2 h 29 min · 9,695 words · 16 September 2009 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 149-minute teaching, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen guides advanced practitioners through Buddhist philosophical schools’ understanding of emptiness, the absence of intrinsic existence. He begins with the Mind Only school’s central claim that external objects lack independent reality and arise only through activated mental imprints, using the example of a woman perceived as mother, partner, or daughter depending on perspective. He then systematically contrasts this with the Middle Way school, which goes further to reject true existence even of the perceiving mind itself. Through detailed stanzas from a philosophical text, Geshe explains how analysis of the present moment reveals no ultimately existing consciousness, how the mind functions despite lacking intrinsic nature, and why understanding emptiness is essential for liberation from saṃsāra. The talk culminates in teachings on meditation on emptiness as the direct antidote to ignorance, culminating in Buddha-mind. Pitched at serious Buddhist scholars familiar with Buddhist philosophical debate.
File metadata (for organising)
File: General Teaching on Buddhism; 16 September 2009 (Day 2 of 3; Afternoon) Video….mp3
UUID: 8b2c55b6-d940-4436-b7a3-f18765db9524
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: General Teachings
Date: 2009 (exact day not recorded)
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~9,694
According to Yogachara or the Cittamātra School, on top of accepting the selflessness of person as posited by Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika. They also posit the selflessness of phenomena. And the kind of selflessness of phenomena they posit is what is known as the emptiness of the emptiness of duality of the subject and the object. When you look at the external objects, they appear as though they are so distinct. They are so separate from the mind perceiving these objects.
So they don’t truly exist in that way. So how do things exist? The the external objects, how do they exist? They simply exist by by the by the awakening by the waking of the activation of the imprints of one’s mind. And then the perception occurs, and the objects objects arise.
The subjective mind and the objects arise together. So these two are, in fact, of the same entity, same nature. But when they appear to us, they appear the the objects appear as though they are of distinct or different nature from the the mind perceiving them perceiving them, such as the physical form, physical sound, the external sound, external form. They appear to exist as separate form of mind. So in true sense, they simply they still exist as one entity with the mind, the perceiving mind.
So from their point of view, the perception of the objects as external is deceptive. This is their point of view. Stanza 19, with respect to a single external object, divergent perception can arise. A form that is beautiful to someone for someone else, it is something else. What is being said here is that, when you look at the same object by different people, that on a surface level, superficially, you might say that, oh, we are seeing the same thing.
But if you probe closely, probe well, then we see that there is difference in the perception. And the same object can be seen as agreeable or attractive by someone, but the same object is seen, as unattractive to someone else. For example, if there’s, one female. And then with respect to the the daughter, she is seen as a mother. In respect to the husband, she’s seen as a consort or a partner.
And with this with respect to the her own mother, she’s seen as sorry. With respect to her own daughter, she’s seen as a mother. And respect to her own mother, she’s seen as a daughter. So all these three perceptions, they are correct. Then but then correct, but then how can you how can you account for the the correctness of all these three descriptions is, only when you bring into account the the things existing through the power of the imputation activated.
Stanza 19, third line, a form that is beautiful to someone. For someone else, it is something else. So So say the same object can be seen as beautiful by one person, but, again, the same thing can be seen as very ugly and and disgusting disgusting to a second person. And 20, with respect to the same female body, three different notions are entertained by the ascetic, the lustful, and the wild dog as a corpse to the ascetic, an object of lust for the lustful person and a food for a dog. So which means that so with the same object, we can different perceptions can be possible.
So if the object truly exists as external with its own characteristics, then if the the object is seen as attractive to one person, it should be equally seen as, it should be seen as equally attractive to all people. But this is not the the case, which indicates that, it is simply dependent on the perception and not not on the object side. So from the object side, there is no external reality. The perceptions, perceptions occur by dependence on the what kind of imprint that is activated within yourself. So this rejects the external reality, something which is independent of our subjective, subjective mind.
To our mind, although external reality doesn’t exist, but to our mind, the ability exists. So when we speak about the appearance of the objects, things not which is not really existent but appearing to mind, it is on two levels, one on the sensory perception level and the other on the mental, level. On the sensory perception level, we speak about things appearing as external reality and in true sense, lacking or empty, being empty of external reality. So whereas when you speak about the perception of the object of negation to our on the mental level, it is, the seeing the object, for example, the external form, seeing the form as the true as the true reference of the label, form. But in true sense, the the form, although it is the reference of the reference of the label form, but it is not truly the, the the the reference of the label form.
So in short, what is what is being said here is that there is no external reality as such, although things appear to to us in that fashion. And then a comment raised comment raised. If everything is simply your mental extension or the mental appearance, no external reality as such, then how can you distinguish between something which is something which is really the object and something which is simply the imagined object. How can you make the distinction? Then it says, stanza 21, it’s the sameness of the object that functions.
If asserted, it is not like being harmed in a dream. Between the dream and wakeful state, there is no difference insofar as the functional things is concerned. So the response given is that even in dreams, one dream of having the sexual intercourse, and then because of which there is the the emission happening. So although it was simply the dream, which was not at all the the real wakeful state, but still, it can function for the the emission and so forth. So even at the when you wake up from your dream, you see the the emission had occurred.
So this means that even even if things are simply dreamlike, which is simply your own mental extension, still the functions can happen. Functions, can be, tenable can be can be tenable. And then 32, in terms of objects and subjects, whatever appears to the consciousness apart from the cognition themselves, no external objects exist in any way. When you in our our ordinary life, when you look at things, we see things as external objects, and we see our own minds as the subject the the subs the subjective agent, although they appear to assume distinct entities, but this is not the real situation. And the reality is that these two assume the same same nature, same entity, 23.
