Compendium of Valid Cognition — 1993-11-19

44 min · 1,942 words · 19 November 1993 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Compendium of Valid Cognition (Khensur Rinpoche)
Compendium of Valid Cognition (Khensur Rinpoche)
Compendium of Valid Cognition — 1993-11-19
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 44-minute teaching on the Compendium of Valid Cognition, Kyabje Rinpoche develops a philosophical argument for the beginninglessness of cyclic existence through an analysis of causality. He begins with Dignāgā’s principle: only consciousness can be the main cause of consciousness. Through systematic examples—wood produces wood, humans produce humans, consciousness produces consciousness—he explains how causes always produce similar results. He details how form, mind, and non-associated compositional factors arise dependent on conditions, then walks through the five key similarities between primary consciousness and mental factors: object, aspect, base, time, and substance. The teaching culminates in a dialectical refutation of newly created living beings—if beings were newly created, their minds would have to arise from non-mind, which is logically impossible. For serious practitioners with philosophical training.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 1993-11-19 – 25A – KR.mp3

UUID: 0d69e398-6a52-4bda-8e17-674bb58b3d82

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Compendium of Valid Cognition

Date: 1993-11-19

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~1,950

In order to bring about that end, I must achieve a state where I have purified all my various faults and brought to consummation all my excellent qualities. In order to achieve that end of removing all my various faults and bringing the consummation of my excellent qualities, I am going to listen to, reflect upon, and meditate well this present teaching on the commentary of valid cognition. Yeah. I mean, According to a verse by Dignāgā where he says that that only a preceding consciousness can act as the substantial cause for consciousness, no other factor can act as a substantial cause for consciousness. So what does that verse establish?

It establishes the beginninglessness of cyclic existence. In order to understand what is being gotten at here, It’s necessary to understand the nature of causes and results. We have to understand how causes produce results. So, in general, with respect to phenomena, there are two categories, two types. There are functional and non functional phenomena.

Functional phenomena are those which arise dependent upon cause and condition. They are products. And non functional phenomena are those which do not which arise not dependent upon cause and conditions, they are nonproduct. So, with respect to those phenomena which arise dependent upon causes and conditions, those which are products, there are three varieties, or three types. Form, mind, and a third type which is called non associated compositional factors.

That is to say, functional phenomena which are neither form nor consciousness. So with respect to forms, they were referring to the four elements, and those which are evolved out of an aggregation of elements, the various evolutes. Of four elements, simultaneous aggregation of the elements acts as the cause for the second moment of the aggregation, the simultaneous aggregation of this element. So, for example, a previously existing form acts here form, it can also be translated as matter, physical material. Most literally, it’s form, so matter.

Previously existent acts as the cause, bringing about the subsequent result of form. There is a similarity between the previous cause and the subsequent result. The previous cause is similar in type to the subsequent result. For example, wood, as a cause, gives rise to a similar, subsequent result of wood. Flowers come from flowers.

Form comes from form. Barley will produce a similar type to itself, barley. Humans will produce a similar type to itself, humans. So this similarly applies to mind. That there is mind, which is an aggregation of the primary consciousness, along with various other mental factors, such as the five omnipresent factors, the All-Going Five, feeling, etc.

And these act as the cause having similarity, cause having similarity, which brings about a subsequent moment of mind, similar to the one which is similar to the previous consciousness which produced it. So there is an aggregation of consciousnesses, which which acts as a as a similar a cause of similarity, having similarity, which acts to bring about the second moment of a similar type of aggregation of consciousnesses. So, the reason that this is referred to as cause possessing similarity is because this aggregation of consciousness, the primary consciousness along with, for example, these five mental factors which are the All-Going Five. These five mental factors being feeling, discrimination, intention, attention, and contact produce a result, therefore act as a cause, which have five similarities. Five similarities.

For example, an eye if we take if we make use of an example, and understand what are these five similarities. An eye consciousness which sees the flower. That the primary the result So, first moment of consciousness is an aggregation of, for example, these omnipresent five mental factors, and the primary consciousness. And they have five similarities. That’s why they act as a cause, having similarity.

Let’s say there is between the mental factors and main consciousness, they have five similarities. And taking as a basis of illustrating these five the eye consciousness is seeing a flower. So the mental factors and the primary consciousness have a similarity of object of observation. They both have as an object of observation the flower. They both have the same aspect.

The eye consciousness, which is the primary consciousness in this example, takes on the aspect of the flower. The mental factors have the aspect of the flower. They all have the same base. In this case, the eye sense base is both the basis of the primary consciousness, the eye consciousness, and the five mental factors. They have a similarity of mental of the sense power, sense base.

They have a similarity of time. Both the primary eye consciousness and the secondary mental factors arise and cease simultaneously at the same time. And they have similarity of substance. There will only be a primary consciousness of eye consciousness, and it will only be associated with single, for example, feeling, mental factor of feeling. There will not be more than one feelings associated with primary eye consciousness.

