40 min · 3,069 words · 2 May 2026 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 41-minute talk, Kyabje Rinpoche establishes the Buddhist philosophical foundations for understanding suffering through dependent origination and causality. He rejects non-Buddhist theories of transcendent creators and universal primal substances, then explains how Buddhism understands all phenomena through causality alone—the aggregation of causes and conditions. He distinguishes internal causation (conscious beings) from external causation (the natural world), introduces Asaṇga’s three principles (impermanence, absence of a designer, and conditional potentiality), and explores why consciousness must arise from preceding consciousness, not from nothing or matter. This leads to the Buddhist doctrine of a beginningless mental continuum and rebirth. Rinpoche then examines cognition itself: direct sensory experience versus conceptual thought, and how false or distorted cognition creates the confusion underlying our suffering. Aimed at serious practitioners seeking philosophical depth.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2026-05-02 – 1B – The 4 Noble Truths Syd – KR.mp3
UUID: ea284055-80a1-4cde-89f5-6a750f2971f7
Teacher: —
Collection: Four Noble Truths
Date: 2002-05-26
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~3,066
To what exactly is the nature of this primal substance, whether the primal substance exist differently for each individual beings. This is something that I cannot I’m not familiar with in in detail, because if you if if the understanding of this primal substance is individual to each individual sentient beings, then this understanding is fairly similar to the certain passages in the Buddhist text where, for example, in a supplement to the middle way, Candrakīrti says that the entire world of environment and the beings come from mind, and mind is the creator. However, if you understand this primal substance to be some kind of universal substratum, substratum from which everything emerges, then of course, this is in conflict with the Buddhist understanding of cause and effect. So, there is one alternative explanation. However, in Buddhism, even this kind of attempt to understand reality is rejected.
And, according to Buddhism, an an attempt is made to understand all things and events, the entire spectrum of reality in terms of interaction of only only on the basis of the aggregation of causes and effects. And when we speak of causes and effects leading to the to the to the evolution, origination of all things and events, Buddhists generally Buddhists identify two sort of general realms of causation. One is the the realm of causation, the external realm of causation. One is the internal realm of causation. And this distinction is drawn on the basis of whether or not that realm is constituted by sentient beings with perception, intention, and feelings on the one hand.
That world is the world of internal realm of causation, and the external world of realm of causation refers to external environment, such as plants and and and the natural environment, where the human intention sorry, where intention and the subjective experience of feeling and and experience is not part of it. So, both of these realms of causation are understood to come into being purely as a result of aggregation of causes and the conditions. And and all of this world is constituted by things which are transient, which come into being and cease to exist. And and and this transient nature, in terms of continuum, is something that we can observe. So, if we can understand something to come into being and cease at a certain point, then we can deductively conclude that in order for that cessation to take place, the the the process of cessation must be taking place moment by moment.
Because if for such a perceptible change to take place, that change must be occurring on a moment by moment basis, otherwise, one cannot account for this sudden change that we can perceive over a period of time. So in this way, Buddhists understand how all things and events undergo moment by moment change. Because they are dynamic, they undergo moment by moment change. And so, this way, Buddhism explains the origination of the entire universe, the origin origination of all things and events. For example, the Indian master, Asaṇga, when explaining this world of dependent origination, he identifies three prime principal conditions.
One, he calls the condition of impermanence, and the condition of absence of designer, and which rejects any notion of there being a transcending transcendent intelligence designing the world. In other words, rejection of the concept of transcendent being. Having rejected that, when he talks about the condition of impermanence, that the causes and the conditions which give rise to the world of dependent origination, they themselves are impermanent. They themselves are subject to change. And these causes and conditions, then he identifies a third condition, which he calls the conditional potentiality.
So, not everything can produce anything. There must be some natural commensurability between causes and effects. Certain causes can and conditions can lead to certain types of effects, and other causes and conditions will lead to other types of effects. So, to to summarize, the basic Buddhist point is that we must understand the nature of reality and its origin purely on the basis of the interaggregation of causes and effects. So this the third condition, condition of potentiality, states an important principle.
The principle is this, that in order for a particular set of causes and conditions, or causes and conditions, to give rise to a particular set of effects or consequences, there must be some kind of natural relationship of commensurability. It’s not the case that anything can produce anything. So, for example, in the case of the internal realm of experience, of our perception, of our intention, of our thoughts, emotions, and so on, and these are mental phenomena, these are not physical phenomena. Therefore, in order for them to come into being, one must be able to trace its evolution through successive stages of cognitions. For this is, one could say, part of the natural law.
