1 h 34 min · 4,721 words · 21 August 2013 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 94-minute teaching, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen walks through the first two stages of the Lamrim, the graduated path to enlightenment. He opens with Togmé Zangpo’s teaching that ethical discipline is the foundation of all spiritual attainment, explaining why it cannot be bypassed even for one’s own welfare. He then moves to the heart of the session: reliance on a qualified spiritual teacher, which he establishes as the root of the entire path. Geshe-la covers eight advantages of correct reliance—progressing toward enlightenment, delighting the Buddhas, avoiding demonic interference, naturally subduing afflictions, advancing through the grounds and paths, never being separated from a teacher across lives, avoiding lower rebirth, and accomplishing all goals—and contrasts these with eight equal faults of not relying or relying wrongly. He emphasizes the risks: reliance offers tremendous gain or tremendous loss depending entirely on correct choice and conduct. The teaching concludes with extended Q&A on recognizing a qualified teacher, handling a teacher who breaks vows, the danger of sinful friends disguised as kind companions, cultural differences between East and West, and what it truly means to take a teacher. For practitioners new to the Lamrim or those exploring the relationship between teacher and student.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2013-08-21 – KR.mp3
UUID: 635b0d31-ac6f-4d16-ae2b-51e0f17e3b35
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Grounds and Paths
Date: 2013-08-21
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~4,718
As Togmé Zangpo says in the 37 practices of a bodhisattva, if one does not protect ethics attaining the capacity to help others would be laughable let alone being able to attain one’s own goals. Therefore the protection of ethics is the training of the bodhisattvas. So this stanza teaches the necessity of practicing ethics. Why is it the case that if one does not protect ethics, one cannot even accomplish one’s own welfare?
This is a case because without protecting ethics, is impossible to attain the state of a Śrāvaka or a hearer. And if one is unable to attain the state of a Śrāvaka or a hearer, one cannot durably protect oneself against a rebirth in these three lower realms. Therefore, it is indispensable to protect ethics to be able to fulfill one’s own welfare. So here, when one refers to the protection of ethics as being indispensable to accomplishing one’s own welfare, this does not refer to one’s own welfare in this life. Ethics is not indispensable to become wealthy or to be healthy.
Ethics, however, is indispensable to attain one’s own welfare in the broader sense of the term, in other words to be able to obtain a higher rebirth in future lives, to be able to attain liberation or to attain full enlightenment. And therefore ethics is indispensable both to attain one’s own welfare and to accomplish the welfare of others. Over and again ethics is compared to the ground of all qualities. It is compared to the ground of all qualities because it is from ethics that all qualities arise. And therefore protecting one’s ethics is the means whereby one can attain states such as the state of a hero or a Śrāvaka and eventually progress upwards in training in the other perfections such as forbearance and so forth.
It is not the case that this is not difficult. This at present however is the only opportunity we will have to engage in such practices. It is therefore now that we should train our minds in this way. So even though this practice is difficult, this difficulty should not be a reason for setting it aside. It is precisely because we have been invoking its difficulty to set it aside since beginningless time that we are in the mess we are in at present.
Whereas beings such as Buddha Śākyamūni who were identical to us many lives ago, instead of setting these practices aside, engaged in them and achieved full enlightenment. Therefore, it is at present when we have the opportunity to do so that we should put these practices into training. Otherwise, if we set them aside yet once again, we will face great difficulty in the future. And therefore it is at present that we should start the process of mental training. Our states of mind at present are inextricably blended with ignorance, with desire, with anger and with the other afflictions.
And it seems very difficult to us to be able to dissociate them from these afflictions. Yet, it is possible and it is not only possible but it is at present that we should do so. Even if we do so for only one minute a day, this minute is well spent. And to turn away from the happiness of this life, we need to give rise to renunciation or definite emergence. Once this has occurred, then we can start training our mind and interest in earnest and we’ll have entered the path.
