2 h 6 min · 6,893 words · 13 March 2013 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this two-hour teaching on emptiness, Kyabje Rinpoche uses a simple table to explain how all phenomena lack inherent, independent existence. He establishes bodhicitta motivation, then walks through how things exist conventionally—through their components and our mental labeling—but not ultimately through their own nature. He applies this to objects, mind, and persons. The practical section addresses meditation on emptiness: maintaining balanced analytical insight and calm abiding, handling distraction and drowsiness, and avoiding the mistaken view that phenomena don’t exist. An extended Q&A explores how emptiness applies to mind, whether phenomena can exist without conscious perception, and whether formal retreat is needed before meditating on emptiness. Intended for practitioners with grounding in Mahāyāna philosophy.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2013-03-13 – KR.mp3
UUID: 92c6823f-0f62-4642-9136-48b2e7b89081
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Emptiness
Date: 2013-03-13
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~6,888
Today, we shall continue the study of Acharya Kamalaśīla’s stages of meditation, the Bhāvanākrama and how to train in it in the Mahāyāna tradition. So we should listen to these teachings with as a foundation not the wish for happiness in this life, but the wish for happiness in the future lives onwards at least. Generally speaking, all of us wish for happiness. However, if we are able to, we should strive for a happiness which is beyond this life and not merely for the happiness of this life. So we shall listen today to these teachings on the Mahāyāna with the wish of obtaining a stable happiness in future lives.
And to listen to this, we should reflect on the fact that we have at present obtained a precious human rebirth and that not only is this rare and difficult to obtain, but in addition, we do not wish it to go to waste. Since the Mahāyāna dharma, which we shall be listening to today, becomes a pure or an impure Dharma in function exclusively of the motivation with which it is listened to, we must create a motivation of love, compassion and bodhicitta which upholds the activities of listening. The practices of love and compassion are of benefit in whichever country we find ourselves in. And in addition, these practices are of benefit to ourselves. Generally speaking, in this world of ours, there are three categories of beings.
There are those who have a religious practice, those who completely reject all forms of religious practice, and those in between who are undecided. And the first category, those who have religious practice of their own can be Christian, Jewish, Muslim, or Buddhist. As for those who totally reject and abhor religion, they believe that religion hinders human development and the development of human society and is akin to a poison. There are many of this opinion such as the late Mao Zedong. This viewpoint arises from ignorance regarding religion and is a clear sign of misunderstanding of the short term or contingent and ultimate goals of religions.
Because if one understands the short term and ultimate goal of the great religions, they are of benefit to mankind. We can see, for instance, that being ordained certainly is of no harm to others, whether one is a fully ordained monk or a nun. Now in the case of Tibetans, there might be some debate since after all, the Tibetans are very few in numbers, and clearly ordination reduces the birth rate. Let alone this, it is clear that the practice of Dharma is not harmful to society since the practice of Dharma or of religions in general leads to a betterment of the mental outlook of the individual to an increase in empathy, in compassion, and in love for others, and these are of benefit to society at large. One of the biggest threats our societies face at at present is terrorism and criminality.
It is clear that terrorism and criminality are powerfully countered by the development of love of compassion and an increase in empathy. Within the categories of beings which we talked about, those who are definite in their membership of a great religion and those who reject utterly all religions, clearly the last category experiences tremendous suffering at the time of death. If we analyze carefully this last category of person, someone who accepts no religion or spirituality of any type, when this person is beset by great suffering, we should analyze carefully to see whether such a person has the means to counter or to eliminate the suffering. We will find that they have very few possibilities to do so. On the other hand, those who are religious and within them, those who are Buddhist, when the time comes for them to undergo the pangs of agony and of death, definitely will derive great benefit from their religious and their spiritual practice.
We have direct experience of this at this center. One of the terminally ill patients, Geshe-la went to visit at the hospital at his request, had just been told he had six months left to live by his doctors and was in a state of extreme mental anguish. When Geshe-la met him, the first thing Geshe-la tried to see was whether he had some type of religious background or not. And he told Geshe-la he had a distant connection with Buddhism. Then Geshe-la explained some basic Buddhist concepts to him.
