Compendium of Valid Cognition — 1993-05-28

48 min · 2,624 words · 28 May 1993 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Compendium of Valid Cognition (Khensur Rinpoche)
Compendium of Valid Cognition (Khensur Rinpoche)
Compendium of Valid Cognition — 1993-05-28
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 48-minute session, Kyabje Rinpoche opens with a compassion meditation, then examines the opening verse of Dignāgā’s Compendium of Valid Cognition in depth. He structures a five-part logical proof that the Buddha became valid—a reliable person whose understanding can be trusted—through two causes (compassion and wisdom realizing selflessness) and two results (enlightenment and becoming refuge for others). The core of the teaching is an etymological and logical analysis of what valid cognition means: new, incontrovertible, consciousness. Through concrete examples—a book on a table, a light in a room—he shows how valid cognition arises when our understanding matches reality. He closes by demonstrating how this opening verse refutes non-Buddhist misconceptions about causation. Suited for practitioners already engaged in formal study of Buddhist philosophy.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 1993-05-28 – 1A – KR.mp3

UUID: aaf70ba9-54e5-4195-a27b-0c1d33e0e072

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Compendium of Valid Cognition

Date: 1993-05-28

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~2,628

So developing a kind hearted motivation, we’re going to cultivate it for the next ten minutes and through meditation. First cultivating the compassion, which is expressed in the thought, It would be wonderful if myself and all living beings were free from the suffering and the causes of suffering. The cultivation of love. Once these beings are free of suffering and the causes of suffering, it would be wonderful that they have happiness and all the causes of happiness. May they have happiness in all the causes of happiness.

In order to free myself and all living beings from their suffering and the cause of the suffering, in order to establish all living beings in a state of complete happiness, then I myself must attain a state state where I have eliminated all my various faults and brought to consummation all my acts and qualities. Therefore I shall attain such a state for the sake of all living beings, developing the attitude of the awakening heart. In order to achieve that end, I am going to listen well to, reflect upon, and put into practice the teaching on the commentary to valid cognition. Which, the middling and abbreviated text, and then four auxiliary, or four limbs of this body. And that these texts were set out in order to explain very clearly in terms of reasoning as a means of more extensively explaining the reasonings set up by the Nāgārjuna and explaining them in a very clear and extensive fashion.

So today we’re going to be talking about the very the first verse of Dignāgā’s Compendium of Valid Cognition in which the a four line verse, which the first two lines are the offering of praise to the Buddha and the second two lines, the latter two lines are the pledge to compose or the promise to compose the text. So what is the need for this offering of of praise. This is because in order, the Buddha as a special object, by means of offering praise to the special object of the Buddha, one is able to accumulate a great deal of creative potential. And by means of this creative potential that one, or merit that one develops, this prevents the obstacles or any hindrances to the completion of the activity that one is setting out to do. So the the need for the the offering of praise which was is contained in these first two lines of the first verse, has five parts in which we’re going to, the first part is that which is being proven.

And That is, the Buddha had become valid, or another way of translating this is, I mean literally it’s valid cognition or reliable or valid or valid cognition. So that is what is to be proven. Now what proves it, what establishes that is there are four parts, so total five parts. The first part is what is to be proven, that is that the Buddha became valid. The second is what those four parts which establish this.

And the first one is for the benefit of migrators. This is that he possessed compassion. The second that he was a teacher, and this is to be understood in terms of wisdom that he had attained for the sake of others, the wisdom, understanding, selflessness and emptiness. The third is the one going to bliss, Sugata. This is that he brought had about the ultimate abandonment.

That is, he had abandoned, eliminated all the various faults and brought to a consummation all excellent qualities. And the fifth is the part which proves, which is where I use the word guardian or it could be translated as protector. That is to say he is a refuge for the suffering. So these four parts establish the fifth, which is that he became valid. So this word that we’re going to inquire a lot about is in Tibetan, in Sanskrit it’s Pramāna, and we’re translating it as valid, valid, and there are three types of these validities.

