Emptiness — 2013-02-17

1 h 39 min · 5,852 words · 17 February 2013 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Emptiness (Khensur Rinpoche)
Emptiness (Khensur Rinpoche)
Emptiness — 2013-02-17
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 99-minute session, Kyabje Rinpoche offers a systematic introduction to emptiness. He grounds the teaching in bodhicitta—the aspiration to place all beings in enlightenment—then explains how understanding emptiness directly counters desire and anger. Using concrete examples (a car, his own person, a rope mistaken for a snake), he demonstrates that things exist only through mental designation, not from their own side. The talk then progresses through the framework of the two truths and a detailed analysis of how consciousness encounters reality—the aggregates, sense sources, and sense objects. A final Q&A addresses Tonglen practice, meditation concentration, and the distinction between Prāsaṇgika and Mind-Only schools. For practitioners already familiar with Buddhist foundations.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2013-02-17 – KR.mp3

UUID: 72ec6c02-d39f-4799-8552-9ca97ed62227

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Emptiness

Date: 2013-02-17

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~5,846

So as usual, as a preliminary to receiving teachings on the great vehicle, one must generate a commensurate motivation. This motivation to engage in great vehicle practices is bodhicitta. This motivation is uncontrived or spontaneous bodhicitta and we should give rise to this if we can. Otherwise, if we are unable to do so, should generate as much of a contrived, in other words, artificial motivation of bodhicitta as possible. We should generate bodhicitta in keeping with the instructions and the stages in the great treatises, but if that is difficult for us, then we should generate as kind and as worthy a mind as is possible.

It will be difficult initially to generate bodhicitta or great compassion, but we must put efforts in this direction. Much of our mental suffering arises from fantasies and fancies. Then when we generate bodhicitta, this dispels a large number of these unnecessary mental sufferings. One should not just generate great compassion in bodhicitta while attending Dharma teachings, but please whenever you have a moment of free, try to think on bodhicitta. This is of tremendous benefit.

If one practices in this way, then materially in terms of one’s health and one’s wealth, there will be no problems and likewise at the inside, interiorly, you will not experience any suffering. What is bodhicitta? bodhicitta is that wish to place all sentient beings in a state of full enlightenment. Let us therefore please meditate for one minute on generating such a bodhicitta. So the last and the former times, what was mainly explained were the reasons for which one should understand Dharma.

And the main reasons are to be able to realize happiness and to abandon suffering. Moreover, within suffering, there are two subdivisions, physical and mental suffering. Dharma is a means to realize mental excuse me, is the means to eliminate mental suffering. The reason for this is that physical happiness is very short term and transient, or mental happiness is stable and enduring. Moreover, within mental happiness there are two subdivisions, the mental happiness of this life and the mental happiness of future lives.

Within these two, the one we should focus upon is realizing happiness from the next life onwards. The reason for this is that mental happiness within this life is mental happiness only until the time of our death. Then our maximum lifespan is one hundred years in this world. So it is a happiness of less than one hundred years span. On the other hand, happiness for future lives extends over countless future lives.

It is therefore far greater in its span. In addition, if we focus on the happiness of future lives, in other words happiness from the next life onwards, as a corollary to that, the happiness of this life will be established. There is an example in Tibet which says if an ox can go up a mountain then so can a yak. Or likewise, if you know that you are going to gain hundreds of thousands of dollars in the stock market, then as a corollary, it’s obvious you’d gain tens of thousands of dollars. And therefore, understanding that we must focus on the happiness from the next life onwards, we should eliminate all unsuitable states of mind and give rise to suitable states of mind.

If we examine our minds carefully, we will see that our minds have an almost limitless amount of thoughts and defects. Then one should start to eliminate progressively these thoughts and defects. Then reflecting on the fact that it is our good mind within this life which will give rise to happiness within future lives, we should put effort in generating such a good mind not just day after day, but month after month, year after year and life after life. Most of us worldly beings tend to be quite timorous in the way we address these things. But if we reflect on the huge benefit of generating these minds life after life, then we will not experience great difficulty in training in them.