For example, even when we look at the world of physical matter, including our own body, or external objects, non-sentient objects or or living organisms or objects, we can see that these material things, we can trace the causation back to another level of physical properties, another level of physical reality. So, through this way, we can, through this kind of reductive process, we can envision at the beginning of the present universe, a kind of a state when there’s a the cause for the evolution of the entire macroscopic world. From the Buddhist point of view, for example, in one of the texts of Kālacakra, tantra, there is an understanding of what is called the space particles, for want of a better word. Space particles, which are thought to be extremely subtle material particles, which are explained to be the the the source or the origin of the entire evolution of the physical universe that we experience now. So we can trace in terms of causation, backwards for all the material objects to its constitutive particles level, then trace back to the origin of the universe.
Similarly, for the world of consciousness, for the world of experience, for the world of cognitions, feelings, sensations, and so on, again, these mental phenomena, one can trace their chain of causation in a similar way. And according to Buddhism, the the point about this condition of potentiality is that in terms of For both material world and physical world, and the mental phenomenon, although there is a causal relationship between the two, but in terms of their own continuum, one cannot produce the other. The mental continuum comes must come from a preceding mental continuum, just as the physical world must come from or material world must come from a preceding material continuum. And, however, there is an intimate relationship between the two. There is a contributing causation between the two.
Of course, mental states can contribute to the evolution of material. It can exert causation. Similarly, material phenomena can act as a contributory factor for certain subjective experiences. And this is something that, in fact, we can observe in our own personal experience. Much of our gross levels of consciousness are very contingent upon our body.
In fact, the very term terminology that we use, conventions that we use, for example, when we say human mind or human consciousness, we are using the contingency of human body as the basis to define a particular state mental state. And and similarly, at the gross levels of mind, such as our sensory experiences, it is very obvious that they are heavily contingent dependent upon our body, and and some physiological states. And when the body is damaged, we can immediately experience the impact it has on the mental states as well. However, the principle remains that in terms of continuum, mental phenomena must come from its preceding continuum and so on. So, in this way, we get to the point where there will there will be a first instance of consciousness in this life.
And now here, we have two alternatives. One option is to say that this this consciousness, the first the first instance of consciousness of this life, must come from a preceding instance of consciousness which existed in the previous life. That is one alternative. Or the other alternative is to either say it came from nowhere. It just popped up.
It came from nowhere. Or to say that it came from some material cause where so in from the Buddhist point of view, both of these two second latter alternatives that it came from nowhere, or it came from a material cause, both of them are found to be problematic. That’s why Buddhist maintain the the principle that for things and events to come into being, they must do so from causes and effects that have a natural relationship of commensurability. So, in terms of continuum, mental phenomena come from the preceding mental phenomena, and material phenomena or material objects come from preceding material objects. So so I quote from the Buddhist point of view, in terms of continuum of consciousness or the mind, the world of mental phenomena is understood to be beginningless.
And since consciousness in terms of continuum, the consciousness is beginningless. Mental phenomena is beginningless. Therefore, the person or the being which is designated upon or the individual being, or the person which is designated upon consciousness or mind, is also, in terms of continuum, thought to be beginningless. Now, when we speak of consciousness or the mind, sometimes we may get the impression we are talking about some kind of a single entity, some kind of monolithic, a single entity, or one thing. This is misleading.
From our own personal experience, we will know we we know that the world of experience, the world of consciousness is tremendously diverse. There are if if we examine every instance of cognition, every instance of experience, every instance of perception, we know that they tend to relate to objects. Whether it is an internal object, or whether it’s an external internal experience, or whether it’s an external object, cognitions, and consciousness, and and perceptions, always arise in relation to objects, things, events. They In other words, they take upon an aspect of that object, whatever it is, the focus. And And one could say that we have a valid experience in so far as the perception of these things is concerned.
However, often we also know that often our perception does not accord with the way things really are. Often there is some Often, there is a gulf between our perception and the way things really are. In some instances, our perceptions of of reality is is veridical. They they conform to they they accord with the the reality, the state of affairs. In many cases, they do not accord with the the state of affairs of the world.
And they are and they are distorted. So, we can see that from our own personal experiences, that within our cognitions, there are various instances, some valid, some invalid, and and in many cases, they are distorted and false cognitions. And also, we know, broadly speaking, if we observe the world of cognitions and consciousness, we will see two broad categories. On the one hand, there are those direct experiences, such as the sensory experiences, like visual perceptions, auditory perceptions, and so on, where their engagement with the object is direct, unmediated. And in some sense, one could also almost say kind of a naked, unmediated experience.
For example, if we are observing visually something, we are looking at something, at that instance, we have a visual experience of that object. A perception of that object, and that visual perception is direct, unmediated. And, however, while you are looking at the object, or especially subsequent to your viewing the object, say for example, when you close your eyes and think about the object, you can still continue to have the image of the object in your mind. You’re no longer looking at it, but here, now, you’re engaging with the object at a different level. Here, you are engaging with the object with a conceptual thought.
