Calm Abiding

1 h 1 min · 6,654 words · 23 April 2011 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Calm Abiding (Khensur Rinpoche)
Calm Abiding (Khensur Rinpoche)
Calm Abiding
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 61-minute Q&A on calm abiding meditation, the speaker opens with a striking contrast: Western practitioners chase intellectual novelty while a 90-year-old nearly-blind teacher continues serving students out of compassion alone. He then turns to student questions on visualization practice. Key topics: why analytical minds struggle; starting with a hand-sized Buddha image and shrinking it while balancing stability and clarity; recognizing and correcting agitation (image shifts size, color, or posture); ideal session length (many short five-minute sessions); handling obstacles like excessive desire or mind-wandering; why individual teacher guidance matters more than generic instruction. A substantial digression addresses consciousness, the brain, and reincarnation. Grounded in Je Tsongkhapa’s system; for serious practitioners.

File metadata (for organising)

File: Q&A 23 Apr 2011 – KR.mp3

UUID: d1cca66b-c833-4d60-b866-6c03182cdbd0

Teacher: —

Collection: Calm Abiding

Date: 2011 (exact day not recorded)

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~6,651

So it’s nice to see the numbers are pretty stable despite the difficulty of the topic. Before we start the question and answer session today, I would like to cover with you briefly the meaning of teachings, why we get ings? And perhaps what is the most important component of teachings? As Westerners, we tend to have an extraordinarily intellectual relationship to teachings. It is something which happens purely at the level of the mental grinding machine.

The electric mental grinding machine functions non stop and it wants new material, otherwise it runs empty. It is a constant problem for Westerners who want to be interested and excited in teachings. They always want something new. Nothing or very little is lived. That is not the function of teachings.

The function of teachings is to lead to existential transformation. For that one doesn’t need a lot of teachings. One needs very little teachings which are lived. Broadly speaking, there are several ways to teach. One can teach the way we understand it by verbal teachings or one can teach by example.

Both are possible. The greatest teachings I received in my life were by example, with often the teacher saying one or two words which impacted very powerfully. Khensur Rinpoche is teaching in both ways. You have these extraordinarily sophisticated teachings on Je Tsongkhapa’s middling stages of the path, which I think for us are very difficult to put in practice. I know for myself it is dubious I would ever attain something like this in my life.

Then we have the example of the teacher. That should be cause for thought for all of us. So in this country, and I think in much of the West, we are accustomed to the humdrum of mediocrity. Most of us are basically slackers. We under achieve, we basically enjoy levels of prosperity which we have if we are honest with ourselves, none of us merits.

If you are born in Australia, you are entitled to handouts from the government by the very fact that you are born in this country. You have done nothing to merit this. Somebody who’s born in another country is not entitled to these handouts through no fault of his own. So when we see great beings like Rinpoche, Rinpoche, we see a model of who we could be if we tried. And I think that is the greatest teaching.

Khensur Rinpoche is going on 90. He’s basically blind. He’s also de facto deaf. He walks in carried by two persons, and de facto has to be lifted on the teaching throne. He told me recently, he said, I don’t know why I bother to teach, they never practice.

I brought the text from India in my bags, 25 kilos at the time. I wonder why I bothered. Yet, Rinpoche continues to teach. And when I came here at Rinpoche’s request, Rinpoche said something to me which shocked me a lot. It’s not the way I was trained.

Trained. Was trained in the European university systems, I did some of my studies at French universities. At French universities, if you don’t have a quorum, five persons attending a class, the class is cancelled. Rinpoche told me if there was one person, teach.

Then I was very shocked. I thought what sort of a system is this? What sort of a country is this if there’s one person teach? You know, that means there’s no interest at all. But that is Rinpoche’s attitude.

That’s the attitude of a bodhisattva. So I think, obviously, we attend the teachings, we listen to the teachings, we have this intellectual relation to the teachings, we have intellectual questions, may or may not be grounded. Much of this is part of the froth, which is very characteristic of our Western minds. But we also have the example of the teacher. And I think for many of us that example is more powerful.

