DB Mind and its Potential 2010 – 2010 10 24 DB01 Mind And Its Potential 2010 10 24

2 h 10 min · 21,294 words · 24 October 2010

DB Mind and its Potential 2010 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
DB Mind and its Potential 2010 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
DB Mind and its Potential 2010 - 2010 10 24 DB01 Mind And Its Potential 2010 10 24
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. A short guided settling meditation on breath and posture opens the session, followed by a review of mind’s clarity and knowing, the six consciousnesses, and conceptual versus direct perception. The talk then introduces the fifty-one mental factors, the root afflictions of attachment, aversion and ignorance, and dependent arising, and closes with an equanimity meditation on friends, enemies and strangers.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2010-10-24

Duration: 2h 10m

UUID: c65bc6bf-98fa-4712-81b9-c7b666f07a8a

Words: 21,294

So find a comfortable meditation posture. Again, those of you who aren’t familiar with meditation posture, the very next module will go into how to meditate. And that will include looking at our physical posture, looking at how we go about focusing the mind and increasing the qualities in the mind. But for now, the main points to pay attention to are make sure that the back is straight. So whether you’re seated in a chair or sitting on the floor, the back shouldn’t be sort of slouched over.

This really congests the energy. When you have the back upright, then the mind is much more alert and attentive. If you’re sitting in a chair, it’s ideal, they say, to put your feet firmly on the ground in front of you rather than crossing the legs and tucking them underneath you or what have you. And then if you’re sitting on the floor, then certainly just find a comfortable place for your feet, your legs. And if you do need to change your posture, it’s certainly fine to do that.

This won’t be a very long meditation. Some of the other elements of posture that are important to point out at this stage is the head. So again, we don’t want the head sort of drooped over. This again brings the energy down too far. At the same time we don’t want the head overly upright because that might excite the mind a bit too much.

So start with an upright posture, and then just gradually, gently bring the mind or the head down just a little bit. This will allow your gaze to go downward and bringing the gaze down, they say along the line of the nose. We just want to have a soft focus to the eyes with the eyelids slightly open if you can do that. If you need to close the eyelids, if this is uncomfortable, to keep them open just a little bit, just a crack of light. But if it’s uncomfortable to do that, then certainly you’re welcome to close the eyes.

So the other thing about getting into this posture, again you can put your hands wherever they’re comfortable. There’s this traditional posture of the palms up, the thumbs together, the right on top of the left, resting in your lap. But again, any other posture for the arms is perfectly fine at this point. So what we’re going to do before we begin our formal meditation is to just check the body to see if there’s stress, tension. We have a lot of parts of the body where we tend to hold a lot of tension.

We want to bring our awareness there and release it. So I like to do this starting from the crown of the head. So just feel a wave of relaxation first going through the muscles in the face, the muscles in your forehead, around your eyes. Sometimes we don’t even realize how much tension we have there. Releasing the muscles around the mouth and the jaw.

Checking to make sure that the teeth aren’t clenched. Just allow the mouth to relax. And bring your awareness to the back of the head, to the neck, shoulder muscles. We know this is a place where we tend to hold a lot of tension. Just soften the shoulders.

You don’t have to droop them completely, but just allow them to relax. And continuing down the back of the body, releasing the back all the way down to the tailbone, letting your tailbone sort of sink into the cushion or the chair that you’re sitting on. And then the front of the body, Release your chest. Release the abdomen if you can, just allowing the diaphragm as you breathe in to expand, fill up the abdomen. And then finally just check the arms and legs on your own if there’s any tension there.

Just allow it to melt away. So we should have a really nice relaxed quality to the body with this upright posture. And we’re going to bring our awareness now to the sensation of the breath as it enters and exits through the nostrils. So begin to pay attention to it. It’s a very subtle sensation that occurs just inside the nostrils, near the tip of the nose.

Just begin to pay attention to that sensation, allowing the mind to rest there. This is the basic instruction. We’re going to do this for just a few minutes. Just allow the mind to watch the breath with each inhalation, with each exhalation. But we need additional instruction because it’s very difficult to do this if we haven’t trained the mind.

So the mind will get distracted in those cases. And when we notice that the mind all of a sudden is thinking about something we need to do later today, or perhaps something that happened in the past, or perhaps it’s gotten distracted by noises or sensations in the body, Whatever the case, notice that you’re no longer watching the breath. Cease to give that distraction any more attention. Just let it go. And then gently bring the mind back to the breath.

So again, we’ll do this for just a few minutes to focus the mind, try to reduce the distraction to some degree. And then we’ll have a short guided meditation to set a positive motivation for our time here today. So I’ll ring the chime to begin this session. So as you continue to watch the breath, see if you can become aware of the mind that is observing the breath, the subjective experience of that. It’s kind of awareness of awareness itself.

So what we’re becoming aware of is the mind. And we’ve talked about how this mind has the nature of clarity, luminosity. It’s nonmaterial. And it has the function of knowing, becoming aware of things. And as we’ve been also discussing, our minds have the ability to change.

We have the opportunity with this life to begin to address the changes that we want to make to our minds and therefore to our lives. We can choose to increase those qualities that help us to be more at peace and that allow others around us to also experience more well-being. Qualities like loving kindness, compassion, patience, a generous spirit. And we can also choose to diminish and eventually even be rid of those mental states that aren’t so beneficial. Minds of greed, anger, hatred, jealousy, pride.

So everything begins with the mind. Everything comes from the mind. And one of the most powerful way that we have of affecting our minds and our lives is by setting very positive intention. And particularly as we’re going to engage in the Buddhist teachings once again on this Sunday morning, it’s important that we set a very far reaching intention, motivation, thinking that we’re here to learn about the mind, to develop our qualities and remove the negative tendencies. Primarily, it starts with ourselves, with understanding that, again, this is the source of our satisfaction.

The deeper peace that we seek is possible through developing our own minds. But moreover, we begin to see that we’re connected to others. You can think about the people we have in our lives right now, and even those who may not be in our lives right now, but who are also affected by who we are and what we do. And through the profound level of interdependence that all beings have, we can see that we can have a profound impact on so many beings just by developing our own qualities and removing those disturbing states of mind. So set this as your intention for being here, having the wish to explore the potential in your own mind to discover what lies there.

In this way, what we do today will have profound impact on so many beings, can’t even imagine. And in this way, we will experience what we have always sought, the deepest level of peace and satisfaction that is attainable, our own state of complete enlightenment. So you can open your eyes fully. And we will do a short review. We do have a few new people in the room, and I want to go through a few of the points that we’ve already discussed.

Again, this whole module is the starting point for discovering Buddhism. It’s an opportunity to kind of understand the arena in which the Buddha’s teachings are taught. You know, the Buddha didn’t emphasize that we need to change the world around us, the external world. This was not his focus. His focus was on the inner world, the world of our own minds.

So as I said in the meditation today, when we talk about mind, we talk about that which is clear and knowing. This is the nature of the mind, its clarity, its luminosity, the fact that in Buddhism, mind has its own substantial causes, which are previous moments of mind that have that same nature. So we did talk a bit a few weeks ago about the relationship between the mind and the body. And obviously there’s an interdependence going on. But we can still talk about very subtle levels of mind that can exist independent of the brain.

Now Western science might find this challenging because of various positions that we looked at, but in Buddhist thinking, mind can only arise from that which has the same nature as it. So when we talk about its nature being clarity or luminosity, this implies it being nonmaterial. And while, again, it can have an interdependence with that which is material, it in and of itself is not material. So how could mind arise from a primary cause that is material? So in the Buddhist thinking, mind has its own continuity.

And the implications of this, of course, are that we can never find a beginning to the mind. That while Western science might say that mind starts when there’s enough electrochemical stuff going on in a brain of a human being so that then consciousness arises. The Buddha would say that this is simply not true. That there are previous moments of a mental continuum that come even before that functionality of a brain. So we can never, going back, can never find like an initial moment where our mind started.

And this is the understanding that is in the Buddhist teachings, as well as, to some degree, some of the other Asian philosophies and spirituality. It’s an understanding of kind of the continuity, and then therefore the reincarnation and rebirth countless times. Going forward we never find an end to mind either, because there’s always that moment of mind giving rise to another one, giving rise to another one, another one, and so on. So these are some of the ideas that we already discussed. Last week we began to go into a little more detail on what we would call Buddhist epistemology.

Epistemology is kind of understanding how the mind works. So actually I did get around to a few people to give a handout from last week. Might need to have someone run upstairs and do a few more copies. There’s a little chart that I gave you. I hope some of you brought that back.

Could you do that, Claudio? Maybe run about six, seven of those. Yeah. Thanks. Here’s one here.

And those of you who still need one, when Claudio returns I can get that to you. But on this chart you’ll see that we began talking about kind of how there are different levels of this consciousness. Again, consciousness, this again is working with the other side of the definition of mind. So while we talk about mind being clear and luminous, it has the function of knowing. So we equate words like mind, consciousness, awareness.

These are all referring to that entity that has the ability to know. So just like space is clear in knowing, space, however, doesn’t have the function of knowing. When we add that function of knowing, then we are clearly talking about the arena of mind, that mere clarity and knowing that has the ability to take in all the various phenomena that we perceive. Well, there are six consciousnesses in traditional Buddhist thinking, and these revolve around the five sense consciousnesses and our mental consciousness. And we talked a little bit last week about how they have different ways of knowing.

How our sense consciousnesses only know things through what we call direct perception. That means that as we observe a color, or we hear a sound, or we smell a flower, that we are directly knowing that phenomenon through that sense consciousness. It is empowered by our sense organ to be able to know that particular phenomenon. So we see that the five sense consciousnesses are somewhat limited. Why?

Because they’re only capable of knowing a particular type of object. Maybe I know Albert needs one. There’s probably several other people that need one. Eric. And did you need one, Emery?

You left it? Okay. Yeah, if anyone left it at home, you’re certainly welcome to take one. Eric. So on the left hand side there you’ll see the chart where we’ve got the main mind divided into a grosser level that has mental consciousness and these five sense consciousnesses.

So on the right hand side you’ll see how even mental consciousness can be divided further up. But let me go back to sense consciousness. Sense consciousnesses are only working with what we call perception, meaning they’re only knowing things in this very direct way, and they’re only knowing the object that they are empowered to know. So can we see a sound? Can we hear the smell of a flower?

I mean, we have very limited capacity within the five sense consciousnesses. Mental consciousness is kind of pulled out of these, and again talked about on that right hand side, because mental consciousness is, again, the arena in which we are primarily doing the work in Buddhism. We can understand that even mental consciousness has an ability to know things through perception, through this direct way. But right now it’s somewhat limited in our own minds. Most of our mental consciousness, most of this six consciousness is conception, conceptual mind.

The conceptual mind, as we spoke about last week, knows things a little bit differently. So if I asked you to, you know, think about I did this last week think about the first few notes of Beethoven’s Fifth Symphony, which I think most people know. And if you don’t know it, then you can think about the first few notes of your favorite song. And you are thinking about conceptualizing an auditory object, something that you’ve known through your hearing. But are you actually knowing that object directly at that time?

No, you’re knowing it through what we would call a meaning generality, a generic image, a mental image. There’s lots of ways that this term is translated. But our conceptual mind always does that. Whenever we are thinking about something involved in conceptual thought, We are all of a sudden working with something that isn’t really the object itself. It’s sort of a reflection of the object.

