Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 63-minute teaching, HH the Dalai Lama addresses the relationship between student and spiritual teacher through the lens of contemporary Western culture and Buddhist epistemology. He begins by establishing why this topic is urgent and difficult for the modern West: our societies have built themselves on radical individual autonomy, a shift exemplified in the design of prams from the 1980s onward, where children now face outward rather than toward their mother. This ideological isolation creates measurable stress and disrupts the natural teacher-student bond. The Dalai Lama then grounds the possibility of relying on a spiritual teacher in Buddhist philosophy and quantum physics. He presents Dharmakīrti’s account of valid cognition—consciousness as non-material and cognitive—and suggests that valid cognizers may correspond to observers who collapse the wave function in quantum mechanics. From this foundation, he argues that omniscience must exist as a necessary logical consequence, and that the spiritual teacher manifests this omniscient mind in accessible form. He concludes by outlining the eight advantages of relying correctly on a spiritual teacher and eight disadvantages of neglect or mistreatment, emphasizing that this relationship is the most consequential choice a practitioner can make. Addressed to serious Buddhist practitioners and newcomers willing to engage rigorous philosophical analysis.
File metadata (for organising)
File: compendium-of-valid-cognition-2012-08-25-kr
Teacher: —
Collection: Compendium of Valid Cognition
Date: 2025-08-12
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~8,196
Thank you very much. It’s a delight to see so many well known faces and I must apologize for the interruption in this cycle of conferences due to a family emergency in Switzerland which has luckily been resolved very fortunately. Then to present a topic which is I think the most important and the most difficult topic of all, it is perhaps a good thing that we are only a few. Then we can talk about things more carefully. This talk will probably extend after 04:00.
If you have to leave, please feel free to leave without further ado. Then I don’t think personally it is possible to talk about the spiritual teacher which is the beginning, the middle, and the end of the Buddhist path without taking refuge. However, I would like that only those of us who are Buddhist who sincerely feel Buddhist from the depth of their hearts Take refuge at present. The others, please feel free to remain seated without further ado. Then we will take refuge in Sanskrit, which is, as a Tibetan say, the language of the gods.
And this is, I think, as I said, the most important and the most difficult topic. It is profoundly alien to contemporary Western sensitivity. At the same time, I think it is indispensable for the practice of the Buddhist path in its totality and perhaps for the practice of any spiritual path. As you know, much of Western culture has erected itself in the last five centuries on the basis of an ever growing autonomy of the subject, which has led us to the point we are now both in the good and the bad sense of the term. We have become the dominant civilization, materially, technologically, and perhaps in terms of our world view worldwide.
At the same time, the full effect of the radical assertion of the autonomy of the subject are becoming more and more evident with societies which internally are often in a state close to a state of collapse. We will talk a little bit about the sociological effects of this extraordinary autonomy of the subject which characterizes the West. There have been, however, reactions. Interestingly enough, one of the foremost thinkers in attempting to understand what the autonomy of the subject is and whether it is meaningful is a French mathematician who is Olivier Rey, a sociologist by avocation. Not exactly a minor mathematician, he’s professor of mathematics at Ecole Polytechnique, which is a French MIT.
And the core question Olivier asks in a remarkable book, which is unfortunately untranslated in English and which is called An Insane Solitude, is whether that which actually constitutes modernity, is the affirmation of independence, individuality and the radical autonomy of the subject, isn’t actually in a sense what is destroying modernity. And Olivier Reyes starts with an extremely interesting observation which I pointed out previously, which is a change in the design of prams. It’s quite striking if you look at prams designed from the nineteen thirties all the way up to the nineteen seventies, that in every single instance the pram is designed so that the child is looking at the mother who is pushing it. In other words, from the standpoint of the pram designer and society, the child defines himself in a relationship with his mother, who is his first teacher. We are going to talk of the spiritual teacher, we cannot talk of the spiritual teacher without talking of parents, who are the first teachers.
It is in 1980 that suddenly the design of PRAMS shifts completely. The child is actually turned outwards away from the mother from the very beginning facing an outside world it neither knows nor understands and left alone to try to define itself with respect to this outside world. Therefore, we can say that in the nineteen eighties, a switch occurred where suddenly the individual no longer constructed himself in a relationship, but started to construct himself independently. Now you might think that this is all very nice and fine but perhaps this is the work of a French philosopher who had too much time on his hands. Actually, Olivier’s work has initiated a series of studies in pediatrics, some of which have been done in Australia on the stress levels of children in prams depending on whether the child is facing the mother or facing away.
One of these studies I listed in the bibliography which I think is available. I actually asked Carol to print it. You should be able to get it during the break. Then this study which is just two or three years old shows that the stress levels measured by pulse, humidity of the skin, stress hormones in the child when he’s facing away from the mother are multiples of the stress level when the child is facing the mother. So something very profound is happening here.
