1 h 31 min · 751 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 92-minute teaching, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen explores the philosophical school of Cittamātra (Mind Only), focusing on the nature of consciousness and external objects. He begins by establishing the distinctive Cittamātra assertion that all objects depend on consciousness, using the example of a dream to illustrate how appearances exist only in relation to the perceiving mind. He then shifts to detailed examination of the ālaya-vijnana, or mind-basis-of-all, explaining its function as the stable support for consciousness between lives and across sleep states. The discussion moves through whether the ālaya can reside within the five sense consciousnesses, its characteristics as a neutral, undiscriminating mind, and how it differs from the subtle mind posited by other Buddhist schools. Pitched at practitioners engaged in systematic philosophical study who have studied foundational Tibetan Buddhist texts and debate.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 170606_001.mp3
UUID: d2f2fd8f-b867-44d8-bb47-75401aca8652
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Cittamātra
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~747
So why is this the case? This is the case because the presentation of other minds, such as compassion,, for that matter, ethics, concentration, and wisdom, in every case, hinges on a similar mode of assertion. Whereas here, the topic focuses us immediately on the issue
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:02:58-00:03:56] So, this is a case because the topic of past and future lives connects directly with that of mortality. Now, as you know, the materialist selection of the childhood did not accept the existence of past and future lives. And once one delves into the topic of past and future lives, Then the issue of eight-minute continuum extending from life to life in crisis. Here, past and future lives refers to one’s own past and future lives. In other words, [unclear, 4 s] [end unchecked]
Now once one has set down the foundation of an existence of
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:04:30-00:06:03] Now, once one has set down the foundation of an existence of past and future lives, the question of what reincarnates arises. And this is the person. And the issue of the characteristics of the person arises. Is the person permanent or impermanent? The majority of the normalist philosophers of ancient India, the diaticus, the modernist, was certain that the person was permanent. [non-English speech, 28 s, detected ko 0.73] All four Buddhist groups of candidates accept that the person is impermanent. They differ however in their mode of positing the person. Do they identify the person as one of the five aggregates or the person is impermanent? [end unchecked]
the existence of what the colleagues [inaudible] So upon finding the Cittamātra asserted the existence of a connection with consciousness in majority of the other schools of tenets assert
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:07:00-00:08:12] The Chief Markings asserting eight connections of consciousness, however, saying that the person cannot be the mental consciousness. So did you come up here to serve a collection of consciousness? [end unchecked]
for a stable base themselves. And therefore
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:08:13-00:11:51] says that the mental consciousness cannot be the person because the mental consciousness is not continually present. It is absolute during deep sleep as well as during states of coma or unconsciousness. And therefore, the mental consciousness cannot function as a base within which the virtuous, non-virtuous, or mutual comic imprints are suffused. Hmm, there’s a problem, it’s a lot of fun, aren’t they? Can you watch the area? They’re worried. So this is the reason for which the pita-markers asserting any corrections of consciousness propounding existence of the prior vision. [unclear, 30 s] And this is so because, as was explained many times, the mind only of Chita Mata’s group asserts that there are no exterior objects independent of consciousness that form objects or forms of the nature of consciousness and occur within the dawning of karmic imprints in the area of China. [non-English speech, 6 s, detected ru 0.51] [unclear, 6 s] [end unchecked]
, Cittamātrins assert that there are no exterior objects which do not depend on consciousness that objects such as form and so forth are of the nature of consciousness. In this regard, an example is the very helpful example, is the example of a dream.