And then being fully aware of the conditions which are necessary to give rise to happiness in future lives, we try to generate within this life good and kind minds and draw to ourselves all of the factors which contribute to this. So from today onwards, we will be talking of the means to give rise to happiness from the next life onwards. Generally, from the standpoint of the presentation of the basis of phenomena, there are two subdivisions, conventional truths and ultimate truths. In dependence on the basis component of conventional truths from within the two subdivisions of the path, method and wisdom, one privileges the component of method. Likewise, in dependence on the ultimate truth component of the path one trains in the wisdom component excuse me, in dependence on the ultimate truth of the basis one trains in the wisdom component of the path.

In dependence on training in those two components of the path, method and wisdom one attains as a result the two bodies. These two bodies are the two bodies of the Buddha, the Rūpakāya or Form Body and the Dharmakāya or the Truth Body. The Form Body is the body which interacts with other sentient beings to help them whereas the Truth Body is the body of qualities of the Buddha which in and of itself is not able to benefit others. In dependence on the practice of the method aspect of the path, one attains the form body whereas in dependence on the practice of the wisdom aspect of the path, one attains the truth body or the dharmakaya. Therefore, to obtain a result, which is those two bodies, the Rūpakāya and the Dharmakāya, we need a practice which involves the union of method and wisdom.

And to be able to practice in this way method and wisdom, one must explain the foundation from which they arise, which is the two truths, conventional and ultimate truth. So conventional existence or conventional truths refer to reality as most of us perceive it. First, ultimate truths refer to emptiness, which is much more difficult to explain. So regarding the first component of the basis, conventional truth, I feel that conventional truths can best be understood in accordance with scientific results. On the other hand, as far as ultimate truths are concerned, they fall more in the category of the view.

And in dependence on training in the view, one attains the corresponding results. And therefore one can present the Buddhist teachings and subdivide them into three parts. The section on the scientific presentation of phenomena, the section on the view and the section on the practice of this view. As the Buddha explained in the sūtra of the Meeting of the Father and the Son, the Pitaputrasamagama sūtra, I shall explain only two truths, conventional and ultimate truths. The Buddha explained in this passage of the Pitaputra sūtra that there is no phenomenon among the base which does not fall either within conventional or ultimate truths.

There is no truth apart from conventional and ultimate truth within the context of the base. And as Nāgārjuna said in the Mūlamadhyamakakārikā, the teachings of the Buddha rely on the two truths. And therefore, to understand for that matter our body, our very body can be understood only in terms of both conventional and ultimate truths. In addition, whatever is a conventional truth can never be an ultimate truth and whatever is an ultimate truth can never be a conventional truth. There is no phenomenon which is not either one of the two truths.

For this reason, since there is no tercium quid, there is no third truth apart from these two, their enumeration is said to be definite. However, these two truths, conventional and ultimate truths, are of one nature. Should the two truths be of different natures, they would be unrelated, and the Buddha said this would incur four faults. The first fault would be that one could not posit the lack of true existence of form as the mode of existence of form. The second fault would be that even though one realized the lack of true existence of form, nonetheless, this would not eliminate, the faults regarding the true existence of form.

In addition, the third fault is that those yogis who meditate for long on the lack of true inherent existence of forms would engage in meaningless practice. And finally, the last fault is that the Buddhas themselves would not have abandoned the thought of grasping at true existence and so forth. However, even though conventional and ultimate existence are not of different natures, they are nonetheless not the same. They are said to have different isolates. In other words, different names.

Since they have different names, they are said to be of different isolates. Should they have the same isolate as would be Donpa Chig, then there would be the following faults. The first fault would be that in the self same way that one can abandon the two afflictions, the afflictive obscurations and the obscurations to omniscience. Likewise, one would actually be able to abandon as well ultimate phenomena. The second fault would be in the same way as conventional phenomena have features such as form, shape, color, and so forth.

Likewise, ultimate truth would also have features such as form, shapes, colors, and so forth. The third fault is that just as ordinary beings can directly perceive conventional truths such as forms, shapes, colors or for that matter sensations, likewise ordinary beings would also be able to perceive directly ultimate truths such as emptiness. The final fault is that not only would ordinary beings have abandoned all of the obstructions, but in addition, would have already attained full enlightenment. For this reason, conventional truths and ultimate truths must be posited as having different isolates. What are ultimate truths?

