1 h 6 min · 8,588 words · 24 April 2011 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 67-minute Q&A session, students ask Kyabje Rinpoche for clarification on three central difficulties encountered during his Middling Stages of the Path teachings. He begins by clarifying “pliancy” (shin jang in Tibetan) — not the English mistranslation, but the extreme purification of mind and body that eliminates reticence to virtuous deeds — and how this gradually unfolds through calm abiding. An extended Guru Yoga teaching follows, grounded in stories of hidden yogis discovered in monasteries. Using these stories, Rinpoche explores the central paradox of the practice: we cannot assess whether our teacher is truly enlightened, yet genuine practice demands seeing them that way for our own benefit. This leads naturally into practical obstacles in Shamatha meditation itself: the distinction between sinking and agitation, the role of vigilance and antidotes, the balance between clarity and stability. He also addresses diet, vegetarianism, and defends single-pointed reliance on one teacher against the Western habit of dabbling across traditions. For practitioners already engaged with Lamrim study.
File metadata (for organising)
File: Q&A 24 Apr 2011 – KR.mp3
UUID: db3fa1c9-cef5-4422-8342-67bf72e7ed90
Teacher: Ilia Durovic
Collection: Calm Abiding
Date: 2011 (exact day not recorded)
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~8,588
The question and answer session and ask questions before so we already have one question going. So you have seen basically that Khensur Rinpoche is drawing parts of the Middling Stages of the Path. He’s not covering the whole text. I have basically translated the whole text, a couple of pages are missing at the end. And that is what has been distributed to you today.
In addition, you have been given an outline of the text. This seems very intimidating. It’s basically a table of contents. This is how a Tibetan would train or meditate on the topic. A Tibetan would actually memorize this.
So this provides the structure for the text. And the way I would suggest that you move upwards from Khensur Rinpoche’s teachings, which, if you’ll forgive me for the term, a little bit like what happens at the end of the of a funnel, at the bottom of a funnel, everything is concentrated. That is what Rinpoche has given. Then if you want to move up into greater developments, start by reading carefully, in the light of Rinpoche’s teachings, the translation of the Middling Stages of the Path with the outline, and then use that as a springboard to move up to the Great Stages of the Path of Je Tsongkhapa. That will be a marvelous way of proceeding because this is can you please summarize this, and this in turn is the essence of the greater stages of the path.
So that’s a very good way of proceeding, and then you have the other commentaries. Then I was not quite sure what Rinpoche was going to cover during the Shine seminar, so I translated of my own initiative, what is called as the Chart of Shine. These are rather diff good ones are very difficult to find, And it’s what was given to you today. The nine levels leading to Shamatha. This is a very reliable chart.
It comes from the translation of Kamalaśīla’s Stages of Meditation published in Sarnath. Rinpoche will not be covering this during this seminar because this is Asaṇga’s presentation of the Śrāvaka or the Hīnayāna approach to the nine stages of the path, but it is for your information. And then at some later point if you are interested perhaps we can ask Rinpoche for an even more detailed presentation. It is not easy to understand. You have nine stages leading up to calm abiding through the application of six forces which are mentioned here, as well as four so called attentions or mental applications.
It’s not easy. Rinpoche has given a much more straightforward Mahāyāna presentation based on Asaṇga’s Differentiating the Middle from the Extremes. Then Richard asked a question just before we started regarding pliancy. What is pliancy precisely? Why is it translated as pliancy?
It’s a very unfortunate translation in English. It’s one we owe to Jeffrey, to Jeffrey Hopkins, and we’ve just worked with it because that’s what there is. In Tibetan, it means one of two things. There’s two syllables, Shin Jang. Shin means extremely.
Jang comes from the verb Jong pa. Jong pa means either to practice or to purify. So the meaning is very much extreme purification. It has very little to do with pliancy. Pliancy is a result of that extreme purification.
The mind, we were struggling at the beginning with translations for these terms, some very unfortunate ones occurred. So what happens is, as a result of calm abiding, there is an extreme purification of mind first, which is called mental pliancy. What this means is that a certain reticence within the person’s mind to engaging in virtuous deeds is eliminated. This reticence is called the assumption of bad mental states. It is present even in the minds of arhats if they have not trained in Shine.
And when this is eliminated, when this reticence, which I have translated in keeping with Jeffrey as an assumption of bad mental states, is eliminated, the mind becomes extraordinarily serviceable. What that means is that the mind can be turned towards any virtuous deed with extreme facility, and what I said this morning, it turns towards this powerlessly. Now, as a result of mental pliancy, one experiences physical pliancy. This is a complete purification of the body. As a result of this, the body itself becomes extremely serviceable, and one has no longer any physical fatigue when one engages in virtuous deeds.
This goes hand in hand with feelings of extreme mental and then physical bliss. But pliancy is never translated by bliss because of the risk of confusion with bliss in the Tantric context. So I hope this clarifies Richard’s question. Question. And then are there any other questions you would have?
Yes. In Tibetan, it’s the same word. So it should be a golden yellow. Are there other questions? Yes, please.
I’ve given the lot of the question. The last question is, know, I feel I feel like a beginner gunslinger down in Omaha, city. The guns just come. I’m very glad you asked that question. I was hoping somebody would ask it today.