It turned out to have been of such great benefit that as soon as this gentleman was released from the hospital, he came and spent the last two days of the teachings on the Four Noble Truths with us here undergoing tremendous hardship despite his disease. And therefore, if we understand the Buddhist teachings and train them, there will be tremendous benefit for us. The teachings on love and on compassion are not exclusive to Buddhism. We find teachings on love and compassion in Islam, in Judaism, in Christianity, and they are of benefit in all these traditions. Then if one is religious and within the category of religious persons, if one is a Buddhist and not just a mere verbal Buddhist, but someone who is a fully characterized Buddhist who has the characteristics of a Buddhist, then our life would have been spent meaningfully.
It is difficult to become a Buddhist through merely saying, I am a Buddhist nor is it terribly meaningful to say, I am a Buddhist. What is meaningful is instead to put in practice the advice which is contained in the Buddhist scriptures so as to eliminate the faults from our mind and to purify our minds. We have given here numerous explanations on how to train and love compassion and bodhicitta. However, it is of little benefit to listen to these without putting them in practice. It is also of very little benefit for those who explain them not to put them in prac into practice.
Such people cause great trouble. If one knows all of the fine points of the Buddhist teachings but has put nothing into practice, one will be of no benefit whatsoever to oneself and one will be of no benefit to others. Let alone this, if the Buddha Śākyamūni came to try to teach that person, he or she would derive no benefit from that. And the reason for which it is said that for such a person, the coming of the Buddha would be of no benefit is because such a person actually knows the Dharma they should be practicing and yet they do not practice it. The Buddha has nothing else to impart but that advice and practice.
If that is not engaged in, what point is there in the manifestation of the Buddha? And therefore, if we put in practice well what we have understood of the Buddhist teachings progressively, the mental afflictions and imaginations which we undergo will progressively disappear and our mental happiness will increase. And therefore, I have confidence that you understand what I explained here, but I beg you to please put into practice what is taught here. And if you put them into practice and one can say that Geshe-la’s teachings were of benefit, then his coming here would have been meaningful. And therefore, today to listen to these teachings on the Bhāvanākrama, whose goal is to act as a cause for attaining the state of omniscience we must have as a motivation bodhicitta.
And therefore, our motivation for listening to these teachings must be in accordance or must meet with bodhicitta. And regarding the goal of full enlightenment, there are two types of bodhicitta. There is both a bodhicitta, which is a longing for the attainment of the goal of full enlightenment, is known as longing bodhicitta, sometimes wishing bodhicitta. And there is that bodhicitta which actually engages in the practices to attain full enlightenment, which is known as engaging bodhicitta. And therefore, the motivation we should generate today is through thinking that we must set all sentient beings without exception in a state of full enlightenment, take the pledge to do so ourselves, and on this basis resolve to listen to these teachings on the Bhāvanākrama.
This is the motivation which we should generate. Generally speaking, the Buddhist teachings are subdivided into two, the lower vehicle and the greater vehicle. The lower vehicle is a vehicle of those who wish to attain a stable happiness for themselves and engage in practice with this as their goal. Whereas the greater vehicle is the vehicle of those who relinquish their own will and wish to attain a state of ultimate omniscience for the sake of all sentient beings without exception. And since the dharma we are listening today is a Dharma of the great vehicle of the Mahāyāna, we should eliminate self-cherishing or egoism from within our minds and replace it by altruism or cherishing others.
Let us therefore meditate as follows for one minute to generate bodhicitta. Let us first think, I must place all sentient beings without exception in the state of unalloyed happiness, a state of full enlightenment. I have pledged to do so, yet I lack the power to do so. Who has the power or the capacity to do so? The fully enlightened Buddha does.
Therefore, I must become fully enlightened to place all sentient beings in that state. This is meditating on bodhicitta. As it says in the Mahayānasūtrālamkara,, the ornament of the Mahāyāna Sutras with an insight rooted in powerful calm abiding, eliminate the afflictions. The meaning of this verse is that the root of the of of all suffering is the afflictions and that the foremost means to eliminate the afflictions is through a wisdom which severs their root. While there are numerous types of afflictions or kleshas, the very root of all afflictions or kleshas is ignorance.
Ignorance is that mental factor which is obscured regarding the ultimate mode of existence of objects of knowledge. That ignorance, which is the root of all afflictions, is countered by the wisdom which realizes the selflessness of persons, which is its main antidote. Because we do not understand the antidote to this ignorance which misapprehends phenomena, our mind is greatly troubled. This mental troubling, this mental these mental difficulties in turn give rise to numerous erroneous fancies, and these in turn give rise to afflictions such as desire, envy, and so forth. And therefore, to eradicate the afflictions which beset us, we must eliminate this mental troubling and to eliminate these mental difficulties which we face, we must in turn give rise to a wisdom, understanding selflessness, which counters the ignorance, which misapprehends the ultimate nature of phenomena.
