44 min · 4,981 words · 17 November 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teaching presents meditation on impermanence and death as the most powerful antidote to delusions, and explains repeated meditation to make the realisation deep. It outlines eight disadvantages of not thinking about death and eight advantages of thinking about it. It then covers the three-stage lam rim meditation on death, beginning with the certainty of death, and ends with a short question and answer exchange on dependent arising and rebirth.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-11-17
Duration: 45 min
UUID: e286e69f-8656-4dbf-b70b-f08af4a27be9
Words: 4,981
So we have to know the antidotes. And if we’ve realized the antidotes, that destroys our delusions. And if we’ve realized the antidotes, then we can help others destroy their delusions. So it is really the whole path. So the easiest antidote to all of the delusions, except ignorance, but to the other ones which bother us moment by moment is the realisation of impermanence and death, not just the intellectual understanding, that doesn’t have much power.
We can tell ourselves I’m going to die until the cows come home but it doesn’t stop our delusions. We can tell ourselves, Oh, this beautiful thing is impermanent, but it doesn’t have much power. The words themselves do have some power. Having heard these teachings and believing them, just that intellectual understanding does have some power but not very much. Because the trouble is, our delusions have a lot of power.
Our delusions have a lot of power, so to squash them, not repress them, just I mean to get rid of them, we have to have an antidote. We have to have an antidote that has a lot of power. Just saying the word death is not good enough, oh I’m going to die is not good enough. But if we have the realisation of the meaning of those words and then we remind ourselves, I’m going to die, I could die outright now, then that can have power to cut any of our disturbing thoughts. If we have some realisation of impermanence that can cut our attachment to people and things and reputation and all the worldly concerns.
It can cut it. So that’s why we have to meditate again and again and again until the realisation comes. Or at least making a deeper and deeper understanding, a deeper and deeper imprint in our mind. Like I always give this kind of analogy that or anyway it’s like this. Here is a nail, here’s a piece of wood, then you put it there and you hit it.
The first time you hit it, because you don’t know how to hit a nail into a piece of wood, it flies off. The second time, flies off. Third time, it bends. Fourth time, get another nail and sticks in a little bit, it’s totally wobbly. But then you hit it again, and then you hit it again, and you hit it again, and you hit it again, again, again, again, again, then it won’t come out.
It’s embedded, totally embedded. So this is a little bit like practising analytical meditation. First time the object of the meditation flies out of your mind, second time out of the mind, third time, fourth time it goes in but it bends, you know, it’s all wobbly and useless. But then you could get it stuck, it’s in the mind a little bit but totally wobbly, know, it’s just there by the skin of its teeth. But then you get it and you hit it again and again and again and again and then it’s stuck in your mind.
Yeah, and you can’t get it out. And then you realize it’s in your mind. It’s not up here, but it’s in the depths of the mind. This is what we’re trying to do with analytical meditation. Like, so each time we do it, it’s helping to go deeper in the mind and to refresh it because it’s impermanent.
We refresh it and drive it deeper. Refresh deeper. Even when the realization has gone deep in the mind, still until we are at a very high level, if we don’t keep renewing that, it fades away. So it’s important to meditate on impermanence and death at the beginning of the path, in the middle and at the very end because it will keep us going. If we think about death now, our own death, not death in abstract, but if we think about our own death now and that it could happen at any moment, then when it actually does, which it will, it won’t be a surprise, it won’t be a shock, it won’t be fearful.
And can die well and have a good rebirth. But if we live our life ignoring our death, never thinking about it, having fear of that, having fear of death and thinking about it, when it actually happens, which it will, it will come as a huge shock, Our mind will be very disturbed, there will be a lot of fear, a great chance that we will not die well and therefore a great chance that our next rebirth will not be as good as this one. That’s why I’ll try again. Plato said, If you want to live well, practice dying. So I’ll just go briefly through because this course is running quickly out, it’s because this course is impermanent, depending on cause and conditions it’s coming to an end very quickly.
It’s almost finished without having started. So just briefly, traditionally there are said to be eight benefits of thinking about our own death. So these are the the first is that we won’t waste our time in worldly concerns. One of the Kadampa Geshe said that if we wake up in the morning and don’t think of death, our whole morning is wasted in following the worldly concerns. If we don’t think of death in the afternoon, the whole afternoon is wasted in worldly concerns and if we don’t think about death in the night time, the whole night is wasted in worldly concerns.
So, we yeah. So, are the disadvantages, right? The eight disadvantages and then there are the eight advantages of thinking about death. So the second disadvantage is that even if we are practising some kind of concern for Dharma, we are actually engaged in Dharma practice, if we don’t think about our own death, much of our so called Dharma life will be procrastination. In other words, always putting off our Dharma practice.
