49 min · 3,226 words · 23 July 1993 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 49-minute commentary on the Compendium of Valid Cognition, Kyabje Rinpoche argues against the materialist objection that past and future lives cannot exist because they are not observable by the senses. Using logical refutation, he dismantles the claim that mind and body are inseparable—deploying metaphors of beer and potency, wall and mural, light and rays—and establishes the three types of valid cognition: valid beings (enlightened teachers), valid speech (authoritative texts), and valid consciousnesses (direct realization of selflessness). By listening, reflecting on, and meditating upon these teachings, practitioners build conviction in the Three Jewels and eliminate suffering at its root.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 1993-07-23 – 5A – KR.mp3
UUID: 521aa51f-3f30-4683-ad1e-af8b8cf4d3dc
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Compendium of Valid Cognition
Date: 1993-07-23
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~3,228
We have achieved a precious human life, which is by means of which we can carry on our practice of Dharma, a human life which has all the necessary conducive conditions and absence of inhibitory conditions whereby we can carry on a successful practice. All sentient beings, whosoever want happiness and do not want to suffer. And there is nothing, there is no greater basis for achieving this in as a means than as a means to eliminate our suffering and to achieve happiness than our precious human body. But we are not simply seeking to eliminate our own suffering and achieve happiness for ourselves alone. That is a very narrow perspective.
It has very little power and will achieve very small results. But instead, try to expand the scope of your horizons and develop the attitude first of love, which wishes all living beings to have happiness and the causes of happiness, and compassion, which wishes that all living beings be free from the causes of suffering and suffering. As a preliminary development of love and compassion, but following that with the attitude that in order to eliminate the suffering of all living beings, in order to bring all living beings complete happiness, I must eliminate all my various faults and bring to consummation all my excellent qualities, and therefore I must achieve such a state. Having achieved that state myself, then I will be able to lead all living beings to that same state. In order to achieve that end, I am going to listen well, reflect upon, and meditate the present teaching in order to benefit all living beings.
In the Pramānavārttika or the commentary to the Compendium of Valid Cognition, we’re looking at the second chapter where it, establishes the the nature of a valid cognition. So amongst the valid objects, there is said to be three types. There are valid beings, valid speech, and valid consciousnesses. So what we mean by a valid being is a person who is able to show in an undistorted, unerring, unmistaken manner the what is to be adopted and what is to be rejected in terms of the four and above truths to those disciples who are striving for liberation. And those texts or books which set out the teachings or the method in non erring, unmistaken manner of what is to be rejected and what is to be adopted are termed valid speech. And a valid consciousness or a valid awareness is a new realizer which newly understands such objects as knowledge as the nature of the four noble truths.
So there’s new realizers or understandings which understand realized knowables. So, in a line from the second chapter, which is paying homage to that which is valid, the main homage is being paid to a valid person. So it is in the second chapter which sets out the establishes the valid refuge with that which is able to afford us protection from suffering. That sentient beings who or whosoever are tortured by various types of suffering. And it is in this section that sets out the methods whereby what is to be adopted and what is to be rejected and find happiness in eliminating our unwanted suffering.
And these amongst the three refuges of Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha, it is the Buddha who is the shower of the refuge. That is to say, show shows us the unerring method which leads to happiness, which eliminates our suffering. So the the Buddha is the shower of the refuge, that is to say, the shower of the methods in terms of what is to be adopted and what is to be rejected. The actual refuge is that is the the jewel of the Dharma. The in explaining the Dharma as the actual refuge, it is the actual realization of the selflessness of persons.
In the Commentary to the Compendium of Valid Cognition, the method of setting out the selflessness is in terms of the selflessness of persons. In general, there are four tenet systems or four philosophical systems of Buddhism. Here in the commentary, the selflessness or emptiness is taught in terms of that which is common to both the Sautrāntika tenet system and the Mind Only tenet system. In terms of emptiness, non true existence of all phenomena is not taught. Rather, of the two types of emptinessesthe emptiness of phenomena and the emptiness of self, the emptiness of self is taught, and it is the direct realization the wisdom which directly realizes emptiness, which is the Dharma.
It is by generating the direct the wisdom which directly realizes the selflessness of persons that all suffering along with its roots are able to be eliminated or abandoned. And how this has come about. The root of all our suffering that which generates our suffering most basically, is grasping at the self of persons. Is in dependence upon grasping at the self of persons, develop the various afflictive emotions of attachment, hatred, anger, pride, jealousy, etcetera. And it is and depends upon this, we engage in various types of negative actions or create karma.
And it is through these negative types of karma that we continue to circle within cyclic existence and experience suffering. How is it the how are we to overcome the root of our suffering, that is to say the grasping at the self of persons? It is by the generating the realization of the selflessness of persons. These two awarenesses, the realization of the selflessness of persons on the one hand and grasping at the self of a person on the other, are mutually incompatible, that they are mutually contradictory. That the realization of the selflessness person is able to understand that the object of grasping toward itself does not exist, and it is in the nature of the actual situation such that it can overcome the illusory quality of the self grasping at itself, which in fact the self is nonexistent.
