Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 06 Tape 03 Side 1 The Mind….

43 min · 4,435 words · 6 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 06 Tape 03 Side 1 The Mind....
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk teaches that mind is formless, beginningless and indestructible, and is the basis of all happiness and suffering. Its fundamental nature is the same in every being and is clear and knowing, so suffering is reduced by changing the mind rather than the external world, and Buddha nature is freed rather than developed. It closes with the refuge and Bodhicitta motivation, a mandala offering and a breathing meditation.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-06

Duration: 44 min

UUID: d0d884b5-8af9-4d9d-ae6d-0a42ca61dfe2

Words: 4,435

Then it means it does have existed before. And if it existed before, it it existed before before. And if it existed before before, it existed before before before, into beginningless time. This is why it’s incredibly crucial to think just about this point: Does mind exist? If you only think about this point in this whole course, the course is worthwhile.

Because if mind does exist the way the Buddha taught, and it’s indestructible, it’s going to go on. We’re not just going to leave it and there’s going to be this nice cozy blackness after death. The mind is going to go on. How is it going to go on? Is a big question, something to really think about.

Will it go on into happiness or suffering? Will it go into greater happiness or even worse suffering? This is something to think about. Then religion becomes something really vital. We really have to take care of our mind.

It’s not something we can escape from. It’s there twenty four hours a day. It is the very basis of our being. Right now, in our confusion, we identify so strongly with this body. Even if intellectually we believe otherwise, we identify so much that I am this body.

If I have a beautiful body, I am beautiful. If I have a strong body, I am strong. But that’s not who we are. Although it’s not completely correct, it’s much more accurate to think what we really are is our mind. This amazing, insubstantial, formless, arising, this process of knowing, experiencing and feeling that goes on moment by moment, endlessly, indestructively.

It’s there when we’re asleep, it’s there when we’re awake. Sleep is mind, it’s just a way of experiencing our mind. Being awake is a way of experiencing our mind. So one core aspect of mind is that it is formless. What is happiness?

Happiness is mind. We all agree that we’ve experienced some kind of happiness. When we experienced it, we may have depended on something external to have that experience, but where did that experience arise? In our mind. Nowhere else.

From Buddha’s point of view, that happiness is mind, or a state of mind. We’ve all experienced suffering and pain. What is that suffering? It is mind. It is a state of mind.

Whose mind? Our mind. Nobody else’s. Hopefully, without going into complicated explanations and everything, hopefully everyone here agrees that love exists. Yes?

So, if it exists, where is it? These are just rhetorical questions. Where is it? Can you locate it? From a scientific point of view, if things exist, it’s some substance, it’s something solid, and solid stuff has to be located somewhere.

Physical things have a location. So where is love? Where do you go to get it? Well, don’t answer that question. And if exists, what does it look like?

What shape is it? What colour is it? It doesn’t have a shape, it doesn’t have a colour, it doesn’t have a locality because love is a state of mind. We’ve all experienced hate. Same thing: Where is it?

Where is this hate? What does it look like? What color is it? What shape is it? What does it smell like?

How much does it weigh? It doesn’t have any of those qualities because although it exists, the way it exists is mind. It is mind. It is a state of mind. Hate is very rampant in this world right now.

It is reality, an undeniable reality, but you can’t locate it anywhere because it is mind. It is a way of knowing. Hate is a way of knowing. Love is a way of knowing. It is a way of experiencing.

Whenever we know something, whenever we experience something, there is also a feeling, a pleasant feeling, an unpleasant feeling or a neutral feeling. These are all aspects of mind. There are so many ways to know things. And we are only using a very small aspect of our mind, we are only knowing things right now in a very limited, confused way. That’s why we experience suffering and no real, permanent, pure, lasting happiness.

But when our mind knows perfectly, then there can be perfect, lasting happiness. This is the argument, you see. Mind is what knows. Right now, we may think, we may believe that what we know is correct and precise and accurate is reality. But the Buddha taught that all of us are not knowing reality.

