Middle Lam Rim — 2009-04-02

2 h 19 min · 6,682 words · 2 April 2009 · Buddha House Adelaide

Middle Lam Rim (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Middle Lam Rim (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Middle Lam Rim — 2009-04-02
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 140-minute session, Geshe Pema Tsering works through the Lamrim’s systematic identification of the ten root mental afflictions, using the image of oil soaked into cloth to illustrate why attachment is so hard to dislodge, and a rope mistaken for a snake in the dark to explain how ignorance generates the rest. He moves methodically through attachment, anger, pride, ignorance, doubt, and the five afflicted views, noting how tenet schools from Vaibhāṣika to Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka differ in their understanding of what ignorance actually grasps. The session closes with extended Q&A on whether calm abiding harms self-grasping (it does not — only wisdom realizing emptiness does), and on an Āryadeva verse arguing that mere doubt about true existence is already enough to shake the foundations of cyclic existence. Suited to students following a structured Lamrim curriculum.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 12 2009 04 02 BP.mp3

UUID: 739bf66a-f026-4bc6-b31e-c34a491dbf01

Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering

Collection: Middle Lam Rim (Geshe Pema Tsering)

Date: 2009-04-02

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 140.0 minutes

Words: ~6,680

Oh, yeah. So again, I guess Geshe-la is then just trying to give us a good motivation to think to think carefully about, this good motivation, to then with the intention of accomplishing the welfare of all sentient beings. Then one, one self must attain enlightenment in order to accomplish that. And one is going to listen carefully to these attentively to the. And with this then in mind, we start with the preliminary prayers, the Heart Sūtra and so forth.

So we approach the next topic then on page one hundred twenty two, identification of the mental afflictions. So we have the three parts to this topic. So the actual identification of the mental afflictions, I guess, that was just briefly mentioning the six root afflictions, the twenty secondary afflictions, and so on, and wrong views, and all that. Then the stages by which the mental afflictions arise. And lastly, the faults or the shortcomings of the mental afflictions.

The first of those topics has ten parts. So the actual identification of the mental afflictions has ten parts. So the first one of those ten parts of identification of the mental affliction, the first one is then desires, or what’s translated here is desire is attachment, attachment. Geshe-la was going through the text. The first of those, desire is attachment, observes an attractive, pleasant external or internal object, and is subsequently attached to it.

And Geshe-la was saying with regards to you, dupa, observes an attractive or pleasant object. Or even sees something which is not actually attractive, but sees it as being attractive, and then gets attached to it. To illustrate, just as oil that has penetrated into cloth is hard to remove, desire’s attachment also clings to its object and pervades it, whereby it separates from that object with difficulty. And so I guess it goes back through the text. Again, saying giving a very brief and simple explanation of of the text.

Again, external and internal objects. In the Tibetan, it starts with external and internal objects which are attractive and pleasant, these objects of observation. And so observing these objects, then one gets attached to them. So Geshe-la was just saying, so external and internal objects, so all the external sense objects of forms and smells and touches and so forth, and internal objects. And the one the one is attracted to, the one perceives them as being pleasant.

Having observed them, having gotten in contact with these objects, then one gets attached. And Geshe-la was explaining again, once one gets attached to an object, just like in the example in the illustration that we are given, just like oil, which is very hard to separate from the cloth, to take away from the cloth, again, once one has attachment, it’s very hard to get rid of that attachment. Once attachment has arrived, it’s very hard to get rid of that attachment. And one can, by applying the temporal antidote, one can diminish the attachment to some degree. But it is only by realizing the lack of inherent existence of it that one can completely eradicate attachment.

And again, I shall just point out how difficult it is to accomplish that, to get rid of attachment in this way. Thank you. So again, Geshe is just explaining how it is difficult, how difficult it is to overcome attachment, to get rid of attachment. Because we perceive that we actually see qualities to that object of attachment that we have. We actually see good qualities to it.

