1 h 1 min · 6,248 words · 10 May 1994
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk opens with reflections on a teacher assuming sickness, explaining that from a Mahayana and Tantric view the teacher’s illness is a display for students’ benefit rather than ordinary suffering. It continues the Tuesday series on the ninth chapter of Shantideva’s Bodhicaryavatara, introducing emptiness as a merely negative, non-affirming phenomenon, inherent existence as unalterable existence, and the need for repeated meditation to move from conceptual understanding to realization.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1994-05-10
Duration: 1h 1m
UUID: ef63e3e2-4265-4777-ab94-eafd790ce0eb
Words: 6,244
It is assuming sickness, and last few weeks have not been able to take the classes. And Rinpoche has advised that, the classes should not be left blank, so people don’t get disappointed. Therefore, the first Thursday, I was able to take the class. And last Tuesday, unfortunately, due to certain reasons, I wasn’t able to take. So Jim very kindly took over the class.
It was good because Rinpoche is very concerned to not let the classes go blank. Expression meaning not to just let it nothing happen. So at least there’s some review and discussion as well or something happening to keep the continuity. Will have to excuse me. It’s not good to apologize at the beginning all the time when my voice is not, that well at the moment.
And with the classes, maybe before we go into the actual topic of the Tuesday evenings, it may be good to maybe briefly talk about how in Mahāyāna and especially Tantric Buddhist perspective, when a teacher becomes sick, what is the perspective to be seen and held by the trainees, the disciples? This topic was already discussed the first Thursday after Rinpoche assumed sickness. Unfortunately, my talk on that topic wasn’t recorded on the tape. We did try to record it, but afterward found it wasn’t recorded. It was very interesting, like a class at that time, on the topic, because there came up a lot of questions from people and active, what’s called clarification of many points about what happens when a teacher assumes sickness or teacher is sick.
I will, briefly just, as a as it’s important point, briefly say a point about it. The thing is, in Mahāyāna and especially Tantric context, the Lama, the Lama or teacher is Buddha, so is enlightened being who is beyond suffering, beyond impure thoughts, the causes of sufferings, and therefore beyond actual pain and suffering of sickness. This then would mean there will have to be dramatic difference in the way how people would have to view a teacher assuming sickness as what normally people would look at others. An ordinary person becomes sick. Of course, this whole point will boil down to the basic basis whether a Lama, a teacher, is a Buddha or not, whether a teacher is an enlightened being or not.
There’s no time and not necessary necessary to go into that point. There are so many reasonings put forth in all the major Lamrim teachings and commentaries, how Lama is a Buddha, a teacher is a Buddha, but manifesting in the form of human, to guide us on par with our accessibility through karma and so forth. Yet that whole point will boil down to that basic thesis whether a Lama actually is a Buddha or not. But let’s assume that all those reasonings put forth in Lamrim teachings are correct and reliable and no need to repeat over them, then that’s on the assumption that Lama is enlightening being a Buddha. Then it is not then difficult to see that a Lama sickness is an act, in good sense, a display, a manifestation in good sense.
The main reflection would be to give a lesson or some kind of instructions to the trainee and disciples. But also, there is a kind of a big difference. If one sees a Lama as ordinary person subject to impure thought, the causes of sickness, the impure sufferings. And in that way, if one really thinks a Lama is sick and must be suffering immensely, It is it cannot be denied that such a care is genuine, well well intentioned. But we can see that whole perspective would be based whether out of innocence out of innocence that whole perspective is based on the point Lama is ordinary person, and is not enlightened, has all the impure part.
If that would be the case, then there is no point to rely one’s whole lot and faith and everything upon such a person. One is contradicting oneself. But on practical level, as on that poster we touched, on practical level, should we then not attempt to give medication and look after the Lama even though it can be an act? Or should we let it just go like that? And why also, from the Lama’s side, they themselves do what’s called make attempt to go to hospital and receive medication and so forth?
It is a contradiction. And to put it beautifully, it is a paradox, and so much of it you can find in the Mahāyāna Buddhism and Tantric Buddhism. There’s a lot of paradoxical things. But I would think that they all are, like, justifiable, and they all have their rightful meaning and reasons behind. In the case of Lama deliberately taking medication, the lesson would be that even to get cured, even one may not be sick, but by having assumed sickness, there will have to be a illusory means by which that assumed sickness can be cured.