What we are experiencing knowing is completely distorted. That’s why we suffer. But mind is that which knows and has the potential to know. And if we allow our mind to know correctly, if we create the conditions within ourselves and the external environment for our mind to know more clearly, calmly, it will do so. That is the nature of mind.

Nothing else does that. So mind is that which knows and has the potential to know. That potential can be developed or liberated so that we know everything perfectly, accurately. When one knows accurately, one knows with love and compassion. Hate is an inaccurate, false way of knowing and experiencing things.

When we know correctly, there is no cause for suffering. There is no suffering and we are not creating the cause of suffering in our mind. So the mere aspect of the mind being that which knows is the source of happiness. When the mind knows accurately, directly, precisely, vividly, perfectly, that is real happiness. Everything else is confusion and suffering and limiting and frustrating and unfulfilling.

Once this pure happiness is established in the mind, because the mind goes on and on and on and on, once this pure happiness that is free from every kind of confused way of knowing, once that is established in the mind, because the mind goes on, one is able to experience pure, lasting happiness. This is the Buddhist argument. This potential for pure, lasting happiness is in our mind, it is the very nature of our mind. It is our Buddha potential, our Buddha nature. It is the quality of every mind.

It’s not unique to some minds and not to others, it is the quality of mind. So every sentient being has a mind and all minds are the same in their nature. Just the process of knowing and experiencing. Minds can temporarily operate at different levels of efficiency and clarity, But the fundamental nature of mind is the same for every mind. Simply that which is clear and knowing.

So we’re all the same. Every sentient being in nature is the same because we all have mind. We don’t have the same mind, we have unique minds, our own unique mental continuum. But each unique mental continuum is the same in its fundamental nature. If we really understand that and can experience it, of course this is the basis for developing love and compassion for every sentient being, because we are all the same.

There’s no real difference. There are many superficial differences because of sex and race and religion and culture and time, but fundamentally there’s no difference because we have mind. We are all the same. And so much suffering arises in the world because on the basis of that sameness we create differences, and we fight about those differences, and believe that this difference is better than that difference and is more real than that difference. But all of that is superficial.

The fundamental nature of our self, of all beings, is the same. And that’s why we can take refuge in the Buddha because the Buddha has mind like ours. It’s the same. It’s not a different kind of mind. The only difference is that the Buddha’s mind is free of all limitation, all obscurations.

This pure nature of our mind is obscured at the moment, And Buddha mind is free of those obscurations. But the nature of the mind, of a Buddha, of our self, is exactly the same. So these are some very fundamental, basic points on which all the Buddhist teachings rely on, and I’ll try to elaborate on these during the course, that we have mind. It is beginningless and indestructible. It is endless.

And it is that which gives rise to every experience, good and bad. All suffering is arising in our mind. All happiness is arising in our mind. If we want to reduce our suffering, our unhappiness, our discomfort, our worries, fears, anxiety, the only way to do it sorry, this is very dogmatic, but make this point. But if we really understand that the mind does exist, the only way to reduce our suffering and unhappiness is to change the mind. It doesn’t matter how much we change the external world, if we do not change our mind, nothing changes.

So, if we want to reduce our suffering, we have to change our mind. If we want to reduce our suffering a little bit, then we need to change our mind a little bit. If we want to reduce our suffering a lot, we have to change our mind a lot. If we want to totally eliminate suffering, then we have to bring about a complete revolution in our mind. And if we want to experience more happiness, then the only way to do it is to change our mind, to develop our mind, to allow the positive potentials of our mind to become manifest, to stop obscuring them.

We do not have to add happiness to ourselves. In fact, we cannot do that. There is no way to import happiness into ourselves. Basically, Buddhist path of achieving greater and greater happiness until we achieve perfect, lasting happiness is to get rid of the confusion in our mind. Because this pure, perfect, lasting happiness or at least the potential for it is there in our mind right now.

We don’t have to create it, it is there because of the very nature of our mind. All we have to do is just eliminate all the things that are suppressing. All we have to do is eliminate those things which are suppressing our true nature. That is the Buddhist path. And nothing in the external world, rearranging the external world, painting it, getting rid of bits of it, putting bits of it here, there, getting more of it, less of it, none of that works. Because there is always a mind experiencing that.

