Awakening Heart — 2013-08-14

2 h 20 min · 6,859 words · 14 August 2013 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

The Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
The Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awakening Heart — 2013-08-14
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 140-minute session, Kyabje Rinpoche uses Togme Zangpo’s 37 Practices of a Bodhisattva to establish that ethical conduct is the sole foundation for liberation and enlightenment. He systematically covers the ten non-virtues to abandon—three physical (killing, stealing, sexual misconduct), four verbal (lying, divisive speech, harsh words, idle talk), and three mental (covetousness, ill will, wrong views)—illustrating each with concrete examples of how they damage the path to higher rebirth. Rinpoche then addresses dedication of merit, explaining six dimensions of correct dedication: what is dedicated, the purpose, goal, beneficiary, proper method, and intention. Throughout, the central theme is that without ethics, all practice becomes self-serving; with ethics protected, even ordinary acts become causes of enlightenment. For practitioners familiar with foundational Lamrim teachings.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2013-08-14 – KR.mp3

UUID: 9f403a01-cd30-492b-84ec-b98ce6ed3c19

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Awakening Heart

Date: 2013-08-14

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~6,855

As Togme Zangpo says in the 37 practices of a Bodhisattva, bereft of ethics, one cannot accomplish the welfare of others, let alone one’s own welfare. Therefore, the training in ethics is a practice of the bodhisattvas. And the meaning of this stanza is that if one lacks ethics, it is laughable to think that one can accomplish the welfare of others when one cannot even accomplish one’s own welfare and here lacking ethics refers specifically to craving after cyclic existence or existence. If one lacks ethics, there is a very real risk that one will think that one can accomplish one’s own goals through, for instance, slaughtering one’s foes or slaughtering others in the same way as a butcher. There are many in this case.

Here in the stanza of Togme Zangpo, when reference is made to one’s own welfare, Togme Zangpo does not mean by this one’s own welfare within this life. This does not count. He refers to one’s own welfare in future lives, to the attainment of a state of lasting and durable happiness which is liberation or to the attainment of full enlightenment. The reason for which the happiness of this life does not count is because in that matter, we are similar to animals. A dog focuses on its happiness in this life and is able within reason to accomplish it.

The human being who does this is akin to an animal. And therefore, the three welfares which are referred to in this stanza are if it is possible for us to attain it, the state of full enlightenment which is a state in which all faults are abandoned and all qualities are actualized. Alternatively, the state of liberation from suffering in which all suffering is permanently abandoned and at the very least a higher rebirth which can act as a basis for the practice of Dharma in future lives. And this is the case because without ethics it is impossible to attain full enlightenment. Without ethics it is impossible to attain liberation.

Without ethics it is impossible to attain a higher rebirth or for that matter a human rebirth, a specific case of a higher rebirth. Instead, without ethics, one is reborn endlessly over again in the lower realms without ever being able to escape from it. And this is why it is said that the uncommon cause for a higher rebirth is ethics. Clearly without a higher rebirth the foundation for liberation or for enlightenment is absent. And therefore since without ethics the attainment of the peerless higher rebirth is impossible.

The practice of protecting whatever ethics we engage in is fundamental. It is the most important practice of all. So one should protect whatever ethics is required to in contingent situations and in addition one should keep whatever pledges and commitments one has received. And therefore, the protection of ethics is the foundation for obtaining a higher rebirth in a future life. However, for such a higher rebirth to act as a basis for practice as our present rebirth is acting, associate conditions are required and these are generated within this life with the practice of ethics in general but also of generosity, forbearance and so forth.

It is not easy to obtain the type of rebirth we have obtained for the practice of Dharma. It’s not easy to obtain the sort of rebirth we have obtained at present and someone in a previous life, our previous incarnation, must have worked very hard to accumulate the various causes and conditions which are required to give rise to such a rebirth. To give an example of this, let us take the case of a flower. It is not sufficient to plant the seed of a flower in barren land and expect it to sprout. Instead, conditions must be assembled, common and uncommon conditions, water, fertilizer, sunlight and so forth.

