Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 10 Tape 14 Side 2

44 min · 5,102 words · 10 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 10 Tape 14 Side 2
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk moves from renunciation of samsara to bodhicitta, based on the idea that all sentient beings have been our mothers and have shown us kindness. It contrasts self-obsession with genuine self-love and uses the image of the samsaric supermarket versus the garden of the mind to show that lasting happiness comes from inner cultivation. It closes with a question and answer session on karma, including abortion and euthanasia, followed by a dedication.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-10

Duration: 45 min

UUID: 1f86ca81-cc61-4490-b34e-186e17ba5423

Words: 5,102

First one has to develop this basic renunciation, and it’s only when we’ve really got that, that we can develop this second level of renunciation wishing to escape, to get out of saṃsāra altogether, completely. No more of this up and down yo yo experience. Having developed that motivation, and one is furiously working to develop this wisdom that will destroy ignorance, if we’re lucky and we work on it, and we are lucky because we have met the Mahāyāna teachings, then we can while we’re working on our own self liberation, developing this wisdom that will liberate us, we can also, with part of our mind, start to think, Well, actually, just as I’m suffering and I don’t want it, I really don’t want any of this suffering, actually, all sentient beings are the same. All these sentient beings around me don’t want suffering, and most of them have far more suffering than myself, and most of them, most of the time, are trapped in a situation where they can’t do anything about their suffering, but I can. My suffering is less, and I have much more ability, not because I’m superior, better, but because I have the method, I’ve found the method and all the conditions to practice the method.

So I am so much better off and I could help these beings, I could help them overcome their suffering. Especially, we can begin to understand by studying the Mahāyāna teachings and thinking about the nature of mind, that because of mind and the continuity of mind and having taken infinite previous rebirths, during most of the time, in most of those rebirths, we were in a body, in a physical body. In the higher god realms, you don’t have a body, so you don’t need parents. But as a human, as an animal, in the preta realms, in some of the lower god realms, you need a body, so you need parents to provide them. So, we haven’t had just the parents of this life.

We’ve had infinite numbers of mothers, infinite numbers of fathers, infinite numbers of brothers, sisters, best friends, best teachers, best helpers. The Buddha taught that every sentient being has been our mother. Every sentient being has been our mother, literally. And not just one every sentient being has been our mother, not just one time, but infinite numbers of times. Every sentient being has been our father infinite numbers of times.

Every sentient being has been our brother, sister, uncle, auntie, grandmother, grandfather, best friend, best teacher countless times. We are just one family, just one family. So if we start to identify with that family, we want to help. They have been so kind to me, life after life. Every being, because of infinite time, infinite rebirths, every sentient being, even when they weren’t our mother, weren’t our father, weren’t our brother, sister, best friend, teacher, every sentient being has shown us every possible kindness again and again.

If you look around, you see someone being kind to someone, we’ve experienced that kindness from someone, from everyone, many This is what the Buddha taught. This is the basis for generating Bodhicitta, the third scope, the first third level of motivation that I I can’t just work for my own liberation because all these beings are suffering, and these beings have been unbelievably kind to me again and again. They are mother sentient beings, So I have to help them. I’m obliged to help them. I’m responsible for helping them because they’ve been kind to me.

I can’t ignore that kindness. So, by thinking along these lines, we can generate the third level of spiritual motivation, which is the bodhicitta thought, that I must achieve enlightenment to repay the kindness of all mother sentient beings. This is the very highest spiritual aspiration possible. There is no higher, more virtuous, amazing state of mind than to feel all sentient beings are one’s mother, and one will do absolutely everything virtuous. Not everything non virtuous, but absolutely everything virtuous in order to achieve the state of enlightenment only, only for the sake of all sentient beings.

So, this thought, the bodhicitta thought, this spiritual motivation is unique to the Mahāyāna tradition. It is the thought to benefit every living being, not just the nice ones, or even the neutral ones, not the rich ones, the good looking ones, the sexy ones, and this and that, but also the evil ones, the terrible ones, especially those beings, especially the bodhicitta thought wants to place in the highest happiness the most terrible people in the universe. They deserve it most, because especially if those beings were happy, they wouldn’t harm anyone, and then everyone else would be so much happier if certain unnamed people in the world right now I didn’t name you don’t know about who I’m here. I wasn’t referring to the president of some country, not him, but some other very unhappy people were right now placed in the highest happiness, the whole world would change right now because they wouldn’t harm, they wouldn’t want revenge, they wouldn’t terrorize anybody if they were really, really happy. But these people are really, really unhappy.

