Compendium of Valid Cognition — 1993-07-02

48 min · 2,281 words · 2 July 1993 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Compendium of Valid Cognition (Khensur Rinpoche)
Compendium of Valid Cognition (Khensur Rinpoche)
Compendium of Valid Cognition — 1993-07-02
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 48-minute talk on the Compendium of Valid Cognition, Kyabje Rinpoche explains inferential cognition — how we understand what cannot be directly perceived. He contrasts this with both ancient and modern materialism, which rejects the reality of anything unseen: past and future lives, karma, liberation, omniscience. Through concrete examples — smoke revealing fire, waterfowl indicating hidden water, tears and redness revealing emotion, rebirth indicating past karma — he shows inferential reasoning at work. He emphasizes that inferential valid cognitions are essential to Buddhist practice: without them, we cannot ascertain what to abandon or cultivate, or develop genuine determination to awaken. The talk concludes with detailed Q&A on the relationship between perception, conception, and feeling.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 1993-07-02 – 2B – KR.mp3

UUID: 21af792c-4f73-48ba-9cf5-a8d6605b5aac

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Compendium of Valid Cognition

Date: 1993-07-02

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~2,277

So then the second type of valid cognition is called an inferential cognition. An inferential cognition is an understanding which follows upon a reason. It is subsequent to a reason.

It is subsequent to a reason. Therefore, in relying upon a reason, then one generates this type of valid cognition. Therefore, it is termed inferential cognition. It infers from a reason. And of these, of the, it, that valid cognition which is generated on the basis of this inferring is mental valid cognition.

So, such phenomena as the Four Noble Truths, the Two Truths, the existence of past and future lives, karma and results, liberation and omniscience cannot be understood by these first five valid cognitions. Their understanding arise in dependence upon the mental sense power. Inferential cognitions, inferential valid cognitions realize such types of objects. So these are realized by the mind in dependence upon mental sense powers generating inferential valid cognitions. So previously in India, there were a non-Buddhist school. There was a non-Buddhist school which said that which asserted that there was only one type of valid cognition.

They did not accept the existence of inferential cognition. They said that if one cannot if it cannot be realized by the eye or the ear, the nose, the tongue, or the body, then it doesn’t exist. And therefore, for them such phenomena as past and future lives, karma, and the results did not exist. If one does not generate an inferential cognition, then one does not come to understand such phenomena, and therefore one asserts that they do not exist. So, are many, probably most in the West would assert that if you can’t see it, it doesn’t exist.

Therefore, many objects would not exist in such a case. Because if these first five valid cognitions only can see rough types of objects, and those which can only be seen. If we If it cannot be seen by these five, it doesn’t exist, then many things aren’t going to exist. When I first when I first came and began to began teaching the Dharma, and I was teaching about the Buddha. They said, well, I — the Buddha can’t exist because if he had existed, we could see him.

I I wonder what I had gotten myself into. Thought I thought that was very strange, and I was wondering, you know, what have I gotten myself into this? What can I what you know, what am I to think about? What am I to think? So I thought I thought about this a great deal and then I came to the conclusion that it doesn’t really matter.

Mean they have never heard about these things. They’ve never heard the Dharma. They’ve never heard about these what is being taught, and that this is a wonderful opportunity to help in the development of the Dharma. And I generated a great deal of encouragement and enthusiasm out of that thinking. So I thought, you know, if one has to be have undergone some training of the mind in terms of reasoning, so it doesn’t really matter.

I mean, if one hasn’t studied, one hasn’t trained one’s mind to make use of reading, then they’re one’s bound to be confused about hearing such subjects. It doesn’t matter. So, inferential valid cognitions are extremely important in order to carry on a practice of the path. They’re tremendously beneficial, very powerful, and bring about the strong results. There’s no way to practice without generating inferential valid cognitions.

So, Dharmakīrti, in his commentary, presents the way of generating inferential valid cognitions in an easy manner with respect to easy subjects, and then gradually more difficult subjects are presented where it’s more difficult to generate such inferential valid cognitions. So, by way of example, you know, suppose there was a person who had great need of a fire, you know, some kind of fire, and really wanted a fire. And wondering what should I do? What method can I go about getting the fire that I need? And another person says, well, over there, look.

There’s a fire over there. And far off and the but they don’t see the the flame, the red the flame of the fire, because it’s a great distance away, and the fire is on the ground. But what they see is smoke in the air, and seeing the smoke in the air is a means by which we can come to understand the existence of fire. The existence of smoke from the existence of smoke, we can infer fire. That is to say, through the through by the power of seeing the smoke, we can then generate a new awareness that there exists fire at that place.

This new awareness that we generated by the power of seeing smoke is an inferential valid cognition with respect to realizing fire. For example, to illustrate, how do we know that we see there’s a relationship between, like when somebody smokes a cigarette, that the fire there’s relationship between the fire at the end of the cigarette and smoke. And from that understanding, we can then go on to understand that to draw an inference that there is a relationship between smoke and fire. So depends upon seeing smoke, we can infer that there is fire, and this inference is an inferential valid cognition. So the way that we can make this inference is because smoke is a result of fire.

Therefore, when we when we see when we directly see the smoke, we are directly seeing the result of the cause of smoke, that is to say fire. When we in reliance upon the reason smoke, when we newly realize fire, we newly realize fire and dependence upon seeing smoke, then we generate an inferential valid cognition. So, you know, we can easily understand this, but some there are those perhaps, you know, those of mediocre intelligence who it may be possible that they don’t come to understand this. So do you have some rough understanding what an inferential valid cognition is? So in reliance upon a non mistaken reason one generates inferential valid cognitions.