For myself it is. So that’s what I wanted to to mention to you, and then I am wide open to your questions on what we covered today. Yes? This type of teaching, like teachings on calm abiding, we study to have a general overview of the path. It’s marvelous all of you have come.

We study because there’s much in these teachings which actually applies to our own daily meditation. And that we can do. Even if we when I was at Sera, I had no time. I mean, you think you are busy. I was up at five.

I was in bed at midnight. So I was not only a monk for doing the full study program, I was a director of two foundations in India. It was a huge thing, you know. I would come back from debate, I would get meetings with the architect, with the engineer, with the finance officer and whatnot. And the abbot of Sera Je told me, he said, you simply don’t have time.

But he said, every day meditate five minutes. I tried. In five minutes meditation, you still have the possibility to identify forgetfulness, sinking, agitation as possible. And then obviously, when one has family responsibilities you do, then Rinpoche, and I think he’s one of the few Tibetan teachers I’ve ever heard who does this, he really has presented a very, very accessible road for us many times in the Wednesday teachings. And Rinpoche said, in the morning when we wake up, we set a good motivation.

All of us can do that. It’s a minute or two in the morning. Just good motivation. We abstain from the 10 non virtuous deeds and the remaining non virtuous deeds during the day, and at the end of the day, we evaluate how we behaved, and if we committed any non virtues, we confess, we purify. It’s a couple of minutes.

For a layperson who has a family, who has children, who has to work, this is possible. Now, many Westerners, and that’s not your case, but many Westerners do not want to hear this. They want to hear about advanced practices which basically we cannot do. We can’t For instance, if you take deity yoga, true deity yoga, we cannot practice. We think we practice deity yoga, we’re practicing wrong deity yoga.

In true deity yoga you have two factors of the mind which must be conjoined: the ascertainment factor which realizes emptiness we don’t understand emptiness and the appearance factor appearing as a deity. We cannot do that. But we become familiar with the path, we come to the teachings, we listen, and then when it comes to real practice, I think those of us who have responsibilities, we practice at the level we are at. Generate motivation, do no harm, try to help, purify at the end of the day. Then I think also personally, Rinpoche’s teachings and that of all my teachers are called a personal sacrifice.

It’s not possible to get somewhere meaningful with spiritual practice without sacrifice. It’s not possible. I mean, it is not possible to have everything. Then, sometimes our choices are already made for us, then there’s nothing we can do. Then, as a friend of mine once said very beautifully, life life becomes practice.

We don’t have time to meditate. All of us have time to practice patience. Big practice for laypersons. Life here is a constant training and patience. We have the possibility, as Rinpoche has pointed out several times, to practice the first three perfections.

We can practice generosity. It doesn’t have to be giving money, one can give time, one can give Dharma, one can give advice. I offer translation, it’s a practice of generosity. One can also practice ethics, it’s not difficult. The restraint from the basic non virtues and forbearance is a very difficult practice.

There are Tibetan Geshe’s who give up everything just to train in forbearance. That we can practice as laypersons. And then, if we really want to get somewhere, we have to be honest. We have to make the sacrifices. You can’t have the job, the relationship, the money, health insurance, the house, the car, going to the movies, a huge circle of friends, and attain Shamatha, direct insight and emptiness and become a great Tantric Yogi in the completion stage.

It’s not possible. It does not happen. And it is being dishonest to say it does happen. It does not happen. We have Tibetan monks who give up everything.

They go to the monasteries. They study for twenty years, and sometimes they still fail. So if they still fail, how much more so us? The problem is it’s the only road for us. Je Tsongkhapa said very beautifully about the practice of confession in Lamrim Chenmo.

You know, we we commit non virtues, we confess them. Je Tsongkhapa said, is not that confession works well. It doesn’t. It is all there is. If we commit major non virtues, it’s not that confessing them sort of cuts the maturation of the karma.