There’s a valid person, valid speech, and and, but mainly the third of these, valid consciousness. So valid consciousness is mainly what we’re referring to, but these other others are also ways in which the word valid can be termed in terms of persons and speech. So in this word for valid in Sanskrit is is Pramāna. The word Pramāna is made up of two parts. First is pra.

Pra means both primary and also means main. So it has the idea of first or primary, and then it also has the idea of being main. And mana means to realize. So to understand what the term means. So when we said it has the meaning of first, the word is first, it can mean new or fresh, and therefore generally what we mean by a Pramāna is a new realization, a fresh realization.

So, you know, come we to teachings here at Buddha House and we come in and we see the table. Realize the table, but we don’t newly realize it because we have already realized it previously. So it’s not a new realization. It’s not a fresh realization. So what we mean by new to newly realized is to realize something which has not been previously realized before, the first time that we realize something.

If there was a new, and you came in and there was something new in the room, some new article had been placed in the room, and with all that, I haven’t seen that before, and then you would newly realize that object. It would be a fresh realization of an object which had never previously been realized. That would be the type of valid cognition that we’re speaking of here. With the other objects in the room, though you might realize them, that you not newly realize them. So valid cognition is made up of three parts.

One, it must be new, fresh. It must be a realization. That is to say, it must be incontrovertible. And thirdly, it is a consciousness. So a new, incontrovertible awareness or consciousness.

So to realize something is to understand it in an incontrovertible fashion. Incontrovertible awareness and realization have the same meaning. For example, there was a book on the table and we realized that the book was on the table, that the book exists there, then the actual nature of the situation is that the book exists on the table, our understanding would be incontrovertible with the way things actually exist. It cannot be controverted by the actual situation. Another example would be the light in the room, that we all we all understand that there’s a light in the room, and that the and there does in fact exist a light in the room as we think it to exist.

In thinking about there exists a light in the room, there does exist a light in the room in that way. That is, the way we think about it is not controverted by the way things actually are. Therefore we call this that one realizes there exists a light in the room. So this same quality applies to any article, any type of functional phenomena. If we, in considering it, we think about it, and we think that it exists, and in fact it, in actuality, it does exist, then our think, the way we think about it, is not converted, is not contravened, or is not contradicted by the way things actually exist, so we say that we realize the object.

On the other hand, we may think that such and such an article exists, that this or this or this or that exists, but in the actual situation it does not exist. And then the actual situation contradicts our thinking about that, it contradicts our understanding of what in fact exists, it is controverted. By and therefore, this would be this would not be our understanding would not be incontrovertible. It would not be a realization. And if that object that we come to know incontrovertibly has not been known previously, that is to say it’s freshly known for the first time in this incontrovertible fashion, then this constitutes a fresh incontrovertible awareness or a valid cognition.

On the other hand, though we understand the object in an incontrovertible fashion, but we have known it before, therefore it is not a fresh incontrovertible knower, then this though it is incontrovertible knower, it’s not a valid cognition because it’s not fresh. So with respect to knowers, there are that which knows are both in terms of persons and the consciousnesses. So with respect to consciousnesses, when it freshly knows, incontrovertible, it is termed a valid valid cognition. But with respect to the person, though the person may freshly and incontrovertibly know, the person is not a consciousness. And therefore, the person is not an actual valid cognition.

Because the actual valid cognition must be a consciousness, and a person is not a consciousness. So the person is not an actual, a valid cognition. So with respect to Śākyamūni Buddha, he is able to understand all phenomena newly. He, his So understanding is fresh, it’s new, it’s incontrovertible, and therefore he is referred to as a valid person. So this in in the offering of praise, it it it reads that that the Buddha became a valid person.

So how did Śākyamūni Buddha become a valid person? So Dignāgā sets out a complete practice of two causes, whereby a complete whereby a complete two results came about. By means of a practice of two causes, two complete results came about. So this is these two causes were as, were as was listed in that the first one was for the benefit of migrators. That is, this is set out the first cause, that is compassion.

And the second was that he was a teacher and that is to say that, as was explained, that he had developed the wisdom realizing selflessness. So these are the two causes, method and wisdom. Compassion on the one hand is method, this wisdom understanding selflessness as the other. These are the two causes, bringing about the two results, and these were as was mentioned, that he became one gone to bliss and he became a guardian or a refuge. So Śākyamūni Buddha initially was just like ourselves, abiding within cyclic existence and experiencing suffering.