So there are no external objects at all existing in the mode of entities. The very perceptions of the individual consciousnesses arise as appearance of the forms. So if things don’t exist as external, then how do they come about? How do they exist? Then it says that it is simply through the through the excitation or through the activation of the the imprint within the mind.
The same imprint same imprint gets activated. And then because of this imprint, they’re getting activated, the perception and the object arise simultaneously arise simultaneously in the same fashion. So the object and the subject, in short, they arise simultaneously and they cease simultaneously, which means that which means that they are giving rise to by the same mental imprint. So it is from this reasoning that we discern that there’s no external reality independent of the subject of mind. Had there been an in external reality independent of the mind, then there should be no reasons why these two, the external object and the internal subject the subjective mind should arise simultaneous.
See and should see simultaneously. 24, just as a person whose mind is deluded sees magical illusions and mirages and the cities of Gandharva spirits, so two forms and so forth, so on are perceived. So in short, things, just as the magical illusions, everything that you see around as objects and subjects, they are all one’s own mental extension. 25. For those who propound consciousness only, this manifold world is established as mind only.
What might be the nature of that consciousness? I should not explain this very point. The first lines Oh, sorry. 25. To overcome grasping itself, the Buddha taught aggregates elements and so on.
So here, that, the Buddha taught the different, the divisions of aggregates, divisions of elements, sense sources, and so forth, the five five aggregates, the the, 18 elements and 12 sense sources and so forth. So while the self is rejected, the existence of concrete, independent self is rejected, then these, divisions, the five aggregates and so forth are taught, implying as though, like, these these exist as intrinsically from their own side. So the very purpose of the Buddha teaching all these different the different divisions of the aggregates elements so forth is meant to reject the existence of a self, which is distinct from these, divisions, these different elements. In fact, in
In Asaṇga’s compendium of the Abhidharma, the treatise on the higher training. So then he said that the the Buddha, for him to teach the the various division classifications, the purpose of that is to reject the absolute independent self, which is distinct from the aggregates and so forth. And, likewise, the the divisions, the 12 divisions of the sources, the 18 elements are taught. So and so this is so after after explaining each of these sets, the five and so forth, then in the end, it is concluded by saying that, thus, there is no distinct self.
That is quite right because because in these various divisions, we don’t find the self as positive distantly from from these various divisions set forth there. So what is self then? Self is simply mentally imputed on the base of these various components, such as the five aggregates, 12, so, the 12 sources and the 18 elements and so forth. So from this point of view from the point of view of these two schools, Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika, while they reject independent or, a distinct, entity itself as an entity away from the aggregates, they they adhere to the idea that the aggregates themselves exist truly or from their own side. And, again, 20, 25, line three and four, by abiding the state of mind only, the beings of great fortune even renounce their teaching.
So these two lines can be interpreted in two ways. One from the point of view of the Cittamātra, the Mahāyāna school. So by abiding that state of mind only, then you the great great fortunes, beings of great fortune, referring to the Mahāyāna practitioners, even renounce their teaching, even renounce the substant substantive substantive existence of the aggregates, the 12 sources and the 18 elements and so forth. So this is one way of interpreting it. And then another way of interpreting it is according to the Madhyamikas or Middle School, which should be read as then the beings of great fortune even renounce that teaching of the mind only.
So this is how we should read from the second version second version of interpretation. So which means that so those beings were the of great fortune referring to the Madhyamikas or the Mahāyāna Madhyamaka practitioners. So finally, not only should they reject the position of the substantive substantively existing aggregate and so forth, they should also reject the mind is existing as truly, which is posited by the Cittamātrins. So they should even reject the Cittamātrins’ view of the mind existing truly. 26.
For those who propound consciousness only, this manifold world is established as mind only. What might be the the the nature of that consciousness? I shall now explain this very point. So here, this manifold world, the world are referring to the inanimate objects and the animate objects that we see in this world. So the world can be loosely divided into two parts, the inanimate and the the animate objects.
So whatever you see in this world, they are believed to be of the nature of the mind by the Mind Only school. And even in sutras, there is a mention that all the three realms all the three worlds or the realms are just the mind, indicating that everything that is that you see around, that you experience, they are all of the nature of the mind. And, also, in the Sūtra of the Ten Grounds, there is indication that there is no external reality. So then it is, said that is this the true intention of the Buddha that there is no external reality? This question.
Then the response given is that, of course, the the the it is the true intention of this particular sūtra, but this is not the true intention of the Buddha. Then why did the Buddha why did the Buddha teach that there’s no external reality in the sūtra of the 10 grounds? It is simply with a very specific purpose of allaying a fear in the minds of the in the minds of those people those people who who are inclined towards to the material view. So and there’s yet another purpose given for the Buddha Buddha giving teaching that things don’t exist externally, one of which is that which is to imply that it is finally the mind which is responsible for creating all these things, which is the primary the mind is the primary object which determines the goodness of badness and so forth. And another one is that the Buddha did teach that there’s no external reality.
It’s just mind because to help those beings who are more inclined to see Cittamātra’s view. And 27, all of this is but one’s mind that which was stated by the evil one is to alleviate the fear of the childish. It is not a statement of final truth. 28. That imputed that that imputed the dependent and the consummate.