It’s not that easy. It’s not a matter of reciting your Vajrasattva mantras and it happens automatically as magic. If the four forces are not present, it does not happen. If they’re not present force powerfully, it may still mature. There’s no it’s not like there’s some sort of contract with God.

You confess, you’re not punished. It doesn’t work like that. But as Je Tsongkhapa says, that’s all there is. Likewise for practice, it’s not that it’s easy, but that’s all there is. There’s nothing else.

I think that’s Rinpoche’s message to all of us. So I’m sorry I developed a lot in your question, but I hope it helps. Yes, Pamela. You want to ask some along from that. Yesterday, we were talking a bit about I’m probably gonna say this clumsily and please bear with me.

That for people like us, it’s, you know, calm abiding meditation probably isn’t calm abiding practice probably isn’t like the foremost thing we should be doing because our minds are quite coarse and that I’m assuming that I’m I’m assuming for the moment that everybody in the room is everybody’s up. But that that that taking the mind through practice on meditation on Lam Rim is extremely beneficial for the mind. However, when Rinpoche was teaching today, I mean, we’re talking about taking an image, you know, a a a holy image as a as a Yes. That’s right. Object of of observation which to which you can make prayers, to which you can confess, to which you can do all sorts of things.

Mhmm. So is there a way of at least beginning beginning to to stabilize stabilize the mind somewhat by interspersing some some, you know, a few minutes of it with something else? So that’s the reason why Kamalaśīla basically pioneered really relying on a Buddha’s image to attain calm abiding. Right. Because it turns it into something which is immediately useful.

Calm abiding, once one attains it, is phenomenal. It’s phenomenal. The problem is one has to get there. Now, training in calm abiding is beneficial from the beginning because it enables us to understand the thoughts in our meditation. That’s the biggest advantage for us.

Training and combining with a Buddha’s image has the four advantages which were explained by Je Tsongkhapa in the middling stages of the path. First and foremost, as Rinpoche pointed out, being able to visualize the Buddha in the death process. It is very powerful because our rebirth depends on the many factors. Karma matures in very different ways, but one of the weightiest forms of karma is the karma generated at the time of death with the last conceptual minds before and this depends on the present presentation, but we’re speaking here of coarse conceptuality in the non tantric sense. The last coarse conceptual minds before subtle non conceptual minds dawn, that decides the next rebirth.

So if that continuum of mind is focused on the Buddha or on our teacher or on any virtuous thought, the next rebirth is taken care of care of. That’s a big advantage of this practice. So that is one possibility, but basically it’s a main advantage of this training in calm abiding. And then what one should practice, one should decide in consultation with one’s teacher. So it’s very difficult in a general presentation to cater to the needs of each person.

All of us are students of Rinpoche, then we should meet with Rinpoche privately, ask Rinpoche’s advice. For me, what is best as a practice? Life is short. Then we have to ask ourselves, okay, how is my time best spent? And the teacher can tell that to us.

If it is calm abiding, then which he will tell us to practice calm abiding and tell us not just how to practice, but calm abiding you practice to succeed. You don’t practice to fail. It defeats the purpose. So if one’s got to start, one has to get to the goal, one has to get the conditions and then find the right object of meditation. So today we have to skip over this.

I would suggest you to read the section on the objects of meditation. Some are specific antidotes for specific mental problems. Someone who has a lot of anger in his mind, for instance, will have to use love as the specific object of meditation. But that the teacher can determine, you know. And a guideline towards this is that if when you start training in calm abiding, calm abiding moving upwards in the nine mental levels means that the mind first has to withdraw inwards.

When the mind withdraws inwards and the agitation of the senses abates, at that point whatever delusion is dominant in the mind becomes clear. Until then, it is not obvious, because our minds are just swirled with things. So, you might think you are a very peaceful person, but then the moment you start focusing on a Buddha’s image, tremendous anger, hostility arises. Our minds are cesspools. We realize the sort of cesspools they are when we start actually examining them carefully.

The image which arise, you wonder where on earth do they come from. Now sometimes this makes it impossible to realize calm abiding on the basis of the image of a Buddha, if there is too much anger. Then one has to use an object of meditation which brings the anger down. The same thing would be true for desire or ignorance. So the teacher can help tremendously in this.