The child, for ideological reasons, is being put in a highly stressful situation which is profoundly unnatural and is being asked to construct himself. In other words, from the beginning of its life, the child is excluded from a teacher student relationship, the relationship to our first teacher, which is our mother. If I have been able to come in this room today to talk to you and therefore to walk to come in, it is thanks to my mother who taught me to walk. If I’m able to speak to you, it is thanks to my mother whose speech I imitated and thus learned to speak. The food I have received I owe to my mother.
Therefore, there is to be blunt no teacher student relationship without initially a relationship of gratitude to one’s parents. And Olivier Reyes points out that two vastly separate disciplines, causality and genealogy, are both similar in that for both man does not define himself. He arises within a lineage. In the case of causality, the cause and effect chain is unbroken. There is no effect without a cause.
In the case of genealogy, we depend on our parents and our children depend on us. More fundamentally, in the spiritual realm, in the case of a teacher student disciple, the disciple arises as the end product of a lineage of teacher. This lineage is a genealogy. It is a sequence of causes. This has been, I think we can say, totally rejected by the West and this causes great problems in our attempt to practice within a tradition in which the teacher student relationship is foundational.
The situation we have created to make not too much of a caricature of it is that of the Lord of Flies. We are in a situation where our democratic societies have defined themselves over and against any concept of lineage, transmission, authority or paternity. Now it will be interesting to see where this leads us, but so far the sociological statistics are very bad. I mentioned in the first talk I gave here, why be religious, that the suicide rate among Australian teenagers between the ages of 17 and 24 has been multiplied by a factor of five in one century. Now we certainly cannot say that materially Australian teenagers are worse off in 2012 than they were in 1900.
Far from there. Likewise, an ominous statistic we have just recently from The States is the number of so called days of internment per 100,000 which is a measure of psychoanalysis of children in America. It doubles between 1997 and 2007. In other words, somehow within ten years, this is before the global financial crisis, suddenly there are either twice the number of children or children spent twice the time in psychiatric care than they did ten years ago. This is a very, very clear sign that something is fundamentally wrong in societies like ours which are extraordinarily wealthy and in which this should not be happening.
So as I mentioned in my first talk at the beginning of the year, I think we can see modernity as arising at the nexus of five different factors. The first is individualism, which really can be traced back to the Greek word, but experiences a resurgence at the renaissance and the reformation in the individual relation to God. The second is egalitarianism. The concept that all human beings without equal, without exception are equal. This again can be traced back to a certain reading of Greek democracy and took over especially with the age of enlightenment.
The third which is relatively recent is relativism. The idea that every single opinion and view is relative. It’s a matter of perspective. There is no such thing as actual true and false statements. This is an extraordinarily common misconception and it pervades Buddhist centers as well.
The fourth is privatization, which is the rejection of public life in the broadest sense of the term. Experience becomes private. Religious experience, which basically up to the Renaissance was public. One prayed in churches, one attended, for instance, Lama Chöpa in a community, one became the member of a community to practice religion, religious experience has become an individual private solitary experience. This is a very modern understanding of religiosity.
And finally technological consciousness which pervades our society. One is only credible if one can appeal to technological arguments. It is one of the reasons in my presentations I systematically appeal to scientific discoveries which are basically irrelevant to what we do simply because of the extraordinary credibility of science among the students. It gives legitimacy to something which frankly is unrelated. Now in the practice of Guru Yoga, you can see how these five features would cause important problems.
Individualism does not function well in a spirit student teacher relationship because one must relate to the teacher. Egalitarianism basically has to collapse in a student teacher relation since the teacher is not one’s equal, he’s one’s superior. There can be no relativism because in a teacher student relationship one commits to practice what the teacher tells one to do. It’s a very goal of the purpose. Privatization is less problematical and technological consciousness in a sense is neither here nor there as long as it stays in its rightful place.
So because modernity arises at the nexus of these five factors, religious practice and spiritual practice in general is extremely different for our contemporaries. But the practice of relating to a spiritual teacher which is rooted in structures of hierarchy and broadly speaking of accepted authority is extremely difficult. And we see this with the experience of young westerners and westerners in general, which over the decades since the transmission of Tibetan Buddhism to the West have acquired among Tibetan masters the unfortunate reputation of being extraordinarily fickle and unreliable. And I saw this happen during my own life. I remember that the outlook, let’s say, my first my root teacher, Geshe Rabten Rinpoche, had on Western students, is very different from the outlook, let’s say, His Holiness has at present.
Geshe Rabten Rinpoche felt that Western students, although disadvantaged because being raised in non religious societies, had great potential. It was just a matter of presenting things the right the right way. After some forty years, His Holiness actively discourages the conversion of Westerners because the experience has not been good. We have exceptions which basically are those for whom the central axis exist, but we have a large majority of and excuse me for the bluntness of the term I’m going to use. We have a large majority of tourists, people who come in one door and go out the other door.