It’s a way that we have of thinking about it. And what happens is we sort of mix together our thought of the object with the object itself. And that can be a little bit detrimental at times, particularly if we have unhealthy thoughts about that object. And we’re going to be talking about this mostly today and kind of getting into what we would call Buddhist psychology, understanding the various states of mind that we have, picking them apart, and being able to understand are they accurate, are they inaccurate, what are they doing to our minds when they arise, all this type of thought process. But our thinking is what really gets us into trouble, because if we had simply the direct perception, we would simply know an object and we wouldn’t go any further.

Now of course we can also use our conceptual mind in a beneficial way. You can have positive thoughts about what you’re experiencing. So let’s take an annoying person in your life, somebody who challenges you, pushes your buttons, maybe has even harmed you. We tend to choose to see them, to see an image of them in our own mind through just whatever we’re experiencing through our senses. It might be the sounds of their voice, the sight of their appearance, all these various things we put together and we create a mental image of who they are.

And we see them as annoying person, you know, difficult person, person I want to avoid, person who I’d just as soon never see again in my life. We create all this story about them through our conceptual mind. And that conceptual mind is kind of dealing with that person and the stimuli that we’re getting from that person in a very indirect way. But that’s what thought does, is it takes that, creates an image, and then begins to work with it. Now we can, as I was saying just a minute ago, we can choose to work with that in a positive way with our conceptual mind.

We might begin to see them in a different light. We might look at them and think, Oh, how horrible that they have a mind that chooses to be this way, that is a difficult person for myself and others, that says mean things to others. We can begin to look at them with eyes of compassion and love as opposed to eyes of hatred or anger. So this is where conceptual mind is not necessarily although it is working with things indirectly, and that is a sort of mistaken way of knowing it’s not necessarily a faulty mind. It can actually understand things correctly, and it can develop.

And this is this little bit that we were in on this side where it says mental consciousness conception, and then it goes into wrong ideas, doubt, presumption, and inference. I went through this last week, how we kind of work away from and this is the whole Buddhist process all of Buddhist philosophy is basically about understanding what are the wrong ideas that we have. And what is it that the Buddha is telling us that we should take a look at and really examine, is this correct or isn’t it correct? Then we begin to perhaps move away from that with some sense of doubt, because we begin to understand that maybe the ways that we’ve been looking at things isn’t quite correct. Then we develop a correct presumption, an assumption about how things actually are.

We start moving away from wrong ideas to what is true, what is correct. And eventually we develop an inferential cognition, which is when we actually use our minds, our conceptual minds, to reason through things and understand things and get sort of an incontrovertible agreement to how things actually exist. Eventually though, this is all to drive us into the very top here on this right hand side, perception, particularly the second one that’s mentioned there, yogic perception. This term yogi again is referring to someone who is a practitioner who is trying to work with their minds. And so a Buddhist yogi, the goal of that practitioner is to develop a very deep understanding of things that no longer becomes conceptual.

It’s no longer with this idea of things, it’s actually knowing reality directly. So we could say all the goal of Buddhist thinking is to produce a yogic direct perception in our minds. And we have the capability of doing this. It does require meditation, which again is in the next module. It does require developing wisdom, and we talked about the three levels of wisdom.

The final one is wisdom arisen through meditation. But that’s preceded by our developing a wisdom through hearing, listening, reading, and thinking about what we’ve heard, contemplating it, beginning to understand it. That eventually will drive us away from our wrong ideas towards a correct presumption, towards an inferential wisdom, one that we’ve gained through our reasoning, and eventually into a direct perception, which is that third level of wisdom, the wisdom arising from meditation. Okay, questions on that so far? That was a whole lot in a very short period of time that we covered in the last few weeks.

Yeah, Leah. You may have just talked about this. Is that intuition? Intuition? I don’t think so.

I think at some level, you know, there might be these bits of an intuitive mind that have some understanding of how things exist or how we really should be in the world, but I don’t think that we would equate the two necessarily. And intuition, if we have any sense of intuition, I think it’s coming from perhaps having done the work somewhere along the line in the past. You know, intuition is a very strange concept. I don’t even know that there’s a Tibetan word for intuition. I think that at some level we could talk about everything falling into some realm of knowledge, wisdom.

And maybe what we call intuition is just a sort of deeper level of knowledge that we’ve gained from some past experience that’s sort of waiting for us to need to apply it at a particular time. But I would say that the Buddha wouldn’t have a keen idea of what we mean by intuition. What do you mean by intuition is probably another thing we should explore. It’s a strange word, yeah. It gets used in different contexts, too, so It does.

I always feel like I feel it A sort of gut or heart feeling, yeah, yeah. No, and that’s why I think that in my understanding of what the Buddha teaches, we would call that some level of deeper wisdom that we have. And next, I think it might be the final class, not next week, we are going to look at this sort of what we mean by this deeper level of wisdom and awareness that we would call Buddha nature. That we do have some glimpses of, we do have some ability to tap into, but it’s kind of there all the time. And this is the deeper level that we want to be able to expose and eventually live in that, abide in that level of awareness.

Well, yeah. So I think the Buddha would say you trust your inner wisdom. And the inner wisdom, if we want to equate that with intuition, will tell us, again, whether we are resonant with how things are or whether we’re going astray, whether we’re kind of moving in a direction where there’s going to be more conflict, more difficulty, more challenges to ourselves and those around us. This is something we’ll get into a little bit today, too, when we start talking about because we have to I mean, this trusting in a deeper level of intuition is a nice thought. But I think what we have to understand is our minds are mostly working on a pretty gross level right now.

And we can do a lot of work right now at this level of kind of how these afflictive states of mind arise and beginning to confront them and work with them. And the deeper level of understanding will be impact to a large degree by the work we do at this more discursive level. When we were talking about I didn’t mention this yet in today’s class, but over on the other side, on that left hand side where you look at how there is a gross level of mind, and then there is subtle and very subtle. Again, this we will go into in more detail in the sixth class. But the understanding here is that we’re mostly kind of operating at if you compare it to an ocean, you know, the waves of an ocean, we’re kind of up here with all the waves, all the sort of crazy stuff that’s going on.

You go deeper into the ocean and it becomes calmer, more still. You go to the very depths of the ocean and things are unbelievably still, not so much movement at all. And this is kind of the states of mind that in Buddhist thinking as well will allow us to tap into a deeper level of wisdom and understanding, and will allow us to generate these direct perceptions of how things exist. These I know I start sounding like a lot of terminology and it’s something that we will be exploring in time over the course of discovering Buddhism. But just to have some awareness that what you are experiencing right now is, again, quite a gross level of awareness most of the time.

And those glimpses that we might have at a subtler state kind of poke through and kind of take a little, you know, gander at what’s underneath the surface. An intuition or this deeper level of wisdom, an inner sense of how we need to be in the world, it’s all there. We just have to find ways to tap into it. But the initial work is kind of right up here on the surface, to at least not get so caught up in all the waves and try to calm our minds a bit in regard to what we’re experiencing in the grosser level of consciousness. Okay?

Other questions about this? Yes, Albert. Right, right. How my view Okay. I’ll be getting into this to some degree today when we begin to look at sort of what’s the underlying ignorance that’s operative in all of this.

And we can say at some level we want to develop a non dual awareness. We want to develop an awareness that isn’t caught up in, yeah, this and that, right and wrong, black and white, whatever the case might be, But abiding in a state of awareness of the fundamental nature of all things being the same. And this, again, we’ll go into in a little more detail today. But as we work in the conventional world, we can still understand that there is a conventional reality that we need to accord with in order to produce the results that we want. And it’s not to sort of embrace duality in an ultimate way or a final way, but understand it in a relative way.

And so the relative nature of things is some sense of duality. The ultimate level of how things exist is with none of that whatsoever. So it’s a bit of a paradox to hold in the mind, but we’ll get to that. And even in this first course, I do introduce in today’s class in particular kind of what is this fundamental level of error that we’re making and how is it removed by a deeper level of wisdom. But obviously this takes a while to develop, and we don’t really get around to a full on discussion of it until much later in Discovering Buddhism, I think module twelve on the wisdom of emptiness.

But, yeah, it’s a good point. Duality in and of itself can serve a function within the relative nature of things. But after that, we can certainly understand that there is a nondual ultimate nature to things that is beyond all of that. Yeah. It’s a good point.

Okay. Other questions or comments before we plunge into the next topic? One thing I do want to mention here, this little box that’s towards the bottom, we haven’t really talked about this over here, and this is where we’re going to go today to some degree, and I’ve got another handout for you. But this other last little bit that’s at the bottom on the right hand side, the conditions for awareness, I just want to clarify something I said last week because I read up a little bit more on these three. These are sort of the conditions for a moment of awareness to arise.

And let’s go through these once more. So if you talked about the eye consciousness knowing yellow, so we had a lot of yellow in the room, you know, choose a yellow. When your eye consciousness is observing that yellow, there’s three conditions for that awareness to arise. The very first one is the actual object. So for our sense consciousness, it is the color yellow.

So we can objectively talk about how there is a color yellow that is appearing to our eye consciousness. The second one, the base, is the sense organ itself. So if you were, you know, if you were born blind, you know, without functioning sense organs, you would be incapable of producing an awareness knowing yellow, an eye consciousness observing yellow, because you’re missing a key condition for having that awareness. So we need the yellow, we need a functional sense base, and we also need an immediate condition. The immediate condition is just pointing to the fact that any awareness arises from an immediate moment of awareness just prior to it.

As I was saying earlier, we have this chain of mental moments. The only way you can have an eye consciousness knowing yellow is if just before that you had another moment of consciousness. And that moment of consciousness could have been doing whatever. Could have been thinking, it could have been listening to a Mozart symphony, it could have been doing a zillion and one things. And all of a sudden, an eye consciousness knowing yellow arises because of that immediate moment.

That’s one other condition that’s necessary. So when we talk about Oh, go ahead, Steve. So is it the case then that awareness has only to do with objects that are sensed? No. And that’s why, again, while this was written here, it says, Example, the five sense objects.

We can definitely say that there would be times when an object of thought can be the object condition. However, even when we have an object of Or when we are thinking about the yellow, like say we look at the yellow and our eye consciousness, it appears to our eye consciousness, and then we begin thinking about it. We get involved in the conceptual mind. Like when Claudio was trying to pick out what yellows were here, had little swatches of the yellow or whatever they call them, the samples. Know, and so we were looking at them and kind of comparing them and going, Well, how would that look?

And thinking about it as, you know, an entire wall and what have you. And we have an ability to start working with our conceptual mind using that as an object. But we could still say that the object condition is that yellow that we looked at through our eye consciousness, but then we start thinking about. But we can even have some things that are purely in the mental domain. Like, think about time.

Does time have a physical basis? No. I mean, we have little watches that kind of show how time is passing, but our watches are not time. Time is a thought. Time is something that we can use as an object and think about time, or think about impermanence, the changing nature of things.

