Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 09 Tape 11 Side 1 Cause & Effect

45 min · 5,372 words · 9 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 09 Tape 11 Side 1 Cause & Effect
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teacher explains how karma and delusion determine rebirth in the six realms, and how the subtle mind carries on into the next life after death. He argues that animals have mind and consciousness, that animal rebirth results from negative karma, and that the human realm is the best place to practise. The recording ends with a short question and answer session.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-09

Duration: 45 min

UUID: a92158b6-c7b6-411a-ba42-93c919d9172b

Words: 5,372

We generate lots of negative thoughts and feelings and so on. Then and we’ve had an uncontrolled mind. Our mind is dependent on so many things, you know, remember the attachment? We get attached because we think it makes us secure, in reality it makes us totally weak. We have the more attachment, the weaker our mind.

And suddenly at the time of death, all those attachments in one nasty moment are removed. The Lord of Death takes them away instantly, and suddenly we are left with not a single one of our favorite supports. Not one of them is left. All the things that we’ve depended on, that we believe we can rely on in one moment, they are all stolen from us. And then we face the naked reality of our mind which is just a mess.

Because we haven’t done anything meaningful with it. So in that state it’s almost guaranteed a negative thought, a negative karma will be nurtured which will throw us in the next moment, in the very next moment, into a state of unpleasant appearances and experiences. This is what the Buddha taught. I mean, the Buddha taught it a lot better than this, and he knew what he was talking about, but I’m at least trying to give some rough idea of what the Buddha taught, and he taught it because the Buddha perceived it directly with a completely pure unmistaken mind. And of course, it’s not just that the Buddha taught these things, although again I have only this belief, but when one develops a certain level of clarity of mind, of concentration of mind, one develops psychic powers and one can know these things long before one becomes a Buddha.

One can recall one’s past lives when the mind becomes clear and there’s all that static in the mind stops. Then you can remember. When we have a clear mind, we have a good memory. And when the mind is really clear, one can remember beyond this life. And this is an accomplishment that in terms of the spiritual path hardly even counts to be able to do that.

It’s kind of low grade spiritual accomplishment. I’m a long way from it anyway, unfortunately. So it’s not just that we have to rely on the Buddhas for this. When one develops clairvoyance, one is able to recall past lives to be able to even remember going dying and being reborn and so on. These things are possible.

Yeah. So this is why if this is true, again, we really have to take care of our mind. As we live, generally speaking, that’s the way we die. Sorry, I think we have a new policy that I’ve tried to keep the questions to the end if possible in the last ten to fifteen minutes. Right.

So these these are the while our mind is controlled by delusion and karma, these are the possibilities that we can experience. The the The various realms of the desire realm, some much more suffering, some more pleasant, then there is the possibility of achieving the desire realm sorry, the form realm or the formless realm. Sorry, maybe this keeps bombarding people with lots of information but in order for our mind to go through the different realms of this desire realm depends simply on creating karma. We create enough good karma we can be reborn as a human being or in the desire levels of the gods. If we create enough bad karma, our mind sinks into an animal realm or below that.

In order for the mind to enter the form realm and the formless realm, this does not depend on creating karma, but it requires very specific causes. And these causes are developing high levels of mental concentration or samadhi. By developing these high levels of samadhi in this life, if we develop those, these levels of single pointed concentration of which there are many many levels that one can achieve, if one achieves those and one maintains them because also one can develop these states but by not practicing the meditation, keeping up the meditation practice, one can lose these high levels of concentration. But if one develops them and maintains them, and one has done them with a very worldly motivation, that one is not trying to accomplish them for a true spiritual purpose. One may think so because we can say I’m doing this for all sentient beings, but the reality is we may want to just impress people or gain power over people.

