Heart Sutra — 2003-02-14

44 min · 2,818 words · 14 February 2003 · Buddha House Adelaide

Heart Sutra (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Heart Sutra (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Heart Sutra — 2003-02-14
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. A coffee cup becomes the central teaching prop as Geshe Pema Tsering draws a sharp contrast between Cittamātra and Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika views on emptiness in this 45-minute Q&A session. He opens by clarifying Ānanda’s status — hearer-vehicle practitioner according to the texts, though possibly a hidden bodhisattva or Buddha — before mapping a hierarchy of emptiness realizations: selflessness of persons, non-separateness of subject and object, and the emptiness of all phenomena. The cup illustrates the Cittamātra position: cup and consciousness arise from the same mental imprint and share one substance. Prāsaṇgika goes further — nothing comes from the cup’s own side at all; it exists only through labeling. He dwells on why this last step is so resistant to understanding: as long as we perceive everything as truly established, the concept of mere labeling remains conceptually out of reach. Suited to students already familiar with Buddhist philosophical schools.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 08 HS 2003 02 14.mp3

UUID: c35ddbc2-969c-47df-a939-5833ad8eb3b5

Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering

Collection: Heart Sūtra (Geshe Pema Tsering)

Date: 2003-02-14

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 44.9 minutes

Words: ~2,817

Right. Technically, in terms of what they’re talking about in the hang on a second. I have to clarify something because that just was really contradictory. I’ll do it now. Right.

So, according to the texts, Ānanda was a Hinayanist who had not developed bodhicitta and was a follower of the was a hearer of the hearer vehicle and his main focus of meditation was the selflessness of persons. So even though he showed compassion, he wasn’t of the higher vehicle. That’s from what the texts say. What he actually was as a being we can’t say. There’s some people in the Tantras that say that he was a Buddha.

There’s other people that say he wasn’t a Buddha, he was Bodhisattva, who was manifesting as a hearer, so what he actually was we don’t know, but according to the texts he was a Hinayanist a hearer of the hearer vehicle. But those same Yeah, so like the perfection of wisdom sutras, they talk about Buddha being born as a Buddha. And so Buddha Śākyamūni being born as a Buddha when he was born, and this yeah. The Ānanda was from the was of the lower vehicle. But whether he was or not is open for debate in several Tantric texts.

But then there’s some people that say he was a Buddha, some people say he wasn’t a Buddha, and but because we can’t see. We don’t know. But then most of the lower schools say when Buddha first came to earth he was a human, just a and not even a an ārya. He was a not an ordinary human being. The the lower schools say.

No. Not those sort of texts. The lower schools. Yeah. He said the purpose of such debates is that when you have debates, have some kind of doubt that you have to get sorted out.

So what happens when you have a doubt is that you do more study and you try and understand things better. So if you don’t have doubts and you don’t have things that you need to sort out, don’t do any study, and you don’t progress anywhere, so the doubts are very important. I understand that in relation to things that one can resolve with, but with something like this, you can’t, because you can’t. Yeah, okay. Okay.

So he said he agrees with you. There’s no Scary. What’s up with that? Oh, it’s fine. All three of them?

The answer was that he doesn’t think they’re actually arguing back and forth about whether he was a Buddha or not. It’s just that they put different arguments forward. So when they say that there’s different arguments, it doesn’t mean that they’re arguing with each other, it’s just that they’re presenting different arguments. Different cases. Play with words.

Yeah, no, that’s fine. Yeah, because you still have a continuum when you’re dreaming, so But if you kill someone in your dream, it’s not the same as killing someone in reality. It’s not the same. You don’t get, like, the the karma of killing someone from killing someone in your dream. But the you get the imprints from the the process that comes about through the dream.

But the because the Sangha, the ultimate Sangha is the Aryas only. Okay. Okay, so the definition of a solitary realizer is someone that depend this main object of meditation is the non separateness of subject and object. Alright, so that’s the definition. So it isn’t necessarily someone that doesn’t have a teacher or someone that doesn’t have Sangha around them.

What there’s two types of solitary realizers. There are those that are Aryas and those that aren’t Aryas. And the ordinary solitary realizers rely on a teacher and have Sangha around them. And when they become an Ārya, they are actually Sangha themselves. So therefore that is how they have the realization by relying on themselves and that’s why they’re called solitary realizers.

No. Reason why they’re called they’re called no. The definition of a solitary realizer The definition of a solitary realizer is someone whose main object of meditation is the non separateness of subject and object. Up until the point where they realize the non separateness of subject and object, that’s like they see emptiness and become an Ārya, they rely on other Sangha and on teachers. Once they become an Ārya, solitary realizer, they are Sangha themselves, so they’re still relying on Sangha, they’re relying on themselves and that’s why they’re called solitary realizers.

