Middle Lam Rim — 2009-05-28

1 h 59 min · 7,615 words · 28 May 2009 · Buddha House Adelaide

Middle Lam Rim (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Middle Lam Rim (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Middle Lam Rim — 2009-05-28
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Correcting a common misconception — that tantric practice makes Vinaya vows irrelevant — opens this nearly two-hour session as Geshe Pema Tsering works through the final pages of the intermediate scope before pivoting to the great scope. He draws on Geshe Langri Thangpa’s barley-and-famine verse (“everything hinges on discipline”) and Lama Atisha’s principle that Vinaya and mantra are mutual companions, not competing paths. The commentary then covers the transition into Mahāyāna: why intelligent practitioners aim at full enlightenment from the start rather than liberation alone. A vivid contrast between arhats contentedly absorbed in nirvana and early-stage bodhisattvas illustrates why bodhicitta accelerates the path. The closing Q&A addresses inferential cognition of emptiness and how to begin meditating on dependent arising, starting with whichever level of the reasoning feels most accessible.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 14 2009 05 28 BP.mp3

UUID: ad75f28f-8b23-4a99-89bb-fa56abbc7867

Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering

Collection: Middle Lam Rim (Geshe Pema Tsering)

Date: 2009-05-28

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 119.6 minutes

Words: ~7,619

So then Geshe is then instructing us to give rise to a good motivation. So then with the intention then of establishing all sentient beings perfectly establishing all sentient beings in the unsurpassed state of enlightenment, then I myself must attain enlightenment. In order to attain enlightenment, we will study these teachings on the lamrim and practice according to the teachings so that I can attain this goal. And in this way, we give rise to a good motivation. And then we start with the preliminary prayers.

We start with the Heart Sūtra. The the Buddha’s, the Buddha’s, Buddha’s, Buddha’s, Buddha’s, rejoice. Bhagavan having thus spoken, the Venerable Śāriputra, the Bodhisattva mahasattva Avalokiteśvara, those surrounding their entirety along with the world of gods, humans, asuras, and Gandhavas were rejoicing, highly praised and spoken by the Bhagavan. Then the extensive dispelling of hindrances. I and also around the sentient beings go for refuge to the Buddha, go for refuge to the Dharma, go for refuge to the Sangha.

We prostrate to the great mother, Prajñāpāramitā, surrounded by all the children, by the assemblies of Buddha and Bodhisattvas of the ten directions. By depending on my prostrations to all of you, may these words of truth be actualized. In the past, the deva king Indra dispelled the Maras by reflecting on the profound profound meaning of the wisdom gone beyond and recited the profound words in daily recitation. In that same way, I also reflect on the profound meaning of the great mother Prajñāpāramitā and recited profound words in daily recitation. May all diseases, possessions, bad conditions, all the negative directions, that which happens due to past karma and immediate conditions, may all these be dispelled, may become nonexistent, may be pacified.

So, we move on to the next topic again. The need not just for ordained mantric practitioners, but also for lay practitioners of mantra to guard the morality of vows. So then if if if such guard of morality is for those who hold the vows of individual liberation, it is also similar in the case of mantra we are told. Yeah. Yeah.

So then, as it says in the tantra requested by Subbahu, of all the pure ethical disciplines of pratimoksha, of individual liberation, that I, the Jina, I taught practitioners of mantra who are householders should abandon the signs and the rituals while practicing the rest. This one. So, again, the whole point being, Geshe-la was saying that everyone has to keep a proper regard, one’s vows that pertain to ethical discipline, to the vows of individual liberation. So, again, not only the ordained practitioners, but also the lay practitioners must be just as careful and attentive to to the vows. So again, Geshe-la was saying, again, one has to whatever vows one has taken, whatever vows one has taken, there are five.

So, again, there is the vows, the five vows, and there is the male and female novice vows, male and female full fully ordained vows. And one has to keep them properly and be equally careful with all such vows. So so, Geshe-la was reading through the text and explaining. So, Geshe-la first will read this. Again, if it is necessary for lay practitioners of mantra to behave as set out in the Vinaya, except for the signs of ordination, the ritual actions, and some parts of the prescribed formulated rules.

What need is there to mention ordained practitioners of mantra? And Geshe-la was explaining. So, again, lay practitioners of mantra have to keep all these vows of the Vinaya just like the ordained Sangha, except for, again, they don’t have to have the signs. They don’t have to wear robes or anything like that. They don’t have to do all the rituals that pertain to the Vinaya, and they do not have to keep those prescribed, those specific prescribed formulated rules.

