Kopan Course 2001 — 2001-11-10

Buddha House Adelaide

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 — 2001-11-10
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: Kopan 2001 11 10 Tape 14 Side 1.MP3

UUID: 5c6ef457-9fbe-4316-8fdd-2e786195e621

Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub

Collection: Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)

Date: 2001-11-10

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 45 min

Words: 4,564

Understand that the suffering in our own minds can only be reduced and eliminated by changing our mind, overcoming the disturbing thoughts. We can generate the thought to be able to I know, I can’t do anything about it. He can, not me. So the more we recognize that as we only ourselves can change our mind, overcome our own delusions, So it’s true for others, but we can help them do that if we have an incredibly positive virtuous mind, wisdom and the energy to work for others. Because although we have to change our mind, it has changed depending on the compassion and wisdom of all the buddhas and bodhisattvas.

It’s not a totally independent job, fortunately. So just as the Buddhas and Bodhisattvas manifest as great teachers to help guide us on the path to enlightenment, we can become bodhisattvas, Buddhas, great teachers that can help guide others on the path to liberation and enlightenment. So to be able to do all these things, we have to follow the graduated path of inner mental development. To follow that path we need to successfully come to the successful conclusion of that path, we need to understand it perfectly, and for that perfect understanding to arise, that wisdom to arise, it depends on listening to the teachings on the graduated path again and again. So we generate the thought, for the benefit of myself and all living beings, I will listen to this explanation.

We can we can visualize, imagine Śākyamūni Buddha who is the the source of these teachings manifesting directly in front of us with an incredibly beautiful body of golden transparent light. We can imagine him surrounded by countless other Buddhas and bodhisattvas and many kinds of holy beings. And at the same time, we think of ourselves surrounded by all the sentient beings of the six realms who have so much more suffering than myself, and far less ability at the moment to do anything about their suffering. Especially we think of our mother of this life on our left, our father on our right, family, friends behind us, and the people we dislike or who dislike us directly in front, and think particularly for these beings, I would achieve enlightenment. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, and the Supreme Assembly by the merits I create by teaching the Dharma.

May I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings? So again, spend just a short time focusing on our breath in order to develop a calmer, clearer mind, place the body in a comfortable position so we can remain still, and then just take a strong interest in the breath. Thank you. So this morning I was talking about the first teaching the Buddha gave on the four truths that appear to noble beings whose minds are free of confusion. The first is that ordinary existence, ordinary life, is in its very nature inescapably unsatisfying and suffering.

This applies to all beings at all times, in all cultures, in all situations, whether rich or poor, healthy or unhealthy, beautiful or ugly, intelligent or stupid, good or bad. All of us are experiencing only saṃsāra, no real peace, sometimes the illusion of happiness, some bubbles of pleasure, moments of pleasure and so on, but no real, lasting peace, satisfaction, contentment. So this teaching is the very basis for developing compassion, loving kindness, and compassion for ourselves and all living beings. If only could contemplate that point to see the truth of that point ourselves or to begin We can’t see the totality of the truth of that with our confused minds, but it’s certainly possible to see a great deal of that truth even with this very ordinary mind if we open our eyes a little bit and look around. And then we can develop compassion for ourselves, being stuck in this situation, trapped in this situation, and we can begin to develop compassion for others, not just for a few others, but for all living beings, because every living being is in this state.

Everyone is suffering simply because of having an afflicted mind. Every living being we can look at. There are some exceptions because there are some holy beings amongst us, but apart from those beings, everybody’s mind is afflicted by delusion and karma, so there is no peace. And because the mind is afflicted by delusion and karma, by ignorance, there is always the potential for some kind of suffering to arise, and even the very worst kind of suffering to arise. So that very fact that our mind is not at peace is the first noble truth, the first truth of noble ones.

And it doesn’t matter if one is incredibly powerful, incredibly rich, beautiful, this or that, these external things do not in any way modify the delusions in the mind. Often they enhance them, exaggerate them. So if we just had that mindfulness in our daily life, if we contemplated that, the truth of that, and were aware of it, we’re able to see sentient beings, experience each sentient being that we meet as being under the control of this first truth, then rather than identifying them as we do uncontrollably, as either friend, enemy or stranger, which gets us nowhere, and just perpetuates our own delusions, aversion and attachment, we could feel compassion for them. We could empathize and feel compassion. And it would be the basis for generating a mind that, since we know this person is already suffering, they don’t want any more suffering, just like, I don’t need any more suffering, I’ve got enough, thank you very much.