So what is presented in Je Tsongkhapa’s teachings and Rinpoche’s teachings is the general paradigm. And that is why we attend teachings like this to get a general presentation, the road of the map. But then for our individual practice, then we should meet with Rinpoche privately and ask Rinpoche for direct personal advice on how we individually should practice. If we follow that, we go very far. Excuse me, developed on your question.

Yes, Richard. I wasn’t. They’re listed in the text. They’re listed here. Yes.

Page five, actually. There’s actually five benefits. So you see my memory is not what it should be. We talked about them yesterday as well. Those are two different things.

Two different things. Okay. The problem is that all training and concentration is a balancing act. So the larger the image, the less clarity, but the greater the stability. The smaller the image, the greater the clarity, but often the less the stability.

This middle ground between stability and clarity where we start out, that depends on the innate powers of concentration. So this is just a general statement that you start with the Buddha’s image the size of the hand, and then if you have stability and reasonable clarity on that basis, you shrink it to the size of an index and then if that works out, you shrink it to the size of the upper part of the thumb. This is for most people. And some people start out very high. It happens that people, when they start practicing calm abiding, pass directly to the third mental level.

It does happen. Then the instructions would be a bit different. But that you have to adapt and arrange in consultation with a teacher. The second part of your question is if the image is small and if you wanted the image to be small and it’s big you have to correct it. When you train in calm abiding, you are training in taming the mind, controlling the mind.

So the mind must do what you tell it to do. If you want to visualize a large Buddha’s image hand, and a small one appears, the mind has not obeyed. Then you correct that. That’s actually a form of agitation. You wanted to visualize a small Buddha image and a large one appears, again your mind has not obeyed.

Then you correct that. If you wanted to visualize Buddha Śākyamūni as yellow, and instead it is a variant of Buddha Amitābha, which is bright red which appears, this is not pure appearance, this is agitation. The mind has not obeyed. Then you correct the color. So this is said to be the case for size, color, posture.

Some of you will see when you practice that sometimes the image will wobble. Now this wobbling of the image is also an interference to concentration, so the image must be stabilized. And all of these interferences are best addressed when you consult your teacher. Yes? I didn’t understand the first one.

The what text are you quoting? So there are many different schools of instruction in calm abiding in Tibet. The ninth Karmapa was a very great being, but the Kagyu presentation is a little bit different from ours here. Then, whatever path one chooses to follow, one has to travel the whole path. It doesn’t make sense to do a little bit here, change one’s mind, do a little bit there.

That’s agitation. When we speak of agitation, it’s sad. My teacher, the late Khensur Losang Rinpoche, always said that the four traditions of Tibet are like the four sides of a house. All four sides lead to the roof on a ladder, which is for enlightenment, but you cannot get to the roof without traveling one ladder to the top. So we have complete freedom in practicing the Nyingma, the Sakya, the Kagyu, the Geluk tradition, but if the goal is actually to get somewhere then we have to concentrate and the instructions on concentration, on the practice of concentration differ from the traditions.

Now regarding ourselves as beginners, during the first three levels, or the first three mental levels, the main obstacles are laziness and a tremendous obstacle which is known as forgetting the instruction. Forgetting the instruction means actually forgetting the object. So if there is a severance, a break in the continuum of concentration. If you let’s say you’re you’re meditating on a Buddha’s image. And instead of just shrinking or increasing when it shouldn’t or changing colors, there is a point after thirty seconds or one minute where suddenly you’re thinking of central market.

That is a break in the continuum. That is forgetting the object. That means already by definition we are not above the third level. Not vigilance, recollection. Yes, so you have two forces which have to be brought constantly into play.

The force of memory or reconnection which remembers the object and the force of vigilance which is developed after memory, which is much more difficult to develop. It’s a small part of the mind, which all the main part of the mind is focused on the object is checking, but not checking continuously. Spot checking from time to time and that is a matter of skill one has to develop. Both are necessary. That you are not practicing calm abiding.

