Mind & Mental Factors — 2006-10-12

1 h 8 min · 4,230 words · 12 October 2006 · Buddha House Adelaide

Mind & Mental Factors (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Mind & Mental Factors (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Mind & Mental Factors — 2006-10-12
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Pain and pleasure cannot arise in the mind simultaneously — this seemingly simple claim anchors Geshe Pema Tsering’s careful opening of the mental factors chapter of the Mind and Mental Factors text. In this 69-minute session, he first contextualizes why Asaṇga’s eight-consciousness system and Nāgārjuna’s six-consciousness system are complementary rather than competing explanations, then introduces the full taxonomy of 51 mental factors across six categories. The remainder concentrates on feeling, the first mental factor, defined as the experience that individually registers the ripening results of virtuous, non-virtuous, and neutral karma. Geshe-la covers its three types, its bodily and mental forms, and draws on the Precious Garland of Nāgārjuna and Āryadeva’s Four Hundred Stanzas to establish that karma is infallible — happiness and suffering each arising exclusively from their respective causes.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 08 2006 10 12 M and MF.mp3

UUID: 22d2d199-06af-45e9-bcbb-b10020abde66

Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering

Collection: Mind & Mental Factors (Geshe Pema Tsering)

Date: 2006-10-12

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 68.6 minutes

Words: ~4,228

Understanding us and to give us a good motivation and then thinking that in order to bring all sentient beings to enlightenment, we must attain enlightenment ourselves. In order to accomplish that, we are we are now going to listen to the teachings on the mental factors and then to to study them and and then aim at that goal of attaining enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings. So we follow on on page fifteen of the English translation. The text is telling us so then in this way, we have in the in India, the land of noble beings, we have two traditions of Mahāyāna vehicle that were expounded by the the the greats, what they are called, the great trailblazers. And this this two very renowned traditions of them, and then one is the tradition of Nāgārjuna, the other is tradition of Asaṇga and his brother.

Is that okay? And then, so we are told of these two systems of Nāgārjuna and Asaṇga, and then we are told that these two Mahāyāna schools of thought, they do not differ by way of its intention, the mind of enlightenment and the practice of the six perfections and so forth. They have a difference in the view that has arisen there is a difference in the view that they hold. And then even though there is this difference in the view, we are told that these views from their own side, are not inferior or superior to each other. These views of both Nāgārjuna and Asaṇga.

But as the Buddha himself has predicted in the sutras, these views have have arise in in accordance with, how do say, the power, the mental power, the mental abilities, capabilities of of of the trainees, of those or the disciples or those beings to be subdued. And so in order to to suit their needs, then these these two different views of these two different ways of explaining the intention of of of the Buddha have have arisen. This one. Okay? And then we are told then so then from that, with respect to the way of positing a mind basis of all as it appears in the body of the works of Asaṇga, and then from that mind basis of all, then ascertaining from that position, ascertaining the way of ascertaining that all phenomena are in the nature of mind only, etc.

So then all these important points of this uncommon system, all these important and common points of this tradition of Asaṇga, then one, if one wishes to know them in detail, then one should study the body of works of Asaṇga itself, and also one should study the excellent teachings, the excellent explanations. How to say? We should study carefully these excellent explanations of Lama Tsongkhapa himself on these points. Okay. And then also, if one on the other hand, if one wishes to learn about the uncommon points of the teachings of Ārya Nāgārjuna, then one should then study the two major commentaries, explanations of the works of Nāgārjuna and Candrakīrti and also study the special insight sections of the greater stages of the path and the medium stages of the path to enlightenment of Lama Tsongkhapa himself, which are teachings which are very difficult to find in in the world, in the three worlds.

