Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 23 Tape 43 Side 2 Suffering

43 min · 5,499 words · 23 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 23 Tape 43 Side 2 Suffering
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk teaches on the suffering of samsara, covering aging, sickness, death, meeting what we don’t want, separation from what we like, not getting what we want, and the contaminated aggregates. It argues that attachment and belief in permanence intensify suffering, and urges renunciation of samsara and the cutting of its causes.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-23

Duration: 44 min

UUID: 4d079a8c-4f3a-47c5-a470-da07a2866161

Words: 5,499

Not in the very early part, but in the latter part. So then there is the suffering of old age. So this is something we can really contemplate, it’s around us all the time. So with old age, there is the decaying of whatever physical beauty, attractiveness that we have with old age, it decays. If don’t start out with much, then it’s a big problem.

Even if we start out incredibly beautiful, sorry, like me, if you start out without any, as you get older, well But even if one starts out being extremely beautiful and very attractive looking, then with old age this fades away. So, again, in contemplating the sufferings of old age, of this suffering comes because of our attachment. We may be very beautiful and so on, but we get attached to that. And when that beauty fades away, that quality of being handsome or beautiful or whatever fades away, then the more attachment we’ve had to that and remember, a quality of attachment is believing it’s permanent. So, we think we’re going to be permanently young and beautiful.

The mind believes that, even though there’s old people all around, but this is also, I think, a very good example of the belief of inherent existence, of true existence. When we’re young, we think that we’re inherently young. And then there’s old people, and they’re inherently old, they’ve always been old. There’s this category of young people, and then there’s this other strange species of old people. And I’m never going to be one of those.

Especially I don’t want to insult young people because old people are always telling young people things, but it is a characteristic when we’re young, the younger we are, the harder it is to believe in getting old. But as you start to get old, it’s much easier to believe in it. It’s funny how that works. It’s somehow we think, oh, one is inherently, existingly young and beautiful, inherently existing from its own side, and there’s this inherently existing old people. We don’t see any connection when we look at an older person that I could end up looking like that, being like that.

It’s very difficult for the ignorant mind I’m not trying to say this in an insulting way, it’s just some reflection of our ignorance of grasping a true existence, any kind of true existence, that it’s so hard to believe that one is going to grow old and that one has this connection with old people. And you think, Oh, because they’ve always been old, it doesn’t bother them. Yeah? There’s no problem because they’ve always every time they’ve looked in the mirror, they’ve always been old so it’s not a problem, you know? And, you know, suffering and so on, they’ve always been like that so they’re completely used to it.

So we never think that actually all of that is suffering. And it’s very amazing to discover, as one gets older, that there is this grasping in the mind that one is still young. You look in the mirror which tells you one thing, that you want to believe something else. And so the more we grasp at holding on to our youth and beauty, the more suffering as this process goes on. Old age itself is not necessarily suffering, it’s the mind that we have, the ordinary samsaric mind that produces the suffering as ageing takes place.

For great lamas, it’s not suffering to grow old. But even then, even with a highly realised mind, the old body gives problems. It does give problems. Even if one is a great meditator, at some level, when the body is old and stiff and so on, it’s a problem. But the real problem of aging is the mind, the ordinary mind controlled by attachment.

So not only does our attractiveness fade away that causes suffering, but also the strength of our body. The older we get, the physically weaker we become. One can be very old but still very healthy and strong, but at some point that strength of the body can’t last. Maybe not a very good example, but if you look at this old dog, Yama, who wanders around here I was here teaching this course in nineteen ninety eight. Then he was the top dog here, was the chief dog of the entire hill and he could defeat any dog that came up here.

He was the top one. He was the macho dog of the entire area, of Kopan area. So, any dog who tried to take over the territory was in big trouble, but now you look at him and very quickly, and apparently the friend was saying it like it was just in the last year that suddenly he’s become so old and weak and infirm and can hardly walk and so on. And you can just look at how old he looks and the suffering he’s experiencing. So this loss of strength, you know, it may happen slowly, step by step, or at some point, as we get older, it happens.