They are objects of compassion. But this motivation, this incredible Bodhicitta motivation, cannot be generated without first generating the renunciation of saṃsāra, and the renunciation of saṃsāra cannot be generated without first generating this renunciation of our obsession with the things of this life. This is where the spiritual path starts. That is the very beginning of the spiritual path, able to recognize that what we are doing in this life is not satisfying. It is frustrating.

There isn’t any happiness out there. There’s lots of shiny, glittery things and beautiful people with beautiful bodies that can do all sorts of things with their beautiful bodies that we would like to do with them, but it doesn’t last. It doesn’t last. It just doesn’t last. This is not Buddhist depressing Buddhist philosophy.

It is reality. It’s reality. And that reality can’t be changed. It just doesn’t last. The sooner we realize that, the sooner we can free ourselves from its limits and find something better, because there is something better, much better.

It’s in our mind. It’s always there. It won’t go away. It can’t be destroyed. Everything out there can be destroyed sooner or later.

So it’s our choice whether we use our wisdom or not to see these things. But that is the beginning of the spiritual life, seeing that, allowing ourselves to see that to some extent. As a little child, we have an ice cream. Some other little child comes along with a bigger ice cream. We want that one.

We renounce this one because we know that is more happiness. It’s the same process, basically. We look, investigate, and discover no matter what Hollywood movies, and if you’re an Australian, the Women’s Weekly says, there’s no this little ice cream isn’t very satisfying, and it melts and dribbles, and you lose it. You can’t keep it, but you can lick it enough to If you lick it after a while, it’s gone. You can’t get it back, but there’s something a little bit better.

As soon as our mind sees there’s something better, we want it. Why? Because instinctively, we are seeking happiness. As soon as we are able to recognize something that is more happiness, we want it. At the moment, our mind is seeking happiness, but what it identifies with happiness isn’t real happiness, it’s just the illusion of happiness.

But that’s why we go after it and chase it, because it looks like happiness. It looks like happiness, so we seek it. But if we use our wisdom, we can begin to discover that it’s not really happiness. It’s not what’s satisfying. It’s not what we really want.

And we can then use our wisdom to see, Oh, over here, there is something more satisfying. So we go after it. It all depends on using our mind, our wisdom, and how much love, real love, and compassion we have for ourselves. Following our attachment to the things of this life is not being kind to ourselves. Someone who is drowning in self obsession, chasing after the pleasures of this life, you could think that this person really loves themselves.

You know, they’ve got these incredible clothes, they’ve spent all this money on all these clothes, and they’ve got the coolest hairdo you can imagine, and they’ve got the very latest car, and they’re out with the latest the coolest people all night long having a wild time. These people really are taking care of themselves. Really, they really you know, this is they really love themselves. From a dharma point of view, this may be not quite true. This is what we call self obsession, self-cherishing, which is not loving kindness to oneself, because these things aren’t bringing happiness.

If we really loved ourselves, which we should do, we should love ourselves, this is not antithetical to the Buddhist path. It’s essential to the Buddhist path to really love ourselves deeply, really deeply, deeply care about ourselves. If we really did that, we would find out what real happiness is and bring that into our life. Loving ourselves, developing real love for ourselves is the beginning of the spiritual path, and that involves giving up self obsessions, self-cherishing, following desire attachment. Following desire attachment is not the path of loving kindness, It’s just the path of self obsession.

This I mean, I’m saying this, we need to check ourselves whether it’s true or not. So in reality, renunciation sounds like something terrible. I don’t want it. It’s heavy, difficult. But in reality, what renunciation is as a day by day thing to do, it is developing loving kindness for ourselves, genuine loving kindness for ourselves, by giving up our obsession with these external things and not forcing ourselves to give them up, but giving them up step by step as we experience, not intellectually know, but as we experience and allow ourselves to experience that this is not what I really want.

It’s not really satisfying. And it has all sorts of other complicated things around it. To experience it, I have to maybe harm others in some way. I get agitated, annoyed, irritated, angry. Yeah.

