44 min · 2,759 words · 1 April 2003 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 44-minute talk, Geshe Pema Tsering opens with a candid challenge: most practitioners aspire to bodhisattvahood without having turned their minds away from samsaric pleasures. He introduces the practice of mixing one’s merit with the merit of all Buddhas and Bodhisattvas before sitting, illustrated by a story of two Tibetan pilgrims combining their tsampa so even inferior grain lasts to the very bottom. The doctrinal core unpacks the Heart Sūtra verse “in emptiness there is no form” as describing meditative equipoise on the path of meditation — the fourth of five Mahāyāna paths — and walks through the categories absent in that state: the five aggregates, twelve sources, and eighteen elements. A Q&A closes by addressing how self-grasping gives rise to pride and anger, and how to locate and refute the arising sense of self.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 22 HS 2003 04 01.mp3
UUID: c67c5ab8-f8ae-4713-a615-c47aaf2f12a0
Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering
Collection: Heart Sūtra (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Date: 2003-04-01
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 44.8 minutes
Words: ~2,785
But from amongst these three types of beings, most of us kind of think that usually kind of think that, you know, a bodhisattva is, you know, the best one, that bodhicitta is where it’s happening, or bodhicitta is where the great bliss comes in and everything, so that’s the one we’re after. So we have this idea, yeah, I’m going to be a but we don’t realize that being a Bodhisattva actually starts with developing renunciation, and it starts with understanding suffering and understanding that anything that we have in Samsāra is is actually suffering, and we don’t want anything to do with it. We have to do that, and then we have to develop bodhicitta in order to benefit all sentient beings. So we have this big idea about becoming a Bodhisattva, but if we were to ask, so how many of you actually can see the shortcomings of saṃsāra? How many of you actually can turn your mind away from the pleasures of saṃsāra?
Then most people would have a bit of trouble doing it. So we have these doubts that we’re trying to deal with, that we were talking about before, and then if we’re not dealing with those doubts and developing firm faith and not practicing listening, contemplating and meditating, then it just seems a lot easier to go for the same samsaric pleasures. They’re just there, you don’t have to work that hard to get them, and we have this habit since beginningless time, so why not just go for it? Not yet,, and even if we’re going to push it a little bit and try and do something virtuous and work towards enlightenment, then it usually lasts about fifteen minutes. But we still have this idea about becoming the Bodhisattva, and we still have this idea about all the happiness and the bliss that comes about with being a Bodhisattva, so we should really treasure that. That’s a good thing, even if it is a weak idea, and even if we have doubts of that, it’s a really good thing that we have the idea.
So we should take this idea, take this motivation that we have, and we should be thinking by studying the Heart Sūtra, by doing all the practices that I’ve done, may the merit from these practices and this studying be combined with the merit of all the five different types of beings, that is Buddhas and arhats and Bodhisattvas, etc, and all their merits may be placed together, and in dependence on that merit may I quickly, quickly attain enlightenment, so I can be of the best benefit to all sentient beings. With this thought in mind, we should try and meditate. So if we’re thinking about this, if we’re thinking by rejoicing and appreciating the merit that all the different types of beings have had, then that makes our meditation incredibly powerful, we should try and remember this, because the merit of one Buddha is so immense that if we try to compare it to our merit, ours would be like a drop compared to an ocean. So we’re meditating on the merit of all the Buddhas and all the Bodhisattvas, it becomes if we’re sorry, if we’re depending on the merit of all the Buddhas and all the Bodhisattvas, then that becomes an immense or very, very meaningful thought in our mind before we start meditating.
Okay. So if we start mixing our our merit with the merit of the Buddhas, it’s like when there was these two guys walking to Lhasa from Kham, which is in eastern Tibet, and they were going to the capital, One of them had really bad tsampa, which is Tibetan ground barley. It all had husks in it, and it wasn’t very pure. His friend had heaps of really good tsampa, and it was really pure and everything. Because they were friends and they didn’t want to carry two separate bundles, they actually put their tsampa together.
The guy that didn’t have very much was eating the same tsampa as the guy that had a lot and had good tsampa. After a few days, then the guy with the lot of tsampa said, well, you know, your tsampa must have run out by now. You didn’t have that much. And he goes, no. No.
Look. There’s like some of the husks of my tsampa right down the bottom. We have to eat all the way down to the bottom before I finish my tsampa. So it it’s the same if we if we mix our merit with the merit of the Buddha’s, then it lasts all the way to the bottom. Yeah.