And so then we have this body that is so difficult to use. Talking about old age at one point, in one way, we can laugh at it because we laugh because we don’t think we’re going to experience it, but when we experience it, it’s not funny. It may look funny in one way because we don’t have so much compassion, but also myself, now when I try to get up, it’s not so easy to stand up as it used to be. Because one doesn’t have the same strength in the body and the body is a bit more stiff and so on, and it’s uncomfortable. One has this body that one has to carry around, but one has less energy to carry it around and do things with, and it causes suffering and uncomfort.

And, of course, part of the suffering of that is remembering that it wasn’t like that. It wasn’t like that. And also the suffering of knowing other people think you look funny and pathetic or something, because younger people do tend to, because they don’t think it’s going to happen to them. So it looks funny, embarrassing or something. So there is the suffering of having that old body, that weak body, but it’s so much more reinforced by the mind, our own thoughts, especially if we haven’t prepared our mind for these things to come.

Like when one gets old, body can be very shaky, to do things, to even hold a book, hold a cup of tea or something, and it’s embarrassing. But these things, if we live to be old, we will experience. If we don’t experience it in this life, we’ll experience it in the next life. If we don’t experience it in the next life, we’ll experience it in the next life, and then the next life. We’ll experience by taking rebirth as a human being again and again, eventually we experience every possible kind of suffering of being old.

Of being old, very old, ancient, senile, and so on. It has to happen and it will happen again and again and again and again. Is this true or not? We should check ourselves. And if it’s true, why do we want to perpetuate this suffering?

Also, as we get older and lose the pleasant appearance of our body and its strength, also the power of our senses fades away. The sense of taste declines so that we may have attachment because also the longer we live we build up our attachment to particular kinds of food, but they no longer taste as delicious. We have this grasping for the pleasure that this should taste like that, but it doesn’t taste like that anymore. So that’s kind of depressing. And our body doesn’t have the power to digest food as much, so we would like to eat all these things but we can’t because we can’t digest them.

Then our hearing fades away. So we can’t hear all the beautiful music that we like to hear. We can’t hear the pleasant sounds of nature or hear what people say. It’s so true that for some reason, because you have to shout louder at people who can’t hear, generate this idea that they’re stupid. Yeah?

Even though the person can be incredibly intelligent, but you shout at them to hear and we generate the idea, Oh, this person is so stupid because they can’t hear. Even in, I don’t know, other languages, but in the English language, the word for not being able to hear and speak is dumb. And we use this word to be meaning not intelligent. But it doesn’t mean that because you can’t hear and speak that you’re not intelligent. And also there’s the suffering of knowing that as you get deaf people think you’re stupid just because you can’t hear clearly what they said.

This is a very humiliating kind of thing to experience day after day. Also, then one’s eyesight fades, becomes different, you know, not so easy to see, to read, and so all the enjoyments that come from that. Apart from the point of view of dharma, you can’t read the dharma anymore, so memorize the dharma now, memorize it while you can read it. But all the ordinary pleasures of reading books and the newspaper, television, you can’t see so well anymore. So all the pleasures fade away.

So with that comes the loss of all one’s enjoyments. With advancing age, the enjoyments fade away, less and less things to enjoy. The body just simply isn’t capable of enjoying these things anymore. And maybe worse of all is the loss of the power of our mind with age as the body and brain cells die, the nervous system isn’t functioning as well and so on, then our mind itself, if we haven’t trained the mind through meditation, Because this ordinary, untrained mind is totally dependent on this body, as it gets weaker and older, then the mind itself loses its powers. So we can experience the suffering of senility eventually, but we will definitely experience this in future lives if we don’t have it in this life, and we’ll experience it again and again and again and again.

As the body gets weaker, one loses the power of the body, one suffers from incontinence and the embarrassment of that and becoming helpless, dependent on others. As the body gets weaker and the senses get weaker, we have to depend on others more and more. This time will come if we live to be very old. If we die young, we won’t experience the suffering of age, aging. But if we grow older and older, we will experience these sufferings in this life.