So then Geshe-la then explained that all this that we just went through is being we are being told all these things because whilst explaining primary consciousness or main minds previously in the last in the last class, the beginning of this text, then there was a mention to the fact that in the the mind only schools, they are posited in order to explain intentions of of of the teacher. Then they they posited eight eight primary consciousness, eight main minds. And and Nāgārjuna, in other schools, then we have only six minds. And Nāgārjuna is saying that all of them, if both Asaṇga and Nāgārjuna, they both accept the six main minds or six six primary consciousness. But in order to explain the intention of of of the teacher, of of the Buddha, to to certain disciples, you shall explain them, they they they explained it by a certain eight consciousness instead of six.

Just a means means of explaining the intention. So then Geshe-la is explaining that the mind basis of all was taught because it was said that the, how do you say, mind mental, the the mental primary consciousness, the mind sense consciousness, it was not a stable basis for positing, for explaining then, how to say, the imprints or seeds of virtues and non virtues and neutral imprints. So then in order to to then to to to to be able to to posit then this virtues, non virtues and and and neutral imprints or or seeds, then they they they needed, how do you say, a stable consciousness, a stable basis for that, and then they they they then they said that that was the mind basis of all. And then also, Geshe-la was explaining, so then this mind basis of all is then it’s a neutral consciousness. As I said, it is not it’s something which is not is neither virtue nor non virtue.

It’s a neutral phenomenon. And then on the other hand, you would have then in order to explain as a basis for as a support for the afflictive mind, for afflictive emotions and conceptions, and you have that which was called by the mind only followers, how do you say, the afflicted afflicted consciousness. And then so you will have, on top of the six primary consciousness, will have also the mind basis of all, and the afflicted consciousness. Okay? So then, I guess, I was then saying that this is this is then is what is in the mind only school, in the tenets of the mind only school.

I guess, Geshe-la was saying that in actuality, there are not there are only six main minds or six primary consciousness. Okay? So then so then the the other two consciousness, then if you then reminding us of the six consciousness, then is the eye primary consciousness, ear, tongue, nose, tactile, and then mind, primary consciousness. So then and so then this ends the the first chapter of of this text, which is the explanation of primary consciousness or main minds. So if if there is if there is something which is if if it is primary consciousness, then it must be one of the six primary consciousness.

And then Geshe-la is saying that for each one of them, from the the various mental primary consciousness and and eye primary consciousness and so forth. There are a whole diversity of each one of them. But if it is primary consciousness, it must be one of the six one of the six primary consciousness that we’ll explain. And then so then we start them with the second major division of this text, which is then mental factors, the explanation, the teaching on mental factors. And then we start with we we we then saying the text is then saying, as for as for mental factors, then we we have a quote from this other text, which is distinguishing the five aggregates.

In the in this text, it reads, what is that? What are those phenomena which are phenomena that arise from the mind? So it’s it’s you have an explanation in brackets of of the meaning of what I’m trying to to say. The the the word is just we have extensively here, so that means arise from the mind, and and that’s what we refer to as mental factors. And so then what are those phenomena we are asked?

And then we are told from the same text, we are told that those are the phenomena which are concomitant with main minds. And then so, Geshe-la was then explaining that it is it is not only that phenomena which is concomitant with the mind. Geshe-la was then making more specific. It’s it’s the clear and knowing phenomena which is concomitant with main mind.

Okay? And then if then we were to divide mental factors, we would have the five omnipresent mental factors such as feeling and so forth. We will have the five ascertaining object ascertaining mental factors six root afflictions, such as attachment attachment and so forth, we will have the twenty secondary afflictions, such as belligerence and so forth, we would have also the four changeable mental factors such as regret and so forth. Okay? And then and then we’re so then there are fifty one of fifty one mental factors.

And then, likewise, we have also, again, from the from the this text discriminating distinguishing the five aggregates. We are told five are the omnipresent, five are the that the as individually ascertain objects, eleven are virtues, six are afflictive emotions, because the remaining are the secondary afflictive emotions or conceptions. And then four are the changeable mental factors. And then Geshe-la was saying, with the first one, five, they are omnipresent. And Geshe-la was then explaining that the five omnipresent mental factors, feeling, discrimination, intention, contact, and mental engagement, they are present in every mind.