So it enables one to sort of enter a bit into the concept of Guru Yoga, what Guru Yoga means and how to practice it. We basically see our teachers, we train to see our teachers as fully enlightened beings. Now there are three different manners of doing this in keeping with the Prātimokṣa tradition, in keeping with the Mahāyāna, the great vehicle, and in keeping with the Tantrayāna. In keeping with the Mahāyāna, we see the teacher as of the nature of the Buddha, but not appearing physically as a Buddha. In the context of tantra, we engage in the much more difficult practice of seeing the teacher as not only of the nature of a Buddha, but as a Buddha in appearance.
Now this is a practice from our own side. It’s a practice from our own side for our own benefit. We have no access to the realizations of the teacher, and therefore no means to know whether the teacher is, in actuality, a fully enlightened being or not. It is impossible for us to say that. We have no way of knowing whether any other person is a fully enlightened being or not.
So as the Buddha famously said in a sūtra which is quoted by Gyaltsabje in his commentary on Dharmakīrti’s Pramānavārttika, I and I alone can assess others. The Buddha meant by this that because he was omniscient, he and himself alone knew the levels of realization of others and could assess them. We are unable to do this. So we train to see our teachers as fully enlightened beings, whether they are fully enlightened or not, because by training in this way we ourselves benefit tremendously. Since by training in this way, the teacher’s teachings become for us the teachings of a fully enlightened being, whether from his own side he or she is fully enlightened or not.
The blessings we realize are also the blessings of a fully enlightened being, irrespective of the degree of realization of the teacher from his own side. The teacher’s realizations we have no access to. Some teachers are ordinary beings, Some teachers are arhats. Some teachers are bodhisattvas. Some teachers are fully enlightened beings.
We do not know. But having taken them as a teacher for our own benefit, to increase the blessings we receive, to increase the power of the teachings we receive from them, we choose to visualize them as fully enlightened beings. Then the question you ask is basically how to assess or how to understand the difficulties a teacher experiences. If a teacher is a fully enlightened being, then these are problems which are manifested to teach the student. As we were saying yesterday, I personally feel, for instance, in the case of Khensur Rinpoche, that a huge swathe of Rinpoche’s teachings are the person of Rinpoche, the actual person of Rinpoche.
Rinpoche’s life is his teaching. Rinpoche’s behavior in the face of physical hardship is teaching. Rinpoche’s level of realizations we have no access to. I have private reasons to suspect they are excessively high, but we have no access to. Then, if a teacher is fully enlightened, he will manifest certain physical problems to impact the students.
He will manifest the problems of old age, or he may manifest a cancer, or he may manifest a limp. Whereas in actuality from own side that does not exist. On the other hand, if the teacher is an ordinary being, or let’s say a Bodhisattva on the path of preparation, he may be experiencing the result of past non virtuous karma. From our side we have no way of know knowing which of the two it is, but we train ourselves to see this as the deeds of an enlightened being. So Guru Yoga is a very difficult practice because it is the gateway to the generation stage of tantra.
The totality of the Buddhist path is subsumed in Guru Yoga. The main object which has to be eliminated in the generation stage of tantra is ordinary appearances and conceptions. This is the crux of Guru Yoga. So Guru Yoga is the beginning, the middle and the end of the path. Now, I have known teachers who I thought in actuality may have been ordinary beings.
I have also known teachers who gave me the very, very direct evidence that their physical problems were mere semblances. There was one very great Tibetan teacher who was actually one of Khensur Rinpoche’s teachers, still, alive in India. He no longer teaches. And, he’s a very, very great yogi of the Yamāntaka tantra and an extraordinary scholar from Drepung Loseling monastery. My teacher for many years, and we became very, very close over the years.
And he had the most horrible limp. He would always walk with a crutch. You know, I mean, was just painful to see him. And he was actually eventually excused from His Holiness’s teachings because of his very advanced age and his incapacity to walk, basically, let alone to sit. And I was visiting him once in the room he stayed, when it was very hot in the South.
I came in the room. I had to make an offering to him. There was nobody else in the room, and he was he’s older than Kundeling Rinpoche. He was going on 90 at the period. He looked at me and he said, I’m really sorry.
I just have to hit the loo. And he jumped. He could not walk without an assistant and a crutch, and he ran to the bathroom. And then he ran back. And I sat in the state of disconnection, trying to understand what I had just seen.
And then after sitting down, he looked at me, and there was his cane there. He said, oh, yes. I forgot that. Then I had little doubt that I cannot say all, but a large amount of the physical difficulties was there for the benefit of teaching the students. But unless you’d see that, you have no way of knowing.
Does that answer your question or go towards answer answering it? You see, teachers teach here in temples. By Buddhism, this is a temple. These teachings don’t hit the students’ mind. Mind.
The teacher’s dying hits the students’ mind. The teacher teaches through the death process. The teacher’s falling sick hits the students because suddenly the students identify with the teacher. Then the teachings they received resonate within their minds. Otherwise, it is what Lama pointed out last Wednesday.
