Entering the Middle Way – 13 Entering 1991 04 04

45 min · 2,333 words · 4 April 1991

Entering the Middle Way (Khensur Rinpoche)
Entering the Middle Way (Khensur Rinpoche)
Entering the Middle Way - 13 Entering 1991 04 04
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teaching opens by setting the motivation of the awakening heart and explains that freedom from suffering comes through transforming the mind. It then introduces the need to investigate emptiness by reasoning rather than scripture alone, using a threefold analysis like assaying gold, and begins Nagarjuna’s and Candrakirti’s reasonings, including the five modes of reasoning illustrated with a sprout.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 1991-04-04

Duration: 45 min

UUID: 738662aa-93ff-4a3b-a6cd-70c0b2fcab86

Words: 2,329

Begin by adjusting your motivation, developing the awakening heart. So now we have a wonderful opportunity which is presented to us by this complete human life by means of which we can practice the Dharma. What is it that we want? We want a type of happiness which is completely bereft of any suffering, which is unremitting and unchanging. And how are we going to achieve this unchanging happiness bereft of all suffering?

It is in dependence upon our own minds. And how are we to develop such a mind? It is by the elimination of all the various flaws and faults within the mind and the development of all the various positive healthy states of mind. And how are we going to achieve this in whereby we’re going to eliminate the various unhealthy factors within our mind and cultivate the various healthy factors? It is through the development of positive patterns within the mind.

Out of these positive patterns of mind will arise various positive types of conduct. So, we have these two factors we’re working with: components of mind and body. Through positive patterns of mind, we will then conduct ourselves in a positive physical fashion. So, of the two, mind and body, the main is that of mind, that all our experiences meet back to the mind itself. So, what types of positive patterns are we seeking to cultivate?

The healthiest that we can begin to cultivate is that of the kind heart. And this is embodied in the thought that considering ourselves and others and how we are troubled and the various sufferings that we all experience developing love and compassion, a type of kind heartedness which seeks to lead others out of their suffering and to establish them in complete happiness. Can we though this is a very healthy intention, very positive can we actually achieve it? And we when we look, we see that we don’t presently have the ability to bring it about, in fact. How can we achieve this in fact?

If I were to eliminate all of my various faults and developed all of my excellent qualities to the consummate end, then I would have the ability whereby to lead all beings from out of their suffering and to establish them in complete happiness. Do we And then initially, how am I to eliminate all my various faults? How am I to bring to consummation my excellent qualities? So, to this end, we must necessarily be able to identify the various faults, and we must be able to come to understand the various methods whereby to eliminate these faults. So, it entails these two aspects: identifying, recognizing our faults, and understanding the various methods to eliminate them.

And how am I to go about identifying the various faulty factors and learning about the methods whereby to eliminate these factors? The methods to eliminate these factors? By listening to the various texts on the great vehicle, by reflecting on the meaning, and then by cultivating them in meditation, then we can begin to identify what are the faulty factors and implement the methods to remove them from our minds. So, for the next three minutes we’re going to cultivate as our motivation the awakening heart, that in order to achieve this in that I am going to physically using to listen to the various teachings whereby I can come to reflect upon them and cultivate them. And to implement these within my physical being whereby I shall seeking to eliminate all the various coarse faults of my body verbally to eliminate all my coarse faults of speech and to put my body and mind and speech to the end of benefiting all sentient beings.

So, the awakening heart as one’s motivation for listening to this present teaching. So, quoting from a verse by the great master Nāgārjuna from his text, the Fundamental Treatise on the Fundamental Wisdom, which was one the Buddha himself prophesied that there would appear in India such a master of the Middle Way. And within this text Nāgārjuna says that: Not born from other, nor born from self, not born from both, and not born from without cause. Nothing whatsoever is produced in either of these ways. Nāgārjuna composed the text Fundamental Treatise on Wisdom in order to revive the then degenerated middle way view, in order to revive it and propagate it.

He composed this text in which the quote was taken from that that nothing whatsoever is born from self produced from self other no cause or both. Both are no cause. So in coming to an understanding of emptiness, it’s not sufficient merely to rely upon scriptural authority, but mainly one has to rely upon cultivating cultivation through reasoning and by means of investigating the nature of emptiness. The Buddha himself said that in coming to an understanding of emptiness, do not rely upon solely do not solely rely upon scripture authority, but mainly rely upon your own reasoning. So, in that same text the Buddha went on to say that one is not to accept my teachings simply out of respect or liking for myself That is not sufficient reason.

So, the Buddha went on to say, The reason that I teach is to benefit the students, those disciples. And I teach in varied manners according to each of the students. And therefore, simply to accept what I say out of faith in me is not sufficient, but one must analyze it and reason with it according to one individual understanding. So, how are we to carry on an investigation of the teachings as to their actual validity? We analyze in the manner of three pronged analysis to determine whether the teaching is valid or not.

And upon seeing no fault, upon applying the three pronged analysis, then we can accept it. So we are to apply this threefold analysis with respect to the teachings. The analogy which is made use of is that in the case of the buying of gold, that when one purchases gold, of course, the seller is going to say it’s of the highest quality, but we cannot simply accept it on the word of the seller, that we have to assay the gold. There’s a threefold method of assaying the gold. First, it’s burnt, and upon burning, this is a coarse way to investigate.

