40 min · 1,591 words · 23 July 1993 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 40-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche examines why beings with a karmic history of killing might live long lives—a question hinging on understanding when karma ripens. A negative action may bear fruit not in this life, but in the next or in lifetimes far ahead. He develops three vivid analogies—a mixed container, a raffle, a field of seeds—to show how multiple dormant karmas wait for the right conditions to ripen, with no certainty which will manifest first. He introduces the four opponent powers as the method to purify karma before it ripens. The teaching culminates in a rigorous logical argument for past and future lives, grounded in the mind-body relationship, followed by Q&A on memory, causality, and rebirth.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 1993-07-23 – 5B – KR.mp3
UUID: 4985db87-066b-40da-8c86-1c170cf420b1
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Compendium of Valid Cognition
Date: 1993-07-23
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~1,586
I’ve done a lot of killing, but in the present life had a long life, or in a past life they were very miserly, in this life they were very generous. To see that if we were to look at that in a view it in a very superficial manner, then we would have to agree with them. Within Buddhism, all our various actions, so to say, the various acts which create karma, whether it be physical, verbal, or mental, bring about a result. But there are three types of results in terms of time. That these actions can bring about a result in this life.
If the result is not experienced in this life, then the result will be experienced in the immediately next life, and if it’s not experienced in the immediate next life, then in a future life. So there are these three possibilities for experiencing a result of an action. Can either be the result can be experienced in this life, the next life, the immediate next life, or a future life. And if one does not understand that, then one could one can make such an error. It’s not necessary that we experience the result of our actions in this life.
It can be in an immediate next life or in a future life. And in the case of one who is experiencing a long life, in their present life, and though they may have in fact killed many people in a past life, but this is not the result of that life of having killed many people. That previous to that, immediately past life, they would have lived a life where they had abandoned killing. And therefore, in some previous life previous to the immediately past life, as a result of the action of having abandoned killing, they would now in this life be experiencing a long life. By way of analogy, if we were to have a container filled with many different articles, and we were to put a new article in that container, and we were to reach in without being able to see, and to draw out that same article, that article which we just put in.
Would have mixed in this new article with those previous other articles. We wouldn’t necessarily draw out that new article which we just put in. It definite wouldn’t that we’d draw that article. If the articles weren’t there, then definitely if we put that in the container, then we’d definitely draw that same newly put article. That’s for sure.
But there are other articles already present and it’s not sure which one we’re going to draw out. Likewise, we have created many karmas in the past, not only in this life but in previous lives. And all of these karmas are ready to create, to generate their results. And it’s indefinite which one is going to generate their result. So it’s it’s very much like a raffle, you know, that if there were many people who who had bought bought tickets and they were all placed in the container and you put your ticket in there along with them and they were all mixed together, it’s indefinite.
It’s not sure that you’re going to pick your ticket. Your ticket’s going to be picked. So likewise, we have many karmas which are waiting to ripen, both negative and positive. And upon meeting a proper condition, then the result will come forth. Another analogy would be if we were to plant a field with many seeds, then which of those seeds germinates germinates and sends up shoots first is dependent upon them having met the proper conditions, and it’s not sure which ones are going to meet the proper conditions.
For example, which ones are going to become wet or moist first, which are going to remain dry. Upon killed many times in the past, then one will experience that result eventually, unless one purifies that negative action and applies the four opponent powers. If one does that, then there will be no result. One can alleviate the ripening effect of that action. But if one does not apply the four opponent powers, then that action will never be lost.
It will eventually it does not become nonexistent, and when it meets the proper conditions, then the result will arise. So, simply by the force of that argument, we cannot refute the existence of karma as actions and the results. If we consider it well, then every, all of our reasoning will come to support the existence of karma or actions as causes and their results. That thinking will in no way refute the existence of karma. That when we think about the nature of results and their causes, it all seems to support its existence.
And as with respect to these two causeless phenomena which were posited, that is the sharpness of thorns and the colors of the feathers of the peacock. They too are not causeless, but in fact, arising depends upon causes. The thorns necessarily arise from a seed. From the seed, the bush, and then the thorns come, and therefore, and sharp thorns. So they have a cause, and likewise, all of the various colors of a peacock each has, arises in dependence upon having collected a specific karma in the past.
They do not arise out of no cause. So there was in talking about the necessity for a cause for the sharpness of thorns, we mean a a cause which caused them to grow. We’re not talking about that each of the thorns was sharpened somehow, and that was the cause of a sharp thorn. So the in terms of the apples, each of the apples grows from an apple tree. That’s their cause.
They cannot hold their position. Those who assert that the karma as actions and their results does not exist, they cannot maintain their position. And also And also, in terms of simply because the mind relies upon the body, that upon the coming of the nonexistence of the body, the mind also comes into nonexistence is not tenable. That simply, and that none of these three analogies are able to be supported, that is to say, that because when flame is extinguished, the rays from the flame are extinguished. Eliminated, then the potency of the butter lamp is eliminated, and when the mural is when the wall is destroyed, the mural is destroyed.
This is not the same relationship between body and mind. If the body develops if the mind develops from the body, then there are two possibilities. Either our mind developed from our own body or our mind developed from our parent’s body? So, with respect to whether our mind develops from the body of our parents, the mind enters into the union of the sperm and ovum. Prior to that, before the union of the sperm and ovum, the sperm and ovum were parts of the body of our parents, and there was no mind present.
It wasn’t our body. Is our body the sperm and ovum of our parents? Yes. Before the union of the sperm and ovum, while they’re still in the parents’ bodies. Are they our bodies?
Is that our body? So then the mind which eventually enters into the union of the sperm and ovum, did that develop from the sperm and ovum of our parents? So there’s there’s a lot to meditate on. So, we’re going to stop there, but it would be I would like for you to reflect upon and meditate on these points of the existence of past and future lives. We’re going to continue on in discussing past future lives.
So, we have a few minutes if you like to, if you have some questions. What’s your question? Yeah. What do you think about it? Can you give me a definition of collective consciousness?
See that here. I don’t think I can discuss this further. What would you do? Then there’s no memory, in general. Like, you if you haven’t if you haven’t if you haven’t seen the color blue, then you can’t have a memory of blue.
If you haven’t seen the color yet, yellow, you can’t have a memory of yellow. If you’ve never seen this person, you can’t have a memory of that person in general. But someone of very sharp faculties, very intelligent person, might be able to be able to remember through there’s some difficulty with the word remember. Think know, Rinpoche was using an example of cold and hot, having gone through so many past lives that one can under and one could have an understanding of of what of what the this of what they’re about to experience since they’ve probably experienced a similar in a past life. And they can use their reasoning about what they’re and they can have a they can understand it, what it would be.
Though they’ve never experienced it, they can understand it through their reasoning. So he died because he had exhausted the potency which maintained his life, even Even though he may have had some clairvoyance and been able, had some premonition about when he was going to die, merely that thought did not cause his death. That he thought he was going to die in five years, but it was at the, when his, the karma supporting his life was exhausted. So, we’ll continue discussing the proof of the existence of past and future lives.
Key terms in this teaching
- four opponent powers nyenpo tob zhi (Tib)
- The four practices used to purify nonvirtuous imprints on the mindstream. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.