There is this constant flow of teachings, and it’s not terribly clear that they penetrate our minds. But I’ve seen many times students who idealize their teacher, and when their teacher passes on, the student is profoundly shocked, and their behavior changes. That is the final teaching of the teacher. And we must remember the final teaching of the Buddha was passing in parinirvāṇa, where he said all composite phenomena are impermanent. So I think from our side, if we are disciples of these great teachers, then we view the hardship they undergo as a manifestation of hardship.
Whether that is the truth in actuality from their own side or not, it is impossible for us to know. It is impossible for us to know whether there is a fully enlightened being among us here or not. I had two clear cases at Sera Je. I knew personally one case, the other case was reported to me, where it was very clear that someone which had been considered as completely ordinary turned out to be extraordinary and in one case we thought perhaps a manifestation. And nobody knew, this was in the last ten years.
One was a young monk who was an extraordinarily pious monk, but dull. Some Tibetans are very dull. He was just dull. Cooked. He took care of things.
He didn’t do well in his studies. His teachers pushed him to no avail. It just wasn’t happening. And people used to laugh at him. They called him Dumbo.
They used to laugh at him. And then around age 25, he felt very sick and died suddenly. He had never done any med meditation, no studies. He stayed ten days meditating in the state of clear light, to everyone’s astonishment. And then when they incinerated his remains, a double rainbow appeared directly over the, burial ground, the crematorium.
Then I remember the monks just being extremely shocked by what had happened because they said, who knows his level of realization? And we were calling him by this name. What have we done? So in a center like this, we do not know who is who. We have some practitioners who have no realizations, some people who are here for completely the wrong reasons, some people may have renunciation, some people may have bodhicitta, some people may have the direct view of emptiness.
All we see is the outer body. From the outer body and behavior, it is inappropriate to infer realizations. It’s an insufficient ground. I will cover the other case and then I’ll answer your question, if it’s okay with you briefly. The second case I knew personally.
This was the teacher of my main teacher at Seraje monastery, Genyen Yonten. Genyen Yoni was a very good Geshe, but not a scholar, and he had never meditated ever. There was no time. He only took care of the material needs of his students. So my teacher, Geshe Yarinchin, became the foremost scholar of the three seats, thanks to his kindness.
And as far I met him many times. As far as I knew, he was a very kind, older Geshe with no realizations worth talking about. He would just chat with me. The only time I knew there was something special going on was one evening I went to visit him and he started asking me very sharp questions about the life of Jesus. So my memories of the New Testament were very distant and he asked very precise questions.
What happened when Jesus died on the cross? The Christians say he was resurrected. How many days after did this happen? What did it look like? How many days after that did the ascension occur?
I just thought this was a Tibetan Geshe documenting himself on And there are other Geshe’s present. And at the end of the conversation, he said, oh, yes. Yes. Yes. Clearly, he was a yogi of the Guhyasamāja tantra.
So I wondered where this came from, from someone who is just an ordinary very, very ordinary monk at the monastery. Then a year later, he died in very suspicious circumstances. Tibetan monks do practices to eliminate obstructions so that they die in a mindful way. In his case, he got up one morning to reach a book from the shelf and he collapsed dead from a heart attack. To the great distress of teacher Geshe Yarinchin.
So I had to go to to Dharmasala to see his holiness, and Geshe Yarinchin, I asked Yarinchin because my teacher was extremely distressed. I said, would you like me to stay? He said, no. He said, it’s a bad death. I don’t know.
Did he break his vows? What happened? We we practice the protectors to avoid just this, to die suddenly with no mindfulness. Then we were all very perturbed. The monasteries started doing pujas.
We all thought there was perhaps a dark aspect to Genyen Yonten we did not know. I went to Dharmasala, and I I really wanted to see what my teacher was how my teacher was doing. So I rang him up after four, five days. I said, Geshe-la, how are you doing? He said, I’m doing really well.
We’re very busy. I said, oh, as usual. He said, no. No. It’s all stopped.
We’re doing pujas for Genyen Yoni. I said, is it that bad? He said, no. He’s in the clear light for five days. I said, okay.
Then I rang back after ten days. I said, Geshe-la, can I come back? I’ll just have the studies with you. He said, no. No.
We’re still doing pujas for Genyen Yoni. He’s still in the clear light. After fifteen days, I rang back. Geshe Yarinchin said to me, yes. Now we are doing pujas to force Genyen Yoni out of the clear light.
Because we have consulted great practitioners. They say if he stays longer, there’ll be a decay of the body elements. Nobody knew. So I hope that answers a little bit more your question. Yes.
You’re gonna ask something. Well, we make strong prayers that this never happen. Now, seeing our teachers as fully enlightened beings, who manifest for our sake in a form which is accessible to us. The teacher, as I said two years ago in a talk, is a boundary phenomenon. It is if the teacher manifests in the highest form we can perceive and relate to.
So if the Buddha is manifested as enlightened beings, then we cannot see them. There’s no benefit. As Sambhogakayas and Nirmanakayas, we cannot connect to them. If they manifested, however, in a very low form as an animal, we would not have any faith in them and they would not be able to communicate with us. Animals can be manifestations of fully enlightened beings, they can be manifestations of Bodhisattvas.
