Compendium of Valid Cognition — 1993-07-30

48 min · 2,627 words · 30 July 1993 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Compendium of Valid Cognition (Khensur Rinpoche)
Compendium of Valid Cognition (Khensur Rinpoche)
Compendium of Valid Cognition — 1993-07-30
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 48-minute teaching on the Compendium of Valid Cognition, Kyabje Rinpoche refutes the materialist objection that consciousness arises from bodily elements alone. Through logical analysis, he traces consciousness backward—from childhood memories through conception, the womb, intermediate states, and previous lives—establishing that consciousness, not the body, persists across lifetimes. He demolishes the materialist position with multiple arguments: consciousness cannot arise from formless aggregates; elements alone cannot generate consciousness; genius parents sometimes produce unintelligent children. Using analogies (seeds and soil, clothes and the person), he shows consciousness must arise from prior consciousness of the same type. He contrasts the mind’s formless continuity with the body’s steady deterioration. The Q&A addresses objections about consciousness and rebirth. For practitioners studying Buddhist philosophy and debate.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 1993-07-30 – 6B – KR.mp3

UUID: 3baf2a01-365f-49e8-a28e-7374c174164b

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Compendium of Valid Cognition

Date: 1993-07-30

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~2,623

Type. That that consciousness of this morning arose in dependence upon yesterday’s consciousness. That is to say, a consciousness a previous consciousness of a similar type. And that consciousness of yesterday arose in dependence upon the consciousness of the day before yesterday and that we can follow this procedure back until we come to the consciousness of the newly born child. So if we will explain how we can establish that our present consciousness arose in dependence upon this morning’s consciousness, it is because there is we can remember what we did this morning.

And the consciousness of this morning arose in dependence upon the consciousness of yesterday because we can there is a continuity between the consciousness of yesterday and today in that we can establish this continuity because we can remember what we did yesterday. And we can continue this process all the way back until the time of our childhood. We can remember the various games that we played, what we did and what we didn’t do. And so this is a sign that a subsequent consciousness relies for its existence on a previous consciousness of a similar type to itself. If it did not rely upon a previously gone consciousness similar to itself, then we would not have memories of what we did in the past.

And likewise, there are many individuals who remember their previous lives. That in this previous life I did this, in this previous life I did this, in this previous life I had this mother, in this previous life I had this father. They have these memories of a previous life. The reason that we cannot remember that someone present who is living present is ourselves in a previous life is because we do not have a memory of being that present person in a past life. Why?

Because we are consciousnesses. Your consciousness and my consciousness are separate, therefore I cannot have a memory of being you in a past life. Each moment of consciousness arises in dependence upon a type, a consciousness which similar in type to itself. And this proceeds all the way back to this newly born, to the consciousness within the newly born child. But this consciousness also arose in dependence upon a consciousness similar in type to itself, that with the consciousness which existed in the fetus of the womb.

And this, the consciousness within the fetus of the womb, can also arose in dependence upon a consciousness of a similar type to itself, all the way back to the consciousness which existed at the moment of conception. But that too, that consciousness too had to arise on in dependence upon a consciousness of a similar preceding type preceding similar type. And that was the consciousness of the intermediate being. And that consciousness of the intermediate being also arose in dependence upon a consciousness of a preceding similar type. And that was the death consciousness of the previous previous life.

And that consciousness and backwards we can proceed without ever finding a beginning to this continuum. So, in understanding the existence of past and future lives, we have to understand that it is the consciousness which is continuing on through the past from the past to future lives. It is not the body. The body has a certain potency to remain in existence. And when that potency is exhausted, then it deteriorates and is sloughed off.

It is left behind. Then the consciousness continues on, assuming a new body, taking on a new body. We have done this in the past. The consciousness came from the past life, and it appropriated our present body. But this body has only a certain potency which maintains its existence.

And when that potency is exhausted, then this body will be left behind and our consciousness will continue on. Is the consciousness continues uninterruptedly in a steady stream like flowing water. Whereas the body — a new body is taken on. That becomes old. That is sloughed away.