We have a lot of conceptual, purely conceptual domain ideas that we would then, in a sense, want to call the object condition for that. But when we’re talking about a physical object, we generally point to that and say that is our object that gives rise to, whether it be a mental consciousness or a sense consciousness, the knowing of that, the awareness of that. Now this is thrown in here in part because this is just a part of our general study of the mind, and to be aware that there are all these elements coming together for us to know something. But the bigger point I raised earlier in terms of how conceptual mind, thinking mind, knows things indirectly and works with things in a much different way than our sense consciousnesses do. Our sense consciousnesses don’t create hatred or dislike or whatever.

Our sense consciousnesses simply bring the raw information in. It’s we who decide, you know, I really don’t like that yellow, or I love that yellow, or I’m neutral about that yellow. It’s a conceptual framework that often gets involved in all the stuff that causes us problems or difficulties, as well as frees us from all of our problems and difficulties. That was basically, in a nutshell, the message I wanted to get across last week that I hope I got across. Today’s yeah, So just picking up on what Steve was saying, like, our dreams would fall into more than Yeah, exactly.

Whatever experience we have with our dreams. I mean, have objects like, you know, a person in your life that appears in your dream that is sort of a reference of that. But dream objects in and of themselves, yeah, are purely mental phenomenon. They’re arising in the course of our mental consciousness and sleep. We don’t have our sense consciousness as operative in sleep.

They basically say sleep itself is defined as the withdrawal of the senses, and abiding in a subtler level of our mental consciousness. So there’s lots of things when we think about it that are in the pure domain of thought, you know, in terms of not really having a reference outside of it. But, again, what we do with those is the big key, is kind of understanding that this is how conceptual mind works, which may be news to many of you, kind of going, Wow, I never thought about the fact that I think about things, and that that’s somewhat different than the actual object that I might be experiencing. You know, what happens when we taste a vegetable that we don’t like? It’s purely a taste sensation of putting that brussels sprout.

It’s my own thing. Putting that on our tongue and tasting it and going, you know. But in and of itself, does it have the It really is just a taste sensation. It is just whatever, you know, gives rise to that gustatory, you know, arisal of stuff in my mouth. And then my conceptual mind gets all involved and it goes, Oh, that’s horrible.

Oh, I don’t want to eat that. Don’t ever give me that again. So All right. Any other questions or comments? Leah?

Doesn’t what? Hold significance. No, I’m not saying they don’t hold significance. I’m just saying that they’re in this domain of mental thought arising without kind of another object. They are the object of that mental consciousness.

Now, our dreams There’s different ideas around dreams in Buddhist thinking. There’s actually even a process what we call dream yoga, where you bring an awareness into your dream and actually use your dream state of mind as a very powerful mind for spiritual practice. So it’s not to say that dreams have no significance. And even in ordinary people who dream, they might have great significance in terms of, again, functioning at that subtler level of mind to work things through or to, you know, help the mind in some way to process things. There can be lots of benefit to dreams.

But I wouldn’t say that dreams are kind of the main focus of Buddhist practice, because we’re only dreaming a portion of our day. What are we doing the rest of the day? Walking around with a mind that’s is involved in the world and all the things in the world, and that’s the more important work that we need to do. You know, but it’s not to devalue dreams in any way. Okay.

All right. Let’s go ahead then and look at initially these categories of what we call mental factors, and begin to talk a little bit about what we mean by mind and mental factors in this division. So if you look over here, again, on the left hand side, you’ll see that we talk about mind there. That’s very similar to that definition that we have at the top, just kind of the whole arena of anything that we would call having the nature of clarity or luminosity and knowing and awareness. But we have that in kind of a raw form in terms of what we call a main mind, meaning that this is sort of just the arena of pure experience, pure awareness.

We call kind of it presences and relates to objects. Just kind of understands them to be, again, outside here or within our mind, and becomes aware of them. When we come down to this other part and talk about mental factors, mental factors is more along the lines of what characterize and qualify the objects that are known by mind. Again, this phrase, characterize and qualify, or get involved in kind of other features of the object. Mind is simply kind of reflecting it in, this main mind, whereas mental factors are getting to the detail, getting to the ways in which those objects are experienced, ideas about them, and so on.

There’s mental factors involved in every moment of our mind. I’m going to talk a lot more about them in a moment. I want to give you Jeffrey Hopkins. This is a little more scholarly definition of these, but it’s worth going through take a look at. He says, A mind, a main mind here, is a knower of the mere entity of an object.

Again, just kind of presencing that object. Whereas a mental factor is a knower which on the basis of observing that object engages in the object from the point of view of other features such as function and so forth. An analogy for this that might also help. Geshe Tashi Sering says this is sort of like a cinema. And when we go to the movies, the theater, there’s a blank screen upon which all the images are projected, right?

The blank screen is like your main mind, just capable of holding whatever is reflected to it. Then the individual film that is shown, you know, the foreign film or the action film or the comedy or whatever, that is the mental factors. That’s kind of apprehending the particular aspect of that experience. So just kind of what fills in our experience of the world are the mental factors. What allows us to experience the world is main mind.

So when we picked apart main mind last week, were mostly talking about kind of this grosser level as well as subtler levels of our awareness of various objects. When we get down to the bottom, we’re going to go through this grouping of fifty one different mental factors. Tibetan Buddhists like lists, by the way. You probably have noticed that so far already. But there are fifty one mental factors that go back to what is called the Abhidharma studies.

Abhidharma is the body of the Buddhist literature that deals with kind of knowledge and wisdom. And in this traditional approach that goes back to the teachings of Vasubandhu that he derived from the Buddhist teachings, there are fifty one different mental factors, fifty one different little individual things that we can pick apart in the mind. Not all of these present at the same time, obviously, or else it would be very confusing. But some of them are present in conjunction with others, certainly. And you never have any moment of main mind where none of these mental factors are present.

They’re always kind of arising together. We always have an awareness of something with some of these operative. So the very first one you see there are called the five ever present, or omnipresent ones. They’re called that because they’re there all the time. You know, you cannot have a moment of mind without these five being present.

And we’re going look at them in a moment. I’ll give you another handout. We’ll go into those in more detail. The next five, that next set, are called the five object ascertaining. They kind of help us to determine and relate to objects in particular ways.

But they’re still quite neutral. The first five are also neutral in terms of they don’t they only take on the flavor of the mind that is operative. They’re just kind of functional, very functional in regard to how we’re relating to things. And those five object determining, whenever we’re working with an object, most of them are present, but they’re not ever present. They’re not omnipresent.

The eleven virtues. These are a key one in Buddhist thinking because when we understand these, then we know sort of what are the wholesome states of mind, the mind that gives rise to positive states of being. And as we’re going to discuss next week, are operative in terms of karma, in terms of producing results through these being the cause for those results. Virtue giving rise to favorable results in our lives. So we will talk a little bit about the eleven virtues.

I’ll introduce you to them in a moment. The next one is the six root afflictions. The six root afflictions are those sort of disturbing states of mind. This word affliction, there’s a lot of different words for this. Sometimes we talk about affliction, sometimes we talk about delusion, sometimes we talk about disturbing emotions.

They all have kind of an interesting flavor to them, though. Disturbing emotions talks or afflictions even talks about how they make the mind unsettled. They don’t bring peace to the mind. They actually make the mind quite agitated, stirred up. The other term that I mentioned, delusion, this really gets to something we’ve already touched on a little bit, which is these minds are fundamentally deluded.

They’re looking at things in a way that isn’t in accord with how things actually exist. They are delusions. They are You know, when we talk about that you’re delusional, when we say somebody’s delusional, we mean that they are kind of thinking up something on their own. They are superimposing, imagining something that isn’t really there. All the delusions do that.

And they are all based on a fundamental delusion, the delusion of ignorance, that is already an exaggeration, a superimposing of something that isn’t even there at all. And again, we’re going to talk about that. That’s one of our six root delusions, six root afflictions. The next are twelve secondary afflictions. Out of those main ones, you also have other states of mind, mental states, that are troublesome for us.

And these are just different shades of the main delusions, as you’ll see. We’re not going to go into those in great detail today, but I’ll give you the list. You can become aware of them yourself. On the very end there are the four variable mental factors. The four variable mean that by their nature they’re not going to be one way or another.

We’ll look at these, but one of them, for example, is regret. I mean, you might think, well, you know, sometimes in Buddhism we use the term regret to talk about those things that we did that were unwholesome. You know, like if we said something really mean to somebody, you get a feeling of regret. Well, is a positive state of mind, right? It’s very wholesome, to regret saying something negative to somebody.

However, we can also regret doing something very kind for someone, right? You know, just gave somebody, you know, five dollars on the street, and then I go to buy coffee and look at my wallet and there’s no five dollars and I go, Oh, my gosh, you know, I really wish I hadn’t given that money away. And we develop a sense of regret at some act that was very positive that we did. You we might even want to go back and get it from them or something. Then we even get into worse stuff because we’ve developed a negative sense of regret.

So regret by itself is variable. It has the ability to be negative, it has the ability to be positive, wholesome, unwholesome, depending upon the situation. All right. Let’s go into more detail then and actually pick these apart a little bit more and begin to understand them. So let’s pass this around.

Should be plenty for everyone. Any questions before we go on? Is everybody with me? Yeah, Mark. If there were a scale of headiness to the studies, where do think it’s falls?

This is one of the more technical studies in terms of I mentioned last week that this is part of what we call Lorik. Lorik means mind and awareness. It is a form of study that is done in the monasteries, sometimes at a bit of an early age, but because you need to kind of understand the whole arena of epistemology and Buddhist psychology. But it can be quite complicated. It’s usually taught from there’s different schools of Buddhist thinking and it’s taught from one of the lower schools, so it gets to be a little confusing because the way it’s taught isn’t really the way that kind of we hold a lot of this as well in a From the point of view of Tibetan Buddhism.

But it can be a very complex subject. We will teach it here. I’ll probably teach it here sometime at the Towards the end of next year is my guess, latter half of next year. And it’s a wonderful, yeah, course to embark on, just to kind of pick apart the mind and know what’s all going on. Does the mind really work?

And, you know, what are the elements of mind? But what I’m trying to give you here is just enough to skim the surface so that you get some appreciation for that approach, but mostly to focus on the behavioral aspects of that. You know, what does this mean for us? And you can spend months studying, you know, Lorig, but if you don’t apply it in your mind and in your life, well, then there’s not a whole lot of point to it. So, okay.

Mental pathways to eliminate them in L1. Yeah, to some degree. To some degree. I mean, some of them are relatively easy to understand. You know, as we go through these, you’ll see and again, some of them we just need to become aware of so that we understand when they’re arising in our mind and do what we can to either increase them because they’re wholesome or decrease them because they’re not so good for our minds.

Yeah. Everyone has a copy? Okay. So this appendix two, the fifty one mental factors, is going to list them in the categories that we talked about in a slightly different order. So the five ever present, these omnipresent mental factors, are feeling, discrimination or discernment, intention, contact, and then what we would call mental engagement or attention.

I’m not going to go into these in great detail again because I mostly want to focus on the more practical aspects of looking at these in the mind. The first one is extremely significant. In fact, the first two. The Buddha actually singled these two out and called these part of what we call the five aggregates, meaning sort of when we talk about the basis of a person, these two mental states are the two that the Buddha picked out to kind of focus on and say, These are a key thing by what we mean by a sentient being, a being who is involved in the world. And feeling is primarily there because we have three different feelings, generally they say.