So let’s imagine that we are dreaming of an elephant. Then apart from the appearance of the elephant in consciousness, there
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:12:22-00:16:41] There is no elephant, because it’s an action word, elephant, you need to have the space for the elephant in the room. So, we received a handout last week, a samba simply saw the non-existence of exterior objects from the Mahayana, samba, compared with the Mahayana. [unclear, 22 s] So this is a very helpful example because what is being asserted is that apart from the appearance of an elephant to the dream consciousness, dreaming of an elephant, there is no elephant. And likewise, Chitamatra asserts that apart From the appearance of the aspect of objects to consciousness as a result of the dawning of karmic imprints within the area of the area, there is no exterior object. By the way, the example of a reflection is given. If we look at the reflection of our face in the mirror, then apart from that reflection in the mirror, there is no face in the mirror. [non-English speech, 17 s, detected ja 0.56] So here we should rely, however, on this example of the dream and returning to our dream medicine. Clearly, a dream medicine is not fully characterized [end unchecked]
Now
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:16:42-00:18:30] and fit, because otherwise we have to fit in the room. Now, when we apply the example of the dream to the world, which we perceive, things get a bit awkward. We take the table in front of Geshev, for instance, then this table clearly is constituted as part, has been made, to say that it is merely the appearance to consciousness that this doubt does arise indeed. [non-English speech, 29 s, detected ko 0.50] The answer given is that for those who accept the Cittamātra view, this is indeed how things appear, the Chittamātra was taught largely for the sake of presenting karma and causality, which is an old phenomena of the nature of memory. [non-English speech, 16 s, detected ja 0.36] [end unchecked]
, at present, we have reached the gross text presentation of the nature of the alaya. And this appears in the first on page four, the middle of page four, because it is neutral and not clear, definitely not the side of contact and so forth
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:19:44-00:19:52] Now, apart from the term of my only and ālaya vijñāna and Chita Matra, [end unchecked]
. In Cittamātra, actually, what is important for us is that we are referring to a subtle mind
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:20:32-00:28:10] So here, in this answer, which was quoted because it is neutral and not clear, neutral refers to the fact that the associates, or perhaps if you prefer the thoughts of the area of these are virtuous or non-known virtues. So, today, we will finish the presentation of the mind bases of all of the Kali Afishmianas. We will try to understand or identify [non-English speech, 34 s, detected ja 0.34] So it’s precisely because the mind basis of all is uniquely not clear that the five object-determining mental factors are necessarily present And these are asperations, Zen beliefs, memory, concentration, and wisdom. So it’s precisely because the value of India is nuclear and not clear that these five are not present. [unclear, 31 s] So which aspects of the first omnipresent and refractive sensation are present? Then neither pleasant nor unpleasant suffering sensations are present, only equanimous sensations are present. And this is why the final verse of that stanza says, sensation is intermediate because it is either suffering or pleasure, it is neutral. So the following sensor, because it is connected with the self-basis of all, provides an etymology for the mind basis of all, in brief. When we refer to the ignorance grasping at a self in the context of Chittamatra, this ignorance views the ālaya vijñāna as self because it is the basis within which the karmic imprints are suffused. [non-English speech, 25 s, detected ru 0.82] And I presently very evident verses on the boundaries of the Adaya Visionana, the engaging and countering of the Adaya Visionana. Now clearly, the Adaya Visionana cannot be traced back in time. It is the beginning of this. But the question is, when does it engage and when does it counter? What are its boundaries? We have understood this presentation of the Arya family’s engagement in the country, but even if that is not possible, if you understand 50 or 60 percent, then that is quite good nonetheless. Then, the topic of the Hariova here, the mind is a more easy difficult topic. In the monasteries, three full months are dedicated to its studies. [end unchecked]
.
Perhaps every two days, basic classes in Buddhist philosophy as well as hours and hours of debate every night. And one would have memorized the text. And even with all of this, it is difficult to understand the topic
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:28:55-00:41:56] [unclear, 13 s] the afflicted mind. Then the teachings regarding the duality, they come later and they resolve this. Don’t be discouraged, actually we covered a lot of hair and surgery in something more like six months, three months. And you need mental fortitude, bone in the heart, literally. Because clearly the monastery won’t debate on this in the mornings, won’t debate on this in the evenings, but some you can have several activities a day. So we have to put here. So what we need is comparing the procedures similar to the flow of a great river, which flows uninterrupted. So then this topic of past and future life labels just to understand the importance of karmic imprints and how they are implanted and this is what is explained very clearly in general. [non-English speech, 17 s, detected ja 0.34] Then there is more of this book from the life of Arya Asanga realized the prayer. He had a vision of Maitreya. And to obtain this vision, he went into a long retreat. But after three years, he had no experience whatsoever of Maitreya. And with very discouragement, he abandoned his retreat instead of returning to the world. And on his way back, he saw that a drop of water falling from a cliff had worn a hole in the rock at its base. And seeing this, he gained enthusiasm and returned to his retreat. Now, you can imagine how long it takes for a drop of water to wear a hole in a piece of rock. It takes millions of years. Yet, this is reality. If it is the case that a dog of water can wear its way into stone and basically make a home, how much more so for our minds? And therefore, we should have fortitude and resolve that there is a passage In the Bodhisattva Chaya that happened to this effect, there are actually numerous passages. Then if we have time, we should not waste this time. but we should study, and eventually over time we will accumulate the storage. We will not have money. So that’s why, not so bad money, so she should be getting in your money to work together. So, one member has no dieting, control of the mental health. And in our cases we have been afflicted. or we have been affected by the afflictions since the beginning of this time. We will not be able to eliminate them rapidly. We have to proceed certainly. And then, most important is to understand the faults of the afflictions epitomized by anger. And if we understand the faults of anger, we’ll try to counter it. If we don’t, we will fall under the sway of anger, and the world now is filled with the deeds of those who are overpowered by anger. So, at present, the issue of the engagement and the country of the Ayatollah is covered in only two verses. It engages and continues uninterruptedly until remainerless and vulnerable. [non-English speech, 4 s, detected ja 0.92] So basically, until where does the Alaya Vignana continue? What are its boundaries? Now, if we look at the load vehicle, the Alaya Vignana exists until the attainment of the state of the part of the load vehicle. So, welcome to Sakshi, upon the attainment of art of good, is the available ban for Ikinayaris. Upon the abandonment of the body since an attack point, we continue this step. [unclear, 33 s] So, within these two verses, it engages the continuum uninterruptedly unto a Remainerless and Varjo-like. Remainerless refers to a remainderless nirvana, in other words, the cessation of the continuum of an arhat. And Varjo-like refers to the intense grammar. The term engages, implies, the notion of countering as well. [unclear, 44 s] [end unchecked]
.