If that passes that test, then it is cut. This is a more subtle way of assaying the gold. Finally, it is rubbed with a black stone to see whether a mark is left upon the gold. If this test is satisfied, then we can understand the fine quality of the gold and we can be assured that it is, in fact, pure. The same threefold analysis is to be applied to assaying the teachings as to their validity and their purity.

We are to apply an analytic reason to the a process of analysis to the teachings of the Buddha. There are three levels of analysis which we are to apply to whatever has been taught. The first of these is that it should not be there should be no fault found through means of direct cognition. The types of valid cognition, the first is of direct cognition. It should not in any way be contradicted by our direct cognition of the way things are.

Having passed that test, then it should be not contradicted by an inference by means of cogent evidence, or influenced by another way of translating inference by means of the actual fact. Inference by means of the actual fact or cogent evidence. Having passed that test, then we go on to the most subtle, and that is to say it should be not contradicted by inference of conviction. Then, whatever the teaching is, if it is able to withstand analysis and not to be contradicted by means of this threefold reasoning, threefold analytic process, then it can be safely said to be without fault, is valid, and can be accepted and trusted as being actual fact. Emptiness is a subtle phenomenon, and it’s necessary to let it be understood through reason analysis.

It cannot be understood solely on the basis of scriptural authority. It is by means of exercising our reason analysis, making use of our reasoning, that we will develop our wisdom. In general, the reasoned understanding of emptiness is presented by Nāgārjuna in his treatise on the Fundamental Wisdom in almost an infinite variety of methods in order to settle the meaning of emptiness. The meaning of emptiness is settled by means of hundreds of infinite variety of reasons. As was mentioned, that Nāgārjuna presents in his Fundamental Treatise on Wisdom almost an infinite variety of reasons as a means to settle the meaning of emptiness.

Present text, Entering into the Middle Way, composed by Candrakīrti, is a commentary written to the treatise. It, Candrakīrti seeks to multiply the number of reasons and to clarify those reasonings. Because what is being mainly taught is emptiness, and we are seeking to understand the meaning of emptiness, we must make use of the reasonings by which we understand the meaning of emptiness. Mainly we’re going to present the various reasons by means of which we can meditate on coming to an understanding. In order to come to an understanding of reasonings, we can make use of five modes of reasoning. These are the- by this is, we can make use of correct signs or correct reasons, and there are five.

So, the first is in terms of entity as assigned. We are analyzing as to whether the entity of all phenomena are truly existent or not. In order to come to an understanding of that, we determine by means of the reason one or many. One or many. So, beginning to investigate as to the entity, whether the entity is truly existent or not, and we’re going to take as our basis of illustration a sprout.

And sprout in Tibetan language is nyugu. And this was taken directly from the Indian, the Hindi, the Sanskrit kyugu. The language of India was nirguh, and it was taken directly into Tibetan as nirguh, and maybe we can take it into the Austrian language as nirguh. But anyway, it means the sprout. And a sprout is, you know, a farmer plants his field, maybe corn or rice or barley, and a shoot arises.

This small shoot is what we’re talking about, what we call a nougou or a sprout. So, first reasoning is really an excellent reasoning in establishing non true existence. We’re going to analyze the sprout itself, the entity of the sprout itself as to whether truly exists or not. We’re going to analyze it in terms of the reason of one and many. The first one we’re going to first type of reasoning will be in terms of entity.

The second line of reasoning will involve the cause. A sprout arises from a cause. That is to say something produces the sprout. So we’re going to investigate, we’re going to analyze whether the cause of the sprout is truly existent or not. The reasoning that we’re going to make use of is called the diamond slivers reasoning, reasoning by way of the called the diamond slivers.

The first is that we’re going to reason in terms of entity. The second, we’re going to reason in terms of the cause. The third mode of reasoning, we’re going to reason in terms of the result. The sprout is itself a result, but it also gives rise to a result. So we’re going to analyze the result or the effect or the result of the sprout as to whether the result of that sprout is truly existent or not.

The line of reasoning we’re going to make use of is called, and I might have to change this name, is called the refutation of production as to existent or nonexistent. That’s the type of reasoning that we’re going to make use of. So this is a very detailed way of reasoning. We’re going to look at whether the entity that is the sprout itself is truly existent or not, and whether the cause of the sprout is truly existent or not, whether the result of the sprout is truly existent or not. Then the fourth mode of reasoning, we say, Well, if each of those are not truly existent, maybe both are truly existent.

So, we’re going to see whether the cause and the result taken together are truly existent or not. The line of reasoning that we make use of is called refutation of production, refutation of the four modes of production. Then the fifth line of reasoning is called the king of reasonings, and this is the reasoning in terms of dependent arising. So, these five lines of reasoning are extremely powerful and very beneficial. according to a verse in which the Buddha is speaking about what is the root sentient beings wandering in cyclic existence and continually experiencing suffering.

The Buddha was said to have compassion hundreds of times greater than that of a parent for their child. Just as in the case of when a child is suffering, the parents are unable to sleep or eat, and due to their great compassion and caring for their child. Likewise, the Buddha constantly was concerned about freeing beings from their suffering and always was seeking means and methods whereby to free them from their suffering. So, the Buddha sought the root of the continual process of wandering within cyclic existence. He saw that all of the various sufferings traced back to the obscured ignorance, which prevented one from understanding emptiness, peace, and the unborn.

So, the Buddha set forth these five reasonings as a means by which to understand emptiness, peace, birthlessness rather than unborn. Birthlessness. Mainly, the first three reasonings among the first three reasonings, the first

Key terms in this teaching

cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top