Kopan Course 2001 — 2001-11-09

Buddha House Adelaide

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 — 2001-11-09
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: Kopan 2001 11 09 Tape 10 Side 2 Cause & Effect.MP3

UUID: cbd843e8-6bf2-4605-95e7-c1ea1a3c889e

Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub

Collection: Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)

Date: 2001-11-09

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 45 min

Words: 4,999

Are experienced in this life, that’s undeniable, you know, we all know that. If you bake a cake, if you put the cake ingredients together, you get a cake. Amazing, incredible. So this killing has generated this karmic seed in the mind and that karmic seed cannot ripen, generally speaking, until a future life. That maybe the next life, but it doesn’t even have to ripen in the immediate next life, it could ripen in the life after that, the life after that, it may not ripen for a million, million, million lifetimes in the future.

But it will ripen when all the conditions come together for that seed, and then that karmic imprint, that karmic potential will ripen. And how does it ripen? It can only ripen as suffering, and because in the case of killing it’s an extremely heavy karma, a very heavy negative impression in the mind. When the suffering that results from that, karmic seed ripening, is not just like the suffering from killing in this life of the fear, the regret, being in jail and getting killed, the suffering the Buddha taught will be inconceivably greater and much will last for the conceivably longer period of time. Because for one thing, that effect, that karmic imprint cannot become the cause to be a human being.

It’s going to produce an effect that that effect cannot be experienced as a human being. Because a human being one way of looking at a human being, there’s a certain range of experience that we can have as a human being, a certain upper limit of happiness and a lower limit of suffering. But there are other realms of our mind, other realms or ways we experience our mind, states of mind, where our mind can experience far greater happiness, joy, bliss than in this human level of awareness. But the Buddha also taught that our mind can sink to another realm of existence where we experience far, far greater suffering. And these negative karmic seeds act to control the mind, to make it sink into those incredibly suffering realms.

So this is what karma is about. karma is not instant. Definitely there are instant results from what we do, good and bad, in this life, but these are not repeat, they are not the main karmic result by any means. For example, we have been sitting here meditating, trying to meditate over the past few days. So there are results from that now that one can experience.

They may last a brief time, the noticeable results may only last a short time, but the subtle results may carry on for the rest of this life. Hopefully also that this being here for one month, this action, this karmic action of being here for one month, have noticeable effects for the rest of your life. But this is not the main karmic result. From just sitting down meditating, it can have all sorts of effects in this life, but this is not the main karmic result. As we meditate, especially with trying to generate a good motivation and we try to concentrate on these virtuous, meaningful things, and we dedicate it, we try and dedicate, direct that energy we’ve generated in our mind to something really, you know, incredibly meaningful such as liberation and enlightenment, that karmic seed we have generated, we are generating in our mind as we meditate, that seed will ripen in a future life as far, far greater wisdom and happiness and compassion than anything we generate in our meditation right now, generally speaking.

For example, we may practice meditation throughout all this life and we may feel sorry, maybe I shouldn’t give this example but we may feel in this life we’ve hardly got anywhere in our meditation practice. Even physically it’s difficult to sit and we don’t feel that we’ve really generated much wisdom, compassion or all these things, some, but nothing like we would hope to have achieved. But what we need to realise is that every time we try to do these virtuous things, these positive imprints are being generated and when those imprints ripen at some future life, they will ripen as, for example, the ability to know how to meditate, to want to meditate, to enjoy meditating and to be able to do it well. And it will be easier by meditating on love, compassion, patience, wisdom for these things to arise more easily, spontaneously, effortlessly because there’s already some preparation in the mind. So this is one of the key points if one wants to follow the Buddhist path and is trying to generate some understanding and faith in it, to understand that, generally speaking, for us as ordinary people, that whatever good results that we experience in this life from practising the dharma is nothing compared to the results we will experience in the future because, as well as the good results that we are experiencing in this life, we are generating these karmic seeds which by their very nature, when they ripen, produce far greater results than the initial energy that goes to create them.

The Buddha taught that just like when you plant a tiny seed in the ground, when that seed produces its result, the result is something huge, such as a huge tree, and the tree produces all sorts of leaves and fruit for a long period of time from this tiny, tiny seed. For example, these sequoia trees, one of the biggest trees in the world, the redwood trees of America. The seed is very tiny, apparently very, very tiny, but it produces this gigantic tree. And in the same way the Buddha taught that these karmic seeds, good and bad, that we generate in our mind, which can be generated in a moment, in a flash, We have a thought of loving kindness that may last one moment, we may have a thought of anger that lasts one moment. In that moment, these karmic seeds are generated, planted in the mind.