There’s something else I forgot to say before is that at the time of Śākyamūni Buddha there was lots of solitary realizers that were learning from Śākyamūni Buddha and then went away and meditated and meditating by themselves is how they yeah. So it’s not Our hearts. We Another thing Geshe-la just said after the thing about Buddha Yeah. Was that no. I’ll ask him again.

So, yeah, no, because there was some at the time of the Buddha, so there was Yeah. And Okay, so there’s this one type of solitary realizer that’s called rhino like solitary realizer because the rhinos hang out by themselves. The only type of solitary realizer that is like a rhino type solitary realizer that you can have is an Ārya. Yeah? Up that point, then they have to have contact with other people.

And he said that it’s possible that there’s solitary realizers in Australia. The the that and there was definitely a lot around the time of the Buddha. So so it’s purely you you you’ve heard the teachings. No, it’s somewhat when they had teachings, were having teachings on this non separation of subject and object. So if someone was a hearer, when they were taking teachings, were taking teachings on the selflessness of the person.

When they were a solitary realizer and they were taking teachings, they were taking teachings on the non separation of subject and object. Describing the same thing? Yes. Synonyms. Synonyms?

You would even go that far. Okay. Okay. So they’re not synonyms. They’re talking about different subtleties of emptiness.

So even for starters, the selflessness of persons, that’s the grossest form of what we’re talking about, and it has a division of two. There is the gross selflessness of the person and the subtle selflessness of the person. Then after that, when you’re talking about the non-separateness of the subject and object, that’s subtler than the selflessness of the person. You mean the selflessness of the person? Hang on.

I’ll finish what he said, otherwise I’ll forget it, and then we’ll ask him. Okay. Then so it goes from the selflessness of the person in the subtle and the gross, and then you go to the non separation of subject and object, and then the final one is the selflessness, emptiness of all phenomena. But then there’s emptiness of self and emptiness of all phenomena that one’s more subtle than the other. They’re different, by the way, because emptiness is the negation of something.

Alright? So the the emptiness the selflessness of the person is the negation of self. Right? It’s the negation the negation of a solid self. Yeah?

The the non separateness of subject and object is the negation of something separating those two. And the the negation this the emptiness of all phenomena is the negation of truly existent phenomena. They work on different levels of subtlety. It’s less subtle to understand the selflessness of a person than it is to understand the selflessness of all phenomena or the emptiness of all phenomena. Yeah?

So that was what you said now. What was your question? Do they work in order? Okay. Yeah, if you don’t understand the selflessness of a person, you can’t understand the non separation of subject and object.

If you haven’t realized the non separation of subject and object, you don’t realize emptiness directly. He said they don’t rely on each other, because when the final your final object of meditation is the selflessness of all phenomena, then the other ones come up about come up. Yeah. Yeah. One that I accident accidentally made up.

Yeah. The autonomous consequentialist school. Yeah. Yeah, he said that’s why they’re divided like that, that’s why they’ve divided them into schools like that. First of all you’re supposed to study the Vaibhāṣika school and then you study the Sautrāntika school and then Cittamātra and Mādhyamika so you can understand them better.

Unless you’re all made up of particles. Okay, I’m getting you to do it slowly so I get it right. Okay, I’m just a bit scared so I’m getting to do little bits at a time. Alright, so this is a cup. We have an arising in the cup.

We have a pramāna, valid cognition, right? Seeing the cup. Yeah? So the way that we see it is that the cup is an object and our consciousness seeing the cup is a subject. Okay, so the way that we see it is that this cup is formed and the consciousness seeing the cup is consciousness, right?

And we see them as being separate, but in actual fact, the cup from an imprint, the cup arising comes from an imprint that was laid in our mind, yeah, and the consciousness arising seeing the cup comes from the same imprint, so they have the same essence. But I gotta get the last piece of the last thing. Okay, so the way we see it isn’t that the consciousness in the cup come from the same imprint and the mind stream that makes them arise. We see them as one is being conscious and one as being physical. Once we can understand that they come from the same imprint and they’re not from a separate source, then we don’t see them as being a separate entity.

We see them as being the one entity. Once we’ve gotten rid of the idea that they’re separate, the mind that arises that they are the same is the non separation of subject and object, that mind. Yeah. But hang on. You’re mixing up your schools.

It’s very possible because I’m trying to Yeah. Yeah. That’s why I was I was trying to figure out how to structure the question. And the kind concept of label Yeah. Is is a Mādhyamika concept.

Right. And this concept we’re talking about is Cittamātra. Okay, so we’re using the mug again. And the one we were talking about before is this understanding that the cup and the consciousness seeing the cup come from the same imprint in the mind stream, right? So they’re not a separate entity.