So it’s important that you
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:42:15-00:46:44] So it’s important that you try to ascertain what you understand at present about the idea of the mind basis as well. The presentation of the topic has been completed. Then Geshe said we will continue discussing it for a couple of weeks. But we will be entering the next subdivision of Chitamatra, which is The basis of which is supported, and this refers to the karmic imprints. This is very important. So, what is your understanding of the language? What’s the nature of the language? It’s not clear. Sorry? It’s not clear. [unclear, 36 s] I think of her. I like shepherds. It has a subordinate aspect. The basis of all is subdivided into two. The supporting basis of all and the supported basis of all. That’s not what we’re talking about. What we want to know is what the nature of the supporting basis of all, in other words, the mind basis of all is. It’s neutral, not a subject of moralizing. Does that mean not a subject of moralizing? It is admin virtue, no non-virtue. [end unchecked]
It is inattentive and does not discriminate
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:48:33-00:52:12] So what we need is a statement. The area here is this. This will not be considered like we will go over a couple weeks and there is no rush. No hurry, no rush, you know. We have time. [unclear, 53 s] So the way to proceed is to examine the object of observation and the aspect of the Aliyah Friyana and specifically the fourfold subdivision of the presentation of the Aliyah Friyana. Its object of observation, its aspect It’s nature and it’s associates. And we’ll find using this material. So, what is the purpose of the Araya Fisiyana? [end unchecked]
, for suffusing the common inputs. And the sensory consciousnesses cannot be the stable support since all five sensory consciousnesses cease at the level of of
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:53:00-00:53:25] Then, if the mind basis of all cannot be the sensory consciousnesses, cannot be in mental consciousness. It cannot be the mental consciousness. And once we have excluded the mental consciousness, what is left? This leads to an understanding of the Ayurveda. As he said in Buddhist texts, what excludes the extreme, and then what is left? That’s what it means. [end unchecked]
sleep. So if I ask you a very basic question, easy question, can the alaya be found within the five sensory consciousnesses? What’s your answer?
No
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:54:35-00:56:36] So, they’re awesome results. [non-English speech, 27 s, detected ja 0.33] So you all answered, unequivocally, the five-century consciousness cannot be the area of the other, the mind is visible, because they are not a stable base for the suffusion of the karmic imprints, because they cease in the state of deep sleep, and if they didn’t need to be staring in space or night, [non-English speech, 29 s, detected ja 0.60] So, the alaya-vijñana must exist during sleep. Then it is self-evident that sensory consciousness cannot be the alaya-vijñana. If they were the alaya-vijñana, since it must exist during sleep, there would be no sleep. So we have to find something which is the alaya-vijñana and exists during the state of sleep. [end unchecked]
. No. Why? So within the
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:57:11-01:01:26] [unclear, 29 s] [non-English speech, 51 s, detected ru 0.44] There needs to be a stable mind in which the karmic imprints can reside during deep sleep. Speak up, express yourself. [non-English speech, 11 s, detected fr 0.42] So that’s a good rejoinder. Because clearly, setting aside memories from the distant past, when we wake up in the morning, we remember what we did yesterday. These memories must have some sort of a receptacle for them to arise. So, question example. What about cases of Alzheimer’s, which are extreme, where the person has a memory span of five minutes? Is there no alaya-vijñana in these cases? I was actually thinking about that. Not the Alzheimer’s, but… [end unchecked]
eight
I was actually thinking about that. Not not the alaya, but there’s a continuity of the person of of, yeah, of the person from one day to the next. And so there is obviously something that connects that continuity, and that has to be from the Cittamātra point of view, the mind basis of all. So you’ve raised that. I’m qualifying — a lot of that is to do with mental — with brain damage.