To get the seat on the bus, to be comfortable, I have to push everyone else away so I can have the seat on the bus. So I can have the best apple, you know, I leave all the rotten ones to other people To get ahead in my job, what do I do? I harm others. I lie, manipulate, promote myself to the boss at the expense of other people, So I get my little happiness of my promotion and more money, but how did I get it? Is this what I really want?

Really? Do I really want these things and at such expense? Especially if we think that the harm I’ve done to get here to some point has created these negative imprints in my mind that aren’t going to go away. And all the time, these amazing experiences we could have in our mind. The Buddhadharma says, and many other most other great religions of the world say, the external world is just an illusion or like an illusion.

There’s nothing there that we really want or need. And yet, and and and from a from a Buddhist point of view, we we are told, the Buddha tells us that everything that we’ve ever wanted, the happiness that we seek in other people, wealth, power and something, we seek those things because we think they’re happiness, but that real happiness is inside, and it’s there all the time. So, the Buddhadharma says, The external world is a disaster, it’s suffering, inside is joy. That’s what the Buddha said. But then, when we look now at the external world, it doesn’t look like suffering, it looks fantastic.

It looks just absolutely terrific. There’s all this shiny stuff out there directly in front of us, graspable and attainable, beautiful, glimmering, shining, brand new, right there. And then the Buddha says, Oh, this amazing mind, this wonderful, blissful, joyful, compassionate mind inside, and we look inside and we just see disaster, darkness, confusion, agitation. We can’t even keep our mind on the breath for five seconds, and this is what the Buddha says, is the source of happiness? Excuse me, something’s wrong here.

So, sorry, I’m going to go into this little mushy analogy that I’ve developed. Some others have also developed it, but Lama Yeshe used to call the external world the Samsarik supermarket. There is this amazing Samsarik supermarket out there, all glittering and shining and easy to get. It’s all arranged in rows, you get your trolley, you just throw everything in and pay at the end, quite easy. And then there’s the mind.

There is the garden of the mind, yeah? And when we look in the garden of our mind, all we discover is this horrible plot full of weeds, yeah? Rank, thorny, poisonous weeds. I’m sorry, I’m just giving a little exaggeration, you know, to make the point. You have to exaggerate to make the point.

Of course, none of us are that bad like that all the time, but we have to make the point. So, we look in the garden of our mind, and there’s just these rank, poisonous, thorny weeds. We can’t find any fruit, vegetables, flowers, anything nice, so what do we do? We go to the supermarket because it’s all there, shiny, gleaming, easy to get. It’s even in tins or Fantastic, so easy.

So we go shopping in the supermarket, and of course to go shopping in the supermarket, you have to have some money, so you have to work, and all this time goes into working, getting a car to go to the supermarket, getting the credit card, all these things, but still there’s all this gleaming lovely stuff. But the point is, and that is our situation now, the mind always going out to the samsaric supermarket. Even though we’ve got this plot of land, we’ve got the garden of our mind, we go out to the supermarket. But imagine, imagine if instead of shopping all day long or shopping much of the time, we spent a little bit of time gardening, pulling out some of the weeds. Instead of all the energy going into working in external things, shopping, etcetera, we put it into pulling out some of the weeds.

So then we have a little bit of clear stuff in the garden of our mind, and we work on that, we cultivate it. And because there are already these seeds in our mind, these positive potentials in our mind, by the very nature of our mind, these seeds, which couldn’t grow with all the weeds there, start coming up. So amazingly, we start to get a little a few vegetables, a bit of fruit, some nice flowers, beans, bean sprouts, whatever. And so because we have something there to nourish us, we don’t have to go to the Samsarik supermarket so often and get so much. And because we don’t have to go to the Samsaric supermarket so often, there is more time to work on the garden again.

So we pull out more weeds, more space, more fruit and vegetables, and we also have time to cultivate the fruit and vegetables and flowers and everything as well. And so, they get better and better, bigger and bigger, tastier and tastier, juicier and juicier. They’re completely organic, much more nourishing. And then we start to contrast, this tomato out there tastes disgusting and doesn’t even taste anything, and it’s got all this poison in it anyway that goes with it. And there’s this nice, juicy apple created in our mind, organic, totally nourishing.