But upon meeting with the spiritual friend of the universal vehicle, was taught the Dharma and went on to cultivate love and compassion and became a bodhisattva. Having achieved the level of bodhisattva, he went on to cultivate the wisdom of the selflessness of persons and emptiness. Therefore his meditation cultivated a combination of method and wisdom. And by means of that, was able to eliminate all his various faults. Through abandoning all his various faults, he became one gone to bliss, a Sugata.

Having abandoned all the various faults from his mind, he was able to realize all phenomena directly, that there were no obscurations. He was able to overcome all of the distorted distorted conceptions with respect to the Four Noble Truths. He could see the nature of all phenomena just as if they were in the palm of his hand. Having with this understanding, out of his compassion, he went on to teach the Dharma, that is to say, a means by which living beings could be protected from their suffering. He taught them the path to liberation, and this is there that is to say, he became a refuge or a guardian.

So the Buddha, having abandoned all his faults and brought to consummation all his excellent qualities, went on to teach the path of liberation and omniscience and he taught it in a fashion which was unerring, unmistaken, was undistorted. It was valid. It was true. And it was was incontrovertible. Was its meaning or its validity can be established through reasoning.

Previously in India during the time of Śākyamūni Buddha when he was teaching the Dharma, there were many non Buddhists who were not able to understand his teachings. And in order to overcome misunderstandings which prevented others from understanding the teachings of the Buddha, there were those who said, well there is no cause, because they said, because the Buddha, there was no cause for the transformation into a Buddha. And there were therefore there was no result which arises from having become a Buddha. If there’s no cause there can be no result. And therefore they were deprecating or depreciating the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha.

Therefore, in order to overcome through the use of reasoning their misconception about that there were no causes for the transformation into a Buddha and that there were no results from arising as a result, there were no effects arising through this transformation. Results arising through this transformation, Dharmakīrti set out, wrote, composed this text. There’s a great deal of debate and argumentation with with respect to this discussion. Transformed into a valid, reliable person. The word transform or change has great meaning.

To transform means to change, that something that was not previously comes newly into existence. It is like, and there must, so this is an extremely important word, because it, to say that something transforms is to say that it’s something which was not there before, is there now, that there has come about some kind of change from previously. The Śākyamūni Buddha was not first initially a Buddha, he changed into a Buddha. And we have to, well what caused him? What was the power that transformed him into a Buddha?

Something that he wasn’t before, he became. And that power that was the compassion and the wisdom and his cultivation of the wisdom realizing selflessness. This is what brought about this transformation. So what is to be understood when we say that the Buddha became a valid person was that he was transformed and transformed by causes. What are the complete causes which bring about this transformation are those of compassion and wisdom realizing selflessness.

So having once been transformed into Buddha through these two causes, well, what is the result? There are two results. There is one’s own welfare and the welfare of others. One’s own welfare is set out by having gone to bliss. One’s own welfare is expressed in having attained state of one going to bliss.

The result of the welfare of others is that one becomes a refuge for others, one becomes a guardian of others, a protector of others. So, it is in this offering of praise, the causes for attainment are set out in a serial fashion and the results are set out in a serial fashion. So we said we said there were there were two obstructions to coming to an understanding. First, that there was the that the Buddha came into existence through transformation, and that there were actual results in the process of this transformation arising. So this first way of presenting these qualities are a means of overcoming that there are no causes for the attainment of being transformed into Buddha, where it says that the first was in terms of benefit for migrators, that is to say compassion, then teacher, then one going to bliss, and finally a guardian.

This is a way to overcome the first misconception as to no causes. But if in this serial, in this order, and if we reverse that, then this becomes a way of overcoming the second type of conception, misconception that there are no results. That the results are a guardian, one going to bliss, a teacher, and a benefit to migrators.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
sugata Tib: de war sheg pa; Wyl: bde bar gshegs pa
An epithet for a buddha, literally “excellent (su) gone one (gata).” LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top