So for an act, there will have to be another act to match with that on on that basis. And that would also indicate that there is no denial from the normal side of cause and conditions in producing the results. Cause and effect relationship is maintained. But we would say that would be the good way to look at such paradox in this case. Now, if one views Lama as sick as one would normally to another ordinary person, then the outcome that happens in one’s behavior, gestures, language, so forth, would be totally inappropriate, although we don’t need to, like, bash for what people do with good intention.
But it would be completely inappropriate and so and other things. For example, people would would say, oh, yeah, I will pray for Rinpoche. I will pray that he recovers soon. Mhmm. And if it goes further, it can be a bit humorous where people might do deity practice and send white lights or purification for Lama who who may need purification or not.
There could be such inappropriate, innocent things done based on such perspective. We can therefore say there’s a huge difference in the two perspectives. But in the questions, there were talks about then should we go and offer flowers to the Lama or not. But we can I mean, there can be such things, such questions out of practical inconveniences and our requirement one may need to ask? But the thing is there’s still nothing wrong based on the same concept that Lama is the Buddha.
One can still do the other things one would normally do in the case of an ordinary person being sick. So when we sit a Lama, offer flowers, and so forth, these are feasible. They all do all work. Anyway, it seems like not very good way to go into all the details. And the other reason is one other important point related with that is why then do Lama become sick?
Why do they assume sickness? Why do they put on the act of sickness? Obviously, it is alleged and very strongly believed, even in the tradition, that, when students are not in harmony and when they are not practicing well, then that would be reflected in the health of Lama. Because after all, the very existence of Lama is completely and wholly for students and trainees’ benefit. Not at the moment is for her or his benefit from the Lama’s side.
Not not the moment. Again, this basic premises that Lama is enlightened being. There’s no need to look after one’s fulfillment. It’s already fulfilled. So the reason why Lama becomes sick, of course, that is given in the tradition, but Buddha’s students and members don’t have to feel guilty and negative about it.
And also from my side, to talk about it would be inappropriate, as I did say at this point on the Thursday, first Thursday, because we can see, on the other hand, Buddha’s members and students had the wonderful, incomparable karma and merit to be able to host and receive teachings from one of the rarest beings you could find in this part of the universe is such a teacher who, even as more people would know, who in this moment has great requirement by his many students’ intensive practicing and studying once over in India and in his native homeland in Tibet. People here don’t have to feel negative about that. The other reason a Lama would assume sickness as well eventually even assume death, dying, would be to very strongly teach, with great emphasis, the need to terminate grasping that things would last permanently, What scripturally is called permanent grasping, that things would permanently be there. Like as you know, there are four major misconceptions, saying impermanent as permanent, unclean as clean, not empty as empty emptiness as not empty, and without self as being with self or identity. So those are the four misconceptions.
So especially in measure against permanent grasping, the Lama would assume even death, dying away. And this, you know, there is reflection in the long life prayers which are composed afterward that the Lama please return soon, that in those prayers whoever composes the prayer, which has to be another high Lama, say, a Dalai Lama or someone else, it is quite common that the prayer would contain the lines such as, in order to pacify or in order to eliminate the permanent grasping of the trainees, the disciple, you have now entered into dharmakaya sphere, dharmakaya realm. But please, with your great compassion for the sake of destitute sentient beings, please return soon. Yes. So there would be such lines and theme in that direction in the prayers.
So those two would be like main reasons a Lama would assume sickness. At any rate, like whether a Lama is alive or assuming sickness or passing away, the emphasis is to benefit sentient beings by guarding them on the correct path or by any way of teaching. Okay. So we’ll stop that point on that one. Is it all right?
Now with the Tuesday evenings, Rinpoche’s teachings has been on the ninth chapter by Śāntideva’s work, popularly called in English the Bodhisattva’s way of life. And that chapter mainly deals with wisdom. But it is a very interesting chapter, or for that matter, a writing of teachings about wisdom and realization of emptiness, overcoming of ignorance the cause of all our problems and suffering by presenting multitudes of counter responses by other opinions during those classical time. So from and therefore, it contains a lot of, like, viewpoints by other Buddhist tenets against the highest Buddhist tenets, of which Śāntideva explains the wisdom and the emptiness part. Like in any teaching, it is possible sometimes, although it may be very in appearance and format, technical looking, textured, or very textual session.