This is of no benefit to them and no benefit to the transmission of the teachings. So how can we ground Guru Yoga in a way for a westerner to be able to practice it meaningfully? I think it must be grounded in logic and analysis. These are the only tools to which we can appeal with a western audience. And therefore, we must start by addressing the issue of the nature of consciousness.
And from the nature of consciousness, build up to the apex of consciousness. And then see whether the apex of consciousness, which is the omniscient mind, can actually relate to ordinary beings. So this leads me to the question of the nature of consciousness. Now one of the goals of my talks this year has been to show that there is a sizable amount of scientific data showing that consciousness is not a byproduct of the brain. If we cannot exclude that viewpoint, we cannot even begin to practice a relationship to a spiritual teacher, because there is no Dharma to practice, there is no spirituality to practice.
So how have we tried to show that there is scientific data showing that the mind is non material? First, we pointed out in the conference on verified near death experiences with the data from Bruce Greyson and his team at the division of personality studies on March 24 that consciousness can be seen as non material. There are clear experiences, near death experiences, which are verified where the person remembers data he or she could have no access to and these have in some cases occurred in controlled environments such as laboratories or operating theaters. These have to be explained by those who claim that consciousness is material. Secondly, we pointed out in the conferences of June 30 that Stevenson’s cases of the reincarnation type research shows quite conclusively that not only does consciousness preexist this life, but in addition it carries information from previous life.
And these are verified cases. Stevenson has some eight hundred twenty verified cases of children with memories from past lives, memories were verified and of these he has some 20 cases which are unexplainable in any way by any other hypotheses. These cases form the crux of our attempt to demonstrate that not only is the mind immaterial, but it is eternal. Then we pointed out during the symposium two weeks ago that from the standpoint of quantum physics, the mind and this is from the standpoint of one reading, the von Neumann reading of quantum physics, the mind must be viewed as causing the collapse of the wave function for a particle being observed. And this mind cannot be material if it were material, it will become part of what is known as the group one, in other words, the group of quantum phenomena.
Not only this, Robert Jahn, the former dean of the faculty of engineering at Princeton University, demonstrated in my opinion beyond doubt that consciousness can influence matter. Jahn demonstrated this through studying random event generators, electronic, mechanical and hydraulic, and demonstrating that statistically over 200 to 300,000 runs, there were deviations from the expected mean which could not be explained in any other way. If we put all of this together, we get a picture of consciousness as non material, pre existing this life, carrying information from previous lives, influencing matter and influencing other consciousnesses. I mentioned this in last year’s symposium when we talked of Vasiliev’s research on telepathy and the research on telepathy which was performed at Stanford University, which provides once again very strong data. All of this data is non-Buddhist.
This is data from interested scientists, physicists, biologists and psychiatrists. And I would strongly encourage you to take the bibliographies which have been handed out and study this material. It is the best possible foundation for solid Buddhist practice. Having shown that the Buddhist position is not irrational, we can now attempt to present consciousness in Buddhist epistemology. In other words, the Buddhist understanding of consciousness, which as you can see can be rooted in reality.
Now from a Buddhist standpoint, what is consciousness? Consciousness from a Buddhist standpoint is defined as that which is clear and cognitive. Clear excludes consciousness as being matter. Cognitive means that consciousness has only one function. Its function is to know.
This is why I use the image of a crystal lens for consciousness. The sole function of consciousness is, if you wish, to acquire or transmit data. And in the context of our understanding of consciousness, it is important for us to try to understand not only the nature of consciousness, but the nature of one privileged consciousness, which we know as valid cognizers or Pramanas. So regarding consciousness, the great Buddhist logician Dharmakīrti, in the second chapter of his Pramānavārttika, asserts that consciousness is necessarily infinite in its duration since it can only arise from its own type. Mind does not depend on generation from the soul body and necessarily depends on its own type, in other words, necessarily depends on a previous instant of mind.
This argument is not very convincing for a western audience until you start thinking of the data which has been gathered by the likes of Stevenson, of Bruce Grayson, of Robert Jahn and some of the data from quantum mechanics. And you can see that if we can establish that one instant of mind is non material, then it is a fairly natural corollary that all elements of the mental continuum are non material. Then I will skip perhaps or very briefly. This is a fleshing out of Dharmakīrti’s argument by the great Buddhist logician Gyaltsab Je. The subject, the mind of an ordinary being, arose previously as a former mind because of being mind.
This is a core assertion of Buddhist logic. Matter can only give rise to matter, just as mind can only give rise to mind. The two coexist, they actually interact, but they are radically different. Now within minds, not all minds are created equal. There are some privileged states of mind and these are known as valid cognizers Pramanas.
Minds can be subdivided into two: minds which are valid cognizers and minds which are not valid cognizers. A valid cognizer is what determines from a Buddhist standpoint whether a given phenomenon is real or not. So the definition or the criterion for the existence of a phenomenon is the mind which perceives it from a Buddhist standpoint. If this mind is a valid cognizer, this phenomenon is real. If this mind is not a valid cognizer, we cannot assert that that phenomenon is real.
