Kopan Course 2001 — 2001-11-22

Buddha House Adelaide

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 — 2001-11-22
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: Kopan 2001 11 22 Tape 42 Side 1 Suffering.MP3

UUID: e47b45d2-3b35-4052-9ba0-fd2b1f521af1

Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub

Collection: Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)

Date: 2001-11-22

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 44 min

Words: 5,087

It’s very very difficult to understand what a karmic seed is, or a karmic potential. And the different schools of Buddhism, the different philosophical schools of Buddhism, there are four major philosophical schools of Buddhism, explain these in different ways. Okay. Maybe we should yes. Okay.

Is merit and good cause the same thing or anything? The merit is what is created by good karma. karma is action, so good karma is good activity of the body, speech or mind, and it creates these positive imprints which we call merit. Or both, because the good karma creates merit. It’s a good karma, it’s a good action of the body.

If you combine it with you could recite mantras as you go around, that becomes good good activity of the speech, and if you think good thoughts, that becomes good good activity of the mind. So all of that is creating merit, which are these virtuous imprints. Happiness, and the causes of the and the things that which give rise to happiness. Which is good karma. No, no.

Your happiness isn’t good karma, it’s the result of good karma. Happiness is consciousness, is mind, a state of mind. Are conditions causative phenomena? Yes. Yes.

So what karmically determines conditions? What karmically conditions determines conditions is? Yeah, well those conditions are the body and the environment usually, I mean, and so they also are the product of karma. Like this world is said to be the result of the collective good karma of all sentient beings that has been created over infinite time, and because of that such places exist as objects to be known by mind. But they can only be known by mind when the mind is in a particular state which is determined by the karma.

What the interplay between the conditions the causes to determine the ripening of the karma. karma. I can’t explain, It’s too complicated. I mean, If if if we we we have the karma to be killed, so we are born in a place where there is a being who is under the control of anger who wants to kill, and somehow these two things come together. We meet the object.

Meeting the object is that that is the condition, but to meet that condition itself is karma. And so if we don’t purify that karma, we meet that condition, and the karma is right, brings its result. But if we purify that karma or and and it changes, then we may not meet that person, so the karma isn’t doesn’t ripen. I mean, yeah, these fine details is very difficult to explain. But, you know, there’s there’s the environmental result where because of negative karma, we’re born in a place which which enables all our our delusions to arise very strongly.

So that is a karmic situation, so our our delusions arise strongly, and the the arising of strong delusions itself becomes a condition for our negative karmas to ripen. It’s very, very complicated. That’s all I can say. Okay. One last one.

Yeah. Right. Yeah, this topic is very difficult to comment on. This is what it says in the teachings. I can’t change the teachings myself, but this is what has been taught.

I mean, many Buddhist schools change these things and don’t say these things, but the Tibetan Buddhist tradition, although it’s often condemned for being a corrupt version of the Dharma, actually tries to maintain what was taught. Personally, as I mentioned to someone, if a homosexual couple are living together in harmony and affectionately and whatever, I don’t see how that is negative when many heterosexual couples are kind of fighting and screaming and doing all sorts of things. So I I it’s difficult I I find it difficult to to believe this point myself. In in certain cases, other cases, because there’s many kinds of heterosexuals and many kinds of heterosexual behavior, there’s many kinds of homosexual behavior, and some of it to me looks very suffering and confused for sure, but not all of it by any means. So the scriptures do not say why it is misconduct?

I think part of well, I think like, the in heterosexual behavior, the other body parts become sexual misconduct because in a heterosexual relationship, one is able to gain sexual satisfaction with the two organs coming together, to put it very technical here. Sounds very worrying. But by the two opposite organs coming together, sexual pleasure is possible, sexual orgasm and pleasure satisfaction is possible, so it’s not necessary for these other orifices to be used, right? So then it becomes like excessive desire, following excessive desire and so on, and the mind of discontent. But then for a homosexual couple there’s not much options, so then I don’t know.

I think we have to stop. One short one? Car to get out would be grandpa. Or grand Marpa. Yeah.

Grandpa. Yeah, right. She’s pretty old. Yeah. Right.

Thank you very much. Great. Thanks. A great discussion group. Okay.

So, we can dedicate the merit of this time that it may become a cause for us to develop the loving kindness and compassion towards ourselves that avoids creating any kind of negative karma and only generates positive actions towards ourselves and others, and through this may we quickly achieve enlightenment that benefits in a totally perfect way ourselves and all living beings. May the precious bodhi mind not yet born arise and grow May that born have no decline, but increase forevermore. Thank you very much. So we spend just a little time focusing on the breath as a way to enhance our concentration, which we can apply to listening to the presentation of the graduated path to enlightenment. Thank you.