Particular, putting off the difficult parts, the main practices, to later on because there’s so much time. Each day because of being controlled by the worldly concerns, we always do the worldly concerns first and we leave our Dharma practice till last. And then we are too tired to do it, so it doesn’t happen at all. This is because when we follow the worldly mind, always the worldly concerns are more important. Our Dharma practice is the least important thing.
And even if we don’t do that, a disadvantage of not thinking about our own death is that our practice is impure, it remains impure, still mixed with the eight worldly concerns of things like reputation and so on. Especially this can work when we actually do gain some Dharma experience but worldly concerns, because we haven’t really thought deeply about impermanence and death, can get attached to our spiritual experiences and develop pride and so on. So our practice becomes impure. If we don’t think about death, even if our practice is relatively pure, it won’t have much strength. We will tend to give up at the slightest difficulty.
And if we don’t think about death and especially that death could happen at any time, even if we are practising reasonably well and keep going, then still we will continue to create negative karma. Possibly the worst fault disadvantage of not thinking about death throughout our life is that we die in a state of regret. Because of not having thought of death, we keep following the worldly concerns and then we’ve wasted our life. And then at the time of death, we are aware of that. Because death is, you know At the time of death, we recall all the things that we’ve done in our life, all the negative things appear to our mind and can cause great torment and regret and fear.
And so in that state, it’s difficult to have a good rebirth. And of course, by not having thought about death, not having and therefore followed the worldly concerns and therefore reinforced one’s attachment at the time of death, one would die with a great deal of attachment in the mind. Difficult let go of the things of this life, especially the thing that we are most attached to which is our body. And we haven’t prepared ourselves at all. And because there’s also a lot of attachment, there will be a lot of aversion.
Why should I die? Everyone else is alive. I am dying. This shouldn’t happen. Many people can get incredibly angry at the time of death because I shouldn’t be dying.
Everyone else is alive and I’m dying. This is not right. Which also comes from this misunderstanding that not everyone dies. It’s completely natural, normal. But the mind that has no understanding of impermanence thinks death is something unnatural and bad and evil and it shouldn’t happen.
But it’s totally natural. So these are some of the disadvantages of not thinking about death while we’re alive. And then there are the advantages of thinking about death: That it makes our life purposeful, we start giving up the worldly concerns and we engage in making our life meaningful in doing Dharma practice. And, as I mentioned, one of the great benefits of thinking about death is that it is a very powerful opponent to all the delusions in the mind. There is the famous Sufi story of the king who asked all his wise ministers.
In the good old days, kings or heads of state always had wise ministers, it doesn’t seem to be the case these days. The kings always ask their wise men, they’re always surrounded by all these wise men. So this king asked his wise men that he wanted some secret formula or some special thing that could make him happy when he was sad and when he was too excited, too happy, too agitated by happiness and distracted. He wanted something that would calm him down, bring his mind down to more stable state. He wanted one thing that would do both, would make him happy when he was sad and calm him down when he was too excited.
His wise men went off to think and they kind of went into a panic because they couldn’t think of anything that could do these two opposite things. But then some other person came along, a sort of junior wise man or woman came along and gave the king a ring. Inscribed inside the ring was the statement, This too shall pass away. This too shall pass away. All your suffering will pass away.
All your happiness will pass away. It all passes away. It’s all impermanent. So why be attached? Attached?
Why have aversion? Why have any pride, jealousy, fear, worry, anxiety? Because it all passes away. That doesn’t sound like it works because that’s only words. But if we meditate on the words and gain the experience of the meaning of the words, has great power to free our mind.
We should experiment, check up. Third advantage is that meditation on death is important at the beginning of our practice because it inspires us to enter the practice, to start the training, training our mind. It’s important in the middle because it inspires us to continue and it’s important at the very end because it inspires us to keep going and to complete the practice. And then it’s beneficial, great advantage, one of the major advantages of always thinking about our own death and that it could happen at any moment is that because we keep this mindfulness of our own death alive in our mind, then when death actually occurs, it won’t be a surprise because we’ve always been telling us, you know, I could die today. It’s almost sure I’m going to die today.
So then one day, one starts dying. So it’s not a surprise at all, it’s not a shock. And one also has learnt what the death process is, we can learn what actually happens during the death process. So there’s less fear because we know what’s going on and there’s no regret because having thought about death every day, we’ve reduced our eight worldly concerns and have been able to practice the Dharma and practiced it freer and freer of the worldly concerns. So we know we’ve done virtuous, meaningful things, so we can die with a happy mind.