It then becomes critical to understand what valid cognizers or Pramanas are. Initially, Dharmakīrti asserted that a Pramāna is a non deceptive consciousness. Consciousness, as we said, is clear and cognitive. In other words, it is something which is non material and which knows. What Dharmakīrti adds is the adjective non deceptive.
Non deceptive here actually means which does not turn back on itself. The Sanskrit term means that this consciousness, once it has experienced the phenomenon in a certain way, never changes in its assessment of that phenomenon. Any phenomenon. Any phenomenon. For instance, my laser pointer.
The first instant of the eye consciousness when I open my eyes looking at the laser pointer is a valid cognizer. But with your permission I will take the questions at the end if it’s okay because I would like to complete everything first. Is that possible? Yes. Thank you.
However, Dharmakīrti’s disciple, Devendrabuddhi, points out that Dharmakīrti later on adds to this statement that Pramāna is non deceptive consciousness that it clarifies an object which is not known, literally which was not known previously. So for dharmakirti, a Pramāna, a valid cognizer is a mind which is non deceptive and new. And new here, as I was saying to this gentleman, means it is the first instant of consciousness apprehending a phenomenon. Why is this the case? Because the first instant of the mind which apprehends a phenomenon has a freshness, later instance do not have.
We all experience this. The first time you go somewhere you have never been before, you have never seen pictures of, there is something particularly compelling about the place which dwindles over time. That first experience therefore is privileged. And for Dharmakīrti, it is that first experience, if it is non deceptive which tells us that the phenomenon, whether it be a sunset or a cup or, let’s say, the skyscrapers over Paris, is real, actually exists. So, having just laid the groundworks of consciousness, the question for us now is what the relationship between consciousness and phenomena is.
And here the Buddhist outlook is radically different from the totality of the Western outlooks. From, I’d say, the standpoint of Western civilization, phenomena exist out there. From the standpoint of the Buddhist and I’d say Indian understanding of phenomena, phenomena are what is established, what is proved, what is asserted by a Pramāna. It is the mind’s being a valid cognizer which establishes that the phenomenon exists. Mind comes first, everything out there comes second.
Now why is this relevant to what we are going to talk about today? Largely because this viewpoint seems to be corroborated by quantum mechanics. If we jump from 25 centuries ago to let us say nineteen thirty, then we have an attempt to understand in the nineteen thirties the behavior of the simplest model of atoms, the hydrogen atom with one proton in the nucleus and one electron orbiting around it in terms of the newly discovered discipline of quantum mechanics. What is very striking is that the ancient models of the atom which are proposed by Rutherford, where the atom was a miniature solar system with a sun in the center, the proton or the nucleus, and a multiplicity of planets, the electrons orbiting orbiting around it, was shown to be impossible in practice. One of the major problems of this model was that the atoms would eventually have to collapse into the nucleus because of the mainly electromagnetic and also gravitational attraction.
This has never happened. An attempt to try to understand in what the structure of the atom was different from that of the solar system led to the dawn of quantum mechanics. In quantum mechanics, position of the electron around the nucleus, in this case the proton, is a probability function, which is generally written as psi. This probability function describes the probability of finding the electron in various positions around the atom. As you can see, it makes sense that the probability of finding it closer to the nucleus is much higher than the probability of finding it further away.
So far so good, but the question which arose in quantum mechanics is at which point does this probability function which gives us the probabilities of finding the electron all over collapse and give us a value? The knowledge that at least the position of the electron is here. We can say nothing about its velocity, its quantity of movement, if we know its position, but we can know theoretically its position with 100% accuracy. This collapse of the wave function, it’s also known as the reduction of the state vector, occurs when an observer enters the picture. And the core question in quantum mechanics is why is this the case?
Is it because the observer through observing, as you would say in Australia, inevitably mucks things up? Or is it something more fundamental than that? And there are two schools. I won’t enter into it in detail today. We talked about it during the symposium.
For the Copenhagen School, basically, it’s the observer who makes a hash of things and by definition observers can only make a hash of things. It is seen as an evacuation of the problem by von Neumann and Wigner, who assert that it is the consciousness of the observer, not just the act of observation, which causes the collapse of this wave function of psi. It’s a consciousness of the observer which causes a transition from a probability distribution where the electron might be anywhere with various probabilities to a situation where we can give its position or perhaps its speed, one or the other according to Heisenberg’s principle. And I’m grateful to you for your patience in this difficult matter because this leads me to a suggestion. And it’s only a suggestion in the present state of affairs.
It is something I’ve been thinking about for around thirty years now. Could it be that excuse me. Could it be that what we as Buddhists know as valid cognizers or Parmanas be the specific type of consciousness which is able to cause the collapse of the wave function for any given particle. If this is the case, we have a very strong connection between the Buddhist assertion that a phenomenon is established by a valid cognizer and the quantum mechanical understanding according to von Neumann at least of certain types of consciousness causing the collapse of the wave function. It’s just a suggestion the present state of affairs but you will see it will lead us very far today.