So we are just looking at the meaning generality of the Buddha, the general form of the Buddha rather than any real I just find it difficult to find a real radiant clarity without some analysis of the science. You have a very analytical mind, which is often characteristic of very intelligent people. People who are very intelligent have extremely analytical minds, then it is often difficult for them to develop calm abiding. So you analyze at the beginning, you take a Buddha statue, as Rinpoche explained, or a Thanka, and you observe very carefully the features and you can read about the 32 major and the minor marks and document yourself, but when you actually start training in calm abiding, the very first level of placing the mind means that actually something must appear. You decide beforehand the size of what must appear.

Let’s say you want to visualize a Buddha which is one hand span in height, then that is what must appear. Until that appears you are not even on the first level. Now when that appears, any thoughts apart from that appearance are agitation. Any thoughts. You start thinking of bodhicitta, that is an interference, that’s agitation.

Other forms appear, let’s say you see of Yamāntaka, it’s not a pure image, that’s an interference. Your mind is refusing to obey the order. That is very difficult, so before we can even start on the path of training and calm abiding something must appear and you will find especially for Westerners whose minds are very conceptual that often what appears is unstable. Tibetan standards have problems with lack of clarity, lethargy and forgetfulness. Many Westerners have problems with extreme instability of the image.

Yes? Well, basically, in the Sūtrayāna, one visualizes the Buddha as if he were actually there. He is actually there. The omniscient mind of the Buddha manifests throughout cyclic existence and there are very powerful advantages in becoming aware of this. In tantric practice however, there are specific advantages in emanating a Buddha’s mind, a Buddha’s form.

That emanation is less stable. So what it means in a nutshell is that you take a pre existing statue or painting and you focus on that something a physical support. You focus on that to actually build your visualisation. Does that help? Yes.

Okay. Just on that clarity, at the bottom of page nine it talks about that if just the course Yes. That’s exactly it. At the beginning, as long as a broad outline appears, that is good enough. The search for excessive clarity at the beginning creates problems.

You get it at the expense of stability. So you have two main factors, as Rinpoche explained this morning, which can be subdivided into four. You have the factor of stability and the factor of clarity. Calm abiding arises at the intersection of the two. The image must be stable and the image must be clear.

If you privilege clarity at the expense of stability, you may end up with a very radiant object which you will lose. If you privilege stability at the expense of clarity, you may end up with a very stable but dull object. So you’re at the intersection of these two. Then more technically, there are actually four features. There is a factor of clarity, the factor of stability and two other factors in which he mentioned this morning: limpidity and intensity.

These are different. They are secondary, but they are important. They both qualify the factor of clarity. It is not enough for the object to be clearly visualized for one to attain calm abiding. That clearly visualized object must be limpid in the same way as water is transparent.

You must be must be able to see all the features of the object and the object must have intensity. There must be a force to that visualization. So this is not relevant for us. We’re not even close to that level. It becomes relevant later on when one struggles against subtle sinking.

We’ll we’ll will talk about that tomorrow. Yes. So the Buddha behind us is naturally present, alright? The statue behind us is naturally present and if you were using this as a support, you would look at it very carefully. You’re not meditating when you’re doing that, you’re just looking at it, you’re examining all the features and then you adopt the posture, the eight-pointed posture of Vairochana.

You focus your eyes on the tip of your nose, you do not close your eyes. If you close your eyes, in our condition you just fall asleep. You focus your eyes on the tip of your nose and you cause an image of the Buddha, it’s actually called a generic image, but it’s an image of the Buddha, which is based on the one behind you to appear. But it is said that it is really important not to cause the appearance of a statue of the Buddha, but of the actual Buddha. So, if that is not possible and you want to practice Calm Abiding, then ask Rinpoche if it’s possible to just visualize a statue as a statue.

Normally what one does is one visualizes a Buddha in actuality which is built, if you want, on the base basis of the statue one has observed. So it’s fleshed out, as Melissa was saying, with the major and the minor marks as much as one can. At the beginning, this is difficult for us. So whatever appears is good enough. As long as something appears, it’s the biggest problem.