But Geshe-la was saying that those those are specific rules that the fully ordained monk or nun has to keep, for example, as not cutting grass, not walking outside the bounds of of the monastic training, whatever maybe outside the monastery or outside a prescribed area. So there are certain rules which are specific for the exclusive to the fully ordained monk and nun that then the lay practitioner does not have to have to keep. So those some parts of prescribed formulae rules, that’s what was making reference to. But all the other vows, they have to keep. Okay.

So again, so what need is there to mention ordained practitioners of mantra? So, again, both lay and ordained practitioners of mantra have to keep these vows also. To correct this common misconception. There is there are there are there are people there are many people who say, okay. I’m I’m practicing mantra, and mantra is much better and far superior than this individual liberation trainings.

So, you know, I don’t need to practice that, those individual liberation vows. That’s, you know, irrelevant if I’m practicing mantra. It’s pointless. It’s no good. Mantra is enough and so forth.

So in order to stop this type of misconception, and we are told we are told this. We are told that everybody should be careful about the vows of individual liberation because, Geshe-la was explaining, because contradicting those trainings of individual liberation is a fault, amount to fault, to faulty behavior, faulty conduct and every little misconduct, every little fault, again, through time, the the the results that they bring increase, proliferate. And if you keep on practicing many, many little faulty actions, again, the the results are going to be great. So one has to avoid all all all sorts of negativities, all types of negativities, even the the smallest, tiniest ones. One has to be careful about all of it.

All of it. Tantra. Tantra and mantra is all the same. Okay. What what would they base that belief on?

Why why would they say that? Say what? That practicing mantra is sufficient. Mantra or tantra is sufficient. Some some people say that.

Yes. But what what what would lead them to conclude this? Oh, So the reason some people, say that is because they haven’t thought carefully about it. They are confused or deluded about it. They haven’t studied it carefully, so they haven’t properly understood the whole thing.

So they say tantra is a superior vehicle. Tantra is a very powerful vehicle. Nonetheless, to conclude that because tantra is a superior vehicle, I do not need to practice these other teachings here. That’s that’s delusion. That’s a misconception.

That’s a mistake. And that this sort of misconception comes about because they haven’t thought carefully about it. They haven’t studied properly. It’s just like saying, oh, I have Geshe-la was saying, I have this it’s like having a big job, you know, a a great job, a better paying job or something like that, and then neglecting all the small little jobs that come with it. Sort of this this sort of I have a big job, have a big I don’t have to do all these little things, you know.

I’m the boss. I just tell people what to do. So it’s not true. So it’s also, you know, really delusion, confusion. That’s why they they they say that.

So So and then Geshe-la will go to the the next topic, which is then it is the the position of holy former masters to make ethical discipline and all other practices mutually supportive of each other. And Geshe-la is then pointing out what what we have been taught before. Again, the ethical discipline is the foundation, is the ground, is the field in which or on which all good qualities grow or develop and so forth. So I was reading that quote from Geshe Langri Thangpa, which says, if a famine breaks out, then everything depends on barley. Likewise, everything hinges on discipline.

Therefore, earnestly apply yourself to it. Pure ethical discipline also does not come about in someone who has not reflected on actions and their results. So, therefore, it is an essential instruction to reflect on that. It is a fundamental importance to reflect on actions and the results. Fundamental importance to reflect on actions and the results.

So, Geshe lah, again, it is it is essential. It is of utmost importance that one study those teachings, those instructions on actions and the results because it is on on on the basis of this understanding of the workings of actions and the results that one can keep one one that one will be able to keep pure moral ethical discipline. English I was explaining because it is for the knowledge that we acquire on the teachings of actions and the results that that virtuous actions lead to to happiness and that non-virtuous actions lead to suffering. It is for this knowledge that we’ll be able then to strive, exert ourselves to accomplish virtue, and then and and give up and abandon non virtue non virtuous actions. So it is of utmost importance then that we study that.

Without studying actually the results, we will lack this understanding and we will do whatever it is that profits us, that profits our own self interest without giving it a second thought or thinking about the consequences of our actions. And then Geshe-la says, generally, also, whatever excellent and fortunate happens, whatever excellent action or fortunate action happens depends on the Dharma. Also, in this regard, if you rely on what is suggested in the you need not change anything. You will become sincere, withstand investigation, enjoy practice, and have a good end, obtain a good result. And then says also says, many people miss out mantra through relying on Vinaya or miss out Vinaya through relying on mantra.