But when they ripen, they produce this entire phenomena, even an entire life and its experiences that goes on and on. This is what the Buddha taught. Of course, this is not something that can be proved. But then we always have to go back and ask ourselves, Why do things happen? Why am I experiencing this?

One can only go back to three answers: It’s happening for no reason. If it’s happening for no reason, this is really depressing. This means that we can’t do anything. We are trapped. We do good things and maybe some good result happens and then disaster happens because there’s no reason for anything.

This means there’s no escape from our situation of experiencing suffering and little bubbles of pleasure if there’s no real cause for things. If there is a creator controlling things, then also we don’t have much control. We just have to, you know, I don’t know, pray and hope the creator decides to stop the suffering for us. But if is mind and the law of cause and effect, it means we can control. We are responsible for what we experience, good and bad, and we can change that.

Right now we’re experiencing a lot of suffering and not much real happiness. But this is because we created that situation. Since that is occurring in our mind, it’s our mind, we can change our mind. This is what the Buddha taught us. We can change our mind, no one else can do it.

But we do it with the help of the Buddhas and bodhisattvas. There’s actually, whether we know it or not, an incredible lot of help around if we open our mind to it. One great Tibetan lama of the Gelugpa tradition said that we shouldn’t expect results in this life. We should just understand that by having faith in mind and karma and the Buddhist teachings, by doing virtuous things, every kind of virtuous good thing, this is creating these karmic seeds and these have to ripen in the future. We should place our trust in that.

This is one of the main problems of modern people, that we expect instant results. We want instant results, that our world is becoming geared to this more and more demanding instant satisfaction, instant gratification, especially in this computer world where we need faster and faster computers. It’s unbearable that it takes five seconds after you’re plugged in for it to start, you know, so you throw it away and spend five thousand dollars to get something that only takes two seconds. And then you realize someone down the street has got one that you don’t even have to turn it on, they’re already working. And then you can plug it into your mind.

So this is a big problem for us in this twenty first century. And what we have to understand with working with the mind is that there’s not perhaps a good advertisement for Buddhism but it takes time and effort. It doesn’t happen overnight, generally speaking. But it does happen, and especially if we understand the law of cause and effect, these imprints are going into our mind and they have to bear a result because we’re experiencing the results of previous imprints anyway, undeniably. Results are coming now because causes were created.

So if we create the causes now, undeniably incredible results will come in the future. And of course, if we want to avoid suffering results, we should stop creating negative actions. Okay, Break. Thank you. Break time.

Ten minutes. I turned it off. Oh, I see. So once karma is generated, the seed remains in the mind. We have to remember that using the term seed is just an analogy, it doesn’t mean, of course, that there’s some physical thing stuck in the mind, because the mind’s not something you put things into anyway, it’s just a helpful way of thinking.

And that seed, that positive or negative seed, will produce bear its result. That is definite, unless there are two factors that modify the ripening of these karmic seeds. In the case of these negative imprints, as we talked about a little bit yesterday, the negative seeds can be purified so that they don’t ripen as great suffering. And there is a very specific ways of purifying the negative imprints in the mind. I’d like to point out that purification means that you don’t totally eliminate the karmic imprint and therefore all the suffering.

Purification means reducing the negative result. And forcing it to ripen in this life. But it ripens in a very modified way, one reduces the potency of the seed so that when it does ripen, it ripens as just a very small amount of suffering, at least much less than what it would have produced if the seed had ripened completely. Many Buddhists go around saying whenever suffering arises, Oh, I’m purifying some karma, but unfortunately it doesn’t mean that at all, it just means karma is ripening. Unless one has consciously, strongly directed some energy to purifying purification, it doesn’t happen.

Unless one has consciously and directly applied the mind to purification, purification doesn’t happen. The ripening of negative karma happens spontaneously, that doesn’t require any effort. The purification of negative karma requires a lot of effort. That’s why it’s much better not to create negative karma, not to think, Oh, it’s okay, I can create it and I’ll purify it later. It is not easy to really purify a strong way one’s negative karma, but it is definitely possible, and this is one of the main practices that we are encouraged to do.