You want something to appear which resembles what you set out to meditate upon. If it’s completely unrelated, you have to change it. If the color is different, the size is different, you change it. But if you have at the beginning, we have to try this. So, you know, these are not theoretical teachings, these are experiential teachings.

Try meditating. Then check your mind while you meditate on visualizing the Buddha. What appears? Does something appear? Or are you just thinking about the Buddha?

As long as you are thinking about the Buddha, you are not on the first ground of calm abiding, of training and calm abiding. You’re engaging in some sort of conceptual meditation. Something must appear. When an image appears, which is more than just a black spot, a yellow outline will do at the level we’re at, then as Je Tsongkhapa indicates, you do not look for the details at that point. Because the goal is not at the beginning to build a very clear and powerful meditation.

At the beginning, the goal is just to get some sort of stability and not to forget the object. So as we said at the beginning, the two biggest obstacles are laziness, which means we don’t even start, or having started we get discouraged, and forgetfulness forgetfulness means forget the clarity, you actually lose the object. At the level we are at, sinking and agitation are not an issue. It’s not an issue. Sinking is a virtuous or neutral state of mind.

Losing the object of meditation is a non virtuous state of mind. Sinking arises when there is already some stability. That’s why it is quite dangerous and difficult to identify. So the level we’re at, you just cause something to appear. Does that make sense?

Questions? Yes. That Yes. So there’s no specific instructions on the length of the session for calm abiding. There are specific instructions for the length of the session for insight meditation.

They’re extended to calm abiding. Basically, the advice in the oral tradition is to do many short sessions, 16 to 18 sessions of approximately five minutes each, ten minutes is a lot for calm abiding. And always with meditation, one stops the meditation where the going is good. One never stops when it has declined, then you don’t want to meditate again. With calm abiding, the object has to appear and then once you have a modicum of stability, you’re trying to get an increase in clarity.

The moment the session spirals out of control, you stop. Well, yes. But for that you need vigilance. So vigilance at all level is very limited. It starts to develop at the third and at the fourth level.

Vigilance senses that things are not going well. Vigilance is a bit, I often like to say, it’s like the secret police. Like the secret police knows beforehand the riots are coming. They don’t send the people in after the riots have happened, they know. Then the rioters are assembling, secret police picks him up, sends him off to jail.

That’s how vigilance should work. Sorry, this is a volcanic example. Are there other questions? Yes. You have to ask him, but I never heard of anyone training in calm abiding on a sound.

The problem is it has to appear to the mind, right? So does it appear, do you actually the sound when you’re concentrating on it? You see, for calm abiding, abiding is difficult enough as itself. You want to choose an easy object. I mean, it’s hard enough as it goes.

You can choose many objects. You want an easy object and hopefully a beneficial object. And that’s why the statue of the Buddha is the standard object. Yes? Suggested that the Buddha is and I can’t remember the word he used, whether it was a more stable object or a more fitting object.

But he dualized it really. And so my question is, if one is focusing focusing on on one’s root guru in the aspect of Śākyamūni Buddha, for example, does one visualize one’s root guru in their ordinary form adopting the posture of Śākyamūni Buddha or does one view or is this a question for Rinpoche? You should ask him. I mean normally when just what keeps it very simple? Well, calm abiding is a very simple practice which for us is very hard because we have very busy minds.

The goal is to get something to appear and to keep it there. And then to keep it there for long, so you have the factor of stability and to increase the clarity as much as you can without losing the object. Then if you visualize the Buddha Śākyamūni, would start with the statue. You could try to imagine him as he historically existed, but we don’t know. If you used your teacher as an object of meditation, there are blessings in that, but the teacher changes their mind, that could cause considerable problems.

If you meet your teacher and he has changed his glasses, it can cause a certain amount of mental turbulence. It’s better to have an object which is unchanging as a physical basis. By definition we have desire. If we had no desires, we would be arhats. These texts were written for monks.