And then at this point one should train one’s mind in compassion, love and bodhicitta which all arise in dependence on others. In this process we can develop our minds. At present, we set ourselves up as foremost and attach little or no importance to others. It is this attitude which has to be inverted and giving no value whatsoever to this life anymore. We should focus on others and disinterest ourselves from ourselves. This is the training we should undergo.
And therefore, we should take the pledge or the vow to attain the state of full enlightenment for all sentient beings and with this as a motivation listen to these teachings on the graduated stages of the path on the Lamrim. Instead of thinking if I don’t attend the teachings, I’ll be all alone, I’ll be lonely, I won’t have a social life, so I come to the teachings to have a social life. We should instead dispel these worldly thoughts which arise unfortunately automatically and think I would attend the teachings not for my own sake but for the sake of all mother sentient beings. We do not do this because we do not understand the qualities of the state of full enlightenment. When we think of full enlightenment, we probably think of a statue such as a statue behind Geshe-la.
But this is one of the possible manifestations of full enlightenment. Full enlightenment is a state in which all qualities have been perfected and all thoughts or defects have been eliminated. And that state can take numerous possible aspects. Then let us for one minute meditate single pointedly on the motivation I shall attain full enlightenment for the sake of all mother sentient beings. So we shall return after the interlude on the six preliminary practices to the body of this teaching which is Gyalse Thogme’s Cycle of Realization.
At present we have reached stanzas eleven and twelve of this text on page three. Then the root which accords excellently with the dependent arising of whatever excellent collections for this and later lives is through striving at relying on the holy virtuous friend, teacher of the path to rely correctly through thought and application. Moreover, upon seeing this, delight him with the offering of realization and keeping with his words without renouncing him even at the cost of one’s own life, noble gurus have practiced in this way, you too who wish for liberation practice thus. The first word of stanza 11 then indicates that one has accomplished the six preliminary practices and reliance on the spiritual teacher is subsequent to this. The following two verses, the root which accords excellently with the dependent arising of whatever excellent connections for this and later lives indicates that relying on the holy virtuous friend, the spiritual teacher, is the foundation of all physical and mental happiness both in this life and in future lives.
This refers not only to all the excellences of this life, but also to the attainment in future lives of a higher rebirth, of liberation, and eventually of full enlightenment. Correctly relying on the spiritual friend is said to be a dependent arising. As a dependent arising or a tendrel in Tibetan, it indicates that this reliance on the spiritual friend is a cause which gives rise to its requisite effect. The last two stanzas is through striving at relying on the holy virtuous friend, teacher of the path to rely correct through thought and application, teach the four subdivisions of reliance on the spiritual friend. The two first subdivisions, the advantages and the disadvantages of respectively relying and not relying on the spiritual friend are taught implicitly whereas the two latter subdivisions, reliance through thought and reliance through application or through deeds are taught explicitly.
So correct reliance to thought entails first generating veneration for the spiritual teacher and then generating respect through recollecting his benevolence. The training by application involves engaging in the actual practice of relating correctly to the spiritual teacher. Both of these are the foundation of the path. And says the noble gurus have practiced in this way, you too who wish for liberation should wish to act thus. In other words, the great teachers of the past have practiced like this and we ourselves must practice in the same way.
The Lamrim teaches that there are four outlines of relying on the spiritual teacher. The advantages of relying on the spiritual teacher, the disadvantages of not relying on the spiritual teacher, relying through thought and relying through application. The first outline, of the advantages of relying on the spiritual teacher is subdivided into eight. So these eight advantages are first, one will come closer to the enlightened beings and to the Tathagatas. Secondly, one will delight the Buddhas and the Tathagatas.
Thirdly, one will not be oppressed by demons and hardship. Fourthly, the afflictions will naturally subside. Fifthly, one will attain the various grounds and paths. Sixthly, one will not be separated in all one’s lives from the spiritual teacher. The seventh point is that one will not fall in the lower realms.