Ultimate truths are those phenomena which are ascertained directly by minds which are engaged in ultimate analyses. The other names for ultimate truths are suchness or emptiness. There is tremendous benefit in reflecting on this even though it is a bit difficult. So Geshe-la is going to carefully give as easy an introduction to this topic as he can. So let’s take a very simple example.

When you look at a car, you affix the label or the name car to that object. But what you have to examine is whether that label or that name exists or not in that to which you affix it. It might be simpler if you take Geshe-la himself as an example. If we take Geshe-la himself as an example, when we look at him we say Geshe-la. But to what do we affix?

To what do we give that name Geshe-la? We seem to give it to Geshe-la’s body. But if we examine Geshe-la’s body from the top of his head to the bottom of his feet, we find no Geshe-la. It is clear that Geshe-la is not Geshe-la’s head. Then we look at Geshe-la’s arms.

They are not Geshe-la. His feet are obviously not Geshe-la. Therefore, not a single part of Geshe-la’s aggregates is Geshe-la. Therefore, apart from the process of giving a name, of affixing the name Geshe-la to Geshe-la, from Geshe-la’s own side, from the side of what we know as the basis of imputation, there is no such thing as Geshe-la independently. Likewise, with the example of the car.

We give the name car to a group of parts. But if we examine each of these individually, none of them is the car. The steering wheel is not the car. The seats are not the car. The wheels are not the car.

Is that the case or not? It is pretty clear on the basis of this example that there is no Geshe-la which exists independently of Geshe-la’s body alone or independently of Geshe-la’s aggregates alone. Then you might think, after all, Geshe-la is just a name imputed to the collection of these parts of the head, the hands, the feet, and so forth. But this also leads to problems. If you were, heaven forbid, to imagine that there is a heap of the limbs of Geshe-la, his head, his trunk, his legs, and so forth in a corner, then obviously you have all the parts of Geshe-la, you would not call the collection of those parts Geshe-la, would you?

And therefore, we can see that the name Geshe-la is merely imputed or affixed to the collection of the parts and so forth. And actually, from the standpoint of the ultimate view, we can say that Geshe-la himself lacks all inherent existence. Then you might think, well, after all, a person is his mind. But if this person was a king and you said, since a person is their mind, then their mind is a king, that would sound very strange, wouldn’t it? And therefore, all conventional phenomena without exception are merely imputed or designated by mind or by consciousness and have no existence whatsoever from their own side.

And Acharya Candrakīrti gives us this example of a horse drawn chariot. It is clear if we examine a horse drawn chariot that none of the parts of the chariot are the chariot, but likewise, the totality of the parts of the chariot themselves are not the chariot either. Once we are convinced that phenomena do not exist from their own side, this is a very powerful means to counter desire and anger. For instance, if great anger arises within our minds towards somebody, all we have to do is try to find ultimately this person towards whom anger has arisen. And when we find that under ultimate analysis this person disappears, there is no such person, this is a very powerful means to eliminate anger.

And here, the term ultimate analysis, refers to that mind which engages in an analysis to find whether ultimately things exist or not. Such a mind of ultimate analysis when it investigates phenomena to see whether they can be found or not, whether they exist or not, will find that they cannot be found, that they do not exist. For instance, for us ordinary beings, desire and anger are very powerful. Then, when powerful desire or lust arises within our minds, we analyze the object towards which desire or lust analysis arises with an ultimate mind of analysis and it disappears under investigation. This is very powerful to eliminate desire.

And therefore what we refer to by ultimate truths is the fact that under ultimate analysis phenomena do not exist in the slightest from their own side, but that they merely exist as nominal and conceptual imputations. So that mere existence as nominal and conceptual imputations is none other than conventional truth. And therefore, that mere existence of phenomena as nominal and conceptual imputations by the mind is a conventional existence. The term ultimate truth in Tibetan is in Sanskrit The first syllable from the Sanskrit in Tibetan is or is to be understood as supreme. Then the second syllable refers to the object or the truth.

