Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: Kopan 2001 11 19 Tape 35 Side 2 Refuge.MP3
UUID: efd8d4bb-59da-4bea-bb82-187dfb596a56
Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub
Collection: Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Date: 2001-11-19
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 41 min
Words: 4,567
And at least the commitment is to respect all members of the Sangha without discrimination, and the teaching says that even if one knows the particular monk or nun is not observing their vows properly, has broken their vows, still one should respect that person simply because well, yeah, you respect their ordination of what they are supposed to be, because they still have the appearance of being a monk or nun, so it benefits one’s mind. And also, even the robes of a monk or nun should be respected, even to the extent of and this is one can see that the Tibetans observe this, that even pieces of red or yellow cloth, if you see them on the ground, you should pick them up and put them in a high place, thinking this is the robes of the Buddha. A few times I’ve seen Lama Zopa Rinpoche do this, when we were walking in Bodh Gaya in the filth, he sees a little bit of red cloth, picks it up, carries around until he can find a high place to put it. So the whole point of these things is they are training of the mind for the mind. And these mind trainings benefit our mind, they make us more aware, more sensitive of the triple gem, and what we have refuge, and what our refuge should be.
So these are the basic commitments, the three things to avoid, the three things to do. And then apart from that, there are six common points of training to engage in, having taken refuge. So the first of these is to always remember the qualities of the triple gem, the Three Jewels, to think of the different qualities of the Buddha, qualities of the Dharma, the qualities of the Sangha. Remember when I mentioned what is faith? Faith is the mind knowing the qualities of something.
The more we know the qualities of something, the more we develop the basic faith. And from that basic faith then arises aspirational faith, aspiring to have those qualities. And then the more we aspire to have those qualities, then that acts as a basis to engage in the activities that will bring about those qualities. So, having taken refuge in the triple gem with the aspiration to become a Buddha or to become liberated, in this tradition we’re trying to take refuge there are three levels of refuge. The first one is the fear of the lower realms, that’s the basic reason for taking refuge.
The second level is to protect from all the sufferings of Samsāra and the highest form of refuge is the Mahāyāna refuge, where we take refuge out of fear of the suffering of others, as a way to be able to because we fear all the suffering that others are getting caught up in, we take refuge so that we can help them out of that suffering. So since we try to aspire to take refuge, to take Mahāyāna refuge, we are aspiring to achieve enlightenment. So the more we know the qualities of the enlightened mind, the more we aspire to that and therefore the more we will engage in it. So therefore it’s really helpful to acquaint ourselves more and more, this is a commitment with the qualities of the Buddha, the qualities of the Dharma and Sangha. Because also sometimes people seem to think that like a Buddha is just like a nice person.
When you become a Buddha you turn into a really nice person, or a bodhisattva is a really kind person. Many Buddhists go around saying, you know, they know someone who’s very kind and generous and this and that, and they say he’s a bodhisattva. So in one way it’s nice to say that, it’s a nice kind of praise, but in another way, if we really think that this person is a bodhisattva, it’s really missing the point. If we really study what it means to be a bodhisattva, what it means to have compassion and great compassion. I mean, is so rare, unbelievably difficult to have this mind, to have the mind of Bodhicitta.
You know, there’s great compassion, and then on top of great compassion there is Bodhicitta. I mean, this is just unbelievable what this mind is. And then there is wishing Bodhicitta, and then there is engaging Bodhicitta. And then there is so there are bodhisattvas who have wishing Bodhicitta, there are bodhisattvas who have engaging Bodhicitta, and then there are excuse me for want of a better word, ordinary bodhisattvas, and then there are ārya bodhisattvas, and there are ten levels of ārya bodhisattvas, And then there is Buddha. So in the Zen tradition there’s this statement, Before buddhahood chopping wood and carrying water, after enlightenment chopping wood and carrying water.
Sounds like there’s not much you could interpret that like saying that, Oh, you know, being Buddha is nothing special, you’re just another person. But actually that’s a very profound statement. But the ordinary mind can interpret that to mean that when you’re a Buddha, you still do the same old things and basically the same old person. But Buddha mind there’s no comparison between our mind and a Buddha’s mind and what a Buddha does. Of course a Buddha can carry water but they carry it with a realization of the ultimate nature of the water and the conventional nature.