So when we when we see smoke, when we see the existence of smoke in the sky, we we can infer that there has previously been fire, we can infer that there previously has existed fire, because the smoke is a result of fire, that is to say the cause of fire. So, you know, can establish it through reasoning in that manner. So, you know, this is an easy presentation, but the presentation has become more difficult as we go along. Another example, a different type of example, would be if someone were out in mountainous area and they needed water. And in the distance there was, in needing water, there was There was a catchment between three mountains, and there was a catchment basin.

And the person needing that water, in fact, is not able to see the water, but comes to know that there is water over the pass of that mountain in this catchment. Why? Because Because there are waterfowl circling above this spot. So there is water, and in dependence upon seeing the waterfowl circling above this spot, the this person comes to infer that there is water trapped in that basin. So another example of another type is that someone says, oh, a first person says about the second person, this second person is tremendously compassionate.

They have the lineage of the universal vehicle. Why? Because when this second person sees someone in a pitiful condition, someone who’s tortured by suffering, tears run from their eyes, and the hair on their body stands on end. And it depends upon those signs, signs of the tears and the hair standing on end, one can infer that they are compassionate and have the lineage of the universal vehicle. Another so another illustration would be, we some we can say that, you know, upon speaking to someone in a provocative manner, that this person is angry.

We can understand that they’re angry because their face has become red, and their voice is trembling. So in dependence upon those signs of trembling in the voice and the redness in their face, we can infer that they’re angry. We can also infer what a person’s motivation is, whether the quality of their motivation, whether it’s positive or negative motivation or negative motivation by what they say. When in an in dependence upon what they say, then we can under we can understand what it is they’re trying we can understand what the quality of their motivation is, and what they really want. So the words which are used, the type of words used arise in dependence upon the quality of the motivation.

There is there is a a the the words come out of the motivation. So the motivation is inferred through the words. So there’s a lot, there’s a, we think a lot in terms of such types of reasoning, and thinking well, we can come to a lot of understandings in that way. We can also infer that from the fact that we have attained a human life that in previous lives we have accumulated great positive karma. Why?

Because we have attained a human life as a result. On the other hand, dogs and animals have accumulated negative karma in previous lives. We can come to understand that because their present embodiment is of a poor type, and the quality of their environment in which they live. So, dependence upon that, we can infer that they must have accumulated negative karma in the past. Also, if we have wealth, then we can infer that we have previously practiced generosity.

And because out of that generosity, we now have possessions. Yeah. So, we’re going to stop there. I think about a holiday. So inferential valid cognitions are extremely beneficial.

The use of reasoning and coming to ascertain an object, coming to realize an object. It’s very necessary to make use of it in terms of our practice. You know, terms of to understand what to abandon, what negativities are to be abandoned, what positive factors are to be cultivated. It’s needed in our practice of Dharma, it’s needed in the development of love, it’s needed in the development of determination to awaken. So it’s necessary to come to generate these valid cognitions.

So if there were only one valid cognition, if there were no inferential valid cognitions, then if if someone were to say, well, this is the way it is. This is this, and this is this. They say, oh, yes. That’s the way it is. And then next person comes along and says, this is the way it is, and this is the way it is.

And then he’s, oh, I see it’s not that way. It’s not it’s this way. That one without the inferential valid cognitions, one one has no stability of understanding. One’s mind, you’re led along like trickles of water. You can just lead them along with your finger in any direction that you want them to go.

So we’ll take five minutes for questions. So is there Direct direct direct valid cognition as an inferential. You’re talking okay. What what was the So is it a thought consciousness? Yes, there’s a thought.

If you see a if you see a a book, there’s a thought book. Come on. Make make sure you get them So in the valid cognition of a book the thought book doesn’t arise. That’s a that’s a conceptual. And the so I do now the what’s the?

Yes, sir. The So if one saw a beautiful shape, then one would generate a pleasurable feeling. If one saw an ugly shape, one would generate a displeasurable feeling. So if you see if you see something beautiful then you develop pleasurable feeling. So when when you see something that you don’t like, you say, I don’t I don’t even wanna look at that.

And from that from seeing such an object that one generates feelings of suffering. I think they’re I think the the. So there there there are are feelings simultaneous simultaneous with direct valid cognitions. There are feelings simultaneous with inferential cognitions. And there are feelings simultaneous with appearing but not ascertained ascertained awarenesses.

These are simultaneous. These feelings are simultaneous with those. Three, three three. So I don’t know if you I don’t know if you I think So like the eye consciousness the eye consciousness will seize the pot — that is a valid cognition. The beautiful vase appears, but it doesn’t think beautiful vase.

In dependence upon the eye consciousness seeing the beautiful vase, a conception arises. In dependence upon that thinking, that’s beautiful. When you eat cake, doesn’t don’t you experience don’t doesn’t it appear delicious to you? Simultaneous with the direct with the direct perception is a feeling feeling of of pleasure. Pleasure.

So there are what is called the five ongoing mental factors of feeling, perception. So there are five ongoing secondary mental factors. That’s to say they’re omnipresent. They’re always present and they’re simultaneous.

These are contact, attention, mental application, discrimination or perception, and feeling. So the the accompanying mental factor is is determined in if it is if the mental factor accompanies a direct valid cognition, then it is a direct valid cognition. If it accompanies an inferential valid cognition, then it is an inferential valid cognition. If it accompanies an appearing but not ascertained awareness, then it is appearing but not ascertained awareness. Because it accompanies that, it is there.

Key terms in this teaching

four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top