Then we can give at present a quantum mechanical definition of Pramanas. A Pramāna, remember Dharmakīrti said, a Pramāna was a fresh, new and non deceptive consciousness. I would redefine it and say a Pramāna is a consciousness which causes a reduction of the state vector, in other words, the wave function psi, for a given set of possible phenomena. For instance, a given set of possible positions of an electron around a hydrogen nucleus. Then mathematically, we would write a Pramāna function basically leads to the collapse of the state vector psi into individual psi.
Now this actually, if it is true, will be a very powerful statement which we’re going to use later on today. And I’d like you to just keep it in mind as we move onwards with our analysis. Now, returning from quantum mechanics, I’m sorry, the difficult bit would be the first hour. Then the second hour after tea you can relax and we’ll talk of things which are more accessible. But I think with the western audience, there is no choice but to go through a very detailed analysis even if it is a bit difficult.
Then we will return at present to the Buddhist presentation no longer of consciousness but of the next step upwards which is omniscience. If we can establish that consciousness is non material and cognitive, Consciousness is being cognitive means that its function is to know. It’s being non material means that it is non restricted. It is possible to talk of an all knowing consciousness. And this is precisely what is a main topic of discussion between the various Buddhist schools.
It is possible to present fairly strong argumentation demonstrating the existence of omniscience, in other words, all knowing consciousness in Buddhist terminology. And we will see before the tea break, I promise that it is possible to make an argument in quantum mechanics for the existence of omniscience as well. So from the standpoint of Buddhist epistemology, with the science of knowledge, omniscience can exist. Why can it exist? Because the nature of the mind is clear, it’s non material.
Then if it’s non material, there’s no material limit to the mind. If there is no material limit to the mind and the nature of the mind is to know, then there’s no obvious reason for which a mind knowing everything could not exist. And if that is the case, omniscience can exist. We haven’t proven that it must exist, but I think we have made a case that it can exist. The mind is non material, it’s not bounded like a table.
Its function is to know. We can envision a mind which knows everything. It is not impossible. But not only can omniscience exist. In addition, omniscience must exist.
Because omniscience or to return to consciousness, a phenomenon to exist must be perceived at every single instant by a valid cognizer. If it’s not perceived by a consciousness which is a valid cognizer, a phenomenon does not exist. Now this is true for every phenomenon and the totality of all phenomena at the same time. If that is true, it is improbable that at every single instant there will be a sentient being busy observing that phenomenon with a valid cognizer. It will be very tedious.
Imagine every single atom in this room is one phenomenon. From a Buddhist standpoint, that atom exists only if at every single instant it is perceived by a valid cognizer. Obviously there is not a sentient being perceiving at every single instant, every single atom, there must be trillions just in the floor with a valid cognizer. Therefore, there must exist at least one valid cognizer which both perceives every single instant of every phenomenon and the totality of all phenomena. Therefore, omniscience in the full Mahāyāna sense of the term must exist.
If you accept Dharmakīrti’s definition that phenomena are what is established by a valid cognizer and you accept that valid cognizers are new and incontrovertible minds, you necessarily must accept the existence of omniscience. It’s a necessary consequence. So not only can omniscience exist, omniscience must exist. Therefore, in the context of Buddhist epistemology, omniscience exists. Now if you’re not a Buddhist and you don’t accept that consciousness, as Dharmakīrti says, is non material, if you don’t accept that consciousness is cognitive, then this argument doesn’t hold.
But if you accept the foundation, then you’re in a unavoidably led to this conclusion. Then the question which arises is what types of omniscience are there? And here the Buddhist schools disagree. Basically, there are two broad outlooks, the lower vehicle and the greater outlook. In the lower vehicle of the Hīnayāna, omniscience is the mind’s capacity to know every phenomenon.
It doesn’t necessarily have to know them, but the mind of the Buddha can know every phenomenon it turns to. Now this is not the Mahāyāna viewpoint. For the Mahāyāna school, omniscience is a mind which cognizes simultaneously every single phenomenon without exception all the time. This is a vastly expanded understanding of omniscience. For us, within the Mahāyāna tradition, it’s a second understanding which concerns us.
And it is one which is very difficult to come to terms with. Because we are asserting the existence of a mind which is exactly in this respect identical to God. The cognitive capacities of the dharmakaya and the Mahāyāna are to that of God in Judaism, Christianity, or Islam. The dharmakaya or the Buddha’s omniscience knows simultaneously everything which was, which is and which will be, every single instant thereof, as well as the totality. It’s a very powerful assertion.
Now if we try to understand the features of Mahāyāna omniscience, we can see that it is necessarily a it is therefore necessarily a valid cognizer which establishes the existence of phenomena. However, unlike the presentation in Judaism, Christianity, and Islam, as well as Hinduism, it is impermanent. It has causes and it has effects. In other words, it can be attained. Our own minds can become the omniscient mind.