So we don’t buy so much out there anymore, we don’t spend so much time out there because we don’t want to. We haven’t imposed some horrible discipline on ourselves. Don’t go out there. We just don’t want to because it’s not satisfying because there’s something free and satisfying inside. I’ve just got to finish the analogy, right?

So it’s like that. This is the spiritual life. We have to keep making, balancing and understanding the difference that although there is this appearance of this amazing samsaric supermarket, what it really is is not what it really appears to be, and it’s not satisfying, and it’s very, very karmically expensive. Whereas the garden of our mind is free and it’s really satisfying. Yeah.

And there’s no karmic debt in generating the garden of our mind properly. And as I said with the analogies, nothing never really completely works with the mind, physical analogies with the mind, because in the case of the garden of the mind, like with an ordinary garden, you can cultivate it and cultivate it, but weeds still come. You always have to pull out the weeds. But with the garden of the mind, one reaches a point when there are no weeds to pull out. There’s simply no more weeds.

With the analogy of an ordinary garden, you always have to cultivate the fruit, you always have to plant new seeds, and cultivate and cultivate and cultivate, but with the garden of the mind, you don’t have to plant seeds because the seeds are naturally in the mind. All the positive potentials are in the mind already because of the very nature of the mind, and if we cultivate them, they grow, And one has to put energy into cultivating them, but at one point, one reaches a point where one doesn’t have to cultivate, one doesn’t have to put energy into cultivating the mind anymore. The fruit is achieved, and it’s self perpetuating. The fruit of enlightenment is experienced. Think about it.

It’s worth investigating. Śāntideva, great Indian bodhisattva, said something to the effect that, The work of this life, worldly work, is endless. It goes on and on. There’s always something to do in saṃsāra. In our life, we can fill our life with endless things, and the work never comes to an end, and it never brings satisfaction.

The work of saṃsāra is endless, but the work of the spiritual life has an end, and the end is totally satisfying. Think about it. If that is true, what wise to do? To follow the samsaric mind, which is endless, endless striving and no real lasting result, or to follow the spiritual life, which comes to an end, and when it ends, ends in this perfect lasting happiness. Do you have some questions?

Maybe just for somebody who hasn’t asked a question first. Yes? Look for a discussion group, but it kind of sets back to karma a bit, but does the law karma permit free will to exist? Does the law of karma permit free will to exist? We have to we should try to analyze what does free will mean.

What does free will mean? It sounds like free will means I don’t know if technically it does, but to me it sounds like one is free to do anything one wants. One has the will, the ability just to do anything, and this is not true because everything depends on causes and conditions. If the causes and conditions are not there, things can’t be experienced. So, is some freedom and some will, but there isn’t complete free will.

So, there is a freedom of choice. Yeah, and that arises, that freedom, whatever freedom does exist, depends on causes and conditions. If we don’t create the causes and conditions, the freedom to act is not there. This is what the teaching about the precious human rebirth is saying, as a human being, having met the Dharma and having leisure and so on, we have incredible freedom. That has arisen depending on causes and conditions created in past lives.

If you look at an animal life, there is far less freedom. There’s far less freedom of choice as an animal, and that has arisen depending on creating the wrong causes and conditions. In hell, there’s no freedom whatsoever, and that has arisen by causes and conditions, by following anger again and again. Yes, someone yes? Is there such a feeling as the first Buddha?

No, there is no first Buddha, beginningless Buddhas. Śākyamūni Buddha met many previous Buddhas, and those Buddhas met Buddhas back in beginningless time. At any point in time, there was a Buddha who depended on a previous Buddha, beginningless Buddha. Buddhism’s got that one covered. Yes?

Is it possible for identical twins to have part of each other’s consciousness? I don’t think Buddhism says that, but identical twins are beings who have incredibly strong karma together, they’ve created unbelievably strong karma together in previous lives. And because of their closeness, often twins can Very ordinary people who are twins can read each other’s minds a little bit from long distance and so on. Yeah. Yeah.

But I You I think you have your own mind though. Which is nice to have. Two: you. One: Oh, wait, maybe we have some people haven’t asked who liked it, especially some new people here. Yes?

