Awakening Heart — 2013-02-20

1 h 22 min · 4,777 words · 20 February 2013 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

The Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
The Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awakening Heart — 2013-02-20
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 83-minute talk, Kyabje Rinpoche centers the path on bodhicitta—the resolve to attain enlightenment for all sentient beings—as the motivation transforming practice from self-oriented to liberating. He methodically works through the mental prerequisites: equanimity, love, compassion, each grounded in recognizing that sentient beings are the actual means of spiritual progress. A striking example anchors this: a Geshe from Amdo Tashi Kyil facing execution recites tonglen and dies without suffering—the fruit of habitual compassion. He then addresses the practical foundation: calm abiding and insight must develop together. He details six concrete conditions for cultivating calm abiding: good location, few desires, contentment, abandoning worldly activity, pure ethics, and freedom from craving. Includes Q&A. Aimed at serious practitioners.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2013-02-20 – KR.mp3

UUID: 0c710b82-afac-433e-874f-875672b7fbb2

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Awakening Heart

Date: 2013-02-20

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~4,775

Whether there are results or not from our listening to the teachings is contingent on our motivation. Therefore, as previously, Geshe-la will give some explanations regarding the motivation. There are three levels of motivation, the small, the middling, the great. Taking refuge occurs initially with the motivation of attaining a higher rebirth such as a god or a human being. The motivation of renunciation occurs or is generated when one wishes to attain liberation from all of the sufferings of cyclic existence and is a cause thereof.

However, if the motivation is held or is infused with bodhicitta, it acts as a cause for attaining the state of full enlightenment bereft of all faults and endowed with all qualities. For what will be taught today, we should infuse our motivation with bodhicitta, the wish to attain full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings and to eliminate all faults and actualize all qualities. bodhicitta is none other than engaging in discarding self-cherishing and engaging in cherishing others. Even though we are unable to generate an uncontrived spontaneous bodhicitta at present, nonetheless it is indispensable for us to put effort at generating a contrived or artificial sense of bodhicitta. There are two different modes or methods of generating bodhicitta.

The first is through the sevenfold cause and effect method, and the second is through the interchange of self and others. Even though one were to rely on the method of the interchange of self and others to generate bodhicitta, Nonetheless, that method contains all the key points of the seven fold cause and effect method. However, before generating bodhicitta, it is critically important to generate within our minds both empathy and compassion. That empathetic compassion is one which cannot bear to see the suffering of beings and wishes to free them from these. The means through which this incapacity to bear the suffering of others arises within our minds is through reflecting of the kindness of others towards us.

This was taught explicitly by the great Kadampa Geshe of yore in the eight verses of mind training in which, they said, bless me to see all sentient beings as a wish fulfilling jewel. In worldly affairs, we well know that gold, silver, lapis lazuli, or coral, such precious substances are the means for us to actualize our goals. In keeping with this simile, sentient beings are the means for us to actualize our happiness both in this life and in all future lives. Let alone the happiness of this life, what really matters is the happiness of life after life and future lives. in dependence on what does such a stable happiness occur?

It occurs in dependence on other sentient beings. It cannot occur through any other means. How is this the case? When we engage in the practice of generosity, we engage in this practice in dependence on other sentient beings to whom we give things. Likewise, when we engage in the practice of forbearance, we engage in it in dependence on other beings.

We can also see that to attain the state of ultimate full enlightenment, one must have generated bodhicitta. To generate bodhicitta, one must have generated great compassion. To generate great compassion, one must have generated love. Every single one of these states of mind is generated in dependence on other sentient beings, isn’t it? These precious states of mind, such as bodhicitta, great compassion, and love, are precious indeed, but we can see that without other sentient beings, they would never arise.

For that matter in this life, all of our pleasant experiences, our relatives, our friends, the clothing we wear, the food we eat arise in dependence on the kindness of others. By ourselves, it would be very difficult to produce all this. There are numerous lines of reasoning like this one, but we won’t enter into them because of lack of time. There is otherwise a risk we would spend an hour fifteen minutes talking about the motivation. And therefore, we must view sentient beings as both most kind and most important.

In worldly affairs alone, it is considered important to discard egoism and to practice altruism, although more so in Dharma practice. For instance, we will say in worldly affairs that the mother who takes care with great care and affection of her child is a most worthy mother indeed, isn’t she? And therefore, in this context, we should think that our goal is to attain full enlightenment so as to free all sentient beings of suffering and place them in that state. And the reason for which we should strive ourselves to attain full enlightenment is because at present, even though we wish to help others, we lack the capacity to do so. Who has this capacity?