That’s that’s what it is to say. If they are not present, then you do not have you do not have a fully characterized mind. And then as for the the five object-ascertaining mental factors, Geshe-la then explained, they are not present in every they’re not necessarily present in every mind. They are present only in those minds which ascertain objects. And in those minds that do not ascertain objects, they are not present.

They are not present. And then eleven, virtues. The six are the root afflictions. And then in in the Tibetan, you have what was translated as, what is it, secondary secondary afflictions in English. In the Tibetan, we use there’s a word which is clearly means close or near.

So then as I was explaining, so then those remaining twenty secondary afflictions, they are are near the root afflictions, so to speak. They are close to the root afflictions. Okay? And then the the the remaining four, the last four, which are the changeable mental factors. So then, Geshe-la was just saying, so then each one of these mental factors of of all the fifty one mental factors here mentioned, they are going to be explained and clarified.

The meaning of each one of them is going to be clarified in the text, one by one. So then the first as for the first one of them, which are the five omnipresent mental factors, then we have we have then feeling, discrimination, intention, contact, and how to say, mental engagement, translated as attention. And then, so then, the first one, so what is the entity of the first one of those? What is the entity then of feeling? Mental factor of feeling.

Then we have from the compendium of knowledge, have a quote which says which is then asking what is then the characteristic or the defining characteristics? What are the defining characteristics or what is the defining characteristic of feeling? And then we are told it is that which has the characteristic of experience. So, whatever entity of experience there is, then, how to say, it experiences the ripening results, how to say, the effects which are sorry. It individually experiences the ripening results, which are effects of virtues or non virtues actions.

And then Geshe-la was then explaining then this entity of experience, which is feeling then, it experiences individually in the sense that it will experience the results of virtuous deeds, non virtuous deeds, and and neutral deeds without having them mixed up. Just we experience each one of these results one by one without having it mixed mixed up with other results. Okay. Is that clear? It means that you cannot experience pain and pleasure at the same time.

Okay. So then this life is an explain. So then, again, as this experience, what is it that it is experienced? It’s experienced. What is experienced is the result of virtuous karma, which is only happiness or pleasurable feelings, or the result of non virtuous actions, which is only suffering or painful feelings, or the result of neutral actions, which are, again, only neutral feelings.

And then, for individually, experiencing them individually, is that one one will experience only one of them, how to say it, from the experience of non virtue will only be suffering, and experience of virtue will only be happiness and so forth. And and in this way, one experiences them one by one. Okay? So then we are told then in this text, here, that that which is the experience of feeling, it is said to be then it is called the fruition results. And why is that?

As as Geshe-la was pointing out that in that in that sentence from the Compendium of Knowledge, we are told that it is the how to say? That which experiences individually, the fruition result. And we are told that it is an original result, and it is we are told that for the sake of understanding that the feelings that we experience ourselves experience of happiness and suffering, all of feelings, and feelings are not only happiness and suffering, also neutral feelings, they are, all of them, the fruition result of the maturational result, the fruition result of actions, of karma, of actions. And and and that we are so then because of that, in order to understand that, and we are told that this that which experience, that which is the the experience of feeling is then fruition result. Okay?

Mhmm. This one. Okay? And then we are told of furthermore from the the greater exposition of the stages of the path of enlightenment, that of of. We are told that the way the way that karma as as for the way that karma is certain, the way that karma is definite, then it is explained that ordinary beings whether or an ordinary being or noble being, whatever happiness there is with the aspect of, how to say, whatever happiness, which is a feeling with a pleasant aspect, even as much even as much as a cooling breeze that that happens to someone who has been born in in the hell realms, even that little happiness that is experienced because previously one has accumulated, how to say, virtuous karma.

And then from that karma, it arises. And then Geshe-la was explaining that so even though whatever happiness there is, whatever pleasant feeling there might there might be, even just as little as as this one of someone who has been born in hell, which is a very hot place. And even though birth in hell itself, birth in hell itself, they are the result of negative karma, they’re suffering, which are the result of negative karma, that little breeze that might be cooling that being there, that is that is the result only of of of virtuous karma, virtuous actions. And then we are told then that there is no way that happiness or pleasant feelings can arise from non virtuous actions. Okay?