Or at least a mind free of fear and therefore have a good rebirth. Not only because we’ve died peacefully, but we’ve put all these incredibly powerful, virtuous, positive imprints in our mind that will bring a good rebirth. So this is why in following the spiritual life, whether we’re following the Buddhist path or the Christian path, the Jewish path, the path of Islam or whatever, the Hindu path, we need to think about impermanence and death. So it’s important to contemplate the disadvantages. If one has a lot of fear and aversion to thinking about death, impermanence in death, especially one’s own death, then it’s very good.
This is why these disadvantages and advantages are taught first. So the idea is to meditate on those, just those. If one doesn’t want to meditate on death yet because it looks too scary and depressing, then just meditate on the disadvantages and the advantages. And by doing that, one will see, by doing it again, becoming familiar with the disadvantages of not allowing the mind to think about it and seeing so many advantages, if we are wise, we’ll come to the conclusion, I should think about death. I really should, for my own protection, I should think about my death.
And then having generated that mind, we will start doing so. And then there is the meditation that we can learn. Then there is the traditional meditation itself that comes in the lam rim of how to meditate on death. So it has three stages and each stage has three points to contemplate. And one can in one meditation session, one can go through all three stages and each point in each stage, or one can try to spend in one meditation session just meditating on the first part and keep doing that meditation day by day until one gets some deeper awareness of that.
Then one can move on to the second stage and then on to the third stage. Or another way of doing it is you can spend most of the meditation on the first stage and just a little bit on the other two so you remember what they are, make some imprint, but keep going on the first part until we get some deep experience of it. Then one moves on mainly up to the second part, does a little bit of the first part to refresh, to do a little bit of the third part just to acquaint oneself with it. Then when one gets a deep experience of the second part, one can concentrate on meditating on the third part. I don’t know if that made sense.
Anyway, explain again later on. But one can do this kind of thing with all the different meditations because each meditation of the Lam Rim has different sections. So in one meditation session, one can go through the whole the whole thing. But, and that’s helpful, especially at the beginning, to go through the whole thing to get some idea of the totality of of what one’s trying to do. Then in actually trying to really get the realization or some experience, one works on the first part and just a little bit on the other part.
And then when the first part dawns in the mind, then one just has to do like a little refreshing meditation on that and work mainly on the second part until that becomes stronger in the mind. Then move to the next part like that. So the first part of the meditation on death is to realize its purpose is to make us realize that we are definitely going to die, that our death is certain. As I said, we all know this, but we haven’t realized it. So the way to realize it more and more is to contemplate this point.
And the way we can contemplate it is to think that firstly, that as we are as ordinary human beings now, we have no power to remain on this earth. Or to put it another way, we have no power for our that we can use to keep our mind in this body. Once and because of that, the mind leaves this body and death occurs. When mind irrevocably separates from this body, death occurs. So we have no power, no ability to keep this mind, this formless ongoing process of knowing, experiencing, feeling.
We cannot keep that in this body, connected with this body, because this body is decaying moment by moment. So death has to happen. Actually, although this isn’t, I for some reason, mentioned in the traditional meditation, and I don’t understand why, because it’s the most powerful argument. But the more we meditate on what I tried to explain yesterday afternoon and this morning, that everything that depends on causes and conditions decays moment by moment and therefore dies. And since we have a body that has been created dependent on causes and conditions, it is therefore impermanent, and therefore has to age and die.
This actually this itself one doesn’t need any other argument, and it’s actually never presented by Lama Tsongkhapa in the traditional meditation. I don’t know why. Well, maybe put it this way. Thanks. Yeah.
So but this for me is the most powerful thing to meditate on. Just that point. Just that point really works. That our body depends on causes and conditions. It is aging.
It’s changing, so we’re going to die. And we have no power to change that process. Nothing. No matter what we eat, no matter what exercise we do, no matter what doctor we have, it’s going to change that. This decaying process is irreversible.
I think when one is about eighteen or nineteen, I heard according to a friend of mine who used to be a fashion model, that the first fine wrinkles start appearing in your eyes. So then you’re kind of finished as a fashion model, or you have to start getting some plastic surgery or do something. But it happens when you’re about nineteen. Why do the wrinkles happen? It’s a sign of change, decay.
Yeah. Have you ever had sorry. Have you ever had a toothache? No. Have you ever had any tooth decay?
That proves you’re gonna die. Just one toothache proves you’re going to die. One gray hair proves you’re gonna die. Just one. It’s proof.