So being in the nature of the actual situation, it is able to eventually increase in its potency while the self grasping is only able to be lessened in its power. Until a point is reached when the self grasping is completely eliminated from its roots, once that occurs then the afflictive emotions which are generated in dependence upon self grasping are no longer developed. We are no longer creating karma and therefore are no longer creating the causes of suffering. We have eliminated the causes of suffering and therefore we have eliminated having eliminated the causes, we no longer experience the resultant suffering. We experience only happiness in terms of liberation, and we have brought about the ultimate purposes of both oneself and others.
We have achieved that state. Mean by the Dharma here is the wisdom directly realizing selflessness. It is able to eliminate all suffering and lead to complete happiness. The wisdom newly and directly realizing selflessness is valid consciousness. We said that there were two types, there’s three types of valid that of beings, speech, and consciousnesses.
Here, what is meant by a valid consciousness is this is the wisdom newly and directly realizing selflessness. If we make effort and implement the methods whereby we we can eventually free ourselves from suffering by generating the wisdom newly and directly realizing selflessness. We can generate such a consciousness and thereby eliminate our suffering. If we are not able to generate such a consciousnesses, then there’s no way that we can eliminate our suffering. If we combine this wisdom, the direct the wisdom directly and newly realizing selflessness with the method of the awakening heart, love and compassion, and couple these two together, then we can achieve the state of Buddhahood.
That is a state whereby we have eliminated all our various faults, and we have brought to consummation our excellent qualities. Those who are practicing unerring methods whereby to generate these two, method and wisdom, are are referred to as the Sangha, or more specifically the Sangha of superiors or the superior spiritual community, the Ārya Sangha. So when we speak about the Sangha or the spiritual community, we are not necessarily speaking about those who wear red robes or monks, etc, or nuns, but those who have generated these wisdoms and methods within their minds. Once one has generated these wisdoms and methods within their mind, whether one is a lay person or whether one is a renounced person, one becomes a Sangha or this superior of the spiritual community. So if we were to through a gradual process of listening, reflecting, and meditating on the subject of selflessness, then we can generate this wisdom of realizing selflessness.
If we don’t utilize these methods, then we are never going to generate the wisdom realizing Therefore, the Compendium the Commentary and the Compendium of Valid Cognition sets out, means by which we are able to identify these three refuges, trying to understand what the three refuges are as a means for eliminating our suffering, as a means for achieving happiness. And if we come to understand what these three refuges are and how to generate them, then we can begin to create thewe can begin to eliminate the causes which bring us our suffering. We can begin to practice those methods which bring us happiness. We can gradually come to a the wisdom of realizing selflessness. We initially, we want to identify what are the three refuges.
But subsequent to that, we actually want to generate the refuges within our own minds. So in order for our practice to go well, we must in order that we are able to abandon our various faults and develop all the excellent qualities, must develop a striving, we must develop some fervent effort toward that end. In order to actually in order to generate the wisdom, realizing selflessness, we must first listen to these teachings and then reflect upon and analyze them. Through this process, we will take heartfelt refuge in the Three Jewels. And we will and through that we can set the basis for a practice in terms of karma, that is the actions as causes and their results, whereby we begin to engage in the practices of what is to be adopted and what is to be rejected.
We go on to gain conviction in past and future lives and begin to analyze the four noble truths. Through this sequence of methods, we develop a very powerful wisdom and we develop a great liking for practice. And we have a very fervent a great effort, a joyous effort in our practice. And we develop a real conviction in these objects of practice. And this is all is extremely beneficial.
In in the development of wisdom and method, and method in terms of love and compassion, it’s necessary that we we cultivate these over a number of lives, that we we go accustomed to wisdom and method, not just in once in our life, but we we cultivate them over numerous lifetimes in order to actually achieve the end of eliminating our various faults and bringing to consummation our excellent qualities. So we have to look to more than one life to carry on such a cultivation. But an opponent may say, well, we cannot cultivate love and compassion and wisdom over many lives. Because why? Because there aren’t many lives.
Past and future lives don’t exist. So there’s no. So previously in India, there were there were many disputes over the existence of past and future lives. Some people held that the past and future lives exist and many did not, and they were they carried on a great debate. With with respect to objects of knowledge, those knowables, there are some objects we simply cannot see with the eye.
In fact, there are three levels of knowables. The first level are those things we can readily see with our senses. These are called obvious phenomena. But then there is another level of phenomena called slightly hidden phenomena. And these in order to understand these, we have to use make use of reasoning.
But there is an even more subtle level of phenomena called extremely extremely hidden phenomena. And in order to come to an understanding of these phenomena, we must rely not only on reasoning, but also on the teachings of the Buddha. We have talked in a rough manner last time about the different types of valid cognitions or valid cognitions. We we said that there were six eye, ear, nose, tongue, body, and mental cognitions which are six valid cognitions or consciousnesses. These first five, these sense valid cognitions, can only understand very rough objects.