Only in my teacher’s tradition, Lama Atisha, does the Vinaya become the companion of mantra and mantra, the companion of the Vinaaya. And the word for companion is companion, helper, friend, and so forth. So it has all these different meanings. So again very simply put if one is practicing tantra, one also has to practice the Vinaya. If one is practicing the Vinaya, one also has to practice the tantra.

There is no place for such talks or such thoughts thoughts of, you know, if I’m practicing one, I do not need to practice the other. They they they sort of synergize with each other. That’s the meaning of that word. They help each other. They are companions with each other.

They synergize ize with each other so must we ought to practice both topic here of this section. How the great beings in the land of Aryas put into practice the requirement that all activities accord with the three scriptural collections. So in this regard, then Geshe-la was reading the starting to read the quote, which is then saying, with with us in India, whenever an important matter or temporary activity arose, those who upheld the scriptural collections convened and established whether they did not reject the three scriptural collections or did not contradict them. And upon that, it was decided. So again, Geshe-la was saying, so in Nālānda, then this monastery, so old monastery in India, when there was something that needed to be done, whatever it may be a construction or repair or whatever it may be whatever activity or action it may be before they engage in the action they would gather together and examine if the action or the activity or the task at hand would in any way contradict the three sets of scriptures so again the Vinaya, the Abhidharma and the Sutras or if it will be in accord with the scriptures the three collections of teachings so was it if it would contradict, then they would not engage in the action.

They would just let go of it. And if it did not contradict, if it was in accordance with it, then they would go on. They would go ahead with the project or whatever activity was at hand. So and then, again, we from Vikramashila, again, then had the task to examine whether it was rejected by Bodhisattva behavior or in contradiction to it, and the decision was upheld by the entire ordained community once the decision was made. And then this and then this then concludes the explanation of training the mind and the stages of the path common to beings of intermediate scope.

So so, again, Geshe-la is just summing up. So the main objects of training points of training of the beings of intermediate scope is then the four training in the four noble truths and the three trainings on on ethics, concentration, and wisdom. And and then again Geshe-la is pointing out what we have been taught here in this chapter is that all these all these trainings depend on on good ethical discipline. So if one has good ethical discipline, then the trainings on concentration and wisdom and the trainings on the four noble truths will turn out well. If one does not have good ethical discipline, then the trainings on concentration, wisdom, the four noble truths will not turn out well.

And this is just pointing out this one word in that last the very last sentence, the stages of the path common to beings of intermediate scope. So, again, it’s common common to beings of intermediate scope and common to beings of greater scope. So common to the beings it’s those are trainings that beings who are training the path of greater scope also engaging. So they are common to both. So, again, Geshe-la moves to the next major section of the text.

So, again, so which is then this teaching on the way to train on the stages of the path of beings of great scope. So then the training the mind in the path of beings of great scope, we have two two points to that, the transition and the actual path. As for the transition, then we have firstly, even for the achievement of one’s own own entire welfare, it is inappropriate to disregard the welfare of others. Therefore, it is necessary to enter the great vehicle from the start. Those ethics only relate to your actions towards other people, or is it also related towards yourself as in As in eating properly or sleeping at the right time and so forth.

Let’s see what we can do with that. Mhmm. Mhmm. Mhmm. Right?

So Geshe-la is explaining so Geshe-la says, so briefly, first, briefly. Right? Ethical discipline is giving up the abandonment of the ten non-virtues. That’s ethical discipline. Briefly speaking, in a nutshell, this is the common ethical discipline that that of all practitioners without exception, the abandonment of the ten non-virtues.

So if you engage in any of these ten engage in any of these ten non-virtues, you are not only harming others, you’re also harming yourself. So whatever actions that are going to cause harm to others and or to one self, if you are guarding against that, if you are protecting against those actions, that is ethical discipline. Generally speaking, right, in a broad sense, that is ethical discipline. So even if the the action is going to seemingly provide you with an immediate immediate benefit or immediate gratification, but if it later on, if it will bring harm, then again, again, it’s to be avoided. So you must must be guarded against.

So whatever whatever it is that is going to harm oneself or another. Whatever whatever it is. And then on the other hand so so generally speaking, Geshe-la says, so whatever it is that’s gonna harm oneself or another or other, then must be guarded against, and that is ethical discipline. And on top of that, whatever it is that is going to benefit in an ultimate sense, in the sense of the Dharma, know, happy future lives, liberation, and enlightenment, whatever it is that’s going to benefit either oneself or others, then, again, is to be accomplished, is to be practiced. And that that also in in this general brief presentation is ethical discipline.