And therefore, wishing to eliminate this obscuration which does not apprehend the ultimate nature of objects of knowledge, we must give rise to a wisdom which does apprehend the ultimate nature of objects of knowledge. There is no means to counter this mind which misapprehends the ultimate nature of phenomena than with a mind which apprehends the correct ultimate nature of phenomena. And to counter this ignorance which is obscured with respect to phenomena, we ourselves as practitioners must generate the antidotes. Our friends and relatives cannot eliminate this misapprehension of the nature phenomena within our mind stream nor can our wealth or financial resources. We ourselves alone have to do this.
And therefore, since it is critical to understand the actual antidotes to this ignorance, which is obscured regarding the ultimate nature of phenomena and that these antidotes are both the subtle selflessness of persons and the subtle selflessness of phenomena. I will explain in detail these based on our commentary. To understand correctly emptiness, it is critical to understand first that which it counters or that which it refutes, its so called object of refutation, its so-called gakcha. If one understands emptiness correctly, there are extraordinary benefits. Buddha Śākyamūni said that there is greater benefit in understanding in-depth one verse referring to emptiness than in building as many stupas as there are grains of sand in the Ganges River.
Someone who has good karmic imprints regarding emptiness will respond to hearing teachings on emptiness by physical manifestations such as having his or her hair stand on end, having tears spring into the eyes and so forth. Then when someone like that receives teachings on emptiness, they are of extreme benefit for him. Therefore, I will start explaining emptiness slowly, and I will be checking you out. It is said that for one who has such a good foundation for the understanding of emptiness, it is important that to such a one, emptiness be clearly explained. This is the principal foundation on which emptiness is explained.
In addition to such an audience or such a listener, someone who even though he or she is not such a supreme trainee, nonetheless has a great wish to hear about emptiness, has faith in the teacher, and is putting striving into it in a non partial way is an adequate trainee for teachings on emptiness. However, one must be wary in teaching emptiness since there is great danger if emptiness is taught to an unsuitable listener, both for the listener and for the teacher. It is said that both will be reborn in the hell realms. So since this text contains extensive explanations on emptiness, it would be incorrect for me not to talk about emptiness, but as it is a dangerous topic, I shall do so warily. And then even if you don’t enjoy teachings on emptiness, Geshe-la begs you please do not give rise to a negative mindset, but at least remain neutral with with respect to the teachings.
When we speak of emptiness, we are speaking of the emptiness of something. It is the emptiness of the object of negation or the object of refutation. The non establishment of that object of refutation is what is meant by emptiness. Generally speaking, one can explain emptiness on whichever basis one chooses to do. It is frequently done on the basis of the person.
It could just as well be done on the basis of a table. Geshe-la will use his table as an example. The different schools of tenets have different presentations of emptiness. The Svatāntrika Mādhyamika presentation is a more subtle presentation than that of the Cittamātra or the Vaibhāṣika school. And the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika presentation is yet more subtle again than the Svatāntrika Mādhyamika one.
Studying the presentation of emptiness in the lower systems of tenets as a prelude to gaining realization of the presentation of emptiness in the higher system of tenets. If we have to posit a foundation, it is clear that the ultimate view is that of the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika or the consequentialist middle way school. However, it is of great benefit to understand viewpoint that viewpoint to understand that of the preceding school, the Svatāntrika Mādhyamika School. Since the author of this treatise, the stages of meditation, the Bhāvanākrama is Acharya Kamalaśīla and his viewpoint was that of the Svatāntrika Mādhyamika School, Geshe-la will explain emptiness from the standpoint of the Svatāntrika Mādhyamika School. If we take the case of this table, this table is able to perform the activities of a table from the standpoint of the conglomerate of the components of this table.