Three flavors to feeling in the mind. And we always have one of these operative. We have a feeling of kind of pleasant, what we sometimes would call happiness, but some sort pleasant feeling, we have an unpleasant feeling. Might even call this pain, but pain, again, has another connotation to maybe being further down the line, because you might just have a level of aversion to something. I wouldn’t call the taste of a brussels sprout painful, but I’d call it unpleasant.

Then we have neutral feeling. Neutral feeling is when we’re not necessarily feeling one way or the other. We have a lot of those during our day, right? You know, we’re not really particularly pleased, and we’re not unpleased, you know, displeased. We’re sort of dealing with that in between.

Well, is the problem with these three that they were singled out? In and of themselves, they’re not a problem. You just have pleasant feeling, unpleasant feeling, neutral feeling. The problem comes in later when we’re going to talk about the delusions, because these are sort of what drive, to some degree, definitely two of the root delusions, but even some of the other ones in terms of when we are involved in particularly what is pleasant and what is unpleasant, we tend to overreact. We tend to have a whole set of conceptual stuff that goes on.

We’ve talked about this already a little bit, and I’ll go into it in more detail when we turn the page. But for now, let’s just acknowledge that feeling is one of the big drivers in our lives, particularly since we get quite obsessed with, and as we’re going to see in looking at the afflictions, getting more of the pleasant feelings and trying to avoid the unpleasant ones. The neutral ones we don’t really have a feeling about in regard to our own experience, to sort of say, Well, they’re kind of there. I really want more of the pleasant ones, and I really want to avoid the unpleasant ones. And that leads to, again, some problems in our delusions that we’re going to talk about.

But these are what give flavor to our experience of the object. The second one, discrimination, was singled out by the Buddha because this is what kind of notes the characteristics and kind of identifies the objects, serves as kind of a basis for our retention of what that object is. So when we are in a particular experience, let’s go back to the first time that I tasted a brussels sprout. I had a discrimination of that in a particular way. There was a feeling that arose.

That feeling got interpreted and I was discriminating and characterizing the Brussels sprout in a way that allows me then to retain an image of Brussels sprout in my mind that to this day causes me to have some aversion to it. Bearing all before you today. But this is, again, another level of function in our mind that gets us into some trouble. Why? Because our discriminations often, again, involve some level of superimposition, some level of kind of working with something, categorizing it, putting it in a particular place, because we’ve discriminated it in that way.

We can even see where in the world at large we get discrimination of views that we hold to in a very fixed fundamentalist kind of way. And this is also problematic, because any time that we are using discrimination in that way, we are simply not allowing some kind of space around it. We are using our own characterization of it and adhering to that. So these two were singled out by the Buddha as being two of the primary ones. It’s kind of interesting.

He didn’t choose some of the delusions as something that we base a description of what a sentient being is on. He used these two because these two, although they’re present with every single moment of mind, they cause us to do all these other things just on the basis of experiencing a feeling or discriminating an object in a particular way. All right? Yes? If they’re present with every single moment of mind, is that regardless of whether it’s an enlightened mind or an enlightened mind?

Absolutely. So in the sixth class we are going to talk about kind of an omniscient mind, a Buddha’s mind, what does that mean. And we would say that all five of these are present in every moment of every single mind of any being who has a mind. Well, that’s how we define a being, is that which has a mind, has sentience and ability to know, feel, be involved in objects. So intention is also one I want to talk about briefly, though, although it wasn’t singled out by the Buddha as one of these five major components of a sentient being.

Intention we’re going to talk about a bit more next week when we get into karma. They actually say that when it comes down to it, karma or action is intention. Now intention, of course, in and of itself doesn’t have a value one way or the other. It’s just present in our mind. We always have some level of intention.

We could define intention in a sense let me give you the very classical definition out of this book by Geshe Rabten that we use for the low rig course. Intention is defined as a distinct mental factor that moves the primary mind with which it bears these similarities of a mental factor, as well as the other attendant mental factors of that primary mind to the object. This movement of the mind towards an object is what we mean by intention. In and of itself, again, we’re just moving the mind towards various objects. What happens is that this intention takes on a flavor by virtue of the wholesome or unwholesome states of mind that we bring to it.

So in that way we have an intention, a strong intention towards a particular being that maybe again we find annoying or difficult, and we therefore are more inclined to act in harmful ways towards that being. Intention at its very root level, though, is just simply this movement of the mind, the mind that’s moving towards things. He says here, It is both the conscious and the automatic moving I’m sorry, conscious and automatic motivating element of consciousness that causes the mind to involve itself with and apprehend its objects. So a lot of this is automatic. A lot of it is simply the way that we are in the world and the way that we get drawn to particular things.

It’s our intention that is drawing us there. It’s looking at the objects that we desire, avoiding the objects that we don’t want to be involved in. So these are all it’s kind of interesting when you get into this discussion of these mental factors, it’s a way of kind of picking apart and isolating parts of an entire experience. And that’s the thing that we have to keep aware of, is that we’re not we can isolate them in that way, but they are part of our full sphere of knowing. And these five in particular are always there.

But just briefly, contact just acts as the basis basis for feeling in that it is the mental factor that allows the object itself to come together with those various conditions in our mind so that we produce an awareness of them. And then mental engagement or attention kind of filters information. Whereas discrimination looks at the particular characteristics. Mental attention gets rid of all the things that we’re not looking at and looks at the thing that we want to. So when I said look at the yellow on the wall, you’re not seeing at that time all the other colors in the room, and maybe you’re not even hearing sounds at that time, you’re just focusing on that color.

That’s what we mean by mental engagement or attention. So we can get a flavor for how these are kind of all operating together, every single moment of mind. We have them. The five object ascertaining I’m not going go into in great detail. There are, again, aspiration, belief or appreciation, mindfulness, stabilization or concentration, and knowledge.

The last, I mean all of these do play a role and they can become very virtuous states of mind when we combine them with virtuous sinking. But you can have, again, equally non virtuous thoughts in regard to all these. Mindfulness is one of the main ones that we’re going to be looking at, as well as stabilization or concentration in the next module. Mindfulness is a word that gets used a lot in the English vocabulary to refer to a lot of different things. Mostly what we’re talking about in this Buddhist presentation is your ability to recollect and stay aware of something, to not lose it, to have this non forgetfulness.

Sometimes people equate the term mindfulness with presence, you know, like having a mindfulness, being present with what’s going on. Well, in that sense you’re not forgetting the object. But here we’re talking about a very specific skill that means that you are on what you’re doing and not and retaining it, recollecting it at every moment. But mindfulness, again, is a skill. It’s an element of our mind that we can develop as to how we’re relating to objects.

And as Venerable Robina, who’s taught here a number of times before, says, you know, even a good thief needs mindfulness. You know? So we can apply it to good things, bad things. It is a skill. It is a factor of our mind, a function of our mind that allows us to work with objects in that way.

Concentration has more to do with the ability to remain on the object. While mindfulness is the non forgetfulness that keeps us from being distracted, the actual retaining of the object and holding onto it is meditative concentration or stabilization. These two work very much in tandem. Mindfulness and meditative concentration or stabilization. And again, we all have these to some degree.

In the How to Meditate module we’re going to look at how we work with them to strengthen them. Then of course, knowledge, intelligence. Again, this is just the ability of the mind to know objects in a deeper way, to determine their value, to discern them more closely. But knowledge in and of itself, again, can be knowledge of that which leads to more difficult things for us, that which leads to more positive things for us. So we can’t really in and of itself call knowledge wholesome or virtuous.

It’s only when it becomes non ignorance, a little bit later on the page, when it becomes an antidote to our misknowing, that it really becomes a virtuous state of mind. All right. Any questions on those two sets? Let’s go on to the four variable and just really briefly talk about them. I talked about regret already, sleep.

You can actually have virtuous sleep. You know, they say if you go to sleep with a virtuous mind and you’re able to cultivate some of that even in your dream state, your sleep can be very virtuous. A lot of our sleep tends to be quite neutral or non virtuous even. Investigation, analysis, these are also some things that we can use in one way or another as variable skills, but they, again, will play some role in regard to meditation, certainly, and we’ll touch on them at a later time. The eleven virtuous mental factors.

These are generally sort of conceptual factors, conceptual states of mind that lead to happiness. We’re going to talk about this next week when we get into the role of karma in all this. But when we define something as virtuous, again going back to Albert’s point, you know, we’re not talking about it in this strictly dualistic way. We’re not saying that there’s some sort of inherent virtue in here. There’s simply a relational aspect, a relative aspect, connection between faith, shame, embarrassment, and so on, all of these, and positive states of mind, positive results in our lives.

We see a correlation between them. It’s the Buddha’s observation that these states of mind lead to the most beneficial results that we want in our lives. So faith in Buddhism, just so you know, we use this word faith a lot, fearful faith, you know. What do we mean by faith? You know, faith here is a much more reason driven thing, an experience driven thing.

We are talking about the faith of conviction that we gain in the Buddhist teachings and in our ability to utilize these teachings through our own experience. It’s not blind faith in the least. The Buddha actually said that if you simply believe in what the Buddha said because it’s the Buddha that taught these things, you know, out of some idea that this is some holy being, well then you’ve missed the boat. You know, you really can’t speak to practicing the Buddha’s teachings because you haven’t actually found them to be truth for yourself. So faith here is about your own conviction that is generated on the basis of applying these teachings in your life.

In that way, it becomes virtuous. In that way, it becomes something that leads positive results. Now I’m not saying again that the Buddha has a monopoly on truth either. You can have faith in many spiritual teachings that are concordant with these same ideas. And we do see that there are commonalities in many spiritual traditions.

But the most fundamental level of faith we want is conviction, convinced faith that knows it through experience. The second one and third one are kind of this role that we help our behavior to be more in accord with things that lead to positive results. Shame, they say in this division, again we don’t have perfect words in English, but shame is equated to a feeling of self respect. This is where we actually are just in our own view of ourselves, wanting to live up to higher ideals because we’re holding ourselves accountable. Embarrassment is when we realize that we don’t want to be doing that in front of others because there’s some element of them having consideration for them and not wanting to be that way around them.

And these are, you know, maybe in some minds you might think that these start sounding a bit of a more primitive way of working with our behavior, but we do see that we have this in the world. Maybe at work you have some sense of consideration or embarrassment that you don’t want to, in the middle of a meeting, call somebody on something the way that they are, that you don’t want to kind of put yourself in that position because it is kind of embarrassing. It is a little bit difficult to kind of be seen in a positive light when you’re the one in the middle of a meeting that’s saying that. Well then, you know, you have some sense of consideration there. You’re refraining from engaging in unwholesome speech because of some feeling of regard for others, not wanting to create a scene, not wanting to, you know, look bad in their eyes necessarily.

The next three are the key, though. These are what we might call the root virtues. These are where we have non attachment, non hatred, and non ignorance. Now, I haven’t talked about the others, what they’re opposites of, so it’s a little premature to maybe go into these three in that regard. Let’s just hold onto them and know that basically all three of these are really the fundamental things that lead us to having a much more peaceful state of mind when we don’t have hatred in the mind, or any form of aversion when we don’t have attachment, desirous, craving in the mind, when we’ve in the end gotten rid of that sort of fundamental ignorance that we’re going to talk about in a moment.