There will be only a single mental factor of discrimination, etcetera, similarity of substance. So, an afflictive conscious an afflictive consciousness, afflictive mind, that is to say a mind which is associated with afflictive emotions, an afflictive mind, afflictive mind, will, as a preceding cause, give rise to a subsequent result of afflicted mind. It will, and along with the five omnipresent factors. Skillful actions — we’re going to discuss skillful actions and unskillful actions as causes.

With respect to skillful actions, a contaminated skillful action, that is, a skillful action which is associated with an afflictive emotion, will bring about a ripening result of that of a human being, in terms of body, a human being, the body of a human being or a celestial being, a feeling of happiness, and this embodiment will be beautiful. So, on the other hand, unskillful actions, or this Karma, has, as its ripening result, rebirth as a hell being, or a hungry ghost, or an animal, the feeling of suffering, and the embodiment will be of a very repulsive appearance, shape, and will have poor resources. And with respect to this third category of functional phenomena, non associated compositional factors, such things as examples of as day, or month, or year. These are are impermanent phenomena which give rise to similar type to a result which is similar in type to themselves. For example, yesterday gives rise to today, and today gives rise to tomorrow.

Last month gave rise to this month. This month gave rise to next month. This year will give rise to next year. So these are neither mind nor consciousness, neither mind nor form or matter. But they are impermanent phenomena, and they give rise to a similar result to themselves.

So because there is a variety of causes and there are a variety of ways of generating results. So why are we going through this explanation of the varieties of causes and their results? You know, we’re trying to understand that rice gives, as a cause, gives rise to acts as a cause producing rice. Barley produces barley. Humans produce humans, consciousnesses produce consciousness.

That is, they’re trying to understand that there is a similarity of type between causes and the result. A result is not produced from a non similar type to itself. And this, understanding this verse which was mentioned initially, that it is only consciousness which can act as a preceding substantial cause to consciousness trying to understand this. So here, we are saying that the result is always similar in type to its main cause. And a result has, in general, two types of causes.

There is its main cause, and an ancillary cause. A product, a result, is always similar in type to its main cause. It is not necessarily similar in type to its ancillary cause or non main cause. So, you know, we take as an example a sprout that it arises from causes. In the case of that of a barley sprout, it grows from barley seed.

The barley seed is the main cause of the barley sprout. It has ancillary causes, which are, let us say, conditions such as water and soil. But it is not necessarily it is not similar in type to those ancillary causes, but it is similar in type to its main cause, a barley seed. The same is true with wheat. Same is true with lentils, and also consciousness.

And, you know, for example, of the various types of consciousness, sense consciousness, and mental consciousness. And the mental consciousness, the main cause of mental consciousness is preceding mental consciousness, that of a similar type to itself. So if illustrate mind of today arose in dependence upon the mind of yesterday. That mind of yesterday arose in dependence upon the mind of the day before yesterday, in dependence upon the mind of a month ago, upon the mind of when you were a child, upon the mind at the moment immediately subsequent to birth, that mind in dependence upon the intermediate state being’s mind, that mind in dependence upon the mind of the previous life. And because our births are beginningless, then our minds are beginningless.

Subsequent to that, the birth which is immediately preceding this life, there was a birth which preceded that and back, a beginningless beginningless, and then the minds which accompany these over the course of these rebirths is also beginningless. Therefore, there is no beginning to cyclic existence. There is no initial beginning. Therefore, there is no newly created living beings. If there were newly created living beings, then there would be a beginning to cyclic existence.

But we do see an increase in population and number of people in the world, increase in insects, but these newly the newly developing population, these are not newly created creatures, living beings. That they have previously they have, in a former rebirth, died, and simply are taking rebirths in their present existence and present embodiment. They have taken they have not it is not the fact that they have this is they are newly taking on an embodiment, but this is simply a new body, which they are taking on. This is not the they have it is not the fact that they have not been born before. So one should consider this fact that there are no newly created living beings.

So what what do you think? Do you think there are newly created living beings? Or not? That’s a pretty big number. Is that?

So, I mean, whether there are not the fact that there are no new newly created living beings would not affect the fact that there are that there are numberless living beings. They from beginningless time, they have been numberless, and they remain numberless. If there were new newly created beings, then we could enumerate them. We could say, well, somebody was newly was born today, and we could count that individual. If there were there were newly created living being, if the new being were to take rebirth, then there would be a newly created mind.

If there were a newly created living being, then there would be a newly created mind. And if there were newly newly created mind, then this mind would have to arise from a cause dissimilar in type to itself. It would have to arise from non mind. The cause of mind must be of a similar type to mind. It it cannot be that which is dissimilar in type to mind.

Therefore, the physical or matter, the elements cannot be the main cause of mind.

Key terms in this teaching

cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
hungry ghost preta (Skt); yi dag (Tib)
The hungry ghost realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence, exemplified by incredible insatiable hunger and thirst. LYWA
intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
ripening result
One of the four ways we can experience the results of an action; the ripening result is the actual realm we are born into when we take rebirth. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top