That’s why the examples of them are the robes. Then, for us, I think the goal has to be to reduce desires as much as possible. The object of desire doesn’t make a big difference. All desire is the same in that respect. It is an exhortation, an unrealistic appreciation of the object.

So whether it’s desire for food, desire for money or whatever, the object changes, but the mental factor of apprehending unrealistically, that does not change. Fundamentally, when certain high levels of desire are present, it’s impossible to generate calm abiding. For instance, traditionally it is said that those with bisexual desire cannot generate calm abiding, because not only do they have heterosexual desire, but desire for the same gender as well, so they have too much. What is being said by this is basically that calm abiding entails mental withdrawal within the mind. If the mind is captured by the senses, is always running outside, to an extraordinary degree, this is simply not possible.

So one first has to reduce the overall level of afflictions. That’s why there are specific objects of meditation. Does that answer your question? Are there any other questions? Yes.

There are many presentations. If we take the highest presentation, which is that of Anuttara Yogatantra and Rinpoche gave me permission to talk about this a little bit, then it is considered that the mind and the winds upon which the mind rides are inseparable. They are said to be of one nature, but different isolates. These winds perhaps correspond to the nervous influx or a subtle form thereof. The channels as we understood in Anuttara Yoga Tantra seem to correspond to the nervous system. If that is the case, then we can see how damage to the brain would cause impairment of the coarse levels of mind.

However, the dependence between the mind and the brain, and this is just according to His Holiness’s latest talks with neuroscientists in Sydney a year and a half ago, is most manifest at the coarse levels of mind. As one moves downwards into more and more subtle levels of mind, then the dependence of these subtle levels of mind on the physical organs such as the brain is very limited. Then scientists are doing their own thing and we wish them well and we see where they get. There’s a major scientist, Professor Ian Stevenson, who has a massive amount of evidence reincarnation, which much of contemporary science has refused to address. So I think at a certain point, you know, it’s going to have to be addressed.

It’s clear that if mind were merely an epiphenomenon of the brain, then Buddhism as such collapses. Nothing is left. And then we close the center, we go to the beach, we have fun. What I do here is meaningless, what Rinpoche does here is meaningless. Rinpoche said, I thought I was a little bit forward when I said this, and Rinpoche said the same things, I thought, okay, you know.

If on the other hand, mind is more than the brain, then there is something very fundamental science is not accounting for. And what struck me preparing the talk on Buddhist meditation neurobiology a couple of weeks ago, was at a certain point how contrived much of the explanations in contemporary neurobiology are for the subtle modes of functioning of the mind. Basically, the moment you move out of what’s known as a visual cortex your biologists don’t know an awful lot. It’s quite astonishing. The moment you move out of what is known as a visual cortex, the part of the cortex which basically processes visual data, colors, recognition of shapes, etc.

It’s quite striking just how little modern neurobiology understands of the more complex modes functioning of the mind. There are many theories, but there is very, very little concrete data. So a lot of claims are made and I think ultimately this from a Buddhist standpoint is non negotiable. Either past and future lives exist and then Hinduism, Jain or Buddhism are onto something, or past and future lives don’t exist and we are all massively wrong and are wasting our time. There’s no middle ground there.

One cannot be a Buddhist and not believe in past and future lives and one cannot be a Buddhist and not accept the functioning of karma. It’s not possible. Normally it is said that there are coarse, subtle and very subtle coarse, subtle and very subtle winds. The very subtle minds and the very subtle winds operate independently of whether the nervous system is fully functional or not. They are actually what reincarnates.

It is that union of the subtlest mind and the subtle most wind which reincarnates. Now regarding Alzheimer’s, I honestly do not know how the disease would be analysed from a Buddhist perspective. There is big damage to the course channels, there is massive damage to memory. Clearly, if Stevenson’s research is authentic, then memories are independent of the brain. So I think at a certain point it raises a very interesting question because I pointed this out in a talk a couple of weeks ago.