We think it is going to give us happiness. And it does give us pleasant feelings, or the feelings of happiness, feelings of pleasantness. And so, does give us contaminated happiness. And in this way, it becomes very hard to think otherwise. And so again, even though it gives us this happiness, it gives us even much more suffering, suffering itself.

But we do not understand that, we do not see that. So again, just pointing out how difficult it is to get rid of it. And again, Geshe-la says, again, we engage in all sorts of activities and work out of attachment, out of our attachment. Then we get the fruits of our labor, we get our salary, our money, and we think that we get happiness in this way. And we remain ignorant of all the negative karma that we have accumulated in the process, and all the negativities that we have accumulated throughout.

So, I guess Geshe-la is just going for the next topic, next affliction, which is then anger. Anger through observing a source of suffering such as sentient beings, suffering weapons, thorns, and so forth, is a hostile attitude, rough mind, intended to inflict harm on the object. So, again, Geshe-la, I was just going through the briefly going through this text, which is then just saying that anger is something arises in relationship to these different sources of suffering in the Tibetan. So we have first the so called sources themselves. So it arises towards one gets angry towards sentient beings, towards suffering, towards pain, pain itself.

You know, if one gets ill or sick, and the suffering gets angry with that, with weapons, thorns, so forth. So all these sources of suffering, one gets angry towards them, one develops this hostile attitude, this harmful intent, and they have this rough mind, and then develops the intention to inflict harm on these sources of suffering. Anger then arises in relationship to that which is undesirable. And on the other hand, we have attachment which arises in relationship to that which is desirable. So if we get attached to that which is pleasant and attractive, and we get angry towards that, which is going to give us the opposite of what the object of attachment will give us, is pleasant.

Geshe-la was just saying, and that’s okay, isn’t it? Geshe-la was just saying, so then this is the way that, you know, generally people think about it. It’s okay, you know, to act in this way is alright. But that’s because we was saying, it is alright to think in the way people think. It’s alright to think this way to get attached towards that which is pleasant, and to get angry towards that which is unpleasant and painful.

And Geshe-la was saying, I got a complete blank. So, guess, I wasn’t just saying. Usually we the way we think is that it is all right then to get attached to be attached towards that which is pleasant and attractive and to be angry towards that which is the opposite of what is pleasant and attractive, which is unpleasant and unattractive. And Geshe-la was saying, we only think that way because we really do not know, do not understand what these do, what attachment and anger do, what are their Geshe-la mentioned beforehand, was saying, I’m talking about their function. We do not really understand their function.

We do not really know what they do. So Geshe-la was saying, we get attached towards a pleasant object, an attractive object, because we think it gives us happiness. But we don’t really know that contaminated happiness is not real happiness. And on the other hand, we get angry. We have this hatred or anger towards that which is giving us a feeling which is the opposite of that happiness, that pleasant feeling.

Or also we get angry towards that which is stopping us from getting that pleasant object of attachment, and so on. And again, we still and we think that in this way we can accomplish we can accomplish our happiness, our so called happiness. But I still we ignore the function of hatred itself, and we ignore the fact that these two minds of attachment and anger, they are distorted minds, They are fundamentally wrong. And Geshe-la was saying before, in the part that I forgot before, Geshe-la was saying that the functions of what anger does is that it destroys all the roots of virtue that we have accumulated. So it does so much damage in the end.

These two minds, they do so much damage in the end as opposed to what we think of them, of this way of of acting. And again Geshe-la says, we get attached towards that which we think is going to give us happiness, which we think is happiness. And then we get angry towards that which is hindering our acquisition of those objects of attachment, that which we think is going to give us happiness. But again, Geshe-la says, even though it gives us happiness, it is not real happiness. It is whatever it may be called, is in the nature of one of the three types of suffering.