In addition, there is also a process of conceptual and nominal imputation on the table from the standpoint of the mind apprehending the table. The reason for which this table is able to perform the activities of a table from the standpoint of its components or its constituents is that if it was merely through nominal and conceptual imputation, then if we were to impute the name of table to that ventilator, that ventilator should be able to perform the function of the table which it is not able to do. However, it is not sufficient that the table be able to perform the function of a table from the standpoint of its components or its constituents. In addition to this, the mind apprehending the table must impute tableness or the name table upon that table. And the reason for which it is necessary in addition to the components of the table being able to perform the activity of a table that there be a mental and nominal imputation of tableness on this table is because before there is such a mental and nominal imputation of tableness on table, the components of the table alone cannot perform the function of a table.
Have you understood So the mindset which considers that table is established independently on its components alone and is not established independently on its components as well as on the mind imputing table on its components is called the apprehension of a self of phenomena. The object of refutation here is table’s the components of table’s capacity to perform the function of a table without any mental or conceptual, excuse me, any mental or nominal imputation of tableness on those components. So this is what is posited as the object of refutation through reasoning. Now, how do we actually perceive table? We perceive table naturally as being able to perform the functions of a table in dependence on its components without any intervention of the mind which imputes table as well as a nominal imputation of table on the basis of those components.
The term true existence refers to the table’s capacity to perform these functions independently and exclusively on its components without depending in the slightest on the mind imputing table on it or on the name table imputed on it. So all other phenomena apart from table, minds, persons and so forth, lack true existence in the self same way as table. Then the very self same thing could be said about the person, then Geshe-la will continue to present this topic in accordance with the text. It is said that, the mind, does indeed exist as designation. It does not exist ultimately neither in the beginning nor in the middle nor in the end.
Since the mind is not established ultimately in the beginning, the middle, or the end, the mind is said not to be established ultimately. Even though the non ultimate establishment of all phenomena must be perceived by the mind that mind itself is also non ultimately established. And therefore, such a mind which apprehends the non ultimate existence, the non true existence of phenomena is itself not established by its own nature, not ultimately existent. The ultimate wisdom which investigates the ultimate nature of all phenomena ascertains their non ultimate existence, their non true existence. Such a a wisdom of ultimate investigation does not see or perceive true existence.
Therefore, there is no truly existing permanence nor is there any truly existing impermanence. And if there is no inherently existing form, there is likewise no inherently existing arising from causes, from conditions, no inherently existing contaminatedness or uncontaminatedness and so forth. In the same same way as the wisdom of ultimate investigation is unable to find a truly existing form, it is likewise unable to find truly existing aspects of any of the four remaining aggregates. In other words, it is unable to find truly existing sensations, compositional factors, truly existing sensations, truly existing discriminations, compositional factors, and consciousnesses. And therefore, in the self same way as this wisdom is of ultimate investigation is unable to find a truly existing form aggregate, likewise, it is unable to find truly existing remaining aggregates.
When the yogi after investigating all phenomena’s ultimate mode of existence using an ultimate wisdom ascertains that they lack any true existence and focuses on this with a Samādhi, with a concentration, that concentration becomes an ultimate concentration. At that point, understanding that there are no phenomena which exist ultimately, the realization of non ultimate existence is born. To eliminate the afflictions and their root, the ignorance which misapprehends the ultimate nature of phenomena, it is indispensable to realize the non ultimate existence of all things. Otherwise, worldly wisdoms are incapable of severing ignorance which is which is at the root of all afflictions. If one does not investigate phenomena using an ultimate wisdom, it is impossible to gain the realization of the non ultimate existence of phenomena.
That wisdom which realizes the ultimate mode of abiding, i.e., the absence of any type of ultimate existence of all phenomena, severs or destroys ignorance in the self same way as kindling is destroyed by the fire which it lights. And the Buddha himself stated that the ultimate wisdom realizing the non ultimate existence of all phenomena can sever the root of the afflictions, which is ignorance in the self same way as the fire lit within kindling destroys the kindling. As the Buddha stated in the Ratnamegha Sūtra, the yogi who wishes to be free of all thoughts must necessarily meditate on emptiness. To meditate on emptiness, we need both a calm abiding whose object is emptiness and an insight focused on emptiness.
In the same same way as to realize insight, we need as a preliminary to have realized calm abiding. Likewise, to realize an insight which is focused on emptiness, we need as a preliminary a calm abiding which is focused on emptiness. And then in the same way as in the general explanation of calm abiding, when we train in a calm abiding focused on emptiness, if the mind is scattered outwards, it must be brought back to the object of focus. And once the yogi has focused on the emptiness of true existence with a mind of calm abiding, he becomes a yogi who is characterized by the emptiness of true existence. It is not possible to give rise to the realization of the non true existence of phenomena through a mere worldly consciousness.