The fully enlightened beings do. Therefore, we ourselves must become fully enlightened for the sake of others. And for this, we should put effort to eliminate the afflictions, the afflictions, which pervade our minds and to generate the qualities, the qualities, which we need to attain this state. And therefore, the motivation we should generate is I am attending these teachings today to attain full enlightenment myself for the sake of all other sentient beings. And therefore, for one minute, let us meditate on this motivation thinking, may I attain full enlightenment to lead all sentient beings without exception to that state?

There are numerous causes which are required to eliminate all faults and to actualize all qualities attaining the state of full enlightenment. What is the foremost cause necessary to attain the state of full enlightenment? It is a wisdom realizing emptiness which is held or apprehended by bodhicitta. To generate such a bodhicitta within one’s continuum, one must initially generate a compassion which wishes to free sentient beings from suffering. Prior to that, one must generate a love, an affectionate love, which wishes to free sentient beings from suffering.

However, prior to such an affectionate love, one must generate an equanimity which is unbiased towards sentient beings. An equanimity which is equal in its treatment of sentient beings and does not allow desire to arise towards one’s friends and relatives and anger to arise towards one’s enemies. Even though we are bereft of calm abiding and of insight, nonetheless, through reflecting carefully on it, can generate such an equanimity within our mind stream. However, to generate these states of mind in an uncontrived, non artificial fashion within our mind stream, it is indispensable to have insight. And to generate insight, it is indispensable to have trained in calm abiding.

Minds or states of mind such as bodhicitta and compassion can be seen as twofold, contrived and uncontrived states of mind. The contrived states of mind cause effort from our side for them to arise. The uncontrived states of mind arise spontaneously. These uncontrived states of mind arise through long habituation of the person to their generation so that they can be generated without any contrived effort. In our case, the afflictions and non virtues arise in an uncontrived and spontaneous fashion within our minds.

We can see that they arise in an uncontrived or spontaneous way because without any effort on our side, as soon as our minds encounter the conditions for the arrival of the afflictions, these arise these afflictions automatically arise. On the other hand, the fact that states of mind such as generosity, forbearance, great compassion or love do not arise easily in our mind without a great amount of effort is a clear sign of lack of past habituation. However, if from today onwards we start training our minds in such states of mind such as love, compassion and so forth, then over time it will become easier and easier for them to arise. There is no hope whatsoever for compassion or love to arise in an uncontrived spontaneous fashion within our mind stream after a day or a month of practice. It is through long continuous practice that this will happen.

It is when such a state of mind arises that the time has come to donate whatever we have to others. For instance, I have a story I would like to tell about this. There was in the great monastery in Amdo Amdo Tashi Kyil A Geshe previously, and he was threatened of death by the Chinese. However, before he was executed, this Geshe asked the Chinese to give him three minutes time before he was shot.

During those three minutes, he uttered the prayer, noble Guru, may all of my happiness be given to others and may all the suffering of other sentient beings ripen upon myself. And after reciting the verses, therefore most benevolent guru, cause all of the sufferings and afflictions of migrators to mature upon myself and all of my happiness to be imparted to others. In other words, taking upon himself the suffering of all beings and giving his happiness to others, he was shot. Then as a result of making this prayer, at the time of his execution, he experienced no hardship whatsoever. Why was this the case?

Because through training for a long period of time in generating great compassion, bodhicitta in such states of mind, great mental courage and power was generated within him. Then in our cases, we have obtained a worthy human rebirth. It may be difficult for us to obtain at now our ultimate goal, our ultimate wish. And therefore, if at present we do not think of future lives and we fall once again in the animal or the lower realms, then there will have been no point whatsoever in this life. There will be no difference between us and animals since animals also try to be happy in this life and to avoid suffering in this life.

And reflecting on the fact that death is certain, the time of death is uncertain, and at the time of death, the only thing which is of benefit is Dharma we should practice. To think I will practice tomorrow or after tomorrow to procrastinate is inappropriate since death and impermanence will come. So it is at present that we can train in the means for us to experience an easy passing, an easy death. And we should do this through reflecting on the meaning of love, of compassion and bodhicitta, how to train and how to generate them. And if we do this on a day by day basis, things will turn out well.

And then I will continue explaining where we stopped. This was just an introduction. And therefore to give rise to these states of mind, bodhicitta, compassion and love, we need as a preliminary insight, and for insight we need calm abiding. And therefore, we shall at present explain the preliminary conditions necessary for the attainment of śamatha and how once one is training in śamatha to focus on the object of observation. Even though the foremost means for eradicating the root of the afflictions is insight, nonetheless, if insight is not associated, literally if it’s not befriended by calm abiding, this is impossible.