As such, it is included in saṃsāra, because it is samsaraic object, a saṃsāra phenomena of saṃsāra. And all that it does, all that is accomplished in the end is more, is a perpetuation of cyclic existence itself in this way. So, one has to understand that, Geshe-la is saying, what we have to understand the greatest shortcomings of these two minds of attachment anger is that it blocks, it stops us from being able to attain liberation from cyclic existence. So what they do, what they actually do, is that they perpetuate our going around the cycle of existence. And they stop us from being able to take liberation from it.

So they give us this so called temporal happiness, but it causes this immense damage, this immense harm on the other hand. So, again, Geshe lah, it’s important that we understand that we see these faults, the shortcomings of these two minds. So it’s important that we realize how is it’s they cause us to remain in cyclic existence. And by seeing, seeing, then by understanding, by realizing these faults, shortcomings of these minds, then we can develop We can develop a this I don’t want to say this like So, by seeing then their faults, we can develop this, the wish to get rid of them. That’s what I want to say.

So, Geshe-la said, in order to be able to realize their faults and shortcomings, one has to engage in a lot of analysis and a lot of investigation. Again, without engaging in a lot of analysis, without thinking hard about it, one will not be able to fully see their faults, their shortcomings. One not being able to see fully their faults and shortcomings, one will not be able to develop their wish to be separated from them, to get rid of them, to let them to let them go, to let go of them. And in this way, one won’t be able to free oneself. This one.

So Geshe-la goes on to the next topic, pride. Pride then, through observing one’s external or internal So, internal or external level or qualities based on the view of the transitory collection is a puffed up mind engages that having an elevated aspect. So there’s two expressions here in the Tibetan, which is high or low or superior or inferior, and good and bad. So again, all sorts of higher status or lower status, more wealth, less wealth, good quality, bad quality. So one and then one thing is engaging that idea that one is more than another, higher than another, so forth.

So and was explaining, again, it arises in dependence on the view of the of the transitory collection. And what is the view of the transitory collection is it is that afflicted afflicted wisdom or is that afflicted wisdom or that afflicted discernment that when observing How can I say that? The I or the mind, When observing any of the two, I or mine, then conceives of the Then holds, grasp, holds or conceives of a truly existent self, a truly existent I. Okay? Once observing, observing the I or the mind, any of the two, I or mind, then conceives, or holds, or grasps onto this truly the existent I.

Okay? And, again, this is explaining. So whilst whilst observing the I or that which is mine, my objects, my parents, my friends, and so forth, the monk conceives of that one then is holding on to that I as being a true existence, inherent existence, and that is, as I was explaining, as existing in the way that appears to exist. And Geshe-la was explaining the two again, the same kindness, against this puffed mind, puffed up mind, which then engages, then enters this aspect of loftiness. Loftiness?

Is that correct? Loftiness? High. Think of oneself as being higher, more important. I think, you know, I am the one and such.

Geshe is explaining in of pride, pride, this arrogance. I mean, one does not need to have, to really actually have great qualities in order to be proud or arrogant. It can arise in relationship to once having big qualities or great qualities, or small qualities, or even having no actual qualities whatsoever. So whilst holding on to that conception of a truly existent I, one truly exists, one thinks in whatever way, in relationship to actual qualities, big or small or to no actual qualities, even though one does not have any qualities, one still thinks that one is better than another, that one is more than another, that one has more qualities or better qualities or greater qualities than another, that, you know, I am healthy and strong, and he is not healthy and strong, I’m better than he is, and so on and so on. So that is this puffed up mind that thinks in this way.

Then, the next affliction is ignorance. Ignorance is an afflicted non knowing due to an unclear mind with regards to the nature of the four truths, actions and the results, and the Three Jewels. So, again, Geshe-la is just explaining this word marigpa, which is just a is a mind that does not cannot does not correctly see the actual way that something exists, something abides, something exists. So, it is Maripa is this, again, this not knowing, this lack of knowledge about the exists correct way that something exists. So again, marigpa, this ignorance, is mi shes pa, which is not knowing.

This is not knowing. And Geshe-la wasn’t saying, no, we look at ourselves, and we think that we actually do know ourselves. We know who we are, what we are, the qualities that we have, and so forth. We do think so. I guess I was gonna say, but we don’t actually know.