This can only happen through a wisdom which investigates the aspects of phenomena ultimately. And therefore, we should train in a Samādhi or a concentration in which the wisdom which is examining form ultimately investigates whether form is truly established or non truly established. A Samādhi which is focused on forms abiding in a state of true existence will not be an authentic Samādhi. And therefore one should meditate on a Samādhi which is focused on phenomena, specifically form not abiding in a state of true establishment. And an ultimate wisdom which investigates whether phenomena are truly established or not and dwells in the non true establishment of phenomena and specifically form is a supreme wisdom.
This was asserted by the Buddha in the sūtra of the Sūtra of the Treasure of Space as well as in the Crown Ornament sūtra. And therefore, one should settle in meditative equipoise upon the lack of true existence of form and of phenomena in general. There is no ultimate meditative equipoise apart from these. And one should over and again meditate on this profound absence of form and of phenomena of any type of true existence. If the mind is focused in this way on the non true existence of phenomena, it will not be scattered or distracted outwards.
Should it happen that the mind focused on the non true existence of phenomena and the form is scattered outwards, So desire for instance, one should examine the causes of desire and the conditions which give rise to desire to bring the mind back inwards. And should an object be the cause of the mind’s being scattered outwards from the object of concentration through desire, then one should meditate on the ugliness and the filthiness of the object to counter this. Alternatively, if the mind is scattered away from the object of focus, one should bring it back on the object of focus through reflecting on the numerous qualities of samadhi or concentration. Alternatively, instead of focusing on the numerous qualities of concentration to bring the the mind back inwards on the object of focus, one can also focus on the numerous thoughts of distraction to bring the mind back to the object of concentration. And then once the mind has been brought back inwards, it will be focused very swiftly again on its object of reference, which is emptiness.
Alternatively, should the mind which is single pointedly focused on emptiness become lethargic and even afflicted by sleep? At this point, in the self same way as in the general training on calm abiding, one should apply the antidotes. In other words, one should reflect on whatever uplifts the mind. Reflecting on whatever uplifts and makes the mind joyous will eliminate sinking. And then once sinking has been eliminated, once again, we want you to focus on the object of reference emptiness.
While meditating single pointedly on emptiness, it can happen that the mind is distracted outwards through agitation, recollecting previous pleasant events, laughter, and play. At this point, the mind should be brought back to the object of concentration and its intensity should be lowered to reflecting on impermanence and death. And then, when the mind has once again been brought back on the object of concentration, one should continue meditating single pointedly on emptiness. When neither sinking nor agitation arise, while the mind is single pointedly focused on emptiness, at this point, it is appropriate to reduce the striving one engages in and to relax the mind somewhat. Whenever one meditates in this way, one must be constantly aware of whether or not interfering factors such as agitation or sinking occur.
And as soon as one of the interfering factors, let us say sinking arises, it is imperative to apply at once the antidote to sinking. Otherwise, if one continues to meditate on emptiness with sinking, it will be impossible to attain insight with emptiness as an object. And therefore, the calm abiding which is single pointedly focused on emptiness needs a factor of wisdom. In the same way as if the analytical factor, the factor of wisdom investigating emptiness within the context of insight becomes too powerful, And in turn, the factor of concentration dwindles, the mind will be unstable in just the same way as a lamp put in a hallway in which there is a strong breeze. Likewise, if the insight which is focused on suchness becomes too powerful at the expense of the calm abiding or the śamatha focused on suchness, it is appropriate to increase the strength of calm abiding.
It is also inappropriate when one meditates for the calm abiding which is focused on emptiness to be too powerful at the expense of the insight focused on emptiness. They must be equal in intensity. As soon as the calm abiding focused on emptiness and the insight focused on emptiness are equal in their intensity, one should continue meditating in this way on emptiness for so long as this does not cause physical discomfort. When physical discomfort arises, one should reflect on the fact that forms are akin to illusion, to mirages and to dreams. Or reflect on the fact that it is precisely because sentient beings have not realized emptiness that they transmigrate endlessly within cyclic existence.
And at this point, one should meditate on the fact that oneself will teach meditation on emptiness to all sentient beings and train in love and compassion. And then even though one may be meditating forcefully on emptiness, all difficulties will disappear. And then as soon as they have disappeared, one focuses once again on emptiness. Then should mental difficulties appear, what should dispel them in the same way? So what is critical here is the inseparable union of a calm abiding and an insight focused on emptiness.