And through a concatenation of various conditions, the seed can eventually give rise to a flower. Likewise, we need all of the common and uncommon causes and conditions to give rise to this human rebirth for us to be able to have such a rebirth. It is not easy to obtain therefore the rebirth we have at present and if we wish to obtain this rebirth in the future, we must put great effort at present where we have the possibility to do so. Then life after life moving from higher rebirth to higher rebirth progressively we will get closer and closer to liberation and eventually to full enlightenment. This is how one can hope to proceed.

So it is at present that we should meditate on generosity, that we should meditate on ethics, that we should meditate on forbearance, that we should meditate on enthusiasm and so forth. This is why it is said that it would be ridiculous to think that without ethics one could accomplish one’s own welfare let alone that of others. And yet we see in everyday life so many people who without any ethics whatsoever engage in practices such as divination and what not and claim thereby to be able to accomplish the welfare of others. Some must think that without ethics they can nonetheless accomplish the welfare of others. When one refers to the welfare of others in this context, one is not referring to their mundane well-being which is obtained through giving, for instance, food, water, money and so forth to the destitute.

Generally speaking, this is a good thing to do, but this does not accomplish the long lasting stable welfare of others. The long lasting stable happiness of others is to lead them to the state of liberation or a full enlightenment. And it is for this that ethics is necessary. And this is why it is said that those without ethics cannot accomplish the welfare of others but that it is the practice of bodhisattvas who do not crave existence to do so. Craving existence in this context refers to craving the marvels of cyclic existence, the wealth of cyclic existence and so forth.

And in the context of the stanza of Togme Zangpo, those wishing or craving for existence refers to those who are afflicted with desire. It is precisely this desire for existence which must be abandoned since this desire for the marvels of existence is at the root of all of the faults which we carry. It is through this desire that we engage in non virtuous deeds that in turn anger arises when we do not obtain what we wish for, that in turn we harm those with whom we have become angry And as a result of this, we will not be able to be reborn in the higher realms, let alone being able to attain liberation, let alone being able to attain full enlightenment and instead will sink into the lower realms to never depart from them. Then this sounds very difficult to us because when we think that we have to give up the happiness of this life and give up really all happiness in this life, we think we will simply not be able to live anymore, particularly if we were to give up all of our wealth and all of our money. And this issue arose in the context of a question on fake or spurious interchange of self and others in equanimity.

And it is important for us here to understand that if we give up desire, we will not die from it. If we give up anger, we will not die from it either. Instead, if we give up desire, the mind of non desire and of contentment will arise. And here when we refer to ethics, we refer to abstaining from the 10 non virtuous deeds, the three physical non virtuous deeds, the four verbal non virtuous deeds, and these three mental non virtuous deeds. So these are the three non virtuous deeds.

The three non virtuous deeds of the body, the physical non virtuous deeds are killing, stealing and sexual misconduct, in our case, adultery. Then the older ones among the students know about this, but the new ones may not. And these are followed by the four non virtuous deeds of speech, lying, divisive speech, harsh words and idle talk or gossip, and the three mental non virtues, covetousness, ill will and wrong views. These as we can see are present within our within our minds, within our mental continuum. And these are present within our mind stream because of habituation from past lives which make it easy for us to engage in this life.

Now we might think it is very difficult to abstain from these 10 non virtues. This is not the case. It is very easy actually. For instance, if we take the second physical non-virtue stealing, in Tibetan taking what is not given to oneself, even in this life it is considered to be an evil deed. Likewise, for sexual misconduct or adultery, seducing another person’s partner even in this life is counted as a non virtue.

Likewise, the first of these three non virtuous deeds, killing, is also counted as a non virtuous deed even in this life whether it is killing a human being or killing some poor animal. The first non virtuous deed of speech, lying, means to deceive intentionally somebody for one’s own interest. This is also counted as a non virtue in this life. The second non virtuous deed of speech is divisive speech. Divisive speech means to separate two people who live in harmony with each other through insinuation, slander or by any verbal means saying to one something about the other and the opposite.

When these two are separated, then this non virtuous deed of speech has been committed. Ethics is called ethics because it protects the mind against harm. This is why it is called ethics. The third non virtuous deed of speech, injurious speech, means to hurt the mind of another person through harsh words. The fourth non virtuous deed of speech is idle talk or gossip.