It cognizes all phenomena past, present and future. And this is perhaps its most extraordinary feature. It simultaneously cognizes both the conventional and the ultimate aspect of phenomena. In other words, both the appearance of phenomena and their emptiness are cognized at the same time by the same mind. So I think you’d agree with me this is quite an extraordinary statement.
And this leads us to the presentation which I think is fundamental to now lead to Guru Yoga of the four bodies of the Buddha. The four bodies or the four kayas of the Buddha are subdivided initially in two. The form body and the Dharma body. The Dharma body is in one aspect the omniscient mind. But this omniscient mind is not accessible to beings.
It’s accessible only to other Buddhas. We could say it is the caused god mind, if you wish. Its emptiness is called the nature truth body that also is only accessible to Buddha. So these two features are only accessible to Buddhas. However, this Dharma body was acquired for the sake of benefiting others.
This omniscient mind was acquired for the sake of benefiting others. Therefore, it must manifest in a way which is accessible and it manifests as an enjoyment body or a Sambhogakāya which can be seen by high bodhisattvas. Bodhisattvas on the path of seeing and above and by a Nirmānakāya, which can be seen by ordinary beings with good karma, such as the disciples of Buddha Śākyamūni. So you can see that from a Buddhist standpoint, I will take questions after with your permission, unless it’s really important.
Ordinary beings with good karma can only hope to perceive the Nirmānakāya. If you were you were born in India twenty six centuries ago, you might have had the good fortune of meeting with Buddha Śākyamūni. However, it’s first ground bodhisattvas who can perceive these emanation, these enjoyment bodies which can manifest instantaneously all over the universe. An enjoyment body? An enjoyment body is a non material body.
It’s a spiritual guide which the Buddhas manifest and they appear frankly in meditative experience to Bodhisattvas. If you’re not a Bodhisattva, I think there’s no hope to see it. So that goes deep into meditation. Yes. Definitely.
But we’ll talk about it a bit more and then I hope to have a very dynamic question and answer session. And I hope you will hear all your doubts at me. And I hope they’ll be numerous. So to develop a little bit more the issue of perception which our friend was addressing, These are the bodies of the Buddha. We have a truth body, the enjoyment body and the emanation body.
The truth body can be perceived by other Buddhas and only them. The enjoyment body can be perceived by first-ground Bodhisattvas and above And the emanation body such as our teacher Buddha Śākyamūni can be perceived by beings with pure karma who lived in India twenty five centuries ago. What about the rest of us? In other words, pretty much everybody. Everybody else can only be helped by the truth body incarnating or manifesting in what appears to be an ordinary being.
These are the gurus. They are there to help those of us who have not been able to connect with, obviously, the truth body doesn’t concern us, but those of us who are not first-ground bodhisattvas and those of us who did not have the karma to be disciples of Buddha Śākyamūni. Then the function of Buddha is to help beings, so they manifest through spiritual teachers. If they did not, they would not be helping the beings whom they have attained full enlightenment to help. So this is a simple presentation of omniscience from the standpoint of Buddhist epistemology and within omniscience a presentation of the four bodies, which it is important to understand to understand the rationale behind Guru Yoga.
Now there is actually some evidence from cosmology, from physics, which shows that perhaps an omniscient mind is necessary from the standpoint of physics as well. Certainly in certain understandings. If we look at the prevalent model of cosmology, so called big bang model, in which the universe arises from what is known as a singularity in physics. A point at which actually the laws of general relativity which concerns space and time, do not apply anymore. The very first instance of the universe is marked by extreme inflation of a mixture of the core constituents of matter.
Quarks, which are the core constituents of protons and hadrons, and the particles which basically transmit the strong force, which binds quarks, which are known as gluons. So the very first instant after this famous big bang was what is known as a quark gluon plasma, a mixture of quarks and gluons. Now if we apply quantum quantum mechanics to quarks, it’s a technique called quantum chromodynamics, we end up with a situation where we can write a wave function for this quark gluon plasma. It’s a big soup of particles. It has to follow the rules of quantum mechanics because we are no longer at the level of the singularity here.
The laws of physics apply right here. Let’s say ten minus thirty five seconds just after the big the big bang. Fractions and fractions of trillions of seconds. If we can write a wave function for that totality of particles, then for those particles to have definite speeds or positions, that wave function must collapse. For that wave function to collapse, somebody must observe it.
No observation, no collapse. No collapse, we remain as far as the globality of the mass of quarks and gluons are concerned in a state of open ended probabilities with no possible measurement of either speed or position. We know this is not the case. Which means that at the first instant after singularity when both general relativity and quantum mechanics applied, there must have been observation. Hence, an observer.
Who could this observer have been? An observer of totality, which causes a collapse of the state vector. Omniscience. There’s nothing else we can posit. If we refuse to posit it, for Neumann’s reading of quantum mechanics, then we have a wave function which never collapses.