We have no access to the levels of realization of a sentient being which seems to be an animal. Then the teachers manifest in the form best suited for connecting with us, which is, generally speaking, a fully ordained monk, but not necessarily. A human being, male or female, who can teach us. So the role of the manifestation is to teach. Therefore, as long as the students from their side are practicing the teachings, the manifestation fulfills its purpose and the teacher stays.
At the very point when the student stops practicing, the manifestation does not fulfil its purpose, and the teacher departs. Therefore, I wanted to mention to you last week that it didn’t occur, that it is profoundly contradictory to come at more than 100 to Khensur Rinpoche’s long life puja, asking the teacher to stay, and to have 30 or 40 people in the temple when Rinpoche teaches. It’s a deep misunderstanding of the function of the teacher in his life. If the students attend the teachings, there is no need for long life pujas. If the students do not attend the teachings, do not practice and break their vows, long life pujas will not help.
The teacher is there to teach and therefore it is from the student’s side that the conditions of the long life of the teacher have to be accumulated, not from the teacher’s side. I know an old friend of mine was the attendant of Lama Yeshe, Tukten Yeshe. You know, Lama Yeshe had major heart problems. He had a hugely enlarged heart. He went to His Holiness the Dalai Lama, this friend of mine was his and was working through the details of a long life puja for the long life of Lama Yeshe.
And His Holiness said to this friend, he said, well, he said, yes, long life pujas are good. Why not? Why not? But he said, basically, if you want your teacher to live long, keep the vows and the pledges you have taken from him. All of us, when we break vows, when we break pledges, when we break commitments, especially tantric commitments from the teacher, we eat into the teacher’s manifested life force.
If we do not come to teachings, then there is no point for the teacher to manifest. Now having posed that first basis, what are responsibilities when the teacher retires? Well, the foremost students, which are the intendant, have a responsibility for finding the new reincarnation, and the other students have a major responsibility to practice what was taught to them, which makes the teacher’s former presence meaningful and increases the odds of his coming again. And then we make prayers. But prayers which are just happening here, they have no meaning.
Does that go towards answering your question? Are there other questions? Yes, Pamela. Can you please say have the karma to see it, probably see it. But why is it why is this kept?
There’s a there are several reasons. First, every experience is the meeting of a source of the experience in our own So if we don’t have the karma to experience sort of things, we will not. That’s point number one. Secondly, people do fly. People do walk through walls.
Here you don’t see them because I think for most of you if you actually saw that, it would probably shatter your sanity. No, it’s true. I mean, I know of a western nun who had a direct experience of psychokinesis where her teacher in Tibet caused, needed a very specific ritual implement she had in India and it disappeared from within her sealed cabinet. Then it reappeared ten days later within the sealed cabinet. She thought she was losing her sanity until the teacher’s attendant rang up and said they were terribly sorry.
They had not been able to get in touch with her and they had just had to borrow it without asking her. Now these things do happen, but they happen if it is of benefit to the student, which generally is not, and they happen if the student’s mind can take it. Now, generally in the West, we are basically completely indoctrinated by materialism to such a degree that one has to apologize for speaking of the mind as a non material phenomenon. Then when the student is suddenly put in touch with something which is completely at odds with that, it may be harmful to the student. And there is in the Buddhist tradition a profound reticence towards any manifestation of these phenomena because then the student is attracted to the teachings for the wrong reasons.
You know, these phenomena are a by product of they may or may not occur. It is not terribly important. The goal of meditation is not the attainment of these paranormal powers, it is to purify the mind. And as we said at the, I think the first session of question and answers, it is through experience, it is through practice, that we ourselves will gain our own experiences. Then once we have those experiences, there is no doubt our minds.
No doubt. Does that does that answer your question? Yes. Those questions you have to address directly to your teacher. It depends on your physical build up, it depends on the specific type of practices you are doing, and you can go a long way without paying too much attention to diet.
I mean, long as you eat enough, reasonably balanced, and you exercise, meditation is a mental affair. Then there are certain type of practice where a very specific diet is required, but you should ask your teacher. In Tantric practice you need for instance much more energy for certain practices and the diet changes. If you are training for instance to develop bodhicitta, then you will systematically try to abstain from meat. Know, as you know the Lankavatara sūtra basically condemns the consumption of meat for practitioners of the Mahāyāna.
It interferes with generation of compassion on the Pāramitāyāna path. Do you know? Does that count? Yes. It’s a question you asked two years ago, and Rinpoche gave a very good answer.
Everything is adapted everything is adapted to the practice you engaged in. So there is no blanket rule. If you are a monk, you’re practicing in other words the pratimoksha, you can eat meat as long as it is the meat of an animal which has not been killed for you and you have what are known as the three ascertainments. It’s actually when you are a monk you train or monastic, you train in non discrimination, You train not to be difficult. Whatever is on your plate is eaten.
My partner was telling me that in Thailand, for instance, the monks basically mix the dessert, the main course, and the drink in their begging bowl. And they eat together whatever is offered to them. That’s how monks practice. Then when one is training on the non tantric Mahāyāna with the goal to generate bodhicitta, then it is excellent to abstain from meat, to be vegetarian, to be vegetarian out of compassion. Whereas in India, for instance, most of the Hindus are vegetarian out of an obsession with cleanliness rituals and ritual purity.
