Principles of the Tenets — 2001-10-30

45 min · 2,961 words · 30 October 2001 · Buddha House Adelaide

Principles of the Tenets (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Principles of the Tenets (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Principles of the Tenets — 2001-10-30
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. A mirror image that appears real but isn’t — Geshe Pema Tsering uses this example to mark a key boundary as he closes out the Sūtra school in this 45-minute commentary on Buddhist tenets. He completes the five types of non-valid awareness with inattentive discernment, then covers the three valid object-possessors: valid being (the Buddha), valid speech (the first turning of the wheel), and valid inference. He explains gross and subtle selflessness of the person and why this school has no interest in selflessness of phenomena — its adherents would simply laugh, he notes, at the Heart Sūtra’s claim that things don’t truly exist. A Q&A then works through the three modes of a correct reason and clarifies that “primordial awareness” means the path itself. For students already engaged with Buddhist epistemology.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 06 Tenets 2001 10 30.mp3

UUID: 760fc2b7-48a4-4f6e-89dc-db9ed6f0d0f4

Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering

Collection: Principles of the Tenets (Geshe Pema Tsering)

Date: 2001-10-30

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 45.3 minutes

Words: ~2,958

Technically, what is said to happen here is that the first part of the three parts of proving a reason to be correct is not established, and that is called paksha dharma. It actually refers to the fact that the subject is not pervaded by the reason. So the fifth one here is, for example, discernment holding sound is impermanent by reason of being produced in a continuum of one not validly determining sound is impermanent is an instance of the fifth because though produced is the correct reason establishing sound is impermanent, such a person does not prove it to be the correct reason for establishing that. In general, being produced is a valid reason, a correct reason for establishing sound to be impermanent. For that particular person, they’re not a correct respondent, to be, given that reason.

They’re not yet in a situation, to be a correct respondent. So for them, even though they have the reason, have the predicate, they have the subject, they’re not able to assemble them as a correct reason in order to generate inference. So that therefore completes the fourth type of awareness, which is correct belief. And then the fifth is inattentive discernment. So here, the definition given of inattentive discernment is non mistaken cognition, which does not determine its clearly appearing object.

In fact, we can divide that up into three parts. So firstly, it’s mistaken awareness. It’s not mistaken to its object, but it doesn’t determine its object. It doesn’t comprehend its object. But the object still clearly appears to the discernment, clearly appears to that awareness.

So there, there are three, types of inattentive discernment. So there is inattentive sense perception, inattentive mental perception, and inattentive self-knower perception. There are those three types. So an example of the first is auditory awareness, holding sound when the eye is attracted to beautiful form. So even though the sound is attractive and one is listening to it to begin with, when one is distracted or attracted to a beautiful form, then the awareness, the ear awareness is inattentive to its object.

So then the second is, for example, this is inattentive mental perception. So mental perception holding any of the five objects such as form, etcetera, in the continuum of an ordinary being. So the third one here is, for example, self perception, experiencing mental perception holding any of the five objects in the continuum of an ordinary being. So then if object possesses are, that completes that section of the five types of non valid awareness. So now again, we move into, again, differentiating object possessors.

So again, if object in general, if object possessors are classified, there are three types, a being or beings speech and valid awareness. Then again, on the next page, page thirteen, if valid objects possessors are classified previously, we just did object possessors. But if we take valid object possessors, then again, by convention, they’re divided up into three, valid being, valid speech, and valid awareness. So a valid being is, for example, the teacher Buddha. So Buddha is in fact, non deceptive.

And in fact, from the definition of valid awareness, which is, which includes the, the component of being non deceptive, then this also is applied here to the Buddha because the Buddha’s speech is non deceptive. What a Buddha says is non deceptive. So that also indicates the being, the underlying being is also a non deceptive. Therefore, are valid. Is this easy to understand?

It is very difficult. It’s not easy to understand. In fact, the traditional way of studying this is to memorize the entire text and then to get teachings on it. Oh. And then debate over a long period what the meaning is because the the meaning is is not easy to penetrate.

In fact, the way in the three main monasteries is just that to memorize these texts and then one gets instruction on them and then debates on them for a long period. And by doing that, then it’s possible to gain some understanding of the meaning. This is the normal way. This is the way that Geshe-la studied this particular text. So in fact, to try and get an immediate understanding of the words is not gonna be easy for us.

Still, it’s possible to set down imprints for future understanding of these issues. So therefore, one of the purposes of going through these types of texts at present is really to set down imprints and latencies that will have an effect later on. Good. It really is difficult, this text, and it is, as I said in Tibetan, hard. It’s like hard to penetrate.