I think it would be much better if this room was free of these pillars. We’ll get rid of these pillars and it’ll be a much nicer room. But the trouble is, my mind experiences this room. So for a while I might think, Oh, this room is much better without the pillars. But then my mind changes, and I think, Actually, would be nicer with more pillars.

Or just get rid of this whole thing and have a plastic dome. Or nothing, just have it out, you know, we don’t need buildings at all. Then it would be much better natural, free, fresh. Endless thoughts. No matter what we do in the external world, another thought comes along from our mind that gets in the way.

Until we change our mind, there’s no happiness. Once we change our mind, really what’s out there doesn’t matter, than being concerned with sentient beings, helping sentient beings to discover their true nature. So I’ll stop here. Sorry, a little bit over time, but any questions? Sorry, I forgot the question time.

Yes? Can you say that there is a quality of space? Quantity? A quality of space. Like the food and the air is space.

The air is occupying space, you could say. The air is there because space is there. Space isn’t an energy, it’s just a mere lack of obstruction. Yes, that’s one aspect of knowing, it’s a type of knowing, sure. Is it hard to say, I am mind?

I was saying Can we wait till the end of the course for this question? I said earlier on that it’s not completely accurate, but it’s more accurate to say that we are our mind than our body. It’s better because to think we are our body is really a wrong view. It’s much more closer to the truth to say we are our mind, but also this is not accurate. We could say we have a mind.

Then, of course, this brings up the question of who is this person that possesses a mind? So this is also what we’ll try to investigate during this course. Yes. Given the potential to change the mind, and I think I heard you say before in terms of similarity between mind and space, in what way can we therefore change space? Yeah, okay.

One can’t change space, but one also doesn’t really conventionally speaking we talk about changing the mind but what this is really referring to is getting rid of the superficial levels of mind so that we experience the deepest level of our mind. That deepest level of mind is unchanging in its nature and it is in its nature blissful. That nature never changes. That is our Buddha nature, one way of describing our Buddha nature, our Buddha potential. Its nature is unchanging.

The characteristics of it is unchanging. That’s what we’re trying to experience. Talking about changing the mind means working with this ordinary level of mind in order we’re changing that, purifying that, in order to experience the deepest level of our mind, which is unchanging in its nature. In an ordinary way of speaking we say, everyone because there’s so many people in this room, there’s no more space to sit. But this is not the space we’re talking about, not the mere lack of obstruction.

There is a mere lack of obstruction in this room and that’s why people can occupy it, sit here, because there is space here. No matter how many people come into this room, they never harm that space. That space is there, that’s why you’re sitting there, why you’re able to sit there because there is this mere lack of obstruction. Why we can move around like I can wave my hand so much is because there is a mere lack of obstruction. Maybe, maybe, yeah.

Maybe one more question, we should finish. The way you talk about space, is there just one space and the way you talk about mind, is it just one mind? Right. There is just one space, the mere lack of obstruction. But there is not one mind, there are many minds.

We each have our own unique mental continuum but the nature of that mind is the same and unchanging. Time is it? Karen should be here by now. Sorry. And we should finish now.

Don’t if Karen’s waiting. Is she waiting outside? Oh, yes. Okay. So, the tradition is having started the teaching by trying to generate the right motivation.

Then we listen to the teaching, especially if we listen in the right way with an open mind, it generates a positive imprint in our mind. This positive imprint can become a cause of happiness in the future. So, what happiness do we want? We don’t want this positive imprint to ripen as just some temporary bubble of pleasure. What we really want is perfect, lasting happiness.

So we can dedicate this positive imprint for it to become a cause of our complete liberation, our complete enlightenment, so that we can continuously benefit all living beings. So the tradition is that there is a prayer we can say to dedicate that merit. So if you want to join in, do so. It’s on the bottom of page nineteen. On the bottom of page twenty three, the first one.

