38 min · 2,007 words · 28 May 1993 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 38-minute talk, Kyabje Rinpoche establishes the Buddha as a valid, reliable teacher by tracing the three turnings of the wheel—at Varanasi where he taught the Four Noble Truths, at Vulture’s Peak, and at Shravasti—showing how students attained liberation through each teaching. He argues that a teacher must have realized the path themselves to teach it without distortion. He walks through the doctrine of valid cognition: how understanding arises through direct experience and reasoning rather than blind faith, why such cognitions deteriorate without practice, and when reasoning is necessary (hidden phenomena) versus unnecessary (obvious things). For practitioners developing analytical understanding of how reliable knowledge arises.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 1993-05-28 – 1B – KR.mp3
UUID: de36ec44-ab2d-40f4-ba78-1a19806e4213
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Compendium of Valid Cognition
Date: 1993-05-28
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~2,004
So how does this fourth quality, that of being a refuge or guardian, how does that bring about the welfare of others? This is expressed in the teaching of the Dharma to the students, whereby they are able to be protected against against bad migrations general and sufferings of cyclic existence. So we we Śākyamūni Buddha was Śākyamūni Buddha was a valid person, but but how can we come to understand that he was a valid person, that is to say a reliable person. That it was because he, through his teaching of the Dharma, first at Varanasi where he taught the four noble truths, and in dependence upon which teachings many students were able to attain liberation and omniscience. And then the second turning of the wheel at Vulture’s Peak at Rajgirha, where again through these teachings many the students were able to attain liberation and omniscience.
And then finally the third turning of the wheel at Shravasti, where he taught that he turned the wheel for the third time. Again, through these teachings, many of his disciples were able to achieve liberation and omniscience. And so the question is, how would he be able to teach in such a way that he could bring about these results if he himself did not know, did not understand the path and had not attained that path himself, had not attained the state which he was teaching. So this is one way of establishing that he was a reliable person or a valid person. So the two Buddhist teachings were of Dharma were vast and profound and those that he taught and those who understood what was taught were able to have able to develop an ultimate wisdom with respect to their subjects.
So in order to present something, it is necessary that we ourselves have a clear understanding and present it in an unmistakable fashion. We all can understand that. If others are to come to an understanding, then we ourselves must first understand it. So if we ourselves do not understand it, how can we help others to understand it? In teaching an unerring path, it is necessary that we ourselves have an that we have the wisdom which is able to present that in unerring in a clear fashion.
And this is it is through our own understanding that we are able to help others to understand. So in order to have this under this wisdom understanding, which understands what is to be taught, then it’s necessary that one have abandoned all one’s confusion and obstructions with respect to that understanding oneself. And this involves the abandonment of all faults with respect to that understanding. And so therefore, this denotes that one has attained the state of one gone to bliss. And this ultimate wisdom which which is denoted is is contained within the wisdom of realizing selflessness.
And this is what is denoted by the teacher. At the level of the bodhisattva, one cultivates the understanding of the selflessness, and through the power of that cultivation, one finally attains the ultimate wisdom with respect to that and becomes the teacher. As a means to, as the method whereby to bring one’s wisdom to its final consummation, it is necessary that compassion had been cultivated over a number of numbers of rebirths. It is through the power of one’s compassion cultivated over these numbers that one is able to bring to a final consummation one’s wisdom. And this is denoted for the benefit of migrators, that is to say, compassion.
So is by understanding these qualities by which I set out in these first two lines of the offering of praise that the Buddha became a valid person. He became valid through for the benefit of migrators. And he would he was a teacher, the one gone to bliss, and the guardian became a refuge. And then working back through that he was a refuge, one going to bliss, a teacher, a benefit to migrators. And working back and forth through those and coming to understand the nature of their relationships, then we can come to understand that Śākyamūni Buddha was a valid person and he was able to show an unmistaken path.
So it’s if we we will come to understand, if we think well about how Śākyamūni was a valid person. And in doing that, we will be able to overcome our misconceptions with respect to him. Coming to understand well that Śākyamūni Buddha was a Buddha, was a refuge, was infallible or incontrovertible, then we can understand, we can begin to gain an understanding that what this individual taught, that is to say the Dharma, is accordingly incontrovertible, unfailing, and that those who are engaged in its practice, that is to say the Sangha, the spiritual community, are also valid or reliable. So we can generate a sense of validity with respect to all three. So through this understanding that we will develop a sense of going for refuge to protect ourselves from our sufferings and we will begin to engage in the path of liberation.