And then also, on the other hand, we have then that whatever suffering, which is a of a painful aspect, or aspect of pain, then even as little as the suffering in the continuum of foe destroyers, I stop there to explain that foe destroyers. Even though they they are liberated beings, they still experience very little suffering. So then just just a tiny little suffering that they experience, even that, and all sufferings greater than that, they are only the result of having accumulated previously non virtuous karma, and they arise only from those. And then there is there is no way that suffering can arise from virtuous deeds. And then and then we have a quote then from the Precious Garland of Nāgārjuna, which reads, all suffering arise from non virtue, likewise, all miserable migrations. And then from virtue, the all the happy migrations and every happiness in within every rebirth.

Okay? And then we and then, Geshe-la was then just explain again, quoting the first two lines of of the verse, then saying that, again, from non virtuous deeds, then we experience suffering, and then all the the miserable realms of existence, the hell realms and so forth, they are all, again, the result of non virtuous having accumulated non virtuous actions. And then the last two lines of the verse, and again, from from virtuous deeds, one is reborn in the happy realms of existence, and then every every happiness that one experience is only only the result of virtuous deeds. And then we are told so then from because of that, then we are told that both happiness and suffering, they are not did not arise without causes. They are not also, did not arise out of a permanent cause or from Īśvara and so forth.

So they do not arise out of discordant causes. And then Geshe-la was explaining, so then, if as for the first part of the sentence, which says that do not they do not arise without a cause, it is to say that they are functioning things. They are compounded phenomena. They are a part of the the aggregates of a person. And then because of that, they are they are feelings.

They are they are also they are they compounded phenomena, and then they they must be then they must have then causes. Must be they must they must have causes. So then they’re not they do not arise also from a fundamental cause or from Īśvara and so forth. So, there is to say, if if one if if they need a cause, then they do not arise from discordant causes either. It’s ambiguous, so then it must have arise from concordant causes.

And as for the concordant causes, And as for the the the concordant causes, then we are told then, generally, generally, then from virtues from virtue and non virtue, you have respectively happiness and suffering. And and then and then we are told that even though the beginning very beginning of the first the next sentence, we are told even though there are various differences in terms of of of happiness suffering. And then Geshe-la was explaining. So then there there there are so many different variations of suffering. There are variations in intensity, in duration, and so forth.

It’s it’s it’s it’s uncountable, Geshe-la was saying. We cannot count them. There’s so many so many differences. And the same goes for happiness. And that is because there are, in the same in the other hand, there are so many different karmas, negative karma, non virtuous karmas and virtuous karma.

There are so many different ones. And then they arise these these results arising in correspondence, in direct proportion to the to their causes. Okay? In correspondence to their causes, not in direct proportion. And then we are told then then, again, from the beginning going back to the beginning of that sentence, we are told then that all these various differences in in in happiness and suffering, they they arise from the various different different karmas, two kinds of karma.

There are actions. There are virtue and non virtue, as I was saying. And they arise without the slightest without having how to say without being mixed not a little bit they all arise individually, each of them, and in this way of their arising individually without being mixed with each other one by one, then that’s knowing them to be so, then understanding them to be so, then that is the the the karma is then certain and infallible in this way, and having found then certainty within one’s mind of these facts, and that is what is called, how do you say, the correct view of the pure view of all the the Buddhist, the Buddha’s teachings. Of all of all followers of the Buddhist teachings. And then so then so then that correct view of all Buddhists then is is what is praised as the very foundation of all wholesome wholesome qualities, of all literally translated as white white dharmas.

And then Geshe-la was explaining of all virtues, virtuous dharma. So then that that knowledge of this this knowledge of the of actions and the results, as it was explained here, that is very basis of all good virtuous dharma. And if we divide feeling, then if are to divide feeling, then we have happy feelings or pleasant feelings, we have suffering feelings or painful feelings, and then you have neutral feelings. Okay? And, again, we are told we we have a quote from the the text which is then distinguishing the five aggregates.