Then, at the level of the three, or certainly the two lower Tantras, Kriyā and Jaya tantra, there were specific instructions regarding the black foods which are to be abstained from, which include not only meat, but for instance garlic and so forth. Whereas, as you move upwards in the tantric practice, once again the goal is to reach a point as in this verse from Bodhichittavivarana, quoting from the Guhyasamāja, where all things are seen to be of one nature. One does not discriminate. Then the great practitioners like Kaulipa, the great Heruka practitioner, ate fish innards. He didn’t just eat meat, he ate offal, which was cast away on the refuse heap.
So it depends on the level of practice one is at. There’s no blanket answer. And then I think one should ask one’s teacher privately. Generally speaking, it is said that becoming a vegetarian enables one to accumulate a tremendous amount of merit. So does that go towards answering your question?
People are very different levels of the path, you know. Then, I think for oneself, if one can be vegetarian, it’s excellent to be. As His Holiness said, Dharma is for taming our own mind, not checking other people’s mind. Then you know what other people do is up to them. One self practices, and if one is vegetarian, I think one will accumulate a lot of merit.
I was for many years in India, I was very happy to be. I was afraid people would ask a lot of questions about pliancy because it’s difficult and I didn’t want to talk about it a lot, but we will. Then there are many explanations. To understand pleincy correctly you have to understand what pleincy is an antidote to. So pliancy, you have two pliancies, you have mental and physical pliancy.
They are direct antidotes to the assumption of bad mental states and bodily states. Literally in Tibetan, lhen skyes lhen skyes, taking bad deeds mentally and taking bad deeds physically. What are these? It is said that even bodhisattvas who have not attained calm abiding can have the assumption of bad mental states and the assumption of bad physical states. In other words, they can have a reticence to engaging in virtuous deeds.
They want to, but there’s a part of their mind which is resisting this. If we check-in ourselves, we all can see this. Know, Rinpoche speaks of practicing ethics and we know we should, but there’s a part of us which says let’s go to the pub and have fun. That that is perhaps a coarse manifestation of the assumption of bad bodily states and mental states. And bad bodily states is a physical resistance to this.
So gives an example I’ve never heard anywhere else, but it may be true. He says that a manifestation of bad bodily states would be, for instance, when a bodhisattva is walking to relax after engaging in virtue and suddenly the uncontrollable urge to skip arises and he skips. So I’ve never had this experience and I’m not a Bodhisattva, but I’ve wondered about that. That basically is what one is trying to eliminate and that is what mental and physical pliancy counteract. Now it is said that the experience of pliancy is one of tremendous bliss and that the potent of the attainment of calm abiding and therefore of the pliancy is a feeling of heaviness in the brain and in no other organs.
The brain actually feels as if it’s weighing down. Now Geshe Gedun Lodro gives a very good explanation of this which is perhaps I’ve not heard it elsewhere again, it’s perhaps the right one, which is that this arises because pliancy can be generated everywhere in the body except the brain. And therefore compared to the rest of the body, which feels light and flexible I described it to Richard like silk, suddenly compared to that the brain I suppose feels heavy. But I think it’s something you’d have to experience to understand. Yes?
I think Geshe Gedun Lodro meant it more as a case of a bodhisattva behaving in a way which is not non virtuous but unseemly. It’s unseemly for a bodhisattva, presupposedly a monk, to skip uncontrollably. Should that impulse arise, it’s not a non virtuous deed. It’s not a non virtuous impulse. It’s not a non virtuous deed, but it is a manifestation of the assumption of bad bodily and mental states.
So it is said that pliancy is the antidote to that. Normally the eight worldly concerns would have been abandoned before that. But as we said, it’s a question of motivation. It’s just the example Gedun Lodro gives. The issue of the assumption of bad bodily and mental states is a difficult one.
It’s something we don’t really understand. But I think if we check our minds, we can see that, let’s say for instance, you want to engage in a really virtuous deed. You want to go home and meditate on the Lam Rim. Rinpoche has said we should, we know we should, we want to go, but there’s a part of us which is holding back. Alright?
It’s not like we’re going like that. As if we have to go to the disco generally, it’s more like that. That part which is holding back, that is the assumption of the bad bodily and mental states. So it is said that when you eliminate that, the motivation become very, very forthright, very immediate. You can understand pliancy very well if you think that pliancy is synonymous with bodily and mental serviceability.
Tibetan term is las su rung ba, the capacity to do work. Pliancy means that the bodily is perfectly capable to do work, physical pliancy. Mental pliancy means it’s perfectly able to do mental work. There’s nothing which is holding it back even for a second. That’s why I if I could, I would translate it as reticence.
I would translate the assumption of bad bodily and mental states as physical and mental reticence, but we’ve stuck or try to stick to mainstream translations. I think it conveys the meaning. Excuse me. Yes. Apart from that, the brain has no feeling, as you know.
It’s a sign. It is mentioned in Asaṇga’s Śrāvakabhūmi. I heard it mentioned by practitioners who have attained Shine. There are many debates about this. I think we won’t enter it.