It is difficult to defend oneself against this one, yet it is in dependence on gossip and idle talk that non-virtue, anger, and so forth arise. The first of the mental non virtues is covetousness. Covetousness is a form of desire and we can see it at work for instance, when we go shopping and in a large shopping mall, we see things which we think we need and desire for these things arises with within our mind. This covetousness is a non virtuous state of mind because it misrepresents the object. The object seems far more attractive than it actually is.

The second mental non virtue is ill will or belligerence. It is a form of anger and it refers to that desire to retaliate to harm another in response to perceived harm. The third mental non virtue is wrong views. This refers to the mindset which believes that the triple gem does not exist, that the four noble truths do not exist, that karma and causality does not exist, that only this life and its happiness exist and future lives and their happiness do not exist or are meaningless. These are the 10 non-virtues which must be abstained from.

Abstaining from them is the ethics of abandoning the 10 non-virtues. If one engages in this ethics, one will in future lives obtain a higher rebirth. At present, let us meditate for five minutes on this. Meditate on protecting ethics, progressing upwards from life after life, from higher rebirth to higher rebirth until one attains a state of full enlightenment for the sake of others. We have reached the final stanza in the seven limb presentation in the prayer of Samantabhādra on dedication which reads as follows in my translation.

I dedicate the slightest virtue which I have accumulated through prostration, offering, confession, rejoicing, entreating that wheel of the law be turned and beseeching the gurus to remain. All of these I dedicate for the sake of enlightenment. There are six outlines regarding dedication. What is dedicated for the sake of what it is dedicated, where it is dedicated, the purpose of the dedication, the correct manner of dedicating and the nature of dedication. So regarding the first outline, what is dedicated?

What is dedicated are the roots of virtue. These are the dedicatum. The dedicatum is the basis which is dedicated. It is dedicated to an end and that end to which it is dedicated is encompassed by a prayer for the attainment of whatever goal we have set ourselves, whether it be full enlightenment, liberation or so forth. Now, in terms of nature, dedication can be understood as either dedicating one’s own roots of virtue or dedicating the roots of virtues of others.

And within the division of the dedication of one’s own roots of virtues, one distinguishes between dedicating past, present, and future roots of virtues. Then we speak here of roots of virtue but do not reflect a lot on the meaning of roots of virtue. Roots of virtue actually simply refers to virtue. In virtue, in Tibetan means what is good. Then here, when we speak of virtue, we are referring to those deeds which assessed in terms of their consequences in the future lead to happiness.

When we are referring to non virtue, we are referring to those deeds which assessed in terms of their consequences in the future lead to suffering. And when we refer to neutral deeds, we are referring to those deeds whose consequences in the in the future are also neutral, neither happiness nor unhappiness. So deeds are therefore assessed in terms of their results. Virtuous deeds are assessed as deeds leading to happiness and non virtuous deeds to suffering. The result of a deed is contingent on the motivation which impels the deed.

If the motivation impelling the deed is altruistic, that deed is virtuous and will lead to happiness. If the motivation impelling a deed is egotistical, non altruistic, that deed is non virtuous and will lead to suffering. Finally, if the motivation is neutral, which is a case of many deeds we perform in this life, the results will also be neutral. And therefore, we refer to the basis which is dedicated or the basis of dedication, we are referring fundamentally to just this, the altruistic motivation as well as the deed which has been performed with such an altruistic motivation which in turn is dedicated towards a certain end, towards a certain goal. And therefore, we should dedicate all of the virtuous motivations which we have generated and deeds which we have performed to the goal of full enlightenment.

And since in this life, the majority of our deeds are non virtuous or neutral, we should confess and repent for the non virtuous deeds which we have performed. This repentance enables them to be purified and in so doing, we can practice through alternating between dedicating the virtues and repenting for the non virtues or the sins. And therefore, Dharma practice is to take care of one’s mental continuum. If one takes care, if one supervises one’s mental continuum, then progressively one situation will improve over time. On the other hand, if one does not do this, then the so called dharma we engage in becomes something for this life only and for material success only and this has no meaning.