So maybe Geshe-la wants to say something else more. Just so whatever actions so harmful actions and beneficial actions, Geshe-la was just saying, again, when we’re talking about harm and benefit, we’re not talking about harm and benefit that pertains to this life. We’re talking about harm and benefit of the next life onwards. So whatever it is that’s going to we we think in terms of what is going to harm or benefit the happiness of future lives and and liberation and enlightenment. And that’s the perspective that we are taking.

Not we’re we’re not concerned with this life. Not not there’s no nothing to do with present life alone. Present life alone. So for as a a as a broad illustration of of ethical discipline, and saying for example, if you kill a sheep or sheep. If you kill a sheep in order to eat, then again, you you you get benefit in this present life because you have something to eat, but you will the the ripening result of such an action is incredible harm in the future.

So that’s something that must not be done. That’s So again, it is maintaining proper ethical discipline in this context is not is not easy, you know, to to figure out what it is that’s going to be harmful or beneficial in in in this in in terms of dharma, in terms of future lives and liberation and enlightenment is not something easy. Not something that it doesn’t come without some measure of, you know, very serious thinking and study. Giving giving again another broad illustration or example. In the same vein of of the the example of killing the sheep, in the same vein, if you are practicing charity and giving money away or giving belongings away and giving, you know, volunteer work, free work or whatever you know you’re giving away.

Again as we ordinary people would see that you are harming yourself in this life, you are losing in this life, but you are winning in future lives. You’re profiting. You’re benefiting future lives in this way. And that’s something that must be done. So that’s the general guidelines.

So, again, this is a topic that, as a layperson, technically, are not allowed to to look into, and I respect that very much. So that we are not allowed to study the Vinaya because we are lay practitioners. But I was just saying, you know, I I, you know, the I I have some friends who are monks, I was just saying, so there is some there are some vows that pertain to, you know, the quality of the food that you are eating or the amount of food that you are eating, the the time that you are eating, the amount of sleep that you get, that you have to get rest. So so just maybe I’m trying to guess what you’re come where you’re coming from and then say again you have one has to look after one’s health in order to practice the Dharma. Now in the Vinaya this this goes you know the Vinaya goes to very great details about what one is allowed to do and what is not allowed to do.

There are hundreds and hundreds of vows and and and prescriptions and prescriptions. So it’s a lot of stuff. But but that’s in an attempt to answer what I think you are asking, yes, one has to that has to do also with what one is doing to oneself. Yes. So that one can accomplish the dharma and all that.

Okay. Okay. Okay. So, again, Geshe-la was just pointing out in in the Vinaya, there are different schools of Vinaya, but in the in the Tibetan school of Vinaya, we have two hundred and fifty three vows for the monks, for the male ordained Sangha, for the fully ordained monks. The nuns have more.

But for the fully ordained monks, have two hundred and fifty three. And then, like I said, are only the ones that are explicitly enunciated. But implicitly, there are innumerable prescriptions and prescriptions. Anything that that accords or is of the same type or similar to those vows falls. And they’re sort of categories, actually.

They’re not just vows. They’re sort of categories. So everything that is many things can be included in each one of those vows. So, in way, they’re really innumerable prescriptions and prescriptions and so forth. That’s a lot of detail in So, again, again, I just want to reiterate this is Geshe has been very generous in sharing all this information with us, but I I just want to reiterate this is out of bounds for laypeople, and I I’d like to respect that.

But Geshe-la was just giving us another illustration of the vows that they have to maintain. So when when a monk or a nun is walking, they are not allowed to look more than a few feet away ahead of themselves. They have to look to the path and just like like one step ahead on it. They’re not allowed to look in any other direction. They’re not allowed to look around or anything like that.

So this this is the just to illustrate the the rigor and and the detail of the monastic training. I was just saying and and there’s much more detail to that. It is a very detailed training and it’s not easy. It only comes with a lot of study. But let’s move on.

There’s a lot of things, a lot of vows to be guarded. So, again, we we move we’ll go back to the text. Even for the achievement of one’s own entire welfare, it is inappropriate to disregard the welfare of others. Therefore, it is necessary to enter the great vehicle from the start. So, again, through meditating in this manner upon the disadvantages of cyclic existence from different perspectives over a long time, you will indeed see all existence as being like a pit of blazing fire, and your mind will be thoroughly overcome by the wish to attain liberation that completely pacifies suffering.