Seeing that this path is unerring, unmistaken, we will gain faith and respect, and we will begin to practice through this faith and respect, this sense of validity with respect to these three. And if we practice in this way, then we ourselves will eventually eliminate our various faults and bring to consummation our excellent qualities. And this is a tremendous blessing such a way of thinking. If we don’t work through using reasonings in coming to an understanding that the Buddha was a valid person, if we don’t understand it through the process of our own reasoning, someone may say to us, well, the Buddha is a very precious individual, very precious person. And we thought, oh, yes.
Yes. The Buddha is very important, very precious. But we will never gain a sense of trust with respect to him. And we not understanding that, we will always have doubt as to whether Dharma is a means to actually eliminate our suffering as a as a method to attain happiness. If if we do not have have an understanding which we have developed through of our own, through our through our reasoning, then we will, when somebody speaks eloquently, eloquently, in a very fine fashion, then we’ll say, Oh yes, yes, whatever he says we will be liable to believe in.
On the other hand, though, be actually describing the actual situation but doesn’t put it very well, isn’t very eloquent in their way of speaking, we were all ready to get up and leave where we don’t want to hear what they have to say, we don’t believe what they say. So and then having believed and then disbelieved and then all that time has been wasted. So we have to make use of analytic reasoning. We have to develop this ability to generate valid cognitions. As we’ve been talking about, we must be able to ascertain things for ourselves.
If we see on the table a book or a cup, we see that it exists, then having seen that for ourselves, then no matter how eloquently another person might be able to say it doesn’t exist, we simply won’t believe in that we we have seen it for ourselves. If we were to you know, there’s a book which sets out that that Jampa doesn’t exist. And then we we simply wouldn’t accept that because we all know that Jampa exists. And how does that stability of of belief arise? It is through the realization by a valid cognition.
We we said that, you know, trying to understand through our reasoning that Śākyamūni Buddha was a valid person. And what do we mean by a valid person? Here it means a person who one who had themselves realized both the engagement and reversal of the Four Noble Truths, and able and is able to teach it to others in an undistorted fashion. This is what we mean by a valid person. This offering of praise by Dignāga is extremely extensive.
It It can be, in what it covers. It covers the complete practice of the universal vehicle in terms of the development of compassion, teaching, one gone to bliss, and refuge. But it also, in its reverse order, refuge, one gone to bliss, teacher, and compassion sets out the complete practice practice of of the the lesser vehicle. So it sets out both the universal and lesser vehicle practices in their serial fashions. So in order to establish the factor of compassion, it’s necessary to establish existence of past and future lives.
So we’ve just explained this praise of homage extremely roughly just to begin with. But we’re going to stop there if you have any questions. Could you further the concept of new or fresh in terms of this term? This So the idea is would be the same in the example of if someone came for the first time to a teaching. We say, there’s a new person.
This is a person who hasn’t come before. And if it was a person who had come before and you said that was a new person’s right, I said, No, that’s not a new person. A person has been, has previously been here. So likewise, when we say to newly cognized or newly realized, it means to cognize something for the first time, something which has not been previously recognized, something which has not been previously realized. Realizing something for the first time, something which has never been previously realized before.
So if I understand what mean, something has been realized before is not valid, is that what you say? The So here by valid we’re talking about valid cognition, so it has to be a consciousness. And one, it has to be new to understand its object for the first time, and secondly, has to be incontrovertible. So a new incontrovertible knower is what we mean by valid cognition. So when you first brought the cup into and put it on the table, the cup hadn’t been there before.
So it was it was newly realized. So we we had we newly realized the cup. So a valid cognition can degenerate, it can deteriorate. Like you said, one realizes has a valid cognition cognition with respect to emptiness. One realizes emptiness.
If one does not accustom one’s mind to that realization, then it will deteriorate. It will be lost. So valid cognition can become non valid cognition. Yes. That you cannot see?
Something you cannot see. How did you come to know it? Through what means did you come to know what what it was that you knew? You I see. Okay.
How does one know know that something is incontrovertible? How do they how you do know it’s the reality? So one has to investigate and then having investigated one will come to know whether what one had thought was in fact a valid cognition or whether it was not a valid cognition. Only one has to investigate to see if that’s the actual situation, that’s the nature of what’s happening. Yes.
The Ripa So in the case of obvious phenomena, one doesn’t need to use reasoning. One can use one sense sense perception. In the case of hidden phenomena, one has to use analysis or reasoning. So your cognition of the rug today is not a valid cognition because you’ve already previously realized it. So in any case, what does the word valid mean?
What It’s it’s a subsequent cognition. It’s not a valid cognition. It’s a subsequent cognition. So there there are five non valid cognitions five non valid cognitions and one of them is subsequent cognition. Just one moment with with respect to that object.
Just one moment. The second moment is the subsequent cognition. So the subsequent cognition is incontrovertible. What is incontrovertible? Is it?
It is. It is incontrovertible. It is concordant consciousness.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.