And and that’s the way it happens. So this is the best type of practice we can do in terms of creating merit. If we are thinking about our merit combined with the merit of all the Buddhas and all the Bodhisattvas, and then we are rejoicing in that, and then we are dedicating it by using the dedication of that for us to achieve enlightenment, by saying, by this, may I achieve enlightenment? Then by saying, by this, we’re actually rejoicing in all their merit. So it becomes like a very vast mind for us and of immense benefit to our practices.
So this idea, this idea we’re trying to get into our minds that may I achieve enlightenment for the benefit of all sentient beings by relying on the merit of all these five types of beings and rejoicing in that merit. This idea is something that we should meditate on, but not just now. We should do it every time that we’re meditating, every time that we’re especially doing some kind of placement meditation, then we should try and have this thought to start off with, because that makes our meditations and teachings and teachings incredibly much more powerful. If we’re doing analytical meditation, we kind of have to follow the path of analytical meditation, but in terms of doing a contemplative meditation sorry, a placement meditation, we really should try and get this mind in our mind stream before we practice it, this thought in our mind stream before we practice it. And so with this thought in mind,
No. Okay. So we’re going through the disc the Heart Sūtra, and we’re up to the part of the Heart Sūtra where it says, therefore, Sharaputra, in emptiness, there is no form. Yeah, does that say therefore, in emptiness there is no form. Yeah, that is where the explanation of the path of meditation starts.
So the the Heart Sūtra actually goes through the path of preparation, the path of seeing, and now we’re onto the path of meditation. Okay. So on the So it doesn’t actually talk about the path of accumulation, which is the first of the five paths. The reason that it doesn’t talk about it in the Heart Sūtra is because on the path of accumulation, most bodhisattvas actually spend most of their effort on developing the wisdom of hearing or the wisdom of study. So what they do on the path of accumulation is go around and get teachings and find texts and study as much as they can on emptiness and other topics.
And so on the path of preparation, what’s usually usually the main focus is the wisdom arising from contemplation. So, on the path of accumulation and the path of preparation, then emptiness is not seen directly. On the path of accumulation, emptiness is learnt about, emptiness and is thoroughly studied, then out of that comes the wisdom of hearing, or the wisdom of study. And then on the path of preparation, we get an inferential cognizer of emptiness, which isn’t seeing it directly, but is seeing it depending on a sign, like smoke on a pass is a sign that there’s fire. And that is called the wisdom of contemplation, so that’s when things are contemplated over and over again, they develop this understanding.
So on the paths of accumulation and preparation, we have a general image of emptiness, which isn’t realizing it directly. Then on the path of seeing, in the path of meditation, there is a direct realization of emptiness, and on these two paths the wisdom arising from meditation is cultivated. So we’ve already talked about the path of preparation and the path of seeing, and today we are talking about the path of meditation. So there there’s a bit of discrepancy between several commentaries on this part of the Heart Sūtra, the oral tradition of Atisha and a commentary by someone called Vilamitra, they both state that at this stage it should say something like, therefore at that time in emptiness there is no form. It says here, therefore, in emptiness there is no form.
And they say, as opposed to that, that it should be, thus emptiness is not form. That makes sense. Oh, yeah. Said, it’s so hard. Emptiness is just so hard.
So according to this scholar called Jamyang Gawe Lodro and he was in accordance with Vilamitra as well. They both say that what this is actually explaining, the part where it says therefore, Śāriputra, in emptiness, there is no form, feeling, etc, is what they’re talking about is the meditative equipoise that is experienced on the path of meditation. So when people are in meditative equipoise focusing on emptiness at the stage of the path of meditation, they, for example, don’t see form. So what this means according to Vilamitra in his commentary is that if you’re seeing or perceiving emptiness directly and correctly, then you don’t see the form at this stage as well. That is something that is experienced afterwards.
So in the Meditative Equipoise directly perceiving emptiness, there is no form, what was it? And none of the rest of the five aggregates. So no form, feeling, no recognition, no karmic formations and consciousness. So there’s also the next bit where it says there are there’s no eye, no ear, no nose, no tongue, no body, no mind. There are no spheres of the eyes, up to no spheres of the mind.
There are none of these all the way up to the spheres of mental consciousness. Section there is actually referring to what are called the twelve sources. Was it twelve? Did I say too many? Yeah.
I think I did say too many. Sorry. Because it’s a different translation to the one I’ve got. So therefore, there’s no form, no feeling. That’s about the five aggregates, right?