So this is the first outline, what is dedicated. The second outline for what purpose or why it is dedicated. Dedication is performed to avoid exhaustion or extinction. The exhaustion or the extinction of merit which occurs when merit is not dedicated through the power of all the afflictions but specifically of anger and of wrong views. Once merit is dedicated, it cannot be destroyed by anger or wrong views.

As is said, the merit accrued through 1,000 eons of the practices of generosity, ethics, forbearance, and so forth are destroyed by one instant of anger. Here, one instant of anger must be understood as one instant of anger towards a bodhisattva. And it is said in Madhyamakāvatāra, there is no greater sin than anger since in one instant of anger, 100 eons of the merit accrued through generosity, ethics, forbearance and so forth is incinerated. The reason for which these two stanzas, the one stanza I think from the Samādhi Rāja sūtra and the other stanza from the Madhyamakāvatāra give different amounts of virtue which are destroyed is because of the difference in the base towards which anger is generated. If anger is generated towards the Bodhisattva, it is 1,000 eons of virtue which is destroyed whereas if it is generated towards an ordinary being it is one one hundred eons of virtue which are destroyed.

The third outline is for what dedication is engaged in. Here dedication can be focused on attaining full enlightenment, attaining liberation, attaining a higher rebirth or even this life. We see that many of these so called long life pujas which are offered are offered on the advice of astrologers or diviners to obtain a long life. This is a dedication for the affairs of this life. Likewise, people dedicate prayers and offerings to obtain wealth, to obtain health, to obtain a good abode and so forth.

A true dedication should be a dedication in which one says, may I attain full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings without disregarding some and elevating some leading all without exception to the state of full enlightenment. Then we might have the doubt full enlightenment after all is very very far away. Instead of dedicating virtue to such a far away goal, it has been more concrete and dedicated to future lives or even this life. This is a profound misunderstanding since if one dedicates one’s virtues to full enlightenment, not only will they mature by leading to full enlightenment, but all of the necessary causes and conditions for the attainment of full enlightenment will also arise in due course. It is a bit similar to, the case of, wanting to eat an apple.

If one wants to eat an apple, all the causes which gave rise to the apple must first have been present. The tree from which the apple came, likewise the leaves, the branches of the tree, the ground which bore the tree and so forth, All of this is necessary for us to be able to eat the apple produced by that tree. So regarding this third outline for what one or towards what one dedicates, as I said, one should dedicate towards the attainment of full enlightenment. Alternatively, if one prefers another dedication, one can also dedicate one’s roots of virtue to encountering a spiritual teacher life after life. Alternatively, one can also dedicate them to receiving both oneself and others the teachings of the Buddha.

These three dedications are identical in the sense that if we encounter a spiritual teacher life after life, we will naturally progress to full enlightenment And if both ourselves and others encounter the teachings of the Buddha, ourselves and others will progressively progress towards full enlightenment. The fourth outline is for the sake of whom this dedication should be performed. This dedication should be performed for the sake of all sentient beings and one performs it for the sake of all sentient beings resolving oneself to attain full enlightenment for their sake and both oneself and others are eventually led to the state of full enlightenment. So within the fourth outline, when we refer to dedicating for the sake or for the will of all sentient beings, one must recollect in the context of the presentation of bodhicitta that there are two aspirations. Aspirations for one’s own welfare and aspirations for the welfare of others.

Here, this focuses on aspirations for the welfare of others. In other words, others being led to the state of full enlightenment. However, this can only happen if we have fulfilled our own aspirations, which is for ourselves to attain the state of full enlightenment for the sake of others. Therefore, in the context of this fourth outline, both aspirations for oneself and for others are fulfilled. The fifth outline, correct dedication or appropriate dedication refers to dedicating correctly through a dedication which is held both by method and by wisdom.

In other words, both by bodhicitta and by the mind which realizes emptiness. And here, such a correct dedication refers therefore to a dedication which is simultaneously held or upheld by the mind of bodhicitta and by the realization of emptiness as well as a dedication in which the emptiness of the three circles has been fully understood. The three circles here refer to the circle of the dedicator, which is oneself, The circle of the what is dedicated, which are the roots of virtue and the circle of that towards which it is dedicated, which is a goal for the enlightenment being empty of inherent existence. One dedicates with this in mind and this is obviously not something which can be practiced at once, so one must generate these states of mind incrementally. And the sixth outline of dedication is the intent that the roots of virtue one has dedicated turn into full enlightenment.