And if not, we’ll experience them in other human lives. Or the ageing of being a dog is even worse, less control. When you’re an old animal, you can’t hunt, so you starve to death. And then, with aging and the loss of all one’s senses and powers and control, then there’s it’s very noticeable in many old people, there’s a lot of fear that arises. So much fear.

Fear to be alone and so on. People worry about being attacked by robbers and this is and that, drug addicts and there’s so much fear like that. Unfortunately, and more of it is becoming justified. But even if it’s not, there’s so much fear because we lose control of our body and our environment as we get older. We hear things, we’re not sure what we heard, we can’t quite see what’s there, so many fears arising.

And of course, as we get older, at some point we can’t pretend any longer that death won’t come. But we’re afraid of it. So, these are some of the fears of growing old. Not everyone experiences them, of course, not everyone experiences all of them, but if we think and meditate in the context of taking human rebirths or rebirths again and again, one will have to experience every possible whatever suffering you see in some other old person, we will experience it. We will have to experience it sooner or later.

In the teachings it says, The only good thing about ageing is that it takes quite some time. Because if one went to bed as a young woman or man and woke up the next morning old, it would be unbearable. You go to bed twenty three years old with nice shiny beautiful hair and this nice shiny fresh skin looking nice and attractive, and you wake up in the morning wrinkles, grey hair. It would be horrifying, totally horrifying. But with ageing, there’s some time to get used to it.

That’s the only good thing. There’s a very interesting poem that takes too long to read. There’s a book by Glen Mullen called something like Death and Dying in the Tibetan Tradition, something like that. So he quotes this in length, translates this poem, which is an encounter with a very young, arrogant man and an old man on the side of the road. This very old man and this young Tibetan man is like the equivalent of a modern, sort of trendy young guy.

He’s wearing all the latest clothes and he’s got this very beautiful horse which is like the equivalent of having the latest flashy car and he’s totally proud of all these things and has complete contempt for this old man, this disgusting old man who actually happens to be a very highly realized yogi. So then the yogi kind of talks to him about, You think I’m disgusting but all of this is going to happen to you. It’s very interesting to read. So, this is true. We don’t think it’s going to happen, but it will happen, step by step, secretly, slowly, moment by moment.

It is happening. It started one second after we were born. The aging process started, and it’s irreversible. It’s happening moment by moment. So, it sneaks up on us moment by moment.

So, remember, this is one of the things that Prince Siddhartha saw. He saw it. After many years in the palace, he went out and eventually he got it. He got it that, Oh, I’m going to grow really old. My wife is going to grow really old.

My parents, all my friends, everyone is going to get really, really old. He realized it. He got out of this little palace of our delusions, of our self-cherishing thought that grasps at permanence and he got the message. It’s important to get this message. When I was young, there was a famous rock group that still exists called The Who and they had a song called I hope I die before I get old and we all used to sing that.

But as we got old, we didn’t decide to die. I remember Mick Jagger saying, I hope I stop singing before I get middle aged. So then there is the suffering of sickness. So again, in this life, in this particular human life that we have, we may have the good karma, the good fortune, the good luck, whatever you want to call it, to not get sick in this life, have hardly any sickness in this life. From the time we’re born to the time we die, we may have almost no sickness.

Some people are like that. But, if we take rebirth again and again and again, it means that we will have to experience every kind of sickness. Every kind of sickness that exists and will come into existence in the future because the Buddha existed, more sicknesses will come, more terrible sicknesses will come, they are starting to come now. So, will have to experience all of them sooner or later, and not just one time, many times. And not just the mild form of them, the worst form of them, again and again and again.

This is how to meditate because if mind exists, it doesn’t come to an end. And if we perpetuate our delusions, they don’t come to an end from their own side. They just don’t stop. They don’t stop by wishing them to stop. We have to cut the root of the cause of all suffering.

