44 min · 2,368 words · 2 May 2002 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The gravest of the eighteen Bodhisattva vow transgressions — abandoning bodhicitta altogether — anchors this 44-minute commentary by Geshe Pema Tsering on Śāntideva’s Bodhisattva Way of Life. He shows why obstructing even a small act of generosity carries heavier karmic weight than killing every being in the world, because a bodhisattva works for the liberation of all. He then introduces the text’s second division — maintaining bodhicitta through the six perfections — and stresses that even offering a single piece of bread with bodhicitta motivation builds vast merit. A Q&A closes the session: when along the five paths bodhicitta becomes stable and unloseable; what exactly constitutes giving up the vow (resolving to seek only personal liberation); and whether anger arising after morning practice cancels its merit. Suited to practitioners familiar with Bodhisattva vows.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 10 Guide 2002 05 02.mp3
UUID: cbb82c3c-0073-4e1a-913c-6113844c4f4b
Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering
Collection: Bodhisattva Way of Life (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Date: 2002-05-02
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 44.3 minutes
Words: ~2,364
Both really contradicts each other and by doing so the explanation here is this is a different case because Śāriputra he was not an ordinary person he has been trained in the previous yeah, trained and the action he has done and the reason why he is not born in the lower realms by neglecting bodhicitta is not easy to describe because he’s not an ordinary person and such actions can only be explained by the Buddha Himself, not like ordinary beings like us. Do you see the point here? Thank you. And, yes, so the saying that taking a Bodhisattva vows and there are eighteen root vows in Bodhisattva’s vow and out of those eighteen the most, yeah, and out of those eighteen, the quitting the bodhicitta is the greatest transgression that one completely lose the bodhicitta. For example saying here in the sūtra that by losing such bodhicitta then the virtuous one has cultivated in the many, many eons time will also degenerate as well by saying that, for example, one has developed the bodhicitta and later on thinking I’ll just attend, just practice the ten virtuous sorry, yeah, practice the ten virtuous actions and then attain to the nirvana of the solitary realizers path by wishing or developing such thought one loses the bodhicitta and then as a result of that, one loses all the virtues cultivated in the numbers of eons and such an action, the transgression is even greater than the four root vows of the ordained monk and the nun.
So the out of those eighteen root downfalls of Bodhisattva vows, losing or quitting the bodhisattva vow has a huge non virtuous action. And likewise, and also if somebody, if one try to avoid others from practicing the Buddhist, practicing bodhicitta. For example, like somebody is practicing bodhicitta and training to develop a bodhicitta and training the six perfections, for example, like practice of giving and out of bodhicitta and somebody tries to give bread to a person and one tried to obstruct that practice saying I shouldn’t be giving this, you should not give this and such and that prevents the person’s practice and doing so has a huge non virtuous actions as well. This comparison here is, you know, the non virtuous one cultivated by doing killing of entire beings in the world as well as stealing all their wealth and that, and that non virtuous action and the non virtuous action one cultivated by avoiding person from the practice of giving, yeah, the non virtuous one collect from avoiding person from practicing generosity is even greater than the other one. It is because killing one sentient being, for example, the result of killing one sentient being one avoids the taking rebirth in the higher rebirths like humans and god realms and one will go in the bad migration and if it has that then avoiding bodhisattva to practice the bodhicitta or practicing generosity, indeed has greater because that bodhisattva is doing his or her practice for the sake of the entire sentient to bring entire sentient beings to the ultimate happiness and avoid them from the sufferings.
So this is this is why that avoiding bodhisattva from their practice has huge non virtuous action. So therefore, one once one have one have developed the bodhicitta and should never let go of that, shouldn’t do this, that and take the bodhicitta and maintain it for a while and then and give it up for a while and then take it now and then and should not do such and by doing so then, yeah, but after having developed that one should maintain the bodhisattva’s bodhicitta and then try to practice the bodhisattva’s deeds like training, practicing six perfections and so forth and it is not appropriate to degenerate one’s bodhicitta. If one does so then even the person who is in the first ground, so called the joyous ground, and even the person who has reached the first ground and by quitting the bodhicitta, that that person in the first ground will take, you know, eons and eons to attain enlightenment. Yeah. So here concludes the first, I think, division of the first of the first, I guess, which was maintaining bodhicitta by being very conscientious by thinking about the actual bodhicitta.