And the eighth point that one will attain all bliss and happiness. So the first advantage is that if one relies on correctly on a fully qualified teacher, one will come closer to the state of full enlightenment. Then if one does not rely at all, one will not come closer to the state of full enlightenment. However, if one relies incorrectly, one will actually move away from the state of full enlightenment. Why is this the case?
Because generally speaking, one must accumulate merit for countless eons to be able to attain the state of full enlightenment. If one encounters a fully qualified spiritual teacher and one relies correctly on him, then in this very life, just as Jetsün Milarepa, it is possible to attain full enlightenment. This is the case in the context of both tantra and in the context of sūtra. In the context of sūtra for instance, the account is given of the Bodhisattva Sadāprarudita in the 8,000 verse Perfection of Wisdom. So here when one speaks of progressing closer to the state of full enlightenment, it is obviously not referring to a physical path but to a process of inner development And this is the case both in sūtra and in tantra.
Specifically it is said in Anuttara Yoga Tantra that without reliance on the spiritual teacher, on the Guru, there will be no attainment whatsoever. And this is the reason for which the second subdivision of the advantages of relying on the spiritual friend is given because through doing this one satisfies all the Buddhas. Why is this the case? Such behavior delights the Buddhas because one engages in practice and progresses on the path for the sake of other sentient beings. One is therefore accomplishing the goal of all the enlightened beings.
To give an example, imagine that parents have children who always misbehave, who are always naughty. And one day at last, for some mysterious reason, they behave nicely. The parents would be absolutely delighted, wouldn’t they? The Buddhas behold us in an unobstructed way. They can see every single deed which we perform.
Then most of the deeds which we perform are nothing to be proud of. And when the Buddhas behold this great, we can say sadness arises within them and they say, my goodness, these poor beings. On the other hand, when the Buddha’s behold us performing worthy deeds, then since through these deeds we are increasing our accumulation of merit and of virtue and are progressing on the path, they are delighted. Even at the time of Buddha Śākyamūni, when Buddha Śākyamūni manifested in this world as the fourth supreme universal teacher, the overwhelming majority of living beings in this world neither recognized nor acknowledged him as a Buddha. For most human beings, he was merely the son of King Suddhodana, a prince of Northern India.
And even among his close disciples, there were disciples who refused to recognize him as an enlightened being and considered his teachings as spurious such as his cousin Devadatta and the monk Upadatta. So we can see that it is due to one’s uncommon karma that one encounters the son of Śuddhodana as the supreme emanation being and not just as a prince of Northern India. It is not the case that the Buddha Śākyamūni manifested to some as a fully enlightened being and to others, he chose to manifest merely as a prince of the Kshatriya caste of Northern India. It is contingent on the karmic predispositions of those who encountered him that some saw him as a Buddha who taught the teachings of the three vehicles, the vehicle of the Śrāvaka or hearers, the vehicle of the Pratyekabuddha or solitary realizers, and the vehicle of the Bodhisattvas. Whereas others saw him merely as an ordinary being, the son of a king.
It is contingent on one’s own karmic predisposition. For instance, when one has attained the path of accumulation of the Bodhisattva Yana, the Mahāyāna, one becomes able to encounter the supreme emanation beings. Whereas when one has attained the path of seeing, one becomes able to encounter the enjoyment bodies or the Sambhogakayas. And finally, when one has attained full enlightenment, one encounters the Dharmakāya itself. The third advantage of relying correctly on the spiritual teacher is that we will not be disturbed by the various demons and interferences.
There are, generally speaking, four demons. These are the demons of the afflictions, the so called demons of the son of the god of Devaputra, the demons of The third is the demon of the aggregates and the fourth is the demon of the Lord of Death. And what is referred to here is the fact that we shall not be disturbed or afflicted by the demons of the various afflictions such as desire, anger and ignorance. We shall not be the victims of possession by the so called sons of the gods, Devaputras, which if they enter into our body can cause elemental disturbances. We shall not experience disturbances due to the demons of the aggregates.