So as I mentioned before, the topics that we’ve covered so far, which are topics for meditation, have the purpose the long term purpose, of course, is to lead us to enter the path that leads to complete enlightenment. But the short term purpose of them, or the medium or the intermediate purpose of these meditation teachings, even these meditations that we’ve done, are to lead us to generate the mind renouncing all of saṃsāra, all of the experiences within that we can possibly have when our mind is controlled to some extent by delusion and karma. When the mind is controlled by delusion and karma, we can experience hell, the preter realm, the animal realm, the human realm, the demi god realm, and we can experience the bliss of the god realms, but none of it lasts. One can get to a point of seeing how pointless that is and renounce develop the great renunciation that renounces all of samsaric existence. This is the basis for being able to achieve liberation, but it’s also the basis for being able to achieve enlightenment.

But before one can develop that great renunciation, the very beginning is developing the first level of renunciation, which is giving up our obsession with the things of this life. And so these meditation topics that we’ve covered so far are for that purpose. If we do them again and again with the right understanding, the right motivation, they will lead us to develop this mind that is less and less obsessed with the things of this life, believing them, this life to be the only one, and the the pleasures and problems of this life to be so important, permanent, and so on, and we will turn our mind towards using this life, enjoying this life, but at the same time using it, putting more and more energy to create the causes to have another good rebirth after this one. And the essential way to do that is to observe the law of cause and effect, to stop creating negative karma, which is the cause to have lower rebirths, and to start creating more and more positive karma, which is the cause to have a better a good rebirth. And as we’re avoiding negative karma in this life and creating positive karma, it also means we have left suffering in this life, and more happiness, more contentment in this life, and we’re causing less suffering to others, and being of greater benefit to others, and we’re giving our life a meaning, a valid meaning, not just making up some meaning, we’re giving our life a meaning that it can have.

Just the materialist view of life is meaningless. It may be true, but if there is mind, if the mind is not just a product of this brain, and there are many indications that it isn’t, so many, then we can give our life this valid meaning, but if the mind is just a product of the brain and this nervous system, our life is essentially meaningless. We can do this and that, we can climb mountains, make money, build houses, have children, travel around, but it’s just it’s just this robot, basically. We’re just a robot, like a traveling television set or something. I don’t know.

Traveling, a mixture of a television set, computer, and and what else. I don’t know. And it and really, if one if one really thinks about the implications that we are just this stuff, it is really depressing. Most people have the view that we are just stuff. Don’t think of all the implications, especially as the world progresses or goes on and all the religious views in the world that say, We’re not just stuff, they totally disappear, and then one is just left with the view, only the view, that we’re just stuff in this world.

I mean, it’s kind of like a nightmare, the implications of it. But it may be right. I I I I don’t know. I don’t believe it. So anyway, if we have some idea that there’s mind or something that goes on, that life has meaning, then this is one way to give it meaning and and to ensure that.

So, the path to enlightenment, as his Holiness said, one way of thinking about the path to enlightenment is well, put it this way, start again. There’s the path to liberation, the path to enlightenment. In both cases, how that is achieved is essentially through developing this wisdom consciousness, developing this consciousness that which we have the potential of right now, which we call intelligence. By developing that that consciousness more and more and more, it transforms into this wisdom consciousness that that destroys ignorance, the consciousness of ignorance. The consciousness of ignorance simply cannot arise when there is wisdom fully developed.

And when that wisdom is fully developed and stabilized, continuously present in the mind, suffering is gone. And there is one experiences the bliss of the mind, and we are liberated. But if we develop the Bodhicitta thought, can see that just developing that for ourself is not so nice. It’s very limited and maybe not so kind. Lama Zopa Rinpoche, in the first course I heard him teach in nineteen seventy six, gave the analogy that it’s like walking in a jungle with your mother, and this giant tiger springs out, and oneself runs up a tree and leaves your mother to be eaten by the tiger, and you look down and watch your mother being eaten by the tiger, and you think, So glad that’s not me.

Glad I’m escaped, I’m free. So to from a Mahāyāna point of view, to just achieve liberation for oneself and leave one’s mother, one’s father, all mother sentient beings behind to be attacked continuously by the tigers of delusion is really terrible because we have the ability to destroy these tigers and show all mother sentient beings how to to eliminate them. So since we have that ability, you know, and sentient beings have been so kind, we we have some responses to develop that ability and achieve enlightenment. But anyway, the key to liberation and enlightenment is this wisdom. And this wisdom, which is a very refined mind seeing the nature of things, firstly, when it first arises, it arises seeing all the false views and eliminating them, then it continuously only sees what is valid.

