Four Noble Truths — 2013-10-09

1 h 46 min · 4,907 words · 9 October 2013 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

4 Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
4 Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Four Noble Truths — 2013-10-09
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 107-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche dismantles our illusion that cyclic existence is a pleasure park, arguing that genuine liberation begins only when we grasp suffering so vividly that urgency for freedom ignites. He illustrates saṃsāra’s blind reversals through the story of a householder unknowingly eating his reborn father (as a fish) while flogging his reborn mother (as a dog) and cradling his reborn enemy (as his child). He details the six fundamental faults of saṃsāra: uncertainty in relationships, insatiability, repeated death and rebirth, endless falling and rising in status, and solitude. Tracing these faults to their root—self-grasping ignorance—he explains how desire and anger generate the karma binding us to saṃsāra. The antidote is wisdom realizing emptiness.

—

Flags: []

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2013-10-09 – KR.mp3

UUID: 9b6ae488-d908-43a5-a1f2-1aa989bd4ae3

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Four Noble Truths

Date: 2013-10-09

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~4,900

As I said in the Guru Puja, bless me through abandoning seeing this cyclic existence as a pleasure grove to engage forcefully in training in the three trainings. So ordinary beings such as ourselves view cyclic existence which is filled with sufferings which are hard to bear as a pleasure grove in other words as a park which is filled with enjoyable objects of experience. This is true for the overwhelming majority of human beings. The overwhelming majority of human beings are focused exclusively on this life. Few if any think of liberation and of full enlightenment and among those few who do actually think of liberation and full enlightenment for most it is a subsidiary pursuit.

It is not by any means their main focus and they put little effort in it. This is what one should reverse and to do this one should generate the profound wish to engage in the three trainings and to practice the seven jewels of an ārya being. Then when one refers to the treasure of these three trainings and of the seven jewels of an ārya being, the treasure here refers actually to the site or the location where these three trainings or these seven jewels of aria being abide. In our cases, the so called treasure we are referring to here is our mind in which instead of having the three trainings and the several jewels of an aria being, desire, hatred and ignorance dwell. Therefore, our goal must be to switch or change treasures.

Then clearly the foundation of this practice is the abandonment of the afflictions such as desire, hatred and ignorance and this calls for much study, and unfortunately, this study is very difficult indeed. Therefore what we have to engage in is a practice of the three trainings. In other words, a practice of ethics which we must understand, a practice of concentration which here refers to calm abiding or shine and a practice of wisdom which refers to a realization of the view of selflessness. Now the seven treasures of an ARIA being are faith, ethics, generosity, hearing in other words study, shame, embarrassment and wisdom. In addition, there are three types of faith which are to be trained in.

The pure faith, the faith of conviction, and the faith of actualization or realization. To give the example of these three categories of faith applied to karma and causality, the first, pure faith in karma and causality refers to a natural conviction and proclivity, a natural inclination to believe that karma and causality are true. The second, the faith of conviction in karma and causality refers to being convinced based on preliminary reasoning that karma and conviction or karma and causality are true. The final form of faith, the faith of actualization refers to a wish to engage in practices related to karma and causality rooted in faith. Then the second of the seven jewels not necessarily in the order given is the jewel of hearing or study.

This refers specifically to hearing and studying the Tripitaka, in other words the totality of the teachings of the Buddha which include the Sūtra Pitaka, the basket of sūtra, the Abhidharma Pitaka and the Vinaya Pitaka. And the goal of these studies is to understand what is to be abandoned and what is to be practiced. As you said in the Udhana Varga, the Tibetan collection of the Buddha’s utterances, faith is the foundation of all practices. It is through faith that one counters sin. It is through faith that one engages in practice.

Well, there is a threefold subdivision of ethics. The very essence of ethics is the ethics which is an abandonment of the afflictions. The following of the seven jewels of an aria is generosity. Generosity is the main means to counter self-cherishing or egoism. It is for this reason that one engages in the activities of giving and generosity.

The following of the seven jewels is shame. Shame refers to that wish to abstain from a non virtuous deed when reflecting on the opprobrium one will incur in the eyes of others to engaging in it. For instance, if one were tempted to kill someone out of shame one would abstain from this thinking others would say I am an evil man I cannot do this. The following of the seven jewels of an Ārya being is embarrassment. Embarrassment refers to abstaining from a non virtuous deed through reflecting oneself on the inappropriateness of the deed out of an inner sense of inappropriateness.