Again, Geshe-la was saying, the same applies, the same not knowing that we have applies in relationship to the four truths, you know, the true sufferings, true origins, true cessation, and true path. We think that we know, but we don’t actually know them. Again, the same to actions of the results and the Three Jewels. And even though Geshe-la was saying, we observe, or we might have them as objects of our observation, we observe them, you know, the Three Jewels, the Buddha, the Dharma, the Sangha, observe, we have the best way to say, in this case, mig pa. Observe, just observe these four truths.

But we don’t actually correctly or precisely know them. We don’t perfectly know them. So, again, and then this not correctly or precisely knowing the way that they exist, this mental factor of ignorance. Have this food that we eat and the objects that we use daily in our lives. Use them.

We know how to use them. We know how they taste and so on. We know so many things about them, but we do not know the actual way that they exist. We do not see see the actual way that those things exist in the tshul bzhin, the correct way that they exist. And by and this not knowing of the in which way that they exist is this ignorance, this mental factor of ignorance.

The next topic then is doubt. Doubt, through observing those three objects, again, the four truths, actions and the results, and the Three Jewels, then do they exist, or do they not exist? Are they, or are they not? And in English language, I just explaining, so again, we have ignorance, then, independent of that ignorance, then this doubt arises, because we do not know the way that they exist. We do not fully realize them, then again, doubt arises.

And again, briefly, again, putting in another way, in a more local way, again, we think with regards to the four truths, we think again, do they really exist? Is that actually the case? Or are they not? Or with regards to action and the results, again, is that really the case? Is that really so or not?

And so, by the power of the ignorance that we have, then again, doubt arises. This sort of doubt arises. And then again, next affliction in the view of the transitory collection, the view is an afflicted wisdom that observing the appropriate aggregates, views them as self, or of the self thinking I or mine. Goes on through the text again. Here, transitory means impermanent, and collection means many.

Many, therefore, the base that it views is a mere, impermanent and manifold phenomenon. Then, in order to indicate there is no permanent unitary person, it is given the name view of the transitory collection. Then the next affliction then is the view holding to an extreme. The view holding to an extreme is an afflicted wisdom, or an afflicted discernment that observing that self apprehended by the view of the transitory collection, views it to be permanent and eternal, or views it to cease without joining this existence to a future one. And so, the next one, the view holding to a bad view as supreme, as best.

Then again, the view holding to a bad view as supreme is an afflicted wisdom that observing any of the three, the view of the transitory collection, the view holding to an extreme or a wrong view, and the aggregates of the person holding the view that arises, and dependence on any of them, holds them to be the best. So, again, Geshe-la was saying, so it’s a view that thinks that the view of the transitory collection is correct, is a correct view, is a good view, or the view that sees, again, that holding to an extreme, the extreme of existence or annihilation, and thinks that that is correct, that is supreme, that is best, and so on. And Geshe-la is just saying that with regards to this holding to a bad view as supreme, Geshe-la is saying that that most likely only occurs to people who lend their minds, who think, who ponder on these things, who ponder about eternalism, nihilism, and such things. For people who do not investigate such topics, this wrong view probably does not occur. Is that making sense?

Is that right? This And then again, the next one, the view holding to a bad ethical discipline and ascetic practice as supreme. The view holding to a bad ethical discipline and ascetic practice as best, as supreme, is an afflicted wisdom that observing an ethical discipline of giving up immortality. Immorality, sorry. Giving up immorality.

Thank you for that. An ascetic practice that sets a dress code, manners and bodily and verbal behavior as definite, the aggregates that arise in dependence on either of them, and views them as purifying negativities, as liberating from mental afflictions, as definitely releasing one from cyclic existence. And Geshe-la was just going for some of those practices, and also the twists, and the piercings, and the burnings, and all these different things that people do with this belief, disbeliefs that will purify from negativities, liberate from mental afflictions, and liberate one from cyclic existence altogether. Then, the last one, wrong view. A wrong view is an afflicted wisdom that deprecates that past and future lives, actions and their effects, and the like do not exist, or superimposes the concept of Īśvara, a primal substance, a primal substance, etc, as the cause of migrating beings.