It is critical here that they be of equal strength. And then one can stay meditating with the union of calm abiding and insight focused on emptiness for however long one wishes to stay for one day, one week, one month or longer. And Buddha Śākyamūni taught in the Lankavatara Sūtra, the Sūtra of the Descent into Lanka, that such a wisdom is indeed a true wisdom. If one wishes to interrupt the meditative session at this point, then when one rises from the meditative session, one should be profoundly convinced that even though phenomena lack inherent existence, they nonetheless have an illusion like conventional existence. Otherwise, if rising from meditation on emptiness, one thinks phenomena are not only non inherently and non ultimately existent, they simply do not exist, then at this point, one will have destroyed the foundations for karma and causality.
While karma and causality, past and future lives or for that matter, full omniscience do exist, they do not exist inherently or ultimately. Is why the Buddha said that the designation of the generation of phenomena exists, yet they do not exist ultimately. Ordinary beings such as ourselves are beset by the conviction that phenomena are established inherently. Such a mind is a mistaken state of mind. It is in dependence on this mistaken mind that we have remained in cyclic existence up to now.
And therefore, one must at this point reflect, will, in this way, accumulate the peerless collections of both merit and wisdom. The foremost obstacle to the attainment of the state of full enlightenment are the apprehension of a self of persons and of a self of phenomena. And to counter this, one must obtain the understanding of the selflessness of both persons and of phenomena. And since the realization of emptiness is indispensable, I must realize emptiness. At this point, it is of tremendous benefit to offer prostrations to the Buddhas in the 10 directions as well as praises and to perform the seven limb offering.
And at this point, we are engaging in the practices of the perfection of generosity, of ethics and of forbearance, one will accumulate a vast amount of merit. I will stop here for today. Are you tired? If one does not understand the foundation of emptiness correctly, after this everything which ensues is difficult. Then I started with an easy presentation of emptiness because I was quite worried of the impact of this text on your minds.
And we will talk quietly about the object of observation of meditation and emptiness and so forth. So we will stop here for today and Geshe-la will address at present your questions and your doubts. Okay. I’ll try and articulate this clearly. I find it’s not easy.
I understand emptiness in relation to material phenomena because, I guess I can visualize breaking the object down into its component parts, but I struggle with nonmaterial phenomena such as the mind. And so I wonder if that could be elaborated on a little further. So it’s the same thing with mind. We understand the emptiness of mind from the standpoint components of clarity and cognitiveness, then it is on the basis of these components of clarity and cognitiveness that the term mind is imputed. Without these components, there is no such thing as mind.
So whichever phenomenon we investigate in this way, it is critical to establish to establish what the basis of imputation on which the designation is affixed is. This can be done for every single phenomenon. Once it is done, we can see that the phenomenon cannot exist from the standpoint of its basis of designation alone, but also must exist from the standpoint of the mind imputing something onto it. If we take the example of Geshe-la’s table, a Geshe-la’s table is technically known as the basis of imputation. It is specifically the components of the table which are the basis of imputation.
The imputer on the other hand are the names or the mind of Geshe-la which imputes or affixes tableness to table. What is refuted is the existence of the object of table independent exclusively on its basis of imputation. Likewise, what is also refuted is the existence of the object table independent exclusively on the imputer. I’ll try and ask my question as well. So in relation to the existence of tableness, I understand that it cannot exist without mind, and that I also understand that phenomena cannot exist ultimately.
What I’m concerned about is is the dinosaurs. So dinosaurs. So I understand that our minds now can apprehend dinosaurs, but what was happening sixty million years ago when So in a nutshell, there is no such thing as an unperceived phenomenon ever. For instance, it is taught in Buddhism that the universe is cyclical and passes through stages of creation and destruction. However, every single one of the stages is perceived by some category of sentient being.
The universe goes through these cycles of destruction. Does that answer your question? So does that mean in a way like the dinosaurs were sentient beings, so they were making those observations? Or I mean, what what was doing what’s been doing with perception? What was perceiving?