For instance, in the case of killing, one would think I cannot kill such and such a being since I myself just as such and such a being would not wish to be killed. It is inappropriate for me to inflict that on him or her. Wisdom refers first and foremost to the wisdom which realizes emptiness and by extension to other forms of wisdom. Wisdom can be subdivided into two, the wisdom of what is to be attained and the wisdom of what is to be abandoned. The first subdivision of wisdom, the wisdom which is to be abandoned refers to all of the mundane wisdoms how to manufacture things, how to make things for this life, all of the forms of wisdom we engage in animated by desire, by hatred, and by ignorance.

If we think about it, these are really all objects of abandonment. The second subdivision of wisdom, the wisdom which is to be engaged in, refers to an understanding of all of the objects of abandonment which are to be abandoned as well as everything which is to be practiced. And in the stanza of Lama Chöpa which was quoted at the beginning of this teaching, when one requests blessing of the spiritual teacher to engage in the three trainings, one requests the blessing to engage in the three trainings and to practice the seven jewels of an ārya being so as to uphold the banner of liberation. Here, the victory banner of liberation can be interpreted as follows. Victory banner in Tibetan is composed of two syllables is victory and in Tibetan means a sign or a symbol.

The syllable refers to overcoming the afflictions the banner, the symbol refers to the qualities which are attained as a result of this. This banner which of liberation which we are striving to obtain, all it is beneficial is not ultimately beneficial since even though it frees us from suffering and grants us happiness nonetheless it does not free other sentient beings from suffering nor does it grant happiness to them. And therefore we should strive to attain a parinirvāṇa in which we will be able to enact the benefit of all sentient beings, freeing all sentient beings from suffering and actualizing the happiness of all sentient beings. At least this is what is said. And now let us meditate on the following reflections.

I myself will endeavor to attain the state of full enlightenment not for my own sake but for the sake of setting all thinking beings without exception in that state. Geshe-la will at present comment on stanza 16 of Concise Meaning of the Path. Without striving at the contemplation of the defects of the truth of suffering, how will the urge for liberation arise? Since without having contemplated the stages of ingress into cyclic existence, the origin, one will not know the manner of severing the root of cyclic existence. One should cherish reliance on the melancholy wishing for definite emergence from existence and knowledge of what fetters to cyclic existence.

The noble gurus have predestined this way and you too who wish for liberation should wish to act thus. The first nine of stanza 16, without striving at the contemplation of the defects of the truth of suffering, the first one understanding of the thoughts of suffering. Suffering here is to be understood in terms of the two outlines of the Lamrim in which suffering is presented both from the general standpoint and in terms of its specific varieties. In terms of the six fold subdivision of the general characteristics of suffering, one experiences the suffering of uncertainty, the suffering of insatisfaction, the suffering of being embodied over and again, other words being born over and again and the suffering of dying over and again, the suffering of falling over and again from the high to the low and the suffering of being friendless or alone. Regarding the suffering, the first of the six fold subdivisions of suffering, the suffering of uncertainty, Śāriputra said, he eats the flesh of his father and lusts after his mother.

These are the sufferings of cyclic existence. I will retranslate the quote. He eats his father’s flesh and flogs his mother and cradles his foremost foe. Sam saṃsāra is indeed a farce. This stanza was uttered by Śāriputra when Śāriputra during one of his trips to India entered in a village and with precious with his clairvoyances realized that a householder who lived in the village had just lost his father and mother.

His father probably must have liked to eat fish a lot because he was reborn as a fish in a neighboring pond. This fish was caught by the householder, killed and prepared for supper. The householder’s mother had also passed on and was reborn as a dog to whom the householder gave some of the bones of the fish but which he beat when the dog tried to eat the fish’s flesh. The foremost foe of this householder had passed on and been reborn as this householder’s child. As a result, Śāriputra said, he eats the flesh of his father and flogs his mother while cradling his foremost foe.

saṃsāra is indeed a farce. And therefore, the first suffering of cyclic existence, the uncertainty of cyclic existence refers to the fact that there is no certainty whatsoever in relations with other beings. For instance, one might be extraordinarily close to someone today and find that that very same person has become a foe tomorrow, whereas today’s enemy might become tomorrow’s friends. We can see this both in families and in marriages. For instance, husband and wife may adore each other, but then within a couple years they have become their own worst enemies.

On the other hand, father or parents might love their children and children love their parents only to realize a couple of years later that they are each other’s bitter enemies. The reciprocal is also true. Likewise, extraordinarily wealthy and powerful people can overnight lose everything through war, fighting or whatever and end up destitute and on the street an object of contempt for all. The opposite is also true. Someone who is destitute and on the street may through an inheritance overnight become extraordinarily wealthy and discover he has an astonishing number of newly found relatives.