But all sorts of people could attend this session. Complete beginner, not very familiar with the concepts, and other premises based on which the present talk is being given. There would be people who have heard the topics of this session so many times. It’s therefore difficult to cater for all different types of people. In the Buddhist perspective, that’s why there is a saying, Only an enlightened being, or one who has attained level of foreknowledge, a term meaning clairvoyance of reading others’ mind, can very suitably cater for sentient beings’ needs.
Otherwise, it would be like talking without any, what’s called, awareness and understanding about the need and to whom to cater for. And also because of that, there’s a saying, Buddha’s teaching never is unsuitable to anyone, and enlightened beings’ teaching is never unsuitable to anyone. The reason for that is the enlightened being who has power, capability of mind to read others’ mind, their disposition, their likes and need, will give teaching suitable to them no matter how many mixed types of listeners there would be. But then, of course, there’s a mention of Buddha may speak in one language, and it could be heard by listeners of hundreds of different languages. The point for this is, therefore, during the teachings, of course, difficult from part of translator to not sound not sound intelligible in good sense, like so not to make it unknown to certain people.
If there is an interpretation of the translation, then it is already an extra bit in the actual delivery of the teaching, and people could get bored and so forth. Therefore, it is possible that people who have been coming during Tuesday evenings may feel that the teachings are a bit unrelatable, unplaceable, and so forth. From Rinpoche’s side and also from my side, as translated, we try our best how to cater for all with our limited resources. Now linked with that reason and linked with that point is well, coming here, I was thinking how should I manage the session tonight. If they turn out to be different types of levels of people, then it may not be suitable to do a review of what has been gone so far in the explanation by Rinpoche, because that might sound a bit too textual and unrelatable.
In which case, I thought it would be better to start with some general important points about wisdom and about emptiness. And then if there is a time, we perhaps can go through the prepared outline which covers at one glance what has been covered in the Tuesday evening so far. At this point, people want to maybe ask questions or something. Are are you happy to continue? Alright.
Okay. Yeah. Now oh, okay. Let’s all we’ll realize emptiness tonight. Now, as a translator, I have done emptiness talk translation many times.
And with all due respect, of course, it all comes down to a point saying, it is empty because it’s not inherently existing. It is emptiness, so it’s empty. It is void because it lacks true existence. It lacks existence from its own side, whatever the topic or the example of the context being. So on a language level, it is easy to say emptiness means emptiness or lack of inherent existence.
Emptiness means lack of natural formation or lack of actual formation, actual existence. So before that, it’s maybe interesting to find that in the original languages, they use synonyms for existence. So existence is synonyms with formed, and existence is synonymous with is there, or existence in the sense of not not as a being or abiding or surviving, but also present present absent an object of knowledge, but formed and existing. So they’re used as the same interchangeable word in the scriptures. So it is not that difficult in the translation.
And also in papals, whoever have listened to emptiness teachings, it is emptiness. The book is emptiness. It’s nature’s emptiness because it doesn’t truly exist. It doesn’t inherently exist. It is not formed truly there.
It does not exist from its own side. So all those now it becomes like a sort of easily flowing with no hair raising inclusiveness raised from the listener’s side. And negative thing about it, it would become like more like jargon, something repeated over and over. Now that negative part comes about to not question what actually those words and terms I mean, and words to look at good way, they are medium of concepts, important concepts. So it comes about due to not asking the question what those means, what inherent means, existing means, and so forth.
Definitely, these talks will not be a meditator’s talk of emptiness, but I would not make it a linguist talk on emptiness. So between the two, will say something a balance of two? Like, I mean, if it’s a meditator’s talk on emptiness, it would be out of realization. But we never should not deny the need of the medium in which that realization is expressed. Otherwise, in the first place, the enlightened beings would not use the speech and medium of language and science and so forth.
Okay. That’s one was a good thing to look at or comment after. Now the other thing is similar other thing about emptiness is, yes, I can relate. The book doesn’t exist truly. The book doesn’t exist inherently.
But what happens then? It doesn’t nothing happens to my perspective. My whole perspective doesn’t change. It doesn’t seem to lessen my ego grasping. It doesn’t seem to uproot the causes of my saṃsāra, my existence of cycle.