I don’t need any more hassles of any kind. So just as applies to me, we can generate this thought to behave in a way that doesn’t cause even the slightest bit of additional suffering to this person. So, the second truth is that all of this suffering has a cause, and that cause lies within our own mind. Suffering doesn’t arise from anything external at all. Of course, things, other people, various things, the environment, the weather, diseases, many things act as secondary conditions for suffering to arise.

But if there isn’t the potential for suffering in our mind, then these external conditions can’t generate suffering. Buddhas walk around this earth and aren’t caused suffering by it because there’s no potential for suffering in their mind. External things act as the condition, but the root cause of our suffering is within our mind, our own delusions, and the negative imprints left by those delusions. I should have mentioned this, when I’m talking about the nature of the mind and talking about the blissful nature of the mind, when we meet a beautiful object and happiness arises, we tend to think that happiness lies in the object. That’s why we get attached to objects of various kinds, human living beings and inanimate objects, because with our non analytical mind we somehow foolishly believe that happiness is in the object.

But even if it was to some even if some of the happiness was in the object, but there is no happiness in the object, but even if there was some happiness in the object, if we didn’t have the potential for happiness in our mind, when our mind contacted the object, no happiness would arise. It is undeniable that when our mind meets outer conditions, certain outer conditions, happiness arises. But those things, other people, objects, praise, even the pleasant sounds, all these things, these are secondary conditions for something already existing in our mind to manifest, to become manifest. Happiness. So at the moment, these outer conditions can only act as a condition for a very gross level and an impermanent level of happiness to arise.

And it arises while the condition is and also can’t keep our memories of it going, that happiness fades away. But the happiness is arising in the mind because our mind has the potential for happiness. And it’s indicating even though that happiness one can call a worldly kind of happiness, it’s not the really satisfying kind we want, it is a glimmer, it is coming from the potential of our mind. It’s an obscured happiness, but it’s showing that within our mind there is the potential for genuine, lasting, meaningful, joyful happiness to be experienced. And that that that is something we can oh, we could call real.

It’s not really real. It’s not truly existing, but it’s something genuine. Although, if we get to the second noble truth let’s get to the third noble truth. Second noble truth, the truth of noble ones, there is an actual cause of suffering which is the delusions and particularly ignorance, this fundamental, primordial misconception of self and others. And the third truth is that there can be a genuine, lasting cessation of this suffering.

Why? Because although at the moment our mind is dominated by suffering and the causes of suffering, it’s so powerful and always has been, and if we look around the world we can see there is so much suffering in the world. The very basis of that suffering, our ignorance, is something false. There is no valid, solid, lasting basis for suffering and confusion and pain. It all depends, all of it depends on this one mind of ignorance, and that mind of ignorance itself is a dependent phenomena.

It can be eliminated from the mind. Once it’s eliminated, every kind of suffering is gone. But the Buddha nature cannot be eliminated from the mind. It is of the very essence of the mind. The Buddha nature and the quality of clarity and knowing cannot be eliminated.

That’s not actually the Buddha nature, but because of the very nature of the mind there’s this ability to know and know everything perfectly, that can never be changed. When that is operating, happiness, bliss, joy is there. All good qualities, all virtuous states of mind have a valid basis which can never be eliminated, can never be undermined. Whereas all negative states of mind, every single negative state of mind, even though they may arise very powerfully, have no valid basis. This is why good always has to triumph.

Yeah. Because although bad, evil, suffering is very strong, it’s just an illusion. It has an invalid basis that can be totally eliminated. Whereas the mind itself, the thought of ignorance, can be eliminated, but the mind that generates that thought, this primordial mind, that can’t be eliminated. All negative minds, no matter how powerful they are, have an invalid basis which is ignorance.