Yes. How is this camera like that? Yeah, you got it? The question is, in the case of abortion, someone may abort a child, a young person, with the very best motivation for the well-being of the fetus. So, what is the karmic situation?

Is that basically it? Yes. So, this is very specific, I mean, speaking, abortion is negative karma because it involves taking life. A fetus has consciousness, one is taking life. And of course, when we get into karma in more detail, although there are fixed aspects of it, karma is incredibly complex and subtle, so the result, the actual result depends on many, many, many factors.

So it’s very difficult for anyone to say because what the result will be. Example, you say a person aborts the fetus with the best thought for the child because the child cannot be looked after and they’ll have a terrible life and the mother is too young and maybe the woman was raped and many, many things like that. But we cannot know what will happen to that child. Theoretically, we could say a child born of a fourteen year old girl who was raped, and the fourteen year old girl is a drug addict and has no education and is stuck in poverty, then this child is going to have a terrible life, so it’s better to abort it. In theory, logically, this would seem the case, but we can’t know.

We can’t know who that being is and what their life will be. Beings have been born in poverty and suffering and misery and have become amazing beings. I mean, they’re usually the exception, but that’s always possible. Come to be pushed into a condition where we experience termination? Speaker You could say that, but this gets very tricky to say that because then one can justify many things if you say, Oh, the question was, couldn’t the consciousness that was in that foetus that gets aborted have the karma to be aborted so that it’s okay?

You know, if I say this, many people will get upset because But the first noble truth is The first truth of noble beings is that existence is suffering, and we don’t really understand what that means. We tend to think, Oh, it means, you know, life is a little sometimes we have problems. But, for example, just maybe I will regret saying this, but there are many kinds of situations that’s happening in the world all the time, a young girl that gets raped and is pregnant. So this is a terrible thing to happen, but karmically, why does this girl get raped having created the cause? It cannot happen if the cause hasn’t been created.

It’s not saying this person is terrible and evil because they got raped, but it can’t happen if the cause isn’t there. Of course, the raping by the man is the condition, of course, but it can’t happen if the root cause isn’t there. So a child can be terminated. And the being who is born into that person who has been raped, that they have the karma to take rebirth in that womb of that person. Do you mean negative karma or suffering?

Yes, this is true. But it’s not. We’re all trapped in that. The question is, you get angry and you create negative karma, but why do you get angry? Because this is also a karmic situation.

Is it a karmic situation? You can say, Yes, it is. This lady is saying, Well, we’re trapped, but it’s not like that. We can break out of that situation. Why we get angry frequently is because we allow ourselves to.

We don’t see the harm of anger and we follow it again and again, so we create these imprints. One of the karmic I haven’t got into all the karmic results. One of the karmic results of both good and bad actions is creating the habit to do it again and again. If you do negative things, you create the habit, it becomes easier to do negative things. If you do virtuous things, one creates the habit to make it easier to have the instinct to do virtuous things.

Is that where free will and choice comes in? Yeah. Right now, we can see we have the ability to recognize that anger is harmful and to apply some antidote to it, not to suppress it, but to subdue it in a skillful way. Yes, yes. That is what saṃsāra is, being trapped in this cycle of instinctual negative behavior.

Yes, and we have those seeds. We have also these positive seeds and imprints that can understand anger is negative. And we have the seeds that can energize us to avoid it right now because we’re in the freedom. In certain states, our anger, our mind is so obscured, our anger is so strong that in that state we can’t do anything about it and we just create more negative karma, or we have the instinct to kill. As an animal, one has the instinct to kill so strongly it’s very difficult to do it, to change that.

This is a karmically determined situation. Fortunately, it’s not permanent, but in the human realm, we have so much freedom to change. We have these negative instincts, but we have the freedom to change them. Yeah. Maybe one tiny one more.

Yeah. Parallels the last question, but I need clarification. If abortion is negative karma, last night Generally speaking. Yeah. Did he say that?

Did Lama Lhundub say that? In the question, there was pure motivation. Yes. If you can take Buddhism definitely says that because karma is not concrete, it gets very complicated, but generally speaking, killing is negative, meaning if you do it with negative mind, but it is possible to kill with a positive mind. Great bodhisattvas can do it occasionally, but we shouldn’t think that we can kill with a virtuous mind.