We have clear evidence that destruction of certain areas of the brain affects, for instance, discursive memory but not operative memory. That’s the evidence is in. From Stevenson’s research we have clear evidence on the other side of children with discursive and operative memories of past lives. In other words, they remember facts and they remember how to do things. One of the major discoveries in neurobiology recently has been that remembering facts and remembering how to do something like riding a bicycle are treated differently by the brain.

Now, Stevenson’s research shows that we have children which have memories of both. If his research is true, he has two thousand five hundred cases, of which I think eight hundred and some verified cases, very strong cases, where the memories have been checked. If that is true, then there probably are two mechanisms involved. There’s probably a cerebral mechanism involved and there is a non cerebral mechanism involved. But we don’t know.

We simply don’t know. That for sure. Someone with Alzheimer’s is going to be almost completely unable to negotiate things. I mean, you can hope even if the attention span has collapsed to a matter of a couple of minutes or even a couple of seconds, if there was preliminary spiritual practice, otherwise it seems difficult, but if there was preliminary spiritual practice, perhaps the best thing to do is to put an image of their teacher in front of their eyes, whatever their religion was. I know of at least one case in England of an elder woman suffering from Alzheimer’s who had a varying attention span of five minutes and even though she remembered nothing previous to that, she retained her Christian religious feeling.

If one can connect to that, there would be benefit. Something I’ve wondered, I’ve been always struck by the fact that I know of only one reported case of Alzheimer’s among the Tibetans. One. It’s India. They diagnose it with that degree of That’s the second case then.

Okay. But there are others. You know, probably different degrees. Tibetans call this Western old person’s crazy disease. Level when his treating doctor assembled with a team around his bed and said, this used to be one of the most famous Tibetan scholars.

And look at him now, you know. So there is something there and it is certain that, well the data is in actually, Davidson’s research shows very clearly that meditation affects numerous aspects of the brain cortical thickness and whatnot, but that is not all there is. So the one thing I mentioned in the talk I gave on the topic and for us it’s major issue is whether or not we accept that the mind is non material. It’s a very important issue for Western Buddhists. I think many Western Buddhists practice the Buddhist teaching with the idea that it is some sort of sterile hygiene.

It may or may not be, it is not the goal. You read this. I mean, I I sort of read the Guardian every day. People are terrified of getting Alzheimer’s and all they want to hear is how to do mental push ups. Well, that’s not really what we offer, you know, and more fundamentally the teachings were not designed for that.

So they have other effects. If we take the case of Shine for instance, somebody asked me a couple of years or some ago what benefit Shamatha had for people who had mental problems. Well the answer is none. I mean if anything the Tibetan lamas discourage people who have mental problems from practicing calm abiding. So I think we have to stop for today.

If you have any extra questions, please write them down. We’ll cover them tomorrow. Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

completion stage dzog rim (Tib)
The second of the two stages of Highest Yoga Tantra, during which control is gained over the vajra body. LYWA
Highest Yoga Tantra Anuttara Yoga Tantra (Skt); la na mä pä gyü (Tib)
The fourth and supreme division of tantric practice, sometimes called Maha-anuttara Yoga Tantra. It consists of the generation and completion stages. Through this practice, one can attain full enlightenment within one lifetime. LYWA
Kagyü
The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded in the eleventh century by Marpa, Milarepa, Gampopa, and their followers. One of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. Cf. Nyingma, Sakya and Gelug. LYWA
Nyingma
The old translation school of Tibetan Buddhism, which traces its teachings back to the time of Padmasambhava... LYWA
real I
The I that appears to exist inherently from its own side without depending on causes and conditions, parts or the mind's imputation. It is the object to be refuted. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Sutrayana döi thegpa (Tib)
The Sutra Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Paramitayana; the non-tantric path that encompasses both Hinayana practices such as the thirty-seven wings of enlightenment and Mahayana practices such as the six perfections... LYWA
Yoga Tantra näljor gyi gyü (Tib)
The third of four classes of Buddhist tantra, literally meaning "union" due to the increased emphasis on internal activities compared with the previous two tantras. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top