45 min · 2,443 words · 2 May 2002 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. A Mara disguised as a beggar who demands Śāriputra’s arm — and accepts it ungratefully — closes this 45-minute commentary by Geshe Pema Tsering on chapter four of Śāntideva’s Guide to the Bodhisattva’s Way of Life. After a brief Lamrim overview of the three scopes of practice, he explains that chapter four, on conscientiousness, exists to protect the bodhicitta developed in the opening chapters. The session’s central teaching distinguishes three kinds of pledge to attain enlightenment: made without investigation, with partial investigation, or after thorough analysis — only the last is stable enough to survive difficulty without degenerating into the serious karmic fault of deceiving all sentient beings. A sūtra image of a man who promises food to the poor and then withholds it illustrates the consequences. The Śāriputra story then opens a doctrinal debate: does abandoning bodhicitta always lead to lower rebirth?
File metadata (for organising)
File: 09 Guide 2002 05 02.mp3
UUID: 7263a017-5e6e-4995-b3e1-d81a9471e7d5
Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering
Collection: Bodhisattva Way of Life (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Date: 2002-05-02
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 45.1 minutes
Words: ~2,444
The great masters of Kadampa have stated that for once we have attained this precious human rebirth which is very hard to obtain but after having attained that it has a huge importance or huge importance that one can distill from that precious human rebirth which is very hard to obtain. So after having obtained such a rebirth, one should not waste that precious human rebirth try to generate the mind to distill the essence of this precious human rebirth from this precious human rebirth in all the time or days and night. So here the extracted, the essence from the precious rebirth of taking precious human rebirth is that should make use of this precious human rebirth to train one’s mind in the trainings of three stages, the small scope, middling, and the great scope. So the trainings of the three scopes, the first one for the middle small scope is that training, practicing the ethical disciplines of ten, not committing ten non virtues and by doing so, and that is to be attained for the sake of attaining higher rebirths in next life, like higher rebirths humans and gods, born in the human and god realms. And then middling scope, briefly speaking, middling scope is that the training in the Four Noble Truths in order to attain the nirvana or liberation and liberation.
And the practices of the great scope is training in the great compassion, bodhicitta or altruistic intention and sevenfold cause and effect instruction in order to attain the enlightenment. So as we we here strive to strive for enlightenment and wanting to get in our yep, reach the Buddhahood, therefore we should try to develop a bodhicitta through training in the sevenfold cause and effect instruction and the practice of equalizing self and others. Equalizing exchanging and equalizing self and others. Here we shall do a short meditation on a motivation of altruistic intention or bodhicitta that up till now we have done the practices of taking refuge, seven-limb prayers and we will be performing we will be doing a practice of listening and giving teachings. So develop in mind that all these practices one is one has done and is going to do is for the attainment of enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings.
On such motivation we motivation we shall do a short meditation. Yeah. We’re beginning from the fourth So the we finished first. So we’re starting the fourth chapter, which is the chapter on conscientiousness. And the first three chapters are the benefit of awakening mind excuse me, awakening mind, disclosure of evil, Full Acceptance of the Awakening Mind.
These three chapters are called the chapters of developing, newly developing or developing the bodhicitta and the next three chapters called Conscientiousness, Guarding Alertness and Patience are called the maintaining or protecting those bodhicitta, what one has developed in the first three chapters and the next three chapters are to protect and not refraining them from degeneration. So the yep, that has three parts. The next three chapters, the chapters of the conscientiousness, the guarding alertness and the patience are to protect the bodhicitta. No. No.
So now, the to expand the first one, the the chapter of conscientiousness, it has two main divisions so called explaining the text and yeah, the meaning of the text or the chapter And then the first one, explaining the text has three definitions. The first one’s called the brief explanation or yeah. Explanation and extensive explanation explanation and and subsuming the meanings. So the the first one, the brief explanation, which is shown by the first line of this fourth chapter, having firmly seized the awakening mind in this way, that’s the one. And the meaning of this is in the earlier three chapters we have developed we have developed those two types of bodhicitta, the bodhicitta, the aspiring bodhicitta and engaging bodhicitta and now having developed those bodhicitta now here I’m maintaining that bodhicitta with yeah bodhicitta and in yeah never neglecting those bodhicitta in all the time and being aware of those bodhicitta and Being aware of that bodhicitta in all the time and never lets one’s one’s mind wander out of that out of those bodhicitta and should maintain it in all the time.