Because with with Samādhi, with single pointed concentration, one is able to develop clairvoyance and all sorts of psychic powers which one can use to manipulate people’s minds, and there are plenty of Gurus around these days doing that, unfortunately. So if one has developed these these concentrations with a worldly mind, when one dies, one enters into those either the form or the formless realm. Because in this life, through concentration, you can develop these form level concentrations or these formless level concentrations. So whichever one you achieve in this life, when death occurs, the mind instantly goes into that realm for a vast period of time. But it’s still saṃsāra, it’s still suffering.

It’s not it may look like liberation because it’s so blissful, but it’s not. It’s just a temporary pleasant experience. It’s just what one Tibetan lama, Chogyam Trungpa Rinpoche called spiritual materialism. A very refined form of spiritual materialism. So basically so to achieve these levels of concentration is quite difficult and is certainly not the aim of the Buddhist path.

There’s no point to achieve these concentrations just for their own sake, but they can some of them can be used to follow the spiritual path. So generally we as people who don’t just ordinary sentient beings who don’t develop these mental concentrations, we wander through the six realms of the desire realm depending on our karma. Of course we have been in these form and formless realms because in previous lives as human beings we practiced these concentrations with a worldly motive and went into these God realms. So we’ve been there, we’ve done that, and it didn’t work. We’re back.

Back in the in the flesh. We had these amazing bodies of light, lost them, got a bit a lump of this stuff again. This is saṃsāra going around and around and around and around. So many people may think this is complete nonsense. I can’t prove any of this but I could try to indicate something that may suggest some of it at least, if not all of it.

I believe it’s all true, I’ve taken the whole parcel. I took the whole package, I believe it. But when we hear this, one could be reborn as an animal or a ghost or in the hell realms or as a God, we think that this is impossible. How could this be? Maybe the idea of being a God is quite nice.

Oh, that’s possible. But to be born an animal, a ghost, a hell being? No, utterly impossible. And this is because one reason we think this is impossible is because of the wrong view of that we have of what we are. We have a wrong understanding of who we are, we don’t really know how we exist, and therefore we can’t conceive of another way of existing.

Particularly we all one aspect of our ignorance. It’s not the main aspect, it’s one aspect because excuse me, I keep telling you that you’re all ignorant. This is not very nice but I am also ignorant. And you may think I’m not ignorant, I don’t have ignorance but I’m a highly educated intelligent person. But one aspect of our ignorance is that the reality of this earth this is just the conventional truth, forget about the ultimate truth, but a conventional reality of this earth that we’re living in is that it’s impermanent, changing moment by moment.

It doesn’t change every week, every month or every year, it changes every moment, every millisecond it’s decaying. But we don’t experience that. We experience a permanent solid unchanging world because of our ignorance. And we don’t even want to think about that the world is impermanent. We want to believe that our objects of attachment are permanent.

We don’t want to think they’re impermanent, that they won’t last. This is an aspect of our ignorance. And so we have this grasping at permanence in our mind and we have this appearance of me, and we grasp that this me is permanent. It’s such a subtle it’s not this gross heavy concept that we go walking around saying I’m permanent, I’m permanent, right? None of us do that.

But there is this very subtle thought constantly in our mind as part of our ignorance that is holding this belief that I, whatever I am, I am permanent. So that view of course prevents us conceiving that I could be anything else. How could this permanent me be a dog or a ghost or in hell? Impossible because I’m me. I’m never going to change.

And to some extent when we think, well it’s ridiculous to say I could become an animal, I could become a ghost, is true. It is true. In some ways it’s quite intelligent to think, I will never become a dog. Because what we are now will not become a dog, or a ghost, or a hungry ghost or a hell being, or a god, or a demigod. Nothing of what we are experiencing now will become a dog.

The Buddha isn’t saying that. Buddhism is not that primitive. This body isn’t going to turn into a dog. Buddhism isn’t saying that. And Buddhism isn’t saying that our mind goes into a fully formed dog, you know, there’s a few dogs running around here so we get born in one of those.