Without calm abiding, even though we may be able to practice a little bit, we will not get far in our practice because our mind will be distracted outwards, in the same way as a butter lamp placed in a windy area. The flame is not stable. Although independent of calm abiding, there is such a thing as the experience of insight. Independent on insight alone, there is no generation of calm abiding. Therefore, it is important for calm abiding and insight to be generated in conjunction or inseparably from each other.

For instance, if our mind lacks stability in the focus of a focus on the factor of abiding of the object of observation, irrespective of the insight training we engage in, we will reach no stable results. For instance, even though someone might himself be working hard at his task, if those around him are distracting him all the time, it will be difficult for him to be good at his work. And therefore, to generate, bodhicitta compassion and love, it is indispensable to have a union of calm abiding and insight. This is why the Buddha said in the Mahāparinirvāṇa Sūtra, This is why the Buddha said in the Mahāparinirvāṇa Sūtra, even though the Shravakas have powerful concentration, they are unable to see the Tathāgatagarbha, the Buddha nature. This is the case because they lack insight.

Here when we speak of the Tathāgatagarbha or Buddha nature in English, this refers to the capacity to attain the state of full enlightenment. All sentient beings are equal in having this capacity, this potency, this germ, which enables them to attain full enlightenment. If these seeds meet with the appropriate conditions for attaining full enlightenment, there will be an attainment of full enlightenment. For instance, isn’t it the case that if a barley seed encounters the cooperative conditions of water, manure, heat and so forth, it will give rise to a barley sprout. Whereas if the selfsame barley seed does not encounter the conditions of water, heat and manure, it will not give rise to such a barley sprout.

And the Buddha added, however, the bodhisattvas do indeed see the Buddha nature through an insight which is subsumed within the wisdom component of the path, but since as a result of this, at times their concentration is reduced, the path takes a very long time. And therefore, it is an equal practice of calm abiding and insight, which is relying both on the exterior and the interior conditions, which is indispensable to attain full enlightenment. If we have calm abiding, our mind will not be distracted outwards nor will it be distracted by wanton fancies. Instead, it will focus single pointedly on the factor of abiding of the object of observation. It is when the mind is single pointedly focused on the factor of abiding of the object of observation that at this point, insight can fruitfully engage in analysis.

It is at this point that when through insight it is possible to eliminate all of the obstacles and the faults preventing one to attain full enlightenment, that through insight, the attainment of full enlightenment becomes a reality. This is why the Buddha said in the Moonlamp Sūtra, by the power of calm abiding, pliability arises, whereas through insight the mind becomes like a mountain. What is meant in these two verses by insight being compared to a mountain is that in dependence on insight, the instability which is due to the wrong views ceases to arise. And since the Buddha has said this explicitly, we should rely equally and inseparably on calm abiding and insight. And practicing in this way, once we have trained in calm abiding, then insight will occur.

Then there is no need at that point to make prayers for it to happen tomorrow. However, before generating calm abiding, we have to address the issue of what the conditions are. Six conditions are necessary to give rise to calm abiding. The first is to live in a good place. Then there are two further conditions.

We must have few needs, few desires, and the third condition is that we must be contented. The fourth condition is to abandon numerous activities. Numerous activities here refer to numerous mundane or worldly activities. The fifth condition is to have pure ethics, which refers to not allowing our body, speech and mind to be blended or mixed with non virtue. And finally, one must abandon the fancies of desire and so forth.

These are the six conditions. Each of these is clearly explained further on. A good place in which to train in calm abiding has five features. First, such a place must be one in which no great effort is needed to obtain clothing and food. Some explanation may be required here.

To train in calm abiding, we need exterior conditions such as clothing so that we are not cold and food so that we do not go hungry. These must be easy to obtain. The second condition is one needs a good abode. This is an abode in which there are no rough beings such as enemies and so forth or noisy persons. The third feature of a good place in which to train is that it must be a place which is not in which diseases are not present.

The fourth condition is that one must be surrounded by friends who have a good ethical standard and who are in harmony with one’s own view of things. The fifth condition is that it must not be a place which is busy by day or noisy by night. If these five preconditions are satisfied, then the place in which one is training in calm abiding is a good place. The second prerequisite for attaining calm abiding is to have few desires. This refers to not having a powerful desire for elegant and expensive clothes or fancy food.

