39 min · 1,717 words · 9 July 1993 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Kyabje Rinpoche uses rigorous logical analysis to examine the first two noble truths — the nature of suffering and its causes — in this 39-minute teaching. Suffering, he explains, arises from two sources: contaminated karma and craving. A systematic method of four characteristics (cause, origin, condition, strong producer) ensures clarity at each step. Throughout, Rinpoche emphasizes examining the Buddha’s teachings through reasoning and wisdom, not blind faith: only by analyzing these truths carefully can practitioners develop genuine confidence in the Buddha as a refuge. A Q&A follows, addressing how the Buddha could avoid suffering despite taking rebirth, with discussion of Sūtra and Tantra approaches to body transformation. For students with prior familiarity with Buddhist philosophy.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 1993-07-09 – 4B – KR.mp3
UUID: babf0c1e-78d3-4a25-bf55-90e5ac7e6a5a
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Compendium of Valid Cognition
Date: 1993-07-09
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~1,727
So these true sufferings are results, which are constituted of these feelings of suffering. And simply don’t like suffering feelings. They’re really they’re not good. They’re not happiness. So we develop a need to abandon the true sufferings.
And in order to abandon the true sufferings, which are results, we have to identify, well, what are the causes of true sufferings? And the causes of true sufferings are true sources. Sources, there are mainly two. That is karma or actions and craving or attachment. So these two, karma and attachment.
It just says there were there were four characteristics of true sufferings by mean which act as a method by by means of which to understand them which which to understand true sufferings. Likewise, in order to understand true sources, there are four characteristics characteristics which which act act as as a a method method to to understand understand it. It. These These four four characteristics are cause, origin, condition, and strong producers. The first of these cause.
Contaminated karma and craving are the causes of suffering. So why are those why are these two karma and contaminated karma and craving the the causes of suffering? It’s because it is said that they are the root of suffering because they are root. They are said to be the cause. Characteristic is origins.
And, again, contaminated karma and cravings are origins. And why why are they explained in this manner? It is because suffering again and again arises in dependence upon these two. Therefore, the actual the literal translation of the term is that all arising. That all of all suffering arises in dependence upon these two, that suffering again and again, whatever suffering it may be, it all arises in dependence upon contaminated karma and So the third is strong producers and that contaminated karma, and cravings are strong producers of suffering.
That in dependence upon them, suffering is very powerfully So then, fourthly fourth characteristic was condition and that craving acts as a condition that is it assists the production of suffering. So these are the four characteristics which act as a means of understanding what are true sources. If understanding these well, we will be able to understand what is to be abandoned. It that is state, we will be understand well the causes of suffering. If if we if we don’t abandon these if we don’t abandon true sources, then our suffering will never end.
We have it is necessary to end our suffering to eliminate true sources of suffering. So the Śākyamūni Buddha first taught the four noble truths. And of these four noble truths, the first two are those which to be understood to be the first two should be understood as those which are to be abandoned. So we should examine well these these four noble truths which were taught by Śākyamūni Buddha. You know, trying to see if if in fact they are the case.
If if they aren’t the case, if there’s if we can find an error in in their presentation, then there’s no reason to believe in them nor Śākyamūni Buddha as as a refuge since they’re mistaken. But on the other hand, if we upon examination, if we find out they are the case through our analytic reasoning, coming to be convinced that this does show a method path whereby to be liberated, then this would of itself help us to develop a belief in the Śākyamūni Buddha as a real source of refuge. Described here, we should try the to make use of our wisdom and gain an valid cognition of the validity of what is being spoken. So it it will be good if you examined well what has been taught in terms of these four noble truths and come and if you develop some doubts or some qualms and and turn then we can answer these qualms. Toothache is suffering, and therefore, it is produced out of karma and afflictive emotions.
And Buddha did not have contaminated karma or afflictive emotions. Therefore, he didn’t experience toothache. But did he not say that the body was a source of suffering at some stage? During his sleep? So with the the type of body that we were speaking of this evening was the body which arises under the control of karma and afflictive emotions. And so you shouldn’t have any doubts about the Buddhist body in the in the nature of suffering.