It is a valid consciousness seeing the way things actually exist. So for that mind to arise, it cannot arise while the mind is totally controlled by the disturbing thoughts, which is what we have now. Our mind is not always totally controlled by the disturbing thoughts, but they’re arising from time to time, sometimes very strongly. So that mind cannot realize the nature of phenomena. It cannot see how we create suffering.

It cannot see the the the the false appearances, the the way our our appearances are false. It’s just it’s just too confused to do that. It’s just too agitated. So it’s only when the mind becomes really subdued that one one has the chance to use one’s wisdom and develop it and begin to see the mistakes and and realize what is actually existing. So concentration has to be developed, single pointed concentration has to be developed by subduing the disturbing thoughts.

Once subdues the disturbing thoughts, concentration arises. By developing concentration, the disturbing thoughts are kept subdued. So every time why how we we how do we create negative karma? By mindlessly following the disturbing thoughts. So the more we create negative karma, it’s because we are mindlessly following these disturbing thoughts.

So the first way to begin the first step in beginning to subdue the disturbing thoughts, which leads to concentration, it is the basis for developing wisdom, which is the basis for achieving enlightenment, the first step is to stop creating negative karma. This is the beginning of the path in a sense. His Holiness says, first we have to stop creating negative karma, then we subdue the delusions, then we eliminate them. And one can eliminate them with the motivation just to achieve liberation for oneself, or in the process of stopping negative karma, subduing the delusions, one can generate the thought, I’m going to develop this wisdom, not just for my own sake, but for the benefit of all living beings. So this is the path.

First, have to put a lot of effort into stopping creating negative karma. This enables us to then be able to subdue the delusions more and more and more, and then we are able to develop concentration and apply that concentration to the wisdom teachings of the Buddha, that in the meantime we’ve been studying, and then we apply that in meditation, and we can begin to realize the true nature of our self and all phenomena. So, these meditation teachings are set out to achieve that. So the first step is to develop this renunciation of this life, which I’ve tried to point out, Some people think this is horrible, you know, renunciation means giving up my happiness, means giving up all the things that bring me happiness. Renunciation means it is a mind that gives up the causes of suffering, not the causes of happiness.

It is not the mind giving up happiness or the causes of happiness. It is the mind that is giving up suffering and the causes of suffering. Yeah. So it is a mind that has genuine love and compassion for oneself. It is the mind that realizes I have to take care.

If I am going to be happy, I have to take care of my mind because I exist totally in dependence upon my mind. I’m not something separate from my mind. I am not my mind, but I am not something separate from my mind. So if I want to be happy, the mind has to be happy, at peace, undisturbed or less disturbed. Therefore, I must protect my mind by not creating negative karma.

Yeah. So, particularly, we have to engage in avoiding the negative karmas of body. These are the grossest things to avoid. Yeah. The the gross negativities of the three negativities of body, also with speech, and by that we we also subdue the the grossest negativities in our mind.

So by doing that, eventually, we we are able to work with the more subtle delusions in our mind, make the mind calmer and calmer. So if we follow the the sequence, we recognize that we have this precious human rebirth, we begin to recognize that more and more, which particularly means that we recognize that well, one of the key factors of having the eight freedoms and ten endowments is that we have faith in a spiritual path, some faith in a spiritual path. That is one of the most important ones, That is not just this materialist view, but we have a view in some spiritual path, perhaps the Buddhist path. We have the method, we have the method, and we have all the conditions to practice the method, to understand the method, to practice it, to be guided by in that method by qualified teachers. That is the meaning of the precious human rebirth, and we have ordinary Dharma friends and and the physical conditions to engage in practice and encourage us and so on.

So having recognized that, and one of the key factors of it is having a teacher, especially when we have that, then we meditate on the first the first real step in developing this basic renunciation is thinking about impermanence and death. Why be so caught up in this life if I’m gonna die at any moment? And why be caught up in this life when it’s impermanent anyway? The pleasures and problems of this life are changing moment by moment, there’s nothing to hold on to, there’s no security in it. Even if we have a billion dollars at the time of death, there’s no way to take one one penny, one paisa, one lira, one dollar with us, and none of it helps at the time of death.

So that’s the first part in release, the first step. That itself can help in itself cause us to generate complete renunciation of his life. But if that isn’t enough, we have to think about what is since I’m going to die and could die at any moment, what’s gonna happen after death? Well, I could fall into the lower realms. Some form of lower realm, even such as having a worse human rebirth than what I’ve got.