Very briefly, just because everyone wants to know how to do this, I’ll just mention briefly, hopefully I want to know how to do it, I’ll just mention it briefly but I’ll explain it in more detail when we come to the topic of karma. The way to purify it is done through what I call the four opponent powers. The main one is developing sincere, uncontrived regret, which is different from guilt. Regret is a type of wisdom and guilt is a type of delusion, ignorance, so one generates sincere regret, one develops the opponent power of determination not to do negative actions in the future. This is not in any specific order, another of the opponent powers combines two things: generating refuge in the Triple Gem, because the essential refuge is the Dharma, and within the Dharma, the essential Dharma is the law of cause and effect.

One is regenerating one’s belief and determination to observe that. So by observing the law of cause and effect, of course, we stop creating negative karma. And the other aspect of that opponent power is trying to generate, in some way, at least in a contrived, effortful way, thought of Bodhicitta, which is the thought to benefit all living beings, to lead all living beings to enlightenment, away from suffering to enlightenment. So that thought is the total opposite to the thought that enables us to create negative karma, because negative karma is created because we don’t even care about harming ourselves. All negative karma involves virtually all negative karma involves harming others, so we try and generate this Bodhicitta thought, which is the very opposite.

And then the last of the four opponent powers is doing a conscious, virtuous act to counteract that negative imprint, to put this positive imprint in the mind to counteract the negative imprint. So, for example, doing the practice of the thirty five buddhas that is being done in the morning here, that is one of the main virtuous practices one can do to purify negative karma. Another one is the Vajrasattva practice that will be taught later on in the course by Venerable Karen, which will be done at night. So these are two of the most directly powerful ways, virtuous practices, to purify negative karma. But actually, any virtuous deed we do helps purify it accumulates merit, it accumulates positive energy, but also every virtuous thing we do, do, think, say, actually purifies, to some extent, the negative imprints in our mind.

Just listening to the Buddhadharma now with an open mind, hearing something that is wise and virtuous, this process itself is counteracting the ignorance that is the basis of creating all negative karma. So it is purifying our negative imprints to some extent, especially if we listen with faith in the Dharma and aspiration to practice it and so that that is purifying our negative karma to some extent. Because this is also something important to understand, that all negative karma is created out of ignorance. The two levels of ignorance, the very root level of ignorance, the most profound kind of ignorance that does not understand and actually distorts the appearance of the way things exist, the way we ourselves exist, the way all phenomena exist, but also the ignorance of the law of cause and effect itself is the basis for creating negative karma not believing it, not understanding it, not knowing about it, not believing in it. Because if mind exists the way the Buddha taught, then the way the mind works is according to the law of cause and effect, and it’s got nothing to do with whether we believe in it or not.

It’s not like if we become a Buddhist, then the law of cause and effect starts working. If that’s true, it’s better not to be a Buddhist. The law of cause and effect works whether one knows about it, whether one believes in it or not. It’s either true or it’s not. So I always give the example that in ordinary reality, for example, if we’re in some place and we don’t know the traffic rules and the speed limits and the policeman gets us to the side of the road and says, Oh, excuse me, you’ve just broken the speed limit and that will cost you so much.

And you can say, Oh officer, please please, I didn’t know, I’m sorry, I didn’t know, please don’t find me. And the officer may not find me because Oh, you didn’t know, it’s okay, I’ll let you off. But the law of cause and effect doesn’t work like that. One can’t plead ignorance, Oh I didn’t know that killing was bad, didn’t know that stealing was bad, I didn’t know that lying was negative, I realize how bad it was. That doesn’t work, there’s no one to plead with anyway.

The very reason negative karma is created is because of not knowing all the levels of not knowing. That is the basis of creating negativity, of harming the mind. The basis is not knowing the mind and not knowing how the mind works. Once we know our mind and we really know, have a strong understanding of how our mind works, that is what protects us from harming ourselves, harming our mind, relatively speaking. It’s this ignorance, all levels of ignorance that enable negative karma to be generated.

Suffering arises because of ignorance. It doesn’t arise because we are evil, it arises because we are ignorant. Not knowing. There’s no such thing as as anyone who is evil. There are such things as being ignorant.

We are all ignorant, but there is no one who is evil, even if the president of the United States says so. Sorry. Sorry. Yes. Sorry?

Also, yes. Also, there’s no great satan either. Absolutely, yes, yes. We’ll get into the details of karma when we this is just an introduction, right? Some important points, but I don’t want to talk about all the aspects.