These are how the mental afflictions are identified from the common perspective of the higher and lower systems. The Prasangika Madhyamaka system will be explained below. So, again, Geshe-la is just explaining all these ten afflictions that have been explained, are accepted by all the other tenet systems. Again, Vaibhāṣika, Sautrāntika, mind only, the autonomous middle way, and so on. English language is explaining, so again, even though there are these general similarities, there are differences in subtleties, in the definition or the understanding of each one of those.

For example, in case of the very root of all these afflictions, which is ignorance itself, there is a difference in subtlety in the way that they explain this ignorance, this ignorance which is the root of all the afflictions. So there are differences in subtlety. How they understand them. So guess I just explained that the lower schools of tenets from the autonomous middle way and below, they all posit coarse and subtle selflessness. But they all, in the case of the selflessness of the person, even though there are some sort of differences, which I will explain, there is general understanding that the selflessness of the person is defined as the unitary self sufficient Say say again?

Self sufficient. So you you unitary self sufficient, substantially existent self. Is that right? Self sufficient, existent. Unitary self sufficient, existent.

Self. That’s the self of the person. So this the view that holds on in the to this unitary self sufficient, substantial existent self, in dependence on the what they all assert in common, independence this view, all these ten afflictions arise. So I guess I was just making this distinction. So for the middle way consequential, conception of the self is of an inherently existent self.

For the other schools, is this independent self sufficient, self sufficient self, and in dependence on holding on to this view, on apprehending this view of substantially independent, self sufficient, substantially existent self, then all these ten afflictions So, again, so they’re going to say the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka system will be explained below, but again, the main thing, the general general idea being that these afflictions then arise in dependence on the apprehension of inherent existence self, which is the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka understanding of it. And then but generally, there is this difference in subtlety in in the understanding of the four truths and so on. So again, Geshe-la, I just explained there is this difference in subtlety in the understanding of the four truths, the true origins, and so on. So some will explain, dependence on the understanding of the misconception or the perception of a unitary, self sufficient, substantially existent self, while others, also more subtle understandings, say that the true origins, and of this explanation of the four noble truths, of the four truths, and again, arise in dependence on the misconception of an inherent existence, self. So there is a difference in the uncertainty in regards to the cause of what they explain as the cause of this vulnerable truth, of the true origins, of these afflictions.

Is that making sense? Is that right? I am mixing them. Sorry? He didn’t say.

He didn’t say. Self sufficient, substantial existent Okay. Yes. It didn’t say cheap. Self sufficient, substantial existence.

So and and and which is the the lower tenet schools and the other, the the inherent existence. So And Geshe-la was explaining, even though there are these differences in subtlety in the understandings of the four noble truths, the sixteen aspects of the four noble truths. But Geshe-la was not saying, even though there are those differences, there is debate with regards to their being an actual difference in their understanding, their explanation of the aspect of impermanence of the truth, the truth of suffering, the true sufferings, which would have impermanence, suffering, emptiness, and no self. You have these four aspects regarding the true sufferings. Because I wasn’t saying that there is a debate, there’s a question with regards to their being different in understanding of this aspect of impermanence in the momentary change of phenomena, moment by moment, their understanding of that.

Geshe-la was saying that generally, there is a difference in there is a so called coarse impermanence, which is then, you know, that an object changing or ceasing to be or being destroyed or dying and so forth, if phenomenal. And there is the subtle impermanence, which is momentary change. But in the case of this aspect of the true sufferings, which is impermanence, makes makes reference to this only to this subtle impermanence. And there is debate whether there is a difference in subtlety between the schools in the understanding of the different tenet systems with regards to this subtle impermanence. So, the next topic, which is then the stages by which the mental afflictions arise, has again has three parts.