So so, again, one one needs to contemplate the disadvantage and the shortcom comings of the entirety of cyclic existence. And if one gains this comprehension, this understanding, then one will be able to develop this relationship to cyclic as if it was a house on fire or a pit of fire and then and and and this intense wish to be free from it. And again, if due to that you train in the three trainings, you will attain liberation from cyclic existence. So Geshe-la goes for the text. Again, if you do so that you train in the three trainings, you will attain liberation from cyclic from cyclic existence.

And moreover, we you will not turn back again even for the glory of high status. And then Geshe-la was making reference, you know, to birth in the form and formless realms of existence. Nonetheless, since extinguishing extinguishing your own faults and achieving good qualities is limited, one’s own welfare is not complete. For that very reason, all this welfare is also temporarily neglected. And in the end, having been urged to do so by the Buddhas, you will have to enter the great vehicle.

Therefore, it is appropriate for the intelligent to enter the great vehicle from the start. Alright? This one. Instead of is one is one is training to attain full enlightenment for the sake of all beings instead of training to attain liberation for oneself alone. That’s what is that’s the distinction.

Yes. So one is aiming at full enlightenment from the beginning. So this is lot of assessment. That’s not what is meant by the text. You know, in order as we have been seeing those paths, the path of beings, the path which is common to beings of small scope, common to beings of middling scope.

They are common because those are also the path of beings of great scope. So and Geshe-la was saying and and what is in practice what we what we have to do is that we have to start training in the mind of enlightenment from the beginning. Yes. And at the same time, we are practicing all these other common trainings on the path of beings of small scope and and middling scope, the three trainings and so forth. And because without going through those trainings of the path of which is common to be a small scope and medium scope one will not be able to fully develop or to perfectly develop bodhicitta in in in the path of the great the beings of great scope.

So it is by no means, that was not is not what is meant. So again, when when when you read when we read here, it is appropriate for the intelligent one for the intelligent ones to enter the great vehicle from the start. We’re not saying you went to the the practice of the great vehicle and you, you know, turn your back or or leave aside the path, the trainings which are common to beings of small and medium scope. That’s not what is being said. What is being said is that again those trainings have to be one has to train in those trainings which are common to beings of small and medium scope in order to fully develop the the path of great scope, and one does that together with the training of the mind of enlightenment.

And I think it goes back in the text, which when he’s making reference, since extinguishing your own faults and achieving good qualities is limited. So Geshe-la was saying that’s making reference to the arhats foe destroyers. So those who have attained liberation for themselves alone, Their accomplishment is is limited. It’s partial. They they have rid themselves of only some of the faults, but not of every fault.

They have accomplished only some good qualities, but not every good quality. They have not accomplished omniscience. They have not accomplished the benefit the ability to benefit all sentient beings and so on. So their their attainment is limited. Their attainment is partial.

So, again, so the intelligent ones here then they they would then seeing that, understanding that, they then start from the beginning, start they don’t train exclusively on one thing or another to the exclusion of another. They train, you know, they are training the mind of enlightenment. They are training on the three trainings together, developing these trainings together so that in the future, there will be there will be no such there there is no place left for partial attainments, partial accomplishments or or limited accomplishments and attainments. Can go straight to enlightenment. This one.

So again, because I was saying that even those in the path or in the vehicle of the bodhisattvas, you know, they have to practice these other trainings. They have to engage these other trainings together with the trainings of the bodhisattvas. Just like we have been told here today in the text, we have been told that practitioners of the Vinaya must also train in the mantra vehicle, and practitioners of mantra must also train in the Vinaya. They do that together. They do it side by side.

And and so and that goes for for the those participants of the the the great vehicle. They do all these trainings. So they develop all these qualities side by side, bodhicitta and these other trainings. So again in the in the in the vehicle, in the Mahāyāna vehicle, then again one also has to engage in the three trainings. And the three trainings that they engage in is is this is is the three trainings which are common to the other types of beings.

It’s not a special type of three trainings that is exclusive to them. It’s three trainings which is common to other types of beings. Yes. Is laughing because the next verse and the translation is is pretty faithful here saying, having abandoned forever those two yanas, those two vehicles, which are without without power to bring about all the world’s aims, those whose nature is of one taste with helping others, and to the jinnas vehicle taught out of compassion. So, again, I was just laughing, saying, know, it it sounds like we have been told to to give up, to abandon those lesser trainings.

Again, it sounds like that. So again again, this this text, this summary of the perfection is a sūtra that has been so it is a word of the Buddha, something that the Buddha said. So if the Buddha says that we have to abandon those two vehicles, then we think, okay, I must abandon these two vehicles. So again, Geshe-la was just clarifying, again because it sounds again as if we are told not to engage in those trainings, not to practice those those teachings that pertain to the lower vehicles, the Hīnayāna vehicles. But again, what is really meant is that we should instead of engaging the three trainings alone, we should engage in the three trainings, the same three trainings that the in a Hīnayāna practitioner is engaging, but steeped in the mind of enlightenment.