If we don’t, the suffering goes on and on. And we are constantly, in our confusion, creating the causes for all kinds of suffering. So, we, as a human, there’s all sorts of simple sicknesses to experience again and again, like childhood sicknesses of measles, whooping cough whooping cough Whooping, whooping, whooping, I’ve forgotten now. Are they? Mumps, then, you know, colds, getting colds, getting toothaches and whatevers.

So there’s all these kinds of simple sicknesses to experience, then there’s chronic sicknesses that we can experience, there are life threatening diseases to experience, there’s the sickness of the body, the infinite numbers of sicknesses of the body to experience and also the sicknesses of the mind to experience, all kinds of mental sicknesses to experience. We may not have them in this life, we may be incredibly mentally healthy in this life, but there’s the chance to experience all of these kinds of mental disturbances life after life. So these are very obvious sufferings of old age and sickness. These are things that actually and again, this is another one of the things that Prince Siddhartha went out and saw, really saw it, not just looked at it, it, really saw sickness and realised that he was not immune to it, had not gone beyond it. All his loved ones, friends had not gone beyond it.

So how can we live a life ignoring this, ignoring the suffering of rebirth, old age and sickness? And then there is the suffering of death itself. I just had a meeting, there was a group of us, people who work with dying people, although there wasn’t time to talk about so many actual death experiences, but just the little I heard was pretty horrifying. It might be actually nice for all those people to get together one night and tell some stories about how people die. Of course, some people die well.

Some people die incredibly happily and radiate happiness to others as they die, but not everyone does that. Not everyone dies like that. So, of course, as a human being, we will have pleasant deaths, but taking rebirth as a human again and again, we will have to experience every kind of unpleasant death, all the fears of dying. Some years ago when I was in Spain, a friend of mine there told me about one of his relatives who had been in the Spanish Civil War, had fought in the Spanish Civil War, killed people in the Spanish Civil War, and then when he died, when he was about eighty five, as he was dying, but still lucid and conscious, before the actual final phases of the death process started, he would have these visions of hell. And he would tell his family, I’m seeing this, yeah, and don’t do what I did.

He would tell his family that. So, there is the suffering of death. What can I say? I could have many gory things to say, but one can imagine that in the teachings it says, is a lot of negative karma in the mind at the time of death, then this actually becomes a cause for the death process to be very painful. There’s a great deal of not physically painful, apart from mentally painful, because of our delusions, uncontrolled delusions, then the death process can be very frightening.

I think it’s so easy to see. If we have a lot of attachment, a lot of attachment to things, friends, and this and that, then they’re lost in one moment. We have no control of them, we know we’re never going to see them again. And we’ve been dependent, we’ve made ourselves dependent on all these things and people for so long. And then it’s all coming to an end.

So, so much fear and worry and confusion. There are many people, we may be among them, who are so frightened to be alone. Some people can’t bear to be alone, to be left alone. Some years ago, I went to Iowa City, a city in Iowa, which is a pretty quiet place, you know, the Corn Belt of America, very quiet country place, a small university town. And the people I stayed with were telling me that a friend of theirs, a woman from New York City, came and stayed.

After a few days, she just couldn’t bear it. She just couldn’t bear the silence. It was just too quiet and there was nothing to do. She was used to New York City life and she couldn’t bear to stay. And some people can’t bear to be alone quiet.

At all. It’s frightening. You have to turn on the radio, do this, do that. So, if we haven’t learnt to be able to be alone, to be a little bit relatively independent of all these sense distractions and other people, how can we have a good death when we become totally alone, separate from every single thing that we’re familiar with and including especially our body. Our body.

So, apart from the suffering that our delusions and attachment are going to cause in our mind at the time of death, the teachings say that the presence of the negative karmas can be responsible for a lot of physical pain at the time of death. If one has a lot of good karma, then there is much less pain and maybe no physical pain at all at the time of death. I know this is a very unpleasant topic. We do not like to hear about it, but in some way, it’s important to think about it because if we think about it, we can avoid the causes experiencing the suffering of death. If we don’t think about it, in our ignorance and confusion, we may accumulate the causes to have a terrible death.