Now towards the second division then maintaining being very conscientious by thinking about the six perfections. And that part has been shown by the next next three verses, which was now, I think, eleven, twelve, and thirteen, I guess. So the meaning of that text the next three verses is that, you know, the body of preserving, developing, and maintaining bodhicitta has huge virtues as well as losing it has huge non virtues. By doing therefore and after having developed that one should be very alert and conscious about the bodhicitta and should never let go of that bodhicitta and never degenerate it and try to maintain work very hard to maintain that bodhicitta even from the very small practices like giving a single bread to a cow and by doing so and do it with the practice of bodhicitta, the practice of generosity that one is doing it for the sake of countless sentient beings and do it with great enthusiasm and give it with offer it with the great respect. So therefore, once one have taken the bodhisattva vow or developed a bodhicitta, and should never degenerate it because by doing so one will not only, yeah, by doing so, by degenerating bodhicitta, not only receives the, sorry, I would have put it in English.
One will not, yeah, not just one will not born in, receive the higher rebirth like human and gods or demigods rebirth, one will even not hear this sound or the name of the of the higher rebirth. Hope you are not lost. And one says that doesn’t matter, the Buddhas will protect me because they are free of entire mistakes or faults and have entire good qualities, It is if one says that it is not that is not suitable because up till now the the numbers of Buddhists, like countless Buddhists has been passed up till now and they were not able they they were not able to help one up to now it is because of one’s non virtuous actions and sometimes one takes precepts and sometimes don’t they take the precept and not maintain it and lose it and take a vow and give up and so forth. Due to this, because of those non virtuous actions one has not been able to become an object that can be saved or protected by the Buddhas. This is how one has been in cyclic existence up till now.
Therefore one should not say such. Yes. Yeah. So because of because of our non virtuous actions, we always perform the opposite way of than the vows we have taken or the virtuous. Because of being born in the cyclic existence, one commits the non virtuous actions.
And as a result of that one goes through huge sufferings, taking birth in the lower rebirths and going through the numbers of sufferings like being cut by the weapons and so forth. So, yeah, one has been and one will, if not, yeah, go through the sufferings. It is it is all this happens because of because of not because of because of performing and the opposites of the bodhicitta and the actions of bodhisattva or or the bodhicitta. Yeah. So by saying so, is a bit difficult here because the main, yep, opposite or a contradiction to the bodhicitta is the self-cherishing attitude.
And because of the self-cherishing attitude then one cherish oneself more important than others and work for the individual happiness. The happiness we are talking here is the happiness of the cyclic existence or saṃsāra like wealth or, yeah, and happiness of the body, speech and mind. And due to this we commit numbers of because of self-cherishing attitude we strive for the individual happiness, one’s own happiness, and due to this and because of working for this individual happiness then that causes the attachment and desire and hatred or anger so forth. So therefore it is very important to abandon the self-cherishing attitude which directly contradicts to one of the main contradiction to bodhicitta. And by abandoning that self-cherishing attitude then all the practices of bodhisattvas or bodhisattvas like practicing the six perfections.
By abandoning the self-cherishing attitude, those practices like six perfections automatically comes. Oh, yeah. Hi there. Geshe-la says, we’ll take a couple of questions. Please.
What did you say? Did I say about the path of accumulation? Sorry? Did I say about the first is that something to do with the path of accumulation part? Yeah.
Yeah? Yeah? Yeah. It is very few who loses or degenerate the bodhicitta in the path of accumulation. As for the path of accumulation, we’re talking from the five paths of Hīnayāna paths.
Right? So the path of accumulation, preparation, path of seeing Yeah. So it’s a five paths. It’s the some of them are yeah. So say path of seeing, part of preparation, part of so path of accumulation, part of preparation, path of seeing, part of meditation, and path of no more learning, for example.