They have only one nature of their own emptiness. Their identities are constructed upon a mind. According to Mind Only School, these two things, they imputed everything that, can that come to comes to our mind can be can be grouped into three three, three categories, the imputed phenomena, dependent phenomena, and the consummate phenomena or the imputed imputed ones dependent and the consummate. And then from the mind only school point of view, they imputed, for ex on the so for exam sorry. The dependent referring to the impermanent phenomena.
The dependent phenomena being characterized as empty of the imputed phenomena. Imputed, of course, it has different connotations. Imputed in the sense imputed has different kinds. One in the sense of imputed phenomena, one in the sense of, object of negation, which is to be rejected altogether. So here, they imputed, in the sense of the object of negation.
So the dependent phenomena, when that is characterized by emptiness nature of the imputed phenomena, is referred to as the thoroughly consummate object or the consummate phenomena, which is the ultimate reality of the emptiness according to the school. And, whereas, whereas the middle school, while positing the three characteristics, the imputed, the dependent, the consummate, But their version of these three are different are different from d v they they differ from the one posited by the Chitamatras. So from their point of view from the point of view view of the middle way, it is not only it is not only the imputed phenomenon. It is not only the, sorry, the dependent phenomenon lacking the imputed phenomena and then positing it as the positing it as the consummate phenomena, consummate phenomena referring to the emptiness of the duality between the subject and object. The the middle school, they posit that everything that exists, including all the three characteristics, are equally lacking intrinsic or true existence.
So in short, what is being said here is that the the view of the the Cittamātra, it is the true intention of the Buddha’s some of the Buddha’s sutras, but they are taught that way in order to help those people who are inclined to the Cittamātra’s view. And then and don’t and in what way it is to help those people who are inclined to the Cittamātra view is because in the second turn of the wheel of Dharma, the Buddha said that that there’s nothing existing truly from their own side, including the mind. And then there is this category who whose mentality corresponds to that of the Cittamātra. They then become a little bit, apprehensive. That’s why the Buddha taught that everything is lacking true existence because, you know, the mind should be existing solidly and truly.
So to to help those people help those people when they are unable to understand what the the Buddha was teaching in the second turn of the wheel of Dharma where where he said that there’s nothing existing truly, including mind. Then the Buddha said that but then the Buddha realizing that the this class of the the people, they they might fall to the extreme of nihilism, believing that nothing exists at all. So to save those people from falling to extreme nihilism, then the Buddha taught the third turn of the wheel of Dharma, particularly specifically the Sūtra Unraveling the Intended Meaning, saying that saying that the reason why the Buddha taught that everything lacks true existence or existence from their own side during the second turn of the wheel of Dharma is to imply that the three characteristics, the three natures the imputed, the dependent, and the consummate. They they have their own ways of own ways of lacking own ways own ways of the emptiness nature, own ways of the always of negating a specific thing. So from the point of view of the third turn of the wheel of dharma, the first turning and the second turn of the wheel of Dharma are interpret are taken as interpretable rather than definitive.
And it is only the third turning of the wheel of Dharma considered as the definitive teaching of the Buddha. And it is taken as the ultimate interpretation, ultimate intention of the Buddha’s view. However, from the point of view of the mind only school, even this third turning of the wheel of Dharma is interpretable. It’s not the it does not reflect the ultimate intention of the Buddha’s thought. And then so why do we why are we able to say that?
It’s because the Buddha, in some other yet in some other sutras, he also said that he also indicated that indicated as though, like, there is a self which is distinct from the from the body and the mind. He said there’s a five aggregates, including the body and mind. They are like a load to carry, and a person is like the carrier of the load, indicating that the the the person and the body and the mind, these are distinct entities. The person is distinct from the the body and mind. Again, this is not the ultimate intention of the Buddha himself.
And then yet in another in other sutras, the Buddha indicated that the self does not exist as independent nature. However, the karma and the aggregates, they do exist as truly. So, again, he is teaching another level of selflessness. So all these different teachings, different contradictory teachings on the surface level, so they are all taught by the Buddha in order to comply comply with the different temperaments and the predispositions of the different, people. And also, the Buddha taught the different vehicles.
And also, accordingly, the Buddha taught three ultimate, ultimate goals. And to some other disciples, he taught that there’s only one ultimate goal. So, therefore, the point is that while the mind only school’s view is the true intention of the Buddha’s some of the Buddha’s sutras, but they do they but they don’t necessarily reflect the ultimate intention of the Buddha. And as to how to as to how to distinguish the Buddha’s teachings into interpretable and definitive is, again, there are different ways of doing it. One, by by the way, as instructed in the Sūtra Unraveling the Intended Meaning, and the other is instructed in the King of Meditative Stabilizations Sūtra and also in the Ten Grounds sūtra.
So there are different ways of doing so. Now however, in the Hīnayāna sutras, all according to the Hīnayāna teachings, all teachings of the Buddha must be taken as literal, as definitive. It is only in the Mahāyāna teachings on a to which even the Buddha’s teachings can be classified into two, definitive and interpretable. So now the question is how do we distinguish between between the interpretable from the definitive? So should we do that according to by relying on some of the sutras or by means of reasoning, by means of analysis?