We may think we’re killing with compassion, whereas we’re killing with aversion. But Lama Lhundub was saying, It is possible to kill without and not create negative karma because it is possible at a very high level of wisdom and compassion, to kill someone. Us are at that point? No, not at all. Speaker So Well, I can’t say, but generally speaking.

Sorry. Speaker You like to euthanize someone just negative karma? One: Yes, generally. All lamas of all the traditions say this, that it’s because we because the time of death is so crucial and we can never know what will at the very moment of death, when the consciousness leaves, or the last moment of the consciousness of this life, which will affect the next rebirth, we will never know we don’t know what state of mind that will be. So to interfere with that is very dangerous, is not wise.

What about euthanising animals that are in pain? Again, it’s the same thing. It’s the same thing. Someone just asked me this earlier today, the thing is we say, Oh, I can’t bear. I want to stop the life of this loved person or this animal because I can’t bear the suffering they have.

So we may feel and think that this is true, but the reality may be that actually their suffering is disturbing us. We don’t want to face We ourselves don’t want to have to put up with this person’s suffering. It’s not that we Yeah? It’s a very, very subtle thing that we may feel we’re experiencing compassion for them, but what we’re actually experiencing is an aversion to the suffering of the person, even if it’s a loved person. We love them, but we have an aversion to having to, day by day, see them suffer.

It’s not compassion, it’s aversion. It’s a very, very subtle kind, but it’s not really compassion, it’s an aversion. We can’t put up with their suffering. Whereas compassion we say compassion is the mind that can’t bear suffering, but what that means is that actually one has the courage to be able to confront every kind of suffering and deal with it in a wise way. And the most compassionate thing may be to allow a person to experience suffering situation, because the next life may be worse.

And the being may be experiencing a lot of suffering but may be learning from it, be developing incredible courage and compassion because of the very fact that they have so much suffering. So we can dedicate the merits of the positive potential generated in our mind right now. May this become a cause for us to be able to follow the complete path to liberation and enlightenment, gain all the realizations on the path to enlightenment, and achieve the fully awakened state that continuously brings about our own perfect benefit, happiness, and at the same time is able to bring about the perfect benefit of every living being. May the precious Bodhicitta, not yet born, arise and grow. May the unborn have no decline, but increase forever Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
preta
Hungry ghost, or spirit. The preta realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Does the law of karma permit free will to exist?

It helps to analyze what free will means. If it means being free to do anything one wants, that is not true, because everything depends on causes and conditions, and without them things cannot be experienced. So there is some freedom and some will, but not complete free will. There is a freedom of choice, but whatever freedom exists arises from causes and conditions, and if the causes are not created, the freedom to act is not there. The teaching on the precious human rebirth shows this: a human who has met the Dharma and has leisure has incredible freedom, created by causes from past lives. An animal has far less freedom of choice, arising from creating wrong causes.

Is it possible for identical twins to share part of each other's consciousness?

Buddhism does not say that identical twins share part of each other's consciousness. Identical twins are beings who have created incredibly strong karma together in previous lives. Because of their closeness, even very ordinary twins can often read each other's minds a little, even from a long distance. Still, each twin has their own mind, which is a good thing to have.

If someone has an abortion with the best motivation for the well-being of the child, what is the karmic situation?

Abortion is negative karma because it involves taking life, and a fetus has consciousness. Karma is incredibly complex and subtle, and although some aspects are fixed, the actual result depends on many factors, so it is very difficult for anyone to say what the result will be. A person may abort out of concern for the child, for example because the mother is very young, was raped, is addicted to drugs or is in poverty. In theory it may seem logical that such a child would have a terrible life, so abortion would be better. But we cannot know who that being is or what their life will be. Beings born in poverty and misery have become amazing beings.

What should we think about euthanising animals, or loved ones, who are in pain?

When we say we can't bear a loved one's or an animal's suffering and want to end its life, what we feel may not be compassion. It may be an aversion to the suffering, because we don't want to put up with seeing them suffer day by day. This is very subtle, and we may feel it is compassion, but it is really aversion. Compassion is often described as the mind that can't bear suffering, but this means having the courage to confront every kind of suffering and deal with it wisely. The most compassionate thing may be to allow the being to experience the suffering, because the next life may be worse.

Scroll to Top