And the final syllable refers to whether the mode of abiding and the mode of existence of phenomena are concordant or discordant. When the mode of existence and the mode of appearance of phenomena are concordant, then these are said to be truths, whereas when their mode of existence and their mode of appearance are not concordant, they are said to be falsities. So here, when we are speaking of Paramārthasatya or Kundzob Denpa and refer to the Sanskrit term Artha and the Tibetan term Denpa, these two terms can mean one’s own welfare and the welfare of others. That is not the meaning here. Here they merely refer to objects.

So the term or in Tibetan, it’s left untranslated in the English translations of ultimate truths. But this term refers to the true object or to what is found under ultimate analysis. Then because such an object is supreme, it is true, it is called ultimate. And to the difference of conventional truths where the mode of appearance and the mode of existence are discordant and therefore they are said to be deceitful, ultimate truths are non deceitful. So it is precisely because the modes of existence and the modes of appearance of ultimate truths are concordant or identical, that they are said to be ultimate truths and truths.

There are two subdivisions of ultimate truths. As is taught by Acharya Candrakīrti. Candrakīrti teaches that the cause for transmigration of sentient beings in cyclic existence is eliminated through training in the two ultimate truths, the ultimate truth or the lack of self of persons and of phenomena. Likewise, Buddha Śākyamūni taught two means to free sentient beings from transmigration. They are the selflessness of persons and the selflessness of phenomena.

If we were to divide ultimate truths further, then there are these subdivisions into the 20 emptinesses, the 16 emptinesses and so forth. Likewise, they can be subdivided into four, into the emptiness of things, the emptiness of non things, the emptiness of nature, and the emptiness of otherness. And these can be subdivided further into the 16, the 18, and the 20 emptinesses. Once one has understood well the meaning of emptiness, the subdivisions are easy to understand. There are no true subdivisions within emptiness.

These subdivisions into four, sixteen, eighteen and twenty are merely posited in terms of the basis on which emptiness is affirmed. For instance, however many there are of us in this temple, each one of us has his own emptiness. Whatever the number of students there are in the temple, there are that many emptinesses in the room. So there is no major problem in subdividing emptiness. Phenomena which are not emptinesses are conventional truths.

There are numerous subdivisions of conventional truth. For instance, Vasubandhu gives a subdivision in terms of the aggregates of the sources and the constituents. So here the presentation of emptiness would be mainly in accordance with the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka view as taught by Ārya Nāgārjuna and his foremost disciple, Āryadeva. The lower schools of tenets have their own individual presentation of emptiness. We are limited in time because normally one should present emptiness by moving from the bottom up, presenting the views of emptiness of each of the schools of Buddhist tenets.

However, here we are viewing emptiness from the standpoint of the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka School of Nāgārjuna and Āryadeva in which phenomena have no existence from their own side. All of the schools of tenets beneath Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka, from Svatāntrika Madhyamaka downwards, all assert that phenomena have some type of existence from their own side. Therefore, all of the schools of tenets beneath Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka, from Svatāntrika Madhyamaka downwards, assert that phenomena arise at the meeting point of something which exists from the standpoint of phenomena and the mind which imputes an imputation on phenomena. This conjunction are what we know as phenomena. However, the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka view is that there is absolutely nothing which exists from the side of phenomena.

It is merely imputed by the mind on phenomena and a good example to understand this is our reaction when we see a multi colored piece of rope on the ground in front of us and mistake it for a snake. Our mind imputes the snakeness on this piece of rope and in dependence on that, immediately great fear arises in our mind. But actually, there is no snake there, just a multicolored piece of rope. Have you understood a little bit? So this is a difficult topic.

This is why we have to go beyond ordinary conceptions towards the perfection of wisdom. The main means to understand this is to understand how one’s own mind proceeds to impute. And then after analyzing how one’s own mind works, we can then rely on the great works of Nāgārjuna and Āryadeva. However, one must point out that the Svatantrikas and so forth disagree with his presentation of Ārya Nāgārjuna and so forth. For instance, the Svatāntrika Madhyamikas debate with the Prasangikas and say, take the case of a boundary stone which marks the limitation between fields.