Yes. Yeah. The person, the door, and so forth is not truly there. Yes. I’ve heard about it many times, reasoning.
It is interdependent. It is dependent arising. It’s not truly there. Now that’s another thing. But it appears, and I can ask or relate, yet it appears.
And it’s not there. Now the feeling one has this, what such thing is, what then the thing about these two, they are related, and we’ll go I mean, about inner inherently existing and so forth, we’ll discuss later. But let’s see. The thing about that is the question would would be asked then how come or when would it be possible that one realizes or one understands it’s not truly there? But with that understanding, a change in one’s grasping, a change in one’s view would take place.
Okay. So it’s not that well put, but we’ll look at it in a different way as well. Now the thing is, okay, to an ordinary person, when analyzing non inherent existence or not naturally formed existence, not naturally formed way of things. It is relatable through reasoning, or to put it derogatively, intellectually, conceptually, that it is not truly there. It is not inherently there.
Now, one can relate that, but still it’s supposed to but still it’s there’s still a grasping. There’s still a kind of cause of all impure thoughts, what’s called ego grasping. Now, anyway, that’s the point. If it’s not made that clear, now we can relate this point, why that happens, that we can relate intellectually, that we can relate theoretically, but nothing happens in the state of our consciousness. Nothing happens in the way our transformation of mind is supposed to happen in realizing the wisdom, in realizing selflessness or in realizing emptiness.
Now that would not happen. So that’s the question. That’s the problem and it’s the thing to look at. Now as a response, that would not happen to ordinary person. Nothing no transformation will happen.
One will still go on with ego grasping. One still go on with ignorance. Although when one reasons that it is not truly there, it is not inherently there, that one can relate. But the moment that stops, that doesn’t the grasping is still there. The ignorance is still there.
So that happens. Now the reason for that would be, from one point might be a bit negative and depressing. But to say the bitter truth is in the highest Buddhist tenets’ perspective, the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika, the Prāsaṇgika, in their perspective, an ordinary person’s consciousness is necessarily mistaken consciousness. Or to put it paraphrase, a person who has not yet realized emptiness, that person’s mind or consciousness all the time is distorted, all the time is mistaken because there is ignorance. So it’s not surprising when joined when joined with this present problem that we can in we can theoretically but still nothing happens.
The grasping is still there. These are, I think, extremely important point because this and the answer for that would dispel a lot of commonly thought of commonly thought of misunderstandings about emptiness and realization and so forth. Is it alright to go like that? Yeah. Now on the other hand, let’s look.
Oh, okay. Because I already mentioned about the depressing part. So better to better to put something else to uplift as against that. Well, that means I am an ordinary person who has not yet realized emptiness. How depressing.
Everything about my mind is mistaken. Now in the highest Buddhist standards understanding, it is true. In factually, it is relatable to be true. But good thing about the whole explanation about emptiness oh, sorry. In this case, about ignorance and mistaken, distorted consciousness of ordinary being.
Good thing that is that comes in the explanation and teachings about it is there will there will be end to such state if the methods are applied, if the antidotes are applied, if one does the necessary practices in meditation. So it’s uplifting. Well, I’m an ordinary person, but I can become Buddha. I can become enlightened given the practices and meditation and so forth done. So it is not depressing to counter with that.
Yes. So that’s the point. Now let’s look at the other point. Say, as ordinary person, if it is acceptable, since beginningless time Of course, this is based on the basic theory. There is no beginning or there was no beginning to our mind.
It has been coming from beginningless time. And from beginningless time, it has been associated with ignorance, the lack of wisdom, realizing emptiness from beginningless time. And along with that, from beginningless time, from our beginningless re beginningless rebirths and rebirths, Our mind has been flowing with all impure thoughts, attachment, hatred, jealousy, so forth. We have, therefore, all these layers of wrappings on our mind consciousness, would it then be possible that with mere momentary rationalization and applying theoretically even the correct reason to prove emptiness, then there would be change with such a thick layered mind, with ignorance, and so forth. So that would what’s called cover Okay.
That thing. Now, otherwise, there should happen change the moment we apply reasonings that the book is not there, that I’m not really existent, I, me, the stone grasping is not there, it’s merely labeled and so forth. There isn’t any change in transformation. So the reason is we’ve been very much associated with negative, the counterpart of that. And near with that slight force, the whole forces of the other cannot be challenged.
