47 min · 2,309 words · 19 November 1993 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 48-minute teaching on Dharmakīrti’s Compendium of Valid Cognition, Kyabje Rinpoche examines whether mind can arise from physical matter or only from a previous moment of mind. He systematically refutes the materialist view that the fertilized ovum or bodily elements generate consciousness, instead explaining how mind must arise from prior consciousness—a principle extending to rebirth and the continuity of subsequent rebirths. Drawing on logical reasoning, he demonstrates why beings cannot be born free of attachment if mind arose from matter, and refutes non-Buddhist schools like the Vaisheshikas. He connects this philosophy to practice: only by accepting past and future lives can we grasp karma as cause and effect, generate genuine faith in the Three Jewels, and undertake spiritual work with conviction. For serious students of Buddhist philosophy and epistemology.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 1993-11-19 – 25B – KR.mp3
UUID: dbf85113-93bd-4ee7-ac1d-cacd4bea13c2
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Compendium of Valid Cognition
Date: 1993-11-19
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~2,310
So therefore, there’s no way that the fertilized ovum of the parent coming from the parents can act as the main cause of mind. Neither this ever the fertilized ovum nor each of the elements which from which this out of, this fertilized ovum evolves out of, none of the elements individually can be the main cause of mind. So the fertilized ovum is not the cause of the mind, the main cause of the mind, nor are any of each of the elements the cause of the mind, nor the aggregation of those elements the cause of the mind. The that the only main cause of mind can only be a previous moment of mind. The ovum is, in fact, the main cause of the body.
If the mind were created only from the elements, then immediately upon birth, that mind, which is generated, there is no reason why it could not be free of attachment since the source of that mind is without attachment. So therefore, it would be acceptable to assert that a mind could immediately upon birth be free from all attachment. Is that isn’t that the case? And then the do you whose whose body? Whose body?
Me upon birth immediately upon birth arises from the fertilized ovum. He’s saying the fertilized ovum is could have attachment. The fertilized ovum from which the mind arises is saying it could have attachment because the fertilized ovum could have attachment? How can how can the fertilized ovum have attachment? How can the ovum have attachment if it’s if it’s not a living being?
How can it fertilize the ovum if it’s not a living being? So it has a seat it has a seat of attachment. It has a seat of attachment. You said it had attachment previously to things like water and etcetera. So what did how how can talking about the the fertilized ovum.
Just just that. You you saying it has attachment, and therefore, it can give birth to a mind which has attachment. And he’s he’s asking how can fertilized ovum itself have attachment if it’s not a living being? Somewhere along the line. Somewhere along the line.
Just talking about that that fertilized ovum. What what was the question to ask? What what was the last statement? He said that a mind if if the mind arose from matter, that is to say the fertilized ovum, then there should be a mind which immediately upon its creation would be free from attachment. Because matter doesn’t have attachment.
So, first off, what we mean generally by attachment, through the force of self grasping, think, oh, that’s really wonderful. I wish I had that. You see a watch, and you say, that’s a beautiful watch. I wish I had that. You develop attachment toward it or desire.
That’s generally what we mean by desire or attachment. Now I’m saying remember Jay is saying, I don’t think elements have that attachment or desire, but you’re saying it you’re saying it does. How can how can the elements have that? So attachment desire is a consciousness. It’s a mental factor.
And, but we were discussing previously whether the fertilized ovum had attachment or not. Does it have attachment? Could So the fertilized ovum, if the intermediate state being has entered into that ovum, then there is a consciousness. If it has not, there is no consciousness. So that’s that’s right.
The upon the entrance of the intermediate state being into the fertilized ovum, there is the taking of rebirth. Is That consciousness which is then present within the fertilized ovum is in continuum, is in continuity with the intermediate state, intermediate state being’s consciousness. So merely the presence of a fertilized ovum without consciousness does not bring about birth. There will be no birth. If there is no birth merely by the presence of a fertilized ovum without consciousness, then in order for birth to take place, a consciousness must be present, and that consciousness arises only from a previous similar type to itself from a previous rebirth.
So this is what Dharmakīrti is trying to get at in his quotation that we’ve cited. That it is only a preceding moment of consciousness which can act as the main cause of a subsequent moment of consciousness. The main cause can only be a cause which is similar in type to the product. If the product is consciousness, then that preceding type of cause can only be consciousness. Therefore, the consciousness of a subsequent rebirth must arise only in dependence upon a causal previous consciousness of a previous rebirth.
So if consciousness were to arise from the elements, then there would newly created beings which did not have had not existed previously. And therefore, they could they could be enumerated. They would not, in fact, be numberless. They would be of a certain number, and they would their exhaustion would be of a certain could be calculated. There would be beings who have anger, who are born immediately with anger, with attachment.
There would be beings born free of attachment, free. There would be foe destroyers immediately upon rebirth. There would be born with both combination of someone would have great anger, great attachment, great desire, someone would have little desire, some would have simultaneously anger and desire. If the are beings which newly these newly created beings were free of of desire, then there would be foe destroyers, there would be foe destroyers, never having needed to meditate on the path. That would really be fantastic if there were foe destroyer(s).
We never had we never had to meditate on the path. We could have we could have Buddhas who didn’t who never had to meditate on the path. So if we can have beings who are born free of desire, then there’s no reason why we can’t have born beings born free of the two obstructions and therefore are born as Buddhas. So, this in fact is not possible because we are born under the control of karmic afflictive emotions. Being born under the force, through the force, the control of karma and afflictive emotions, then we’re born with afflictive emotions, when there are not beings who are born under this process who are free of attachment or desire.