Even when take one universe is being created, there are beings from other universes which perceive the creation of this universe. Hesitant about giving a full explanation of this topic because he feels there are issues you will not accept. Therefore, he doesn’t see a lot of point in doing that. Normally, this is explained in the light of omniscience, that every single phenomenon is perceived by an omniscient mind. But if you don’t believe in omniscience, then this is unconvincing.
Omniscience. Omniscience. Omniscience. Omniscience. Omniscience.
Yes. Why is a realization of emptiness not sufficient for enlightenment by itself? The reason for which the mere direct realization of emptiness on the path of seeing is not sufficient to mean that one has attained instantaneously for enlightenment is because at the time of the direct realization of emptiness, we eliminate all conceptions which perceive phenomena as inherently or truly existent. However, because of prior predispositions, karmic imprints in other words for seeing phenomena as truly existent, we do not eliminate the innate perception of phenomena as truly existent. This must be eliminated on what is known as the path of meditation.
In the teaching last week, said that phenomena, the phenomena is none other than the factor of the mind, the only appearing factor of the mind. And is it the same as mental projection? I don’t think I can translate mental projection in Tibetan. What what do you mean by mental projection? There’s a very close connection between these two, between the fact that all phenomena of the nature of mind and that all phenomena are imputed by mind in this system of thought.
So the meaning is broadly speaking the same. However, the object of refutation is not. So the meaning is very similar, but the meaning of what is refuted is slightly different between these two. So when one speaks of the factor of appearance, one speaks of something which is outside there. Whereas when one speaks of imputing something of phenomena, one speaks of an activity onto phenomena.
So the meaning which is understood is a bit different. For instance, if we take Geshe-la’s table, if Geshe-la tells you that this table is of the nature of mind and if he then says this table is an imputation of the mind, you have a different understanding of these two. Don’t you? Even though this table appears to the eye consciousness, when we speak of an imputation on the table, we are not merely speaking of the way it appears to the eye consciousness. Okay.
Oh, yes. Please. Please. Please. Nothing else is necessary apart from the tables apart from the table being able to perform the function of table in dependence on its component and the mind imputing tableness on the table.
However, you need a good mind, in other words, a non mistaken mind which imputes tableness on the basis of imputation. We have all sorts of minds, don’t we? I have two questions, Ilya. The first one is really just following on from what Dewa was asking. Is it all right for us to work on understanding that we’re imputing table onto the table as also understanding that the table is the nature of mind?
Is it all right to examine both of those, you know, at similar time? At the same time? Definitely. Each of these benefits the other. Yeah.
Yeah. Diggy. Second question is, last week, Geshe-la talked about doing the six month calm abiding retreat and that it’s really only once you’ve done that that you can actually achieve special insight. And I haven’t actually scheduled in a calm abiding retreat for this year. So up until the time that that gets scheduled in, will is it how much am I, like, allowed to meditate on emptiness?
Like, should I be doing as much as I can? Because there’s this I suppose my perception from what we talked about doing a calm abiding retreat is that it’s sort of only then that you’re really ready to meditate correctly on emptiness. Definitely, you can meditate on emptiness. Ah. Very good.
Tony and Jasmine. Just two quick questions as well. Thank you, Geshe-la. The nature of mind, the table is in the nature of mind. I’m wondering whose mind?
Is this the omniscient mind we referred to? Is it our individual, self identified mind? When we speak of table being of the nature of mind, we must analyze very carefully what is meant. Every individual being when he or she perceives a table is actually constructing a table in dependence on his or her own mind. Table is both realized by valid cognition and is also established by the individual valid cognitions of beings.
Let’s just take an example. If we take the example of Geshe-la’s glass and imagine it filled with water and three beings, a god, a human being and a preta perceiving it simultaneously. The god perceives it as filled with nectar. The human being perceives it as filled with water and the preta perceives it as filled with blood and pus. The nectar is established by the valid cognizer of the god.
The water is established by the valid cognizer of the human being. Whereas the blood and pus is established by the valid cognizer of the preta. Therefore, the nectar is of the nature of the valid cognizer of the god. The water is of the nature of the valid cognizer of the human being and the blood and pus is of the nature of the valid cognizer of the preta. So in the case of the table, which is a shared object of observation, this table is established for each of us by the valid cognizers within our minds and is of the nature of the valid cognizer of one’s own person who is perceiving it.
Such a wisdom is a true wisdom as you quoted. Such a wisdom is true wisdom, I think, towards the end of Geshe-la’s teaching. And I just wanted to clarify what how you how true is defined. Is that true as in truly existing? Truly established?