You get into a lot of strange things. Are many strange things. That’s why I think Gedun Lodro’s explanation is problematic privately, because if the explanation for the brain’s heaviness is that the rest of the body has pliancy, physical pliancy and the brain does not, then since physical pliancy is what enables you to pass through walls, what happens when you try to pass through walls? Your brain stays behind? You see?
So it’s a problem. But he’s trying to find some sort of an explanation for a phenomenon attested in meditation. Then he gives a tantric explanation, which again is a little bit, I think a bit awkward. But it’s a very good mind trying to find explanations to difficult things. Marvin, who is an engineer, mentioned that during the symposium last year.
I think that’s exactly it. If you take the distance between the nucleus of an atom, that’s an atom of hydrogen, the single proton, and the electron, it’s huge. It’s basically mainly empty space. Mainly empty space. But we don’t know, you know, so I didn’t want to get drawn into pliency because it’s a difficult topic.
Yes? I think it was thirteen or sixteen days. And as you know, His Holiness then said to Khensur Rinpoche when he met him, I have heard about the feats of your student. If the student has done this, the teacher must do even more. I must really say it’s not just something I mentioned here at the Dharma teaching.
If you live in the monasteries, if you actually meet real practitioners at a certain point, you you have to become very, very careful about how you assess people. We do not know who is who. The the monks especially, we do not know who is who. One has big surprises. Surprises.
Yes. I think you wanted to ask the question. Monks especially, do As far as I know, Rinpoche is followed carefully by Western doctors and he is treated in keeping with Western medicine to the best of our capacity. So this is where we relate to the ordinary aspect our teacher manifests and do our best to make sure that ordinary aspect is taken care of. In which his eyes were treated using cutting edge, Western ophthalmological techniques, laser treatment, you know.
Then what in actuality is going on, we do not know. We do not know. Right. So, simply, I hear what you’re saying. Has he been diagnosed with glaucoma?
That I do not know. You should ask his attendant. You should ask his attendant. I could say my own experience of Rinpoche’s eyesight is that Rinpoche’s eyesight is a highly mutable phenomenon, depending on whether there’s a large number of students or you are privately with him. When there’s a large number of students, Rinpoche’s eyesight is very poor, and when it is privately with human text involved, Rinpoche’s eyesight is very good.
So I have first hand experience of that. Yes. Now there are degrees. It starts by being very intense and then it fades. Both bodily and mental pliancy fade, until one attains what is known as shadow like pliancy, which is a shadow of the former pliancy.
This occurs simply because the mind becomes accustomed to pliancy and is less troubled by it. Judy, you wanted to ask something? So vigilance, as Rinpoche explained this morning, is not the antidote. Vigilance just checks. The antidote is the next step after vigilance, which is, in the case of sinking, for instance, the application of the antidote to sinking.
Sinking occurs because the mind is becoming duller. Then, if it is coarse sinking, for instance, one tries to lighten the mind, but she did not cover this in great detail. If need be, one can even break the session and, visualize light or anything intense to to bring the mind up. Vigilance is not an antidote. It it basically is vigilance is like your security agent.
The thief has broken in, the security agent can’t make an arrest, but he calls the police. The police is the antidote. Agitation is mental turbulence. Many antidotes, you can try to bring it down a little bit by the force of will, then if agitation is very strong, you have to depress the mind. So typically meditation on death and impermanence tends to bring the mind down quite sharply, you know, but that obviously entails breaking the continuum of meditation.
So before you apply these powerful antidotes, you try to apply lesser ones. If you are interested in this, I would recommend the translation of the middling path, which has been distributed. Do read through Tsongkhapa’s section on Calm Abiding and Tsongkhapa’s Great Lamrim. We have it in the library, you can photocopy it. It is the way forwards from this.
Yes, Richard. Intemperate application doesn’t concern us. Doesn’t concern us. Unless you are very advanced practitioners. Intemperate application means that you have eliminated sinking and agitation, they’re not arising and you nonetheless, you’re fretful basically, that’s what it means.
You’re applying antidotes where there’s no problem. So if you did not apply them, the meditation continuum would go well, but by applying the antidotes you disturb it. So in our case, most of us in this room do not have sinking or cannot recognize sinking and agitation. Sinking and agitation can be recognized basically from the level of patchy placement onwards. That’s where you can recognize sinking and subtle sinking.
Now before that it’s possible to recognize sinking and agitation, but the biggest obstacles are laziness and especially forgetfulness. So at the very beginning, we are right down here. The problem is laziness, which is we don’t meditate, as Rinpoche said. So if you don’t meditate, then, you know, it’s not going to happen, you know. Then the next problem, you see the monk the monkey is running after his mind.
This is a sign of forgetfulness. The mind is not connected to the object of meditation. You’ve lost the object of meditation. So as long as you basically have lost the object of meditation, you lose the object of meditation, you’re not at the third level of patchy or repeated placement. At the third level or from the third level onwards, you should not lose the object of meditation.
It’s at that point that your focus shifts from the first two of the five faults. Remember the five faults. The first two of the five faults which are laziness and forgetting the instruction, forgetting the object of meditation, to the third one which is sinking and agitation. Problems with your line of reasoning. Your goal is not at the beginning to stay for extended periods of time.
