Heart Sutra – 1992-08-18 – Side 1 – KR

45 min · 2,445 words · 18 August 1992

Heart Sutra (Khensur Rinpoche)
Heart Sutra (Khensur Rinpoche)
Heart Sutra - 1992-08-18 - Side 1 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. This talk continues a teaching on the path of meditation, the fourth of the five paths, and its ten grounds. It explains how each ground abandons obstructions, how a Buddha removes the subtle knowledge obstructions, and how meditative equipoise on emptiness does the abandoning. It then begins explaining the five aggregates from the Heart Sutra, including why form is said not to exist for the realizer of emptiness, using the analogy of container, food, eating and eater.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 1992-08-18

Duration: 45 min

UUID: e8182e63-0ff9-4a6f-abf4-1a4ac0fa4ccd

Words: 2,441

According a verse by the renowned master of the Middle Way, Āryadeva, where he is speaking of the great benefits to be derived from an understanding of emptiness. And he goes on to say that those with little merit potential, those who do not make effort, do not even have a doubt, do not even generate a doubt with respect to the meaning of emptiness. But those who do, not even to speak of the realization of emptiness, but really to have a doubt as to whether things exist this way or not in terms of the meaning of emptiness. Simply that doubt shakes the very foundations of mundane existence. So there’s tremendous benefits to be gained out of coming to an understanding of emptiness.

Just by merely reflecting upon emptiness, we’re developing a great deal of merit. And by meditating on it, mind, those afflictive emotions which continually cause the mind to circle within cyclic existence begin to decrease. So in the case of yourselves that you have been listening to emptiness and reflecting and meditating on it and you have accumulated a great deal of creative potential in doing so. Whatever the Dharma might be, whatever the activity may be, if we think of its various benefits, the various advantages in pursuing such an activity, then we’ll joyfully engage in these activities that will develop a great deal of merit. So, in the future when we enter into the path of the universal vehicle, the great vehicle, then we have to know the way to travel that path.

Even if we do not enter into the path in this life, in some future life we will. And what is the road? How are we going to travel that road In order to understand how we’re going to travel the road of the universal vehicle, we need a map. So, in general, when we’re traveling a road, we have various markers by which we orientate ourselves. Know where we are, we know the name of this, and we know the name of this, and we know that we’re traveling in the correct direction.

And in traveling the path in terms of the mind, then we need a direction. And the way in which the mind travels the path is in terms of wisdom and method. So in terms of traveling a path with the mind, we first want to know, well, what path do we enter into first? What are the realizations which are necessary to be generated in order to enter into that path? Along this path, what various faults are eliminated?

What realizations are gained? And then proceeding onward in that fashion, what new generations are needed to be gained, what faults will I newly eliminate on this path, what realizations do I gain, and proceeding along this way until we attain Buddhahood. So, as we’ve mentioned, the universal vehicle has five paths. The first is the path of accumulation. The second is the path of preparation.

The third is the path of seeing. This is where we have direct insight into emptiness. And now, as we were explaining last week, we’re discussing the fourth path, the path of meditation. So, the activities or the work which we perform on the fourth path, the path of meditation, are extremely profound and vast. We are bringing about the cessation of various faults and we are applying various antidotes.

So this is a vast section of the path. So we were discussing this fourth path, the path of meditation. We said that there are 10 grounds over this and we’re going to discuss it in a very simple manner. And we said that the path of meditation is divided into overall three divisions: great, middling, and small. Then each of these has a corresponding great, middling, and small, making nine.

And the very first of these, the smaller and smaller, is divided into two making a total of 10 grounds. So the universal vehicle is divided up into five paths and 10 grounds. So, of these grounds has two paths. Each of these grounds has an unobstructed path. Sometimes it’s translated uninterrupted path.

Unobstructed or uninterrupted. And it has a path of release. The unobstructed path is that which eliminates the obstruction. So, it is the antidote which eliminates the particular obstruction. It abandons the obstruction.