Then we can understand roots of virtue in this context a bit as money. If you have money, you can use money for whatever goal you have set yourself. You can have a good meal, you can go out, whatever or you can focus your money on one single goal. Here having dedicated the roots of virtue to the attainment of full enlightenment, we are saying I won’t be giving my money to anybody else. It will only go to full enlightenment.

And therefore, the sixth outline of dedication, the intention that what is dedicated become the cause of full enlightenment is the nature of dedication. Now within the preliminary practices, we have reached the final preliminary practice which is the entreaty. And this is a request to all of the beings of the field of merit which has been visualized in keeping for instance with Lama Chöpa to bestow their blessings upon us. In keeping with the entreaty in the Lamrim or the stages of the path entreaty which begins with the verse, glorious root guru, I entreat thee. And then one visualizes all of the teachers of the Lamrim lineage bestowing their blessings.

And the meaning of this entreaty is that one entreats the root guru to dwell upon one’s crown or within one’s heart and to bestow blessings until one has attained the state of full enlightenment. And at this point, the Guru, the spiritual teacher says, this is very well indeed and one meditates on joy. And in the morning therefore upon waking one makes this entreaty for the blessings of the spiritual teacher and because of this blessing we cannot be harmed by others or by disease. However, this should not be done for that purpose. It should not be done so that we not be harmed by hungry ghosts or demons but instead with the motivation of attaining the state of full enlightenment for others.

Then we have Geshe-la has completed at present the presentation of the six preliminaries and next time we’ll explain reliance on the spiritual teacher in keeping with Jetsün Chöpa’s Canticle of Realization. But since we have now entered within the context of meditation, I would like to explain a bit about meditation. There are two types of meditation, analytical and fixative or concentration meditation. In the context of Lamrim, we engage in analytical meditation. At present, we are unable to engage in concentration or fixative meditation.

There is no concentration meditation until one has attained calm abiding. Before that, all meditation is analytical. All of the attainments from the ordinary attainments to the state of union are contingent on the practice of analytical meditation. We are fortunate in that we actually are oriented towards analytical meditation. Without being aware of it, we engage in activities akin to analytical meditation all day.

For instance, we engage in intense analytical meditation when someone harms us and we start to generate anger thinking such a beastly person this is to have harmed someone like me. And then with many lines of reasoning, this is analytical meditation, we foster our anger which blazes fiercer and fiercer. So we are very experienced in generating anger through analytical meditation and likewise we generate desire through analytical meditation. Looking at something and generating numerous reasons for desiring it, thinking this is so beautiful. How could I ever live without something like this?

And once again desire increases and increases. However, we never orient our analytical meditation towards full enlightenment. So we have to change the focus of our analytical meditation which at present is focused exclusively on the non virtuous component of our lives and has no interest whatsoever in the virtuous component and focuses instead on the virtuous component of our practice and turn away from the non virtuous one. Then we shall stop here for today. Then there are probably questions.

Geshe-la, we will take your questions at present. Have two questions that relate to the karma aspect of taking the life of another sentient being. We can take one at a time. Question and then when everyone has finished you can ask your second question if you wish. The first one is, do you have some chickens or a pet and it becomes very old, sick and it’s suffering and there’s a choice of where you have to take this creature’s life to end its pain and suffering, where does it leave you?

So it is a sin to kill or to euthanize we would say in the West a pet. Even if the pet is suffering instead when the pet is sick it should be taken to a veterinarian, medicine should be given to it and then if medicine is of no help at a certain point then one should let the animal finish its life in peace. It is the sin of killing within the 10 non-virtues. I actually have one. Would it be possible to expand on repenting non virtuous states?