Buddhism isn’t saying that. Those dog bodies have already got a mind in them, you can’t put another one in. So What we are now, even anyway, the person that we are right now is dependent, that appearance is dependent on this body and dependent on the mind that is at the certain level of mind that is able to, excuse me, operate in this body. Depending on this particular body and the particular mind we have now, there is me. At the time of death this body is finished, the continuum of this body is cut, none of it goes into the next life.

At the time of death, the mind that we have that we are using now, that is operating now, that mind as I try to explain with the analogy of the television set, that mind is dependent, is arising very much dependent on the nervous system and brain of this body, so that mind is not going to go into the next life. It stops completely finished, But it doesn’t mean the totality of the mind stops because this mind that we’re using now, although to a large extent it’s operating, working through this body dependent on the body. Its real basis is a more subtle level of mind and that subtle level of mind basis is the most subtle level of mind. So it’s this most subtle level of mind that goes into the next life. Or to put it another way, it’s from this most subtle level of mind that the appearances and experiences generate, which we call the next life.

Mind is going on moment by moment and it is generating appearances, experiences. A whole continuity of those appearances and experiences on top of that we call a life. So nothing of what we’re and and the me, the me, this wonderful me that we are now, whatever however we conceive that me, that person that we are, is totally dependent on this body and this mind, the ordinary mind of this life. Right? We can’t conceive of a me that is not somehow connected to this body and this mind.

If I’m here, if my body is here, I’m here, I’m not over there. So when this body and this mind finish at the end of this life, Me, the me of this life. Nothing. Nothing left of it. But in the very next moment, in the very next moment, because there is the next moment of consciousness which is the first moment of the next life, there is the subtle mind generating the thought I.

I I I I I I moment by moment. It’s still there. It’s a different I but it has a continuity with the I of this life. Just like we talk about me, you know, we can open up a scrapbook of our high school pictures, baby pictures and you say, That’s me, there’s this little naked baby. You’re forty five years old and you say, That’s me.

That’s me? And in one way it is me, in another way it’s not me. Why can we say it’s me? Because there is a continuity between this little naked baby and what we are now. Yeah, so it’s me.

But there’s been a big change, moment by moment. But you can’t point to some other naked little baby on the bare rug and say, That’s me. You have to point to a particular one, there has to be this continuity, continual connection, right, back, back and into the future, right? So the I of this life, the me of this life stops with the body and mind of this life. But in the next moment, in the next life, the next experience, there is the thought I, which is connected to that previous thought of I.

But it’s a different thought of I because this body is no longer there, this ordinary mind is no longer there. But one is still grasping that the thought of I is arising on something else because something else is appearing there. And what is appearing there, the meat the meat that is appearing there is depending on the karma, the causes we’ve created in our mind. So in our past life or in previous lives, not maybe just in one life but in many different lives, we created the cause for this life. And there was a point in our past life, our immediate past life, where the consciousness of that life stopped, but the very subtle mind continued and in the next moment it entered by the force of karma, or after a short period of time in the Bardo state, by the force of karma it was able to meet the conditions to enter something that became solid, another body.

Fortunately there was no choice about that, no control, but we created good karma so that karma directed our mind into these two bits of liquid, two lumps of liquid that came fortunately from a human man and a human woman. And those bits of liquid joined, our consciousness joined with them, those bits of liquid mixed together and grew. And it grew into a human body with a human brain and a human nervous system. So our subtle mind that entered into those those liquid substances is able to function again with a human consciousness. But it’s possible, it’s equally possible that we die and the subtle mind goes on and it through the power of karma it sees something, it is attracted, something appears, the consciousness through the power of attachment to what is solid, wanting to be solid is drawn to this substance and sinks into it.

It gets trapped into it and this body develops. But it’s a rat body. It’s the sperm and egg of rats, or a cow, or a dog, or a snake, or a fly, or something. Yeah. And the consciousness having entered into that material substance, that material substance grows and our mind can only operate through that that body and that brain and nervous system.