A new body is taken again, that becomes old, is sloughed off, and a new body this is proceeding through re births in this way. So if we were here to illustrate this the difference between our body and mind in terms of the aging process. You know, we can trace back consciousness from the moment of the newborn baby and proceed down through the course of its life through the ages, through the teenage years, and proceeding down to maybe, like myself, to the age of 70 or something like that. And that the mind remains and just continues on in a steady stream through these series of years, over these years. But if we look at the body over the same period, then, you know, when we’re young we have a healthy body, a good body, a beautiful body, a very powerful, flexible body.

But as we grow older, we lose our hair, we become bald, we are bent over, wrinkled. There’s tremendous changes going on with respect to the body, which do not take which are not occurring to the mind? So the, finally the body changes to such an extent in this deteriorating process that it is no longer able to support the mind. And it is it is left behind. And what but what does the consciousness do?

It is it is still in the moving along in an uninterrupted uninterrupted continuum as it has throughout that life. But now it simply appropriates a new body. The the mind is can be likened to the person and the body like clothes. Like when our clothes become old, just throw them out and we get some new clothes. Likewise, our our our body gets worn, then we just throw it out and we get some new body.

We get a new body. Let’s bring that back to what we’re trying to establish in terms of consciousness. What the adversaries are saying is that the consciousness of the of the newly born child arose only from the body. That is to say, arose from various elements. But here we are disputing that.

We are saying that it did not arise only in dependence upon the body or the elements, but in fact arose in dependence upon additionally a previous similar type. The adversaries are saying, no, it does not arise in dependence upon a previous similar type, it rises in dependence upon only the body. So it’s important to analyze, well, what do they mean when they say that the consciousness arises in dependence only upon the body? What do they mean by body here? Do they mean the body of the parents, the mother and father?

Do they mean the sperm and ovum, which united from the mother and father? Or do they mean the body of the newly born child So one way we can look at this is that there are many types of sentient beings who do not have bodies. There are the beings in the formless realms. There are unembodied sentient beings. The beings in the formless realms, these beings only have, of the five aggregates, only four aggregates, those of feelings, perceptions, mental formations, and consciousnesses, they do not have the aggregate of forms.

So these beings do not arise in dependence upon a body, do not develop in dependence upon a body. But if we could come back to ourselves as humans, then trying to establish what body do they mean when they say that the consciousness arises in dependence upon the body. The consciousness existed previous to the birth of the child. The consciousness existed while the child was still in the womb. So the consciousness did not exist in terms of the body upon birth.

It did not the consciousness did not arise only it did not arise in dependence only upon the body at birth, but the consciousness existed previous to that body. They would probably say, well, the consciousness arose in dependence upon the fetus while it is in the womb. And what they are saying when they say that is that the consciousness arose in dependence upon the collection of the elements and the evolutes. Those that those materials which evolve out out of the elements. The elements being earth, fire, water, and air.

Therefore, the consciousness must have arisen in dependence upon the four elements earth, water, fire, and air elements. And if that were the case, elements each of the elements must have a conscious component, and each of the elements would be a sentient being. So if each of the elements were a sentient being, then within the womb there would be many, many sentient beings, and upon birth there would be the birth of many, many sentient beings. It arises in dependence upon only the elements. That is to say, that which is dissimilar in type to itself.

It arises only in dependence upon the elements of the body. If that were the case, then if consciousness only arose in dependence upon elements, then how are we to explain the differences in the various capacities of the consciousness which do arise in terms of its clarity, its power, the intelligence of the consciousness, its various attitudes of having some people have strong anger. Some babies have a great deal of anger, some no anger. Some have a great deal of attachment, some no attachment, some have more compassion than others. So there’s all these various unique varieties of consciousness which do arise within a newborn child.

But this cannot be explained if the consciousness only arises in dependence upon the elements, since the elements would be exactly the same for all of the children. But it is because of the unique causes that these varieties of results arise. Because the unique cause is their own individual stream of consciousness preceding them, therefore there are these unique results and different temperaments and characteristics of consciousness. They all have to be the same if they only arose in dependence upon the elements. Also, this internal phenomena of consciousness arises through aggregation, only in dependence upon an aggregation of various internal elements, then it should be also duplicated in the external world.