Point one. Your goal is good short sessions. Two, three minutes, five minutes, five minutes is long in this practice. Repeated good short sessions. Then the problem with the breath is that the breath is a neutral object of observation.
No benefit particularly. Easy Easy object to come back to, but your goal is not as in Satipatthana constant mindfulness of the breath. That’s not what we train in here. In the Theravāda tradition likewise is a very sharp distinction between the śamatha and the Satipatthana practitioners. People who practice śamatha do not practice Satipatthana, people who practice SatTibettana do not practice śamatha.
The techniques are different. Yes? You are free to practice as you want but my task is to present Khensur Rinpoche’s teachings. That is my function. Basically, as far as Dharma practice is concerned, you decide what you want to do.
So I’ve had thirty years experience with Westerners and I’ve seen in thirty years the image of Westerners with Tibetan masters collapse. It’s been a collapse. It went from when I was with Geshe Rabten, great teachers at Geshe Rabten saying, they don’t understand, this is why, to the Tibetans turning towards Asians and saying, at least the Asians have faith. To the present situation, which is, and this is not my personal perspective, this is described by Wallace in an article I handed out to you, great teachers saying they are fickle, they are unreliable, we’re wasting our time. This is now the dominant perspective.
The dominant perspective is Westerners don’t stick to a teacher, they don’t follow his instructions, they shop around all the time, it never becomes real. Now, a teacher like Khensur Rinpoche and the great teachers will be asking after five, ten, fifteen years from their students, where are you? Not how many books have you read? What are the realizations? Okay.
You may follow this path, that path, any path, but show me the real stuff. So Rinpoche says that it’s important for those with the predominance of discursiveness to meditate on the breath. Exactly. It is important, but it is even more important to check with one’s spiritual teacher on how to practice. So as I said earlier, we are free to practice as we want, but we must be very aware of one thing.
There are a lot of Western practitioners, there’s not a lot of Western practitioners with real attainments. There are few Tibetan practitioners compared to Westerners. There are quite a few Tibetan practitioners with real attainments. There is something we are not doing which the Tibetans are doing. I think the main part of is perhaps single pointed reliance on a teacher.
Now before we can choose, we check, we examine, it is important to do so. At a certain point, it is not a case of constructing our own system of meditation for ourselves. You can go that route. I will put money down on the fact you are not going to succeed as well as one of my friends who lives in the monastery, practices only in one tradition, has only one teacher, knows only one language. I think given time, he will go much further than anyone who is a dabbler.
We have this massive reputation as dabblers, you know. People It’s for you. It’s necessary for you. And you are free to do it, but you I’m not saying I’m juggling. It’s necessary for you, and you are free to do it, but I do not remember Khensur Rinpoche mentioning that it was a good idea to have many different teachers in many different traditions.
And none of my teachers of my 11 teachers, and I have teachers in three of the four traditions, encouraged to getting scattered, not one. Because it’s it’s very common. You see, it’s it becomes a big obstacle for older students. People come and they say, yes. One of these teachers said this, the other teacher said that, and as a result, they don’t practice either.
You can you can reach the goal in any of the four traditions of Tibetan Buddhism. It’s a given. But you cannot reach the goal if you go up and down on every one of them. So we choose before, but then I said it to one of the Tibetan students two years If you want to drive a nail into a board, you hammer always on the same point. So you’re free.
You put the nail here or here, but you have to keep hammering on the same point. If you hammer here, then here, then here, it doesn’t go in, you know. People have different capacities. If people are very bright, then it is possible to try to check on the side. Khedrupje said that there is great benefit in knowing all the systems if one is able to do so purely.
That is, I think, a big problem. In my case, my capacities are limited, so I focus on one tradition and I have always asked permission, and this should be a systematic rule if one tries to rely on a teacher. One asks permission before taking on a new teacher. One asks permission before receiving teachings from a new teacher. When one has taken on a new teacher, at that point, discrimination between the teachers stops.
All the teachers become the same. The student has to handle that. Now, I’ve seen many Western students who run into big trouble like this. They go to the teachings of everyone who comes to town without examining, then they take on a lot of teachers, then some teachers are their favorite, some teachers are not. Then they hear something bad about one teacher.
Then they would like him no longer to be their teacher. It is too late. Before you get married, you can check, but after you’re married, you don’t have the right to start now you do, but before you didn’t have the right to start checking, you know, and changing your mind. Yes? Well, Dalai Lama is a teacher of teachers.
Certainly, we cannot take the Dalai Lama as a teacher, who can we take as a teacher? Dalai Lama is Khensur Rinpoche’s teacher. The way in the Tibetan tradition one functions, and as I said, I’ve lived too long with a Tibetan, so I can’t help you for some things, you know. I function on the Tibetan model, I’m happy with it. I think many Westerners find it difficult.
But in the Tibetan model, if you have received teachings from one teacher, you have the natural right to receive teachings from teachers who are his teachers without any particular question. It’s obvious. It’s the same lineage of transmission. It’s the same flow. If you want to receive teachings from anyone who is not their teacher, you have an obligation to ask them.
If you have taken them on as a teacher, if you have not, you can go to all the teachings you want out of curiosity. His Holiness has given Westerners basically a privilege in that respect. Experience shows that the fewer teachers you have, the better things go. It’s much better to take one good teacher and rely single pointedly on him than to have many. Because if you have many teachers, Atisha had a 150 and some, every one of them must be the same.