So these three again are what you might call the root virtues. The sixth one, just so you know, they’re the non ignorance or non confusion, could be equated really to wisdom. When we talk about not just knowledge, but wisdom, true awareness of exactly how things exist, that is that whole process that I mentioned earlier, moving away from wrong ideas to more concordant ideas, ideas that are in accord with how things actually exist. That wisdom is virtuous. It is non ignorance.

It is going against the deluded states of mind that you’ve had that are based on incorrect ideas. The next four, numbers seven, eight, nine and ten, effort, pliancy, conscientiousness and equanimity. I’m not going to talk about these so much here. We’ll touch on them briefly in the next module because all four of these are sort of virtuous mental states that are involved primarily in, well to a large degree, in meditation. Now effort or enthusiasm is involved in all of our practice of spirituality or this, you know, Buddha’s teachings.

Why? Because we actually have to have some sort of enthusiastic perseverance to keep going and pursuing this path. We will see, obviously. I mean, it’s not like it has to be solely generated from nothing. We do see the positive results in our life which give us more enthusiasm for the practice.

But effort or enthusiasm plays a great role in meditation. Those of you who meditate in the room know this. I mean, have to put some, initially at least, some effort into getting your butt on the cushion and doing a more formal meditation practice. And if you don’t have that effort or enthusiasm, it doesn’t go anywhere. Eventually that will result in some of these other states of mind, pliancy, this sort of form of conscientiousness and equanimity.

You know, but conscientiousness isn’t as involved, but equanimity there, what we mean by equanimity, I have to mention this because we’re going get a meditation on equanimity. There’s a couple of different ways that equanimity, this term, is used in Buddhism. When we’re talking about the mental state, we’re talking about a mind that’s sort of abiding in an equipoise state, a state that’s very stable and without any disturbance. So we’re going use a different connotation for equanimity when I explain that meditation later. The last one, non harmfulness or non violence, is very close to non hatred, but this is really equated to compassion, whereas nonhatred we would equate to love, lovingkindness.

So you notice that compassion and lovingkindness aren’t on the list. You might be shocked, you know, like, well, aren’t these virtuous states of mind? Well, they’re included. Loving kindness is included in number five, non hatred. And compassion is equated to non harmfulness or non violence.

Or it is a part of that. But we see that this is where these ideas start, is a feeling of not harming, a feeling of not being violent towards others eventually leads to some feeling of identifying with their suffering. Because the reason why we’re not harming them, it might feel good a bit from our side to react in that way. I mean, that’s why we often do it, is because we like that kind of charge we get from putting somebody in their place. But then we begin to have some consideration for what they feel, and that goes from not wanting to harm them to eventually wanting to free them from their suffering, which is what we mean by compassion.

Any questions on any of those? These virtuous states of mind. Okay. I think it’s time for a break. When we come back, we’re going to go into the root delusions, the root afflictions, and then I’m going even talk a little bit about kind of what are the factors that tend to give rise to these states of mind.

And we’ll explore that a little bit. Okay. So take about a ten minute break or so. All right. Any questions before we start the second part of this, kind of looking at the other half of that sheet and getting into the real meat of it, which I all the other stuff is relevant, but I think this is where it’s most relevant.

We kind of look at these unhealthy states of mind. No? Okay. All right, so turn the sheet over, and you’ll see there that we’ve got the six root afflictions described there, at least three of them, given and this is, again, why all the other ones I didn’t put anything on there. But for these three, I think it’s really important that we spend a little bit of time looking at a more classical definition of what they are.

These are often even called the three root delusions. While you might say there’s six here, these are the three within there that are key. And even when we come down to, Well, what is the one delusion that’s driving the whole show? It’s number three there: ignorance or confusion. So the other three I will talk about a little bit, but they’re not maybe quite as important in this discussion.

The very first one: attachment or desire. Sometimes we even call this attraction. We know this kind of energy. This is something that we have in our lives a lot. Here it’s described as a distinct mental factor that when referring to a contaminated phenomenon Contaminated phenomenon is, again, a technical term that simply means something that is involved in the world in which we are currently at.

Know, hate to say it, but this is a contaminated world. Contaminated what contaminated by our delusion, by primarily our ignorance. This is all a product of our ignorance. And we’ll talk about that next week when we talk about karma. But anything like that in other words, if we had if there was a Buddha in the room with us maybe there is but if there was a Buddha, that’s not a contaminated phenomenon.

And so we wouldn’t be able to, in a sense, kind of generate this feeling of attachment or delusion of attachment towards that being. Why? Because there’s no way for us to over exaggerate the qualities of that object, because a Buddha has qualities that go so far beyond what we have, and there’s no limit to them. So what we’re doing with our attachment, though, is we’re taking something that we’re experiencing in this contaminated world, and as it says here, we over exaggerate the attractiveness and then proceed to wish for and take a strong interest in that object. So where we have a lot of attachment, most of us, is in the sense objects, right?

We have things that we have brought into our lives and developed a taste for, not just gustatory taste, our wanting to experience them. And what we are doing, the Buddha says, with those and I mentioned this in a previous class is that we are exaggerating the attractiveness of those objects. So let’s you know, and I like to use music because I have my own fondness for music. It’s one of my objects of attachment. But we see that in the world of music, there are many different types of music, right?

And everyone in the room, I’m sure, can speak to maybe one favorite type of music, or maybe even a few that you might listen to pretty equally. But you also have music that you have strong aversion towards, and we’ll talk about that in the next one. But those types of music that we have a strong attachment to, the test of whether we’re exaggerating the qualities of that music isn’t so difficult to do, because all we have to do is play that music for somebody who doesn’t like that music, and do they see the same qualities in that music that we see at the level that we see them? So anything that we look at, we can do this sort of test. There is no universal object, if you will, in this world that we could kind of say everyone sees this in exactly the same way.

What we do when we are attracted to a particular object is we take what we like about it, all the pleasant qualities, all the delicious stuff, and we bring it to the top, and we even elevate how much is there. We exaggerate it, superimpose a nature to it that makes us not see any of the negative qualities to it. Makes us, in fact, relate to that object in a way that is untrue, that is not in accord with reality. Now, our seeing even the positive qualities in it is relational. Then our exaggerating it is certainly everything that we’re doing from our side.

We’re making it into a much more attractive object than what is really there. As I said, everyone else that doesn’t like that, or even is neutral about it, doesn’t see it in that way at all. So we can see that this is something we are doing if we look at it closely enough. And the Buddha’s encouraging us to do this. Well, that’s I don’t want to move away from it too quickly, but is everybody seeing this?

And maybe music doesn’t work for you. Choose what is your biggest object of desire in your life. Usually, again, it might be a sense object that you like to experience. And see, I mean, Robina always uses chocolate cake. Chocolate cake doesn’t work for everybody.

But if I would have brought in a chocolate cake, I guarantee that most of us would be salivating right now and be looking at it and thinking about all these amazing qualities of the chocolate cake. But there might be a few people in the room who don’t like chocolate cake. Chocolate cake isn’t their thing. It doesn’t give them any great thrill. Maybe even you have people who have allergies to certain aspects of that chocolate cake, like gluten intolerance or whatever.

They look at it and they see it as almost poison, rather than delicious dessert. Or somebody who’s diabetic, who looks at all the sugar content of that and says, this is pure poison. If I put this in my body, I know that it’s going to eventually cause difficulty for me and my health. So this is, again, different ways of perceiving the exact same object. But we relate to it all very differently.

We have a different way of perceiving it. And that’s what attachment is about in terms of the pleasant stuff. So going back to feeling. And one of the points that was brought up during the break, Catherine brought up, when we use this word feeling, where does the word emotion fit into all this? And actually, the Buddha’s presentation doesn’t include the word emotion.

But what I would be tempted to classify it as emotion is the thought process we get into on the basis of feeling. Feeling there, when we it’s not like, oh, me your feelings. How are you feeling about this? Feeling there is just the raw experience of something pleasant, something is neutral, or something is unpleasant. When we experience it in that way, then we go into a story.

And the story has to do with our emotion. You know, how joyous we feel when that’s in our life. How sad we feel when we lose something in our lives. All of those are just simply the raw feeling that get interpreted into an emotional story. His Holiness at Dalai Lama, this book called Destructive Emotions, because sometimes we do use the word emotion to, like, refer to the afflictive emotions.

But all of these are thought processes. Whereas feeling there’s no thinking with feeling. Feeling just happens. It’s the thought process, the conceptual mind that relates to those feelings that gets into the territory of what we might call emotion. So I’ll just read a little bit of this.

He says the challenge was to find analytic precision in the Tibetan terms corresponding to emotion as used in English. He says that in Tibetan, there is no word for emotion. And one of the participants, Francisco Varela, said, I’m very surprised. This is, by the way, from this mind one of these mind life conferences that I mentioned before. I’m very surprised because it seems that thought, whether irrational or intelligent, is so clearly different from emotion and this was, again, the perspective of a scientist whether irrational or intelligent oh, I’m sorry.

I said that already is so clearly different from emotion. Granted, in the West, we are a little obsessed with the idea that emotions are beyond the control of voluntary action, and thoughts are somehow rational. Yet how could it be that in the Tibetan language, given this enormous capacity to discriminate mental events, this very gross distinction is not made. So this is how we tend to relate to emotions, and these types of afflictions in the West, is we think that they’re just part of our being, that they just arise. The feeling of desire just naturally comes up.

And we want to attribute that level of it being just a feeling. It’s just like something that is there, omnipresent, and just sort of arises. The Buddha is telling us, and what His Holiness goes on to say, is that these emotions of attachment, or aversion, or what have you, these are thought processes. These are actually the conceptual mind engaging in something quite automatically. And we’re not denying that there’s a level of just like instantaneous reaction to things.

But we are thinking about things in a particular way, and we have habituated the mind to think about things in a particular way. So that when brussels sprout appears, I’ve got this instant kind of reaction to it that makes me have that strong feeling of aversion and pushing it out of my not wanting to let it get close to my tongue. That is a thought process. And I’m not sitting there and actually going, wow, there’s that round green object that looks like blah, blah, blah. I am identifying that as a brussels sprout.

I am thinking about that and deciding that it is not a pleasant object, and therefore I’m going to have aversion towards it. That’s not what’s going on, but it’s going on like that. I’m not thinking linearly. I’m thinking quite spontaneously. But this is one of the main things that I really want like I said, is there something out of today’s lecture that I want you to get?

It’s to really understand that these are thought processes. These are conceptual minds. All of these afflictive emotions. They are a conscious decision that we are making in a sense, and that we’re assenting to our habituated way of looking at things. But this is why we often talk in Tibetan Buddhism about being under the control of the afflictions.

Why? Because they’re so deeply ingrained in us that they take charge. They get in the driver’s seat all the time. We have to learn that these are actually thought processes that we’re engaged in and start to pick them apart. If I was going to assign some homework from this week, it would be choose what you want to work with.

Maybe you have a more prominent problem with attachment versus aversion that we’re going to talk about in a moment. But choose one of those two. And even just one object that brings you that feeling of aversion, that emotion of aversion, or one that brings up the strong desire and attachment, and try to work with it this week, and pick it apart, and see how you are conceptualizing at that time, and exaggerating the qualities of that. With attachment, it’s the pleasant stuff, and it looks so much more gorgeous and delicious and beautiful than it really is. With aversion, it’s the exact opposite.