So that’s one thing. Now in in this way, then what the instructions then say is one first has to theoretically establish the lack of concrete identity, lack of true existence, lack of inherent existence, so forth about oneself as a person, the ego identity, and about all external phenomena or things. And then one one gets completely cleared of all doubts and misunderstanding, then remain single pointed in what is called equipoise, the profound meditation session. Remain single pointed with the power of calm abiding, which is single pointed mastery of single pointed power to remain concentrated as long as one wishes. Mhmm.
So excuse me. So once theoretically it is understood, then on that ascertained understanding, decisive understanding, remain single pointed in formal meditation session and remain single pointedly focused on such understanding of emptiness, lack of true existence, lack of inherent existence. Not one meditative session, not one equipoise, but many repeated sessions of profound meditation. And then if it improves, then one would gain what is called the realization of space like emptiness during equipoise, during profound meditation. And then when coming out of that meditation session, by the force of having ascertained emptiness to single pointed focus during the session, that out of session, things would appear, but there will be no grasping.
There will be no clinging. Only then it happens that there will be no clinging. Only then if one does theory theorize or rationalize about non inherent existence, there will along by be no clinging and grasping to the things of oneself. And that becomes what scripturally call the illusion like emptiness. So there are those two, the space like emptiness during equipoise and profound meditation time, and illusion like emptiness during post session times or during in between sessions.
I mean, if it does sound heavy, sorry about that. But this is interesting because then there will be no need to ask that emptiness can be beyond concept, and it will just come one day. You don’t have to work for it. I mean, will it be reasonable to think that? I mean, that that would be automatically counted.
Such con comes would be automatically, yeah, counted. So there will be no like, there will be no realization without working working for it. Because it is it is very commonly misunderstood thing of people when they come to see lamas in the private interviews and so forth. Without having done any what’s called necessary minimum requirements, they will seem to think that they have realized emptiness or they have sparks of realization of emptiness. And similarly, that emptiness realization might just happen if you just remain everyday calm for a few minutes, and it might just happen like that.
Anyway, see, my main focus in planning, you know, in this session was to talk briefly about important points without making it sound too heavy and negative and bashing. It’s the sort of thing. Yes. That’s how well, it then becomes relatable, that it is meaningful to familiarize because meditation, as would be explained, is familiarization, getting used to virtuous state of understanding and knowledge as counter to non virtuous mistaken, and then retain it and maintain it maintain it over and over where the force of familiarized knowledge and ascertainment becomes stronger, able to surpass the unmist the mistaken one. And then realization and so forth, what kind of doubt.
And now another point about is why, in emptiness, why one just rely on a brief instruction by a experienced teacher and be content with that? And what the whole hassle and mess about going through all the reasonings and rationalizations and this, that, and that, that, so forth? So people could ask that. I would say the thing is the topic itself is so delicate. There’s bound to be so many avenues of doubts, discomfort, lack of decision, so forth.
Now they all will be cleared if one counters all those doubts and the questions come so forth based on such based on misunderstanding. And then those doubts so forth would be cleared. And the time one goes into the actual meditation and applying our instruction, there is no danger of mind still suspecting, still doubting whether it is truly existing or not, whether it is emptiness or not, so forth. I would say that would be the main need, while there will have to be power rationalization and very rigorous, over and over, applying of you see, in the scriptures, they talk about hundreds of reasonings, especially in the case of Bodhisattva, Mahāyāna realizing emptiness in different to the lower the hearers and solitary realizers. Mahāyāna, Bodhisattva applies hundreds hundreds of reasoning.
So hundreds is as is the word used could mean infinite, as many as possible to every angle in view to establish emptiness in order to overcome all sorts of possible doubts that one may have still lingering about the topic. Yes. So it may definitely seem as ninth chapter, just by outline, it looks very like a court case sort of thing. And then let me please go through some other important points, because this will help in future when language gives teachings that they because I mainly will be dealing with some commonly raised doubts and issues about emptiness and wisdom and few which has to do more with language or the medium by which the important concepts are explained. Now we go back to inherent existence.