And as for the path of accumulation it has three, small path of accumulation, middling, and the great one. So it’s very few will degenerate or lose their bodhicitta in the path of small accumulation, but when one reach the middling accumulation and the great accumulation the bodhicitta will never degenerate. Yeah. It is because of their familiarity with the practice or with the bodhicitta. The path of seeing is the first — that’s the small path of accumulation with the very beginning.
It’s very few we’ll lose but not much there and with more training so forth they gradually upgrade the practice to reach the middling path of accumulation and then because of their more familiarity with the practices they will they won’t lose the bodhicitta. Yes. The criterion of giving up the bodhicitta is like whenever one make resolution that I’m not attaining the enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings and just wanted to attain individual liberation by having that made that thought and developed within one’s mind. And and and that is not and and that attitude is not free from self-cherishing attitude. And it is a self-cherishing attitude because of individual liberation and having thought of that and neglecting sentient beings, it’s because one is one has confirmed not to attain enlightenment for the mother sentient beings, that is the sign of giving up or, yeah, of giving up the bodhicitta.
Yes, please. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Keeping oneself busy.
Just kidding. Sorry for that. And sorry. Because the time is limitless. And and until you attain nirvana or liberation, you know, the time is limitless and one will keep taking rebirth and rebirth, and there’s no limit until one is free from saṃsāra.
Because our previous previous lives is limitless, you know, because it’s beginningless and it’s numberless. And likewise our future rebirths are numberless until one is free from cyclic existence and there is no limit of time and this is through your time and you have to finish everything before that there’s no limit. And our rebirth is numberless as well in future. So it will take time until you attain nirvana. Take it easy, mate.
Patriarchy. Yeah. Whenever one feels competent and capable of doing so, like, well, done this much practice up to now, and it looks like I’m okay, I can maintain bodhicitta and so forth, that is the right time. This is the last question. Done my practice, I’m going into the real world and creating massive negativity and karma?
Or am I not having generated bodhicitta, so it’s not that bad anyway? Yeah. Do you do you see what I mean? Like, when you’re when Yeah. Creating negativity because of that motivation.
The motivation of bodhicitta? Yeah. Because of that. Yeah. Okay.
Yeah. It is not because of the motivation or of bodhicitta. The bodhicitta you have developed in the morning that you and you finish the practice, you go down and all the action, let’s say anger or something like that, it’s not because of the motivation. And anger is caused by the different conditions. It is not the bodhicitta.
And what you have done in the morning, you have a huge virtuous or merit by doing so. But anger is not a result of that. Is your anger is the result of some other conditions. No. No.
So, yeah, the Buddhist thought of vows is not making taking a vow is forsaking oneself and up from today onwards or now onwards that that I will work for the sentient beings, for the betterment of sentient beings and that and so attain enlightenment for the sake of all mother sentient beings and from today onwards. That is and and that is the Bodhisattva vows, the main vows. And and whenever one quits, oh, I can’t do it. No. I’m not going to do this.
And then that that’s where one loses or degenerates the bodhicitta. So and there is one. So take a bodhisattva vow, and then there’s eighteen downfalls, eighteen root downfalls in one and by committing any of those root downfalls one cultivates the numbers of non virtuous actions. But there is a point that is it better off not taking Bodhisattva vow at all or take Bodhisattva vow and then one commits one of the loses and, yep, root downfalls and lose the bodhicitta. And out of those two choices, it’s better to take it and lose it because by taking it, one one had planted predispositions on one’s continuum on one’s continuum, and sooner or later there will be a time that latency or a predisposition will arrive, and that moment it’s very easy for a person to develop a bodhicitta.
So the choice is which is better, either take bodhicitta or not, but taking bodhicitta is better off.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
- The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
- five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
- The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
- individual liberation
- The liberation from cyclic existence achieved by a hearer (shravaka) or solitary realizer (pratyekabuddha), as compared with the full enlightenment of a buddha sought in the Mahayana. LYWA
- path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
- The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- ten virtuous actions gewa chu (Tib)
- Actions of body, speech and mind which are the opposite of the ten nonvirtuous actions, therefore, one refrains from killing, speaks the truth and so forth. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.