That’s the brief explanation. And now the second subdivision which is details explanation or extensive explanation. And as for the maintaining consciousness of being very conscientious, yeah, there are three ways of doing it, but being very conscientious, being aware of, being very alert by thinking the precepts or advice of the bodhicitta and also being very conscientious by thinking about the precious human rebirth and the third one is being very conscientious, isn’t it? By in terms of thinking about the abandonment of the yes, of the disturbing emotions. And then for the first one, being very conscientious by thinking on the precepts or the practices or the advice of the bodhicitta it has two divisions being very conscientious in terms of thinking on the actual bodhicitta or actual bodhicitta or altruistic intention and and being conscientious in terms of thinking about the six perfections.
Yep. So being very conscientious about thinking on the actual bodhicitta which has been explained with the next ten verses. The conqueror’s son must never, whoever and goes down till ten. The meaning of those ten verses is we make promise or yep, promise in three ways to do some work or do something that some make promise without checking whether it’s suitable to work or not. Some make promise to do something by examining a little bit, really thoroughly and make promise.
And some make promise after having examined or checked thoroughly whether that something is or the work is suitable to do or not. These are the three ways of making pledge or a promise. So now here the pleasure of promise is we’re talking about the promise that to attain enlightenment for the sake of for the sake of motherly sentient beings and as for that to make such a promise or a pledge there are three ways of doing it and some like Bodhisattvas, they make the pledge to attain enlightenment for the sake of for the sake of motherly sentient beings after having examined through the valid cognition and established that there is a Buddhahood and it can be obtained and so forth and by going through detailed investigation or analysis and finally they make the pledge or promise to attain that Buddhahood for the sake of motherly sentient beings And that’s the way in how they developed the bodhicitta. And some, they just made that pledger or promise that the bodhicitta that in order to attain enlightenment for the sake of motherly sentient beings without checking or without any investigation and just by doing it in the name of devotion or faith.
And some make little investigation and then they just make a pledge. So out of all those three pledges or promises and the first two which is making promise to attain enlightenment for the sake of motherly sentient beings without any, yeah, investigation. And the second one is with a little investigation. Those two are not a very firm and and solid promise that it can be degenerated because but just with that promise in their practices and and face a little bit of difficulty, in that moment there is a danger of losing or degenerating that bodhicitta.
So therefore one should make pledge and then make that pledge or promise with the detailed investigation or detailed analysis and after having understand everything that practice that pledge in order to attain enlightenment for the sake of motherly sentient beings and that can be enlightenment can be obtained and which is suitable and it is suitable to do so but making that pledge then one should maintain it and should not simply develop or make that promise just because of devotion or of faith and by doing so first one tried to generate it newly newly generated bodhicitta and then and that was without any any analysis and gradually later on one degenerates or abandons it then one commits huge non virtuous because it becomes like deceiving all the entire sentient beings because first one made the pledge to attain enlightenment for the sake of motherly sentient beings and later on one quit that which becomes abandoning entire sentient beings. So it has one has one commits a non virtuous action. And so once one made the promise or developed the bodhicitta and then degenerate, by doing so one commits the non virtuous actions and actions and as a result of that will lead one towards the lower rebirths and to prove that the one of the sūtra said in sūtra has studied that for example demonstration here is one first one made the promise to attain enlighten for the sake of motherly sentient beings and developed the bodhicitta and with bodhicitta and one practices the practices of perfection and the first one of the perfection of generosity or giving, first one made a promise to give a food to a poor and later on one changed the mind.