They arise solely because of ignorance, and that ignorance is something that cannot be sustained. It can be eliminated. So although suffering and the causes of it appear to be something incredibly powerful, like right now, if we look at our mind, if we’re honest, if I look at my mind, the negative minds appear to be much more powerful than any thoughts of love, compassion, wisdom or whatever arise in my mind. And so, one can make the mistake of thinking, Well, that’s the nature of my mind. I have all these nasty thoughts and tendencies, which is like they are so powerful and I’ve got this pathetic little bit of wisdom and compassion occasionally that somehow accidentally pops up, so there’s no hope, there’s just doomed, no hope.

So it looks like that, but the reality is opposite. The basis Although right now our good qualities are very weak, the basis of them is something incredibly powerful and indestructible, whereas the negative thoughts right now are in the ascendancy and are very strong, but the basis of them is an illusion. There’s nothing solid to it whatsoever. This is something we can think about and understand and discover. Because all of the teachings, the intellectual presentation of the teachings, is for the purpose of leading us to have the inner experience.

So the fourth truth of noble beings, those with the clear mind seeing reality, is that this cessation, this definite cessation of suffering, can be accomplished because there is a method, a method to follow. There is a method, a system that we can rely on to completely eliminate ignorance. Firstly, we can subdue the disturbing thoughts, and having subdue them, we are able to develop a clearer, concentrated mind which can then be used to see how ignorance arises and therefore eliminate it. So, there is a definite method. And this method exists, I don’t know, in other traditions, I don’t want to go on about this point, but it definitely exists in the Buddhadharma.

There is this definite method to follow, a graduated path to follow, starting from where we are right now as beings controlled by self grasping, ignorant self grasping, and this self-cherishing or self obsession, these two fundamental causes of all our suffering, starting from that situation step by step, we can overcome all this suffering and the causes of it, and achieve not just liberation but enlightenment. And so this is particularly what the Course is about, is to present that path. There are many ways of presenting that path, But the essence of it is developing wisdom. The wisdom, this clear mind that directly perceives phenomena as they are, and it is this wisdom that can completely destroy ignorance. And so, with the motivation of being free of suffering oneself, when we develop this wisdom we achieve nirvana.

If we develop this wisdom with the stronger motivation to benefit all living beings, we can eventually achieve the state of complete enlightenment and become a Buddha. So one simple way of seeing the path to, at least, to liberation is, as his holiness says, First, we have to stop creating negative karma. That’s the very first step. Then we can subdue the delusions, not suppress them, not suppress them, that doesn’t work. We have to subdue our disturbing thoughts, every single one of them, and then having subdued them, we’re in a state, a situation where we can eliminate them.

So that’s the path to liberation, and if we do it with the motivation to benefit all sentient beings, having developed this wisdom, we can go on to eliminate the subtle obscurations in our mind and achieve enlightenment. But in the Graduated Path teachings that we’re going to discuss, these teachings exist in some form in all the four schools of Tibetan Buddhism, but it was particularly brought to, how can we say, perfection, can we say that? And emphasized in the Gelugpa tradition, particularly by the great master Tsongkhapa, the founder of this Gelugpa tradition, who wrote a text, composed a text called The Great Graduated Path to Enlightenment, where it explains this psychological process of transforming the mind, developing the mind. It was based on earlier teachings of the Buddha. This path, the graduated path to enlightenment, takes all the essential points of the different Mahāyāna Sutras and arranges them in this psychological sequence of practice that is easy to understand and is easy to practice.

Because if you try to study the Mahāyāna Sutras that the Buddha taught, and also if you study the Pali Sutras as well that the Buddha taught, and there are many, many of them, so even if we could read them in the original languages or whatever, it would take an incredibly long time to even read them, let alone to even intellectually understand them. And if we did intellectually understand all these sutras, we would discover that on one occasion the Buddha said this, and on another occasion, he said almost the opposite. And then on another occasion, he said something quite different. So does this mean the Buddha didn’t have a clue what he was talking about, and he just said whatever came into his mind just to keep people happy? This could be an explanation, but the great masters of the past who had this vast comprehensive mind realized that the Buddha, in teaching a particular sūtra, was teaching a particular group of people, he understood exactly the minds of those beings and said exactly what was necessary, that they could understand and that they could practise, that all the time behind any specific teaching the Buddha gave, it was simply a skillful means that would lead them to ultimately achieve liberation and enlightenment.

