48 min · 2,384 words · 30 July 1993 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 48-minute session, Kyabje Rinpoche interweaves practical Mahāyāna teaching with philosophical argumentation. He begins with how to cultivate great compassion and bodhisattva resolve, using the vivid example of a mother desperate to free her suffering child to show how compassion naturally motivates action. These qualities must develop over many lifetimes. But if past and future lives don’t exist, how is this path possible? Rinpoche then establishes rebirth philosophically using the Buddhist doctrine of valid cognition, contrasting direct perception with inferential reasoning. He presents Dharmakīrti’s key argument: consciousness arises from previous consciousness, just as all phenomena arise from similar types that carry the capacity to produce them. For serious practitioners studying Buddhist philosophical texts.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 1993-07-30 – 6A – KR.mp3
UUID: 5b970a4b-14dd-4c05-9f6f-4c4f2f8d0e28
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Compendium of Valid Cognition
Date: 1993-07-30
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~2,390
Means whosoever in the world. That and when we speak of happiness, we don’t mean, simple happiness, but a happiness bereft of all suffering. The, and they want the causes of happiness. And the causes of happiness are the abandonment of the 10 unskillful actions and the development of the three fundamentals of the path, such as the determination to be free, the awakening heart and the awakening mind. Here, when we speak of happiness, we are speaking of the happiness of liberation.
And its causes are the various types of practices such as ethics, love, and compassion. So in expressing love is expressed in the thought that may myself and all living beings — It would be wonderful if myself and all living beings had happiness and the causes of happiness. May myself and all living beings have happiness and the causes of happiness. And then this attitude is is strengthened to the in the development of exceptional resolve whereby one resolves that I myself will bring all living beings happiness and the causes of happiness. And it is in the context of such an attitude that in order to achieve this end, I am going to listen well, reflect upon, and meditate.
And therefore, in such a context, we’re going to meditate for the next ten minutes. According to a verse by the master Dharmakīrti, where he said initially generate great compassion. And on the dependence of the great compassion, one goes on to develop exceptional resolve and then awakening heart. And these are assisted by, accompanied by the realization of the selflessness of persons. And it is by means of the combination of these two, method and wisdom, that one is able to eliminate all their various faults and bring to consummation all their excellent qualities.
So the root or the foundation of the universal vehicle or the Mahāyāna vehicle is compassion. How are we to go how are we to proceed in developing great compassion? It is great compassion is a tremendous longing that living beings other than oneself be free of their suffering. They’re seeing beings tortured by their various types of sufferings and ill feelings and developing a sense of compassion which wishes them to be freed from it. It’s not something which is demonstrated externally, but it it is an internal attitude, a very powerful longing that others be free of their suffering.
By way of illustration, we can take a mother whose only child is experiencing great suffering, and she develops a tremendous compassion, wishing that her child is free from that suffering. And what whatever she may be doing, whether it’s whether it’s talking, whether it’s sleeping, all her various actions are permeated with the spontaneous thought, may my child be free of that suffering. And out of this great compassion that the mother feels toward her only child who is tortured by suffering. When the thought arises, I must do something. I must I must free my child from this suffering.
And she reflects that I I don’t have the ability, you know, what can I do or who does? And she takes the child in this in this example to a doctor and the doctor prescribes a particular medicine, the method whereby to eliminate the child’s illness. And likewise, seeing all living beings tortured by various sufferings, one generates great compassion and the longing that they be free from their suffering. But one goes on to develop one goes on the exceptional resolve that I myself must free them from their suffering. And upon reflection, one sees that I simply don’t have the ability to do such a thing.
But how what can I do? And one goes on to understand that if one oneself removes all of one’s own faults and brings to consummation all of one’s excellent qualities, then one will be empowered whereby to free all living beings from all of their suffering. So one determines with great courage to remove all of one’s own faults and develop one’s own all of one’s own excellent qualities. Having developed this courageous resolve to remove all of one’s various faults and to bring the consummation all of one’s excellent qualities, we we must proceed in working with some actual means. And we have to question, well, how can I develop excellent qualities?
How can I remove my various faults? The basic fault that we are seeking to remove is that of self grasping along along with its latencies. And it is the quality of the wisdom realizing selflessness by selflessness of persons by which by means of which this fault can be removed. So one determines to cultivate this, this wisdom as a means to remove this fault. And out of one’s compassion, one develops this resolve to carry on this practice.
So it is by means of this combination of method, which is compassion on the one hand, acting as a motivating force for the development of wisdom on the other, whereby we actually are able to bring about a removal of all our various faults and bring into consummation our excellent qualities. If we were speaking within the context of secret mantra, then by the means of that practice, we could in one single human lifetime remove all our various faults and bring to consummation all our excellent qualities. But here, our present discussion is not in the context of the secret mantra. It is within the context of the perfection vehicle. So therefore, in the development of these two method and wisdom, that of compassion and wisdom realizing selflessness, it’s necessary that it be generated over a number of life rebirths or lifetimes.
So it is it is necessary that that these two, method and wisdom, be cultivated over numbers of lifetimes, many lifetimes, whereby to remove our various faults and bring to consummation our excellent qualities. But here, an an adversary is saying that then it’s not possible to develop these because there are no many lifetimes. There are no past and future lives. And therefore, as a means of resolving this, assertion of this of the of the adversary, it it is necessary, as we mentioned last time that we were going to discuss today, it is necessary to establish the existence of past and future lives, that is to say rebirth, as as a foundation for understanding the necessity to cultivate these qualities of method and wisdom over numbers of lives. So this adversary is saying that that there are there are no past and future lives.