And then the next bit where it’s, there’s no eye, no ear, no nose, no tongue, no body, no mind, no form, no sound, no smell, no taste, no tactile object, no phenomena. That’s what’s referred to as the twelve sources, and the literal translation of the word that’s usually translated as sources from Tibetan would be like the coming and the going, so therefore it’s the things that come towards us, the smell, the sounds, the tastes, and the eyes, the consciousnesses that actually perceive those. So it’s the combination of those two. Okay. So for every one of the five senses and the mental sense, there is the one side therefore like the eye, and then the thing that it perceives which is form.
So there’s no eye, there’s no form, there’s no ear, there’s no sound, there’s no nose, there’s no smell, there’s no tongue, there’s no taste, there’s no body, there’s no tactile object, there’s no mind, and there’s no phenomenon. These aren’t experienced. Wow. Okay, so right. The next thing where it says there is no eye element and so forth up to no mind element and also up to no element of mental consciousness, what this is referring to is what’s called the non appearance of the eighteen elements.
The eighteen elements are referred to as the six consciousnesses, as well as the six bases of consciousness, that is the power to see, the power to hear, the power to taste, etc, and the six consciousnesses. Did I say something? Consciousnesses and power and the objects that are perceived. So, there’s three for each six, which adds up to eighteen.
So does everybody have questions? So thing that we should remember about the eighteen elements is that there’s six elements of objects, right? There’s elements of the six objects of the six consciousnesses, then the basis for those which is the power to be able to see, etc, and then the six consciousnesses themselves, and that’s the eighteen. Okay. So the objects.
Okay. Right. Okay. So the other the six bases aren’t actually the power, Sorry. The six bases are what the different powers are made up of, which are the six elements.
Which is earth, fire, no, let’s start at the beginning. Earth, water, fire, air, ether and mental consciousness. So those six are what’s called the six bases. So they’re not defined by the separate powers of the different consciousnesses, but what they can be made up of. And then these aren’t seen when people are in meditative equipoise on emptiness. Okay.
So after you’ve abandoned the nine things to be abandoned on the path of meditation, you enter the path of no more learning, which is Buddha, Buddhahood, if it’s a Mahāyāna path. So the path of no more learning of the Mahāyāna path is complete Buddhahood. And this cannot be achieved according to the sutras in a human body. It must be in the highest level of saṃsāra, formless. He said, don’t you wanna go there?
He’s like, you’ve got a problem with going to the what’s it called, the highest place or whatever it is. Yeah. There’s three of you. Yeah. I don’t know.
I don’t know. Okay. Okay. You can’t actually perceive Self directly because it doesn’t exist. So then by trying to find it is how you perceive that it doesn’t exist.
Uh-huh. He said lots of time when that is actually happening, not so much self grasping as on top of self grasping pride and like thinking that you’re quite alright, thank you very much, and how dare they insult you. So it’s more like pride that’s happening there instead of self grasping. He said from self grasping comes pride, from pride comes anger, usually if people have insulted us. So there’s this whole process going on.
So, what is actually happening is you identify this feeling of self, grasping itself there when you feel that self coming up. Then you have to realize that that Self doesn’t actually exist, so the process is to go, Hang on a second, that doesn’t exist. But that’s when you can actually feel it, when those situations come about, and that’s the thing that doesn’t actually exist. So it’s not that you have to define it in order to refute it because you can’t define it because it doesn’t exist. So what the process is you go, okay, I’m not liking this self at the moment.
There’s this pride happening here. What is the base of this pride? And then you go looking for it. And there’s no way you can find it. There’s no way you can find that self.
So when there’s no self there, then there’s no point of self grasping. There’s no point at self pride. Yep. Yes. Oh, great.
Yes. I have no idea. Okay. I was thinking, phew. Yeah, yeah.
I was a bit confused. I was like, what are you talking about? Okay. Okay, right. So there’s the six consciousnesses here, and then there’s the six powers, right?
This was getting confused. The six powers as in the power of sight, the faculty of sight, faculty of hearing, the faculty of taste, the faculty of smell, the faculty of touch, and the faculty, the mental faculty. Right? And then in the objects, there is the five elements in the object section. There’s the five elements and phenomenon.
That’s that’s eighteen. Yeah? No. No. No.
Because it’s got there’s also mental consciousness, which is In the phenomena one, there’s everything. He said everything. There’s lots of different things, not just form. So anything that isn’t in the other elements is in is in the the phenomenon in one. Yeah.
So all phenomena have to fit into these eighteen. So anything that doesn’t fit into the six consciousnesses, the six faculties, and the five elements goes into the phenomena, whatever it’s called, phenomena what?
Key terms in this teaching
- analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
- Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
- The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
- The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.