Therefore, cyclic existence has no certainty, no definiteness. This is one of the reasons it should be abandoned. Likewise in this life many of us have fancy houses and luxurious cars and yet if one has a luxurious large car there is no certainty whatsoever this car is not going to stall and die literally upon us. Even if the car does not stall and die upon us, we ourselves may die before the car has stopped working. And therefore reflect on the fact that there is not a single person or phenomenon in cyclic existence which is reliable or stable.

The second of the six faults of cyclic existence is the fault of in satisfaction. This we can best understood through looking at our own selves. If we have one house, that one house is not enough for us. We need to buy a second house as an investment. Once we have two houses, we figure a third house would be an even better investment.

Then five, ten, 100, 1,000, 1,000,000 houses, we never have enough houses even though we ourselves are unable to use or to inhabit them. The more houses, the more things we have, the more arrogant and full of ourselves we become as well as the greater the desire within our mind stream. Eventually we reach the point where our desires can no longer be satisfied at which point we become downcast. Nobody ever says, I don’t need another house. I don’t need more money.

I will focus on liberation and full enlightenment. There’s no such person, isn’t there? The third of the six faults of cyclic existence is the thought of relinquishing over and again our bodies in other words of dying over and again. And this is a tragedy which befalls all living beings in cyclic existence from the lowest of the hell realms up to the great gods such as Indra and Brahma. Eventually even these gods must die and fall into realms inferior to their own.

Then some upon dying fall into the lower realms others upon dying who were in the lower realms are reborn in higher realms. There is therefore not even any certainty in this matter. Upon death one is transported by the ocean of karma uncontrollably and it is impossible to know if one will be reborn in a higher or in a lower realm. At present, we have a good body. Therefore, we do not wish to be freed from it.

In the future, when we will have a bad rebirth, we will be unable to find the means to be freed from it. What is liberation? Liberation in a nutshell is a state in which for once we have power and we gain control whereas at present we are totally controlled by our own karma and our own afflictions. The following thought is being reborn over and again. In our cases, we have been reborn an infinite number of times as Brahma and Indra and likewise we have been reborn an infinite number of times in the lower realms.

The number of times we have had each rebirth is basically measureless. Every single time we have moved from that rebirth to the following rebirth under the power of karma and affliction. Finally, the fault of friendlessness of being alone refers to our fundamental solitude in cyclic existence. We are fundamentally alone in the death process since we are unable to take anyone with us as we die. Nobody can accompany us.

Let alone this, within this life we experience countless sufferings due to disease and so forth. However much they might wish to do so, our parents, our children, our friends will be unable to experience even one iota of the diseases which we are experiencing at present. These diseases and these sufferings we must experience completely alone. And therefore, as is said in the first line of stanza 16, without striving at the contemplation of the defects of the truth of suffering, The defects of the truth of suffering here refer to the six general faults of the sufferings of cyclic existence and the truth of suffering and the truth of the origin of suffering refer to cyclic existence themselves. These two through contemplation give rise to a melancholy, a downcastedness which wishes for liberation from cyclic existence.

If one does not meditate on suffering, one will not wish for liberation. The two first lines of stanza 16 without striving at the core of the defects of truth of suffering, how will the urge for liberation arise indicate that it is not merely an intellectual understanding of these truths which is required. One must have a profound realization of the truth of suffering because otherwise the wish to be liberated from this suffering will not arise. Such a wish has to be akin to that of someone who is in a fire, in a house which has taken fire. If we are in a house which has taken fire, all of us merely wish for one thing and that is to flee the house.

This is not something, this level of intensity of wish for liberation is not something which arises easily. On the other hand, if one meditates on the six folds of cyclic existence, both a mind wishing for liberation and definite emergence renunciation will arise. The following line of stanza 16, since without having contemplated the stages of ingress into cyclic existence, the truth of the origin, one will not know the manner of severing the root of cyclic existence. The first is the fact that the fundamental root or the fundamental cause of suffering is none other than the noble truth of the origin of suffering. If one does not understand the noble truth of the origin of suffering one will be unable to sever it at the root and be freed from suffering.

If we analyze this line more carefully, in the line without having contemplated the stages of ingress into cyclic existence, cyclic existence saṃsāra in Sanskrit, Kora in Tibetan refers in a nutshell to existence or birth which is taken on under the power of karma and affliction. Karma is the main cause of cyclic existence and the afflictions themselves are the main cause of karma. Now the afflictions are countless in number and will be difficult to explain them here but it is not inappropriate to present them in terms of the three poisons of desire, anger, and ignorance. In the following line, one will not know the manner of severing the root of cyclic existence. The root of cyclic existence which is to be identified here before being severed refers to self grasping.