Again, it’s described here as a distinct mental factor, that in reference to one of the three objects, the being or object by whom we are being harmed or in some way made uncomfortable, the suffering that occurs through our being harmed or made uncomfortable, or the reasons for which we are being harmed, Any reaction to anything like that agitates the mind through being unable to bear or through intending to cause harm to the object. So this isn’t it doesn’t talk in there about this exaggeration, but we are doing the exact same thing with aversion. It’s the unpleasant feeling we get. And then we relate to that object in a sense of exaggerating, superimposing unfavorable qualities to it beyond what is there, and to the complete negligence of any positive qualities. So say the person that you find annoying in your life.

What are you doing? You are seeing them as an inherently annoying person. That is who they are. That is how they manifest for you. That’s how you think about them.

That’s how you react to them. But does everybody see them that way? They’ve got people they go home to that love them, that care for them, maybe even their pets that are totally delighted when they walk in the door. Does everybody see them as an annoying person? This is just we know all this stuff.

That’s what’s kind of interesting about what I’m presenting, is at some level we know all this, but we just don’t live our lives that way. We think that everything is exactly how we experience it. Oh, how could you like that person? They’re so annoying. Well, he’s not annoying to me.

She’s not annoying to me. Whatever. We don’t really get that our experience and our interpretation of that is based on our own minds. And we’re not denying. I’m not saying this person didn’t do something that was one of these objects.

They were harming you, or they gave you suffering from the harm that they gave you. We’re not denying that. We’re just simply saying, but be realistic about how you react to that. Really think about why you’re reacting that way. And are you capable of actually changing your mind and choosing to look at it in a different way?

This is what Buddhist philosophy is most about, is really allowing space in your mind to be able to find a more factually concordant and supportive way of being in the world that actually brings you happiness and well-being, rather than makes you tormented by all the annoying people, all the difficult things in the world. It’s a wonderful verse. I just try to throw it in whenever I can because I think it’s really important. Śāntideva, Master Śāntideva, I mentioned before, I think a great Indian Buddhist master of the eighth century, wrote a book called The Guide to the Bodhisattva’s Way of Life. And in it, the fifth chapter, somewhere around the fifteenth verse or something he’s talking about how all these various practices in Buddhism are in our minds.

And he uses for developing patience, he uses the example of covering the world with leather so that you’d never have to step on a single sharp object. You know, if you could imagine finding enough thick leather to pave the entire world so that you never have to step on a thorn, never step on a rock, never step on anything that would penetrate the flesh of your foot. Well, he says a simpler solution is to put leather on the bottom of your feet, right? Because then, no matter where you go, you don’t have sharp objects penetrating. Well, is an analogy for what we need to do with our minds.

If we can make a conscious decision to sort of cover our minds with that which will not allow it to penetrate, not allow it to harm us, not allow it to create difficulty and suffering for us, Well, then we abide in a state wherever we go. We can be with pleasant things and not get so caught up in them. We can be with unpleasant things and not get so disturbed by them. This is a wonderful wisdom from Śāntideva, and so this is what I’m trying to get across today, is kind of understanding that we can make some conscious decisions to not follow these states of mind. Those two, attachment and aversion, or anger, whatever we want to equate that to, these are based in, as are all the delusions, the third one, ignorance.

What is this ignorance? Well, ignorance can have a lot of different meanings, and I’m going to talk about a specific form of ignorance in a moment. Let’s read the definition. It says, an afflicted state of unknowing brought about by the mind being unclear about the nature of such things as karma, the law of cause and effect, the triple gem, which we’ll talk about. This is the Buddha, the Dharma, and the Sangha, and so forth.

Again, this is in a very Buddhist flavor, but basically ignorance is a state of unknowing. There is one element of ignorance, though, that wasn’t mentioned in that, such as that is the deepest level of ignorance that we have operative, which is actually described as a misknowing as opposed to just an unknowing. A lot of times we use the word ignorant to mean, you know, I’m ignorant of quantum physics. That’s because I just don’t know quantum physics. I haven’t studied it.

The Buddha is saying that this ignorance isn’t just not knowing how things exist, it is actually misknowing how things exist. Thinking things exist in a way that is very different to how they exist when I pick them apart and analyze and really reason through it. So let’s talk about these two minds of attachment and aversion and how they are operating with that ignorance present. As I said, the mind of attachment that’s listening to my favorite music or tasting my favorite dessert or whatever thinks that those qualities of deliciousness or beauty or whatever I’m attributing to it are there and at this elevated level. Well, fact that I’m even assuming that they’re there, as I said, that even gets proven false because not everyone who hears that music or tastes that dessert experiences it in the same way, right?

We know this for a fact, that the choices, the things we have in our lives are there because they give us pleasure. We have that relationship with them. And not everybody has that. Even the fact that we think that there’s something inherently there that is that quality is what we mean by this level of ignorance. Now, we also are even thinking that the object itself is its own identity is out there on the object.

So let’s use a piece of chocolate cake as the example, since Venerable Robina seems to find it to be her standard old, reliable piece of chocolate cake. So we put this piece of cake in front of you. And again, some of you may have an aversion for it, some of you may have an attachment towards it, but you have some sort of feeling towards it, maybe even a neutral feeling. But at some level, you are holding that there is this thing that is called a piece of chocolate cake in front of you that exists independently of you. It has this kind of standalone nature.

Now, all the other qualities we put on it, whether we have deliciousness and so tasty, or whether we have an aversion, seeing negative qualities to it, something that we don’t like about it. All of these we also think are out there. But the fact that we even think that there’s a piece of chocolate cake out there on its own, being chocolate cake from its own side. This is the root problem that we have, is that we think that things, the terminology that they use, we think that things inherently exist. That they exist from their own side, that they have some way of sort of setting themselves up.

Now the easiest way for me to explain this in this very first module because, again, this is an idea we’re going to be exploring over time. And those of you who feel like you’re ready for the deep end of all this, come on Wednesday night when we’re talking about emptiness there. But what the Buddha says in these teachings on the nature of reality is that if we start looking at it, we see that actually the objects that we relate to and even ourselves exist in a way that is contrary to how we think that they do. And the way that this is described, and probably the easiest way to get a handle on it at this stage, is to think about the term dependent arising or dependent origination. We have a feeling that things are independent, that there’s kind of you over there and me over here and this over there and the chocolate cake over there, and it’s all kind of on its own, establishing itself as what it is.

Well, the reality is that things have a way of arising that belies that, that is totally contrary to that. And that is the fact that they arise in dependence on various other things. Let’s talk about that in a real basic way. So let’s use something that maybe we don’t have a lot of attachment towards or anything. Let’s use this flower.

So we have a sunflower here, and this sunflower, in its very basic way, we can say that this arises. It’s a dependent arising. Why? Because it comes from its causes and conditions. This is the most fundamental way that we can talk about this.

So what are the causes? What’s the main cause for this sunflower? Sunflower seed. Yeah, sunflower seed that was planted in the ground that went through all the various other conditions, nutrients in the soil and moisture and sunlight and someone tending to it, what have you, all that gave rise to the sunflower that’s in this vase right now. There is no sunflower that exists independent of its causes and conditions.

This might sound like, Well, yeah, what are you saying? You know, we get that things arise from their causes and conditions, but we still think that they have some inherent identity independent of that, not seeing them as kind of part of a process. The other level, the next level that we talk about it, though, gets to a subtler level where we say, You know, also the sunflower is greatly dependent upon its parts. What do we have here? We have a zillion parts if we keep going.

But basically, we can talk about the center of it. Do you have any Mark, what would you call the center of this? The stamen. Don’t know. There’s lots of stuff.

Yeah. We have the center of it. Okay. We’ll just give it that We have the petals. We have a lot of little yellow petals.

We have the back of it here with all of the green encasing of the flower before it bloomed. We have the stem, we have leaves. And then of course each of those has parts, right? We could go to an individual petal and talk about a zillion parts to that petal. You keep going and going and you never sort of find anything that doesn’t have parts.

And so we can’t talk about sunflower existing without talking about the parts of a sunflower being there. If I were to take all the petals off, would you still have a sunflower there? Well, you might have naked sunflower or something. But you wouldn’t have what we normally would label as a sunflower, call a sunflower. This begins to take us to the most subtle level of dependent arising, because there’s these three levels dependent upon causes and conditions, dependent upon parts.

And the last level, which is in the end, the Buddha says and this might be hard for us to get our minds around the only sunflower that we can posit as existing is actually the label of sunflower that I’m giving to this collection of stuff. Sunflower doesn’t exist out here. What is out here in my hand is all the parts of a sunflower, but it is what we call sort of the basis for my labeling it sunflower, calling it sunflower. There’s no sunflower that has its own inherent existence out here on the part of this thing I’m shaking with my hand. Instead, sunflower in the end is just a label, a designation that we all conventionally agree to.

We’re going to call this sunflower rather than rose or whatever. And we attribute various ideas to it on the basis of that. We have the yellow of the petals of the sunflower and the it doesn’t have a fragrance, but if it was a fragrant flower, then we would talk about the fragrance of that flower and so on. All of these are simply ideas, thoughts, that we are labeling on the basis of what we’re experiencing. There’s nothing from the side of this object out here that makes it that.

That makes it sunflower, that makes it beautiful yellow, that makes it anything that I’m attributing to it. So we go back to the chocolate cake, and it’s exactly the same. Chocolate cake arises from its causes and conditions, too, right? We don’t get a chocolate cake. It doesn’t fall out of the air.

And we’ve got, like, instant chocolate cake not arising from any of the various things that need to go into making a chocolate cake. We also have its parts. You’ve got the frosting, and you’ve got the layers of the cake, and all the various bits of that that you could again pick apart and find that there’s infinite parts to a chocolate cake. But in the end, there’s no chocolate cake at all that exists apart from my mind labeling it chocolate cake. My mind giving it that identity as chocolate cake.

Again, this sounds pretty radical for most of us, I’m sure. We’re not really sure what to do with this information. What the Buddha says, though, is it’s kind of like we have organized the world that we live in with all of our ideas and thoughts, and then we hold the world to be how we organized it. That the chocolate cake’s out there on its own, just like tempting me, like saying, Come, eat me, eat me. I’m delicious.

It’s got all that there packed into it. And I’m totally independent of that. When in the end, I am what it’s dependent upon. There is no chocolate cake without my mind imputing chocolate cake on that basis. Good.

So again, this is an idea that we have to learn about. We have to be willing to kind of open our minds and say, maybe things like Don said in class on Sunday maybe things don’t exist in quite the way that I think they do. And you just start to open that crevice a little bit. And eventually, you want more and more of this, you want deeper and deeper teachings. And eventually you develop that realization.

Going back to what I explained earlier today as well as last week, you go from a wrong idea, which is holding that everything exists, including me, in this independent, concrete, separate way, to a way of understanding that everything is interdependent, and that at the deepest level, our interdependence arises simply on the basis of a thought, an idea, of how we are labeling things. Yeah, John. How does this relate to attachment and aversion? How it relates is that, as I said, if we think chocolate cake exists from its own side and has those qualities from its own side, then we have a platform on which to be attached to those qualities. And we think that I exist in this concrete, independent way, and I have to go satisfying that sense of a self.