When a boundary stone is seen from a distance, it looks like a man. Then as one imputes humanness on it, can it act as a human being or not? To this, the prasangikas respond that the base of imputation on which imputation occurs must be a valid base of imputation and the imputation must not be at odds with worldly conventions. And as Acharya Candrakīrti says, conventional truths can be subdivided into the 12 sources, the 18 constituents and the five aggregates. The five aggregates are the form aggregate, the feeling aggregate, the discrimination aggregate, the compositional factor aggregate and the consciousness aggregate.

Moreover, the form from within the form aggregate can be subdivided into 11. These include the visual sense organ, auditory sense organ, olfactory sense organ, gustatory sense organ, tactile sense organ, and the mental sense organ. As well as the five objects of the five sense organs, which are forms, sounds, smells, tastes, and tactile sensations. And in addition, there is a form which can only be perceived mentally, which is the object of the mental sense organ. To understand this fully we would have to enter into the details of the teachings of Abhidharma, in which it is said that the eye consciousness, the ear consciousness and the mental consciousness do not encounter directly their objects which are forms, sounds and mental objects but encounter them through the mediation of an organ, the eye, ear and mental organ.

Why is this the case? Because we can with our eye consciousness see phenomena which are far away, with our ear consciousness hear sounds from a great distance, and with our mental consciousness recollect phenomena from the past or anticipate those from the future. However, the remaining three sense consciousnesses, the olfactory, gustatory and tactile sense consciousnesses actually necessarily must encounter their object close-up, smells, tastes and tactile sensations. So you can see this is pretty obvious. If you want to know whether something smells good or not, you have to inhale, right?

Go like this. So the smell and the organ must actually connect. Likewise, tastes, sweet, sour and so forth must necessarily come in contact with the tongue. They cannot be experienced from a distance. Like, you can see this for instance, if someone asks you, is this sweet or not?

You have to put it in your mouth to know. You can’t know this from a distance. Likewise, regarding tactile sensations, there is no way to know whether something is smooth or rough unless it is in direct contact with the body. It can’t be known from a distance. So we were talking about the five aggregates, Geshe-la will not go into greater detail on the form aggregate.

The second aggregate is the aggregate of feelings or sensations. There are three types of sensations or feelings, pleasant, unpleasant, and neutral, in other words, which are neither. That inner mental experience of pleasure or displeasure is what is meant by sensation or feeling here. The third aggregate is the aggregate of discrimination. Discrimination is a mental capacity which says this is a body that is white, this is red, etcetera.

This operation occurs through the potency of discrimination. And therefore, all minds must have discrimination. Moreover, discrimination is subdivided into conceptual and non conceptual discrimination. In addition, discrimination can be subdivided in terms of its object into vast, middling and small. The fourth aggregate is the aggregate of compositional factors.

The aggregate of composition of factors is the aggregate in which we include everything which cannot be included in the remaining four aggregates of form feeling discrimination and the fifth aggregate consciousness. Compositional factors can be subdivided in turn into concordant and discordant compositional factors. Concordant compositional factors include all of the mental factors which are not included within feelings and discrimination. This means that this refers to all of the mental factors not included within form within feeling and discrimination. So this subdivision is made because even though there are countless mental factors, the main problems in the analysis of mental factors arise within the context of those which are either included within feelings and discrimination or those which are not included within feelings and discrimination.

What are these problems? Well, for instance, simple people such as peasants and farmer, farmers will mainly experience compositional factors within the context of the feeling aggregate. On the other hand, compositional factors which are included within discrimination tend to occur mainly in the minds of intellectuals, those who, for instance, analyze tenets philosophy and so forth. For this reason, the subdivision of compositional factors in function of their relationship to feeling and discrimination or not is presented. The second subdivision of compositional factors is discordant compositional factors and they are subdivided in turn into 14.