It is the abandoner of the particular obstruction. Therefore, by this, it becomes unobstructed. That’s its name. Then the second, the path of release, is when we’re having eliminated, then there is a freedom from that particular obstruction. So, the path of release is the moment of when having applied the antidote, the obstruction has been eliminated, and then there is a moment when there is a freedom from that obstruction, the path of release, one is released from that obstruction.

Did I explain to you the 10 grounds today? So there there are nine obstructions. The first obstruction is abandoned by the second ground. And the second obstruction is is is abandoned by the third ground.

The third obstruction is is abandoned by the fourth ground. The fifth obstruction is abandoned by the sixth ground. The sixth obstruction is abandoned by the seventh ground. So of the nine obstructions, the the sixth obstruction is abandoned by the seventh ground. So now we’ve arrived at the eighth ground and thus far we’ve abandoned six degrees of obstruction.

At the eighth ground, having abandoned six, there remain three obstructions, three degrees of obstruction yet to be abandoned. And on the eighth ground, we simultaneously abandon all of the smalls, all of the subtle obstructions or the small obstructions. The three levels of small obstructions are abandoned simultaneously on the eighth ground. At the eighth ground, one has completely abandoned all of the afflictive emotions which generate cyclic existence. So, on the eighth ground, we have abandoned all the afflictive emotions.

Have we achieved Buddhahood? No. We haven’t achieved Buddhahood as yet. Though we have abandoned the afflictive emotions, there still remains the predisposition to the afflictive emotions just as we use the analogy that if you poured some alcohol into a glass And though you threw the alcohol out, the smell remained. Likewise, though we have removed the afflicted emotions, there is still a latency or predisposition which remains to be abandoned.

These latencies are referred to as knowledge obstructions or obstructions to omniscience. So though at this point on the eighth ground we have eliminated all of the afflictive emotions which create actions perpetuating cyclic existence, still we have obstructions. And these are referred to as knowledge obstructions. Why? Predispositions or latencies act to obstruct us knowing directly all phenomena simultaneously.

Just like if I cover the bell with my hand, my hand obstructs me from knowing directly that bell. Likewise, it is due to these predispositions of the afflictive emotions, of these latencies which hinder, which obstruct my simultaneously directly realizing all phenomena. So, these are knowledge obstructions. They prevent me, obstruct me from knowing all phenomena. With respect to knowledge obstructions, there are three, great, middling, small.

With respect to the great, of the great, there is the coarse and this is eliminated at the eighth ground. And the middling of the great is eliminated at the ninth ground. And with respect to the small, this has two levels. The first of the two levels is eliminated at the tenth ground. When one eliminates the subtle of the small, knowledge obstruction, one generates the this is simultaneous with the generation of the exalted wisdom of a Buddha.

It is at this point that one has eliminated all faults and brought the consummation all excellent qualities. One has become a Buddha. So, the word Buddha is a Sanskrit word. This word was translated into Tibetan using two syllables, Sangye. This is the Tibetan way in which it was translated.

So it has two syllables, Sangye. Sang means literally to clear, clear away and to eliminate. So the clearing away of all faults, the elimination of all faults. Then the second syllable is which can mean to evolve, that is to grow, to evolve. It’s just like in the case of a lotus, that when it is a seed, it has a certain potential.

And as it grows, its potential is actualized until it’s fully evolved. And it is the same with in terms of when it is the full evolvement of one’s awareness and knowledge, the full evolvement of awareness and knowledge. So the Buddha has many wisdoms, but whatever wisdom, that wisdom is able to directly know all phenomena. Whatever exists, that wisdom directly understands it, knows it just as if it were in the palm of one’s hand. So how does this come about?

The reason that we can’t see all objects is that they are hidden from us, that there is some obstruction which prevents us from being able to see them. But a Buddha is one who has, in removing all the various faults from the mind, removes any type of hindrance, obstruction, which prevents the seeing of all phenomena. So, we’re looking at the 10 grounds of the path of meditation. Over the course of these 10 grounds, we are abandoning all of the various afflicted emotions through the application of antidotes along with the various knowledge obstructions. And these are all abandoned by means of the meditative equipoise on emptiness.