In fact, it’s the same. As Geshe says, initially in the monastery, it’s just a question of memorizing these words. And although they don’t have any meaning to begin with, then through the kindness of one’s what’s called a ge-gen or the teacher to whom one goes for instruction on dependence on their kindness, then gradually the meaning of the words begins to become clear. Then valid speech, for example, here, the turning of the wheel of the four noble truths. So that’s the first turning of the wheel of dharma in Sarnath, near Varanasi.

And then valid awareness, for example, as given before, valid perception and valid inference. So then the sixth category here is the method of asserting selflessness. So the, the sixth, classification here from the seven that were initially given, is the method of asserting selflessness itself. So So here, a person being empty of a permanent single self powered self is asserted to be gross selflessness of the person. And a person empty of being self arisen and substantially existent is subtle selflessness of the person.

And this is similar to what the advocates of the great exposition stated previously. And also that they do not assert selflessness of Dharma, which is similar also to the exposition. Then the seventh one here is explaining the principles of paths and grounds. So here then, when accumulating the collections of the three types, it is an accumulation in the context of the four learner paths. Yeah.

So here, when one accumulates merit, is accumulation occurs at the time of the path of accumulation, preparation, seeing and meditation. So this differs again from what was stated by the great exposition school in the first section of the text. So then by that reason, the physical aggregate of a Buddha is accepted as Buddha. Also, they’re similar to the great exposition because their method of asserting obscurations is similar. So therefore, they assert afflictive obscurations and non afflictive obscurations similar to the great exposition presentation.

And also the method of proceeding on the grounds and paths is similar to the great exposition. So that therefore completes a brief overview of the Sūtra Sautrāntika school. So here we’ve got starting now on the third section, explaining the system of mind only. Would it be preferable to just have a pause here and maybe, do some questions and maybe discuss a little bit the Sūtra school, or would you prefer to continue into the Mind Only school? So, Yishya says it may be useful to stop and just discuss the issues surrounding the sūtra school at this point.

And in fact, if anyone has any doubts or points to bring up, it could be useful to bring them up at this. At this point, Geshe-la will seek to answer them to the best of his ability. Or as an exemplifier. So in fact, here, it’s they’re called exemplifiers precisely for the reason that they teach all dharmas by citing examples. So whatever they’re trying to teach, they will cite an example.

Say for instance, say a vase is self powered or non self powered, they will So they teach things being non self powered or So for instance, you know, this idea of teaching Dharma by example can be given also for the higher schools as well. So for instance, an example here could be, say, for a middle in a middle way, which asserts things to be non truly existent, then you’d say that the non truly existent just as an image in a mirror appears to be truly existent, but is not existent. What appears to exist in a particular way in which it doesn’t exist, and we can understand that. We can understand that things do not exist in the way they appear to exist by an example of a mirror and the image in a mirror. So here, for the sūtra school, they assert that everything, can be taught, through appropriate examples.

So in fact, many examples are given, like, the example of a mirage, the example of echo, the example of bubbles in water and so forth. There’s many types of examples that are used, for instance, to teach non true existence. So also with the Sūtra School, they’re employing similar types of example. So here it’s you’re talking about their main system of teaching that in fact, they use it as a main system, a central system. The, citing of examples to illustrate the meaning.

So they in a sense, it’s a question of degree. They really concentrate on it more than other schools. In number six, They do they do the Sūtra School assert a subtle self? Which section of that are you referring to? Yep.

This they have subtle selflessness. But here you’re wondering perhaps that that is the question. What is the self of dharma that they do assert? Because they don’t assert selflessness of dharma, whereas they do assert gross and subtle selflessness of the person. So here with the the self of dharma that they do assert is that the the dharmas, meaning all existent objects, truly existent.

That in fact, all objects, all dharmas, truly exist. They inherently exist. And in fact, if the Sūtra School and the Vaibhāṣika School, if for them objects were not truly existent or inherently existent, they would not exist. They couldn’t exist at all. Of the Heart Sūtra.

Here, even though the Buddha has stated that in the Heart Sūtra, for those that follow the Sūtra and the great exposition presentation, they don’t have any interest at all if someone were to say, that things don’t truly exist or things dharmas don’t inherently exist. They would laugh at such a suggestion. I would simply they it wouldn’t penetrate their ears. They would not they would think it was some sort of strange, weird statement. So in fact, the Buddha has made various statements.

At some on some occasions, he stated that things truly exist. Other occasions, he stated that things don’t truly exist. So in fact, for this particular school, they find reference to support, their particular beliefs within the speech of the Buddha, but it’s necessary to be able to differentiate, the different types of speech of the Buddha, what’s interpretive, what’s definitive. And in each of these schools, what they’re finding is a way of interpreting the speech that supports their own particular view. But doesn’t harm their own worldview.

I had that reasoning. It takes sound. It’s impermanent because it’s produced. In general, that type of reason is, stated to a person who’s in a very particular situation. You’re a person who’s understood, that sound is produced and that if it is produced, anything which is produced must be impermanent.