The trouble is once you start, you’re forced to talk about everything. But definitely the motivation, good or bad, affects the strength. There are four things that affect the strength of the karmic result. But I wanted to talk about that later on. Can we talk about that later?

I just wanted to introduce the basic idea of cause and effect and how it’s relating to the mind, that’s the basic thing. karma is created because of our disturbing thoughts. There is mind, and this mind is disturbed by our afflictions. So these afflictions not only obscure our mind, and while they’re present in our mind, they cause suffering, But so, for example, anger anger obscures the mind, the potential for anger in our mind obscures our mind. When it manifests, it produces suffering while it is manifesting in our mind, but what is worse is that it produces these karmic imprints.

And when the karmic imprints ripen, it ripens only as suffering. So I’m trying to present the basic idea of mind and its implications. Yes? Yes, once it’s ripened it’s finished, just like a seed produces a flower and that’s it, it doesn’t produce another one, the seed is finished. But there’s very clear distinction between the ripening of negative karma and the purification of negative karma.

Every human being, every sentient being, is experiencing the ripening of negative karma. That’s life, that’s what’s called life. But very few people purify their negative karma, very few people are engaging in purifying their mind. That’s another completely different thing altogether. Yes.

You experience suffering, how can you distinguish whether it’s ordinary ripening of negative karma or the effect of purification factors? Probably in general it’s difficult, but if one has done some purification practice and then some suffering happens, then you can hope, we can hope that that is the result of purification that we did. But also one general sign is that well, in the teachings it explains that when one does engage in concentrated purification practices over a period of time, then certain signs appear there are specific signs in dreams, for example, that one has purified a great deal, then certain signs appear. Another obviously white things, you know, seeing white milk and all these kind of in dreams, Right? I haven’t had them either.

That means a great deal of purification has happened. But at an ordinary level, what can be noticed when you do purification, do retreats and so on, is that there is some experience of the mind being lighter, that there is more interest in practising the dharma, and when one reads it and so on, or hears it, there is there is more clarity of understanding and more joy in all these things. This is because some heaviness in the mind has been lifted, a little bit of that heaviness, that obscuration has been lifted temporarily. So that is a sign of purification. Yes.

Yes. It just ripens. Yeah. The job, our job, really, is to how we react during the life of that experience, how we react to Yes. That kind of ripening Yes.

That creates virtue Yes. Is important as negative karma ripens, the attitude we have to that experience determines whether more suffering occurs or something better. Is that what you’re saying? Yes, this is true. We’ll talk about in the Course more and more, And there’s a whole practice called mind training Lojong about dealing with the ripening of suffering, how we can deal with it.

Because usually what happens when our negative karma ripens, we don’t see it as something that comes from us. It’s just suffering, and I don’t deserve it because I’m good, and this is not fair, so we reject it, we get angry with it, upset by it, and we create more negative karma. So it gets perpetuated. But if negative karma ripens and we can accept that it is a ripening, the cause must lie within our mind and therefore we can accept that, then ripening of negative karma doesn’t become the cause for more that particular stream of negativity to perpetuate itself again and again. But this is one of the basic things in understanding the law of cause and effect, is to understand that everything that happens to us, good or bad, the cause lies within our mind.

So then we start to be able to accept what is happening to us, not in a passive way, but mentally accept that this suffering is happening to me, even though I can’t see the direct cause of it, but the cause must lie within my mind, the root cause, and therefore that’s why I’m experiencing this result. Therefore it’s teaching us, if I don’t want this suffering, this kind of suffering again, I need to avoid doing negative actions. Maybe we’ll leave the questions a little bit I’ll just go on a little bit more and we’ll have some questions later on. I just like to make this point because it should be obvious, but what the law of cause and effect is saying is that the suffering that we experience is not some kind of punishment. There’s nothing that is punishing us for doing negative actions, it’s just simply the way the mind works.

If we negate the essential goodness of our mind by generating these negative thoughts and following them, feeding them, and following them, and acting on them, suffering results. Inevitably, inescapably, suffering results in this life, but also because of the karmic seeds in future lives again and again. It’s just like if you lie out in the sun long enough with no clothes on, you get burnt, or your skin peels off. You’re not being punished, it’s just the way the skin works too much sun peels off, it’s just the nature of things. No one is punishing, no one is coming along ripping your skin off.

The sun isn’t punishing you, your body isn’t punishing you, it’s just the way things work, it’s the way the body works. It’s just the nature of the body for too much of something, the sunlight, then peeling off happens. Too much negativity in the mind, occurs. It’s just the way the mind works. Similarly, when we do virtuous things and happiness results, no one is rewarding us.