You know, it’s sort of like the entire framework that we built everything up on had an erroneous foundation from the beginning. So the entire structure will topple at the point where we remove that ignorance. Because the way that we’re relating to objects and going back to what Albert said about kind of this dualistic way well, in our conventional world, there certainly is a duality. There’s kind of ways in which things work in positive ways and negative ways, in productive ways and nonproductive ways. But this is all, in the end, a creation of our own minds.

Our own minds create the reality that we experience. I said that quote from the Dhammapada that I’ll start with. Actually, there’s another quote from the Dhammapada next week. But the quote that I mentioned of everything comes from the mind. This is the most fundamental Buddhist teaching that Lama Zopa Rinpoche in September in North Carolina really emphasized this teaching.

That in the end, at the deepest level, it’s all arising from our minds, from the way in which we are conceptualizing the world that we live in that has none of this from its own side. Is there a yellow? We certainly see yellow coming back at us from this wall. But is there yellow from its own side? Its yellowness is a determination that we make conceptually.

There’s no yellowness in that object. Now you might think, well, then what makes that yellowness different from blueness? Well, conventionally, we can still talk about different dependent arisings. The causes of blue is different than the cause of yellow, right? They’re not the same causes.

You don’t get a blue color from the same causes as what you get a yellow color from. This just shows, again, that there’s all this variety of stuff arising. But in the end, it’s our conceptual mind that organizes and determines what it is. And then, as John was bringing up, what we do is we relate to it in an unhealthy way. We start having attachment for all the things we find pleasant that we have conceptually decided are pleasant.

Because once we go back to even, like, feeling this is one of the things that’s kind of interesting, too. When we talk about dividing feeling into these three pleasant, neutral, and unpleasant like I said, those aren’t even fixed in the object either, right? I put that Brussels sprout on my tongue, and I experience unpleasant. Somebody else loves I know there’s people in the room that love Brussels sprouts. I think Eric does.

We were talking about it one day. You know, he finds it yummy. He’s like totally there’s pleasure in putting that same object on his tongue. Even, like I said, the qualities that bring about those experiences aren’t inherently within that object. Even the identity of that object isn’t there.

It’s a hard one for us to get. Trust me. I mean, I know from my own working with this that it’s very hard to think that there’s not something inherently there that is brussels sprout. Because we think if it can’t if there’s not something there that makes it brussels sprout, well, then why can’t it be chocolate cake? But as I said, we know that there are phenomena.

I’m not denying that there are phenomena. I’m not denying that things exist. I’m just saying, let’s look at really how they exist, because we are relating to them in a very different way than how they actually exist. Can you relate this to doubt? Well, I mean, is a part of that process, again.

If you’re talking about doubt here as an affliction, though, you’re talking about an affliction. Well, they say doubt as an afflicted doubt is really where we kind of have a mind that is two pointed with regard to something that we need to get through to get to a more virtuous state of mind. So if we had doubt about this idea of emptiness, how things are empty of that way of existing, or if we had doubt about the Buddha’s teaching on karma, you know, that there is some connection between what we do and what we experience. Again, we’ll talk about this next week. All these ideas, if we have a mind of doubt, we are basically undecided.

We can’t go one way or another. And in that way, it acts as a form of a non virtuous state of mind, because it keeps us from engaging in what is more beneficial. That’s the best I can do in terms of relating it to that. Doubt is on the list here simply because when we get to that point where that becomes a major roadblock for us, then it can definitely influence our behavior based on that. But we would say probably the bigger issue, because we might not have doubt as often as we have ignorance, You know?

Even ignorance of the law of cause and effect we’re going to talk about karma next week, as I keep mentioning, but most beings live their lives totally ignorant of the fact that what they do and how they think and how they speak and all the things that they are involved in in the world have some repercussions for themselves. This is, again, one of the most difficult teachings to get to on this level of really understanding how karma works. And to some degree, we just have to have some level of faith in it. But it’s totally grounded within this reasoning of emptiness, of knowing that at some level there’s no inherently good or bad or wholesome or unwholesome, what have you. But there is conventionally this functionality, the way that things work.

This is tough teachings. Felicia told me during the break that she was a little bit lost. So I told her I’d try to make sure that I got her unlost in the second part. Maybe I’d made more people lost. So sorry, Felicia.

But, you know, I think we have to be very patient with these teachings, too. We’re just many of you coming to these teachings initially and sort of hearing these ideas for the first time. The most important thing out of today that I really want to drive home is that these first two in particular are choices that we’re making to conceive of things in a particular way. How we are looking at something and making a concrete decision that that is unpleasant, that is pleasant, and we are then having aversion and attachment towards these objects, respectively. But then we if we have the ability to kind of drive a little bit deeper and go to, well, what is operative at a deeper level that makes us even make that jump to relating to it in that way.

And that’s thinking that there’s some inherent object out there to begin with, and that there’s an inherent I that wants to relate to that inherent object and receive inherent pleasure from that inherent object. We overlay with an entire fictitious way of being. One more thing I’ll throw out that just may give some flavor to this. One of the analogies that the Buddha often used for talking about emptiness and how we are misperceiving things is the idea of a dream. So we talked about dreams earlier.

When you are in a dream, if you’re like me, you know, go to sleep with kind of a dull mind, and you wake up in your dream, you’re, like, doing all these sorts of things, and you’re having experiences. And then when you actually wake up from that dream, you’re kind of shocked at some level that it wasn’t real, because you were buying into it as a level of reality that you were totally convinced of. We do this every night. How many times do we have to dream before we don’t buy into it? Well, the Buddha says and this is why the term Buddha even means awakened one.

This means somebody who has awakened from the dream of reality. That in effect, in our waking life, we are buying into things and existing in a way that is totally contradictory to how it actually exists. In the same way that when you’re in your dream, you are buying into your dream objects existing in a way that is totally the opposite of how they actually exist. Why? Because when you wake up, they’re not there.

The person you were relating to and the situation you were in and everything that was happening didn’t happen at all. It happened in a dream world. Now, there are differences in this analogy. Don’t get me wrong. I’m not saying life is but a dream, you know.

Row, row, row your boat, whatever. I’m saying that there’s an analogy that will help us to kind of see how we’re doing this in our waking life. There are repercussions of what we do in our waking life that aren’t there in our dream life. If I kill somebody in my dream life, heaven forbid, you know, then that still doesn’t mean that I killed a being in my dreaming state of mind. But if I kill somebody in my waking life, I haven’t killed an inherently existent being, but relatively, I have taken the life of a being.

So there’s differences. I’m not saying it’s totally equivalent. But when we talk about the way that we are totally convinced of our dream reality in our dream, and the way that we are totally convinced of our waking reality in our waking life, that’s the analogy. Yeah, Claudio. So as one starts to take in this information, we kind of go around about our lives thinking we know what we’re doing.

I’m going here. This is the direction of my life. This is organized this way. It’s organized that way. And so we kind of start to have a sense or we’re learning that there’s a misknowing going on.

So the world kind of starts to shift a little bit. Maybe one feels a little disoriented, going, wait, I thought things were the way I thought they were. So they’re like a middle ground that somebody can use to a crutch, allows them to start tapping into it without everything. So they can taste it without having the fear of everything. Well, I think that that’s the challenge, though, Claudia, what you’re pointing out.

And they often talk about, again, this point of view I’m expressing is often called the middle way view, where you have to kind of find they say it’s a bit of a razor’s edge, that you have to find that very precise point that you abide in, where you’re not still holding there to be some inherent existence, like we currently do, this kind of grasping at things, having this concrete, independent identity, or falling into the other extreme, where you kind of go, It’s all just a big soup of nothing. There’s no point in anything. What’s a more nihilistic kind of view? You might think it’s pretty hard to fall to a nihilistic point of view, but it can happen. And so I think that it’s always just a matter of tempering it and sort of acknowledging that this is a part of the process, that you’re going to maybe fall back and forth between these two.

And at times you might think, well, I feel totally disempowered at doing anything because it seems like you take everything away from it. And then other times, you feel like I just can’t get it because I’m just too grounded in this concrete way that things appear to exist. It’s problematic. For beginners, I’d say just play with this idea. Don’t start to take it too seriously in some regard.

Give it some space to sort of develop in your mind. Because this idea we will touch on many, many times over the course of discovering Buddhism. But we can say that definitely the Buddhist teachings, every single one of them, is to drive us to have this understanding. Why? Because this is the key.

This is, you know, what unlocks the whole thing. And as I said, once that platform, that foundation is removed, the rest of it all topples. But it doesn’t leave you with nothing. It actually kind of interesting, I mean, there’s one student that I work with who really hates this term emptiness, and she wants to see it as fullness. And at some level, I mean, I’m not denying that.

When you come back around, they say, after this realization, this yogic direct perception of emptiness, that you kind of have a feeling of just the interconnectedness of everything. Our sense of kind of independent, isolated, separated self is the problem. The sense of kind of the spacious fullness of identifying with all, if you will, is the solution. To get out of this narrow, confined, grasping, tight way and loosen the mind into a much more spacious way. For wholeness.

Yeah, wholeness. You know, we feel like we’re this isolated little separate part, and we even attribute a wholeness to this. And this is fictitious wholeness in terms of there’s no real wholeness here. The wholeness, in a sense, comes from any lack of separateness, lack of individual kind of concretizing. And these are just ideas.

And that’s the one thing to always keep in mind with all of this is the conceptual framework is to kind of get you there. It’s the boat that gets you across to the other shore. But it’s not the solution in and of itself. The solution in and of itself, we can’t even begin to put words to, they say. The experience of that that comes through reflection, comes through the wisdom that we develop.

And that will be something else. That will be something that we won’t know until we really taste it. But what’s amazing and what is most heartening to me as a Buddhist practitioner is that the Buddha gave techniques for seeing this reasoning, rational techniques, logic. And in the Western mind, if any mind is based in logic, it’s the Western mind, right? We know very logically how to put together a most complex computer to do all sorts of things, make things smaller and smaller.

There’s just a logical, very scientific approach to things. And the Buddha says it’s exactly the same here. We will get into these sort of forms of reasoning and analysis that will help us to support that kind of approach. I don’t have too much time left, but I want to just say, basically, from those three, we could say that basically all the other ones have some flavor of that. Even pride.

Pride has some sense of attachment to ourselves and our own standing, right, and thinking about ourselves in an elevated way. Doubt is a form of ignorance, if you will. Afflicted view are also some way of misrelating to things. I don’t want to go too deep into that. We will look at these in more detail in one of the future modules.

The twenty secondary ones, right there I gave you kind of where they all come from. From desire or attraction we have miserliness, haughtiness, excitement. From anger or aversion we have all these flavors of anger when somebody’s belligerent or resentful or spiteful, jealous, harmful, and so on. You can see how all these other secondary delusions have flavors of the root ones. Now what I want to do to conclude today is to talk about the meditation that I want you to work with, because, as I said, getting all this information does absolutely no good.

I mean, can go to cocktail parties and say, you know, the most interesting thing, you know, heard about how attachment is rooted in fundamental ignorance, and then people are going to probably leave you, you know? How are even going to want to talk to you? But if we simply take on this knowledge and information as just like a nice thing to know and we just sort of file it on the shelf, well, then there’s no point. The point of this is to apply it to our lives. And one of the ways that we’ve already kind of touched on this is the fact that we relate to sentient beings with these eyes of attachment, aversion, and even some level of ignorance, obviously.