And that also they have doubt about whether sound is impermanent or not. To such a person, if one were to say, take sound, it’s impermanent because it’s produced, they would be a a correct respondent for that reason. And that reason, that syllogism that’s expressed to them has the capacity to generate in their continuum understanding that sound is impermanent. But those conditions have to preexist for them to be a correct respondent. Is that In fact, in order to be a correct respondent, in order for there to be a correct reason, three modes have to be fulfilled in a reason.

The first, second, third mode, which is the having the three modes complete is the definition of a correct reason. Is that exactly where you’re at at? Yeah. Right. So here exactly in the context you’re talking is, as an example of the first type of, inference.

Is that true? Let me get back to the text. Is that that’s also in that particular section, isn’t it? Of the three types of the, four point two point four point five, is it? Or is it the one inference by the strength of fact?

One point two and one on page ten. So that’s inference through the strength of fact, right? That particular here, inference is generated by the correct reason, right? And the correct reason is expressed in three parts, the subject predicate and the reason. And when we have that example of a correct reasons, for instance, the subject takes sound, predicate is impermanent, reason because it’s produced is a valid reason.

It’s a correct reason because it conforms to the three modes of formulating a reason. It possesses the three modes. It’s a correct yes. It’s a correct reason. It’s a correct reason by essence, in fact, when one without going into it’s a valid reason.

It’s a correct reason, and it’s a correct reason by essence. And it has the capacity to generate a correct conception of the thesis, which is the first two parts of the syllogism. No, no, no. They’re not the three modes. No.

The three modes are really the forward pervasion, the reverse pervasion and the choknyi. The first mode there actually, really refers to the fact that, the subject is pervaded or the subject is that reason. For instance, take sound. It’s impermanent because it’s produced. Sound being produced sound is produced or something which is produced is the first mode.

Yeah. So it needs to be the first mode. And the first mode is simply that that say, whatever is the subject conforms with that reason that’s expressed. And then the second mode is that if it is that reason, it must be the predicate. And the third mode is if it’s not the predicate, it’s not the reason.

The second mode is if it is that reason, it is pervasive that it is the predicate or that which is the predicate. And the third mode is that if it’s not the predicate, it is pervasive that it is not that which is the reason. That’s in brief, but that’s roughly speaking. That’s the reason they’re being produced is the reason. Take sound.

It is impermanent because it’s produced. Produced is the reason. Production is the root cause of impermanence. Here, to actually say that produced is the cause of impermanence would not be acceptable because they occur at the same time. Produced and impermanence are of one essence, one substance.

They coexist. They exist at the same time. For something to be the cause of something else, it has to exist before it. The cause must exist prior to the result. Cause and result can never exist at the same time.

Actually, this Here, in fact, the primordial awareness is basically referring to the path itself. It doesn’t mean that it’s existing from beginningless time. In general, when one talks about primordial awareness, it’s referring to the path itself. The etymology of the term, in Tibetan refers to right? That there also has the implication of primordial.

But here, it doesn’t necessarily mean, or it’s not necessarily taken in that sense, right? It means really the path itself. It’s synonymous with the path. So here, the etymology of the term doesn’t necessarily reflect the definition of the term, basically. And one has to look at the definition of the term.

And the definition is that it’s the same as the path itself. Hip path meaning like a path of accumulation by the preparation, seeing, and so forth. So it’s that’s only the etymology of the term. It’s not reflecting on this definition. And that is because that primordial awareness there is synonymous with the path itself.

And here, the ārya path. So we don’t take it to mean that that awareness existed from beginningless time. No. Of course, the if we were to recite something like the the wheel of the four truths, say for instance, the turning of the wheel of Dharma Sūtra, that would simply be turning of the wheel of the Dharma Sūtra, expressed by us, so which exists in relation to our continuum as an ordinary being. It wouldn’t be the speech of the Buddha.

It would be our speech. So in fact, it’s it wouldn’t be valid speech because it’s speech of an ordinary being, not the speech of a Buddha. Yeah. Of course, the higher schools would accept that that form to be a valid reason as well. Oh, well, that is a valid reason that could used.

It’s a valid it has the three modes. Well, the three modes follow for that. So it’s good anyway to reflect on these issues and develop some ideas about these particular issues so that they can be addressed. These doubts can be addressed again in the future. So is that okay?

Yeah. Keep me up with this one. Was that okay that answered? Was that answer about the correct reason okay? I had yes, I thought there was such a broad area.

I mean, it could but yeah, it’s not something that’s easily resolved in one or two questions. Did you have you studied, say, correct reasons before at all or in this sense? This type of this presentation.

Key terms in this teaching

Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA
valid awareness pramana (Skt); tshema (Tib)
A new non-deceptive cognition. There are two types: valid perception, such as the eye consciousness seeing a flower, and valid inference, such as inferring fire from seeing smoke. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top