Finally, the consciousness aggregate, the fifth aggregate is subdivided into the various consciousnesses from the visual consciousness all the way down to the mental consciousness. The 12 sources are subdivided into six inner sources and six outer sources. The six inner sources are those which are part of the continuum of a sentient being. They are the eye, ear, nose, tongue, tactile and mental. Whereas the exterior sources are phenomena which are not included within the continuum of a being such as forms, sounds, smells, taste, tactile sensations and phenomena in general.

Generally speaking, the eye sense organ and the eye source are synonymous. So we say that the eye sense organ is the uncommon condition for the source of form to give rise to experiences within the visual consciousness. So it is difficult to explain this carefully without understanding modern neurology but the way Geshe-la explains this to his students is that the eye sense organ is a very subtle organ not that different from a mirror. And in the self same way as whatever form or shape is reflected into a mirror, in the self same way, exterior forms and shapes are reflected into the eye visual organ and from the eye visual organ appear to the eye sense consciousness. And therefore it is in dependence on the condition of the visual organ that forms and shapes can appear within the visual consciousness.

This is known as the visual consciousness. Should I explain this in even greater detail? So, you can see that the same process is at work with the auditory consciousness and the olfactory consciousness. Sounds impinge on the ear organ and through impinging on the ear organ dawn in the ear consciousness likewise smells impinge on the olfactory organ and through that appear in the olfactory consciousness. So this presentation obviously is closely connected to science.

After the 12 sources, we have a presentation of the 18 constituents. These include the six sense organs from the eye sense organ to the mental sense organ. In other words, the eye sense organ, ear sense organ, nose sense organ, tongue sense organ, tactile sense organ and mental sense organ. And in dependence on the six sense organs, in turn, we have six consciousnesses, which are the visual consciousness, auditory consciousness, olfactory, gustatory, tactile, and mental consciousnesses. And finally, we have six objects, one for each of these consciousnesses, which are forms, sounds, smells, tastes, sensations, and what is known as a constituent of phenomena phenomena simply.

And therefore we have the six bases which are the six sense organs. We have the six which are based upon, which are the six consciousnesses which are based upon the six sense organs. And we have the six objects of the six sense organs and six consciousnesses, which makes 18. In brief, all composite phenomena are included within the five aggregates. And all phenomena are included within the 12 sources and the 18 constituents.

Then we will perhaps stop here for today since the time has run out and Geshe-la would be delighted if you ask some questions. I have a question about Tonglen practice. Is that okay if I ask something related to that? Yes. It’s okay.

Yes. It’s okay. Okay. My question is what what visualization techniques does Geshe-la use when practicing Tonglen? So the practice of Tonglen or giving and taking is closely related to the practice of the interchange of self and others.

And in this practice, the goal is to imagine that whatever happiness we have, we give to others. And whatever suffering they have, we take upon ourselves so as to increase ever more our own compassion. This is beautifully presented in the Buddhist teachings in which it is said that actually the more we dedicate ourselves to others and the more we think of others, the more as a result not only are others happy, but the more we ourselves will be happy. Whereas the more we think of ourselves, the more egotistical we are, not only the more unhappy will we be, but also the more unhappy will others be. Okay?

So when Geshe-la visualises compassion, is there a particular does he think of it maybe a puppy or some people think of mothers? Or is there any particular technique that he can share? So at first, since we ourselves want to be happy and don’t want to be unhappy, we should start by taking ourselves as an object and developing compassion for ourselves. And then understanding that others are no different from us in this matter, we take those we are close to, we take first our friends or our relatives and develop compassion for them and once we are able to do that, then we extend the objects to beings to whom we are indifferent and finally to all beings including our enemies. Thanks.

I noticed that the fact of, completely eradicating watching television has improved visualization of the Buddha. Can Geshe-la explain why that is using the teaching he’s just given on eye consciousness not being drawn out in television, but somehow it increases the inner ability to visualize the Buddha. It is excellent actually to give up watching television, movies and shows in general since they lead to a great increase in conceptuality. And when we meditate, we are trying to reduce this mental agitation in conceptuality. So by giving up television, you have reduced this level of mental agitation And then as Geshe-la explained in the context of the affliction desire, which when it is focused on its object leads it to become clearer and clearer.