So only these greatly accomplished masters can really understand by looking at the totality of all the different sutras what they’re really about, and Lama Tsongkhapa was one of these great masters. So he took the essential meanings and practices of the different sutras and arranged them in this non contradictory path to enlightenment. So this is an incredible kindness that we are benefiting from right now. So Lama Tsongkhapa taught that path, and to his direct disciples who gained the realization, they taught to their disciples down to the present day. Of course, His Holiness, the Dalai Lama, is the lineage holder, the supreme lineage holder of these teachings.

There are other lineage holders, but there are many great accomplished masters of these teachings existing, so that the what they call the warmth of the lineage is still alive. The blood is still flowing in the lineage, so we can contact that. So I’ve had some contact with these great beings. Some of you here also have heard the teachings from these great beings. So we can study with these beings and also if we study it and practice it, there is no reason why There is no reason at all, no valid reason.

There is no valid reason why our minds cannot experience the result just as all the beings of the past have experienced the result. Why? Because we’ve got a mind, and the beings of the past have mind. No different than ours. At one point, they were totally deluded just like us.

Same delusions, same confusion, same suffering, but they followed the method, the unmistaken method, and achieved liberation and enlightenment. So basically, the path to enlightenment, as explained by the Lama Tsongkhapa can be divided up into what are called the three principal paths or the three principal qualities, three essential states of mind that we need to achieve to bring about liberation and enlightenment. So, the first of these is renunciation. So, renunciation does not mean giving up happiness, which is what most people interpret as, as kind of giving up all one’s nice things, wearing a hair shirt and beating oneself on the back and shaving one’s head and eating bread and water, and this kind of thing. Renunciation actually means giving up the causes of suffering, and what it involves is giving up one’s obsession, firstly with the things of this life, believing there is only this life and that the happiness of this life is all there is and it’s real and lasting.

We renounce that by seeing that it’s false, that it’s not what it appears to be. We have at least some intellectual understanding of that, some experience of that, and because of that our mind turns towards working towards future happiness. There is the great renunciation of seeing that all of samsaric rebirths, either as a human being again and again, or as a God being with a body of light and everything, even that is suffering. So, one of the principal qualities that we need to generate is this mind of renunciation. That particularly has to come first.

That is the basis for the other two major qualities that we need. Without renunciation, the other qualities just simply cannot really develop completely. We can work on them and some of the strength of those qualities will arise, but unless we have the foundation of renunciation, things will keep collapsing. Will never really work because it’s the very basis of everything else. The other principal powers that we need to generate is this quality of wisdom, which is this mind, this direct insight into the nature of reality, the nature of the reality of our self and all phenomena.

So, if we have renunciation and wisdom, that will bring about enlightenment. But we need another principle state of mind to bring about complete Did I say no? That will bring about liberation. If we generate complete renunciation in our mind and complete wisdom, that will bring about the state of nirvana, total freedom from suffering. But in order to bring about enlightenment, we need this other principle quality in our mind which is called Bodhicitta, the thought seeking enlightenment, which is a type of compassion, but it’s more than compassion, it’s more than great compassion.

And we’ll talk about this mind a lot in this course because this is what distinguishes the Mahāyāna path from the path to enlightenment. On the path to liberation, one needs renunciation and wisdom. On the path to enlightenment, one also needs renunciation and wisdom, but one needs this extra state of mind which is Bodhicitta, this incredibly powerful, great compassion, which is that is the basis of Bodhicitta, but on the basis of this great compassion, wanting to free all sentient beings, all sentient beings, friends, enemies, strangers, from every kind of suffering, one generates the thought that I must become a Buddha. I must develop the full potential of my mind because that’s the only way to help guide others from suffering. So these are called the three principles of the path to enlightenment, the three principle states of mind that lead to enlightenment.

We also need these in our daily life anyway. If we want happiness in our daily life, even ordinary happiness, if we have a little bit of renunciation or detachment, things go much better. If we have some wisdom in our daily life, things go so much better. And if we have some real concern, compassion and concern for others in our daily life, everything goes so much better. So, we need these qualities day by day in our ordinary life, and we need them in our spiritual life to achieve enlightenment.