Having the these three trainings steeped in the mind steeped in bodhicitta, steeped in the mind of enlightenment. That’s and that’s how we should practice. Is steeped in the mind of enlightenment includes brings about the same results or includes also training in the three trainings without not steeped in the mind of enlightenment. So if you if you engage in three trainings steeped in the mind of enlightenment, that includes also the mere or engaging in three trainings alone. Is that making sense?

Is that is that alright? This one. Is that okay, Daniel? So again, move on to the next topic. Since accomplishing the welfare of others is worthy of great beings, it is something that must be accomplished.

Since, again, since it is the happiness and magnificence of beings and and the ability of a being, it is appropriate to take responsibility for the welfare of others. So again again, since it is the the happiness and the magnificence of beings and ability of a being, it isn’t appropriate to take responsibility for the welfare of others because to observe only one’s own welfare is something that even any animals do. And so all this this translation is not very precise, but it was just saying, so all the the happiness, all the magnificence magnificence, and all the abilities, and all the excellent things there are, they, again, they they come in dependence on others. That’s how the Geshe-la was putting it. So, again, it’s our responsibility to look after the welfare.

It is to our is of of utmost importance to look after their their their welfare and not look after one’s own welfare alone because that even do. In case that was in that saying, I so much so then far surpasses the attainment of the arhats foe destroyers. Therefore, the natural disposition of great beings strive for the benefit and happiness of others. And guess what was saying is pointing out how how this this is actually the case, how even animals look after their own interests, their own welfare. You know, they they seek for for food, water, comfort, you know, protection from the weather and so forth.

So even though they they all look differently, their forms, their bodies, their shapes look all different, you know, their minds are very much the same in that they are all concerned with their own welfare, with their own survival and so forth. So again, when they are hungry, they look for food. When they are thirsty, they look for drink. When they are cold, they look for warmth. When they are hot, they look for coolness.

You know, when they are in danger of being hurt or in pain, they look for relief from that or release from that. So they they are all always engaging in means to accomplish their own welfare, their own interests. So again, Geshe-la was saying, so we we we engage And I guess I was gonna say again pointing out to this word that was gonna say is magnificence. So one one is magnificent when one is concerned with the welfare concerned with the welfare, the well-being of others. That’s how one becomes magnificent amongst others again so pointing out the importance of cultivating this intention and this care for others and Geshe-la was pointing out again to difference between the value or the magnificence between arhat foe destroyer and a bodhisattva.

So the bodhisattvas are more magnificent than the arhats foe destroyers. And then, Geshe-la was reading that quote from the letter to a student which says, when cattle see easily obtainable mouthfuls of grass, they eat it themselves. And when tormented by tormented by thirst, they find water, and they happily drink. So the magnificence of beings consists in the effort they make for the welfare of others. This is the noble ability of happy beings.

Traveling, riding across the sky, the powerful sun illuminates all. Regardless of the burden, the earth supports the world with everything in it. Those without the least self interest equal in nature to the great totally strive for that singular taste of the benefit and joy of the world. Is that right? Yes.

Me just probably talk a little bit more on that. Is it is it is it easier for a being who’s achieved bodhicitta to achieve the wisdom understanding emptiness, or is it more easy for a being who’s achieved wisdom understanding emptiness to achieve bodhicitta? Lah, I was just saying, so, first of all, answering the the last question. So, yes, having bodhicitta, one can then easily accomplish the accumulations of of merit, and then that makes it much easier to realize the emptiness. Yes.

So the answer is yes. And then, Geshe-la was just reiterating then, that the accomplishment of arhats foe destroyers, is no minor accomplishment. They not only have realized emptiness, they have rid themselves of every affliction, and they experience nothing but happiness. They experience no suffering whatsoever. Are totally free from suffering.

So their accomplishment is no minor achievement. It’s a huge, huge accomplishment. If you take a bodhisattva in the beginning of the bodhisattva path so someone who is in the the small path of accumulation so they have the small, medium, and greater path of accumulation so someone who is in the small path of accumulation the very beginning of the Mahāyāna path somebody who has developed bodhicitta right there and then that person if you put the two side by side, you put a an Arhat and that’s Bodhisattva in the small path of accumulation, that Bodhisattva will attain enlightenment before that arhat. That Bodhisattva will attain quicker than the arhat. So, Geshe-la was saying, that bodhisattva then was also engaged in the training on wisdom, also engaged in the training, cultivating the mind that realizes emptiness.