So one ends up having a consciousness of a dog or the consciousness of an ant. Even though our consciousness has Buddha nature, because of our delusion and karma we’ve trapped, we have obscured, we have squashed our consciousness into this very limited realm of awareness and experience. This is what happens according to the Buddha. And I’d like to make when do we finish? Five five, isn’t it?

Five five. Yeah. So, I haven’t left much time, but I’d just like to talk now a little bit about animals having consciousness. Probably most people here are already convinced, maybe everyone is convinced. But if we can understand that animals have mind, have consciousness, if they have consciousness, this consciousness is not somehow separate, a different kind of consciousness than ours.

Is certainly of course, it’s operating at a different level. That’s no question. There is no question about that. But mind is mind. There’s not different kinds of minds that just go on and on in one track.

All minds have the potential to know. They all have Buddha nature. So why is that mind operating at a dog level of consciousness? Because it’s an effect having a cause. Dog consciousness is in effect having a cause.

The cause is following delusion and karma and creating negative karma, heavy following heavy delusions and obscuring the mind more and more, obscuring our Buddha nature more and more. And if you check, animals do have consciousness, they do know things. Of course, there is no animal that has the level of awareness of a human being, generally speaking, maybe a few have, but generally speaking all the different species of animals which includes of course the animal realm includes birds, four legged beings, two legged, insects, fish, all of that the animal realm. None of them possess the intelligence and awareness and so on of a human being, but beings in the animal realm know things. They’re not robots, they’re not television, they’re not walking television sets, they know.

For example, just very gross levels of knowing, animals experience hunger. hunger is an experience. It’s experienced by the mind. It’s not just a hole in the stomach or in the intestines that has to be filled. And even when we ourselves, when we eat a lot, our mind can still be hungry, wanting more because hunger is basically a mental state.

And you can see with dogs, if you ever had a dog, can feed your dog forever and it’s still hungry. Because it’s a mind, it’s not just a physical thing of filling its stomach, there is a mind wanting something, desperate for something. That is mind. It’s not oh, and people say, oh it’s instinct. It’s just instinct.

What is instinct? Please tell me what is instinct? What is the Buddha will tell you what instinct is. Instinct is is when we repeat an action again and again, follow desire again and again and again, strongly again and again, you get instinct. You don’t have to think about it anymore, the imprint is just so unbelievably strong.

But instinct is mind, it is thought, it is thoughtless thought. It is so ingrained one doesn’t have to analyze, you just grab. Yeah? And we have instincts too, good and positive ones and negative ones. Dogs experience pain.

If you hit them, there’s every indication they do not want it. Mean really I’m not trying to make jokes. They do not want this. They do not want. Want.

Want. What is that? That is mind. Want is not a thing, wanting is mind. Dogs do not want to be hit, they do not like being hit.

Liking is mind, they dislike it. If you pat them they like it, they love it, they have attachment, they have desire. Animals get angry, they hate, but also they have affection. They also have altruism, it’s been discovered that certain animal, maybe all animals, but with experiments there are animals who sacrifice their lives to save their own species but also their owners and their owners children. They recognize danger, they re recognize danger.

This is mind, yeah? If you put your finger over an ant, this tiny tiny little bodied thing, it runs away. Why? Because there is fear, there is a recognition of danger, there’s this huge great lump of stuff coming down. This is recognized as danger.

This requires intelligence, not a great deal of intelligence, but it requires intelligence which is mind. And fear arises, fear is a state of mind, and the ant works out an escape route. This requires again some intelligence, Not a great deal but intelligence. This is mind. It’s mind operating at quite a low level but it’s mind.

All my favorite stuff I don’t get to say. Bad planning. Very briefly I have to say my favorite thing is years and years ago when I first became a monk some of you have heard this story, sorry Claire and other people, but there was a National Geographic magazine printed in about nineteen seventy six, seventy seven, seventy eight, something like that, about this woman scientist in America who had taught a female, a six year old female gorilla sign language. She had taught the gorilla about five or six hundred words in sign language. The gorilla had to learn that.