Then, if that’s the case, since it’s so easy to create the causes of those kinds of rebirths, what what how am I going to prevent that? Take refuge in a valid system. And then if we take refuge in the Buddha Dharma, the core refuge is the Dharma, and within that is the law of cause and effect. So then we think about, we meditate on the refuge, and we meditate on the law of cause and effect, and we come to an understanding of how important it is that day by day, to make this precious human rebirth meaningful, at the very least, is I have to avoid creating negative karma. That’s the very least, the minimum spiritual practice of avoiding the ten non virtues day by day, moment by moment.

Cause any one of them can throw me into if I’m not careful, into the lower realms, some kind of lower realm. It’s not gonna be the cause to perpetuate the type of life I have now. Alright? And I can purify my mind of those kind of imprints I’ve I’ve done earlier in this life, in previous lives, out of ignorance. More than that, I can use this life moment by moment to accumulate the causes of a similar life that I have now.

So this is the minimal aspiration of turning our mind away from the things of this life, to use this life to create the causes of a better rebirth, because this life lasts that long. Even if we live to be a hundred, even if we live to be a hundred and twenty, it’s just that much time in the ongoing, endless continuity of our mind. It’s just that much. So what is worth? What is more important?

To use this life to have that much happiness, to get rid of that much suffering, or to create the causes of having ongoing ongoing happiness and not to have ongoing suffering. If we don’t like to have one cold in this life now, we don’t want a cold now, so we don’t want a cold tomorrow, next week, next year. We don’t wanna have one the next life, many times next life, many times the life after that, and the life after that, and the life after that. It’s it’s just really boring, distracting, annoying, uncomfortable. So we turn our mind to using this life for just things of this life to ensuring happiness in the future because we can do it, we can do it, we have a method, and we have the potential within us.

So this is the purpose of this set of meditation teachings, and we need to meditate on them again and again, to hear the teachings so that we can understand them more clearly. Because, you know, sorry, I I with all due respect, I’m not trying to insult anyone or anything from hearing the questions people ask to myself and Lama Lhundub. Sometimes you can see people haven’t even though I you know, I’m sorry, I repeat myself many many times deliberately, and I’ve just repeated something I’ve said many times already, that people don’t even hear the things. So if you can’t hear them, you can’t understand them. First you have to hear, then you have to be able to understand what is said and understand it correctly.

Not understand it from one’s own perspective and get all depressed because, oh, it seems to be saying that. This is so depressing, all this. But if one understands it correctly, it’s not depressing. It’s liberating. Just just understanding these points is liberating.

It’s liberating when one hears it, and the practice of the awareness of it, the mindfulness, in the moment, every every moment we are mindful of any of these points, they are liberating. Not totally liberating, of course, but they liberate us from some suffering, confusion in the moment. Every moment we remember impermanence, death, refuge, the lower realms, karma, the precious human rebirth, the existence of the buddhas around us and gurus. This awareness, this mindfulness is liberating us from confusion in the moment. It is liberating us from this low view of what we are, what we what what life is.

It’s liberating if we use it correctly. It’s liberating and it leads to liberation. It’s making us loving and it leads to more kindness. It it makes us compassionate in the moment for ourself and others, and it leads to more compassion for ourselves moment by moment. I mean, this is taught, this comes from the buddha mind.

I’m sorry, my presentation is not a buddha’s presentation, but it is coming from the buddha mind. This is the this is the way all the great beings of the past have achieved enlightenment, contemplating these things, and we need to do it again and again to get deeper understanding and to reverse because the old habits, of course, keep coming back. The imprint is there, it comes back. Many many imprints of the delusions are there, so they they come back and again and again. So now we move on to the next stage of the path to enlightenment, which is well, on the path that leads to the path to enlightenment.

We’re trying to You see, there is the path to enlightenment, which is like a highway. So to get onto that highway, there’s a What do you call it? Not an exit, not an exit, but an entrance, an entry lane onto that highway, onto that super highway. So we’re just thinking about getting on to that road that leads that goes onto the highway. Entrance to the highway is renunciation, complete renunciation.

Actually, the entrance to the path to enlightenment is Bodhicitta. There’s the highway, and then there’s the superhighway. The superhighway to get onto the superhighway, one has to generate Bodhicitta, then one is on the path to enlightenment. So right now, maybe we’re only thinking about whether we’re going to follow the spiritual life. Maybe we we we just want to take certain aspects of the spiritual life to sprinkle on top of our worldly life to make it more interesting.

Yeah? More entertaining. A little bit of meditation here, a little bit of mala here, a little bit of dorje here, Dorje and bell ringing here, a little bit of this here, a little bit of loving kindness here, a little bit of compassion there, just to sprinkle on top of the worldly life. But this is not what the Dharma was taught for. It’s not just to sprinkle on top to make life entertain a little bit more entertaining.