Of course, it must be done by means of analysis. Because if you rely on another sūtra to to discern which of the teachings of the Buddhist interpretable and which definitive, then, again, you have to know as to why that sūtra, which on the basis of which you decide the interpretable and definitive, why that sūtra is something reliable. Again, you have to to look for another sūtra, yet another sūtra to decide as with that sūtra having the authority to say that some sutras are interpretable and others are definitive. So when the reasoning is used, instead of relying just on the sutras or the teachings of the Buddha to discern which of the teachings of the Buddha interpretable and which definitive. So there, we come to know that the third turn of the wheel of Dharma is indeed interpretable.
It’s not definitive when you rely on reasonings. So this is the unique feature of distinctive feature of the Mahāyāna teaching where there is a liberty even to examine the Buddha’s own teachings to see if that is interpretable or definitive. 29, to those who delight in the great vehicle, the Buddha taught in pervasive selflessness in perfect equanimity, in perfect equanimity or selflessness in all levels and that the mind is primordially unborn. With the with the, what, dependent phenomena referring to the impermanent phenomena, it is of two kinds. One, which is pure and the other impure or the defiled and the undefiled.
So whereas, this dependent phenomena or the impermanent phenomena, according to according to the mind only school and the lower schools, it is taken as it is regarded as truly existent and intrinsically existent. So here, Vasubandhu, in his interpretation, he said that the conceptualization exists. So here exist must be qualified qualified with the intrinsic existence, indicating that the conceptual conceptualization, which falls in the category of the dependent phenomena, exists intrinsically, indicating that the dependent phenomena exist intrinsically and truly. And so according to Stanza 29, which is the position of the Madhyamikas, the Madhyamaka view that is not only the external world, even the internal world, everything that exists is lacking true existence or intrinsic nature, ranging from form to enlightenment or the omniscient mind. They all are equal in being empty of true existence.
And then when you point to the emptiness nature of everything, including the mind, there’s the emphasis on the emptiness nature of the mind. And this especially taken of taken as with great emphasis, the need to realize the emptiness nature of the the mind. Because in Nāgārjuna’s text, the Five Stages and the commentary by Āryadeva, it is the emptiness nature of the mind and the meditation of the is very much emphasized.
Through mastery of one’s own mind and through utter transformation, his state is the opposite of his own reflexive awareness. For those of for those who who are inclined, who are less less intelligent, they view they view the dependent phenomena, the conceptualization, which is the mind as as truly existent while rejecting external existence. So then it appears as though, like, when one when one realizes this fact that everything is mental imputation, then gradually all appearances come to halt or come to come to stop. And then it’s as well, like, the mind alone is left. And just as the one of the non-Buddhist Sāṃkhya tradition believed that that everything is created by this primal substance known as the Prakriti.
And when the when you as a self are through the power of meditative concentration, when one realizes that everything is simply emanated by this primal substance, godlike primal substance, then the godlike primal substance, it it it feels embarrassed to to to to have seen that the yogi has discovered one secret of emanation. And then it immediately withdraws all the emanations, and the self alone is left. At that point, the self is regarded as having achieved liberations. So similarly, from the point of view view of mind only school, when you realize that everything is simply your own mental display, mental extension, then because of this realization, when you meditate on this, then gradually, all other appearances comes to an end. And then the mind alone is left.
Mind alone is experienced. 31. That which has passed is no more. That which is yet to be yet to be is not obtained as it abides in its its locus is utterly transformed. So how can there be such awareness in the present?
This is rejecting the existence of us existence of the mind, which is truly existent. In Śāntideva’s Bodhisattva’s Way of Life, there is there is an analysis as to argument performed by the school against the mind only school as to what the mind only school would posit for the self. And then the mind only school responds by saying that it is the mind, which is finally the self. And then rejects the existence of such a truly existing mind. And, also, in the fundamental wisdom of the middle way, in the second chapter, he rejected the existence of exist when analyzing.
Now as to what it what it means by walking, does the walking exist? So then he did the analysis in relation to the, the action of walking. And then how this mind is rejected is by by analyzing the mind in the temporal sense. The mind can be broken down into three the three segments in time, the past mind, the present mind, and the future mind. And then without the without the present mind, then the past and the future mind cannot be posited because it is only in relation to in relation to the present mind that the past and the future is posited.
So then when you analyze the existence of the present mind, if in present mind, we have to divide that that into two, the present mind is also composed of parts and some of which are yet to come and others which already elapsed. So those which are yet to come is future, and those which are already gone, they are past. So the present present one can begin to bring down the two, the past and the the future. So we don’t really find what is known as present present mind. So since that there’s no present mind, then how can you posit to the past and the future?
Because past and future is posited only in relation to the present mind. If the present mind is absent, then the past and past the past and future as well cannot be existent. 32. Whatever it is is not what it appears as. Whatever it appears as, it is not so.
Consciousness is devoid of selfhood, yet
Consciousness has no other basis. By being close to a a lodestone, an iron object swiftly moves forward. It possesses no mind of its own, yet it appears as if it does. So here, the question arises now from the Cittamātra’s point of view, from the Cittamātra’s. If mind does not exist truly, then we see that the mind functions.
So how can I account for how can you posit how can I account for the mind functioning? Then it is given the analogy of a magnet. Although it has no mind, it does not it does not possess the as agent, as a mind, but still it functions to draw forth the iron filings. So even likewise, even though the mind does not exist truly, but it is through dependence on the respective causes and conditions of the mind that that the perceptions can occur. And the reason why and then the contradictions issue is raised is why did the Buddha said that the mind is that the whole all three realms are of the nature of the mind.