Likewise, when we meditate, even though we engage in a virtuous act, the mind operates in the same way. And if we focus on the Buddha through practice, eventually he will become clearer and clearer. Generally speaking, the mind rides on the psychic energy, the prana or the winds, like a rider on a horse. And then if the winds in the mind are out of the body focused on exterior objects, it becomes very difficult to meditate. Practice, the practice of meditation involves withdrawing the mind and the winds inside and focusing them.

For instance, the reason for which we engage in mindfulness of breath in Satipatthana is precisely this. Through focusing our mind on the outward and inward movement of the breath, we eliminate all other conceptuality. So, my question is why does a conceptual understanding of emptiness have to be accompanied by single pointed concentration to achieve liberation? So why is a conceptual understanding alone not enough? It’s impossible to attain liberation in dependence on analytical understanding of emptiness alone.

It is indispensable to attain liberation to first understand emptiness through analysis and numerous lines of reasoning and then to focus single pointedly on it using calm abiding. And it is not sufficient for this calm abiding and this insight to be mere calm abiding and insights since even non-Buddhist outsiders have them. These must be calm abiding and insights which are focused on emptiness. In addition, through merely understanding analytically and conceptually emptiness, there is no liberation. So this is why those who want to practice seriously go into retreat on mountain peaks and so forth.

Because when they are in retreat on mountain peaks, is much less exterior stimulation and much less conceptual stimulation. Clearly, if you are in retreat in the hermitage in the mountains and whenever you have a moment off, you go down to the neighboring village or the city, that doesn’t count as a retreat, does it? Geshe-la mentioned the discordant compositional factors can be divided into 14. I just wonder if he could Divide what into 14? Discordant compositional factors.

I just wonder if he could give an example of a couple of those. Thanks. Then Geshe-la didn’t mention these because these 14 subdivisions are specific to the Vaibhāṣika presentation of Abhidharma and he didn’t think they were of benefit, but he will present them if you wish. Then this makes my life much easier. So you go to page 118 of the English translation and the 14 subdivisions are acquisition, non acquisition, similarity of type, one having no discrimination, absorption without discrimination, absorption of cessation, life faculty, production, aging, duration, impermanence, group of stems, group of words and group of letters.

Isn’t there some very, very beautiful explanations about all of these? Thank you, Geshe-la. Within the Cittamātra School, from what I understand, our relationship with the external is positive as something that’s is totally mind created. This is my understanding. I’m I could first of all, I’m just interested in this this idea of ultimate truth or things existing as nominal and conceptual imputations by the mind.

Mhmm. I mean, that already makes me feel as if we’re sort of leaning towards a Cittamātra view right there. And I just wondered how we differentiate in this tenet. You know, that it’s I know it’s not of the Cittamātra school, but what is the difference there? Because it’s still sounding as if pretty much things exist within the mind only.

The biggest difference is that in the Cittamātra view phenomena do exist from their own side whereas in the Prāsaṇgika view phenomena never exist from their own side. For instance, in the Cittamātra or Mind Only View, Geshe-la’s glass and the visual consciousness which perceives Geshe-la’s glass arise from the single or from the same karmic potency implanted in the mind. Therefore, the Chittamatrans assert that there is no difference in nature between Geshe-la’s glass and the mind which perceives Geshe-la’s glass. Whereas the two lower schools of tenets, Vaibhāṣika and the Sautrāntika assert that this glass is actually different from the mind perceives that it is a product of a factory. To counter this, the Chittamatras assert that this glass is merely the appearance of mind.

And therefore this glass is of the same nature as mind, of the same entity as mind. So we’ve gone ten minutes past the time.

Key terms in this teaching

Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
dharmakaya truth body; chö ku (Tib)
The ultimate reality of a buddha’s enlightened mind, which is unborn, empty of true existence, free from conceptual thought, naturally radiant, beyond duality and spacious like the sky. One of the three embodiments of a buddha. LYWA
Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
rupakaya form body; zug ku (Tib)
The form body of a fully enlightened being; the result of the complete and perfect accumulation of merit. LYWA
Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top