does it not does the the pleasure not only decrease, but at some point stop and become something worse? If if this is true, it is indicating that it never was pleasure in the beginning. Why?
Because something can’t change its nature. Why not? This is a good question.
Key terms in this teaching
- conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
- As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
- The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
- nagas lu (Tib)
- A snake-like being of the animal realm that lives in or near bodies of water; commonly associated with fertility of the land, but can also function as a protector of religion. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
- What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
- suffering of suffering duhkha-duhkhata (Skt); dug ngäl gyi dug ngäl (Tib)
- Aka the suffering of pain; the commonly recognized suffering experiences of pain, discomfort and unhappiness. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.