Repentance within the four forces refers to initially identifying one’s non virtuous deeds or the sins one has committed and then reflecting in detail on the suffering which will arise as a result of this. Then when one reflects on the suffering, fear arises in the mind. This fear leads to repentance. In our cases, we don’t know what repentance is. So when we have committed a non virtuous deed or a sin, we find this enjoyable and then we rejoice about having performed it.

Then this rejoicing makes the karmic weight of the deed even heavier. So instead of rejoicing in the non virtues we have done, we should instead repent at them and then this repentance makes them weaker and eventually purifies So in our cases, when we go to see a movie or show, we rejoice. We go to see the movie and if it’s an action movie and there’s a lot of killing in the movie, we think that is good. It’s a good action show. And we rejoice every time someone gets killed and in the process, we accumulate a huge amount of non virtuous karma and then after leaving the movie theater, we think this was a good movie, good show and we make the non virtuous karma we accumulated even heavier than this.

Instead of this, we should think, my goodness, what an amount of time I have wasted by going to see something in the cinema. I could have taken refuge, I could have meditated, I could have said prayers. And then thinking in this way and thinking that as a result of the non virtuous karma we have accumulated, we might be reborn in the lower realms, repentance does arise. This is Repentance is a thought, this is inappropriate. This isn’t okay.

Then if we repent of a non virtuous deed which we have performed, this is virtuous. On the other hand, if we repent of something virtuous which we have performed, it is non virtuous. For instance, if we have spent the day meditating and reach the evening and think this is a wasted day. I could have earned a lot of money today, I didn’t. I wasted my time.

Then this is a non virtuous thing. I was interested to hear that before calm abiding is reached, all meditation is analytical. I make some feeble attempts to develop concentration with my meditation. But is all of that just analytical? What are you meditating upon?

That is a preliminary to meditation. It is not meditation. Analytical meditation is meditation in which one uses numerous lines of reasoning to investigate a topic. Concentration or fixative meditation is meditation in which the mind is focused single pointedly on an object. But meditation on breath is a preliminary to both of these meditations designed to calm the distraction of the mind and to bring the mind inwards.

And then having withdrawn the mind inwards through focusing on breath and counting the breath, one should at present try to engage in some form of fixative meditation or concentration meditation. Then if one is a Buddhist, one should try to focus on emptiness. Alternatively, on the body of a deity, one aspect of which can be focused upon and in dependence on that one can attain eventually calm abiding. So meditation on breath is therefore not the actual body of meditation, it is merely a preliminary practice for concentration meditation or for analytical meditation. Then some people have the strange opinion that meditation on breath qualifies as actual meditation.

I do not accept that view. Then without experience of meditation, there is no experience. Then somebody else has a question. In the context of rejoicing and rejoicing in and dedicating past virtues of this life, a deed is only karmically complete when it has the four features. So then we’ve only performed truly virtuous deeds since having become a Buddhist.

So do virtuous deeds in the past without the four features still count as a virtue that can be rejoiced in or dedicated? Virtue and non virtue has nothing to do with being a Buddhist or not. The smallest of insects accumulates non virtue. A deed which is performed with the intent of helping others and which is a good deed is a virtuous deed. A deed which is performed with the intent of harming others and which harms others is a non virtuous deed irrespective of whether one understands what these deeds are or not.

Sometimes one hears it said that it is really only the Buddhists who talk of virtuous and non virtuous karma and it only concerns one if one chooses to become a Buddhist. This is not the case. It is irrelevant whether one is a Buddhist or not, whether one is religious or not. Past and future lives exist in reality and karma exists in reality. It operates whether we accept it or not.

My question is does Geshe-la consider watching or concentrating on the mind or stream of consciousness a form of meditation? For example, the practice of Mahāmudrā where you take the object of your meditation as the mind itself. Most definitely this is an authentic tradition of meditation but merely focusing on the mind without having any of the preliminary realizations is of no benefit whatsoever. The practice of Mahāmudrā or Dzogchen, it’s often called Dzogchen by some, is a very advanced practice which supposes that one has already attained renunciation, has already generated bodhicitta, one has had an experience of emptiness and then one engages in this practice. Dzogchen has its preliminaries which are identical really to Lamrim and these must be engaged in and meditated upon before one engages in the practice of Dzogchen.