And so what happens in the thought is that you conjure this image of the object, and here, that engagement with the object is categorically or qualitatively different from your visual experience when you have when you engage with objects, with thoughts, then, you know, it does so through the mediation of concept, It does so through the mediation of image. And what happens is that there is a, you know, a conflation of time and space that occurs in it. For example, if you have seen a beautiful flower somewhere in the eastern part of the place, and next day you’re taking a walk in the southern part, and all of a sudden you see the same flower, a sense of recognition will occur in you, and you will feel, oh, I’ve seen that flower before. So in reality, although these two individual flowers are completely distinct, One exists in the eastern part, one exists in the southern part. In the thought, what happens is that and also, the flower that you saw before, you saw yesterday, not today, and you’re seeing the flower now.
So although in terms of these two flowers, and they were separated by space and time, in in your thought, when the recognition occurs, you conflate time and space, and and and you project the image of the the flower that you saw yesterday onto what you are seeing now. So, when with thought, there is a conflation of time and and space, and thought is mediated through language and and concepts and so on. So, you broadly speaking, the point is that in in the world of mental phenomena, there are the sensory direct experiences, perceptions on the one hand, and cognitive conceptual thoughts on the other. Now, within these thoughts, again, you will see a tremendous diversity, some which are valid, which perceive things in the way they exist, some which are false cognitions. And these false cognitions are not only distorted, but if they are simply distorted way of understanding things with no negative consequences, then it that’s fine.
However, that’s not the case. It is this false way of understanding the world, false way of looking at thing viewing things that really lead to all kind of problems and and difficulties, because it creates confusion in our mind, and this confused way of engaging with the world lead to our sufferings and so on. And since we all have the natural capacity to experience pain, and enjoy happiness, we all possess this natural inclination to wish for happiness and overcome suffering. And with this natural inclination, or natural natural sort of instinctual aspiration, we try to bring about the fulfillment of this aspiration to enjoy happiness and to overcome suffering. Therefore, for us who naturally seek happiness and seek to overcome suffering, it becomes vitally important to really understand that these confused way of understanding the world lie at the root of much of our suffering and and and difficulties.
So in terms of understanding the nature of perception and how it engages with objects, within the Buddhist schools, there were Vaibhāṣika schools who believe that all the sensory perceptions, and they perceive things in a naked way with no mediation, no interpretation whatsoever. However, other schools such as Sautrāntika and so on, they rejected the idea of unmediated, naked experience of the world. And they argue that even for the sensory perceptions, and there is some form of mediation, and this term, the mediation is done through something which is called the for want of a better word, literally translates as an aspect, but it’s more like the sense data, the the western philosophical sense. So, there is an understanding that there’s a kind of an interpretive process that goes when you when your sensory such as your visual perception perceives an object. There is a mediation of some kind of the data.
And this second idea that there is some level of degree of interpretation through this sense data seems to be quite close to the current scientific understanding of the functions of these perceptions. And also, related to this, which is although just an aside, in Buddhist text on epistemology and psychology, when describing the the nature of these different sense sense perceptions, there is quite a detailed explanation of the conditions that give rise to sensory experience, such as in the case of visual perception. There is the external object as a condition, and then sensory faculty, the the sensory base, and the sense organs, and so on. However, in the in the Buddhist text, an implication is given that these the basis of these sensory faculties somehow lie very close to the actual sense organs that we can like the eyes, ears, and so on. Somehow they are separate from each other.
And this explanation seems to be at odds with the neurobiological understanding of how all the sensory, the five sensory experiences, perceptions, really have their central locus on the brain. And somehow the sensory base of these sense perceptions really lie in a kind of a central nervous system, rather than close to the actual physical sense basis. And so there seem to be some conflict between the Buddhist explanation of the nature of these sense perceptions, and particularly the sensory basis, and the modern scientific explanations. So, I think it’s an area where some further research needs to be done to try to understand convergence or the divergence between these two contrasting understandings. In Buddhism, Buddhist understanding of these perceptions, however, there is an understanding that at the sensory level, what happens is that there is a through this mediation of the sense data, there is the direct experience of the object.
However, it does not make any evaluative judgments of whether this being desirable or undesirable, or attractive or unattractive, good or bad. These judgments do not occur at the sensory level. They occur at the second stage, when the thought comes into play. So, these thoughts are conceptual thoughts. However, it seems that in current modern scientific cognitive psychology, there doesn’t seem to be clear distinction made between direct sensory experience on the one hand and conceptual thought processes on the other.
Key terms in this teaching
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- tantra gyü (Tib)
- Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.