In other words, that ignorance which is known as the ignorance of the view of the decaying collection. Here, this ignorance refers to the ignorance which apprehends both the I or the self as well as the mind or what is mind as being inherently or truly established. In other words, established from its own side. Here the view of the decaying collection and ignorance that ignorance which is self grasping are the roots of cyclic existence and therefore they are what is to be severed. The definition of ignorance is that obscured mental factor which misapprehends thusness.

And this mental factor, ignorance, it does not merely misapprehend thusness or emptiness. It actually apprehends thusness in exactly the opposite way of the way in which wisdom apprehends thusness or emptiness. In Candrakīrti’s system, ignorance and the view of the decaying composite are one and the same. Whereas for Ārya Asaṇga, they are somewhat different. However, the difference which Asaṇga postulates between the collection the decaying collection and ignorance is a slight one.

The decaying collection or the view of the decaying collection is an instance of ignorance and this is best understood through an example. If we see a piece of multi colored rope on the ground and looking at it, we misapprehend it as a snake and fear arises in our mind thinking there is a snake here, then that is an instance of the view of the decaying collection for Asaṇga. However, if because of the darkness which surrounds us, we do not see clearly what that piece of speckled rope on the ground is, that would be an instance of ignorance for Asaṇga. I would like to open a parenthesis and point out that the explanation of the two first lines of stanza 16 on suffering, he only gave a presentation of the general suffering of cyclic existence and the six fold subdivision of the general suffering of cyclic existence. We obviously must reflect on the other forms of the suffering of cyclic existence specifically the specific sufferings of cyclic existence those of the hell realms, of the hungry ghosts, of the animals and so forth which there is no time to present in Now regarding the view of the decaying collection, this view of the decaying collection is the innate sense of I which we have.

This is a sense of I which has been accompanying us since beginningless time. It can be understood in two different forms as a coarse and a subtle innate sense of I. The one posited on our present aggregates, the other posited on the fundamental mind of clear light. This ignorance which grasps at the self gives rise when it manifests to a state of mind which on the one hand wishes for what is wished for and on the other hand does not wish for what is not wished for. This mind which wishes for what is wished for in turn gives rise to desire, whereas the mind which does not wish for what is not wished for gives rise to anger.

It is in this way that the ignorance grasping at itself gives rise to both desire and anger. Desire is that state of mind which thinks, may I get what I wish for? Whereas anger is that state of mind which thinks may I not get what is unwished for? In other words suffering. It is through desire and through anger that all karma is accrued.

And then in turn, through desire and through hatred as well as the afflictions in general, virtuous and non virtuous karma is accrued, which in turn give rise to happy and unhappy experiences. Neutral or equanimous karma has no strength or power. And therefore in the line of stanza 16, since without having contemplated the stages of ingress into cyclic existence, the origin, the term the origin sometimes translated mistakenly in English as a noble truth of the origin, it’s just the truth of origin refers to karma and to klesha, in other words to karma and to the afflictions which are caused by their root ignorance. Ignorance therefore gives rise to karma and klesha. Karma and klesha in turn give rise to the totality of cyclic existence.

If we are unable to sever the root of karma and klesha we are unable to sever the root of cyclic existence. What is therefore the antidote of this ignorance which grasps at itself and is the root of cyclic existence? Its antidote is the mind which apprehends itself in the directly opposite way from it. This ignorance misapprehends the self as truly existent. Its antidote is a wisdom which apprehends And therefore this wisdom which realizes selflessness enables one to eliminate all of the faults preventing one from attaining liberation and to accumulate all the conditions for the attainment of liberation.

And this is why one must gain a realization of emptiness since that realization of emptiness is the direct antidote to the ignorance which grasps at itself which itself is the root of all karma and affliction. As is said in Āryadeva’s Four Hundred, the Chatuhshataka, by it all of cyclic existence is destroyed. And therefore the two following verses of stanza sixteen, one should cherish reliance on the melancholy wishing for definite emergence from cyclic existence and knowledge of what fetters to cyclic existence refer in the case of the first verse to the generation of definite emergence or renunciation from cyclic existence and in the case of the second verse to knowledge of ignorance which is what fetters one to cyclic existence. Noble gurus have practiced in this way you too who wish for liberation should wish to act thus. We will stop here for today having completed the presentation of the path shared with the being of middle scope.