So the meditation that I’m going to have you do is a meditation on equanimity. As I mentioned, this word equanimity has different flavors, different definitions, and different contexts. Here, what we mean is not a mind that’s just kind of in this equipoise state, but there is a flavor of that equalizing of the mind, if you will. Here it has to do with the fact that we traditionally, every one of us in the room, I’m sure, categorize sentient beings into three different categories. We have friends, acquaintances, chummy people that we like around us.

Sometimes they slide back and forth in categories. Not without I mean, that certainly does happen. But this is the general category of people that you kind of surround yourselves with that make you feel good. We like them in our lives. We want to spend time with them.

We want to be with them. Then we have the exact opposite, the people that we try to keep out of our lives. I sometimes use the analogy of like it’s the Don stage show. And so I’m on the stage, and I choose who gets in the front row, right? The good seats.

Where the lights, I can kind of see them, and I like to see their smiling face. And then the other people that are like these, We use the term enemy, but that’s a pretty strong word. I don’t know if I asked you, Do you have an enemy? People would be like, No, there’s nobody I consider my enemy. But who do you dislike?

Who annoys you? What politician drives you up a wall? All these kinds of flavors of that that give a feeling for those people that we want to keep out of the theater. Right? We want to try to keep the doors closed.

They keep busting in and interrupting the show and upsetting us. But we try to keep them out of our theater. But then we have the whole dark part of the theater that’s just filled with all these other beings that are kind of indirectly involved in our show, but we don’t even like to acknowledge them. We haven’t had a contact with them. Somebody described them and we call them strangers, but somebody said a stranger is simply somebody who you haven’t learned to like or dislike yet.

So we have a whole bunch of those in the world. I mean, that’s the largest category. And those we have this kind of dull, ignorant feeling towards, whereas we have the attachment towards the friends and the aversion towards the people we’re trying to keep out of the theater. Every one of us live our lives like that, right? And we feel totally justified in doing that.

We feel like this is kind of a psychological safety mechanism that we need in place in order to kind of keep us feeling good, keep all the negative stuff out, and don’t deal with what we don’t have to, all the people in the dark that are just kind of out there in an indirect way involved in our lives. So this meditation on equanimity is to ask you to go in and take a look at this and reason through it and look at these three categories by pulling one being from each of those groups. You put them in kind of in front of you. You don’t have to work with the whole group. Just work with one from each group.

And you begin to examine, well, why am I having that feeling towards this person? Well, first, what’s the feeling that’s coming up as I focus on that person? Why am I having that? Is that something that I could imagine changing? And we know, as I was saying earlier, sometimes people slide back and forth between categories, right?

You have the friend that’s kind of sitting in the front row, and all of a sudden they start saying stuff to you. And you’re like, get out of the front row. Get out of my theater. Or maybe even have the person banging at your door who was trying to interrupt your show all the time. And you have a different context that you get to know them.

And you’re like, oh, come sit in the front row. You’re really not such a bad person after. So we see that even in the course of a single lifetime, we’re rearranging seats constantly. We’re ushering people all over. And the people in the dark are all of a sudden somebody pops up and they go, hey, here, wonderful gift for you.

And then we have them in the front row for a while. So we’re doing this and rearranging the seating for unbelievable when we really look at it, it’s such silly reasons. Because we are holding, at the time when we put them in the front row or try to keep them out of the theater, that that’s kind of who they are. And it’s totally, totally dependent upon our most recent experience of them. Now, if we take this to another dimension, which I don’t know if it’s mentioned in the meditation, I don’t think it is, but if you take it to the dimension of countless lifetimes, which, again, is based on this continuity of mind that goes back to the lifetime before this and the lifetime before that and so on, well, reality is that we’ve been in different relationships with every one of these beings.

Our dearest, most loving, compassionate friend has been like our worst, most vile enemy. And this is the reality that we can accept if we accept the fact that there’s been this interplay of all kinds of lifetimes before this one. But even in this single life, just look at what you have to work with and acknowledge that it’s totally changing. We can imagine times when the people that are our dearest friend could be our worst enemy, or the people who are our worst enemy could be our dearest friend, or someone who we don’t even know all of a sudden comes into our life and becomes one of our closest companions. Right?

So let me pass that meditation out. You can take a look at it and see what you think about it. There’s one other thing I need to distribute today, which is the reading that’s on your list as well. Any questions about that? This meditation, again, the purpose of it is to really help you to examine how this plays a role in how you relate to sentient beings, other beings in your life, and begin to question that a bit, to have a little more space.

It doesn’t mean that you do this meditation, and all of a sudden you’re having your worst enemy over for tea, you know, and wanting to sit around and talk to them. Maybe you need that distance. Maybe this is, again, something that you can acknowledge that there is a conventional reality. But why are you thinking about the person that way? Why are you adhering to such a strong identity of them as that, as undesirable person in my life?

Did you have your hand up, Mark? No. Okay. Okay. Any other questions or comments on this?

It’s a very powerful meditation. This meditation comes back again in several modules. We particularly see it as a really important basis if we’re going to generate genuine love and compassion for all beings, which is one of the key tenets of this sort of flavor of Buddhism, Tibetan Buddhism. You know, that if we are able to actually be in a space where we want all beings to be happy and all beings to be free from suffering, well, if currently we’re trying to keep some people out of the theater and we’re totally neglecting a whole bunch of them, well, how can we ever generate that mind? We need to have at least a level playing field.

Put all sentient beings on the same plateau, the same basis. Here’s another again, this was in the sheet that has the readings. This is one of the readings for this week that I just hand out to people. It’s not in any of the other materials that you have, but it allows you to kind of read a little bit from Lama Zopa’s perspective about kind of what is Buddhism. And he does mention in there he calls it the equilibrium meditation.

I think it’s mentioned on the second side. The equilibrium meditation is the same as the equanimity meditation. It It just basically means one where you’re trying to find this sort of calm way of abiding with all beings so that you don’t have this interference of seeing them as friend, enemy, stranger, and so on. In terms of the afflictions that arise, I mean we’re not denying, again, that conventionally there are people we call friend, and there are people we call enemy, and people that we call stranger. We’re denying or trying to get at, well, what are the afflictions that arise on the basis of that?

The indifference towards strangers, the attachment to friends, the aversion to enemies. All right? Okay, so we did have a list that went around the room that had Claudio has it. Don’t know if everyone if you didn’t see this list, what we’re doing with this list is we’re just trying to share some of the positive energy that we’ve created here today with beings that are in our lives, or maybe even organizations that we know of, that are experiencing certain forms of dissatisfaction, difficulty. So we can begin by thinking about sharing all this energy with those beings that we know, or, again, organizations that are experiencing obstacles.

So think very strongly that through what we’ve done here today, it might seem so insignificant to counteract what’s going on in terms of these people’s lives, but think that this becomes the cause in some way for these beings to be free from their obstacles, for these organizations to not have to experience hindrances and obstacles. So we’ll recite those names now. And if you need to add any additional names after, you can certainly do that. So for obstacles, Ellie, John, Jamie, Vaughn, Mark, Shirley, Emily, Bandit, Colleen, Bernice, Anne, Charlene, Skya, Anthony, Connor, Melanie, Chris, Christopher, Matthew, Alexia, Elena, Steven, Leonor, Sylvia, Margie, students, Claudio, Dee, Rowena, Greg, Sabine, Leon, Judith, Rāja, Eric, Lori, Jufre, Porter, Timothy, Linda, Andy, Pamela, Beth, Paul, Ali, Ben, Bess, Jessica, Linda, Christopher, Victoria, Shelley, Enid, Don, Dan. We can then also share this positive energy with all those beings who are experiencing illness.

So here, we put these names forward because the situation these beings are in stirs our own heart and wishes for them to be free of this. So think that through what we’ve done here today. May this be the cause in some way for these beings to be free from their illness and all the causes of illness. Tom, Bernice, Anne, Anthony, Skip, Sam, Patrick, Louise, Brendan, Leonor, Eric, Yurish, Eileen, Jenny, Rāja, Jolie, I think, Don, Gary, Israel, Michael, Donnelly, Helen, Doug, Kristen, Mark, Cricket, Kevin, Araya. Harper, Sonny, Scott, Rich, Mary, Margaret.

And then the last category that we also want to share this positive energy with are those beings who are dying or who have died recently. So here I think that, again, because of our connection and compassion for these beings, we’re helping them to have a good rebirth in the future, to continue to be exposed to teachings and teachers that will help them to develop their own minds and their own potential to eventually become enlightened themselves. So you can recite these names with that in mind. Bosco, Sean, and Neil Sr. And Don, Shannon, Bella.

And then finally, we can dedicate thinking through what we’ve done here today. May this be the cause for ourselves to be able to fully potentialize our minds, to understand more clearly how things exist, understand how we exist. In this way, be able to be rid of all the disturbing states of mind down to the subtlest levels that these abide in our mind, and fulfill, completely potentialize, all the positive qualities of our mind, being able to have perfect wisdom, compassion, loving kindness, and connection to all beings so that we can then help them to achieve that same state. Okay, thank you all very much. It was a good class today.

So I didn’t get around to the last thing I wanted to talk about, which I feel kind of bad about, but I’ll insert it at the beginning of next class. That’s these factors that cause the afflictions to arise. It’s a really interesting teaching. If you’re really curious about it and want to read between now and then, there may be a few copies of this book, Wisdom Energy. We use this in module three, but I’d like to introduce this idea.

It’s in the fourth chapter, How Delusions Arise, fourth chapter of this book, Wisdom Energy, by Lama Zopa and Lama Yeshe. Again, there may be some copies. Katherine, our librarian, can help you if you’re trying to find this. I think there’s a few there. But you might take a look at these.

We’ll go through them at the beginning of next class, and then we’ll go on to the topic of karma. But I think it really helps to kind of get some understanding of what all plays a role in these deluded states arising, because we’ve pretty much just singled out kind of our mistaken thoughts. But there’s also other things that do play a role. Okay, thank you all. Have a good week, and I’ll see you next week.

Key terms in this teaching

dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
lorig
Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
omnipresent mental factors sarvatraga-chaitta (Skt); sem jung kun dro (Tib)
One of the six groups of mental factors, these accompany every main mind. There are five: feeling, discrimination, intention, mental engagement and contact. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
root delusions mulaklesha (Skt); tsa wä nyonmong (Tib)
One of the six groups of mental factors, these are the afflicted or nonvirtuous minds that subsequently lead to the secondary delusions. There are six: attachment, anger, pride, ignorance, afflicted doubt and afflicted view. LYWA
secondary delusions upaklesha (Skt); nye wä nyon mong (Tib)
One of the six groups of mental factors, these are the afflicted or nonvirtuous minds that arise in dependence on the root delusions such as attachment, anger and so forth. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Does awareness only relate to objects that are sensed through the senses?

No. The five sense objects are given as an example, but an object of thought can also be the object condition. After seeing yellow, we may start thinking about it, comparing paint samples or imagining a whole wall, though the object condition is still the yellow seen by eye consciousness. Some objects are purely mental, such as time or impermanence. Time has no physical basis, since watches are not time. Sense consciousnesses simply bring in raw information, while the conceptual mind decides we like or dislike the yellow. Thinking mind knows things indirectly and in a very different way, and this conceptual framework causes our problems as well as freeing us from them.

Scroll to Top