First it was confirmed to give and then an actual situation or a time comes, came and that person changed their mind and feel miser and decided not to give, by doing so, then as a result of that, one will take rebirth in the hungry ghost. So and also in sūtra I said that one make the promise to give the food like rice, veggies, grains and so forth and made that promise and it’s entirely given inside one’s mind from the first stage. And then when the actual time comes and decided not to give, so such person will be born in the hungry ghost realm and will go through huge suffering. And this is what the Sūtra said, so therefore likewise making pledge of developed bodhicitta which is to attain enlightenment for the sake of motherly sentient beings and after having developed that and if one has just simply done it with the speech and the words and later on abandoned that bodhicitta or attain enlightenment for the sake of mother sentient beings and doing so will become deceiving entire sentient beings and therefore as yeah, you have deceiving entire sentient beings, as a result of that, one will not go through the higher sort of good migration and will be born in the lower realms.
Got it? So by doing so one cultivates the huge non virtuous actions because losing the bodhicitta is one of the root one of the eighteen root downfalls and likewise you know there is a huge virtuous or a benefit of developing bodhicitta. And it goes vice versa. And having developed that and then losing it also has the huge non virtues. So yeah, if one practices or maintain develop bodhicitta one receives a huge virtuous or merit goes vice versa for losing that bodhicitta.
The reason why it is because the purpose of developing bodhicitta, its main goal is enlightenment and that is for the sake of motherly sentient beings to free, save those motherly sentient beings from the suffering and bring them to the state of ultimate happiness and because of this it has a huge benefit or one collects the huge virtues, you know, by developing bodhicitta and the doing neglecting so is become neglecting entire sentient beings and as a result of that one cultivates non virtuous, huge amount of non virtuous as well. Yeah, because all this having developed the bodhicitta and then by doing so one cultivates a huge amount of virtuous because of its quality and and and yeah, its quality because, for example, like the the qualities or actions did by those the the those bodhisattvas who have bodhisattvas who are in the path of accumulation, small accumulation. They’re like, you know, so on yeah. Small, middling, and a great many divisions. So, for example, like the smallest bodhisattva or bodhisattva who was in the small smaller or smallest path of accumulation and all his or her deeds are the greater deeds and has more virtuous than the actions, the virtuous deeds of those who are hearers and the solitary realizers path as well as the ordinary beings.
And it is because of their quality, it is because of the quality of the bodhicitta and it has a huge virtuous or merit of doing so, because of its quality and by doing opposite, which vice versa, then one goes one collects greater and huge greater non virtuous than the others. So after having explained all this, the one received the huge virtues and the merit by developing bodhicitta, and it goes vice versa that one will be born in the lower rebirth or the lower realms by neglecting or degenerating the bodhicitta. By explaining that, there is a bit of a debate or a debate on this particular topic saying, some say that it is that contradicts it is not true because the Śāriputra who was the who have attained nirvana, who so called they attains the nirvana of the higher schools, means free from sufferings. But saying that once Śāriputra has developed a bodhicitta and one of so called Sanskrit, we call it Dushkaravanchu, was the Mara or so called devil or evil.
And through his magical powers, yep, power he transforms, appears as a beggar in front of Śāriputra. And Śāriputra who has developed the bodhicitta at that time and begged for his right arm, right hand, yeah, right arm. And Śāriputra happily, you know, cut his right arm and gave it to that beggar who was the Mara, so called Dushkaravanchu, with his left hand. Once it’s been cut and he offered it, that beggar didn’t receive that hand or arm happily or with respect, just pull it from the Śāriputra’s hand and saying, well, I found this. This is mine and with no respect, which was true story.
And by doing so, the Śāriputra was very, upset and and and saying this is how I practice bodhicitta, but the person has no respect and so forth. He felt very sad and this is where he lost his bodhicitta. So he lost his bodhicitta but he was still not born in the lower realms because he has attained the, what is called the nirvana of the hearer schools. So by doing if it’s a true story then that theory which is neglecting bodhicitta will not result one being born in the lower realms
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- hungry ghost preta (Skt); yi dag (Tib)
- The hungry ghost realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence, exemplified by incredible insatiable hunger and thirst. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
- The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.