This is very difficult to do. All teachers must be equally seen as emanations of the Buddha. Then you can get in very awkward situations when where some teachers seem to be at odds with each other. You have to handle that. You can’t walk away at that point.
So for that reason, since life is short, we want to get somewhere with our practice, we examine carefully before, we don’t commit quickly, we choose one teacher and we rely on him, and we rely on his advice to receive teachings from others. So was very lucky to do this from the beginning with Geshe Rabten. Geshe Rabten always told me who to go to, whom not to go to. I never questioned my teacher. Then practice did not go too badly.
That’s my private perspective. This is also what my teachers say. Now the problem is for us in the West, we are highly educated and we function in Dharma centers on the university educational model. It is the transmission of information. Dharma teachings are not the transmission of information.
There’s a transmission of wisdom. If it doesn’t change our mind, there is no benefit. So for us it makes it very difficult, I think. And yes, perhaps? But she didn’t develop on it, then it’s not my place to talk about that.
But you can ask him, but she there’s a specific way to do it. I’m sure he’ll be glad to explain it. Then if there are no more yes. I’ll take it, please. Between what and what?
So when you start meditating on calm abiding, the first problem is laziness. Then the second problem is losing the object. Then when you’re able to keep your mind on the object visualized, it actually appears and you can keep it there. There’s two possible problems which can The object can either sink. It’s often translated as laxity.
The mind basically remains stable on the object, but the object loses clarity. It becomes dull. How dull it becomes depends. If it becomes very dull, but you can still see it, that is coarse sinking. If it is still there and it looks quite clear, but not perfectly clear, not radiant, that is subtle sinking.
Rinpoche has not explained these because it’s a bit difficult to explain, and it takes us very far. So coarse sinking is difficult for us to identify. I mean, we lose the object, just finding coarse sinking is hard. We will think if we have sinking that our meditation is going well, Then the other problem is agitation. Agitation occurs when there’s a certain mental fretfulness.
The object is not just clear, it is quite clear, but it’s not very stable. And there’s once again coarse and subtle agitation. For us, we cannot identify these clearly. There was a big problem in Tibet at Tsongkhapa’s time, which is that many Tibetans thought that subtle and even coarse sinking were good meditation. Because it is true that with sinking you have stability.
The object is stable. It’s dull, but stable. Then if you practice based on that, there are all sorts of problems which arise. So I just perhaps end with one small point, and then I’m afraid we do have to break, which is calm abiding occurs at the intersection of clarity and stability. Both are needed.
It’s not one or the other. Stability means that not only is the object not forgotten, it is there and it is clear. Clarity is something extra. The object has a radiance to it. These two have to be present.
And at the beginning, these two are almost contradictory. Ory. If you have the one, you don’t have the other. If you have the other, you don’t have the one. So you’re looking for a middle way between clarity and stability.
The perfect middle way is calm abiding. The perfect middle way between clarity and stability is calm abiding. At first, for us it’s difficult to understand because we do not have a lot of direct experience in meditation. What we probably know in meditation is losing the object. That we see.
Then depends well, that’s even worse, actually. But losing the object, at first what you try to do is to develop a vigilance which brings you back faster. You can prevent yourself from losing it, but you don’t want to lose it for minutes at a time. If you can lose it for one or two seconds, that’s not too bad. Then you shorten that gap until you don’t lose it at all.
So when you don’t lose it at all, you’re already at least at third level. Then at that point, sinking and agitation become a problem. Until then, if you had sinking and agitation, you would think the session’s going well. I haven’t lost the object. So these are difficult topics and the reason they are important is because if one practices calm abiding wrongly, it leads, as we said during the first session, to mental dullness.
Then that is something we don’t want. Excellent. Thank you very much.
Key terms in this teaching
- clear light ö sel (Tib)
- The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
- generation stage kye rim (Tib)
- The first of the two stages of Highest Yoga Tantra, during which one cultivates the clear appearance and divine pride of one’s chosen meditational deity. LYWA
- guru yoga lama nel jor (Tib)
- A practice in which one views the guru as inseparable from a deity or the Buddha, in order to amass the two collections of merit and wisdom and to purify negativities and obscurations. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Paramitayana Pharchin thegpa (Tib)
- The Perfection Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Sutrayana; the non-tantric Mahayana path. LYWA
- parinirvana
- The final nirvana the Buddha attained when he passed away in Kushinagar, India. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- tantra gyü (Tib)
- Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
What is pliancy in calm abiding practice, and why is the Tibetan term translated into English as "pliancy"?
"Pliancy" is an unfortunate translation that has simply been kept because it is what exists. The Tibetan, shin jang, means extreme purification: shin is "extremely" and jang comes from jong pa, "to practice or purify". Pliancy is a result of that purification. Through calm abiding, the mind is first purified, which is mental pliancy. A reticence to engage in virtue, called the assumption of bad mental states, is eliminated, and the mind becomes extraordinarily serviceable, turning to any virtuous deed with ease. Physical pliancy follows, a complete purification of the body, so there is no physical fatigue in virtuous deeds.