Well, it’s we mentioned earlier, it’s very relatable, and we even don’t sometimes seem to question what does lack of inherent existence means. What does lack of? Even simple, it doesn’t exist truly because it’s dependent arising and so forth. Yeah. There doesn’t seem to be.
We’ve been so much like a we won’t not even question direct. It doesn’t even trigger a little bit. Inherent existence, whatever its English meaning and so forth be, is opposed to emptiness. Something exists inherently is opposed to something being of emptiness or lacking such nature. Good thing explained about inherent existence is that if something is inherently existing, the actual word actually it’s popularly translated as inherent existence, but actual word in the original Tibetan and Sanskrit would rather mean, like, naturally formed.
But then word natural, again, can be interpretable to whatever individual connotation. Even in the English speaking your case, you individually, people will differ from like with anything, with translation, it’s very tricky thing because every word has got not only cultural connotation, but individually. These mean different things. How can you scatter for such a diverse interpretation, even on individual level? It is difficult.
But still, assuming there is a commonly unwritten acceptance about the words, general meaning, then originally, the words for inherent existence actually says naturally formed. So whatever that would but generally naturally formed, whatever it would mean, that’s how it means. Later on, some bright translators in the sixties and seventies, especially Jeffrey Hopkins. Those people might have felt it better to use the word inherent to mean it more. Although inherent is just being there as you go look into its literal meaning in etymological and dictionary doesn’t really convey the original meaning.
No matter whatever be those difference, let’s look at inherent existence. Now in the like Dzongkapa’s writing on praise to Buddha for having taught interdependent arising there, the line says, If something is naturally formed, if something is inherently existing, then it is unalterable. And if something is dependent arising, it is alterable. It is changeable. So from that, we get a very good description.
No matter whatever inherent existence so forth may have different meaning in even in English speaking world, but the definition we then would find is if something is inherently existing, it is unchangeable. It is unalterable. So that would mean as then the whole teachings become so relevant because they do talk about, say, if the book is inherently existing as book, then it will always be book. It will never change, no matter elemental and natural disasters or forth. It will subject to no change at all, unalterable.
But that is inherently there, naturally formed as that. So that’s a very good description. And then we can relate when there is a teaching and so forth. It is emptiness because it is not inherently existing. So it is not existing unalterably.
It is not existing unchangeably. It is subject to change and so forth. Sounds good. Yeah. It makes a huge difference about those points.
And now let’s say word emptiness itself again. Unfortunately, I didn’t get a chance to look at old English translations of Buddhist texts on emptiness or wisdom recently. Otherwise, it would be interesting to look what in the past, people would have used the word for to translate the word and. Into yeah. Okay.
That’s good. That’s I mean, that’s still, I mean, popularly followed, both whiteness and emptiness. But apart from that, because it gives a good what’s going on? It gives a good avenue to dispel a lot of misunderstanding about emptiness itself, even by using the right term and medium to express it. Like emptiness, well, does ness part, n e, the last part, convey to English speaking people just mere?
Does it convey? It doesn’t. It doesn’t convey that part. Therefore, in the original word, has more like empty, and is only or merely or just. So just empty.
Merely empty. Merely. Now that itself wouldn’t would seem more like a language play or word play, but the implication behind that is in the explanation about emptiness, they They did go in the past when there was a lot of misunderstanding about it in the classical period, even in Tibet in third and fourteenth century during Tsongkhapa’s time. The masters like Sankara did write detailing about how emptiness is not an affirming phenomena, but it is not affirming. It is negative phenomena.
What that well, that’s scriptural language. What that means is because a lot of people still think emptiness is nature of everything, that everything is in the nature of emptiness. But they still, underlyingly, beneath their mind, they still seem to think emptiness must be something solidly to really go for it. Well, it it must be there. So that’s the mistake.
Even like in the liberation in the Palm of hand, Bhagavam Guramji, on that point mentioned, while doing the meditative in during session and meditate emptiness, if one thinks one has found emptiness, then that’s wrong. If one thinks I’ve realized emptiness, then it indicates it’s imperfect. So it’s not to be found. Emptiness itself is emptiness. That’s why in the divisions of emptiness, they’re talking about four emptinesses, sixteen emptinesses, twenty emptinesses.
And in those lists, we do find the list. Emptiness, emptiness. As such, you say, external emptiness, internal emptiness, emptiness, emptiness, itself is emptiness. So at least that’s the meaning. So scripturally put, therefore, emptiness is called as a negative phenomena, non affirming phenomena.
