18 min · 1,841 words · 10 May 1994
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. This question and answer session continues an earlier talk on emptiness. The teacher says the clear light state at death resembles realization of emptiness because gross consciousnesses have ceased, though ordinary people cannot use it for meditation. He argues that genuine realization must be lasting rather than a momentary quiet mind, and that karma remains the responsible factor behind how phenomena arise from the sphere of emptiness. He then discusses whether a lama can choose to assume sickness.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1994-05-10
Duration: 18 min
UUID: 07d373ce-48ba-4e0e-bf4f-f7628b29aa8b
Words: 1,837
See, I haven’t got any, what’s called, instructions teaching specifically, Catherine, for that question because such question hasn’t come about. But based on the teachings generally and instructions generally, we would say why the clear light state of mind during the death, even ordinary person’s case, is likened similar to realization emptiness or state of emptiness realization is because in the case of ordinary person as well that is the state of mind where all gross consciousnesses have stopped. So there is no wrapping of the mind with gross consciousnesses. So gross consciousnesses basically mean gross attachment, hatred, and the eighty categories of concepts as they describe. So it’s mere.
As I said, I haven’t got specific instruction on that, but generally based on other instructions we can see. For ordinary people’s case, there is just a state of mind of certain purity free of gross, but there is no capability to use that clarity of mind as a time to meditate on emptiness. Whereas in the case of experienced and seasoned practitioner, they would grab that opportunity. So it would also seem paradoxical that mind itself is in clear light state, but yet there has to be a subjective mind which does meditation on that clear light. So it does seem a bit contradictory how that would happen.
But we can say that would happen. In the case of seasoned practitioner, the mind will have the capability. Mhmm. Yeah. Okay.
But along that same line, if, you know, if there is birth after birth after birth from beginning of this time, say these people in, you know, who who claim to have sparks, you know, realization. Say in their previous life, they attain a high a high level within the preparation state, the the path of preparation Mhmm. Which was just as far Mhmm. From actually attaining the path of saint, wouldn’t that imprint be I mean, possibly be strong enough in that person that better sort of give them a boost somewhere. Mean, how would that work?
I mean, just in in in every rebirth, do you start absolutely from scratch? No. No. Until you attain a direct realization of That’s enough, Jim. We’re about something.
Yes, yes, yes. That’s right. We’re talking a specific situation. Definitely, you don’t need to start from scratch every definitely you don’t have to start from scratch every next three days. But we’re saying if someone has realized emptiness in previous life, direct realization, then in next life, theoretically saying that person will have continued state of mind realizing emptiness.
Now there is form part of saying it is non relapsible part, scripturally speaking. Even way before that, the path of seeing. But in there they talk more about not falling to three lower rebirths. But anyway, with sparks, it just will have to be a peoples’ claim. So it’s possible that people are mistaking a quieter state of mind. When they experience a quieter state of mind, there is an experience as a realization.
Possible. Yeah. Very possible. Yeah. Yeah.
And what you’re saying is that realization of emptiness is beyond merely experiencing a quiet Yep. That’s right. It can’t be just momentary. Right. State of mind.
Yep. So it cannot be a momentary as well. It cannot be just happening without any necessary effort towards its actualization or experience. Yeah. Somebody who has or who would have to have this right path of seeing a realization.
Yeah. I crave with you very much in agreement with your I your last point about. Many people have mistaken idea that it’s, you know, yet another phenomena out there to stress. And yet, come across in my readings many times a phrase. I don’t know what it is in Tibet, obviously, called the sphere of emptiness.
Mhmm. Yes, ma’am. What is that? What is the sphere of emptiness? That just a poetic term or No, it is good.
Now the whole thing about what’s called emptiness, it’s something we cannot put it aside from the context of karma. That’s why I was thinking people in scientific world I mean, I don’t understand at all anything about quantum physics and so forth, although it’s fashionable thing to look into books talking about them. According to them, like, there’s a talk of scientists looking for, especially physicists looking for a unified field where everything emerges from. I was thinking, similarly, I mean, a couple of years ago, not a couple of years ago, there was a lot of talk about chaos theory theory of chaos. Although they were still not finding any reason which causes that initial butterfly effect.
Temporarily, they have given a suppositional factor with some term. But anyhow, what I was saying is, again, there is a very dramatic concept of looking at a very vague compared to many in the past, there is a very advanced understanding about phenomenal happening. Yet, they cannot reconcile because they can’t find the bottom line that count that is responsible for all this. And I think it will be difficult. It will be difficult because everything happens out of karma, and karma is so complex.
Now the very manifestation of the watch or the book from this sphere of emptiness or from emptiness itself is due to karma. Without karma, this manifestation from emptiness would not happen. So in what’s called relation with emptiness theory, we have to bring back the karma being the responsible factor. And the word sphere for emptiness, it is correct and is used throughout the classical scriptures’ language. It’s just more or less talking about, we might say, energy field, but without the bad connotation as if it is solidly there.
