Cittamatra

53 min · 1,914 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Cittamatra (Khensur Rinpoche)
Cittamatra (Khensur Rinpoche)
Cittamatra
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 53-minute teaching on Cittamātra philosophy, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen explores the Alaya Vijñāna (the mind basis of all) and how karmic imprints are deposited within it across the continuum of individual minds. He walks through the five characteristics that must define the basis into which imprints are infused: stability, neutrality, capacity to receive karmic impressions, continuity with the infuser’s mind-stream, and foundational status. The heart of the session is an extended and carefully worked philosophical debate about a commander of murder — whether and how the instigator accumulates the karma of killing when the actual murder is carried out while they sleep. This case exposes deep questions about the role of continuous motivation, the timing of karmic accumulation, and the Cittamātra claim that the Alaya Vijñāna infuses imprints even when the six gross consciousnesses are not operating. The discussion moves between classical Tibetan Buddhist logic and direct confrontation with intuitions about responsibility, consciousness, and causation. Pitched at serious practitioners already familiar with Buddhist philosophy.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 25072017Cittamantra – KR.mp3

UUID: e8525248-c679-482c-87f7-dafb8ef0a3a5

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Cittamātra

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~1,910

So regarding the Vijnyana, the Alaya Vijnyana or the mind basis of all is the base or the foundation in which virtuous, non virtuous and neutral karmic imprints are infused. And the infuser or the depositor of these karmic imprints can be virtuous or non virtuous minds. Now most of these non virtuous minds, afflictions, would be included within the afflicted mind. In other words, the seventh subdivision of mind which Geshela will be talking about shortly. So the mind basis of all is therefore the base or the foundation within which the imprints are deposited or infused, and they are deposited or infused by afflictions whose root is none other than ignorance, or if you prefer, the view of the disintegrating composite which amounts to the afflicted mind.

So at present, we have completed the presentation of the Alāyavijñāna or the mind basis of all, and it’s very helpful to reflect on the topic. Now the Alāyavijñāna is a subtle mind. The presentation of the subtle mind abuts on that of past and future lives. So therefore, that which passes from past to future lives is the subtle mind, the Alāyavijñāna, from previous to future lives. And that which gives rise to future lives is none other than the imprints deposited within the Alāyavijñāna.

So here the depositor of the karmic imprints are the seven collections of consciousness. This is the infuser, and the base infused is none other than the mind basis of all which has been explained, and as you remember last time, it was explained in stanza 18 as being endowed with five characteristics, which is important to know and understand. So as we said, therefore, the mind basis of all is that within which the karmic imprints are infused, and that base of infusion is endowed with the five characteristics. So what are these five characteristics? It’s a question.

The five characteristics are that they are, it must be stable, it must be neutral, it must be receptacle of karmic imprints, must be of the same nature as the infuser and it has, this is the point of one limit. So the five characteristics. Good, good, good. And another. Yeah, repeat.

So it is the supported, it is neutral, it is that which is infused, it is related to the infuser, one, three, four, which is infused related and has become supportive one limit. Are there other volunteers? Supported, neutral, infused related to the infuser and a basis in its own right. It’s very helpful, very useful to reflect on these five characteristics in sequence. So the fourth characteristic in the fourth characteristic in the third verse being related to the infuser is an important one.

It means that the base of infusion, the infuser and the karmic imprint which is infused are all related by being within the continuum of one person or one being. So here the infuser can be a virtuous, non virtuous, or neutral mind. Now regarding that which is infused, the karmic imprint, if we say it is virtuous, non virtuous, or neutral, what do you say? Neutral. Yes, indeed.

As I said in the root text, irrespective of whether the depositor is virtuous or non virtuous, the deposited imprint is neutral. And indeed, irrespective of whether the depositing mind is a virtuous mind or a non virtuous mind, the karmic imprint is necessarily neutral. It would be very strange, otherwise, if the depositing mind was virtuous, and let us say, the imprint was non virtuous or inversely. So, let us now analyze the following situation. Let us imagine that someone is commander of a murder and says to another person, I want you to kill so and so and whatever evil is involved, I will take upon myself.

So we therefore have the commander of a murder, the murderer and a victim. So the commander generates the motivation and he says to the assassin, I would like you to kill this man, do whatever is required. Then the assassin seeks for the means to kill the third party, the victim. Then the commander of the murder gives the assassin the instructions to perform the murder within one day, one month or one year. Now at the end of that period whenever the murder is performed, the two first parties have accumulated the karma of killing, haven’t they?

Don’t understand? That’s a murder. It’s a clear example of this one. So then once the victim has died, the murderer, the second person has definitely accumulated the karma of killing. The first person who ordered the murder, has that person accumulated the karma of killing or not?