So the karmic increase probably would still remain and would then manifest in a in a future life
[Unchecked machine transcript 01:03:08-01:16:22] [unclear, 20 s] [non-English speech, 637 s, detected ko 0.49] This associate is called bereft discrimination. It’s an inattentive mind. So it’s not really appropriate for us not to know the five evidence, right? Form, sensation, discrimination, compositional factors, and consciousness. [end unchecked]
. What’s associated with contact? Geshe-la said — Geshe-la said that the mind basis of all has a very close connection with the Wondering what the difference is between the assertion in the other schools that the it is the subtle mind that passes from life to life and the Cittamātra assertion that the alaya passes from life to life. So what is the difference between saying it’s a subtle mind and which is meant to be a separate consciousness? So so the Sautrāntika schools, I think, assert that it’s the subtle I’m asking about the difference between the you know, what the difference is between saying it’s a subtle mind and saying it’s a mind basis of all the passes from life to life.
They say it’s separate
[Unchecked machine transcript 01:19:11-01:22:48] [non-English speech, 28 s, detected fr 0.51] Don’t burn yourself. The meaning is basically the same apart from terminology. The idea of it as a receptacle for communicating is the same. So, the terminology is not used, nor, for that matter, the term the subject of mind. Instead, it’s a mental consciousness which is the instance of the person. Then, whether it’s present or not in the sleep is a delicate problem. Also, it was mentioned that The alaya-vijñana does not. It would seem that the Vajra-like mind is aspirational, that we would need an aspirational wish to get going. And then part two is, well, once we attain full enlightenment, the ālāyavijñāna is abandoned. So what is left when… [non-English speech, 42 s, detected fr 0.75] [end unchecked]
.
Technically speaking, at the level of the three pure grounds, there is no ālāyavijñāna. There is a metaphor which is a similar type to the ālāyavijñāna. Now regarding your first The definition of mind is clear knowing, says Geshe-la. Clear and knowing. But Geshe la mentioned that Alaya, how do you pronounce it?
Alaya. Alāyavijñāna is not clear. What what did Geshe la mean by that? Not clear. The is a consciousness.
It is temporarily unclear, but through training, it becomes clear. And upon becoming fully clear at the level of full enlightenment, it becomes the wisdom. We’re meeting in the event with Sister Natalie [unclear]. Well, actually, it’s mostly with the Geshes. And the brushes. Actually.
Yes. Geshes. I’m just doing a little bit. And And the fabulous raffle with Andrew’s fabulous glass pieces. And so there’s a a donation of $50 and registrations for about the June 17th.
So bookings are essential. You’d like to get tickets on the day to the raffle. No. Actually No. But Tim wants to talk to you about the raffle because such a a very important
[Unchecked machine transcript 01:30:52-01:31:24] That’s the 17th of June. So bookings are essential. Can you only get tickets on the day to the raffle? Oh, no. Actually, Tim wants to talk to you about the raffle, because given it such a very important crisis, and it’s only a couple of weeks away, we suggest you maybe extend the raffle on. Oh, yeah, I thought we’d already talked about that on the side. Right, so I thought… Sorry, the raffle, so there was a raffle. [end unchecked]
but that
[Unchecked machine transcript 01:31:24-01:31:54] There is a raffle. But it’s not drawn on the day, though. No, it’s not being drawn that day, so you can buy tickets that day. And beautiful, beautifully recommended buying thousands of tickets because I’ve seen the glasses. It’s amazing. You know the blower? I do know the blower, yes. So there are other things on the horizon, and you can see that in the website, the magazine, and flyers out there. But these are the hot topics for the morning. [end unchecked]
these are the the hot topics in one.
Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
- A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
- object-determining mental factors vishayapratiniyama-chaitta (Skt); sem jung yul nge (Tib)
- One of the six groups of mental factors, these accompany all virtuous minds and their function is to ascertain the object. There are five: aspiration, belief, mindfulness, stabilization, and wisdom. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.