For example, say for example, say, the fat cat eats and the fat cat doesn’t eat during daytime, then it it is negative, but it is not non affirming. It is affirming. What it affirms is implicitly it affirms a statement that the cat must be eating during nighttime because the cat is fat. The fat cat doesn’t eat during daytime. So and that’s it, what’s called classical example given.
Although in the text, they used the name of the classical character during Buddhist time, a person. Yes. And so that’s affirming. But if we say booklessness, then it doesn’t affirm or say anything apart from that. So that’s a negative phenomena.
So anything a statement which doesn’t say anything or doesn’t implies anything at all is then scripturally called the negative phenomena, non affirming phenomena. And emptiness is explained as a negative phenomena, non affirming phenomena. But that is the very that’s a very brief way of describing things. Very good. See, thing about the technical words and things in any field of knowledge and work is to save verbosity, wordiness.
So in the past, the great seers have used short, compact words, so they use non affirming phenomena or negative phenomena. The reason the meaning behind this that if something’s emptiness, that still doesn’t say it doesn’t mean to imply there’s something beyond that. That’s that’s the that’s the it. That’s the mere absence. And and it’s supposed to be just empty.
The just part or the merely empty is supposed to indicate that part. Mere. Just the knee part, the mere. And then but being very little in eighty nine, for Rinpoche’s nine preliminaries are using their forward emptiness, just empty, just empty, just empty. So it’s very awkward, but it has its own, like, meaning.
So and sometimes it is good to use alternate word to, like, trigger some kind of thinking. But Elaine and some some other people have suggested maybe just empty may be a bit awkward, so merely would be better. So merely empty. Merely empty. So instead of emptiness, merely empty.
That’s good. And so the whiteness, but that that still has that called awkwardness. So mere void. Mere just void. Anyway, that’s opinion.
You can consider and look at it how it is. So the emptiness emptiness is explained to be emptiness. Emptiness is not solidly to be found. The things about this is they dispel a great deal of popular questions which then need not be asked. No question sessions.
Yeah. And there are some other important points, but I think we’ll limit to this. And then we’ll, anyway, have some questions. And after the questions, if we have any time, then we’ll briefly go through the review of Rinpoche’s teaching so far based on outline and was suggested somebody suggested it would be good to have debate with some one group of section holding a thesis and other asking questions. Perhaps we can do that on the outline later if there’s time.
Yeah. Okay. Then we’ll have some questions anyway. Well, in the taking the instruction, the that’s the spark is the way of people’s description, but it scripturally, would mean direct realization. That only happens when one has sorry.
When that happens, then one is on path of seeing, which means one already has done path of accumulation and part of preparation. During those two parts, already it’s expanded, there has to be a great deal of many sessions and meditation theoretically on emptiness to conceptual understanding. So we would it would mean, as I said, as people exclaim, sparks happening, would be more likely such thing doesn’t happen. So, like, if the realization or any experience of realizing emptiness happened, it would happen after a great deal of theoretical and conceptual sound understanding of emptiness, along with a great deal of accumulation of merits and purification. And when direct realization happens, it would not just be a spark.
It would have continued. So his birthday is to be a describe it. Oh, people claim, to put it nicely, but in other it’s just a I mean, people claim also I mean, as a what’s call it private interview translators throughout. People come with all sorts of claims, and you cannot I mean, denies. Yes?
Key terms in this teaching
- buddha, a sang gye (Tib)
- A fully awakened being, who has totally eliminated all obscurations veiling the mind and has fully developed all good qualities to perfection. LYWA
- dharmakaya truth body; chö ku (Tib)
- The ultimate reality of a buddha’s enlightened mind, which is unborn, empty of true existence, free from conceptual thought, naturally radiant, beyond duality and spacious like the sky. One of the three embodiments of a buddha. LYWA
- ego-grasping dagdzin (Tib)
- The ignorant compulsion to regard one's self, or I, as permanent, self-existent, and independent of all other phenomena. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- merely labeled tag tsam (Tib)
- The subtlest meaning of dependent arising; every phenomenon exists relatively, or conventionally, as a mere label, merely imputed by the mind. LYWA
- path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
- The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.