The first one being the system of the treatise on the levels asserts that the view of the transitory collection and ignorance are in opposition to each other. Are not the same. Again, making and Geshe-la is just going through the text. Again, if the if the view of the transitory collection and ignorance are asserted to be different, the status by which the mental afflictions arise must be understood in the following manner. For instance, with regards to a coil rope, once darkness has fallen to some extent, if the mode of abidance of the rope is not clear, a mind apprehending a snake arises.

Likewise, through the darkness of ignorance obscuring the clear mode of abidance of aggregates mistakenly arise as a self, and from that, the other mental afflictions arise. Again, Geshe lah, just explain that this the way that happened is that by not being able to see clearly, because it is dark, again, one might conceive of the rope as being a snake. And the same way, so when the mind is obscured by ignorance, again, one might conceive of the transitory collection of the aggregates as being the I, as one might perceive it as being the I, and then in dependence on that I that arises in this way, then again, the afflictions follow from that attachment and aversion, so on. And then Geshe-la goes for the second topic: The system of the Sautrantikas and Vaibhāṣikas assert that the view of the transitory collection itself is ignorance. If those two are asserted to be the same, the view of the transitory collection itself is the root of the mental afflictions.

So Geshe-la wants to stop here today. Tag. Tag again. Oh, yeah. Did you understand the view of the transitory collection?

Did you understand that? As for the view of the transitory collection? So I just joking and said that they probably didn’t understand. So I I wasn’t saying yes, didn’t understand because all these wrong views, all these views, we all have them. We are all sort of possessed by them.

So that’s why we don’t we don’t understand them. We cannot see. So we all have attachment, anger, pride, and so on. We all have this afflictions. But we don’t recognize them.

We still think that they are good, and all that. And they are, you know, the main, you know, fundamental reason they are bad is because they arise in dependence on these wrong views, the view of the transitory collection. Again, because of this, because we are all obscured by this ignorance, which is the view of the transitory collection, because we cannot see the way that things exist, actually. Again, these afflictions arise, attachment and anger, the pride, and so on arise. And so Geshe-la was saying, the whole point being that all these afflictions, all these afflictions that we have been going through, they arise in dependence on this view of transitory collection.

Then I ask, what is this view of the transitory collection? And as we have seen in the text, I was just going through the definition again. It is an afflicted wisdom that, whilst observing the the aggregates, views them as a self, or of the self, was thinking I or mine. Again, it’s a view that holds on to this inherent existent self whilst in dependence on the observing the appropriate appropriate aggregates, the aggregates. So Geshe-la was just saying it is it is this mind, is this wisdom, this discerning awareness, this afflicted discerning awareness, this afflicted wisdom that then conceives of the I, thinks of things I.

And Geshe-la was saying, it’s very hard to identify this so called view of the transitory collection. So Geshe-la was in Tibetan, and Geshe-la says, is the first person pronoun I. So when this when the I, it comes about in our being very strongly, this this this sense of I, and that is the self grasping, the self grasping mind. In dependence on the self grasping mind, there is a discerning awareness, so to speak, which is what they refer as which is the same word for wisdom, but they said they called it an afflicted wisdom, which is an afflicted wisdom. And Geshe-la was explaining that’s not an actual wisdom.

But it is, it has a quality, it’s similar to wisdom in that it is exercising an analysis, a discernment, you know, is looking into that I and thinking, oh, is it good or bad? And I want this, I want that, I need this, I need that, and so on. So it is it is sort of a an afflicted discerning awareness. That’s how I translate it. So that makes more sense.

And guess I wasn’t saying, and that is this view of the transitory collection, this afflicted wisdom, this afflicted discerning awareness. And it’s very hard to identify that, to see that. All What’s the question? To meditate on emptiness or to meditate on selflessness or just emptiness in general. Is that what you mean?