The opposite of having few desires is obviously having great desires. And for instance, one’s clothing, being a person who always must be the best best dressed person in the world. Then for such a person, there is a lot of suffering in the training in calm abiding. And here, having few desires therefore refers to being someone who is satisfied with whatever he has and says, this is good enough. Then there will be no great suffering in the training in calm abiding.

The third prerequisite is contentment. Contentment here refers to being satisfied with whatever food or clothes one has. The fourth prerequisite is to give up numerous activities. And this refers, for instance, to business and to all of the activities which are not connected with dharma. In Geshe-la’s opinion, when Kamalaśīla here refers to abandoning business activities, he is referring to trainees who are ordained.

Then for those of you who are not ordained and who wish to train in calm abiding, obviously, you cannot abandon all of your business activities, but you should reduce them. The second feature of abandoning numerous activities is not to associate and befriend a large numbers of lay persons or for that matter, monks. And also, obviously, one must abandon the practice of medicine and astrology or divination. Then if we are sincere about really wanting to generate calm abiding within our mind, we must definitely abandon these. The fifth criterion is to have pure ethics.

And here, whether one has just Prātimokṣa vows or one also has Bodhisattva vows, one must abandon both the prescribed and the natural non-virtues. And in this context you have a handout which translates the section which is untranslated in your book on this on page 95. Now regarding natural non virtues, these natural non virtues are non virtues for all, both those who are ordained and those who are not ordained. So natural non-virtues are non virtuous deeds or sins. On the other hand, prescribed faults are faults which are only faults for those who are ordained, not for the laypeople.

This is the case because those who are ordained were instructed by the Buddha to abstain from a large number of deeds in the light of their training. And should they engage in these deeds, they would be acting at odds with the Buddha’s instructions. So to do that is to engage in prescribed non virtuous deeds. I will give you an example in this matter. For instance, if those who are ordained drink alcohol, we incur a prescribed fault.

This is a case because the Buddha forbid those who are ordained from drinking. Then behaving in this way, we would be at odds with the prescribed instructions of the Buddha. On the other hand, lay people do not have those instructions. Why do we incur a prescribed fault if we ingest alcohol? It is not the actual ingestion of alcohol which lies behind the prescribed fault.

It is acting in opposition to the instruction of abstaining from alcohol, which is the What is the rationale behind the Buddhas forbidding those who are ordained from drinking alcohol? It is because if one starts drinking, then it is quite easy day by day to drink a little bit more. Then because alcohol is tasty, it is difficult to have a measure. Then through drinking eventually a lot of alcohol, the person loses control over their mind. And then through one’s mind being troubled or confused by the consumption of alcohol, numerous non virtues eventually arise, such as, for instance, selling dishonestly things which one shouldn’t sell and so forth.

So this does not occur through ingesting a small amount of alcohol, but most of those who consume alcohol are unable to control their consumption. And then through the uncontrolled consumption of alcohol, the being’s mind is troubled, and eventually, they fall into sin. Should any such thought arise, one should immediately generate remorse towards it. The most powerful remorse arises when one reflects on the effect of the non-virtue. However powerful the thought, the non virtue we have accrued in this life, if after committing such a non virtue, we think, how I have fallen, what have I done?

Then through the power of such powerful remorse, such a non virtue will not mature in future lives. We will not have to experience its results. Then after generating such powerful remorse at the thought of whatever non-virtue we have committed, we should take the pledge or the resolution never to engage in it again. And it is extremely important at this point to reflect that whatever fault or sin we have engaged in is non-inherently existent. In this context, whatever phenomena or dharma we are involved in, we should reflect on its being non inherently existent and empty.

This explanation, which I have given on non virtuous deeds, is rooted in the Ajatashatru Sūtra. I will recount you the tale of Ajatashatru. He was told by the Buddha’s cousin Devadatta to kill his own father. This happened after Devadatta was unable himself to murder the Buddha. Then King Ajatashatru, on the instructions of Devadatta, slaughtered with a sword his own father.

Then after a great suffering, the father of King Ajatashatru eventually died. Great remorse arose in the mind of King Ajatashatru after killing his own father. Then Buddha Śākyamūni said to King Ajatashatru, you do not need to feel such tremendous remorse over this. And for this reason, the sūtra is called the Sūtra of the Remorse of King Ajatashatru. The following topic is abandoning desire.