Yeah? Complete proof that we’re going to die. Ever had a hair fall out? It’s proof that we’re gonna die. Notice that your nails grow long.
It’s proof we’re gonna die. If you bash yourself, you get a bruise. It’s proof we’re gonna die. It’s proof. Decay depending on causes and conditions.
So there’s no power to change that. We have no power to stay in this body because this body is falling apart moment by moment. So death has to occur. Sooner or later, we are definitely going to die. The aging process started in the second moment.
Aging is occurring moment by moment. Aging turns into old aging, and old aging turns into death. So in the traditional presentation, they say that we have to die because if we look at everybody, every being who has taken a body has died. Sooner or later, they die. They leave that body.
Death happens. If we think of all the human beings who have been on this planet, if we look at ancient civilizations, these powerful civilizations that produced such amazing things, there’s nobody left from those civilizations. Not one person left walking on the earth who built the pyramids. So there were huge cities on this earth. Those those cultures, the cities of those cultures, those those cities were produced by particular cultures, those cultures have completely come to an end, and all the beings that generated those cultures and built those cities that looked so permanent.
The people who lived in those cities felt they were permanent, and that society, that culture, civilization would go on forever. That all completely disappeared. Completely disappeared. And these these cities, these cultures that we exist in will one day totally disappear. One day, there’ll be bits and pieces of this culture in the museum.
My glasses, but I doubt it won’t last that long, might be an exhibit in a museum somewhere. This will be preserved in a museum. Plastic water bottle, circa two thousand and one. Yeah. Very rare, incredibly beautiful.
Yeah. A priceless creation of of twentieth century society. Yeah. So everyone who’s born, no matter how rich they are, they die. No matter how powerful, they die.
No matter how intelligent, they die. Even even if you are highly realized, you die. The Buddha died. Christ died. Muhammad died.
All the famous saints died. So we have to think, I have I have a body like theirs, or is my body different? Why am I not going to die? If all these beings died and are dying all around me, why do I think I’m not going to die? What is there about my body, my situation that means I’m not going to die?
Can we find any valid reason for thinking as we do that we’re not gonna die? Is my body stronger? Can we really why why do we believe we’re not going to die? What is the argument that we have? What is the argument?
Check out. What argument do I give myself to convince myself I’m not going to die even though death happens to people around me every day? So this is the first point to think about, and one can give many examples to illustrate that to oneself. Think of more examples. To try to come to the point of this understanding that definitely I’m going to die.
But especially it seems the best argument is simply if we’ve understood something about impermanence. The conditioned things come to an end simply because they have no power from their own side to remain the same for one moment. They are overpowered, are impermanent, changing moment by moment, simply because of being created. This body is created, it’s aging and will die. This at first is depressing.
Again, this may be misunderstood. I will try to explain it may be misunderstood as a criticism that is not meant like that at all. But what mind finds all of this depressing and wants to reject it? It is our self-cherishing thought. Our mind obsessed with me, wanting to believe I am permanent, will go on like this forever.
This is a very self-cherishing thought that our self grasping creates this wrong view of self, part of which is that it’s permanent, and then our self obsession dances around that, praising me, making me real. And it is that very process, that inter network of confused thoughts that doesn’t want to hear this and gets depressed by it, rejects it. But if we listen with another mind, our mind of wisdom and our own self genuine love and affection and compassion for ourselves, if we listen with that mind, it’s not depressing. It’s liberating. If you have any questions?
Yes. So if you’re thinking about a certain way of dying, yeah, then? The question was if you think by thinking about your future, can you create that future? I think it’s very difficult to give a very definite answer to that, but I think in some ways by thinking in certain ways, in certain directions, like in generating that fear and so on, you can create the conditions for certain negative karmas that you have to ripen so that you experience that result. But in the same way, directing your mind in a very positive direction, you can create the condition for some positive karmas to ripen that help bring that result along.
I mean, I think it can be possible to some extent but not necessarily. It’s certainly by having either these dwelling on certain positive types of thoughts or negative thoughts, it’s acting as a condition, it’s starting to create the conditions for that to happen. Well, our self obsession, our self-cherishing is what is labeled on our attachment, all our different desires, all our different attachments, which are thoughts, right? And our anger, our aversion, our fears, these are all thoughts, our anxieties, our pride, our jealousy, all these things bounce off each other and create this incredible network of thoughts and appearances and so on, perceptions and projections, work to maintain this illusion of the truly existing self, which is permanent, which we believe to be permanent. These two things feed off each other.