We haven’t got a clue about the conventional nature of the water yet. And we think we’re really carrying the water. And we think there’s real water and there’s a real bucket and there’s a real me and we’re really carrying the water and that we’re really walking along. A Buddha doesn’t have a single thought like that. So it’s it’s really important to acquaint ourselves with the qualities of the Buddha, of the Triple Gem and the path, and then we don’t make mistakes of applying labels such as third level bodhisattvas, or thinking the guy who’s put in the advertisement must be some incredible being.
The more we know the qualities of the Dharma we protect ourselves from all this phoniness that is existing in this world, all the confusion, the false teachings, the false teachers and so on. Then the next point of training is to take refuge three times in the day and three times at night. So this means at least to go through the prayer, say some prayers such as the prayer we say in the Sangye Chödang is a very good one, because this comes from the mind of the great bodhisattva AAtisha. So one can say that three times in the morning, three times at night. Also, as part of that, the commitment is to make three prostrations in the morning, three times at night.
Soon as when we get out of bed, especially if one has an altar or an image of the Buddha, even if one doesn’t, one visualizes the Buddha, makes three prostrations. Then at night before going to sleep, one makes three prostrations. There is the practice, I don’t know if Venerable Karen’s mentioned, that you can visualize the Buddha seated on your pillow, you make three prostrations to the Buddha seated on your pillow, then you jump into bed, and you put your head in the lap of the Buddha, and you stretch out with your two legs on top of each other, or you lie on your right side, and in the in the lying posture, which is the posture the Buddha assumed when he passed into paranivana. And so you put your you’re right lie on your right side, which is a very healthy way to go to sleep because you don’t squash your heart and other things. And also it prevents certain disturbing thoughts arising in dreams and so on.
It helps the winds in the body much better if you sleep on your right side, not on your left or on your stomach or on your back. And ideally you sleep like that blocking your right nostril. So this is how the Buddha passed into Paranivana. So at least it’s difficult to maintain that all night, especially if there’s someone in bed with you. If you’re a monk it’s much easier, or a nun.
But at least one can start the evening like that. There are some other practices also one can do as one goes to sleep, but this is something very good that protects the mind and also reminds us. So then when we wake up, we can also wake up imagining the Buddha is there. And then, you know, then we make three prostrations in the morning as well. Basic common point of training is that when eating or drinking, we first offer at least the first mouthful, the first mouthful of food, the first mouthful of drink to the triple gem, so that one can do that just very quickly in one’s mind, or one can do some rituals such as ombre, transforming it into nectar and saying the prayer at meal times, this is incredibly good to do, but at least in some sense offering the food to the triple gem and drink.
Also doing the prayer, therefore one can do it mindfully rather than just take the food and start eating as you’re walking to the table and eating walk, standing up, one sits down and eats and just thinks a little bit about it. So one can eat mindfully to cut attachment. Like I said, thinking one can think of all the suffering that went into producing the food, and therefore how can I eat this just for pleasure and the pleasure of just this life? But we try to eat with a thought, to energize the body, to practice the Dharma, so all the suffering that went into that becomes meaningful. All the people who suffered for this food that I’m eating, if I eat it and use that energy to practice the Dharma, all the suffering of those beings has become meaningful.
Somehow I think one can say that one has created some karmic connection with those beings. And then when I get in a Buddha, all of those beings get drawn with me to enlightenment. But to eat a little bit mindfully, especially mindful of the triple gem, is really very helpful and a commitment. The fourth one is to always rely on the triple gem, the Buddhadharma and Sangha. Whenever something goes wrong, what is our refuge?