This refers to disturbances of any of the five aggregates. And finally, we shall not be afflicted by the demon of the Lord of Death. This refers to a premature ending to our lifespan. So this is something which we may find very difficult to have faith into if we do not understand it clearly. It is not being said that karma and causality are abrogated.
We are on the receiving end of our own karma and causality. What is being said is that there will be a reduction of the harmful causes and conditions which might interfere with us. To give you an example for this, there is not a single doctor in existence, however expert who can guarantee that someone will never die. However, for every given cause of death, there probably is a doctor who can be of some help or can prevent death. The third advantage also refers to not falling under the sway of sinful friends.
Sinful friends are a particularly dangerous enemy in that while sincerely wishing to perform our welfare and to help us and often being very affectionate or even in love with us, they are profoundly harmful to our Dharma practice and to our future lives, since they are the main cause for our being cast in the lower realms. Then, if we rely correctly on the spiritual teacher, we do not fall under the sway or the control of these sinful friends. Otherwise, if we do so, it is very difficult to escape from this. Sinful friends are not terrifying creatures with horns and pelts of skin on their backs. Instead they are very kind, gentle and alluring people who love us deeply, who have profound affection for us and who harm us through their wrong views causing us to be reborn in the lower realms.
We have many friends in this life but we do have the right to decide which of our friends are helpful and which are harmful. And this we should do in terms of the results for ourselves and get rid of our harmful friends. Sinful friends are very dangerous, very difficult to recognize to start with. And the reason for which relying correctly on the spiritual friend prevents one from falling under the sway of these is because our Guru will tell to us this is how you should behave, this is what you should abstain from, be careful of this person, this person is harmful to you and so forth. So this is the third outline which is a very difficult one and the fourth one is that if we rely correctly on the spiritual teacher, afflictions will naturally abate.
This is because the afflictions are objects of abandonment and the spiritual teacher will teach us the means to abandon these afflictions. And then the more we suppress the afflictions, the greater increase of our attainments and our eventual progression on the grounds and paths. This is the fifth outline. And an example of this would be for instance when we encounter our guru and he says, so this bodhicitta we have been talking about, do you have it or not? And then when ashamedly we say I don’t have it, the wish to generate it arises and we train in it.
And this is the case because through relying on the spiritual teacher, we will understand the kindness of sentient beings, benevolence towards us, recollect it and through training in bodhicitta progress upwards on the grounds and paths. The sixth advantage is that we shall never be separated from a spiritual teacher and this occurs through the non deceitful nature of causality. To rely on correctly on a spiritual teacher in this life, in future lives, we will also be closely rely correctly to a spiritual teacher. Whereas if one breaks with a spiritual teacher in this life then in future lives one will be far removed from spiritual teachers. And then through being connected life after life with a spiritual teacher, we will train in love and bodhicitta and eventually attain the state of full enlightenment.
The seventh benefit is that we shall not fall in the lower realms if we rely correctly on the spiritual teacher. And this is because to fall in the lower realms, to be reborn in the lower realms, we need the impending cause for being reborn in the lower realms. And as a spiritual teacher directs us to avoid non virtue and to practice virtue, we will not create this impending cause. And finally, through relying correctly on a spiritual teacher, we will accomplish all our goals both contingent and ultimate. There is nothing which in truth can be accomplished without relying on the spiritual teacher.
And therefore reliance on the spiritual teacher is the foundation of all practice from avoiding rebirth in the lower realms all the way upwards to attaining full enlightenment. The eight faults of not relying on the spiritual teacher are the exact opposite or the counterpart of the eight advantages of relying on the spiritual teacher. So for instance, the first advantage is that one shall grow or one shall move closer to full enlightenment. The disadvantage of not relying is that one should move away from enlightenment. The second advantage of relying on the spiritual teacher is that one will delight the Buddhas and the Tathagatas.