Or to meditate on No. No. So when you take that calm abiding meditation, that peaceful state, and you want to know if that is a good opportunity to meditate on emptiness, or if there is a better opportunity other than that. Is that what you mean? So, yes, in circumstances it beneficial to then you know, having attained to this relative stability or calm.

And again, it is definitely beneficial to contemplate emptiness or to contemplate So, again, Geshe-la was gonna say, yes. It is good. It is good to, you know, if you want to contemplate emptiness, contemplating then that phenomena does not exist in the way it appears to exist. And in a situation like that, you know, it is becomes easier to then leave that imprint, that impression on the mind. And, again, also, it is very beneficial to give rise to bodhicitta, contemplate, you know, develop your cultivate your intention to attain enlightenment for the sake of all beings also very good.

Is that alright? What? I’m not sure what you mean to say. Do you mean to say that if I have meditated and I am peaceful and calm, do I still perceive myself to exist inherently? Is that what you mean?

Or do I or because I am calm, I am seeing myself to exist less inherently than I would otherwise. No. You’re still as deluded as ever. Is is that is that what you mean? So so so then let me see if how how would I put that in in Tibetan?

So if can I put that in Tibetan, Is it? Okay. Yes. Of course. The answer then will be no, basically.

Shortcut to all of the things. No. The only thing that can harm this self grasping in any way is the wisdom that realizes emptiness. Is the wisdom that realizes emptiness? So, again, this state of mind you know, of calm abiding, or something similar to it, doesn’t affect the intensity or the quality of the self grasping in any way.

And what Geshe-la was saying, the only thing that can affect hurt in any way is this wisdom to realize that. And Geshe-la was quoting then this verse from Āryadeva. The first two lines of the verse are saying that, you know, people with little merit do not think about it. Right? Do not people little merit do not think about it.

And just merely having doubts about it is enough to shake the foundation of cyclic existence. So, the whole point being that mere developing, having doubt with regards to emptiness is enough to then start harming the self grasping. So you were going to say something? No, developing doubt in the sense of does the emptiness exist or not? Is the emptiness actually true or not?

So we are starting to develop this understanding. You know those those I forgot. You know, when you started studying the subject and you had developed doubts about it, then you develop the correct assumption and so on and so on. So when you get to that stage yes. Yes.

That’s what is being referred to. And Geshe-la was then saying, now with regards to the calm abiding, what it what such a state would harm is not the conception of, you know, it’s not the self grasping. What it does harm is laxity and excitement. That’s what calm abiding harms. That’s what calm abiding is there to remedy.

And again, Geshe-la was saying, so again, excitement is the mind that scatters towards sensory objects. It’s the mind related to attachment, to craving, and so forth. And again, laxity is a mind that sinks, gets too relaxed, too lax. And again, so this calm abiding meditation remedies these two situations, these two things. Yeah, no.

Neither and none of us, I guess. It does have you of living in the inherent existence. So does that have an origin? Or does that itself arise innately or something? So, yes, innate conception.

So Geshe was saying, yes, it has a cause, and the cause is, you know, the previous moments of the self grasping. Then Jampa was asking, so when did it begin? When did it all begin? Geshe-la was saying, it began in the very beginning, from the very moment that the person arose, then the grasping at the self of the person also came about. That more or less what?

Came with the being, translated as innate, isn’t it? Yes. It has existed for as long as the person has existed, as the being has existed. human form, or is it in the sense in which it begins with the mind and beginning with time? Is it associated with being having a precious human form?

Maybe innate is not the best translation, however? So what what I’m not thinking very clearly today, but what what Geshe was saying, was asking what this word that is It literally means simultaneously generated. So when the person arises, when the I arises, then this self grasping arises. Whenever there is no beginning to it. There is a and Geshe-la was saying, whenever a person arises, comes into existence, then that self grasping also comes together with it.

Geshe-la was saying, correcting himself, not person, but sentient being. And that answers the question. Even though even though it is beginningless, there is an end. So, when one attains to the state of foe destroyers, that’s the end of it. But to attain to that stage is very difficult.