So it is simply to point to the fact that the primary the primary actor or the agent for the creation of world is the mind, and it is to reject any other agent which is independent of the mind as the agent to create the world. 34. Likewise, the foundational consciousness too appears to be real, though it is false. In this way, it moves to and fro and retains the three realms of existence. And this here, foundational consciousness is what is so unique, uniquely posited by the mind only school.
And, this is rejected by the mind only school, by the middle school by saying that, the foundation consciousness, this being a consciousness, it must have the object it must have the object of perception, and it must have the agent which perceives. They must be the perceiver and the perceived. So when you when you push or when you push the in the position of the foundational consciousness, finally, they have to come down to the acceptance acceptance of self cognizant mind. And the self cognizant mind, it has no object and the the subject as as two things. It is simply the self cognizance referring to the mind at the the self cognizance mind itself as the object as well as the subject.
It cognizes itself. So it fails to account for the need to have the object perceived and the perceiver. As such, the foundation the basic premise that the foundation, consciousness exists becomes a falsity. And, next 35. Just as the ocean and the trees sway about, though they possess no mind, likewise, foundation consciousness too move about in dependence upon the body.
So if it is considered that without a body, there is no consciousness, you must explain what it what it is, this awareness that is all to the one’s own specific knowledge. So here, the mind only school, it is it is emphasizing on the need for self awareness mind, self awareness. Self awareness. So what does it mean by self awareness or self awareness mind? So according to this school, it is believed that whenever there’s a consciousness, it must have two elements or two facets.
One, the objective facet and the other, the subjective facet. The objective facet, referring to the the element of the mind having the ability to direct its focus on an external object, a distinct and distant object. And then the subjective facet referring to the mind’s mind’s element to the element present in the mind to direct one’s, direct to oneself, perceive oneself. So there are two facets to the to a single incident mind. So this second aspect, having the element having the the facet to to direct to oneself towards oneself is known as the self cognizant mind.
However, when you explore deeply, then we see that whenever there is a perception happening, whenever there’s a cognizant a cognition happening, they must be cognized and the cognizer or a perceiver and the perceived. Without that without without the perceiver and the perceiver, then the action of perception is becomes untenable. So, therefore, the acceptance of self cognizant mind becomes untenable. 37. By calling its specific awareness of itself, you are asserting it to be an entity.
Yet by stand by stating that it is this, you are asserting it also to be powerless. Again, this stanza this stanza indicates that when whenever there’s cognition happening cognition happening to our innate mind, the cognizer and cognized necessarily should appear to our mind, which means that the cognizer and cognized, according to the mind only school, it cannot be posited as posited well as as tenable. Whereas according to the to the middle school, it is not posited from its own side of as truly. Rather, they cognize in the cognition and the cognizer. These two have posited posited in dependence on each other.
in dependence on in dependence on a cognizer. Cognizer, the agent, the the subject, the object is posited as the cognized. And in relation and similarly, the action of cognition is is posited. And likewise, in dependence on action of cognition, the object is is the con cognized and the agent is the cognizer. So, therefore, according to school, these three are posited posited only in, by means of dependence, mutual dependence instead of truly existent from their own side.
38, having ascertained oneself and to help others ascertain, the learner proceeds excellently, always without error. 39. They’re cognizant perceives they’re cognizable. Without the cognizable, there is no cognition. Therefore, why do you not admit that neither object nor subject exist at all?
So here, the object and subject, they are not pointable as independently from their own side. They come about only by dependence on the on on other factors. As such, what is left behind as the object is merely the name in the form of the labels. Because because in the commentary, it says that the cognizant and so cognizant, it is the it is the the feeler, the one which feels. And it says recognizable, it is the the feel it is the what is field what is felt.
Sorry. What is felt. And the feeler and the felt, these two these two can be posited in relation to the dependence on the the other on the other side. So when you say, I feel it. I feel it this way, then there must be the object to be felt and the agent, which is the feeler.
The object which is felt, the feeling of pain or pleasure. And the agent, the the agent in the sense of the the mind, which is the feeler feeler. So that happens only when there’s a feeling, the pleasure and pain. So in short, the these actions of cognizant cognizable and the cognition, they are posited in relation to the the mutuality of dependence, not through independent from independently from the own side. 40, the mind is but a mere name.
Now the position of the mind in the school sorry, the middle middle school. What is mind then? Mind is but a mere name. It does not exist truly. Apart from its name, it exists as nothing.
So view consciousness as a mere name. Name too has no intrinsic nature. Say, now the middle school, they speak about the mind even as lacking truly existent. If it is not the case, then it should be truly existent. Truly exist existence connotes independence of dependence.
If it is not dependent on any other factor, then it should be it should exist self sufficiently without dependence on the other factors. If that is the case, then then the the the cognizant and the cognition and the what is what is cognizable, these three becomes senseless. And with the same object, without dependence on on any on other factors, then the the cognition is not not possible. It cannot be posited as a cognizant. So so just as the the short and long, they are they are posited in relation to each other, dependent on each other.
There is no intrinsically tall, intrinsically short. So likewise, the cognizant and the cognizable, they’re also posited in relation to one another. 41. Stanza 41. Likewise, within or somewhere in between the two, the conquerors have never found referring to the Buddhas.
Buddhas have never found the mind. So the mind has the nature of an illusion. The mind here, when we if we take the eye consciousness, it is not something pointable from the from its own side. So if you look at where this the visual consciousness is, it is not found in the object which is perceived, nor it is found in the the sense sense faculty sense faculty, which is like the mirror. It is not found there.