Learning requires mind intelligence. This gorilla could carry on a conversation with this woman. Five hundred or six hundred words is apparently the intelligence of about a four or five year old child or something, I’m not sure, some child psychologist might know. And from these words that the gorilla was taught, the gorilla herself developed some swear words. When she was upset she used some of these words to insult the lady.

I can’t remember what they were but she developed some. The woman also tried to teach a male gorilla, a younger male gorilla the sign language, but he wasn’t as intelligent as the female gorilla. So once this woman, while she was trying to teach the male gorilla some sign language, the female gorilla was in the cage behind and she turned the woman turned around and discovered that the female gorilla was trying to show the male gorilla what to do. Because when the male gorilla learnt a new sign he was allowed to go into the cage with a female gorilla. And the best thing in this article is that at one point the woman asked this gorilla, What are you?

What are you? And the gorilla replied that she was she she is or what she she said I am in sign language she said I am a fine female gorilla. This is mind. Yeah. It’s quite a high level of mind actually.

A fine female gorilla. She had a high opinion of herself. She was feminist gorilla. Just recently, just a few days before I left Australia to come here, saw a program on television about gorillas, chimpanzees that are used for experiments which is just truly horrific, and many of the scientists working with these animals came to the conclusion, these scientists came to this conclusion, that these beings have mind. And it showed one scientist who had been working with a chimpanzee many many years ago, and they also communicated with sign language, and the man had taught the chimpanzee his name, which was Joseph, and the gorilla had developed a sign the chimpanzee had developed a sign language to chop it from Joseph to Joe, you know, the equivalent.

He did this this apparently of sign like that to say Joe, hello Joe. And then this animal was used for all these experiments and the scientist went on to another job somewhere else, and maybe ten, fifteen years later he went back because this chimpanzee had been infected with AIDS or something like that. So it was totally isolated in this horrific cage with bars like that. And this man went up to the gorilla again, and the chimpanzee sorry, it wasn’t a gorilla, was a chimpanzee, and this chimpanzee recognised him and said, Hello Joe. Because the man hadn’t even remembered that he’d taught him this short version of his name, but the chimpanzee remembered and said Hi Joe and was really happy to see him.

And then the man said that when he had to say goodbye he said you could see you could also see the gorilla, the chimpanzee there, that it was like this incredible heavy burden fell on this animal and he just kind of went back and crouched in the back of the cage. Because of course he had no one to talk to, he was in this cage by himself for years. And then he met an old friend. And the old friend talked to him for ten minutes and then went away forever. But this is a being, this is a sentient being with Buddha nature like us.

Yeah. So if this is true, if animals have minds, we can create the cause to have animal mind. Animal mind doesn’t arise. The principal cause of animal mind is not an animal body. It is mind coming into the things that give rise to an animal body.

So I think this is worthwhile thinking about. So we have a short question time, very short? Yes? Right. Right.

Right. I think this is just myself, I’m vegetarian. I wasn’t always a vegetarian Buddhist, but the question is, if this is true, how can Buddhists justify eating meat? I think it’s very difficult actually, to be honest. It’s difficult, but Buddhists are sentient beings.

Not perfect. Slowly, slowly. Yes? What does how does that affect how does meditations at the time? Yeah.

Clear. Clear. It’s very hard to say. I really don’t know what the effect could be. I don’t really know.

Of course, generally speaking it’s much better to have a clear mind at the time of death, especially if one has been a practitioner, because then with that clear mind there’s a chance of maintaining some control at that very last moment. But just because the mind is medicated at the time of death and not conscious, doesn’t mean that there can’t be a good rebirth. Yes? Right. This question about how can we consider the animal realm a lower realm, this is also often asked that why do human beings think they’re the best and everything else is worse.

I mean, just one point, one answer which is probably not very satisfactory is because the Buddha said so. It’s much better to be a human being, but then does anyone really want to be I mean, some people do. Some people want to be born animals, but if you really investigate it it is a more suffering situation. We’ll go into this in more detail, but animals are much more limited than human beings, which are working with their mind. The body is more limited, the mind is more limited.