The second disadvantage is that one will displease the Buddhas and the Tathagatas. The third advantage is that one will be freed from affliction by demons and obstructions. The third disadvantage is that one will be afflicted by demons and obstructions. The fourth advantage is that one will see a natural decline in the power of the afflictions. The fourth disadvantage is that one will see a great increase in the afflictions within one’s mind stream.
The fifth advantage is that one will naturally progress upwards on the grounds and paths. The fifth disadvantage is that one will sink ever lower in terms of one’s faults. Then the sixth advantage as you remember is through relying correctly on the spiritual teacher in all lives. One will be close to a spiritual teacher. The sixth disadvantage of not relying correctly on the spiritual teacher is that one will be separated from a spiritual teacher in all lives.
The seventh advantage is that one will not fall in the lower realms relying correctly on a spiritual teacher. The seventh disadvantage of not relying correctly on the spiritual teacher or relying wrongly on the spiritual teacher is that one will definitely fall in the lower realms since it is the teachings of the spiritual teacher on the practice of virtue which prevent this from happening. And the eighth advantage of relying correctly on the spiritual teacher, accomplishing all one’s short term and long-term goals leads us to the disadvantage of not relying correctly on the spiritual teacher, we will accomplish none of our goals. Relying on the spiritual teacher is a dangerous practice since there are both great profits and a very great loss to be made. The profits and the losses have been explained.
They depend on whether one relies correctly or wrongly on the spiritual teacher. If one doesn’t rely on a spiritual teacher at all, there are neither profits nor losses to be made. So in some senses it is the safer alternative. If one has not been careful in choosing one’s spiritual teacher and after relying on him one changes one’s mind and one criticizes him, then the eight faults of relying wrongly on the spiritual teacher will occur. Therefore relying on a spiritual teacher offers tremendous profit and the possibility for tremendous loss as well.
One should therefore analyse very carefully over and again over a long period of time someone before deciding to take him on as a spiritual teacher. And if any doubts arise, and one thinks perhaps this behavior might cause me to lose faith in this person later on, it is far better never to enter into that relationship. It is perfectly okay not to rely on a spiritual teacher. Then when one examines a spiritual teacher, one must see whether the characteristics of a spiritual teacher are present or not. Geshe-la will cover that next time since we have run out of time today.
Then in the relationship to someone whose teachings you attend, it is best to view that person as a Dharma friend, someone who talks of Dharma and in that context we are all equal and not to enter in the relation to a spiritual teacher. And in that type of Dharma friendship relationship, we help each other and are only equal. There is no guru in this So we shall stop here. If there are questions, Geshe-la can take questions for fifteen minutes today. I get my question.
Okay. If you’re a student and your teacher breaks his vows, what will happen to the student if they turn against the teacher and then also encourage other students to turn against the teacher? So should that happen then from one’s own side, if let’s say one’s Guru has broken vows and so forth, one should never criticize one’s Gurus and one should never think badly of him. Instead one should think this is a fully enlightened being. I myself have chosen to take him on as a spiritual teacher.
He is performing deeds for the welfare of others, manifesting these deeds which I cannot understand. And if others criticize him, this in no way concerns us. And one should think to myself as well as to others appears the faulty behavior of this teacher, but these are mere appearances and I know that appearances are deceptive. For instance, phenomena appear as inherently existent to me even though they are not. I chose many years ago to take this teacher as a Buddha.
He is a manifestation of Vajradhāra and that is how I try to see him. We are convinced that things exist in the way they appear to us. The mode of appearance of phenomena to us is profoundly faulty. If things truly existed in the way they appear to us, then we would have to say that everything is inherently existent since everything seems to appear as inherently existent. So we can see that there is a big difference between the person who analyzes and the person who does not analyze.