We have this self grasping, the wrong view of the self, and we have the self grasping and then we have the self-cherishing. And these two things feed off each other. Because of the self grasping, we have self-cherishing, self obsession, and that self-cherishing perpetuates our self grasping. So the self-cherishing self grasping gives rise to more self-cherishing which perpetuates the self grasping. So they feed each other.
Things which depend on other things which are not themselves Always in the nature of intelligence? Yes, yes. I have to check that one, so I’m not sure. It’s dependent. So does it depend on things other than itself?
I’m not sure about Buddhahood, have to check that one. But by other powers Space is impermanent, but it’s dependent. Does it depend on things other than itself? It depends on directions. It depends on the mind labelling, you see?
Yes, yes, it depends on direction. It depends on things other than itself. So it’s not necessarily impermanent. But if it depends on causes and conditions, it’s impermanent. Yes, it’s not a conditioned phenomenon.
But it’s a dependent phenomenon. Because it’s not a conditioned phenomenon, it doesn’t depend on causes and conditions. It is a permanent phenomenon, but it’s still a dependent phenomenon. It depends on directional parts and also temporal parts. Present space depends on previous moment of space and it also depends on the labelling mind.
Of things that exist, there are permanent phenomena and impermanent phenomena. Both permanent phenomena and impermanent phenomena are dependent all things that exist exist by being dependent arisings. Impermanent phenomena, which is the vast majority of all phenomena, are dependent arising because of three things: causes and conditions, parts and the labelling mind. Permanent phenomena are dependent arisings but they don’t depend on causes and conditions but they depend on parts and the labelling mind. So all phenomena are dependent arising but only impermanent phenomena depend on causes and conditions.
They also depend on parts and the labelling mind, but only impermanent phenomena require causes and conditions. Yes. Yes, that’s true, yes. And also related to that, there are some people who go to reincarnation or regression therapy. Yes.
And then they go back into their previous incarnation. Yes. They’re all human. Yes. They are human, but they are not necessarily precious human rebirths.
In fact, the descriptions I’ve read of people doing that, they are not precious human rebirths at all. They are human rebirths. So is there always a step prior to a precious human rebirth? To be human? Not necessarily, but the causes to have a precious human rebirth, generally you need to be a human being to create those causes.
But the result may not be experienced until much later. It’s very complicated, but it probably happens that once you enter the human realm, you stay in the human realm for some time. That energy keeps going. Just like once you fall in the lower realm, you’re you’re really stuck in the lower realm. But once you’re a human being, there may be some chance that there’s the condition to be reborn human in the again and again for some time for some time.
But so in those run of human rebirth, that’s where it is easiest to create the causes, be a human to have a precious human rebirth. But it’s not easy to have a run of precious human rebirth. Oh, yes. Sure. Yeah.
One of the people reason people regress who are regressed, remember human rebirth, is because with this mind, it’s very difficult to actually experience the memories of of of nonhuman state. But if you read the studies of what’s his name? Robertson. Stevenson, doctor Stevenson, his his twenties cases suggestive of reincarnation. I’m not sure if it’s in that book or one of his other books.
At least one of the people he studied who could recall their immediate past rebirth, they also could recall a rebirth as a bird. First, there was like, in their immediate lives, they they were in in this life, just before this life, they were a bird, and before that, they were a human being. Oh, okay. If I can find it again. This actually is in Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s wish fulfilling golden sun.
Rinpoche quotes it there, But it’s from one of the sutras where Buddha says, This vessel-like world, which existed at an earlier moment, does not do so at a later one. That it seems to continue in the same way is because something else similar arises like the stream of a waterfall. They can be stopped. They can be what? Take refuge in your Buddha nature.
Like, I said, I said
Key terms in this teaching
- analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
- Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
If you think about your future, can the thinking itself create that future?
It is difficult to give a definite answer. In some ways, thinking in certain directions, such as generating fear, can create the conditions for negative karmas you already have to ripen, so that you experience the result. In the same way, directing the mind in a very positive direction can create the conditions for positive karmas to ripen and help bring that result along. So it is possible to some extent, but not necessarily. Dwelling on positive or negative thoughts acts as a condition, and starts to create the conditions for that outcome to happen.
Is being born human always a step before attaining a precious human rebirth?
Not necessarily, but generally you need to be a human being to create the causes for a precious human rebirth. The result may not be experienced until much later. It is complicated, but once you enter the human realm you probably stay in it for some time, as that energy keeps going. Just as once you fall into a lower realm you are really stuck there, once you are human there may be a chance of being reborn human again and again for a while. In such a run of human rebirths it is easiest to create the causes, but it is not easy to have a run of precious human rebirths. It is also difficult for this mind to recall memories of non-human states.