So nowhere is found the consciousness. But then how does it arise then? It’s in the arise it’s in the arises by dependence on the combination of these three factors, the object, the sense power, and the immediate the immediately preceding consciousness. Combination of these three gives rise to this eye consciousness. So the eye consciousness or the mind simply exists on the mere nominal acceptance.
It does not exist truly independently from its own side, outside the mere acceptance. However, by reliance on the on the on the name, on the the the labels such as the consciousness or the mind, then to our mind, the the consciousness appears as as so well defined from its own side, but this is deception. 43. The distinctions of colors and shapes are that involved in the subject of male, female, and then the neuter. The mind has no such fixed norms.
In brief, the Buddhas have never seen nor will this ever cease
Mind. So how can they see it as intrinsic nature that which is devoid of intrinsic intrinsic nature? So here, the Buddhas, described as not having seen the mind are pointing to the Buddha not having seen intrinsically existent mind. If you analyze the mind with this intrinsic nature, then no way can you find a mind. Not even the slightest particles, slightest temporal moment moment as to be taken as a mind from its own side.
However, the mind does exist simply on the level of mere convention. The mere convention of 44. Entity is a conceptualization. Absence of conceptualization is emptiness. Where conceptualization occurs, how can there be emptiness?
So here, the conceptualizations are referring to are referring to the conceptualization of the the object, for example, mind appearing to appearing to appearing to us. It’s still like existing from its own side. And in true sense, it is just deceptive. It might not exist from its own side. So, this distinguishes, this makes the line between, the demarcating line between the two kinds of the, Middle Way philosophers.
One, one who accept intrinsic nature on the conventional sense and the other who rejecting even the interest intrinsic nature even on the conventional sense. And, this conceptualization, seeing things as truly existent or or having the experience of the mind as truly existent is, what comes to our mind. And to all our conceptualization, there’s always the appearance of true existence. And all minds of the ordinary beings should necessarily have the appearance of true existence. Again, this is what the mark is between the Madhyamaka, middle way philosopher, one who accepts the intrinsic nature on the conventional sense and one who rejects intrinsic nature even on the conventional sense.
And, so absence of conceptualization is, emptiness. So if you realize that, the things, how they appear to conceptualization as truly existent, when you realize the emptiness nature of that, this is the realization of the ultimate reality. And the next line, where conceptualization occurs, how can there be emptiness? So whenever there’s conceptualization of a phenomena of of any form or whatever, then then automatically, there’s appearance of the the object, that objects as truly existent. So if you are unable to cut, if you are unable to eliminate the any degree of appearance of true existence, then the enlightenment cannot be achieved.
And then, of course, there are two there are two kinds of meditation and emptiness. One is space like meditation and emptiness, and the other, the illusion like meditation emptiness during the post meditative state, a post meditative period. At that point, during the post meditative session, again, there’s mention of two kinds of it. One, the meditate on the emptiness, with aspect, and with the appearance and without appearance, And this is also common between sūtra and the tantra. So the point here is that when you that even to that mind which realizes emptiness conceptually or conceptually or dualistically, there’s appearance of the emptiness as truly existent emptiness as truly existent.
However, on the level of the the discerning of the or on the level of the ascertainment, there is no appear there is no intrinsic existence appearing. However, the one that we are discussing here is the ultimate bodhicitta, which realizes emptiness directly and nonconceptually through that perception. At that so in in that case, there is no elaboration. Even the appearance of the the the object object whose emptiness is realized, there’s no appearance of that object. 45, the mind in in terms of the perceived and the perceiver.
This the the hearer referring to the Buddha have never seen. Where there is a perceived and a perceiver, there is no enlightenment. So here, some people tend to view the emptiness as so to the existent. In true sense, even the emptiness does not exist independently. It is it is it it arises even the emptiness arises by dependence on imputation.
So it is for this reason that there is a mention there is a teaching on the emptiness of emptiness. And then the line three and four of the same passage stanza, four to five, where there is the perceived the perceiver, there is no enlightenment. When there is when you when you have a when you have the perception of the object in the fashion of the perceived and the perceiver, then there is still the the dualistic appearance perpetuating or there existing there. So when there’s a dualistic perception of the perceived and the perceiver, then the enlightenment is not achieved because enlightenment is described as totally devoid of any elaborations. When you describe the enlightenment in the sense of in the sense of cessation in the sense of in the sense of cessation, not knowing oh, sorry.
In the in the sense of cessation and unborn the knowing of the unborn nature and the cessation nature. Here, the cessation does not connote does not connote simply the cessation of the the defilements, but the cessation of the defilements in the sphere of the ultimate reality. So, therefore, when there is elaboration in the sense of the object subject duality, there’s no enlightenment. 46. Now if if the enlightenment, if it is said that without understanding the empty emptiness, there’s no enlightenment.
So what is the enlightenment then for those who seek it? Devoid of characteristics and origination, devoid of ceasing, devoid of abiding, and so forth, and and devoid of substantive reality. So in a different version, we have the devoid of existence. Existence is defined as something which is which is validated or which is established by a valid mind.
And, whereas the emptiness, although it is existent, but it is, it exists in the form of mere negation of the true existence, to reality. So, it is not it is not it does not exist in the form of a positive or or implicative, phenomena. And then it transcends it transcends ends transcending speech. When you realize emptiness directly, when you have, true true direct experience of emptiness, So that experience is something which cannot, be expressed in speech nor can that be nor can that come to a a conceptualization or thoughts as it is. And then is space like.