We cannot actually write the laws of physics. And we know we can write the laws of physics. So my personal understanding, my personal analysis is that it becomes necessary to posit an observer who causes the collapse. I wrote it as Ψ_Ω, the wave function of Ω often used for the totality in mathematics. The state vector for the universe.
And I would suggest that this observer is omniscience in the Mahāyāna sense of the term. In other words, the dharmakaya, the wisdom truth body. You note here that omniscience in the Hīnayāna sense of the term is insufficient. An omniscience which merely could observe whatever it wished is not sufficient to cause the collapse of the universal state vector. Then I think you will agree with me that following these two parallel tracks of investigation, those of Buddhist philosophy and of quantum mechanics, we have started to make a rather strong case for the existence of omniscience.
And the existence of omniscience is critical if we want to rely on the spiritual teacher. Because the spiritual teacher is seen as a manifestation of this mind. Certainly in the Mahāyāna understanding of relying on the spiritual teacher. And then from now on, I must reassure you, it becomes easier. When I started giving conferences, I always gave the easiest bit at the beginning and then I figured whenever he was in the flow of things, we’d enter into the nitty gritty.
And then I noticed large numbers of people staggering towards the exit at the end of the conference, and I figured perhaps I should reverse the robes. But I think you will agree with me that even though this is difficult, it is beneficial. So what is the function of the spiritual teacher? Or in our case, for most of us in this room, is the function of Khensur Rinpoche? From Buddhist standpoint, is very simple.
As is said in one of the readings of the Udānavarga, sages do not wash away sins with water. They do not clear away being sufferings with their hands. They do not transfer their knowledge to others. They liberate by teaching the truth of reality. This in orange is a function of the spiritual teacher.
The function of the spiritual teacher is to teach the truth of reality. You will notice here three words which I think are critical to teach, not to bless, not to save, truth, in other words truth does exist and reality. So our focus here is on reality and on truth. And for this we use the tools of analysis at our disposal. Then if this is the function of the spiritual teacher, how do we rely on the spiritual teacher?
In this context, we must be very clear about the advantages of relying on the spiritual teacher, the disadvantages of not relying or relying wrongly, how to rely mentally and how to rely through one’s behavior. The two first points I would say for us are critical because it is on this basis that we can decide whether we want or not to enter in this relationship which is by far the most potent and also the most dangerous relationship we can have. So this analysis must be done very carefully. So if we analyze a situation well, there really are only two roads from a Buddhist perspective. The road upwards leads to this beautiful little temple, a Thai temple offered by king bhumipol to the town I was raised in in Switzerland, the city of Luzanne.
I had the privilege, the good fortune to go to the same school as the king of Thailand. You know, I always felt it was quite something. And if on the other hand we rely badly, then we end up in the type of situation described rather aptly by those dark billowing clouds. So what are the eight advantages of relying well? And these I have drawn heavily from Pabongkha Rinpoche’s Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand.
If you want to enter in this topic from a Buddhist standpoint, I would say there are two main works, Lam Rim Chenmo for a more theoretical presentation and liberation in the palm of your hand for a more experiential presentation. You need to work through Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand to understand Guru Yoga. Some of the finer reasonings are presented there. The eight advantages are first that one comes closer to enlightenment precisely because the function of the teacher is to teach one how to get to enlightenment. The second advantage is that it pleases all the Buddhas of whom the teacher is as it were an emissary.
The third which doesn’t really concern Westerners since we don’t believe in their existence, is that one will not be attacked by evil spirits. Then whether you will not be hit by a truck if you don’t believe in the existence of a truck is a question I leave to you to answer. From my standpoint, it is wise to on the side of caution in these matters. Fourthly, all delusions and misdeeds stop naturally. Obviously, when one is under the aegis, under the mentorship of a spiritual teacher, since his function is to teach, especially if one relates correctly to him, one actually explains to the spiritual teacher what troubles one, then one’s mental turbulences are naturally going to dwindle.
Insight and realization of the levels of the path increase. This is self evident since the function of the teacher is to teach. We will progress within our practice as much as we can. One will not be deprived from spiritual teachers in future lives. This is a karmic consequence of relying correctly on the teacher in this life.
If we rely correctly on the teacher in this life, then in future lives we will be able to meet a teacher. If however there are thoughts on our reliance on the teacher in this life, then the odds of meeting a teacher in the future life are very small. One will not fall into the lower realms since the spiritual teacher teaches at least the path of the being of small scope. If one relates correctly to him, one will not accumulate the karma which causes animal rebirths and so forth. And finally, one will achieve all one’s goals.