For example, the eye valid cognition can only understand it sees colors, it sees shapes, red, white. That’s all it’s able to understand. Nothing more than that. The ear can hear pleasant sounds or unpleasant sounds. The nose can smell pleasant odors, unpleasant odors.
The same with the tongue in terms of flavors, and the body can feel rough or smooth textures. That’s all they can know. These objects are very obvious. In order to understand these objects, we do not need to rely upon reasoning. So in order to understand the objects of these sense valid cognitions, we don’t need to think about the objects.
We can just see it or we can hear it, merely that is sufficient. So the proponents of the nonexistence of past and future lives based their assertion on the fact that they do not see past and future lives, and because they don’t see it, it does not exist. But if we were to say that just because we don’t see something or we don’t understand something by means of these five sense valid cognitions, then it doesn’t exist. This would be extremely absurd. There are many, many objects.
Probably most phenomena are not able to be understood through merely the sense valid cognitions. For example If we just speak of this in very rough terms, there have been many, many past objects in the world, many past phenomena, which are not available to our direct observation by the senses, but we know that they exist. Also, there will be many future phenomena which are not presently observable by the five senses, but we also can understand that they exist. Also, between the two, body and mind, we are not able to sense the mind in terms of we cannot see it with the eye or we cannot observe it with the eye, nose, smell it, or taste it, or feel it. Therefore, some people would say, well, it doesn’t exist.
So you can think about this for yourself. Does the eye consciousness understand the existence of the mind? Does the ear understand the existence of the mind? Does the nose understand the existence of the mind? Does the taste understand the existence of the mind?
Does the body consciousness understand the existence of the mind? If we relied solely upon those consciousnesses then we would think that the mind doesn’t exist. So the mind thinks of many different types of objects which are not able to be observed by the sense consciousness. If if because we aren’t able to understand it by the five senses, it doesn’t exist, then such phenomena as impermanence, selflessness, the awakening heart, love, compassion, because they are not observed by the five senses would therefore not exist. So the first in refuting the non existence of past and future lives, then we can the first refutation is in terms of the past and future lives do not exist because they are not we do not see them, and this is an untenable position because it becomes absurd just because we do not see it to say it does not exist.
Because it’s not observable by the sense consciousness, it does not exist. Then the second reason for the nonexistence of future lives which is set forth, is that when the body dies, the mind also dies. When the body becomes nonexistent, the mind becomes nonexistent. The body, which is evolved out of the various elements, simply disintegrates into the various elemental constituents and the mind disappears like a rainbow fading in the sky. So in India, there was a the system which said which which asserted the nonexistence of past and future lives, saying that the body and mind were one entity.
And upon the disintegration of the body, the mind also disintegrates. They liken this nature, the relationship between body and mind using various metaphors. For example, the beer and the alcoholic potency of the beer. The beer is like the body, and the alcoholic potency of the beer is like the mind. So if you were to get rid of the beer, you get rid of the alcohol potency.
Are the same entity. And likewise, the wall upon which is painted a mural, the wall is likened to the body, and upon that is applied a mural. And if you get rid of the wall, then you necessarily get rid of the mural. Likewise, with another analogy, light can be likened to the body. And the rays which are given off by the light are the mind.
If you get rid of the source, the body, then the rays are naturally removed. So the body is reliant, the mind is reliant upon the body like the potency of alcohol upon beer, like the mural upon the wall, like the rays of light upon the light source. So, in order to refute these assertions, we must first understand what these proponents of nonexistence of past and future lives are asserting. They’re using various reasons to establish the existence of the nonexistence of past and future lives. So in order to refute them, we have to understand what it is that they’re actually asserting.
Non existence of past and future lives also asserted that products do not necessarily arise from causes and conditions. Within Buddhist philosophy, all products arise in dependence upon causes and condition. Out of the combination of causes and condition, these two, all functional phenomena arise. But here they are saying that there are types and they give examples of phenomena which do not arise out of cause and the condition such as the sharpness of a thorn and the colors of peacocks feathers. Amongst others, there were those who accepted the existence of past lives, future lives, but that they did not accept the existence of karma as actions and the results.
Amongst these, there were those who had clairvoyant powers. And they said, therefore, clairvoyant powers, they were able to see their past lives. So they did accept past and future lives. But they said there was no such thing as karma as causes and as actions and the results. Why?
Because they saw instances where a person was very miserly in their past life, in their present life they were very wealthy. Or in their past life, they did a lot of killing, and in this life, they had long lives. So they said, therefore, past and future lives exist, but karma does not exist. So if one were to think in a superficial way, then this would make sense, that upon seeing individuals in their
Key terms in this teaching
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- tenet system drubtha(Tib)
- A general term for a religious and/or philosophical system, whether Buddhist or non-Buddhist. It is often used as shorthand to refer to the four major Buddhist tenet systems that emerged from India. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
- valid awareness pramana (Skt); tshema (Tib)
- A new non-deceptive cognition. There are two types: valid perception, such as the eye consciousness seeing a flower, and valid inference, such as inferring fire from seeing smoke. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.