So that bodhisattva will eventually develop in the realization of emptiness. We’ll start the cultivation of the realization of emptiness. So in the meditative stabilization, when the person is in formal absorption formal meditative absorption in emptiness, then that that is the cultivation of wisdom. When out of the meditation session, when the person rises from his or her meditation seat, and the person is cultivating bodhicitta and the perfection and so on. When when training in this way, alternating, you know, the the cultivation of wisdom and of method in this way, the one quickly attains enlightenment by force of this training.

Whilst the arhats for destroyer is sort of caught up in the in the bliss of nirvana. It’s just abiding happily, not doing anything. So then the arhat foe destroyer, they remain absorbed, sort of absorbed in nirvana for a very long period of time. In the meantime that bodhisattva in the path of accumulation is working out his enlightenment, his or her enlightenment and attains enlightenment before and then arhats, hearers and solitary realizers arhats, they once they are there caught up in in their enjoy ment of nirvana, the Buddhas come, you know, in this, you know, what what what do you think you’re doing? I mean, just sitting there enjoying yourself whilst all other beings are are caught up in pain and misery.

When your your peace is is with this nirvana, this lower nirvana, you have not accomplished your have not perfectly accomplished your own welfare nor have you perfectly accomplished the welfare of others. Have you have you no shame sitting here enjoying this peace all for yourself alone whilst all all of the mother all all the mothers in are in the most utmost misery? Do you think it’s alright to just sit there in nirvana like that? And then and then the other arhat, Geshe-la will say, oh, yeah. You’re Yes.

You know? That’s that’s not right. You know? So Arhat then will start contemplating those trainings of beings of great scope and eventually the Araha will develop bodhicitta and then will enter from that moment on that they have shed away the path of the arhat, the path of the Hīnayāna, the small vehicle, and they have entered the greater vehicle. They are then in the path of accumulation of the of the Mahāyāna.

And then and even then, Geshe-la is saying that being will not attain enlightenment as quickly as that other bodhisattva who went straight to aim aimed straight at enlightenment from the very beginning. Because because of his experience of of nirvana, he will, you know, he will tend to miss that nirvana, you know, to long for that peace because it’s a it’s very blissful. It’s just it’s just very good. It’s good stuff. So so that that sort of slows the slows that being down, so him or So the whole point being that somebody who has attained liberation for him or herself alone will take much longer much, much longer to attain enlightenment.

Alright. Okay? I don’t know. Maybe. So so I just want to to clarify that when when you say intellectual understanding, I translate it as an inferential cognition, which is a very high powerful realization.

So that inferential cognition, yes, it has the power to damage or to hurt or to diminish or to weaken the imprints and seeds of the afflictions and so forth. And Geshe-la was saying quoting the four hundred verses of Āryadeva, which that those with little merit do not even hear of it, emptiness. But merely having doubts about it is enough to shake the foundations of cyclic existence. So, again, just having doubts about it is enough to start damaging or hurting those seeds and imprints and so forth. Alright?

And Geshe-la is gonna say no because I I use a very specific when you say intellect, you understand it. That’s very vague, so had to pick up one word. So I say I used inferential cognition, which is an intellectual understanding. It’s an intellectual certainty, which is free of every doubt. So it’s it’s it’s an unshakable intellectual certainty.

It’s a very high and powerful attainment. And Geshe-la was just saying if one has attained, developed an inferential cognition, one has done like most of the hard work has been done already. And if one has, for example, developed an inferential cognition with regards to the self grasping, then one has developed a mind which is directly opposite to the self grasping mind. The mind that grasps at an inherent existence or truly existent self. It’s a powerful powerful thing.

It’s a very powerful thing. One has to one ought to make effort in developing realization of emptiness. It’s it’s of unimaginable benefit. So these two minds, the mind of bodhicitta and the mind that realizes emptiness are unsurpassed in terms of benefit. So, Geshe-la was saying, these two are the two things that we ought to try to understand, contemplate in an attempt to understand, to develop understanding at all times, every chance we have, we should be striving to gather the causes and conditions for realizing these two, understand this too.

Yeah, yeah. Alright. What was that? What was that? Dependent Dependent arising.

I suppose. And in dependent arising, there are different levels. There is cause and effect, parts, and imputation. So it’s for example, if I wanna do it every day, do I have to go through all those from the coarse to the subtle reasoning and dependent arising. Mhmm.