Next time we will begin the presentation of the Great Vehicle. I was very interested in that section between Candrakīrti’s description of ignorance and Asaṇga’s. Could Geshe-la elaborate on the differences between those two? It is best understood in terms of the example Geshe-la gave of the rope, the speckled rope misapprehended as a snake. Both the view of the decaying composite and ignorance misapprehend the speckled rope as a snake.

Both are unclear in their apprehension of the speckled rope as a speckled rope. So the view of the decaying composite is posited from the standpoint of wisdom whereas the view of ignorance is posited from the standpoint of benightedness. Does that help? So the question is if one intentionally assaults another person without intending to kill them and therefore the six or the four components of the deed are not complete. When one acts with a harmful intent, does this such a deed become one of the 10 non-virtues?

So Geshe-la said no. Such a deed is a non-virtue, yes, definitely. But it is not one of the 10 non-virtues since for instance it’s not a deed of killing because as a result of that deed the other party does not die. Just from last week, one of the eight qualities of a precious human rebirth that we should wish for was great power or wealth. It was one of the qualities that we should have.

But then today we are talking about how getting a house and wanting another one as an investment and the same goes for any type of gain of wealth leads to arrogance and being full of ourselves. There seems to be like we’re wishing for one thing that’s going to give us arrogance and being full of ourselves. There are two types of greatly wealthy persons, those who know how to use their wealth and those who do not. Those who know how to use their wealth will not let the wealth become a cause for desire and discontentedness. Those who do not know how to use their wealth will become a victim of desire and discontentedness.

So in the context of the eight qualities of additional qualities of a precious human rebirth, when one speaks of great wealth, one refers to the great wealth of one who is contented. Otherwise, if one is poor, how can one practice generosity? If one is poor, one can practice generosity with one’s mind. Definitely. If one has nothing to give, one can then practice generosity mentally through visualization.

One can have someone with great wealth who out of avarice offers very little and what little he or she offers actually becomes almost a source of non virtue because of the avarice and someone with little or no wealth who through visualization makes extensive offerings to the triple gem. Dharma is a mental activity. If one is able to engage in these deeds mentally with a happy mind then they become the source for a higher re birth. If on the other hand when one engages in these deeds there is regret or one engages in them for unworthy purposes then to the exterior appearances the self same deeds of generosity become the cause for a lower rebirth? The Buddhas and the Bodhisattvas for instance visualize extensive offerings.

These offerings are of great benefit to beings because they know precisely how to benefit beings. We ourselves however are seldom able to benefit others with what we offer because we do not understand how to benefit them. With the shame of the seven jewels, in what way does that differ from the shame of the eight worldly concerns which I understood as meaning that we shouldn’t care what other people think about what we do. What exactly is the shame in the eight worldly dharmas. Oh, I thought it was that not shame as such, but that, you know, we shouldn’t be concerning ourselves with what other people feel about our words or actions.

So here in the context of the seven jewels of an ārya being, shame refers to not engaging in non virtuous deeds which are condemned by others. On the other hand, a being who has abandoned the eight worldly dharmas is actually an extraordinarily being since such a being has abandoned any attachment to pleasure or suffering. Therefore such a being is an ārya being. As an ārya being he has exclusively shameful consciousness. has a consciousness which is fully aware — it’s very difficult to translate correctly in English but which has a strong sense of shame and does not engage in shameful deeds.

To such a being, happiness and suffering are equal and indifferent. Such a being is never want to engage in non virtuous deeds or shameful deeds. Thank you, Geshe-la. I was wondering the difference between Asaṇga’s asserting that there is a slight difference between the two ignorances. Does that have anything to do with the difference between meditating on the selflessness of persons and the selflessness of phenomena being different?

No. There is a big difference because basically the only difference between the mind which apprehends a self of persons and the mind which apprehends the self of phenomena is one of the bases. In other words, it is a terminological difference. The mind which apprehends a self of persons focuses on the person whereas the mind which apprehends the self of phenomena focuses on the aggregates of that person. Otherwise, there is no difference in the mode of apprehension.

So that sort of difference is absent between The view which apprehends a decaying composite is an instance of the apprehension of the self of persons just as the ignorance which apprehends the self of persons is also an instance of an apprehension of the self of persons. Don’t forget to turn your phones back on and you’re invited to join us for some chai, which am sure you will practice not being attached to.

Key terms in this teaching

Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
higher realms
The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
parinirvana
The final nirvana the Buddha attained when he passed away in Kushinagar, India. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
three poisons dug sum (Tib)
Attachment, anger and ignorance. LYWA
three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top