We’ll just do that one. I can say in Tibetan, if you want to join in like that, or at least read meaning in English, which is on page twenty three. The Tibetan is on page twenty two. Okay, thank you very much. I think our next session there won’t be discussion group today, so the next class the next session will be, I think, three thirty.

Isn’t it? Teaching three thirty? Okay, thanks very much. But I think Karen will say something now. Maybe you can remind me at the end.

I’ll tell people at the end. Okay? So, to make this time as effective as possible for ourselves and others, it really depends on our own motivation. So the stronger the motivation we generate, the clearer the motivation we generate, and the more virtuous, positive or meaningful the motivation we generate, then the greater the effect for ourselves and others. So in the Buddhist tradition, especially in the Mahāyāna tradition, which we are trying to present here, then the very greatest motivation that we can possibly generate is called the Bodhicitta thought, where we seek to develop our mind, firstly overcoming all the disturbing thoughts in our mind and, on the basis of that, developing all the positive potentials of our mind completely in order to achieve a state of complete awakening or enlightenment.

So, in that state, not only do we achieve the perfect lasting happiness that we’re always seeking, life after life, but in this state we have the qualities that enable us to guide all living beings away from suffering and towards happiness and guiding them to be able to experience their own true nature. So, as much as possible, we can try and generate this Bodhicitta thought right now. This Bodhicitta thought, for it to really fully develop, arises on the basis of understanding or believing in the existence of Buddha mind that enlightened minds do exist and they have these inconceivable qualities of all encompassing wisdom that is able to continuously, perfectly, directly perceive the true nature of all phenomena in a completely unmistaken way. Buddha mind possesses the qualities of an all encompassing great compassion for every living being that never declines or changes in any way. And Buddha mind possesses the endless, skillful means and energy to guide each and every sentient being to enlightenment.

So the more we believe in the existence of such minds, we can aspire to achieve that mind ourselves because we have that potential within us. Because we have mind, simply because we have mind, we have Buddha nature. And the more we believe and trust in the existence of these perfect, omniscient Buddha minds, the more we can trust in the teachings, the Dharma, that come from these enlightened minds. These teachings elaborate, or firstly explain, how we have mind and how mind has buddha nature, and these teachings show us how we can develop that Buddha nature, free that Buddha nature. Actually, don’t think you ever develop the Buddha nature.

You free it, it spontaneously arises as Buddha mind. So the more we develop an understanding and trust in these teachings, then we’re inspired to follow them and achieve this enlightened state, not just for our own sake, but for the benefit of others. These teachings also explain, and this is something I will go into some detail during the course, that why should we benefit sentient beings? Because sentient beings have been kind to us, are kind to us, have been kind to us life after life. We have incredible, close connections with every sentient being.

We are, in reality, just one big happy family. Actually, a sad family at the moment, but we could be a happy family. And the vast majority of sentient beings, although they have a Buddha nature, are experiencing suffering right now, and much more suffering than we ourselves are experiencing. So, compared to the vast majority of sentient beings, we are in a very fortunate situation. If we use the teachings, we can recognize this more and more and use this fortunate situation not to just achieve a little bit of temporary pleasure and comfort and distraction and so on, but we can use this time to develop our mind, and the teachings show how to do that.

The third object of refuge is the aryasangha, the community of practitioners who have practiced the Buddhadharma, practiced the teachings intensively for a long period of time, and have gained a deep insight into those teachings, a deep experience of them, have liberated their minds from suffering. So these beings can inspire us and guide us on the path. So the more we have some understanding of the qualities of these, what I call the Three Jewels of the Buddhadharma and Sangha, They act as a basis for developing a stable basis, a valid basis for being able to develop this mind seeking enlightenment. In order to seek enlightenment, we have to believe it’s possible and other people have achieved it. So the more we understand all these things, then we ourselves can not only aspire to this state, but actually become involved in all the practices, the different kinds of practices that lead to that state.