Or I can choose one or two that I feel that might have more impact on myself and focus on one or two So then the the idea is generally speaking, when we talk about dependent arising, there is just one reason as as in as in, you know, a vase is not truly existent because of being dependent arising. A person is not truly existent because of being dependent arising, and so on and so on. So that’s the the reasoning. That’s the reason, the formal logical. Reason, the formal logical form of the reason.

And now there are different levels of subtlety of dependent arising. One can think of the coarse level, like the seed that gives rise to the sprouts, the tree, the fruits, and so forth. You know, the the water evaporation, rain, clouds, and all that jazz. So we can think of of the coarse forms of dependent arising. We can think of the the subtle forms of dependent arising, which are not obvious, and and and there are different ways to explain dependent arising.

But in order to answer your question, because I wasn’t saying one one starts with what is more comfortable for one. Whatever it is that one feels easier or more comfortable, then one realizes that first. One strives to develop that realization first and then moves on to something else which may be more difficult, which can be built upon that that first realization. But, Geshe was saying, this whole reasoning of dependent arising is is something not easy. It’s quite difficult.

This one? Yes. Did you understand? So one one must first understand, excuse me, What is a what is dependent arising or what is a dependent arising? So, one can think of things or impermanent phenomena as everything that arise in dependence on cause and conditions so everything that arise in dependence on cause and conditions is a dependent arising and one must understand that again body, the person, or whatever object one is contemplating, one has to understand that it it arises in dependence on causes and conditions.

And as such, it’s dependent arising. Having understood that, then one can establish that, again, that, you know, the person or the body, whatever it that one’s meditating on, is not truly existent because of being dependent arising. So one must first understand what is dependent arising and then establish that. I guess I wasn’t saying there are two ways to understand different kinds of phenomena. So impermanent phenomena, they depend arising because of they arise in dependence on cause and condition.

Permanent phenomena do not arise dependence in dependence on cause and conditions, but they come together in dependence on various parts. They they have many parts, and and they arise in dependence on many parts. But a person, for example, it depends on arise in dependence on cause and conditions. So again Geshe-la was gonna say that which is established or arises arises or comes into existence dependence on on many parts, is a dependent arising, is a dependent origination. It’s dependent that’s the definition of dependent arising.

Or that which, comes into existence dependence on cause and conditions again is dependent arising. Do understand that? Yes. So the person also arises in dependence upon many parts. So one must understand that, one must realize that.

Can be so the the person arises in dependence or comes into existence or exists in dependence on many parts there is different way of translating. But if it exists in dependence on many parts, then it doesn’t have any independent existence of its own or from its own side. Therefore, it doesn’t exist it doesn’t it doesn’t exist inherently or it doesn’t exist truly because it is dependent arising. Now if you really want to go in-depth in this subject, you have to study that book. It’s all there.

So again, you start with one reasoning and you stick with that until you develop some certainty and then you move on to others. So Geshe-la is just quoting a saying in verse which says that, again, one one must realize realizing emptiness with regards to one thing or with one reasoning, then having realized that, then is mind easily realizes the emptiness of other things. So one stick to one object of meditation with one reasoning, realizes that, and then it’s easy to develop the other reasonings and the other realizations with regards to other objects. So again, Geshe-la said, if we realize the importance of one thing, then one is easily is almost almost naturally realize the emptiness of everything else. Oh, yeah.

Is that okay? Oh, yeah.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
individual liberation
The liberation from cyclic existence achieved by a hearer (shravaka) or solitary realizer (pratyekabuddha), as compared with the full enlightenment of a buddha sought in the Mahayana. LYWA
mantra ngag (Tib)
Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
pratimoksha vows pratimokshasamvara (Skt); so thar gyi dompa (Tib)
The various levels of individual liberation vows for lay and ordained, including the five lay vows, and the novice vows and full ordination that monks and nuns take. LYWA
three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Does ethical discipline only concern actions toward other people, or does it also apply to oneself, such as eating properly and sleeping at the right time?

Ethical discipline is abandoning the ten non-virtues, and it is not only about others. Any action that harms others or oneself is to be guarded against, and whatever truly benefits oneself or others is to be practiced. Harm and benefit are judged by their effect on future lives, liberation and enlightenment, not just this life. Looking after one's health is needed in order to practice the Dharma, and the Vinaya has vows about the quality, amount and timing of food and about getting enough sleep and rest. So ethical discipline does include what one does to oneself, so that one can accomplish the Dharma.

Scroll to Top