I’m sorry, I don’t know the lady’s name, but someone was talking about how she works with people who are dying from extreme Was it the lung cancer? No, the lady? Yes. Maybe you could tell some of the things you’ve heard and seen, but of people who are dying in extreme pain, yeah, and having to give all sorts of drugs to stop that pain and sometimes it’s very difficult to stop the pain and the drugs that stop the pain cause the mind to hallucinate and freak out, then you have to give other drugs to stop that. So we can experience such a death.

We can’t say we won’t. If we don’t in this life, we can experience it in another life. There are so many things that can go wrong with this body. But, now we have the method. The reason for thinking about this is to wake up that we have the precious human rebirth and a method to avoid all of this, or to at least modify it as much as possible.

We are capable. We can do this. But if we somehow just try to ignore all this and we don’t have to think about any of this, it’ll all be okay. It’ll all be okay. But the idea is to think about the suffering of death to motivate us to use the life however much time we’ve got left, because death could happen today, to make life meaningful with Bodhicitta, cherishing others more than self.

So, even these meditations themselves are enough, you know, to think about these things because they are very directly things that we can see around us and to think that if this human being is experiencing this suffering, I could experience it in this life or a future life. His Holiness says, Just to think about the suffering of the human realm is enough to generate renunciation of saṃsāra. But if it doesn’t work, then think about the suffering of the other realms. But just the suffering of human beings is enough to generate the great renunciation, to generate the courage to destroy ignorance and develop wisdom. Lama Zopa Rinpoche says that always do meditation on the sufferings of saṃsāra with refuge.

First, feel the unbearable fear and suffering, and then take refuge and make purification. And also to realise that this suffering is not happening now because one doesn’t have the karmic imprint for it right now, so take refuge and make purification. And at the time of death, to remember that there is a method not to fall into the lower realms, that the triple gem has the power to save us, and therefore, with a happy mind, make purification. So these are some of the four sufferings that we’ve already experienced the suffering of birth, even though we may not remember it, but we’re now the suffering of aging has to take place, we may experience the suffering of illness, and then we have to experience the suffering of death. But again, really, most of the suffering is not because of the thing itself aging, sickness, death and so on it’s the mind that our attitude to that, the way we conceive of those things, how much the strength of our attachment.

The more attachment, the more suffering comes with all these things. So, all suffering is teaching us, Don’t be attached. Don’t grasp your permanence because everything is impermanent. So then, also in this human realm, one of the sufferings that we meet again and again in this life, and also we will go through again and again, life after life, is the frustration, the suffering of meeting what we don’t want to meet. One can make a list of the things I don’t like.

I don’t like this, I don’t like that, I don’t like this, I don’t like that. And then, there is the suffering of meeting these things, which we meet again and again. Yeah. And, of course, the more self-cherishing, the more the fear of things. So, the more we follow the self-cherishing the thought, which demands that things be perfectly right for me, the more things there are to dislike because they’re not exactly what the self-cherishing thought likes.

So, the mind is tormented. So, there is the frustration of meeting the unwanted Meeting it in some way, seeing it, hearing it, tasting it, touching it, feeling it, whatever, thinking about it. The light. Because the self-cherishing thought, the self obsessed thought that wants happiness right now, you know, exactly the whole world should be exactly as perfectly fitting for me, that that mind meets many unwanted things, you know. For example, this table has got a chip.

I don’t if you’ve noticed it, but you can’t be bothered to give me a decent table that’s got a chip. I really don’t like this chip on this table. I’ve never said this before but I’ve been putting up with this chip for two weeks. Why can’t I have a decent table? And this pink laminex, I mean, what pink laminex?

Good grief, you know? And it’s an old table, how come I can’t I don’t get a good table, you know? Mean, this is not a joke, know, this is serious stuff, you know? I’m a very important person and I get this third grade old table and look, look, look at this, and it’s got this old sticky tape on it. You can get better gongs than that for me.

I don’t think I’m going to come here anymore, you know? But this pathetic thing, look at that. Anyway, this should be over here. This should be over here. No, I think I like it over here better actually.