It’s meant to destroy our worldly life. It’s not meant to destroy our ordinary our daily life. The spiritual life, the Dharma practice is meant to destroy our worldly life completely. Completely smash it, rip it to shreds. But there is a big difference between worldly life and daily life.

The Buddha has a daily life, His holiness has a daily life, day by day. It is a it is a life totally infused with the Dharma. It is not a worldly life. His holiness is living in the world, but his mind is not stuck in it at all. So if if we generate if we really generate this loving, compassionate mind of renunciation that begins to really want to protect our mind from the disturbing thoughts and creating negative karma, and fill the mind more with with the positive karmas that come from generating loving kindness and compassion for oneself, and beginning to develop that for others, then we use this life more to practice Dharma than to create worldly pleasure.

So we follow that path, and we think, Oh, I’m gonna have a good rebirth, and then then in that next rebirth, I’ll do the same thing, and have another good rebirth, and then I’ll do the same thing and have another good rebirth. Oh, this is really nice. This is terrific. I’ve got it made. Yeah?

But then one one can contemplate that even if we have a good human rebirth again and again, and sometimes we decide to zap up to the god realms, zap up into one of the the the desire the god realms in the desire in the desire realm, hang out there for a while, float around on a lotus for a few thousand years, chat with the the other gods and goddesses and whatever, that would be nice, then we can come down, be a human being, and so on. That that could be really, really nice, you know, very nice. Yes. That’s that’s great. So we can do that forever.

But even if that goes on forever, being reborn as a human being, even as with a precious human rebirth again and again, going into the God realms again and again, we haven’t avoided, escaped suffering. Suffering will continue. Every kind of suffering will continue. So this is the next topic, the heavy one to think about. The reason to think about it is not to make us unhappy and depressed, but it’s to make us aware of what is the reality, so if we want to, we can avoid it.

We can avoid suffering by becoming aware of it, we can discover the causes of it, and so we can completely eliminate them. Because in this first part of the path of developing this basic renunciation and putting effort into avoiding negative karma so we can have a good rebirth, and then another good rebirth, and a good rebirth. We haven’t made the decision to eliminate our disturbing thoughts, we’ve just made the decision to modify them. Okay. Right?

I’ve got these disturbing thoughts, so if I modify them, then I have another good rebirth. So that’s not such hard work modifying the delusions. Oh, this looks like a good solution to the problem. I just modify. But it’s not a solution because even if we modify our delusions, we reduce our suffering, we get a little bit of pleasure in saṃsāra, but we haven’t eliminated suffering.

It will just go on and on and on. We can eliminate it, but just by subduing the disturbing thoughts doesn’t eliminate suffering, it just modifies it. So what we’re being encouraged now, what the Buddha is trying to encourage us to do is not just modify our suffering, but to eliminate it. And the only way to eliminate it is to eliminate the causes, and the only way to eliminate the causes is to want to. We have to eliminate the causes ourselves from our mind, and the only way to do that is to really, really want to get rid of the causes of suffering in our mind.

And the only way to get to reach that point, that thought where I really am totally fed up with the delusions and suffering is to think about suffering, and how it’s gonna go on and on and on if I don’t create the causes to stop it, to eliminate it. The mind goes on by not by not controlling the delusions, we create the imprints for them to arise again and again, especially there is ignorance there, which is giving rise to the delusions. While ignorance is there, the potential for the delusions is there again and again. So what gives us the energy to decide, I’m totally fed up, I’m going to develop this wisdom to destroy ignorance? This incredible radical mind, this is a completely revolutionary mind.

The first revolution in our mind is to decide this life is not what it’s cracked up to be. Just working for this life is not what everyone says it is. I need to, you know, protect my mind. That’s the first revolution. The second revolution is to realize that I have to get rid of the causes of suffering, not just modify my delusions, pacify them, but eliminate them.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
causative phenomena
Things that come about in dependence upon causes and conditions; includes all objects experienced by the senses, as well as the mind itself; impermanent phenomena. LYWA
desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
eight freedoms dalwa gyä (Tib)
The eight states a perfect human rebirth is free of: birth as a hell being, hungry ghost, animal or long-life god; as a barbarian; in a dark age when no buddha has come; with wrong views; or with impaired faculties. LYWA
graduated path lamrim (Tib)
A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. The lamrim was first formulated by the great Indian teacher Atisha when he came to Tibet in 1042. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
possessed result
One of four ways we can experience the result of an action, also called environmental result; possessed result is the environment we find ourselves in when we take rebirth. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top