That upon when the various In external world, when the elements combine together earth, water, fire, and air then there should arise consciousness since these elements are exactly the same as the external elements are exactly the same in their function as internal elements. Therefore, consciousness should be arising externally. So we can ask the question, well, if the consciousness arose in in dependence upon the aggregation of internal elements, then the elements which are external types the types of elements, they perform the same functions, have the same capacities and abilities, then why not in dependence upon external? The aggregation of external elements does not generate consciousness. They’re the same.

So, we should have we also should have consciousness arising through the aggregation of external elements as we do in the aggregation of internal elements. So, we can also proceed with put forth a reasoning by way of an analogy. We could say that if things simply if we do not need a similar type previous in order to generate an object then why can’t why doesn’t if even when we do not plant seeds such as barley and wheat, but if we simply add if we simply combine water and soil, why doesn’t barley grow? Why doesn’t wheat grow? Since they’re all the various elements are present.

But in fact, in order to grow a barley seed, in order to grow barley or order to grow wheat, we have to have a cause similar in type. Must precede that production. And therefore, let us say we must plant a seed. In order to grow barley, we have to plant a barley seed. So this or in order to grow wheat, have to plant a wheat seed.

Without that seed, then there’s no production of the result of that particular type of result. And likewise with consciousness, the must be preceded by a similar type of cause like a seed, and that previous type is the previous moment of consciousness. So I think it would be good if we stop there, but and try to resolve some of your qualms, your doubts, and you can ask some questions. Yes? So the body is formed, the mind is formless, but the mind has power over the body.

If we think to do something, for example, if we think to talk, then the mouth starts working. If we think to write, then the hand starts writing. If we think to walk, then we start the feet start moving. Though it’s formless, less, the mind has power over the body. If we get angry and want to hit somebody then we can can hit them.

So whoever the being may be, they they are under the influence of their mind. Their only power, not other power, is their own mind, whether it’s a bodhisattva or an ordinary person. In the case of a bodhisattva, by the power of their great compassion, their awakening heart, they take rebirth after rebirth for the sake of sentient beings in order to teach them the Dharma, in order to benefit them. They go through immeasurable difficulties. In the case of ordinary beings, out of our anger and jealousy.

We kill. We steal. We commit sexual improprieties. We speak harshly about others. And these all occur through the power of our individual minds.

Yes? So we’re going to discuss this next time, but just very briefly, there are those who assert as your question was asking that since the body does arise from the sperm and ovum of the parents that is in a way of speaking from the parent’s body, then the same is the case of the consciousness. The consciousness comes from the parents’ consciousnesses. And if this were the case, then if the parents were geniuses, then the child should be a genius. On the other hand, if the parents were dumb, then the child should be dumb.

But as we do know, that genius parents can give birth to dumb children, and dumb parents can give birth to genius children. I think I got that right. Consciousness. When and where does it begin? What was the first word?

The consciousness. Where when and where? When and where. The question. So there is no beginning to the continuum of the consciousness of the individual.

There’s it is beginningless. There’s no point at which we can identify as the first moment, as the beginning of the consciousness. There is no beginning or end to the consciousness. There are new moments of consciousness, but there’s no there’s no newly established continuum of a consciousness. And in terms of newly newly new moments of consciousness arising, it’s like the yearly yield of a fruit tree.

Each year flowers grow and then a fruit grows. And this happens year after year. The new fruit comes year after year after year. There is no new beginning of the continuum of the fruit. There are new moments of consciousness, but the continuum of consciousness of the individual is not newly established.

So this is by new moments of consciousness, we could, as we did today when we cultivated compassion and we reflected, ‘May all living beings be free from suffering and the causes of suffering’, or we could, we could, generate love, or we could generate the wisdom, we have the ability to generate the wisdom of realizing selflessness. So these are all newly generated moments of consciousnesses. Yes. And and initially, did you generate compassion?

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

When and where does consciousness begin?

Consciousness has no beginning. The continuum of an individual's consciousness is beginningless, and no point can be identified as its first moment. It has no beginning or end. What is new is the moments of consciousness, not the continuum, which is never newly established. This is like the yearly yield of a fruit tree: flowers grow and then fruit grows, year after year, yet there is no new beginning of the continuum of the fruit. New moments of consciousness can be generated, for example when cultivating compassion with the thought 'May all living beings be free from suffering and the causes of suffering', or when generating love or the wisdom realizing selflessness.

Scroll to Top