The same thing is true for what we call Dzogchen in the Gelug tradition Mahāmudrā. Also, it is a meaningless practice without the preliminaries leading up to it. So Dzogchen calls as a preliminary just as Mahāmudrā for renunciation for bodhicitta and for the direct realization of emptiness. It is within the direct realization of emptiness that the subtle mind, the fundamental mind in Dzogchen manifests and this fundamental mind is at that point focused upon. Then for us, this is meaningless talk.

We don’t have any of these realizations. What is meaningful for us is to dedicate the virtues which we have obtained as a cause for attaining full enlightenment and here is explained by Geshe-la as referring to so it is within that context that we can create the future causes for the practice of Given Geshe-la’s comments about fixative meditation and that we’re not there, there is a group that is as a result of Anila Jampa Tenzin, a text is being studied, the Dalai Lama’s text on the middling stages of meditation. I’m wondering whether it’s Geshe-la’s opinion about whether we should continue in the absence of Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen it’s just not clear in terms of direction whether we should continue with studying that text or set it aside in order to focus on something more in line with studying that we’re currently doing on a Wednesday night? Or is that not Geshe-la’s decision? There’s no difference.

Both Kamalaśīla’s Bhāvanākrama and Kamalaśīla’s Bhāvanākrama and Jetsün Chöpa’s Canticle of Realization, teach the practice of the beings of the three scopes. You find them in both, you could study both. I just want to seek further clarification on this one, Ilya. A bit terrier like tonight. So before calm abiding or meditation is analytical, so when I’m meditating on the body of the Buddha, is that fixative or analytical?

It depends on whether or not that mind is affected by distraction. If the mind is affected by distraction, it is not fixative meditation, it is analytical meditation. If however that mind is no longer affected by distraction of any type then it is a continuum of mind which will eventually attain calm abiding then it can be called concentration or fixative meditation. But do you understand its nature is still analytical meditation? And the reason its nature, even if it’s single pointedly focused on its object without distraction is analytical meditation is because recollection and vigilance are necessary throughout.

Then the recollection and vigilance are analyzing. This is analytical meditation. Even though it is in its nature analytical meditation, it can be called concentration meditation because eventually it will lead to calm abiding. But it is analytical because of the operation of recollection and vigilance all along. Thank you, Geshe la.

My question is about the seven-limb prayer. Is each limb a cause for the subsequent limb? For example, only when one fully prostrates can then one offer. Is there a causal relationship between the limbs of the prayers? No, no, you can offer the seven limbs in any sequence you wish to offer them in as long as the last limb is the limb of dedication.

It’s perfectly all right to make offerings first and to make prostrations after. Can I go back to the gentleman with the chicken? Many years ago, before I became interested in Buddhism, well on a couple of occasions, I found a mouse or a bird that a cat had mauled and I used to kill those mice or birds because I didn’t want to see them suffer. Some years ago, I was in the country and I came across a bird which had been hit by a car. And I held that bird for twenty minutes because my heart wanted to put it out of its suffering, but aware of, non virtuous actions, I couldn’t kill it.

Now if that happened tomorrow, I’m not sure what would happen. It was a very difficult issue for me. So two questions, Geshe. One is, if I had killed that bird the second time because I couldn’t stand it suffering, would my karma have been less because I supposedly am better educated than I was before? And secondly, if one were to end the suffering of an animal like that, doing so with the full realisation that you would then inherit the karma of killing, that would presumably lessen it somewhat than if one does it out of malice or Yes.

It is a sin. It is a karmic non virtue to kill an animal even if the animal is on the road to death because it has been for instance tormented by a cat and so forth. Killing means to be the enemy of life, to be the foe of life and therefore abstaining from killing means to stop severing the vital continuum of sentient beings. Then in our cases, when we say that we act through compassion, we have to be very clear. We what we call compassion is not the true compassion of the bodhisattvas.

It’s not great compassion, let alone bodhicitta. If we had great compassion or bodhicitta, then the very term of sin becomes meaningless, but we do not have it. Thanks. The way I see that is the bird was hit by a car due to past causes. Its non virtue was coming to bear.