The Buddhadharma and Sangha, not drugs, not the advice of confused people, and this and that, or hiding from our problems. The idea is we try to seek the solution in the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha, with refuge that the solution does lie in the triple gem. If our Dharma practice isn’t bringing results, it’s not because Dharma doesn’t work, it’s because our practice isn’t working properly, we’re not doing the right things. Our refuge should be the Dharma as much as possible. Try to and therefore by relying on the triple gem, to use our life as much as possible, to listen to teachings and to use time to contemplate them, to read Dharma books, and to study them, to contemplate them, meditate on them, and to practice.
In other words, the basic practice is to subdue our senses, our delusions, and develop a good heart. The fifth common point of training is to encourage others when it’s appropriate, not just all the time, but when it’s appropriate to encourage others to take refuge in the triple gem. Not going around converting people, this is not at all a Buddhist practice. When the Buddha Buddha was enlightened, the Buddha did not say a single teach a single word of the path until he was requested. The four disciples came up and said, how did you get like that?
And then the Buddha started teaching. So this is a fundamental tradition of Buddhism that has been followed from that time that you do not teach the Dharma until someone asks you. When someone asks and then one should also check, is this person asking out of idle curiosity, or they really want to know something? When someone asks out from, you know, from some real wish to really know something, especially from maybe because of suffering and wanting to stop that, find some method, then that is an appropriate time to teach the Dharma in some way, in a way that is suitable to the level of the mind of that person, to say something of the Dharma, it doesn’t have to be using Dharma terms and so on, and with a preface, Now I’m going to teach you the Buddhadharma, but one can just say some wise compassionate things appropriate to the person, and we have the commitment to do that when it’s appropriate. We shouldn’t hold back, It is a commitment to help sentient beings with the dharma when they want the help, when they give signs of wanting that.
And some people may not actually formally ask, but if one knows a person, and there may be some pride or something preventing them, but you know, at least we know as much as we can know, that this person, this friend is showing every indication that they need help, that they may be too proud to ask it, but if they’re indicating the need for help, then one has the obligation to help, to say something wise and compassionate, not the usual samsaric nonsense, but to give some dharma advice, which could also be a little bit heavy, you know, compassion doesn’t necessarily involve patting people on the head, it can sometimes involve, you know, punching them around a bit. If you ever have the good fortune to receive teachings from the Venerable Robina. Okay, and then the sixth point of training is to never give up one’s refuge in the Triple Gem. From our side, we decide the Buddhadharma and Sangha is the refuge, something that we can trust in, so we shouldn’t lose that faith, that trust, but always maintain it, no matter what happens. When one takes refuge in the triple gem and practices in the Dharma, all sorts of terrible things can happen.
This is because of the ripening of our negative karma, because we’re one of the benefits, remember one of the eight benefits of refuge is that all one’s negative karma starts to reduce. How does that happen? Because it ripens a little bit, and if one does a lot of intense virtuous practice, it causes one’s it not only accumulates merit, but it forces some of one’s immediate negative karma to ripen, to purify. It purifies it by forcing it to ripen, to bear fruit quickly but in a small way. So having taken refuge and a whole series of disasters takes place, this is not a sign that the Dharma is evil and the work of the Satan, but it may be a sign that it’s really good and one’s Dharma practice is working if one has the right refuge, the right understanding.
And even if it is not the purification of negative karma, there are the mind training teachings that one can learn to transform that suffering and all problems. So if we have a real refuge, everything in our life, good and bad, can become beneficial. If we use our Dharma understanding as our refuge, If we think properly, one way of thinking brings every kind of suffering, one way of thinking brings every kind of happiness to ourselves and others. So the right refuge is the right way of thinking. Okay, thank you very much for your attention.
If you have some questions Yes? What’s about making people wear red and yellow clothes? Sorry? Wearing yellow clothes. No, that’s fine.
That’s okay. Yeah, sure. Yes. I don’t remember. Sorry, I have a very bad habit now, which I should not have, of not putting down the sources of where I get things.
But it’s from a valid dharma source. It would really take me a long time to find out where I dug that up now. Any idea where I might find the In a book in the land of monastery. Sorry. Yes?