Arise from the same thing, and they have the same substance. What we’re talking about when we talk about something being merely labeled and labeling something is that our mind labels the cup. It doesn’t come from its own side at all. So what we’re talking about from the from the not being separate is that the mind and the cup come from one one imprint, right? And what we’re talking about with the mind labeling the cup is that the mind it only comes from the mind side that the mind is labeling the cup.

So the cup doesn’t exist from its own side at all and the other one, they both arise and are the same entity, and this one is the mind labeling the cup. So it’s very different. So the idea from the labeling the cup is that if it doesn’t exist from its own side, then we can’t say that it doesn’t exist. The way that exists is because we label it with our mind, with our eye, not with just like a consciousness but with our sight and all of our minds as a cup so that’s coming from the mind’s point of view, it’s the labeling from that side. So it’s difficult to understand that but that’s more difficult to understand than the idea of the cup and the consciousness coming from the same imprint.

Well if you’re understanding it properly, yeah. It depends, I mean, because it’s much more subtle than one about the Because Geshe keeps saying it’s very difficult to try and get the idea of labeling the cup. He said that he thinks it’s much more difficult to understand properly the concept of labeling because what you’re talking about is something that’s coming from one side, So it’s like one side labeling a cup. If you’re trying to so it’s like merely the the consciousness going cup here that makes the cup come into existence and the reason that it does that is because it has to exist in some way right so it stops going from the extreme of nihilism yeah so that’s the cons that’s what’s behind the concept of labeling cup right but when we’re talking about the idea of the cup being one with a consciousness, so the non separation of subject and object, that’s a lot simpler to understand because it comes from one cause and that cause is the imprint. So by, but from the substance of the imprint you get a consciousness and a cup and object arising but their one substance right their one substance is that imprint so that’s a lot because it has one cause and it’s only what two things working in combination it’s a lot simpler to understand in that whole of the mechanism behind the merely labeling of cup That’s what Geshe-la reckons anyway.

Yeah, so I just put forward the idea that perhaps because he’s going that doesn’t make sense, how can you say one’s more difficult? And I was like because you’ve probably studied a lot. So Geshe-la says it’s really hard to try and get the concept of Because it’s really hard to try and get the concept of Mādhyamika, the labeling, because what is Prāsaṇgika? Because it’s actually saying it’s not there the way I think it is. It’s not any way like we see it.

If you see so therefore because none of that’s there, none of the things that we’re ascribing are there, then you have this danger of going to the extreme of nihilism. So it’s nothing like what we see. So it’s because it’s nothing like what we see, it only comes about because of this labeling, because it’s got no relation to what we’re actually seeing, it’s very difficult to understand. The other ones have more relation. So from this side, the side of the object, there’s absolutely nothing coming.

There’s nothing. There’s no base. There’s no nothing. There’s no appearance. So he says like there is no physical, there’s no form, there’s nothing there from its side, right?

So apart us labeling it, there’s nothing. Because we and we see it as being truly established. See, not only do we see it, but we see it as being truly established. He was saying there’s no base, there’s no nothing. Yeah.

There’s nothing there, but it’s not a nonexistent. Existent. And so it’s nothing like what we’re looking at. There’s no no relation to the way that we see it. So every time we see it, we’re seeing it as being truly established.

So we can’t get our heads around what it means to to label it until we get rid of the idea of it being truly established. So you’re saying, but I can see it. It’s saying, I can see it being truly established. So everything we see, we see as being truly established. So he says because we have this concept of of that if if it isn’t there, right, if we can’t see it, if we don’t if it if it doesn’t exist from there, if it’s not truly established, we can’t see it, then we can’t actually understand the concept of labeling because we can’t see anything as being anything but truly established.

If you get if you can’t if it doesn’t exist, you can’t see it. Right? Because we don’t understand that if you don’t exist if something doesn’t exist hang on. I’ll try again. Alright.

Okay. Okay concentrate, right? We think, right, that for something to exist, no, for something not to exist, we have to not see it, right? So therefore, every time we say, but I can see it, we’re seeing it as being truly established therefore we’re not understanding the concept of merely labeling something. Because to merely label something we have to be able to understand the direct emptiness of it in order to merely label something.

This point of view, what is I’m gonna have a sip now. What is that cognition? From which point of view? From the from the merely labeling. Okay.

What’s valid cognition? The Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika point of view? Because this labeling is Prāsaṇgika. Okay.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
merely labeled tag tsam (Tib)
The subtlest meaning of dependent arising; every phenomenon exists relatively, or conventionally, as a mere label, merely imputed by the mind. LYWA
pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
Shravakayana nyen thö kyi thegpa (Tib)
The Hearer Vehicle. One of the branches of the Hinayana. The path of hearers (shravakas), practitioners who strive for liberation from cyclic existence on the basis of listening to teachings from a spiritual guide or teacher. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top