That’s kind of much nicer there. No, I don’t like that. Yeah? The more self-cherishing, the more we demand things to be perfect, the more we meet what we don’t want to meet. Yeah?

And, we torment ourselves. And, we’ve created the karma to meet what we don’t want to meet. Yeah. Because yeah, anyway. So, that happens all our life.

So many things that we don’t like because we have this concept that this is how it should be, this is good, and the more we hold on to that, then it’s much better there. So, we suffer. And then there’s the suffering of when we do get what we want, there’s the suffering of being separated from it. We get the perfect table and then someone takes it, steals it, it gets destroyed, whatever. We’re separated from all the agreeable things that we want.

Again and again, this happens. Just as like in the six sufferings of rising and falling, we meet the friend, but there always has to be the separation. So, we’re always separate. We collect things that we like, we collect money, and then we get separated from it, we collect stamps and we get separated from them, we collect this, that and the other, and sooner or later we have to be parted from all our collections. So whatever pleasure there is, we get separated from it.

This is something we have to even in the high realms, in the pleasant realms, that suffering has to be experienced again and again. Right? So, there’s the bliss of the God realms, but we get separated from it again and again. And this happens throughout this life and every life we take will experience that meeting what we don’t want to meet, being separated from what we’ve become dependent and attached to, again and again and again and again. And then, as well as that, there is the suffering of not getting what we want.

We have many things we would like to have, but we don’t get them. Or, we wish for something and we get it, but it’s not exactly what we wanted, not exactly how we conceived it in our mind. So, so much suffering comes from that. And again, if you check, what is behind that suffering is our attachment. The stronger the attachment, the more the suffering.

So, it’s important to think of many examples of that, how we can go through life like that, wanting this, wanting that, but we don’t get it, or we get it, it’s not exactly what we wanted. And this goes life after life after life. And then I just check the the Yes. And then the last of these sufferings is having this body bound by delusion and karma. Having these five aggregates, the form aggregate, the aggregate of feeling, discrimination, composition of factors, the aggregate of consciousness, all controlled by delusion and karma.

So, we have such a body, these five aggregates, the five defiled aggregates, life after life in saṃsāra. A Buddha has five pure aggregates: a pure body, like the Rūpakāya, which is consisting of the two forms, the Sambhogakāya and the Nirmānakāya, and then all the aspects of the Buddha’s mind completely pure: pure feelings, pure discrimination, pure consciousness. But we have five contaminated aggregates, even in the high realms of humans and gods, and we take these five contaminated aggregates again and again, and we suffer. So, eighth suffering is like summarizing all the previous ones. Because of having a contaminated body, there’s aging, sickness, death, and so on.

Because of having a contaminated mind, there’s the suffering of the delusions and self-cherishing and so on. So these are some ways of thinking about the eight kinds of sufferings. The main thing to think about is to really make it strong in the mind if one wants to, to develop aversion to want to get, not just to stay in this cozy cell, thinking there’s just this cozy cell, but to escape from the entire concentration camp, is to think about life after life. In one life, it’s okay. Maybe it’s bearable to put up with aging, sickness, death, meeting with what we don’t want to meet with, this and that, but to think that this is going to go on and on and on forever if we don’t do anything about it, that this is the best we can hope for.

We just modify our delusions, if we don’t modify our delusions at all, we get the suffering of the lower realms. If we modify our delusions and avoid negative, you know, the worst negative karma and create lots of good karma, then we be born in the upper realms again and again, but all these sufferings will happen again and again and again. And eventually, we will experience every kind of

Key terms in this teaching

contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
nirmanakaya emanation body; tul ku (Tib)
The emanation body of a buddha that manifests in a variety of forms for sentient beings. LYWA
rupakaya form body; zug ku (Tib)
The form body of a fully enlightened being; the result of the complete and perfect accumulation of merit. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
upper realms
The three higher realms in samsara of human, asura and sura. LYWA
Yama shinchi dagje (Tib)
The Lord of Death, seen on the Wheel of Life. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top