That is to say, the direct realization of emptiness is what is actually doing the abandoning. In this single pointed equipoise, the wisdom which consists of a single pointed meditative equipoise on emptiness has only a single object. That is the emptiness. Emptiness is the only object which is appearing to this consciousness. There is nothing other than emptiness which is appearing to that consciousness.

To such a consciousness, true existence does not appear, inherent existence does not appear, self defining existence does not appear. With respect to the nature of emptiness, there are two factors. There is the non existence. There is the factor which is the non existence of the natural existence of all phenomena or the non existence of the true existence of all phenomena. There there are two truths.

There are there’s the conventional truth and ultimate truth. Ultimate truth is emptiness. Conventional truths are such types of phenomena as the five aggregates, table, flower, eye, nose. These are all conventionalities. They are conventional truths.

In proceeding through the text, The Heart of Wisdom, we were looking at the five aggregates. The five aggregates are conventional truths. Over the 10 grounds, that which does the actual abandoning is the wisdom of meditative equipoise on emptiness. Nothing appears to the wisdom of meditative equipoise other than emptiness. So, for example, the form aggregate is taken as the subject, then it does not end as the subject of meditative emptiness.

When the actual meditative equipoise is generated, the form aggregate does not exist for that consciousness but only the emptiness of that aggregate appears. So, we should think about it and we can look at the actual text where it says there is no form, no feeling, no recognition, no karmic formations, and no consciousness. Though it says it says there does not exist form, there does not exist feeling, or in fact form exists, feelings exist, perceptions exist, mental constructions exist, consciousness exist, the five aggregates exist. Why does it say that? Why does it say there is no form?

Form exists. Why does it say that it doesn’t exist? We should think about that. So, what does it mean when it says there is no form? Over the 10 grounds, that which is realizing emptiness is the wisdom of meditative equipoise.

And the only thing which it is appearing to it is emptiness. So therefore, when it says there is no form, what it means is there is no form for the wisdom of meditative equipoise realizing emptiness. That is to say, the realizer realizing emptiness. For realizing emptiness, there does not exist form. For that realizer, there does not exist form. If form existed for that wisdom of meditative equipoise realizing emptiness, then form would have to truly exist.

So if it is because form does not exist for the wisdom of meditative equipoise, that is to say, that it doesn’t because the form does not exist for the realizer realizing emptiness, that form is empty. If it did exist for that realizer, then it would have to truly exist. So we should think about this, why it says no form. Because if the form did exist for the wisdom of meditative equipoise, then the form would have to truly exist. Why?

Because then the way the object appears and the way the object exists would be concordant. That is that its mode of appearance and its mode of abidance would be harmonious. But in fact, it is a falsity. The way it appears and the way it exists are discordant. But if it existed the way it appeared, it would appear for this wisdom and therefore would have to truly exist rather than mere falsities.

So this applies to the remaining four aggregates. You know, it says there is no form, but it goes on to say there is no feeling, there is no perception, there are no mental constructions, there are no consciousnesses. So this would apply in the same way to all the five aggregates. That their way of existing or their way of non existing are exactly the same as it was applied to non existence or form for such a wisdom consciousness. So we’re going to explain how are the five aggregates posited.

We’re trying to we’re going to explain them in terms of analogy. And in this analogy, the form aggregate is analogous to food. The the feeling aggregate oh, no. I’m sorry. The form aggregate is analogous to the container of food.

The container of food. The feeling aggregate is analogous to food like rice. The aggregate of perceptions is analogous to lentils like dal. The act of mental constructions is analogous to the act of eating the food. And the aggregate of consciousness is analogous to the eater of food.

So it’s explained in terms of these analogies, five analogies. So these are explained in terms of the ease in understanding. The first one in terms of form is the easiest to understand. And then as you’re proceeding, understanding the form aggregate is slightly more difficult until you get to aggregate of consciousness, which is the most subtle and the most difficult to understand.

Key terms in this teaching

conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top