An animal, even the most intelligent animal that is known, cannot read. So that an animal can’t read the dharma. An animal, even the most intelligent animal, is probably incapable of understanding emptiness or even much lesser concepts. From the point of view of being free of guilt, it’s better to be an animal. If you just want to follow the bodily desires and have a good time, maybe better to be an animal because you don’t have to feel any guilt or shame.

But if one has higher aspirations, then to be an animal is not the way to fulfill those aspirations. And then the point of view of in the case of a tiger or even a cat, and forced to kill and so forth by the very nature, this is exactly what the point is that why the Buddha taught to not create the cause to be an animal, because apart from that state being very limiting and suffering, one is forced by the environment, by the situation to create more and more negative karma. And therefore, it’s a very once one falls into the lower realms, it’s very difficult to get out. It’s possible because at some point the negative karma that traps us in those appearances and experiences runs out. And when it runs out, there is the space for some karma that throws us into the human level of appearance and experience can arise.

And and of course, the thought can arise, but that’s not fair. But it’s got nothing to do with being fair or unfair. It’s to do with the law of cause and effect. We create the cause, we experience the result. If we don’t create the cause, we don’t experience the result.

The tiger can’t contribute to the salvation. Not not, that’s the point, not as an animal. Tiger animals have Buddha nature, but there’s no way to develop the Buddha nature, free it or even remove a little bit of the obscuration in that realm. It’s only in the human realm that we can do that. What’s someone who yes.

So the question is as a human being can we experience the the other realms? Like for example when we’re hungry is that like is that being in the hungry ghost realm are you saying? Or is it like being The main feeling, yes. Yes, certainly as a human being we can have similar experiences to the other realms, perhaps if we develop psychic powers, our mind can perceive those realms and feel something of the suffering. But because of the nature of our mind, as a human being we can’t have the exact same experience.

And God or then you go through the head? No, no, because their level of pleasure is far higher than ours, so that while they’re in that state, they can’t and they wouldn’t even want to. They don’t want to. Okay. One more and then In that, the question is what is the point of reincarnating as a human being if one is very heavily handicapped or has very deep suffering?

From the moment of birth. The answer is that it’s not a question of point, of the point of something. We are born human not because there is a point to it, but because there is a cause. Yeah, right. Yeah.

Yeah. Okay, good question. Again it’s an example of I can’t explain everything at once. Generally, I said generally speaking in the human realm is the best realm. It this I mean, this is true, that the human realm is the best realm to be in to practice the Dharma or the spiritual path, to create the causes to get out of suffering and achieve happiness.

But this does not mean and we’ll go into this in much more detail later on, a little bit later in the course it doesn’t mean that every human being has that chance. Because what we can see in the human realm actually there are many different kinds of human beings. Some human beings have enormous suffering all their life. They’re born into it and they never go beyond incredible suffering their whole life. So such human beings have no chance to practice.

Oh, this is not fair. It’s got nothing to do with being fair. You create the cause, you get the result. Obscure the mind, in the human realm, you get a horrible human life. Some human beings have incredible pleasure and luxury in every wonderful thing their whole life.

And they have all the chance to practice the Dharma, but they never do it because they don’t see any need, because they’ve already got a Rolls Royce. Happiness. They’ve got a fifty room house with marble bathrooms and gold, solid gold taps, happiness. And it’s going to last forever, no need to practice Dharma. But then there are other human beings who have some suffering but not horrible suffering, they have some happiness but not unbelievable happiness in that sphere of human life and with a

Key terms in this teaching

buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
hungry ghost preta (Skt); yi dag (Tib)
The hungry ghost realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence, exemplified by incredible insatiable hunger and thirst. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
six realms
The general way that Buddhism divides the whole of cyclic existence; there are three lower realms (hell, hungry ghost and animal) and three upper realms (human, demigod and god). LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top