Well, in the sense that Mahāyāna refuge is the highest kind of refuge because it’s the refuge aspiring to achieve enlightenment, to benefit not just oneself but all others. The refuge aspiring to achieve nirvana brings about one’s own benefit but not the full benefit of others. As an arahant in a human body, one can go around teaching loving kindness and compassion and wisdom, so that definitely benefits others, but when the arahant mind separates from the body and goes into this blissful state of nirvana, it stops benefiting, it doesn’t harm others, but it stops benefiting them. Whereas the enlightened mind or even bodhisattvas are continuously benefiting sentient beings, not just themselves. So from that point of view, from a Mahāyāna point of view, the Mahāyāna refuge is the highest one, it’s the most comprehensive.
Yeah, it’s tricky. Like in an apartment, like it’s difficult to burn. The oven? I think actually His Holiness is said these days because things get very very complicated, it’s okay to put even dharma paper in places where it will get recycled as paper, even if it’s mixed with ordinary paper rubbish. That’s one creative solution.
But go to the countryside every month and have a barbecue, a vegetarian barbecue. Burn it somehow. Take it to your local Dharma center. Yeah. Really.
Yeah. As the actual Sangha as Ārya beings. So how do how do you balance that with like, I know we’ve seen in in the Christian tradition recently and even in seen in Buddhism and other countries where it’s been a long time that that where well respected sort of religious leaders become corrupt. But because people have wanted to respect them, they don’t say anything about it. It says they’re So how does Yeah.
Well, yeah. It’s it’s I think that’s it’s very difficult but somehow Yeah. The is about one’s supposed to see ordinary monks and nuns and so on as ārya beings, trying to see them, like to have this pure view, but then many religious teachers in Buddhism and also in other traditions can become very corrupt, some do. So how do you combine that? Should one just ignore their corruption and harm or speak out?
This is very difficult to but at some point, you know, somehow one has to combine having the thought of respecting the the Buddha nature of the person and and and the the ordination they have, and that but at the other hand, maybe it is necessary to, if one really knows that certain things are happening, to bring it to the attention of appropriate authorities. But see, it’s very complicated to point out the faults, of people who are teachers, because this can even if you do it with the best intentions and your information is correct, many people have devotion to that person, and this can cause not only their devotion to the person to collapse, but their devotion to the path and to all teachers. Because the mind, our mind, tends to think, oh this person’s bad, therefore they’re all bad, and therefore the whole thing is bad. So this can be very very dangerous to do. Yeah.
No, he didn’t say that as such, he said it’s good to, if you’re trying to follow the dharma, at least do fifty percent of your daily dharma and fifty worldly things. Yeah. Sure. This is the message. Yes.
So Oh, okay. You had said that fear comes from past inference, Yeah. That’s true, but I think there is like a more fundamental fear that that comes from life to life, from life, past lives. That we’ve always something has always in some life been causing us fear like racist views that have been handed on and this and that, because we’ve had that life after life. So it’s not just in this life.
There may be causes in this life for to develop specific fears, but fear in general is there because of the experiences of so many previous lives. If there wasn’t the potential for fear, fear couldn’t arise in relation to specific things. Well, I I don’t think there’s anything you can specifically define as what the core but there has to be a certain like, for each of us, there has to be, a reasonable amount of the Dharma that we feel confident with. If we only think only one thing in the Dharma is true, then it’s not really much of a base to take refuge in. But if if we feel like there’s like there’s a whole lot there that makes sense, and that opens up our heart and mind, right, then that’s a but there’s some other parts of it which aren’t central to the whole thing.
You don’t have to we don’t have to worry about those, but there’s essential core things to take refuge in. I guess for everybody that would be different than what is Yes, sure, sure. But we need to feel that there’s like a whole, a very substantial amount of stuff there that we can really work with. Yes. Does the Sangha know all the obstructions to Omniscience?
The Ārya Samgha do. No. No. We we don’t. But the Ārya Samgha.
Yeah. I think they they they know what the obscurations are. No, no, no, no. No, I think you have to know you have to one of the aspects of creating karma completely is you have to have an unmistaken recognition of the object. Although it does get tricky.
But in that particular example I think we could be okay. Any questions? Amazing. Yes. Well, if if you know they’re going to freeze to death, you know, that’s killing them.