But there are beings who are not born under the control of karma and afflictive emotions. There are beings who are born due to the force of their compassion. There are beings like Bodhisattvas who are born for the benefit who take rebirth for the sake of living beings. But these beings have meditated the path previously and have abandoned the afflicted emotions.
We have been involved since beginningless time in the taking rebirths. And we have, you know, we’ve taken the case of we ourselves as ordinary beings, that we have taken rebirth previously and under the force of the afflictive emotions and not having abandoned those afflictive emotions, we will take rebirth under their power in the future. If in these future rebirths, if it’s under the force of negative actions, and we’re going to experience if we take negative a rebirth in the future, we’re going to experience great suffering. And even if we take a positive rebirth in the future, it will not be similar to sufferings of these negative states. Still, it will be dissatisfactory because we still are experiencing it within cyclic existence.
So, we recognize and begin to understand the nature of this dissatisfactory situation, then we will make effort in implementing the means to abandon our suffering and cyclic existence. We will make effort in implementing the means to abandon all our various faults and try to achieve all the excellent qualities. So, if we go beyond our sense of either that the past and future lives do not exist, or trying to go beyond our doubt as to whether past and future lives in fact do exist or not. And try if we understand in fact they do, then out of this we’re going to develop a great faith in the Three Jewels. We’re going to really involve ourselves in going for refuge to the Three Jewels, and take up the practice of, in a very powerful way, what is to be adopted, and what is rejected.
And in such an understanding, our practice is greatly benefited. This is the reason that the second chapter is being explained in order to benefit our practice. We can understand the power of the mind, and the existence of past and future lives, then we can begin to understand Karma as actions and results. Without past and future lives, then there’s no karma as actions and results. So we have one more teaching, and we could devote that to, you know, if you have any qualms, and then we can try to clear those up, having whatever doubts that might have.
So, you know, previously, Kimball was questioning the So, Kimball asserted a main assertion which is similar to what is called a school of philosophy called Vaisheshikas. Enumerators. I don’t know why it’s in Sanskrit.
In which, so holding that the, because the mind and the body are one entity, when the body disintegrates, the mind disintegrates. And the reason, the similar examples which they’re able to give is that if you destroy the wall, then you simultaneously destroy the mural which has been painted on the wall. Or you destroy, if you get rid of the alcohol, like whiskey, then power to to cause to bring about drunkenness is also eliminated. So it’s quite possible that there are these types of assertions. Think many Westerners would assert this, the same doctrine.
So, we have to investigate these doctrines with reasoned analysis. And through a process of reasoned analysis, we can come, we can see that the mistakes which these assertions are making, if we investigate them, then it’s quite easy to accept something what you don’t investigate. And that’s what many are doing. But we can, through reason analysis, refute them. So, you know, we can have disputes even among Buddhists.
That’s quite possible, but whatever the position, we should try to make analysis using correct reasons. The position may be, trying to analyze it using correct reasons. So there there was previously a Buddhist sect which held that the self and body were neither permanent nor impermanent. So, Śākyamūni Buddha said that you know, should not accept my doctrine out of respect for me, but you should ask it as you would gold and only upon testing should you then accept it. That, you know, just as the various means of testing gold to assay it.
You know, they use a stone, they use fire, and they scratch it with a knife, and only upon having passed these various tests do they accept it as being pure gold. Śākyamūni Buddha taught various doctrines to various disciples who were striving for liberation. To some he taught there was a self, to others there was no self. To some he taught there is true existence, to others he taught there does not exist true existence. So he taught a variety of means to for each of these particular disciples, but he said to them all that you are to investigate it, and that’s what you find true.
That is what you should follow. Why is the mind So, the reason if we illustrate that today’s mind arose in dependence upon yesterday’s mind. Yesterday’s mind rose in dependence upon last month’s mind. Last month’s upon last year’s, last year’s upon the mind when we were a child. That mind of a child arose in dependence upon the mind immediately upon the taking of rebirth.
That mind arose in dependence upon the mind of the intermediate state being. That mind in dependence upon the mind of the previous immediate immediately previous life. That mind of that life arose in dependence upon the life of previous to that that life, and that life in dependence upon the life previous to that life, that previous to that previous that. It is always arising from a previous mind, isn’t it without beginning. So this mind is said to be accompanied by attachment in either of two ways.
Either, you know, the mind is accompanied by mental factors, and of these mental factors there is the factor of desire. So, it is accompanied in terms of having an accompanying mental factor of desire, and so that’s one way. So, there’s a primary consciousness which is accompanied by a mental factor of desire, and then another way we can say that mind is accompanied by desire is that it the being has a great we say has desire and the it’s in So then there is so there’s the desire as one of the mental factors which accompanies mind, and then there is the we say that the being has desire. Because the being has desire, then that person’s mind is said to have desire, just like one can have a skillful mind, even though one has it can be accompanied by attachment. Now, one generates desire, then that is a mind which is said to be accompanied by desire or a desirous mind.
It’s accompanied by desire because it’s a desirous mind. But the mind which is simply being accompanied with the mental factor of desire does not necessarily have to be the desirous mind. It has that mental factor accompanying it. But in the case of when desire is actually generated, then we say it’s accompanied by desire because it’s a desirous mind. Is it delusion?
Is that an afflicted one? Is did you say that? Desire, which accompanies that main mind. Yeah. What do you mean by delusion?
Key terms in this teaching
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
- The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
- The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.