Or as Geshe Potowa puts it, I think very beautifully, without a guru, how can we succeed in traveling to a place where we have never been, having just been reborn from a miserable realm? Whether or not you believe in lower realms, if you believe in rebirth and rebirth as a human being, the odds are that most of us in this room had no connection with the Buddhist teachings in the past. Then how do we hope to gain some type of realization of the Buddhist teachings without a teacher who has been there and who can actually tell us what to do? Books are not sufficient. Then the eight disadvantages of not relying or relying incorrectly on the spiritual teacher are well known.
Since the spiritual teacher is as it were the ambassador of all Buddhas, one who disparages his teacher disparages all Buddhas. Then since obviously the spiritual teacher is the most powerful karmic object we can hope to encounter once we have built that relationship, it is a huge karmic amplifier. Negative thoughts to the spiritual teacher carry tremendous weight. Tantric practice not only does not lead to its goal but precisely because tantra is rooted in the use of certain aspects of the afflictions without relying on the spiritual teacher, Tantric practice leads to the amplification of the afflictions and to collapse. Then it is obvious that not relying on the teacher, there will be no further development and probable degeneration.
And as I have seen many times myself, people who have entered in this relationship and then broken off with their teacher face great hardship in this life. It is quite surprising to see. It happens within a couple years, sometimes sooner. I knew one case in America. I used to transfer to the Buddhist Center in Virginia when I was a student.
The sponsor of the center was a woman who had little control of her emotions, and she once slapped the geshe, who was the resident teacher, in a fit of anger. Slapped it? She slapped the geshe. Then from that point on, lived in fear of him. He’s a very quiet, monk.
And then I moved in the center largely to be there as a moderating influence. This poor woman’s mind became very disturbed. She was a Buddhist scholar, actually, and she died quite shortly after of the cancer of the womb, you know, in a state of great mental distress. And there was very little one could do for her. Very little.
It was rumored about nobody wanted to talk about what exactly had happened. I have seen, in Australia, I will not talk about it, the treatment which was meted out to our teacher, Khensur Rinpoche, which is, almost as bad as this case. I have lived fifty years. I’ve been a Buddhist now for thirty one years. I have 11 teachers.
I have never heard a teacher say as Khensur Rinpoche did last year during the general assembly that his stay in Australia had been the cause of many tears, but of that, he would not talk. It’s a big indictment of Australian students, You know? And it’s very striking to me that Rinpoche never refers to his Australian, students as disciples. There’s a specific term in Tibetan. He refers to them as students, which is a term used for someone’s students studying in high school.
The reasons for this. And the karma which is accumulated by those students is heavy. And those of you who have eyes to see, you can see it unfold under your eyes. Then in future lives, obviously not relying on the teacher, one will wander in the lower realms. Obviously there is no understanding of karma and causality.
Naturally having related wrongly to the spiritual teacher, one has no hope to meet a spiritual teacher in future lives. The karma for not meeting one has been created. Then it’s an open question of what one can hope to achieve by oneself. You know, I think for many westerners precisely because this relationship is not lived well, the karma for not meeting a spiritual teacher is being created, then in the future, we just have to hope that they are able to reconstruct large elements of the Buddhist teachings by themselves, if it is possible. And then I think perhaps we will stop here.
After the tea break, we will address on the issue of how to choose a spiritual teacher. This is the most important choice you will make in your life. It’s much more important than the choices you think are important, such as choosing your boyfriend, your girlfriend, your husband, your wife. What part of Adelaide you buy a house in? Which bank you’ll get a mortgage from?
Who you’ll work for? What school you’ll send your children to? Those are choices whose full consequences lapse within twenty to thirty years. That is not more than fifteen thousand days. This is a choice whose consequences go with us as the mind moves on.
Therefore, if you are one of those careful persons who goes to all four Australian banks to compare the interest rates before getting a mortgage, you ought to be all the more careful in choosing a spiritual teacher. Because mistakes made in this field do come back to haunt one. Thank you very much.
Key terms in this teaching
- dharmakaya truth body; chö ku (Tib)
- The ultimate reality of a buddha’s enlightened mind, which is unborn, empty of true existence, free from conceptual thought, naturally radiant, beyond duality and spacious like the sky. One of the three embodiments of a buddha. LYWA
- four kayas catuhkaya (Skt); ku zhi (Tib)
- The classification of a buddha’s body into four: jnanakaya (wisdom body), svabhavikakaya (nature body), sambhogakaya (enjoyment body) and nirmanakaya (emanation body). LYWA
- guru yoga lama nel jor (Tib)
- A practice in which one views the guru as inseparable from a deity or the Buddha, in order to amass the two collections of merit and wisdom and to purify negativities and obscurations. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- nirmanakaya emanation body; tul ku (Tib)
- The emanation body of a buddha that manifests in a variety of forms for sentient beings. LYWA
- rupakaya form body; zug ku (Tib)
- The form body of a fully enlightened being; the result of the complete and perfect accumulation of merit. LYWA
- sambhogakaya enjoyment body; long ku (Tib)
- The enjoyment body; the form in which the enlightened mind appears in order to benefit highly realized bodhisattvas. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.