Space like referring to just as a space is, posited from the point of view of negating any obstructive, obstructive feature. Similarly, emptiness is space like in the sense that emptiness is posited by negating the in in terms of, negating the true existence. And then awakening mind. Awakening mind here referring to that enlightenment must be accompanied or complemented by, the mind of, the bodhicitta or the awake the awakening mind or the spirit of enlightenment. And enlightenment possess possess the characteristics of nonduality.
Nonduality here referring to the the elaborations, not the the freed of elaborations. And then 47, those abiding in the heart of enlightenment, such as the Buddhas, the great beings, and all the great compassionate ones always understand emptiness to be like space. So here, when when when enlightenment is such that the the person who who experience who experiences this enlightenment, if the person ever arises out of this enlightenment, this indicates that this enlightenment is not enlightenment of Buddhahood. It is enlightenment of the the other the lower arhats or the Aryas. And whereas if the enlightenment is such that the that the person the person never never arises from this enlightenment is always merged with enlightenment, this is the enlightenment of the complete buddhahood.
So those abiding in the heart of enlightenment, such as the buddhas, the great beings, and all the great compassionate ones, are they compassionate ones referring to the bodhisattvas, always understand emptiness to be like space.
When emptiness is described as devoid of elaboration, then we stand for forty-eight. Therefore, constantly meditate on this emptiness, the basis of all phenomena, tranquil and illusion like, groundless, and destroyer of cyclic existence. Here, tranquil, referring to the tranquility, the emptiness in the form of tranquility of in the beginning and in the end. And it is the this realization of emptiness emptiness serving as a direct antidote, direct remedy to the grasping of true existence of the self that that the the saṃsāra that the suffering in saṃsāra is eliminated. Groundless and destroyer of cyclic existence, so this destroys the cyclic existence.
49, as non origination and as emptiness or as no self grasping at emptiness as such, you will meditate on a lesser truth that is not true meditation. There are practitioners who don’t understand the true meaning of emptiness. So still thinking that one is meditating on emptiness. So these, some belong some are meditating on a partial emptiness, partial understanding of emptiness, and some meditate on emptiness simply what they mentally contrive and not something which is the true nature of the object. And and the 50, the notions of virtue and non virtue characterized by being momentary and disintegrated.
The Buddha has spoken of the emptiness other than this. No emptiness is held. Some there are some practitioners who think that simply withdrawal of one’s mind from the object is meditated on emptiness. So then this stanza saying that without understanding understanding the true meaning of the ultimate reality or the emptiness, simply by withdrawing your mind from the object will not lead to enlightenment. So here, there are dimension of all these different schools.
They they propose idea of emptiness. They propose idea of selflessness. The the word selflessness or the emptiness is used equally by all the equally used by all these different schools. However, they differ in the interpretation of what as to what the emptiness means or the selflessness means. And then the say, when you speak about the emptiness of external reality, so to some extent, it has benefit in overcoming your attachment and so forth in relation to external object, but it does not stop you from grasping at the true existence of the mind.
As such, it doesn’t really serve the purpose of realizing emptiness. And then another version of emptiness would be the emptiness of autonomous essential nature of the self. So although, again, it helps you to subdue some degree of attachment and so forth, with the self, but then it does not help you to overcome overcome the negative emotions in relation to the external objects such as the aggregates and so forth. And then within the Middle Way school, there’s one who believes who ascertain who who accepts the existence of intrinsic nature on the conventional, you know, reality on the conventional level, which means that things, they appear to exist inherently. And then they say that there’s no wrong in it.
And there is no wrong in it in it there is no wrong in the fact that things appear to to us to exist intrinsically because things do exist intrinsically on the conventional sense. And, while rejecting to existence, however, it is the the higher level of the middle school to reject the existence of it is the higher, it is the the higher level of the middle school who reject the intrinsic existence even on the conventional sense. So we see that although these different schools, they posit the same terminology, emptiness or selflessness, but they are they are they interpret it differently. And with this series of the emptiness, as explained earlier, we see that while you understand the emptiness, the gross levels of the emptiness, still, there’s a possibility for the the the opposite, the grasping at the true existence, which is opposite to that of the emptiness as posited in a subtler sense, there is a possibility for these graspings to arise. But if you if you discern the emptiness on the subtlest level, then there is no possibility by which the grasping the true existence of the the lower levels can can arise in you.
So this is what discerns this is what determines the subtlety of the different levels of the different levels of emptinesses. And on the basis of this, we discern as to which of the emptiness is subtler and which is grosser. And then stanza 51, the abiding of mind, which has no object, is defined as the characteristic of space. So they accept that meditation emptiness is, in fact, a meditation on space. 52.
52. With the lion’s roar of emptiness, all pronouncements are frightened. Wherever such speakers that reside, the emptiness lies in wait. Emptiness should be understood in the sense of negating the subtlest of the object of negation. So it means that things are empty of how they appear to our to our mind.
So when you when someone says like that, and then immediately naturally, there’s gonna be a sense of fear coming in you. It’s just so like saying that things, the things existing in front of you, that’s what exists. Because, when the production from the other is negated, is rejected, then the opponents or the the the proponents of the other production, they say that what if the other production do not exist does not exist, then you are contradicting the obvious direct perception, obvious experience because we see that the things are produced from others. So, naturally, there’s gonna be a sense of fear coming in you when someone says that, oh, there’s things don’t exist the way they appear to us. And all teachings of the Buddha all teachings of the Buddha, somehow they are meant to give rise to liberation, free the beings from suffering, and to let and to let them achieve full enlightenment, Buddhahood.