So, we try and generate as much as we can that motivation or something along those lines. At least, if one doesn’t believe in all those things, hopefully we’re all here because we believe in the power and importance of loving kindness and compassion, and that we want to develop these qualities more and more. As we generate this motivation and sense of refuge, as I mentioned this morning, it’s helpful to especially those people who have a belief in the Buddha and feel some refuge in the Buddha, Dharma, Sangha. It’s helpful as we say this prayer and generate this motivation to imagine the Buddha in front of us. One can imagine him surrounded by countless other Buddhas and bodhisattvas and other holy beings.

So the Buddha is our object of inspiration, guidance and refuge, and at the same time we try to think of all sentient beings, all the suffering sentient beings surrounding us who are our reason for practicing, of developing our mind. Particularly, it’s helpful because the idea of all sentient beings, infinite sentient beings, is something very difficult to grasp onto. At least we can begin by thinking of our mother on our left, our father on our right, family and friends behind us and the people we dislike or wish to cause us harm directly in front of us. And as much as possible, we try and think of countless other living beings as well, thinking that they have so much suffering, so much confusion, and they need my help. If only I could purify my mind, develop my mind, I could really help them in a very profound way.

For this reason, I’ll listen to these teachings in order to develop some understanding of them so that I can perhaps adopt them in my daily life, practice them in my life. So the prayer of refuge in Bodhicitta is on pages eighteen and nineteen. I go for refuge until I am enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, the Supreme Assembly. By the merits I create through practicing the Dharma. May I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings.

Then, we offer the mandala, page twenty to twenty one. Again, we visualise all the beautiful things of the universe, imagining the whole space filled with all inconceivable numbers of different beautiful things. And we offer these up to the Buddhas. The Buddhas themselves, of course, don’t need these things but from our side we offer them to try to overcome our attachment, our obsession with these things. In this way, we free our mind in order to be able to hear the teachings the way they are meant to be heard, so that we can understand them correctly, so that we can practice them correctly and gain the true insights, just as all the great practitioners of the past have done.

So, as well as listening with the right motivation, it’s also important to try to listen with a concentrated mind. So, the more we concentrate on the teachings, the more we’re able to understand them correctly because if our mind is distracted, we don’t hear, we don’t hear exactly what we could hear and so on, so we can misunderstand what’s being said. And also by listening with a concentrated mind, the imprints of hearing the teaching goes deeper into our mind. I’ll try and talk about this later on, what I mean by all these things. And these imprints can bear fruit in our future lives so that we have a greater and greater understanding of the Buddhadharma, not just in this life but in future lives.

And not only a greater understanding of it, but a greater ability to practice it. So, for this reason, just like this morning, we’ll spend a minute or so doing breathing meditation, trying to sit in a comfortable position in the posture that Venerable Karen explained as much as one can. And having put the body in that posture, then just to be aware of the breath coming in and going out, don’t change it in any way, just simply observe it. Particularly, notice the sensation that arises at the tip of the nostrils as the breath comes in and as it goes out. And try to focus just on that sensation.

Don’t force it in any way, you don’t have to create that sensation. Just try to allow the mind to observe it, to be aware of it as much as possible. It may be very subtle that one can’t observe very much, but that doesn’t matter. Just simply put in the effort of trying to notice that sensation. And by doing this, by trying to keep the mind without forcing it, by trying to keep the mind on one simple object, we begin to gain mastery over our mind.

And it’s only when we begin to master our mind that we can really transform and develop our mind. So, in the process of trying to keep the mind on the object, we face the problem of the mind becoming distracted by external sounds, pain in the body, and our own thoughts. So, we simply try to notice those things arising as quickly as possible, just simply realize they are distractions, they have no real meaning, no benefit. Let go of them, gently let go of them. Don’t force them away, just simply gently let go of them and bring the mind back to the breath.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
mandala khyil khor (Tib)
A circular diagram symbolic of the entire universe. The purified environment of a tantric deity; the diagram or painting representing this. LYWA
mandala offering
The symbolic offering of the entire purified universe to the spiritual teacher (guru) and the visualized merit field. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Is there only one space and only one mind, or are there many minds?

There is just one space, which is the mere lack of obstruction. Mind is different: there is not one mind but many minds. Each person has their own unique mental continuum. Even so, the nature of that mind is the same and unchanging.

Scroll to Top