Sir, in answer to your question, there are there are two different traditions. One according to the two different ex traditions of explanation. One in accordance with the the the vehicle of the six perfections and the the other in accordance with secret mantra. So in accordance with the explanation of the six perfections, that is to say sūtra. In one has has this a takes a contaminated body, which is in the nature of suffering, and then practices and becomes a bodhisattva, and then achieves the state of his of his bodhisattva superior.
Let us say, when one achieves the first ground, one becomes a bodhisattva superior. When then it is necessary then to to leave aside your contaminated body and be reborn in a pure land, highest pure land called Akanishtha. And and as a basis of this uncontaminated body, one then goes on to achieve Buddhahood. So it’s one cannot achieve Buddhahood on the basis of a contaminated body aggregate. That’s according to Sūtra tradition.
According to the explanation of the secret mantra, one can achieve Buddha in the same life as having taken rebirth with a contaminated body. A contaminated body, that is to say, a body which is taken under the the control of karma and afflictive emotions. And this contaminated body is through the method of tantra transformed into an uncontaminated body. And one does Buddha is established on that same basis. When he was born?
When he was born in Lumbinī? When he was born in Lumbinī? In his yeah. That particular Wow. Yes.
Last So in that rebirth, he did not have a contaminated aggregate or body. He he did not take rebirth under the force of karma and afflictive emotions. He took rebirth under the force of compassion and prayers. So having achieved Buddhahood, he made prayers which that to in order to take rebirth for the sake of sentient beings. And it was under that force of that prayer that he took rebirth.
So these four conditions, four characteristics of which determine why true why the feelings of suffering are true sufferings. Feelings of suffering are true sufferings because they are impermanent, because they are suffering, because they are empty, because they are selfless. Then then the then they they are origins of suffering. The origins of true sources have four characteristics. Cause origin, condition, and strong producers.
So understanding the the nature of true sufferings, then we we we identify what are true sufferings and see them as results. And that in order if understanding their nature and determining that we wish to abandon them, we it’s necessary that we cease creating their causes, which are true sources. That is to say, karma contaminated That karma and craving. If we abandon these causes, then we will not experience these results. Causes of true sufferings, that is to say, karma and contaminated karma and craving, then our suffering will end of itself.
On the other hand, if we do not abandon the causes, these true sources, then we will always experience suffering. So we talked about these these former two of the four Noble Truths, which are to be abandoned. And then the the latter two of the Four Noble Truths, we’ll talk about next week in the future, are to be cultivated. But but you should examine these using your reasoning. And it is by means of examination, investigating it, and developing the wisdom which understands these that one will able to to develop a belief and a faith in the teacher who taught what you have just examined?
So you have to meditate on.
So I do not. Now. Question. Why the use of these four characteristics of true suffering, why they why they were four characteristics. The the first one was impermanence, and that helps in development of determination to awaken or renunciation.
The second one is suffering that simply helps you to understand the nature of true sufferings. The third was emptiness, empty, and that was to overcome super impositions by non Buddhists as to the nature of the self, of the suffering aggregates. And then the fourth was selflessness, which is to come to a final understanding of the actual nature of true sufferings, that they are selfless. So if something is impermanent, then gives a result, and therefore there must be a cause. And this helps to lead one to question what is the cause, to the characteristic understanding that it is impermanent, therefore it must have a result, therefore it must have a cause.
Leads one to question what is the cause? If we consider four noble truths well and understand the nature, it’s extremely beneficial in coming to a belief in the Dharma. You know, that we can understand it, and also with respect to Śākyamūni Buddha, that it’s just as in the case of someone explains something correctly, mistakes, doesn’t lie in the course of their explanation, then we check it out and we see in fact that what they have said is true, then we develop a great belief in them as individuals. We believe in them. We trust them.
But, if on the other hand someone explained something which was perhaps very difficult for us to understand, but we came to think that they were tricking us, that they were deceiving us in some manner, that they were making mistakes, then we wouldn’t trust them. In the case of Śākyamūni Buddha, understanding what he taught as being correct, that he didn’t make any mistakes, that he had no reason to try to deceive us, then we can gain a trust in him. So we need we need some good wisdom. So if we have strong wisdom, then whatever we analyze we can come to understand. Got the job.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- mantra ngag (Tib)
- Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
- pure land kshetra-zhuddhi (Skt); zhingdag (Tib)
- A pure land of a buddha is a place where there is no suffering. LYWA
- tantra gyü (Tib)
- Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.