We are told what what are feelings? What whatever what are whatever feelings there are? Then they are there are three types of feelings. And then we have happiness, suffering, and then that which is neither happiness nor suffering. So then and then we are told then explaining in the text is explaining to us what is happiness.

And happiness that if that which that that happiness is that when that when it is stopped, when it is arrested, or is that then we have the wish to meet with it again. We wish to meet it, to meet with or to encounter. And then suffering, as for suffering, is that when it arises, then we wish to be separated from it. Okay? Detail.

So then if if one is is if happiness has arisen already, then one then wishes it to remain unchanged. And then if if it has not arise arisen yet, then it’s that which one wishes wishes to arise, to to have then. Okay? So then and, again, as for suffering, being that which when it arises, one wishes then to be divorced from it, separated from it. And then Geshe-la was then explaining so then again, suffering is is that even though it when it has not arisen within our minds, mental continuum, when we see someone else suffering, already we also wish we already have the wish not to have it not to experience it.

Okay? And then if that which is not happiness suffering arises, When that arises, then one sorry. That which is neither happiness nor suffering, when it arises, then when those wishes, both the wish to be divorced or the the wish to encounter, those wishes do not arise either. And then that’s what is called the neutral feelings, not having neither the wish to be separated from it nor to encounter it. And also those three types of feeling, they can be again divided in terms by means of the basis of of either body and mind.

And then we have six. So then we have we have three feelings of of body, three feelings of mind, and then you will have so then, body bodily feelings of happiness, bodily feelings of of pain, bodily feelings, or neutral neutral bodily feelings, and then again of mind, again, happy mental feelings, suffering mental feelings, and then neutral mental feelings. So then and then Geshe-la wasn’t reading the text, the text is just telling us that, again, as for the three bodily feelings, have pleasant bodily feelings, painful bodily feelings, and then neutral bodily feelings, and then as for the the three mental feelings, again, you have happy mental feelings, suffering mental feelings, and neutral feelings. And then what is the difference? We are told what is the difference between bodily feelings and mental feelings?

Then those feelings which arise around any of the the the five sense powers, sense consciousness, of the five sense consciousness, those are bodily feelings. Those are said to be. Those are called bodily feelings. And then those feelings which arise in the vicinity or around the mental consciousness, those are what are called mental feelings. Okay?

So then, what is the reason? We are asked, what is the reason then for positing those bodily feelings to be feelings which arise around or in the vicinity of an eye sense consciousness, for example. And then we have a quote from the Four Hundred Stanzas of Āryadeva, which says, Just as the body sense power pervades all the body, then ignorance abides in all. So then we are told then that body sense power that pervades all of the body from the very top of the head, from the very crown of the head to the soles of the feet. And in this All things that arise in relation to the eye sense consciousness and so forth, and the other things that arise around all the other four sense consciousness, they are called then bodily feelings because of that.

Okay? So then Geshe-la explains that all those those those sense consciousness, the five sense consciousness, as as, for example, the the eye sense consciousness, it because it arises in dependence on the eye sense power, then then it is then it is called a bodily feeling because the eye sense power itself is part of the body.

Key terms in this teaching

changeable mental factors anyathabhava-chaitta (Skt); zhen gyur sem jung (Tib)
One of the six groups of mental factors, these are factors that can be virtuous, nonvirtuous or neutral depending on one's motivation and the specific situation. There are four: sleep, contrition, investigation and analysis. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
compounded phenomena samskrta (Skt); du jä kyi chö (Tib)
Phenomena that arise due to causes and conditions. LYWA
insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
omnipresent mental factors sarvatraga-chaitta (Skt); sem jung kun dro (Tib)
One of the six groups of mental factors, these accompany every main mind. There are five: feeling, discrimination, intention, mental engagement and contact. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top