And to and these two can be done with the with the ultimate bodhicitta. So all teachings somehow are boil boil down to bringing boiled down to giving rise to the ultimate bodhicitta. So in short, all teachings, they are they are somehow related either to point to the ultimate reality or lead to the ultimate reality or or explicit teaching on the ultimate reality. So the teachings of the Buddha should fall in one of these three categories. So these are all means to lead to the ultimate subtlest of the the understanding of the emptiness.
53, to whom consciousness is momentary, to them, it cannot be permanent. So if the mind is impermanent, how could it be inconsistent with emptiness? It is through the teaching on impermanence is meant is given so that the one is gradually led to the understanding of emptiness. The through the understanding of momentariness or impermanence, then gradually, this understanding can serve as the the basis, the the premise to give rise to the understanding of the emptiness of to existence. 54.
In brief, if the Buddhas uphold the mind to be impermanent, how how would they not uphold that is empty as well? From the very beginning itself, the mind never had any intrinsic nature. It is not being stated here that an entity which possesses intrinsic existence somehow lacks it. So this line, the second line, says the mind never had any intrinsic nature. It is not the case that the mind was originally existing as truly in truly existent or true true nature or intrinsic intrinsic existence.
And then gradually, at one point, the intrinsic existence disappears, and then one realizes it. This is not the case. The intrinsic nature has never been a part of the the the nature of the mind since primordially. And the third line, it is not being stated here that an entity which possesses intrinsic existence somehow lacks this. Again, the same thing.
Originally, the things existing as intrinsically, and then at one point, this intrinsic existence disappears or gets out of the sight of the the object. And then the person realizes it. This is not the case. Things have been lacking intrinsic nature since beginning of this beginning of this time. Then 56, if one assess this, one abandons the locus of self, worst in the mind, it’s not the nature of things to transcend one’s own intrinsic nature.
Just the sweetness is is the nature of molasses and heat, the nature of fire. Likewise, we maintain likewise, we maintain that the nature of all phenomena is emptiness.
When the peace of emptiness is the nature of all phenomena, one in no sense propound nihilism. But at the same token, one does not propound eternalism either. This stance is, is is pointing to the the emptiness to understand as to be understood as the the middle way, which avoids the two extremes, the extreme of nihilism and the extreme of eternalism or absolutism. So when you speak about emptiness, there must be the emptiness which it it should be understood associated with the basis emptiness of something. So there must be something existent to describe to posit emptiness.
So because the the object and the characteristics and the characterized, These two must be these two must be existent. Without the characteristics, the characterized cannot be posited. And likewise, without the characterized, the characteristic cannot be posited. So the emptiness is the characteristic, and the the basis of the emptiness is the characterized. So when you speak about the emptiness, there must be the characterized the basis existent.
So this helps us, remove the extreme of nihilism, which means that there is something existent. And then at the same time, we say that it is empty of true existence, rejecting true existence. So it’s avoiding the extreme of eternalism or or absolutism. Another question is why should we discern emptiness? It is because that it is a misperception of the reality, the ignorance which misconceives things to exist as truly that the negative emotions such as attachment aversion arise, and be and because of which we suffer in in saṃsāra.
Now to in order to free ourselves from saṃsāra, we need to cut. We need to remove the afflictions such as attachment aversion, for which we need to remove the the ultimate root cause, which is the grasping, the ignorance, grasping the true existence of things. So to remove that, we must understand the we must introduce the wisdom, which understands the reality, the reality, which is contradictory to the way things are posited posited by the the ignorance. So what is that? The reality is the emptiness of true existence.
So so we see that these help us eliminate these help us eliminate the grasping the the extreme of eternalism, extreme of absolutism, thing saying that there is emptiness nature, empty of true existence. And the Buddha and the Buddha also said that whatever is produced from causes and conditions is not produced. And whatever which is lacking true production and whichever whatever is produced from the conditions is empty by nature. So here, the concept of dependence dependency is taught. So saying that everything comes into being by dependence on other factors, there’s nothing existing independently of anything else.
So and also, Nāgārjuna, in his fundamental wisdom of the middle way, he said that whatever is dependent originated is emptiness. And this to be honest this is to be understood as dependently imputed, and this is the middle way. So this stanza is, pointing to the middle way, avoiding two extremes, extreme extremes of extreme of nihilism and eternalism. It avoids the extreme of nihilism by positing the fact that things do exist as the basis of the emptiness And and also the Buddha, when he said that whatever is dependent originated on given rise to by conditions is not produced is not produced inherently. So here, the premise mentioned by the Buddha is the dependence on causes and conditions.
So this means that something is there, dependence. So this helps us avoid the extreme of nihilism. And at the same time, it is said that the because it is dependent originated, there is no independent existence, rejecting independent existence, thereby avoiding the extreme of absolutism or eternalism. And this is the middle way. We are going to stop here for today.
And tomorrow morning, we’re going to do the taking of aspirational bodhicitta, the ceremony of taking the aspiration bodhicitta.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- Samkhya drang chen pa (Tib)
- Early non-Buddhist philosophical school; the so-called "enumerators," because they advocate a definite enumeration of the causes that produce existents. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
- three realms traidhatu (Skt); kham sum (Tib)
- The desire, form and formless realms. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
- two extremes tha nyi (Tib)
- Eternalism, seeing things as having an intrinsic reality, and nihilism, seeing things as having no reality at all. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.