So I wondered what the karmic result is for the bird when its negative karma hasn’t fully ripened because we’ve ended it. Obviously, sins of the bird haven’t been exhausted, but you have accumulated a lot of sin. So we can’t say for sure regarding the bird, but regarding ourselves, we can really say we accumulated sin. So if you take the case of a cat killing a bird, the cat has accumulated sin and as long as we do not participate in the deeds, we don’t accumulate sin which is important. Apart from meditating on compassion for the cat and stroking it, there’s not a lot we can do.

If you had a situation where someone was attacking you physically and you knew that they had the intent to kill you, and the only way you could stop them was to kill them, this would be a sin? Or do I just stand there and let them kill me? Definitely a sin. If you fight back, it is definitely But to fight back is a sin and to allow anger to rise in one’s mind at that moment is also a sin. Then when we are attacked by somebody, we should not resist and if they for instance want our our money, you know, if they threaten us, we should give them our money and say, you know, I I am so sorry for this person, you know, it is because they have no money that they attack me and then when we give them the money, we should mentally dedicate this while attaining full enlightenment.

Then this becomes a deed of generosity. The money is not wasted and we have accumulated no sin. As a result of this, something very small which is losing money becomes a cause for something very great which is the attainment of full enlightenment. And one should not then generate anger towards the person who has attacked one. Instead, one should think he has been most kind.

Thanks to him, I will attain full enlightenment. May he attain full enlightenment as well. This is pure Mahāyāna practice. Geshe-la, in 2003, I attended teachings by the Dalai Lama in South Africa and somebody asked him a question and the question was, if somebody rushed on stage with a gun with the intent to shoot him and he had a gun, what would he do? And he said he would shoot him in the leg or the arm or something and then he would say, What are you doing that for?

And the whole audience laughed. And I think it took me five or six years to understand what that lesson was. And I took the lesson to be that he actually would have shot that assailant in the leg. He would have taken on the karma of injuring that person to save the assailant the karma of killing him. I’d be interested in Geshe-la’s comments on that, bearing in mind what he’s just said.

So Geshe-la believes that what his holiness meant by this answer was the following. Through shooting the man in the arm or the leg, he would not have incurred the great sin of killing but merely would have made him ineffectual. He would have incurred the sin of harming him, of violence, but not the great sin of killing. So you can see that this is a much more serious situation than if you were attacked for your money but even in this case, one is not entitled to kill the other person to defend oneself. Then obviously if one were assaulted for one’s money then one should give one’s money away.

Key terms in this teaching

analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
dzogchen
Literally "Great Perfection", the practice to attain the mind's natural, primordial state. LYWA
higher realms
The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
Mahamudra chag ya chen po (Tib)
The Great Seal; a profound system of meditation upon the mind and the ultimate nature of reality. LYWA
preliminary practices ngondro (Tib)
The practices that prepare the mind for successful tantric meditation by removing hindrances and accumulating merit. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Can you expand on repenting non-virtuous states and actions, and how repentance works within the four forces?

Repentance in the four forces begins with identifying one's non-virtuous deeds, then reflecting in detail on the suffering that will result. This brings fear, and the fear leads to repentance. Ordinarily people enjoy and rejoice in non-virtuous deeds, which makes their karmic weight heavier. Instead, one should repent, which weakens them and eventually purifies them. For example, rejoicing at killing in an action movie and then praising the film accumulates heavy non-virtuous karma. Instead one should think of the time wasted, when one could have taken refuge, meditated or prayed, and of possible lower rebirth. Repentance is the thought that this is inappropriate.

Is watching or concentrating on the mind or stream of consciousness, as in Mahamudra or Dzogchen, considered a genuine form of meditation?

Yes, it is an authentic tradition of meditation, but merely focusing on the mind without the preliminary realizations is of no benefit whatsoever. Mahāmudrā, or Dzogchen as it is often called, is a very advanced practice that presupposes renunciation, bodhicitta and an experience of emptiness. Its preliminaries are essentially the same as the Lamrim and must be practised first. Without them the practice is meaningless. It is within the direct realization of emptiness that the subtle, fundamental mind manifests and is focused upon. Since we lack these realizations, such talk is meaningless for us.

Scroll to Top