And in this context, since such fancies give rise to numerous hardship both in this life and in future lives, they are to be abandoned. And these can be easily understood abandoned through understanding that all of the phenomena of saṃsāra are of the nature of transitoriness and are destroyed. Reflecting on the fact that bodies, these bodies within cyclic existence, the enjoyment, and for that matter, the sins of cyclic existence, all are transitory and will all disintegrate. And therefore there is no rationale for being attached to this body or to the enjoyments of this body since we will have to separate from them eventually. So these are the numerous preconditions to give rise to calm abiding.

Then we will stop here. The next chapter is the prerequisites to give rise to insight. Then Geshe-la will take one or two questions. Yes, please. Regarding the examples of paternal and maternal compassion, that rather contentious Ah, yes.

Example. And one example I thought may be less contentious would be because the it was a case of capacity that it rather than maternal and paternal compassion, maybe the compassion of a child and the compassion of an adult? I suppose children and adults are able to feel compassion, but maybe the adult only has the capacity to actually bring about the end of the suffering. That’s precisely it. Basically, that is the meaning of these terms.

Then they were used in a very different context. And my question is regarding Geshe-la saying that to attain full enlightenment, it is the wisdom realizing emptiness which is apprehended by bodhicitta. Is this possible to have what is essentially focusing on two things at the same time in a meditative state? Is that possible because wisdom realizing emptiness is meditating on the object and bodhicitta is meditating on the subject? So even though ultimate bodhicitta is called bodhicitta, it is not precisely bodhicitta.

Ultimate bodhicitta is the mind which realizes that emptiness through which one can attain full enlightenment. For this reason, it is qualified by the term bodhicitta. Geshe-la, in the generation I’m sorry. This was, a while ago. In the generation of equanimity Mhmm.

And in the generation of loving kindness and then, compassion, should one mainly or only focus on all beings wanting happiness and not wanting suffering and all beings, having been kind? Or should are there other things to bring into the generation of equanimity, loving kindness, and compassion? So if anyone is trying to generate love or compassion, in the case of love, one meditates on the fact that sentient beings wish for happiness and the causes of happiness, whereas in the case of compassion, one meditates that they are equal to us in wishing to avoid suffering and the causes of suffering. However, one does this through the reliance on numerous reasons, not just on that line of thought. So one can either give rise to these states of mind incrementally reflecting on the fact that all living beings have been our mother sentient beings, that they have been greatly kind to us, that we have to repay their kindness, then generating love, compassion and so forth, or through reflecting directly on the benefit others give to us.

Both of these approaches are possible. I was just wanting to ask this question about, the kindness of others, that we everything that we have is dependent on the the kindness of others. Mhmm. Because we all know many people go to their work and and make clothes and things and and organize food for us with quite negative minds and not with any motivation to be kind to us at all. Could Geshe-la address that?

So one way to look at this is to think that in this context, we are reflecting on the kindness of sentient beings from the standpoint of what they do for us, from the standpoint of our benefit as a result of their actions. And there, there is definitely kindness. Let’s take the example of the practice of forbearance. To practice forbearance, we need someone who is angry with us. Then this person who is angry with us is angry with us for all the wrong motivations.

However, if we reflect on the fact that they are angry with us and that this anger with us is the indispensable condition for our practice of patience, it is in dependence on their kindness at getting angry with us that we practice patience. Therefore, they are our teachers, our spiritual teachers in patience. Said that the results of the practice of forbearance in future lives are a beautiful physique, numerous friends, wealth, and good conditions. So as the teaching is finished, we have we’re going to take tonight a very special prayer for those who are passed away and self-immolated in the past. It’s around hundred three, you know, since 2011.

So today, we have a request Tibetan community from his holiness represent from Canberra, and it’s not only for us. You know? It’s all around the world where the Tibetans are. They request to pray. So our community going to join us and our Gyume Khangtsen will be here.

So we’re going to do Guru Puja prayer, but don’t don’t scare. It doesn’t take long. Alright? We we we skip the torma offering because the Guru Puja is I remember, you know, when we were doing, you know, when we take the corpse into a graveyard, monks sit around and do Guru Puja. Alright?

So that we do and Rinpoche said, you know, the Guru Puja is the really it’s got a whole prayer in there. So that we’re going to do the most of in the Tibetan in a kinda like quick. There’s no tuning. And stage the path, we’re going to do in English. So and after that, we do some prayers, and different mantras.

So please join us, and you can stay as it is, and there’s no need. Okay.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
puja chö pa (Tib)
Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
torma balimta (Skt)
An offering cake used in tantric rituals. In Tibet, tormas were usually made of tsampa, but other edibles such as biscuits and so forth will suffice. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top