It’s just the way the mind works. So then, the often asked question arises, which I myself asked when I first heard about the dharma, and I also, like many people, got extremely angry by this, is this: are you saying that innocent children who suffer like who get sexually molested and who are starved are born in places and starved to death, this is their karma, are you telling me that? How dare you tell me this? And that’s exactly what is being said. Because no one is innocent.

A tiny child, the child’s body is new, the mind is ancient, the mind is ancient. The child hasn’t done anything in this life to deserve that suffering, but the mind was an adult, was another being, and created negative karmic actions, and the result happens. If we create the cause, we experience the result sooner or later. So the suffering result doesn’t ripen because we are bad. Suffering doesn’t happen just to bad people because we are evil and naughty and wicked, it happens because we’ve created the cause.

We’ve harmed our mind, and the result has to happen if we don’t purify the result. And the result comes when all the conditions come together, sooner or later. And it can happen when we are extremely nice people. But extremely nice people have minds, These minds are ancient, and extremely nice people such as ourselves haven’t always been extremely nice. When we were not extremely nice, we created negative did negative things, not because we were extremely evil, truly, existing evil people, but we were confused, ignorant people, and we created negative actions.

Those imprints remain in the mind, and when the conditions come together, the result happens. So sometimes the suffering result occurs when we are extremely good, innocent, even tiny children, or the suffering may happen when we are extremely nasty. It happens because when all the conditions come together. This is what the Buddha taught. No one is being punished, no one is a victim, it is just simply the way the mind works.

Otherwise, you have to say, why is this little innocent child suffering? For absolutely no reason, or because God decided, a creator decided this little child not this little child doesn’t have to suffer, but this one can suffer. In both cases I find this awful. Truly, there’s nothing to do. But if this so called innocent child has created the cause, then something can be done.

There is freedom. karma isn’t fate. karma is working according to a logical system of the mind, and because of that, things can be changed. If there wasn’t this definite connection, this ongoing definite relationship between cause and effect, then nothing is possible. Then bombs explode in our life for absolutely no reason, or because someone out there who we can’t see, can’t contact, decides a bomb will drop on us.

Okay. Yes. Yes, I will. I try, yes, later on. As I tried to say, this month long course, tried to present the path to enlightenment.

The path to enlightenment is a huge thing, and I’m sorry, but it always happens people get bombarded with millions of bits of information to try and process. So I try to introduce the topic a little bit so you can think about a few things now. But if I talk about everything now, which is difficult to do anyway, it gets overwhelming. The Buddhadharma is vast and very extensive. The mind chooses to be born in a particular situation, yes?

Experience Do we then choose which karma to be experienced? In both cases, no, the answer is no. We do not choose where to be born, who our parents will be. We are karmically pushed, we create conditions, causes to be born in certain situations, but we’re not conscious of that. But it is possible with time, with practice, as we purify our mind, even though we are still pushed by our karma to experience things, we’ll gradually be able to control it so that even though we have to take a rebirth as a suffering human being again, at one point we can reach a point where we can firstly get born in better and better human situations, then we can actually choose our parents, and so on.

But right now, as very calmly controlled people. That was pretty polite, wasn’t it? This includes me, of course. Do not choose where we are born, we have no choice. Are just mindlessly creating the causes for things and these karmas ripen and bingo, we are somewhere.

And the second point is that we don’t decide what karma is going to ripen, we have no control over that. I mean, there is this kind of view that we are born here to learn lessons. This is a very dominant view developing now, this is not the Buddhist view. Haven’t come to this earth to learn things, no one has put us here because that implies something is controlling everything. Of course here we can learn things, definitely, but we haven’t been put here to learn a particular thing.

No one has put us here and even ourselves, we haven’t put ourselves here to learn particular things. We are here through the force of our karma, but actually to be here as a human being is very good karma, and to meet the Buddhadharma and to find out about the mind is really great karma. And so we definitely can learn things, and there’s much to learn. But it’s not like that has been directed by something or someone. This is not the Buddhist view.

Sure. Can you create good karma without believing in karma? Yes, we do that all the time. And you create negative karma without believing in negative karma, unfortunately also. Yes.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
four opponent powers nyenpo tob zhi (Tib)
The four practices used to purify nonvirtuous imprints on the mindstream. LYWA
Gelug
The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
thought transformation lojong (Tib)
Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top