So this is what this course is about, how to develop these Three Principal Aspects in our mind. At the moment, our mind follows other paths, the paths of attachment, the path of aversion, the path of self-cherishing. But we’re trying to create different paths in our mind, the path of renunciation, wisdom, and Bodhicitta. So, to generate those paths also depends on contemplating and practising different things, different meditations to do. So this is what we’ll explain in the course.

So another way of looking at the graduated path to enlightenment is from the point of view of raising the motivation in our mind. Step by step, developing a greater, greater and greater motivation for following the path. So, at the moment, For most people in the world, we won’t say people here, but for most people in the world, the motivation that dominates the mind is not a spiritual motivation at all, but is the worldly motivation seeking the happiness of this life, of trying to avoid the suffering of this life. So probably, most of us, I don’t want to say this, but possibly, that is what is dominating our mind now, that motivation. Even though we’d like to think of ourselves as following a spiritual path, but the reality is, our mind is probably dominated by this worldly motivation to have pleasure, and happiness, and security, and fun, and this wealth, and fame, and friends, and nice clothes, and all these things, which is the worldly motivation, and to be free of suffering.

Not to be free of the causes of suffering, which is much more difficult, but to be free of suffering. That’s what we want. We don’t want suffering, but we’re not willing to get rid of the causes of it. And of course we want someone else to take the suffering away, not us, mom, dad, someone, please take it away. So this is the worldly motivation.

So the first scope, the first spiritual motivation, the first level of spiritual capacity is changing that motivation, involves changing that motivation of just being obsessed with this life, the little happiness and the suffering of this life, and changing our direction, our motivation, and therefore our actions to work for the happiness of future lives, particularly our next immediate life. So this is this first level of motivation, the first level of spiritual motivation is generating the basic level of renunciation, renouncing the attachment to this life in order to work for the happiness of future lives. This is the first scope, the first level of genuine spiritual motivation. So the more we develop that motivation and the practice that goes with it, we can enter into the second level of spiritual capacity or scope or intelligence, because it’s being intelligent to change one’s motivation from working for the happiness of this life to the happiness of future lives. But as we use that intelligence, our intelligence can increase, and we can begin to see Of course it’s good, it’s necessary, it’s essential to use this life to work for the happiness of future lives because future lives are going to come, and it’s in my power to determine whether my next life will be a good one, a happy one, a beneficial one, or a suffering one.

I have the choice right now, the freedom to work with my mind, to create the causes of a better life, so that’s essential. I have to get involved with that. But one can do that with a thought that that’s good enough. I’ll just work And so in my next life, I’ll also just tinker around with my mind a little bit, not too much hard work, because enlightenment and liberation looks really tough, so confusing. All these concepts and bits and pieces, all these people are talking about giving me a headache, and to practice them, my God, my Buddha, was too much.

So, hey, I’ll just work for that. Now, this life, I’ll just work for the happiness of next life, that’s okay. And in my next life, I’ll just work for the happiness of the next life. Great, I’ve got it solved. Terrific, fantastic.

But if we contemplate that more and more, we can see that even being reborn a human again and again, or to be reborn as a god again and again, we don’t avoid suffering. We have to experience sickness, old age, and death again and again and again. There’s more that we can read, I won’t go into it now. But we have to even as a human being, even as in the God realms, one can’t avoid meeting with suffering again and again and again, and creating the causes of suffering again and again and again. Contemplating that more and more, allowing that to really touch the heart deeply, we can generate this second level of motivation, second level of spiritual intelligence or scope, which is the great renunciation that says, I don’t want any more of this.

I’m totally fed up with all this suffering and all this limited happiness. I want out of here. I want liberation.

Key terms in this teaching

buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
Gelug
The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
graduated path lamrim (Tib)
A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. The lamrim was first formulated by the great Indian teacher Atisha when he came to Tibet in 1042. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
obscurations to knowledge jneyavarana (Skt); she drib (Tib)
One of the two obscurations, the more subtle ones that block enlightenment; also known as subtle obscurations, obscurations to enlightenment and cognitive obscurations (Berzin’s translation). LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
six realms
The general way that Buddhism divides the whole of cyclic existence; there are three lower realms (hell, hungry ghost and animal) and three upper realms (human, demigod and god). LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top