So some kind of some kind of untraceable potentiality. You can say that. So I mean, that’s what what would be a sphere would be. But still, it cannot be a solid thing. I can mention that.
And no. I was just thinking about a very interesting point on this point. So, yeah, after all, we have to trace it back down to karma being responsible for that. And it is like, unthinkable how things happen, like, unimaginable. And the point I was thinking was they do say, like, as you heard, because it is emptiness, everything is possible.
Now in there, emptiness can be seen as a potential field from which emerges. Like the very line from Nāgārjuna says, is emptiness feasible, everything is feasible. So in a way, the point is, if it is emptiness, anything can happen from that. And it’s not that difficult to relate, like many years ago, the capability of chips, computer chips, do so many things, and the miniaturization of things, and many other things, or even the like a cordless communication satellite, so forth, unimaginable thing. But they do happen.
There’s nothing like to be amazed. More more amazing things can be technologically made in the future because after all, it’s the field is emptiness. The the source, the very base is emptiness. And the very base is emptiness, and it’s a beautiful line. I I don’t think it will ever be proven wrong.
We still can leave it open, that Nāgārjuna’s line. In whichever is emptiness feasible, everything is feasible. That’s the way I say it. Okay. Any more questions?
I hope it’s not like a very random hodgepodge sort of thing. Being Buddha and the the assuming of sickness. Let’s say that Nipasha had a blood test for a particular illness that he was assuming and all the biochemical indications were that he had the illness. Mhmm. And the test for the existence of the virus indicated that he had the virus as well related to that illness.
Is is it more of is it what what’s the sense of assuming? Is it assuming as in making a choice in inverted commas to allow this to occur to my physiology Mhmm. As distinct from the rest of us where it just happens whether we want it or not? Mhmm. Or is it assuming in a sense of just putting on an act when the physiology really hasn’t been changed?
Do you get the difference? Yes, it’s an interesting question and difficult to differentiate. It can work on both ways. Like on that point, like last Thursday, when we talked about that, we were saying in His Holiness, the Dalai Lama’s second autobiography, Freedom in Exile, under the chapter called Magic in Mystery, he, in passing, talks about the passing away of his senior tutor. And the anecdote mentioned there was when he was away in Europe somewhere, his senior tutor, Ling Rinpoche, suddenly fell sick in India.
But he wasn’t unable to go straight or return to India. But eventually, when his holiness did return to India, Ling Rinpoche was still sick. And finally, he didn’t recover from the sickness, and he died. Now, that’s an anecdote mentioned by His Holiness in his autobiography. And the concluding remark he makes is firstly, His Holiness says, Ling Rinpoche has been his, like, rock solid support without whom or from whom he draws all his supports and everything.
And life without him would have been unimaginable. So now when when he looks back at the whole incidence of the sickness, he realizes that Ling Rinpoche, his tutor, deliberately prolonged the sickness in order for him to get used to be without him. So that’s what he mentions in the autobiography. Now in that, we can really infer that His Holiness believed his tutor had the control and choice to even prolong the sickness, which would imply that he also had the choice to actually make it happen. I mean, I don’t think it cannot be irreconcilable to say that a Lama or enlightened being makes the choice and physiologically the change also happens.
There can be nothing wrong. You can say, the implication is if one assumes, then it may not necessarily physiologically change in place. Yeah, that’s acceptable. But we don’t know. Even in their case, dead body does show the normal symptom of sickness and so forth.
So we might say that the whole lot is an assumption at display in good sense. And then reading that part in the autobiography, it was quite normal if one assumes his holiness teacher didn’t have the control on sickness and prolonged sickness and wasn’t enlightened, then it’s quite a sad reading because the sickness was a shock and was paralyzed for a long duration. And it’s pretty tragic if it happens to a choice less ordinary being. So when I read, I felt, oh, was a bit, would that happen to you longer? But the concluding was a good one.
Yeah. So it his holiness believed his tutor deliberately prolonged the sickness. Poisoning. Poisoning is being like poison. Yeah.
It is. Yep. It is supposed to be poison. Yeah. So it’s same thing.
Yeah. It’s enlightened being. And it’s similar with Milarepa, how they talk like that. Anyway
Key terms in this teaching
- clear light ö sel (Tib)
- The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
- path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
- The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
If someone reached a high level of the path of preparation in a previous life, could that imprint give them a boost in this life, as with people who claim sudden realization?
Nobody has to start from scratch in each new life. If someone directly realized emptiness in a previous life, then in theory they will carry on with a state of mind realizing emptiness in the next life. Scripturally, there is a part described as non-relapsing, even well before the path of seeing, though the texts there speak more about not falling into the three lower rebirths. As for people who claim sudden sparks of realization, this has to rest on what people claim. It is quite possible that they are mistaking a quieter state of mind for a realization, when they experience that quieter state.