The person who analyzes sees that appearances are at odds with reason and takes a party of reason. The person who does not analyze just looks at the way things seem to be and says this is the way they have to be. Whatever karma we have accumulated we will experience. Is it possible for the sinful friend to be a member of a Sangha or is that impossible or contradictory by nature? A sinful friend or a dharma friend?
A sinful. A sinful friend. As member of the Sangha. Yes. Or is this a contradiction by nature?
Yes. Many, many. Yes, I mean there are many such cases of who merely wears monastic robes, but whose behavior is sinful and who is harmful to one’s own practice. Then such a person is both a monk and a sinful friend. This person is harmful to one’s practice and to one’s attainment of liberation or for enlightenment.
There are many such people. So how can we take refuge in the Sangha in this? You must take refuge in the Dharma and you must take refuge in Sangha, what you are talking about is not a fully characterized Sangha but the ordinary Sangha. The fully characterized Sangha is Ārya beings. An ordinary Sangha you have virtuous and non virtuous monks.
You only take refuge in those which are virtuous. It seems that there are many difficulties in these kinds of situations. For a start, there are cultural differences between Tibetans and Westerners. And so what appears good behavior from one side or what appears bad or negative behavior from one side might be culturally normal and and vice versa. And then on top of that, as Western students, many people might, in their minds, think that they’ve taken somebody as a spiritual teacher without under really understanding what that means.
Can Geshe-la say something about that? So what is the question? Well, there’s two parts to the question. First, there are are cultural differences. Uh-huh.
And what seems acceptable behavior in one culture is not necessarily in another. Therefore, there can be some confusion between students and teachers and vice versa. That’s that’s one part of the question. And the second part of the question is that if a student thinks that they’ve taken a teacher without fully understanding what that means, have they really taken them as a teacher? So, Geshe-la says that for most of the people involved in that situation, since they do not understand the characteristics of a spiritual teacher, then when they say that they have a spiritual teacher or they have a guru, actually they do not understand what they are saying.
Therefore, they only nominally or terminologically have spiritual teacher or a guru. One cannot say they have actually entered into the relationship to a spiritual teacher with the full understanding and belief that such a teacher will lead them life after life to ever higher rebirth until they attain the states of either liberation or full enlightenment. Then the relationship has not been entered into. Therefore here in such cases one will be talking of a nominal relationship to a spiritual friend and nothing more than this. A spiritual friend is someone who teaches the holy Dharma and his disciple is someone who listens to the holy Dharma.
Holy Dharma as from the standpoint of the friend who teaches and of the disciple who listens refers to virtue. If non virtue is involved, it no longer is the holy Dharma. Therefore there cannot be such a relationship. The relationship to such a person would be the relation to someone who teaches psychological well-being or happiness in this life. That sort of teacher is not a spiritual friend.
That is someone akin to a high school teacher or a university teacher. We shall stop here for today. Having finished the beginning explanation of how to rely on the teacher. Just a couple of quick announcements. Ilya, our esteemed translator, will be presenting a seminar this coming Saturday at 02:00, two to four, the core of Buddhist teachings, namely the understanding of the meaning of the four noble truths.
Key terms in this teaching
- grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
- Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
- The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
- pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
- A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
- preliminary practices ngondro (Tib)
- The practices that prepare the mind for successful tantric meditation by removing hindrances and accumulating merit. LYWA
- tantra gyü (Tib)
- Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
- yana
- Literally, vehicle; a spiritual path that leads to an awakened state. The vehicle and spiritual journey depends on the attitude of the practitioner. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Can a harmful (sinful) friend be a member of the Sangha, or is that impossible or contradictory?
Yes, it is possible, and there are many such cases. Some people merely wear monastic robes while their behavior is sinful and harmful to one's own practice. Such a person is both a monk and a sinful friend. Such a person is harmful to one's practice and to one's attainment of liberation or enlightenment. There are many people like this.