Is that all right? Does that answer your question? Yes. All right. Any So, there is no causal relationship, mean, Geshe-la says there is no causal relationship between one and the other, but Geshe-la says, still, the realization of this impermanence is a coarser realization, and the realization of the lack of inherent existence of phenomena is subtler.

So Geshe-la was saying, one would realize this impermanence before it would come before one realizes emptiness. Sort of one of the pit stops. But there is no cause of relationship. There’s also a thing as the realization of impermanence, and such impermanence being the cause of the realization of So one has to realize there is a certain impermanence before one can realize emptiness. But would that wisdom that realizes impermanence harm self grasping?

No, it would not. Okay? So, again, Geshe-la was not saying, because there is this because one must what one can say is that coarse impermanence is helpful towards realizing emptiness, because one has to realize that coarse impermanence beforehand anyway. But, again, will that realization of coarse impermanence harm the conception of true existence? You know, that self grasping the conception of true existence?

No, it will not in any way harm that conception of true existence. What will harm the conception of true existence? That conception of true existence will begin to be harmed when one starts to generate doubts with regards to the lack of true existence. All right? And that’s when that conception of true existence starts to be harmed.

Is that all right? Is that okay? Appear in the I’m dizzy already. Yes, mind. I lost you right in the beginning.

Can you make it shorter, briefer? Because my attention span is very short in there. When we try to negate the I, our own. I think that’s that’s the and investigation, we come to a conclusion that I do not exist as I hold myself. So gradual, I’ll get rid of the intensity of the grasping of myself.

And then when I get out of the get out of the meditation session and I see something or I feel something, and I how can I apply the conclusion that I have during the meditation session to the feeling that I have towards, say, for example, a specific person? And towards that, I’ll be able to have the simultaneous appearance of the ultimate truth and the conventional truth. That’s the question. Yes. When do you realize ultimate and conventional truth at the same time?

Yeah. On they’ll appear not not through the negation of the inherent existence, and then I say, oh, the the the the real the true existence of the the object. Realizing that the object is inherent. Yeah. I Yes.

That’s a good point. And So when do you realize simultaneously? Is that what you mean? Actually, with this last part, can you help me with this last part? But what Geshe was saying is that there’s no such thing as basically, the of that you chose is not the word that we would technically use.

So in order to realize ultimate reality, not to realize ultimate reality, first, you by engaging in the proper studies of analytical meditation, you start developing doubts, and then furthermore, you go on by proceeding with your investigations, your analytical meditation, then you get to the point where you can develop the meaning generality, or the general conceptual image of it, and dependence on that you can develop the inferential cognition. And then again, in the inferential cognition, if you proceed with your meditations and teachings and meditations and meditations and meditations, then you develop a direct realization of it. And that’s how we explain this process. Then, when so this is the process of realizing then ultimate truth, ultimate reality. And Geshe-la was explaining the relative truth.

Can you get any any? Geshe-la was explaining the etymology of the word, we translate as relative reality. But it’s not a very good translation. Truth for a concealer. That which is truth for an obscuring mind.

That which is truth for a mind that has not realized the emptiness, that has not realized the ultimate. Okay? Yeah. That’s it. This one.

Is that okay? Not this Yeah. Sure. Sure. Okay.

Key terms in this teaching

conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
three types of suffering dug ngäl sum (Tib)
The suffering of suffering, the suffering of change and pervasive compounding suffering. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Is the peaceful state reached in calm abiding meditation a good time to meditate on emptiness, or is there a better opportunity?

Yes, once some relative stability or calm has been attained, it is definitely beneficial to contemplate emptiness. This means contemplating that phenomena do not exist in the way they appear to exist. In a situation like that it becomes easier to leave an imprint, or impression, on the mind. It is also very beneficial in that state to give rise to bodhicitta, cultivating the intention to attain enlightenment for the sake of all beings. This is also very good.

Scroll to Top