So you are saying that since the first party accumulate the karma at the time of the death of the victim, if the victim is killed by the murderer while the first party is sleeping, he’s accumulating karma while he is sound asleep? Yes. So how is that possible? He sound asleep. How’s he accumulating karma?

You fell asleep at the wheel and you drove into someone and killed them, you would still accumulate the karma of killing while you’re asleep. So how, we have to explain the mode of accumulation of the karma of murder when the commander of the murder is sound asleep at the time when the murderer kills the victim. He’s in deep sleep. How is karma accumulated? As he gives the order and the guy walks away with the instruction.

Karma of killing along with the soldier. Isn’t that correct? But if the soldier keeps what the general kills what the general is asleep, how does a general accumulate karma? He’s asleep. He’s sleeping soundly.

He’s given the order. So he’s infused his mind with that motivation. So yes, generally speaking, that’s good, the motivation, the wish has infused his mind, but you still have to account for the accumulation of karma in deep sleep here. The Cittamātra position would be that the Alāyavijñāna is accumulating the karma even when the other six consciousnesses aren’t working while the person is asleep. Oh, working or not working?

Not working. According to you. Because it’s stable. So it’s a bit strange, right? If you’re saying that infusion can occur without an infuser, then the karmic imprints are infused causelessly.

I would agree with Matthew that it is when he wakes up that the karma is accumulated because he then rejoices or it’s confirmed and that’s the end point of an accumulation. So it’s not actually infused until that point. You don’t wake up noon on virtually accumulated. So what has Geshela says, so what happens if you don’t know about the situation? Then it’s not a complete karma.

So according to you, if the murderer has killed the victim on the orders of the first party, and the first party doesn’t know what happened, and he dies at that point, then has he accumulated the karma of murder or not? It’s a very strange. I’m trying to reconcile it with what I understand about the components of karma and a completed karma and until somebody says to the general or whoever, these people have died, then he, in his mind stream, he is unaware. I mean he’s given the order, he’s gone to sleep and he can’t be sure whether the order has been carried out or not until somebody tells him. He definitely has to know according to you.

So it’s good that you think about it like this. So as you remember the second point now, in this third verse of stanza 18 being related to the infuser, what is being said is that the base infused, the infuser, and that which is infused, in other words, the karmic imprint are all related, right? So the second art is the following. How does the commander of the murder, the first person, infuse a karmic imprint of murder within his mind stream, dependent on the deed of murdering of the second person, the murderer. I think perhaps the the assassin, the second party is like a weapon, the weapon of the first party.

So here you understand that the commander of the murder accumulating the karma of killing occurs independent on the murderer killing the victim. How does this help? I can’t posit the commander of the murder as having a placer of a karmic imprint for killing because there is none present. Even if it’s not there, he accumulates a karma of killing. No.

I think the killer, the assassin has carried out the killing, the deed of killing and the commander related to the assassin has no killing karma occurred because it’s only wrong view and Not wrong view, this is the wrong influence to the view, probably wrong view is that, you know, influence the other people to have a wrong view to kill. This is his karma. That’s what I’m thinking. So to reflect on this situation, it is important for you to be mindful of the fact that the motivation of killing, the wish to kill is continually present within the mind of the first person, the commandant of the murder. Yeah, was just thinking that so if that motivation is continually present and the first person then falls asleep with that motivation, then when that motivation is manifestly oriented towards objects ceasing at the moment of sleep, then it would infuse the mind with the imprint of killing when that deed is completed.

So clearly, if the wish of killing is continually present within the mind of the first party, the commander of the murder, there is no problem. If however that wish is averted, then probably the karma of killing will not be accumulated. Now in deep sleep, that wish or motivation is not manifest, but that does not mean that it has been averted. So let us now meditate during a couple of minutes on the mode of deposition or infusion of imprints under the power of non virtuous states of mind. In other words, the mode of accumulation of non virtuous karma.

Page one. So Geshela, we’ll take one or two questions. I am unsure why there needs to a relationship between the person that persuades someone to murder and the actual deed of murdering. From my perspective, I see it’s completely separate. It’s regardless whether the murder actually took place or not.

If I persuaded someone to commit a murder, whether that person actually does it or not is irrespective of the mind that I have in wanting to persuade that person to do it. So from my perspective, the karma deed is complete as soon as I’ve convinced that person to commit a murder. Another? If karmic imprints can be the cause for a future life, why can’t they be the cause for the first instant of the coarse mental consciousness upon the first moment of waking? At present we’ll have a discussion or debate.

The topics are the following. The first is, does the commandant of the murder accumulate the karma of murdering? And if so, when? And the second question is, how? How is the karma infused in his mind?

And the third point is, since the karmic imprint must be infused in the foundation as Lama Tsongkhapa teaches, how does this infusion occur for instance in the case of deep sleep? Okay. So by groups of three or four maximum, the smaller the group the better.

Key terms in this teaching

Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top