There’s no such thing as an inherently existing or truly existing phenomenon. What is meant by correct or ultimate wisdom is a wisdom whose object is the ultimate mode of existence of phenomena. Just clarifying about valid cognizer. I thought valid cognizer meant like a clear light mind. So I wouldn’t have thought that a preta could have a valid, be a valid cognizer.
Now here, first, it is not true that all valid cognizers are minds of clear light. And here, it is in addition inappropriate to speak of minds of clear light since it’s a specifically tantric topic. The mind of clear light only arises during sleep, but specifically during the death state. All valid cognizers are not minds of clear light. So valid cognizers are very easy to understand.
There are valid cognizers which are eye consciousnesses, ear consciousnesses, nose consciousnesses and so forth. If we take the example of Geshe-la’s glass, the very first time a mind sees Geshe-la’s glass and that mind is unmistaken, that mind is a valid cognizer. So there’s nothing very complicated about valid cognizers for all phenomena or all objects of knowledge. The first time a mind perceives them in an unmistaken way, that mind is a valid cognizer. Yes.
I’m afraid it’s 09:00. If you have no if you’re not tired, Geshe-la is not tired. One of the reasons I have a better understanding of material phenomena is because of actually one of the presentations you did on quantum physics. And I can’t recall if it was on that specific presentation or another one that you’ve done. You discussed dark matter, and its uncertain nature.
Does that mean dark matter is not perceived by an omniscient mind or would that simply our minds don’t perceive it? There is no single phenomenon which is not perceived by a valid cognizer. Does it follow then? I’m trying to figure out what dark matter is then. Is it a nonphenomenon because it’s not perceived by us?
We don’t know what it is. So Geshe-la doesn’t understand modern physics. He can’t answer your question. All he can say is that from the standpoint of Buddhist philosophy, all objects of knowledge are perceived by valid cognizers. Yeah, yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Okay.
Key terms in this teaching
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- clear light ö sel (Tib)
- The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- preta
- Hungry ghost, or spirit. The preta realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
How is the emptiness of nonmaterial phenomena such as the mind understood, and what is the basis of imputation for mind?
Mind is understood in the same way as other phenomena. Its basis of imputation is its components of clarity and cognitiveness, and the term mind is imputed on the basis of these. Without them there is no such thing as mind. For any phenomenon, it is critical to establish what the basis of imputation is, on which the designation is affixed. Once this is done, it can be seen that the phenomenon cannot exist from the standpoint of its basis of designation alone, but must also exist from the standpoint of the mind imputing something onto it. In the example of a table, the components of the table are the basis of imputation, and the imputer is the name or the mind that affixes tableness to it.
Why is a direct realization of emptiness on the path of seeing not enough to bring instant enlightenment?
At the moment of directly realizing emptiness on the path of seeing, all conceptions that perceive phenomena as inherently or truly existent are eliminated. However, because of prior predispositions, meaning karmic imprints for seeing phenomena as truly existent, the innate perception of phenomena as truly existent is not eliminated. This innate perception must be eliminated on what is known as the path of meditation. So the direct realization of emptiness alone does not mean one has instantly attained enlightenment.
When it is said that a table is of the nature of mind, whose mind is meant: an omniscient mind or our own individual mind?
The claim needs careful analysis. Each being who perceives a table is constructing it in dependence on their own mind, and the table is established by the individual valid cognizers of beings. As an example, a glass of water is seen at once by a god, a human and a preta. The god sees nectar, the human sees water, and the preta sees blood and pus. Each is established by that being's own valid cognizer, so each is of the nature of that being's valid cognizer. Likewise, a table, though a shared object of observation, is established for each of us by the valid cognizers in our own minds. It is of the nature of the valid cognizer of the person perceiving it.
Is a valid cognizer the same as a clear light mind, so that a preta could not have one?
Not all valid cognizers are minds of clear light. Clear light is also not appropriate to discuss here, since it is a specifically tantric topic, and the mind of clear light arises specifically in the death state. Valid cognizers themselves are easy to understand. They include eye consciousnesses, ear consciousnesses, nose consciousnesses and so forth. For example, the very first time a mind sees a glass and that mind is unmistaken, that mind is a valid cognizer. This applies to all phenomena or objects of knowledge: the first time a mind perceives them in an unmistaken way, that mind is a valid cognizer.