That they do accept consciousness just as we do within Buddhism, that consciousness does exist. But this consciousness is said to the consciousness of this life is said to be generated only in reliance upon the body of this life. That it is not a product of a preceding consciousness consciousness of a preceding life. It is generated only in dependence upon the our present embodiment. Therefore, when our present embodiment deteriorates and becomes nonexistent, likewise, the mind which of this life, which is only dependent upon the body of this life, also deteriorates and becomes nonexistent.
Therefore, there is no past or future lives. Other adversaries that would propose that there are no past and future life because if if past and future lives existed, then we would be able to see them and we do not see them, therefore they do not exist. From the those who who assert the non existence of past and future lives, assert only one type of valid cognition. That is to say, direct valid cognition. They do not as is accepted by the Buddhist who accept a second type of valid cognition that is inferential valid cognition.
The Buddhists assert two types of valid cognitions, direct and inferential. Those who assert those who are presently asserting the non-existence of past and future lives do not accept inferential valid cognitions, only direct valid cognition. Cognitions. As far as the observation of past and future lives, the Buddhists would agree with the these these non-Buddhist adversaries in that the sense the physical senses are not able to directly cognize past and future lives. The five physical senses are not able to directly cognize past and future lives.
With the the are are agreeing with the the non-Buddhist adversaries in in saying that that the the that past and future lives are not are not able to be observed by the five sense valid cognitions. Those of eye, ear, nose, tongue, body. They are not able to observe the existence of past and future life. But they go on to assert that it can be validly cognized and by an inferential valid cognition which the non-Buddhist are not accepting. So the Buddhist position is that that past and future lives can be validly established, observed by a inferential valid cognition.
What we mean by an inferential valid cognizer is a cognizer which relies upon reasons. A realizer which newly cognizes its object in dependence upon correct reasons. A realizer which newly cognizes, understands its object, in dependence upon correct reasons. The the when we see something with the eye, we cognize it, but we don’t depend upon reasons. When we hear a sound with the ear, we we cognize it correctly, but we don’t use reasoning.
Here, we’re talking about the mental consciousness, not the sense consciousnesses. That that part of that type of consciousness which reflects, which uses which can think. It it is thinking, if it is this, therefore, it must be that. That. If it is this, then it must be that.
It is this, therefore it must be that. So it is a reflective type of consciousness using reasonings. And in dependence upon correct lines of reasoning, it can come to valid understandings. A simple example of be how we can arrive at a valid understanding through the process of reasoning. If you left an article in your room in the morning and maybe some money, and you went away for the day.
And in the course of the day, one person came by and came into your room. And that evening, you came back to your room, and your money was gone. So you figure, well, the money didn’t walk away by itself. And there’s only been one person here over the whole course of the day. And my I put that money here this morning, and now it’s not here this this evening.
Therefore, this person must have taken my money. And so you don’t let them get away, you grab them and you get your money back. Through this process of reasoning, one can come to a valid conclusion and understand that it only could be this person who took my money and this is one can come to a new valid understanding. Cognition which arises in dependence upon correct lines of reasoning. And this is what is meant by inferential valid cognition.
And this is probably what most scientists use in the course of their work. And they reason out on the basis of various experiments and come to new realizations, in dependence upon lines of reasoning. So, when someone who’s extremely ill would come to a doctor and the doctor could, through examination, reason out that if this person were had to have a transplant, say, or maybe they need a lung transplant or a heart transplant, that this would be of great use to them. And therefore, in dependence upon this hypothesizing and reasoning out, then they come to some understanding and then they go ahead with an operation. So in order to refute this assertion of this adversary who does not accept the past and future lives, it is necessary to go on to establish past and future lives.
And this, Dharmakīrti does in his commentary. And there is a verse in which he says that the consciousness does not arise only in dependence upon the body, but in dependence upon a previous similar type. So if we explain this in terms of external phenomena, it will be easier then to bring it back to internal phenomena. So beginning with external examples such as the various types of grain, whether it be rice, barley, wheat, or peas, etcetera, lentils, that rice grows in dependence upon a previous type similar to itself. This extends to all types of external phenomena, whether it be flowers, grass, wood, leaves, that they all grow in dependence upon those which have a potency to bring about a similar type to themselves.
Without this potency or capacity of being able to generate something which was similar to it, then it could not be produced. That they do not simply grow haphazardly, but always in dependence upon something which has a capacity to produce something similar in type to itself. Something something it has a capacity to grow. That which has the capacity is similar in type to itself. That which has the capacity to grow it, has to be similar in type to that which is grown.
So just the as case of similar, as in the case of external phenomena, the same applies to internal phenomena such as the breath, such as the sense powers, such as the consciousness, the mind. They all arise in dependence upon a previous type similar to themselves. Let me get it. They all arise in dependence upon a previous type which is similar to themselves. So if we said that inferential valid cognitions arise in dependence upon reasoning, or another word which is used is in dependence upon a sign, a correct sign or a correct reasoning.
And if we were to put this in the form of a line of reasoning, an example would be as follows: The clear sense powers, arose in dependence upon a previous type similar to themselves, because they are sense powers, respiration, and mind. So if we elaborate on what we’ve just said using that of consciousness, we can take ourselves and that we are adults and that we can take the consciousness which we presently have, the consciousness which we have at present, arose in dependence upon the consciousness of this morning, which is to say a consciousness of a previous
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- mantra ngag (Tib)
- Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
- Secret Mantra sang ngag (Tib)
- Another name for Vajrayana, so called because it should not be revealed to those not ready. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.