In this position one is always asked these kind of questions, and this may be a giant cop out, but I don’t think it’s the job of someone presenting the Dharma to give all the answers, the exact answers to every problem in life. I think having heard the Dharma and having some belief in its truth, then from our side and understanding how karma works, then from our side we have to make a decision ourselves what we’re going to do, how we’re going to practice, and and and we have to accept the consequences of our actions. I know the karma, I know what the Buddha taught about karma, I believe it, so if I do this, this will happen, generally speaking, if I do that, generally speaking, this was probably what will happen. And then one makes a decision oneself, right? It’s our choice, yeah?
It’s not like I have to answer every question and say, You must do this. We have to use our own wisdom and recognize our own limitations and so on, and whatever. And what is more important, some temporary comfort, or at the expense of causing some harm, or a little bit of discomfort, but now of making sure we don’t cause create the cause for a lot of discomfort in the future. And this is basically what we have to make the choice moment by moment, and how much we follow our self-cherishing thought that wants the cozy comfort now. That’s that’s the and it’s saṃsāra, samsaric world, samsaric life presents us with these difficult choices all the time.
It’s the first noble truth. Yes? karma is not what? Yes. Right.
Yes. Right. Right. Yes. Yes.
The question is, karma is not something is not a conventional reality that we can see. So the question is, is is karma something that has been decided by the Buddha, or is just a natural law. What I was trying to explain that from Buddhist point of view, the law of cause and effect is a natural universal law, because it’s related to the mind. It’s not something made up by the Buddha. The Buddha presented it because the Buddha had the mind, the unobscured mind, the omniscient mind that sees into the far distant past to see how mind works.
It definitely teachings of the law of cause and effect do require faith, because we can’t see all the subtle aspects of karma. We can have some logical reason for believing it, which always goes back to the point, why is this happening? Is it happening for no reason? Some totally external thing is controlling it? Or it has a cause lying within me.
We always have to go back to that, and if we think about that we can develop some logical reasons for believing in karma, even if we can’t see all the complexity. In the teachings it says even arhats can’t see all the complexity of karma. Only the Buddha mind can see all the subtle ways the mind works and how karma works. But it’s not something made up by the Buddha at all. If mind exists and delusions exist, the Buddha then karma exists.
The delusions are creating these potentials in the mind moment by moment. So the law of cause and effect is trying to explain subtle workings of the mind. It’s a do you call it a skillful means. It may not all be literally true, but it’s a model that we can use, it’s a working model that we can use as as a guide to help us. It’s like, you know, even if I understood it, could I could I teach the which I don’t, but could I teach Einstein’s theory of relativity that we would all immediately understand absolutely straight away?
Who who understands the theory of relativity completely in all its details and can can, you know, talk about it non stop for however long it takes to explain the theory of relativity. And that itself is only a model and that itself that is only a model of trying to hint at what reality is. So the teachings on the law of cause and effect are some kind of working model that the Buddha presented that our mind can work with. Thank you very much. So we can dedicate the merits of this time To be able to, by this merit, may we find in our life a perfect refuge that never betrays us, that we never lose confidence in, and because of this, may we always be able to follow a perfect path to complete enlightenment, quickly achieve that state for the benefit of all living beings.
May the precious bodhi mind not yet born arise and grow. May them born have no decline, but increase forevermore. Then we can, if we wish, make the food offering. Page sixty. Thank you very much.
While I think of it, I’ve I’ve asked Tenzin Sopa to come again tonight. He will talk a little bit about his life as a monk and his relationship with Geshe-la Kancho. The precepts start tomorrow morning, so this afternoon I’ll talk about precepts, what they actually are and the benefits of keeping them and so on. Okay, thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- buddha, a sang gye (Tib)
- A fully awakened being, who has totally eliminated all obscurations veiling the mind and has fully developed all good qualities to perfection. LYWA
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- prostrations chag tsel (Tib)
- The act of showing respect to the objects of refuge, the Guru and the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; the first of the seven-limb practice and one of the preliminary practices. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.